@@stalinsampras Abhijit would've addressed if anything as such took place. What proof does one have that we were as brutal as Mughals and as cunning as Britishers?
@@cleanpull999 they are sister languages where the languages are almost exactly the same(except for inflections that Sanskrit borrowed from Tamil and some phonetic shifts, like the Sanskrit S becoming the Persian H sound)
We invaded Europe and Central muslim regions all Greek gods are ancient vedic gods and there language has come from sanskrit . The Indian subcontinent I the centre of world civilization 💪💪💪👊👊
@Rigel I think you've misunderstood the comment above. Cornel isn't implying that R1a originated from Moldova . He's just trying to say that he possesses R1a gene also.
Indian male DNA: C is oldest 73KYA, later CDF 50KYA-and mutation that gave rise to R is Indian. R 43KYA (oldest/may have originated in India). R1a, 36KYA& later derivatives oldest in India. #NoAryans continuous evolution
Oldest non-African DNA: male lines (C & later) oldest female lines (M & later) are Indian. Oldest language is Indian. And India has indigenous origins for agriculture, metallurgy, & domestic animals. Only continuity not abrupt overlaps or changes. No Invasion/conquest/ #NoAryans
Yes to Aryans but We are the Aryans . These Guys say that Dom(dumah डुम:in Sanskrit ) came from India and Became Roma in Europe . Then why deny that Jats came from India became gouts in Europe . Scandeneive is Sanskrit from Skand . Etc.
@@anhilatorofignorance2584 yes your are right jats are originally from india . and there are 7 dweepa in vedas one of them is sakal dweep where shakas used to leave after they were declared an arya melichhas after king sagar won the battle of 7 tribes in which shakas huns and yavanas were thrown out of arya varta and declared melichhas as they disobeyed vedic laws of war during killing of father of king sagar and in battle of ten tribes. all the people on the earth were actually aryas but as they did bad deeds n adharma became barbarian immoral melichhhas thats why western people were called melichhas only place for aryas was arya varta that is bharata
@@meerimeeri4659 Dude, "Oldest language"? Come on. First of all, what do you mean by language? Is the Afrikaans language only a few centuries old, or should we consider it to be as old as Dutch, since it's basically a form of Dutch? And should Dutch be considered as old as Germanic itself, since it's a form of Germanic? By using a term like "oldest language" you're really muddying the waters to the point of no hope. Second of all, what are you basing your claim on? Seriously. What are you going to do, show me a text that's very old? That wouldn't prove anything. There could've been languages that died out long long long before writing was ever a thing. How would you know there wasn't?
@@BloodskullMannoroth there is a mittani inscription which is a treaty between mittani and their rival king. That inscription was written in 1380 bce and it had many sanskrit influence and also included rigvedic deities. This proves sanskrit is much older than that. We already know vedas are the oldest texts to mankind and there were also many hindu granth for astrology and astronomy which could easily be traced towards 10,000 bce
Check the Slavic Vedas... Sanskrit and Russian even to the present day has expansive similarities. Svetlana Zharnikova has spent her life on this topic and has many interesting findings. 🙏
Indian Female DNA: M is 74KYA and about 60% of Indian population. It’s sub clades N in 5% & R is 15% represented by Indian specific branches of U. Rakhigarhi skeleton aDNA showed U2b2, an indigenous female clade specifically found in India
According to me R1A1 originated in saptasindhu region , kashmir , Baluchistan and Afghanistan. Then they started moving to Iran , Turkey, Eastern Europe and southern Russia.
Indians were the earliest explorers of the human civilisation, they spread their to genes to east in australia, indonesia, burma, thai and vietnam to the west in africa, middle east, russia, north and east europe and ultimately to America.
@@stardust2045 Link please for that arguement. We make claims because we have history written in texts and the oldest civilizations were part of this. They discovered just a R1a gene in siberia. But here you can find whole remains of civilization. The place and community where I come from is Hariyana. We are Jats. You can find two most of the ancient remains of civilization as Rakhigarhi and Bhiranna in Hariyana. We even have Kurukhsetra today that we are hearing of it in our stories of Mahabharat war. Oldest texts in sanskrit mentions about us. Some of the documents were summarized and put online. You can take the reference of it from website jatland. According to this also you will also find the migration pattern from here to there. Here I am completely agree with what Srinjan Sanyal has wrote.
Yes the parent of R1a clad c and m are originated in india then they mutated and spread in different branches of r there is a recent research paper on this issue you can find it on twitter of dr avanya vemsani p.hd.
@@NipunShastri oldest are Ikshwakus of ayodhya study texts but it's also true chandrawanshi lineage is from king iskhwakus sister ila and chandradev. Jats most probably are the cursed son of yayatis descendents named anu .anu clan and others which were defeated in dasragnya war and later migrated out of India but later they came as scithion invasion of India. And anu clans descendents were scithions. Also a brother of anu also got cursed named as tourwasu and alzo got defeated in dasragnya war who are modern day turks.
Yep their was Aryan Invasion from India to Europe , we gave name of european river as danu ( assur ) , which is mother of many european pagan ( especially Celtic) ,as par hindu scripture she is mother of danav , first ever danav was vitrasur ,who was king of danav vansh and enemy of Indra and Indra killed him with the help of sapt rishi
@@NordicPolestar bro just google Celtic mythology, google Danu goddess and it's relationship to india. There is a dashranjana war in rigvedic times,here 10 kings fight,the ppl who lost were called as asur and they were sons of goddess Danu,they further went and settled in Europe,the Vikings were also known as Danes, Europe was a pagan culture ,roman ppl also were pagan ppl,later when their king constantin converted to Christianity, Europe turned Christian, today European ppl are actively looking for their history before Christ, danu is a river goddess,just go on Google Earth and look for the names of European rivers,if you do research you will find there is truth to what other person said. You converted and you threw away your ancient civilization, now if someone is stating history,you feel he is delusional,you do research,you will find your ignorance.
@@MM-dh3wr as the varnasharama did not exist in early vedic age or rigvedic period. There is no word like Vaishya or Shudra in Rig Veda. The words Brahamana and Kshatriya occur in various family books of the Rigveda, but they are not associated with the term varna. The words Vaishya and Shudra are absent. Verses of the Rigveda, such as 3.44-45, indicate the absence of strict social hierarchy and the existence of social mobility:[29] O, Indra, fond of soma, would you make me the protector of people, or would you make me a king, would you make me a sage who has drunk soma, would you impart to me endless wealth.
@@MM-dh3wr I guess you did not hear my comments ,they were vedic but barbaric not dharmic ,the norse call themselves asuric, worshipped aesir gods ( human sacrifice were common among them ) , and Celtic were danav desends , Greek were the only one who was related to dharma and they did had similarity in vedic education system
@@MM-dh3wr the Indo European languages is like this even Norse mythology talk about odin created ,farmers , warrior and slave but it doesn't mean they were birth based , slave became kings/ queen in their pagan World and farmers too
Chavdaji your answer is not detailed. R1a, r1a1 and so forth have been found in ancient dna in East Europe dating back to 7000odd years and maybe even earlier. There is no male ancient dna from india so we cannot say. However, the Indian specific subclade is R1a1a1b2a1 otherwise called R-L657. This subclade and its immediate ancestor mutated around 2500bce, however it has not yet been found anywhere in central Asia or Europe in bronze age. It was not found in swat valley samples either. The only match yet is from roopkund lake samples dating to 800ce. There are European specific R1a subclades which are definitely not indian in origin as you do not see them in india. So the story is complicated and at best you can say that the children of R1a spread in both Europe and India independently. This becomes more complicated by the fact the the ancestor of L657 which is R-Z94 is found all throughout the ancient dna around the steppes. So the AIT guys have a decent claim that the Indian L657 all descended from these steppe Z94. However there is another possibility - that there was a common Z94 somewhere between India and steppe and it spread to both places north and south and mutated independently thereafter. There need not be any language transmission due to this Z94 connection as the AIT wallahs claim. AIT wallahs have another problem - the swat DNA samples showed that the steppe migration there was primarily female mediated, which means that rather than male 'aryans' invading, what actually happened was that swat valley locals were taking steppe women as brides. What we actually need is ancient DNA from india older than 2000bce which is +ve for R1a or its subclades. This will be an extremely strong evidence. Another not so strong evidence, but good enough, will be to find all the ancestors of L657 in our modern population. Eg R*, R1*, R1a, R1a1, R1a1a, R1a1a1, R1a1a1b and so on to show that all the links are present locally. I believe Choubey ji is working on this but I'm waiting for publication.
R1 is originated from single family which lived in Indian subcontinent 40-60000 years ago. They migrated along Chinese coastline to Mongolia and then finally settled near Baikal lake in Russia. Then mutations lead to R1a and R1b which further diversified into R1a1R1b1.Homosapien and neanderthal gene mix-up may be the reason along with climate.
Sir, if AMT is fake, then why do skeletons found at harappa have no R1A gene in them? The fact that R1A exists in todays Indian population but does not exist in harappan population means that there was a migration from outside
Are you talking about the Rakhigarhi skeleton? If so then it is not possible to find R1a genes in it as it is a female skeleton and R1a is found in Y chromosome of males.
It is possible for genetic mutation, but bro you're denying science because it harms your Indian supremacist beliefs, why does it make since for brahmins to have great r1a then surrounding Indians, and have higher percentage of light skin and colored eye, always why would North Indian have a lighter skkin than Europeans? The migrations didn't happen that long ago.
@@buddha9715your talking of just one skeletons which is a 25 year old female. There is another one of a 38 year old male from same sight and as the above person said, it contains no R1a and hence is proof of Indo Aryan migration. "Two of the skeletons, a man between 35 and 40 years old" - www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rakhigarhi%23:~:text%3DTwo%2520of%2520the%2520skeletons%252C%2520a,men%27s%2520head%2520facing%2520the%2520women.&ved=2ahUKEwj1lO67ju-GAxWWxjgGHeE4An0QFnoECA0QBQ&usg=AOvVaw2YtOfyLDuhpWxY79OmY5vl
North Irish guy here, I’ve got type O rh negative blood and am in R1A1A haplogroup, figure that one out. Guess we’re all Aryan. Eire-Ann(Ireland)=Iran = land of arya
I read in an old book from Aryavrt/Bharat/India, that the Sanskritum term for Ireland = Aryakund. Don't know Sanskrit/Sanskritum; but I do know that "kundan/kund" [?---> "land"] means bloodline and lineage and family. [The Irish/Celtic people are Spiritual people/have a strong inclination for spirituality, and to question.......question authority; as are the (non-abrahamic) Dharmic Arya of Aryavrt.] [The tri-rung/tri-colors of the people, of the land, of the flags are very similar, of Ireland & Aryavrt.] Over thousands of years and much migration, Bharatvarsha had developed a vast "civilizational gene pool". As the barbaric Machiavellian Roman vEmpire transmuted to the Roman Catholic Empire via the Mediterranean-basin Mideast outcast Babylonian A-Dharmic A-Brahminic ABRAHAMIC [UnChristlike] political social economic/banking philosophy, Europe faded from its noble PreChristian/"preOld Testament" roots. A people are a language---of the tongue. [In the cerebrum, the tongue is the software, (and the "holy" Orthogonal-Angle Thumb/prehensile gripper is the hardware (toolmaker)]. Sanskritum root sounds and concepts are found in multiple languages; the reverse is not seen---that is Latin nor Deutsche nor PYCCKI root and words are found in Sanskrit.
Indians have only one branch under R1a aka R-Z93 which is about 4,000 years old, and its oldest historical subclades were found in Central Asia/Eastern Europe as well.
R1A developed is South Siberia 6000 years ago as per recent DNA research. You can call them first Aryans. Most people in Russia,Poland, Ukraine,Belarus - R1a. As far as I know from new study the most of Indian Brahmans 70% - R1a-z093. I am not going to drive any conclusions here but Sanskrit and Russian/Old Slavonic have around 1000 words of the same meaning. I support a view of some historians about Aryan migration to India due a Climate change. Veda in Russian means till now knowledge. There is no need to translate this word from Sanskrit.
R1a old as 25,000 year old And r1a without steppe ancestory found in India ( no place in the world but only india) Also 18,000 year old mutation r1a found among saharia tribe of central India
R1a 800ce recent but we have evidence of r1a present in india without steppes ancestory+ steppe ancestory oldest in north India date back 700bce ( according to top Geneticist Dr Niraj rai ) presence of vedic culture is is almost 1900bce ( most visible) Early evidence such as rituals evidence is almost 2900bce old
@@greaterbharat4175 How many skeletons R1a have been found in India? We are talking here about different approach. If branch R1a belongs to archeological culture of Bronze Age with burials of few hundreds of skeletons on some territories it can be consider as an evidence and a new archeological culture. So far the oldest R1a have been found in Corded Ware culture, Fatyanovo culture, some Steppe cultures and then moving to Arcaim and Sintashta cultures in South of Siberia. All of them R1a. R1a is native/aboriginal to one place in this planet that I have mentioned above. This can be easy calculated with modern technologies. If some pilgrims came to India in Bronze age it does not mean this DNA is native to India.
@@ShivamRaina-dm9df I know about it. This is not my point.I was referring to bronze age archeological horizon when they did not do this yet. It is 5000-6000 years ago. But honestly it will just prove little thing that Aryans never moved to India from the north. It will not really change anything. Vedic religion is Indian religion even if it was brought from outside. The same like Christianity.Many accepted it because they feel it is right.Myself I think India is blessed because of Vedic tradition.
@@princekumar-yb4oq Haryana and NW Indian has some percentage of European genes and this European gene came from Central Asian or Eurasian people. There is nothing Aryan about it. The real holders of the R1a gene are the Central Asians who lived in the ancient Tibetan plateau. This is where the mutation of this gene occurs. The Aryans are not a single nation, in ancient times all of these Asian continents identified themselves as Aryans.
I'm very much indian and my genetic analysis says maternal haplogroup as A and paternal as J-M241. Looks like J-M241 haplogroup has been in Indian since around 34,000 years ago. I don't see any R1a in my genetics. What does it mean? Also J-M241 is 34,000 yrs old means we have been in the sub-continent forever.
They are fighting a lost battle to save a wrong History. India is home for all religion and philosophy and culture . I am not just saying ,it will be proved .
Proof requires the ability to discern facts from chaos and bias. Indian wild patriots are just as braindamaged as European aryan fanboys. The original PIE people does not exist anymore because newer steppe peoples destroyed and took over their homeland. A people is made up of their genes, culture and knowledge. Remove or replace any of these 3 and you'll end up with a different people from the original.
@@fredriks5090 So labelling someone also proves something. So,just because someone disagree an idea he has to be X,Y,Z. So ,why do you think Aryans came from outside India and is it from Central Europe on somewhere else and why do you think so ?
@@fredriks5090 Hello Fredrik , what you are saying is FALSE. We already know that after the 'Out of Africa' Migration happened , India became the first homeland of the human population. And after humans settled in India , they migrated to the rest of the World. We know this because almost all non - African haplogroups (for both males and females) have originated in India . If a "MASSIVE GENOCIDE" of these "PIE" people occurred in the past then we would have clearly seen a shift in the genetics of the humans in the Indian Subcontinent. However the genetics of Indians have remained constant ever since we have settled in the Indian Subcontinent. Only minor changes have happened , for example , R1a has mutated to R1a1a and these minor changes are a result of climatic conditions.
@@fredriks5090 how do you explain the ice ages which were existing in Europe and which led to Europeans inter mixing with Neanderthal. Maximum Neanderthal DNA is found in Europe. R1a DNA went from India to Europe. The R1a DNA is concentrated in Russia and they don't even have any recorded ancient history like India. The Sarigarhi fossils predate the dates of invasion theory and have Aryan DNA. Just stop preaching racism in the world, you are our small son
16-17% R1a1 genes are mostly found in upper caste orthodox Brahmins of North India,,if this genes originated in India it should be present in all Indian population,,only a mere male population of North Indian consist it
@Cherry.pandey Pandey ji tumhare naam mai Pandey hai yahi bta raha hai ki tumhari anscetory panditayi krke dakshina mang kr khane ki hai 😌isme uncha kuch nhi hota self uncha proclaimed krne wale brahmin ji. Mai haryana se hu hmare yaha brahmin ki shadi mai jimte tak nhi hai . 😭😭😭😭bechara online hi apni frustration nikal leta hai . Feeling sad for you.
When they talk about R (R1a1 mostly) clades, they confuse folks with percentages. What they hide is the Age- the oldest R clades including R1a1 are in India. How can the oldest R clades be derived from young R? They avoid it so they can perpetrate baseless theories. #NoAryans
@@alokbejai5250 also search about max muller what he was before he was hired by British. He was a like novelist .so he cooked a story for aryan when there is no word aryan for a particular group in any text or any where there is a word called arya arya putra or aryaman which is purely a religious term used for who follows vedic ideology or ideology related to it.
@@alokbejai5250 cool down chiled, indians don't save body under ice or soil, they burnt it. So be chill aryans were india and they spread across the world we don't need proof we have enough. Main proof is our history and veda
What about the sindhi people in pakistan they were the most extremist hindu before mughals but when peaceful community appears other religion dissappears.har har mahadev🚩🕉️🕉️🕉️
@@ArcanumArcanorum17 Okay, I think I may misinterpret your comments, but if you wanna say that Mughals were Persian by this comment, then you are wrong here man! Cause Babur's origin was in Uzbek region, and his ancestory was Turkic, but when and indigenous king Sher Shah suri defeated and expelled his son humayun, then he became refugee in Persia and through Persian help, he established his empire back, that's why you can see influence of Persian culture in Mughal Empire like use of Persian language as Court language, but they were not Persian at all! Another factual correction: before brits, india was ruled by two major power, Maratha and Sikhs, not Mughals.
That’s completely untrue, the highest historical diversity of yDNA haplogroup R1a was found in Eastern Europe and Central Asia, not in India. Indians (especially) northern Indians) have the highest levels of yDNA haplogroup R1a and central Asian yamnaya ancestry. Rors, Kashmiris, and Sindhis have the highest levels of Yamnaya ancestry (20-40%) and that’s why they look much lighter than other south Asians who lack this ancestral component/have it in a very low percentage.
According to most anthropologists and scientists today Indo-Aryan languages are related to sintashta-Andronovo cultures which are related to east-central European corded ware culture, they all belonged to yDNA haplogroup R1a (Z93) and had blue eyes, fair hair, and fair skin. They lacked the ancestral south Asian component AKA AASI.
It is totally proven that Aryans invaded India and bred with native Dravidian women. It is not vice versa! Original Indians are Dravidians not Indo-European.
Yeah so much that there aren't even mass genocidal bodies like when the yamanayas did to Europe And the battle of ten kings is historical even written in rig veda Like what kind of source is going to say that the dumb Europeans were the ones that wrote the rig veda
The ancient DNA record has shown the first R1a during the Mesolithic in Eastern Hunter-Gatherers, from Eastern Europe, c. 13,000 years ago. Data has a Comb Ceramic Culture (CCC) male that belongs to related R1a5-YP1272, from Estonia.
Yep and at the same time Indian skeletons from Indus Valley which are 4600 years old have a total lack of R1a. As usual Indians can't accept that anything that goes againts the idea of India not being first place.
@@Kukhyaati I am not going to answer on your offensive language! There is at least one more rout for migration and it is "gate of people" in Russia and Kazakhstan. Do you for really think that answer on my question is "Indians have migration to Middle East"? In another word you didn't answer anything. PS: I am not Western
Good day to you Abhijit. I am a Czechoslowakia born Slav, with R1a1a1a1 genome. I am certain that the Vedas say that once there was a one unified world population, Vedic population. After Kali begun, Europe was repopulated by breakaway unruly ksatriya kings fleeing from the old Bharatavarsa capitol Hastinapur. That is why we are Indo Europeans, better still Indo Aryans, Aryans meaning of high class, noble. So we Euroeans came from the Indian Asian region. Not the other way round, that is some nonsense and misinformation that the likes of Smithonian Institute would spread. The ksatriya kings established many cities that are the capitols to this day. Praha, the capitol of Czechs was originally called previously Pragalbha. Varsava - the capitol of Poland - both cities carry sanksrit root in the names. As the quest of world parasites continues to wipe out the remnants of the old Vedic culture based on principles and order so that chaos and discord can be spread, we see the group of todays people that are being persecuted the most - the Slavs. Genetically Slavs are the biggest carriers of R1a gene. (ancient Scythians) There are lot of words based on Sankrit in Slavic languages. The symbolism is the same (swastika), the name of old Gods is the same. Eventually it is important to remember that the separation between races, nations, religions are not really significant IF you can realise that we are all of one origin. Many greetins to you from the heart of Europe and Slavic land. Namastaey
White skin is adaptation to the cold weather. -> as more R1a you have as more white skin you have->north India brown skin-> Afghanistan yellow-> Siberia white
Genetic Evidence for Westward Indo-Aryan expansion Recent DNA evidence shows that Europe experienced a massive population influx from the east, beginning around 4,500 years from the present. Several haplogroups were involved in this expansion, including the Indian-origin R1a1a. This was almost a total replacement event, which indicates that Indo-Aryans, among others, expanded westward into Europe and to a large extent, replaced indigenous European males and their Y-chromosome strata (Sharma and his associates, 2009) This genetic evidence indicates that several Y-chromosomal (patrilineal) lineages, one of which was the Indian-origin R1a1a, gave rise to the modern European population. Out of these lineages, R1a1a is the most widespread and numerous. 1. The R1a haplogroup originated in India. 2. The Indo-Aryan people have lived in India for at least 15,450 years, which invalidates the theory that the Indo-Aryans invaded India 3,500 years ago. 3. The hundreds of millions of members (possibly over a billion) of the R1a family living across the world today - a very large fraction of humanity - are all descended from one single male ancestor who lived in India at least 15,450 years ago. This discovery demonstrates the close genetic (and hence linguistic and cultural) affinity of Indians with the Russian and Polish people, the Vikings and Normans, and with the ancient Scythians and Tocharians, among many others (Sharma et al, 2009). This is irrefutable scientific proof that not only did the Indo-Aryan people originate in India over 15,450 years ago, but also that they expanded out of India and settled in lands far to the west in Europe. It thoroughly invalidates the AIT (Aryan Invasion Theory) and AMT (Aryan Migration Theory). Literary Evidence for Westward Indo-Aryan expansion Consider the Baudhayana Shrauta Sutra, a Vedic text. Baudhayana Shrauta Sutra @ records: “Amavasu migrated westward. His people are Gandhari, Parsu and Aratta.” This refers to a Vedic king called Amavasu, whose people are the Gandhari (Gandhara - Afghanistan), the Parsu (Persians) and the Aratta, who are tentatively identified as living in the vicinity of Mt. Ararat, which is located in Turkey (eastern Anatolia) and Armenia. Afghanistan (Gandhara) was historically part of the Indian civilization until the Islamic invasions. The name “Persia” comes from the ancient Parshva people (an Aryan clan). The word “Parshva” is derived from the Sanskrit/Avestan (Old Persian) word “Parshu”, which means “battle-ax”. There are clear linguistic and cultural similarities between India and Persia. The traditional Armenian name for Mt. Ararat is Masis. It is named after the legendary Armenian king Amasya. The name “Amasya” is linguistically related to the name “Amavasu” of the Indian king recorded in the Baudhayana’s Shrauta-Sutra. This establishes literary evidence for the westward expansion of Indo-Aryans, via Afghanistan, to Persia, Armenia and Anatolia. The ancient kingdom of Mitranni, of the people who used to worship Mitra, the Vedic God, located in present-day Syria and Anatolia, had an Indo-Aryan, Sanskrit-speaking ruling class. Mitranni kings had Indo-Aryan names. The oldest recorded (Vedic) Sanskrit words are found in a horse training manual by a Mitranni horse master named Kikkuli. Although the text is written in the Hittite language, it appears that Kikkuli was not familiar enough with that language to use technical terms, which made it necessary for him to use the terminology of his own language (Vedic Sanskrit) instead. Inscribed clay tablets discovered in Boğazkale, Anatolia (Turkey), record a royal treaty and invoke the Vedic gods Indra, Mitra, Nasatya & Varuna by the Hittites, another Indo-European tribe, as witnesses. The Boğazkale clay tablets are dated to about 1380 BC. This is around the same time as Kikkuli’s horse training manual. The Mitranni and Hittites belonged to the Indian-origin haplogroup R1a1a. This is clear evidence of a large-scale westward expansion of Sanskrit-speaking Indo-Aryans, and their presence as the ruling aristocracy in lands thousands of kilometers west of India. The children of Goddess Danu. The primordial Rig Vedic river goddess Danu is the mother/progenitor of the Danava clan of Indo-Aryans. The Danavas revolted against the Devas and were eventually defeated and got banished. As it turns out, that was far from the end of their story. The word dānu means “fluid, drop” in Rig Vedic Sanskrit. The Avestan (old Iranian) word for “river” is “dānu”. The Scythian (Saka/Shaka) & Sarmatian words for “river” are also “dānu”. Now consider this: linguistically, the names of the European rivers Danube, Dnieper, Dniestr, Don, Donets, Dunajec, Dvina or Daugava, and Dysna are all derived from the Rig Vedic Sanskrit root word “dānu”. These rivers flow across eastern & central Europe. These rivers, all named after the Rig Vedic goddess Danu, seem to trace the gradual westward migration through Europe of the Danava clan of Rig Vedic Indo-Aryans. According to Irish & Celtic mythology, the Irish & Celtic people are descended from a mother goddess - a river goddess - called Danu. The ancient (mythological) people of Ireland are called the Tuatha Dé Danann (Old Irish: “The peoples of the goddess Danu”). Is there genetic evidence to support this story? As it turns out, there is. The R1a1a haplogroup is rare in Ireland, at 2.5% of the population. This can be explained by the fact that Ireland has suffered many invasions since the Bronze Age, which would have led to the gradual replacement of the R1a1a haplogroup with those of the various invaders. The fact that R1a1a is still present in Ireland proves that people of Indo-Aryan origin settled there in the past (Sharma et al, 2009). Elsdon Best (1972) in his book wrote that the ancestors of a tribe Tuhoe in New Zealand came from India via Peru. DNA tests on some of them proved the origin of their ancestors. They said that they traveled from India after the Mahabharata war to New Zealand. Thus, the story of Manu dividing up the world among his sons maybe not a myth. (@ In a report published in Nature, a group of scientists and archeologists of the ASI (Archeological Survey of India) and IIT (Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur) proved that the cities of Indus valley were at least 9000 years old, not just 3500 years. The cause of the decline was not any Aryan invasion, but a continuous lack of rainfall since that 9000 years when most rivers dried up. That might have caused the outward migration of the Aryans from India (Sarkar, 2016). (This is quoted from our (Victoria Miroshnik and Dipak Basu), forthcoming book, Ethics, Morality and Business, to be published by Palgrave-Macmillan. )
Tracing the R1a origin, it evolved in central Eurasia, between the Indian and European clusters. You can trace the mutations backwards to the steps. And the proto-R haplogroups evolved even futher into the East, in Asia. European scolars are not trying to "prove a European origin". Not even the German nazi researchers in the 1930:s tried to do that. Evidence has always pointed towards the step, towards the Kurgans, the Yamnaya, the Andronovo culture. Present day scientists are so woke that they would love to place it far away from Europe but evidence points clearly to the step. Very interesting with all the genetic evidence of human migration gathering. Interesting to hear your thoughts.
Everyone would invade and do large migrations, but yes the biggest and most important migration was into India but India also sent out their own migration floods but like very small and it’s attributed to different peoples.
That last point is false. Scythians were horse riding nomads far different than Southern Indian culture. And their appearance is also more European Aryan than southern Aryan.
The oldest known sample of haplogroup P1, which is ancestral to R, was found in the north of Yakutia, the most ancient R was found in the Mal'ta-Buret' culture near Baikal. The oldest R1a was discovered in Russia, in the Arkhangelsk region (11 thousand years old). The oldest R1a-z93 were found in the Fatyanovo-Balanovo culture in Eastern Europe, where they originated. The population of the Fatyanovo culture spoke the Proto-Indo-Iranian language and was closest in autosomal DNA to the North European populations and had a high continuity with the Corded Ware culture. The CWC heritage is at its peak among northern and eastern Europeans.
nothing you said changes my statements. R1a z93 is literally the most common haplogroup among the Indo-Aryans, with the largest concentration among the upper castes in India, and we can say for sure that it did not appear in India and where it migrated from.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 European cattle have an admixture of zebu due to the fact that about 4 thousand years ago in the greater Middle East there was a drought due to which zebu mixed with Middle Eastern domestic cows as a result of migration
z93 that originated in Europe is most common among the population of India with the highest concentration among the upper castes. Plus Europeans or CWC populations do not have an autosomal Indian component, while Northern Indians have a European component, as do Tajiks and Pashtuns who have more r1a distribution than Indians as well as a European component. In fact, this is already enough to close the topic. I can even ignore the rest of your arguments.
First migration about 44k years ago k came to India from Africa and then its branches migrate to South East Asia and then branches to china to Lake baikal there p1 branches to r1a r1b some moved to India some moved to Central steppes. So it round tripping which mutated K to P to R. K is well established its origin in India
Hi Abhijit, Firstly can't thank you enough for all the knowledge you provide in these videos! I belong to the community of chitpavan/koknashtha brahmans from Maharashtra. As we usually have white skin, blue/green eyes- I have heard theories from different people that we originated from the Jews/British, etc. I am not sure if that is entirely true..i know this is too specific! But could you explain a bit about that? Where did the koknashtha/chitpavans come from?? (There are even some superstitious theories that the parshrurama created us!)
Chitpavans are indo greek origin.greeks mostly setteled in gandhar region of North Pakistan and Pakistani Punjab but some Greek people want to return Europe by sea route . Some people settled in konkan coast during this journey. The physical appearance of chitpavans Brahman resembles greek ancestral link.
@@tarunbhadana2722 are you stupid ? Greeks are more blonde then most Germans you will meet lol, don’t let foreigners fool you, Greeks are more white then most Europeans you will meet, bactrians and other Greek settlements gave rise to white looking Indians
I agree us Eastern Europeans and North Indians have a paternal link, but I believe it originated in steppes of Russia, anyway R1a people are of noble blood.
No way it’s from India.. reasons are as follows; India is populated recently.. R1a origins also has a sibling R1b.. fair skin itself develop in cold environment.. India is home for others but no indo-European originated in India
R1a found oldest genetics diversity in india. Indian tribal population from south to north both carry oldest r1a genetics which is more than 20k years old. So maybe aryan were native to iran .Small migration happened in indus valley civilization from west asia. Yamanaya don't carry r1a so no aryan invasion happened.
#AskAbhijit If you think Haplogroup R1a originated in India then why according to Karafet et al they say that Haplogroup R which holds the lineage R1a evolved from another Haplogroup called Haplogroup P, which originated in South East Asia?
Haplogroup P originated in South Asia and gave rise to R and Q, the R and Q were ANE (Ancient North Eurasians) the Q gave rise to Native Americans, the R1 gave rise to Europeans, a lineage of the R1 gave rise to the Indo-Iranians of the Middle East, a group of Indo-Iranians came to India and mixed with the Dravidian
@3 AMRITANSHU SINGH Read Sharma report , highest frequency occurs in Bengali Brahmins 😁 , second is UP Brahmin , them Bihar . Sikhs and Jats have lesser frequency
Abhijith Chavdaji Namasthey I have only one ☝️ sincere question to you. Can you replace our present Prime Minister Modiji in the next election 🗳 that’s 2014? Three ancillary queries (A) if so how and if not why? (B) Is it possible or impossible? (C) Is it relevant or irrelevant to our Indian 🇮🇳 context? Thanks 🙏 Pandu Kuchibhotla Anaheim CA USA 🇺🇸
A person with no medical background blurting out lies. Study actual data on R1a gene oldest samples have been detected in and around Ukraine. So Aryan race originated there and migrated to western Europe and Asia.
@@shahanshahpolonium Aisa hi hai toh Jaipur dialogues ne prize money rakha hai AMT prove karne ke liye. Toh kyun kisi ne accept nahi kiya. AMT propaganda is brutally crushed and is now on its last leg.
In the book of Esther it is said that Ahasuerus the Persian/Iran king ruled part of India and Ethiopia. Plus Zoroastrian/Iranian were the earliest Abrahamic group that sought refuge in India to escape the Muslim persecution. Iran and Vedic have the same astrological deity. I study Vedic and Abrahamic religion :) pretty much part of the huge Indo-European family 😁
All people have U2b2, not one tribe. This is selective interpretation. clade U originated in India & it’s subcldes a-c are widely spread among all folks of India.
5:10 This is untrue, again, the Scythians indeed belonged to haplogroup R1a but they lacked the ancestral ancient south Asian ancestry also known as AASI, autosomally they shared more with present day Northern and Eastern Europeans, not present day south Asians, and their cultural similarities with current North Indian people is due to their own influence on South Asia, but they weren’t south Asians themselves as Autosomal analyzes have already shown. The Scythians were blue eyed, fair haired and fair skinned too, typically for corded ware cultures which had a central/eastern European origin.
Sir,.we take uncooked natural food that can be naturally digested,, healthy and variety. That kind of food is only in India, none other. How come human come from Africa?
R1a is very very old. Its even found in Indian tribals. Now I'm more interested in L-M357 which is common in Jats and Afghan Pashtun males, but also being found in Indian Muslims.
No it's not, it's definitely of Indian South Asian origins, it's found even among isolated tribes in Southern Asia and even in even in remote island regions like the Maldives OFF OF THE COAST OF SOUTH INDIA OF ALL PLACES, steppes was barely and sparsely populated to have originated such a major genetic haplogroup found among such a high concentration of people in a highly populated place like Southern Asia
Central Asians called their land Otter korus , which comes from Uttar Kuru of the rig Veda . Uttar Kuru means Northern Kuru . Kuru was the capital of Aryavartha ( india ) present day Haryana . Which indicates the Central Asians considered themselves as a part of Indian subcontinent .
@@stardust2045 I didn't say that the Andamanese have steppe admixture, I said the steppes had the Andamanese ADMIXTURE COMPONENT at significant amounts, even remains like M'alta boy all the way in Siberia among others. The fact that the ANDAMANESE DO NOT HAVE THE STEPPE ADMIXTURE COMPONENT BUT THE STEPPES HAS THEIR GENETIC COMPONENT PRETTY MUCH SEALS THE DEAL THAT THE OOI MIGRATIONS DID INFACT HAPPEN!!! Also the Andamanese DO NOT REPRESENT ANY ARCHAIC SOUTH ASIAN POPULATIONS ONE BIT!! The Andaman islands are GEOGRAPHICALLY IN SOUTH EAST ASIA AND NOT SOUTHERN ASIA-INDIA REGION!!! The closest land masses to the Andaman Islands if one were to use a boat are SOUTH EAST ASIAN COUNTRIES LIKE INDONESIA OR BURMA etc etc NOT EVEN INDIA OR OTHER SOUTH ASIAN COUNTRIES LIKE SRI LANKA!! In addition the Andamanese are so genetically isolated and have been isolated on their islands for almost ten thousand years approx that they form their own distinct genetic pool and group COMPLETELY DIFFERENT FROM ANYONE THAT EVER EXISTED IN MAINLAND SOUTHERN ASIA!!!! The fact that the steppes had the Andamanese admixture COMPONENT in significant amounts considering all the above IS A HUGE GIVEAWAY THAT THE OOI DID HAPPEN!!! Also using a single remain or sample for R on steppes doesn't mean that IE people's originated from there or that said R carrier spoke an IE language as many Turkic and even Semitic people's carry R haplogroup.
Indian male DNA: C is oldest 73KYA, later CDF 50KYA-and mutation that gave rise to R is Indian. R 43KYA (oldest/may have originated in India). R1a, 36KYA& later derivatives oldest in India. #NoAryans continuous evolution
2019 genetic research: Absence of R1a gene in Harappan people. And knowing that Harappan Civilization preceded Vedic civilization archaeologically too.. It becomes obvious to conclude that Aryan were not present when Harappan Civilization was in prime. Aryan didn't originate in India. That's true. I am surprised you are not taking account of 2019-20 research regarding R1a1 genetic research of Harappan People. Aryan came later on and spread in Indian Subcontinent.
Illogical to say when their is no single paternal dna is research in Harappan or any site of indus civilization ( from main sites) Genetic studies happened in female skeleton Female have no y haplogroup R1a is y haplogroup
R1 dna are aryans of pamir, tian shan, siberia,khotan and descendants of grand parent R..... R2 dna are proto tamizhis of sindhu river and descendants of grand parent R..... Both were one ppl of same coin....
But it is proven R1a originated in Siberia, near lake Baikal, also this guy said there is a narrative ? How western Europeans and the britishers control the media and hate that Indians have a relationship with Russia. Western Europeans have always looked down on slavs, the word slaves actually comes from slav, because the ottoman Turks enslaved slavic people, we share that both Turks invaded and made y'all Muslims this also happens in Bosnia a slavic country, and they tried to convert all but the slavs kicked them out luckily.
Its obviously originates from northern iran / caucases. Iranians invaded india and brought with them aryan culture. Thats why northern india is lighter skin than the south. Zoroastrianism is older than hinduism.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 My profession lets me understand this better than you. You probably dont know about the differential dating of Yamnaya vs Sinthastha Vs Androvo haplogroups , your ignorance is appalling .
Not to mention R2 and R3 the descendant /evolved Version of R1 (white/Euro dna is only found in Indian! its proof the Sub-continent is the homeland because it contains the most genetic diversity even they don't have
This generation needs weekly doses of Mr.Chavda's knowledge 🙏🏻
@@stalinsampras Abhijit would've addressed if anything as such took place. What proof does one have that we were as brutal as Mughals and as cunning as Britishers?
No bro , we need daily dose of his knowledge.
@@kunalkishore4714 😂😂😂😂
I am a gen z, and yes i take the daily dose.😂
@@facepalm_ i can guarantee that if chankya had been in India 700 urs ago, their would have never been any islamic invasion.
Raja Vikramaditya - The Thug of Eurasia 😎✌️
he was no thug he was the hero for the world.
The Arabian Peninsula, the Levant, and Iraq are not part of Eurasia
That's a mythology...
Truly said
@@ansh1778 according to west
Sanskrit is the source of Indo European languages incidentally. Those languages contain Sanskrit words. Sanskrit does not contain their words.
Sanskrit and Avestan are similar
@@cleanpull999 they are sister languages where the languages are almost exactly the same(except for inflections that Sanskrit borrowed from Tamil and some phonetic shifts, like the Sanskrit S becoming the Persian H sound)
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 Sanskrit is the older one, in not denying that. Avestan/Persian is derived from Sanskrit.
@@cleanpull999 it's because Parsi Religion and Vedic Culture are Sister Religion. Battle Of the 10 kings explains this very well
We invaded Europe and Central muslim regions all Greek gods are ancient vedic gods and there language has come from sanskrit . The Indian subcontinent I the centre of world civilization 💪💪💪👊👊
@@xanshen9011 sit tight and brace yourself lol
@@xanshen9011 yes ?
@troonjak white European people don't want to believe anything that goes against there white dominated history Theory
@@xanshen9011 India will be superpower by 2050
Central Asia was neither Turkic, nor Muslim. It slowly over the last 2500 years slowly became one.
R1a from Moldova 🇲🇩
@Rigel I think you've misunderstood the comment above. Cornel isn't implying that R1a originated from Moldova . He's just trying to say that he possesses R1a gene also.
From Georgia too R1a-z93
@@adityaraj2447 Mine is J-m172 but we Georgians have R1a-z93 people from Fatyanove expansion
@@adityaraj2447 Gandagana is Good but i prefer Mtiuluri and kazbeguri
@@ILIADIS29 z93 its more like asian
Indian male DNA: C is oldest 73KYA, later CDF 50KYA-and mutation that gave rise to R is Indian. R 43KYA (oldest/may have originated in India). R1a, 36KYA& later derivatives oldest in India. #NoAryans continuous evolution
Where did you learn all this?
@@mangopudding5979in genetics classes in universities
True ,one of my gujarati friend have it .also he is a patel
Oldest non-African DNA: male lines (C & later) oldest female lines (M & later) are Indian. Oldest language is Indian. And India has indigenous origins for agriculture, metallurgy, & domestic animals. Only continuity not abrupt overlaps or changes. No Invasion/conquest/ #NoAryans
Yes to Aryans but We are the Aryans . These Guys say that Dom(dumah डुम:in Sanskrit ) came from India and Became Roma in Europe . Then why deny that Jats came from India became gouts in Europe . Scandeneive is Sanskrit from Skand . Etc.
@@anhilatorofignorance2584 yes your are right jats are originally from india . and there are 7 dweepa in vedas one of them is sakal dweep where shakas used to leave after they were declared an arya melichhas after king sagar won the battle of 7 tribes in which shakas huns and yavanas were thrown out of arya varta and declared melichhas as they disobeyed vedic laws of war during killing of father of king sagar and in battle of ten tribes. all the people on the earth were actually aryas but as they did bad deeds n adharma became barbarian immoral melichhhas thats why western people were called melichhas only place for aryas was arya varta that is bharata
@@anhilatorofignorance2584 scythians came from this skal dweepa
@@meerimeeri4659 Dude, "Oldest language"? Come on.
First of all, what do you mean by language? Is the Afrikaans language only a few centuries old, or should we consider it to be as old as Dutch, since it's basically a form of Dutch? And should Dutch be considered as old as Germanic itself, since it's a form of Germanic? By using a term like "oldest language" you're really muddying the waters to the point of no hope.
Second of all, what are you basing your claim on? Seriously. What are you going to do, show me a text that's very old? That wouldn't prove anything. There could've been languages that died out long long long before writing was ever a thing. How would you know there wasn't?
@@BloodskullMannoroth there is a mittani inscription which is a treaty between mittani and their rival king. That inscription was written in 1380 bce and it had many sanskrit influence and also included rigvedic deities. This proves sanskrit is much older than that.
We already know vedas are the oldest texts to mankind and there were also many hindu granth for astrology and astronomy which could easily be traced towards 10,000 bce
Check the Slavic Vedas...
Sanskrit and Russian even to the present day has expansive similarities.
Svetlana Zharnikova has spent her life on this topic and has many interesting findings.
🙏
That us because Indians had migrated to Russia and gave Russians their language.
@@mangopudding5979 what 💀
Very true .
@@mangopudding5979 true..
INDIAN CULTURE is older than Slavic Culture..
@@shahanshahpolonium cant handle truth?
Indian Female DNA: M is 74KYA and about 60% of Indian population. It’s sub clades N in 5% & R is 15% represented by Indian specific branches of U. Rakhigarhi skeleton aDNA showed U2b2, an indigenous female clade specifically found in India
I'd like to thank all those who ask such questions.
According to me R1A1 originated in saptasindhu region , kashmir , Baluchistan and Afghanistan. Then they started moving to Iran , Turkey, Eastern Europe and southern Russia.
Indians were the earliest explorers of the human civilisation, they spread their to genes to east in australia, indonesia, burma, thai and vietnam to the west in africa, middle east, russia, north and east europe and ultimately to America.
@@stardust2045 Link please for that arguement.
We make claims because we have history written in texts and the oldest civilizations were part of this. They discovered just a R1a gene in siberia. But here you can find whole remains of civilization.
The place and community where I come from is Hariyana. We are Jats. You can find two most of the ancient remains of civilization as Rakhigarhi and Bhiranna in Hariyana. We even have Kurukhsetra today that we are hearing of it in our stories of Mahabharat war. Oldest texts in sanskrit mentions about us. Some of the documents were summarized and put online. You can take the reference of it from website jatland. According to this also you will also find the migration pattern from here to there.
Here I am completely agree with what Srinjan Sanyal has wrote.
Yes the parent of R1a clad c and m are originated in india then they mutated and spread in different branches of r there is a recent research paper on this issue you can find it on twitter of dr avanya vemsani p.hd.
@@moorthypadmanabhan1998 thanks
@@NipunShastri oldest are Ikshwakus of ayodhya study texts but it's also true chandrawanshi lineage is from king iskhwakus sister ila and chandradev. Jats most probably are the cursed son of yayatis descendents named anu .anu clan and others which were defeated in dasragnya war and later migrated out of India but later they came as scithion invasion of India. And anu clans descendents were scithions. Also a brother of anu also got cursed named as tourwasu and alzo got defeated in dasragnya war who are modern day turks.
Yep their was Aryan Invasion from India to Europe , we gave name of european river as danu ( assur ) , which is mother of many european pagan ( especially Celtic) ,as par hindu scripture she is mother of danav , first ever danav was vitrasur ,who was king of danav vansh and enemy of Indra and Indra killed him with the help of sapt rishi
@@NordicPolestar bro just google Celtic mythology, google Danu goddess and it's relationship to india.
There is a dashranjana war in rigvedic times,here 10 kings fight,the ppl who lost were called as asur and they were sons of goddess Danu,they further went and settled in Europe,the Vikings were also known as Danes, Europe was a pagan culture ,roman ppl also were pagan ppl,later when their king constantin converted to Christianity, Europe turned Christian, today European ppl are actively looking for their history before Christ, danu is a river goddess,just go on Google Earth and look for the names of European rivers,if you do research you will find there is truth to what other person said.
You converted and you threw away your ancient civilization, now if someone is stating history,you feel he is delusional,you do research,you will find your ignorance.
@@MM-dh3wr as the varnasharama did not exist in early vedic age or rigvedic period.
There is no word like Vaishya or Shudra in Rig Veda.
The words Brahamana and Kshatriya occur in various family books of the Rigveda, but they are not associated with the term varna. The words Vaishya and Shudra are absent. Verses of the Rigveda, such as 3.44-45, indicate the absence of strict social hierarchy and the existence of social mobility:[29]
O, Indra, fond of soma, would you make me the protector of people, or would you make me a king, would you make me a sage who has drunk soma, would you impart to me endless wealth.
@@MM-dh3wr I guess you did not hear my comments ,they were vedic but barbaric not dharmic ,the norse call themselves asuric, worshipped aesir gods ( human sacrifice were common among them ) , and Celtic were danav desends , Greek were the only one who was related to dharma and they did had similarity in vedic education system
@@MM-dh3wr the Indo European languages is like this even Norse mythology talk about odin created ,farmers , warrior and slave but it doesn't mean they were birth based , slave became kings/ queen in their pagan World and farmers too
@@NordicPolestar your mohh@mmd piggu is delusional
Chavdaji your answer is not detailed. R1a, r1a1 and so forth have been found in ancient dna in East Europe dating back to 7000odd years and maybe even earlier. There is no male ancient dna from india so we cannot say. However, the Indian specific subclade is R1a1a1b2a1 otherwise called R-L657. This subclade and its immediate ancestor mutated around 2500bce, however it has not yet been found anywhere in central Asia or Europe in bronze age. It was not found in swat valley samples either. The only match yet is from roopkund lake samples dating to 800ce.
There are European specific R1a subclades which are definitely not indian in origin as you do not see them in india.
So the story is complicated and at best you can say that the children of R1a spread in both Europe and India independently. This becomes more complicated by the fact the the ancestor of L657 which is R-Z94 is found all throughout the ancient dna around the steppes.
So the AIT guys have a decent claim that the Indian L657 all descended from these steppe Z94. However there is another possibility - that there was a common Z94 somewhere between India and steppe and it spread to both places north and south and mutated independently thereafter.
There need not be any language transmission due to this Z94 connection as the AIT wallahs claim. AIT wallahs have another problem - the swat DNA samples showed that the steppe migration there was primarily female mediated, which means that rather than male 'aryans' invading, what actually happened was that swat valley locals were taking steppe women as brides.
What we actually need is ancient DNA from india older than 2000bce which is +ve for R1a or its subclades. This will be an extremely strong evidence. Another not so strong evidence, but good enough, will be to find all the ancestors of L657 in our modern population. Eg R*, R1*, R1a, R1a1, R1a1a, R1a1a1, R1a1a1b and so on to show that all the links are present locally. I believe Choubey ji is working on this but I'm waiting for publication.
Did u even watched the video genius?
Tibetan Plateau or Himalayan ranges are the origin of R1a. And this mutation occurs in the Ice Age.
@@shingha9297 Maybe true as the Sapt rishis also came from Tibetan plateau ( Kailash )
During ice age? You do realise we're still in an ice age. What nonsense are you saying 🤦♂️
There is more controversy in indian science history than anywhere in the world.
R1 is originated from single family which lived in Indian subcontinent 40-60000 years ago. They migrated along Chinese coastline to Mongolia and then finally settled near Baikal lake in Russia. Then mutations lead to R1a and R1b which further diversified into R1a1R1b1.Homosapien and neanderthal gene mix-up may be the reason along with climate.
West Africans have 19% ghost fna theroized to be hono hablis, would explain their behavior...
Source please
we indians are the father of world
bruuh
@Ф 🤡🤡
According to this comment section...youre delusional clowns😅
Don't say that 💀
Don't take pride in useless things
bozo
Jai Shri Ram 🙏🚩🕉️
Sir, if AMT is fake, then why do skeletons found at harappa have no R1A gene in them?
The fact that R1A exists in todays Indian population but does not exist in harappan population means that there was a migration from outside
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216ok
Are you talking about the Rakhigarhi skeleton? If so then it is not possible to find R1a genes in it as it is a female skeleton and R1a is found in Y chromosome of males.
It is possible for genetic mutation, but bro you're denying science because it harms your Indian supremacist beliefs, why does it make since for brahmins to have great r1a then surrounding Indians, and have higher percentage of light skin and colored eye, always why would North Indian have a lighter skkin than Europeans? The migrations didn't happen that long ago.
Came to see in comments this sort of question and got the answer
@@buddha9715your talking of just one skeletons which is a 25 year old female. There is another one of a 38 year old male from same sight and as the above person said, it contains no R1a and hence is proof of Indo Aryan migration.
"Two of the skeletons, a man between 35 and 40 years old" - www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rakhigarhi%23:~:text%3DTwo%2520of%2520the%2520skeletons%252C%2520a,men%27s%2520head%2520facing%2520the%2520women.&ved=2ahUKEwj1lO67ju-GAxWWxjgGHeE4An0QFnoECA0QBQ&usg=AOvVaw2YtOfyLDuhpWxY79OmY5vl
If R1a DNA originated in India, then, why is it not flowing towards the eastern part of the Asia?? What led them to go west??
North Irish guy here, I’ve got type O rh negative blood and am in R1A1A haplogroup, figure that one out. Guess we’re all Aryan. Eire-Ann(Ireland)=Iran = land of arya
I read in an old book from Aryavrt/Bharat/India, that the Sanskritum term for Ireland = Aryakund.
Don't know Sanskrit/Sanskritum; but I do know that "kundan/kund" [?---> "land"] means bloodline and lineage and family.
[The Irish/Celtic people are Spiritual people/have a strong inclination for spirituality, and to question.......question authority; as are the (non-abrahamic) Dharmic Arya of Aryavrt.]
[The tri-rung/tri-colors of the people, of the land, of the flags are very similar, of Ireland & Aryavrt.]
Over thousands of years and much migration, Bharatvarsha had developed a vast "civilizational gene pool".
As the barbaric Machiavellian Roman vEmpire transmuted to the Roman Catholic Empire via the Mediterranean-basin Mideast outcast Babylonian A-Dharmic A-Brahminic ABRAHAMIC [UnChristlike] political social economic/banking philosophy, Europe faded from its noble PreChristian/"preOld Testament" roots.
A people are a language---of the tongue. [In the cerebrum, the tongue is the software, (and the "holy" Orthogonal-Angle Thumb/prehensile gripper is the hardware (toolmaker)].
Sanskritum root sounds and concepts are found in multiple languages; the reverse is not seen---that is Latin nor Deutsche nor PYCCKI root and words are found in Sanskrit.
European gave that group to Indians panjeets lies...
Arya is no race..it's a term used for Gentleman in India
Indians have only one branch under R1a aka R-Z93 which is about 4,000 years old, and its oldest historical subclades were found in Central Asia/Eastern Europe as well.
See: yfull ancient DNA R-Z93
R1A developed is South Siberia 6000 years ago as per recent DNA research. You can call them first Aryans. Most people in Russia,Poland, Ukraine,Belarus - R1a. As far as I know from new study the most of Indian Brahmans 70% - R1a-z093. I am not going to drive any conclusions here but Sanskrit and Russian/Old Slavonic have around 1000 words of the same meaning. I support a view of some historians about Aryan migration to India due a Climate change. Veda in Russian means till now knowledge. There is no need to translate this word from Sanskrit.
R1a old as 25,000 year old
And r1a without steppe ancestory found in India ( no place in the world but only india)
Also 18,000 year old mutation r1a found among saharia tribe of central India
R1a 800ce recent but we have evidence of r1a present in india without steppes ancestory+ steppe ancestory oldest in north India date back 700bce ( according to top Geneticist Dr Niraj rai ) presence of vedic culture is is almost 1900bce ( most visible)
Early evidence such as rituals evidence is almost 2900bce old
@@greaterbharat4175 How many skeletons R1a have been found in India? We are talking here about different approach. If branch R1a belongs to archeological culture of Bronze Age with burials of few hundreds of skeletons on some territories it can be consider as an evidence and a new archeological culture. So far the oldest R1a have been found in Corded Ware culture, Fatyanovo culture, some Steppe cultures and then moving to Arcaim and Sintashta cultures in South of Siberia. All of them R1a. R1a is native/aboriginal to one place in this planet that I have mentioned above. This can be easy calculated with modern technologies.
If some pilgrims came to India in Bronze age
it does not mean this DNA is native to India.
@@yuliac3980 we brahmins burned our body according to our Vedic tradition how can our body be found there
@@ShivamRaina-dm9df I know about it. This is not my point.I was referring to bronze age archeological horizon when they did not do this yet. It is 5000-6000 years ago. But honestly it will just prove little thing that Aryans never moved to India from the north. It will not really change anything. Vedic religion is Indian religion even if it was brought from outside. The same like Christianity.Many accepted it because they feel it is right.Myself I think India is blessed because of Vedic tradition.
Tibetan Plateau or Himalayan ranges are the origin of R1a. And this mutation occurs in the Ice Age.
No. Up and haryana and j&k is aryan homeland
@@princekumar-yb4oq up northern of eurasian
@@princekumar-yb4oq Haryana and NW Indian has some percentage of European genes and this European gene came from Central Asian or Eurasian people. There is nothing Aryan about it. The real holders of the R1a gene are the Central Asians who lived in the ancient Tibetan plateau. This is where the mutation of this gene occurs. The Aryans are not a single nation, in ancient times all of these Asian continents identified themselves as Aryans.
Then why is R1a Haplogroup higher in Bengali and Bihari Brahmins ?
@@aryanchakraborty5175 mate r1a is higher in Bengal region due to aryans pushing into that region
I'm very much indian and my genetic analysis says maternal haplogroup as A and paternal as J-M241. Looks like J-M241 haplogroup has been in Indian since around 34,000 years ago. I don't see any R1a in my genetics. What does it mean? Also J-M241 is 34,000 yrs old means we have been in the sub-continent forever.
Can you take screenshots of this genetic report? Am curious
Which state are you from?
@Yash Sontakke I think he is from andaman Islands
Hard to believe even the tribal people of india have 15 to 29 percent r1a1
Hmm 'J-M241' is a South European haplogroup, pretty common imo. Would be great if you could send some SS!
They are fighting a lost battle to save a wrong History.
India is home for all religion and philosophy and culture .
I am not just saying ,it will be proved .
Proof requires the ability to discern facts from chaos and bias.
Indian wild patriots are just as braindamaged as European aryan fanboys.
The original PIE people does not exist anymore because newer steppe peoples destroyed and took over their homeland.
A people is made up of their genes, culture and knowledge.
Remove or replace any of these 3 and you'll end up with a different people from the original.
@@fredriks5090 So labelling someone also proves something.
So,just because someone disagree an idea he has to be X,Y,Z.
So ,why do you think Aryans came from outside India and is it from Central Europe on somewhere else and why do you think so ?
@@arzoo_singh You hammered him , damn
@@fredriks5090 Hello Fredrik , what you are saying is FALSE. We already know that after the 'Out of Africa' Migration happened , India became the first homeland of the human population. And after humans settled in India , they migrated to the rest of the World. We know this because almost all non - African haplogroups (for both males and females) have originated in India .
If a "MASSIVE GENOCIDE" of these "PIE" people occurred in the past then we would have clearly seen a shift in the genetics of the humans in the Indian Subcontinent. However the genetics of Indians have remained constant ever since we have settled in the Indian Subcontinent. Only minor changes have happened , for example , R1a has mutated to R1a1a and these minor changes are a result of climatic conditions.
@@fredriks5090 how do you explain the ice ages which were existing in Europe and which led to Europeans inter mixing with Neanderthal. Maximum Neanderthal DNA is found in Europe. R1a DNA went from India to Europe. The R1a DNA is concentrated in Russia and they don't even have any recorded ancient history like India. The Sarigarhi fossils predate the dates of invasion theory and have Aryan DNA. Just stop preaching racism in the world, you are our small son
16-17% R1a1 genes are mostly found in upper caste orthodox Brahmins of North India,,if this genes originated in India it should be present in all Indian population,,only a mere male population of North Indian consist it
Nope brother,
Some Brahmins, khatris & Ahirs of Punjab/Haryana have 60-70% R1a1 gene (check Wikipedia report)
@Cherry.pandey report padhle bhai, idhar dimag mat khaa.
Ek baar Google krne ka kasht krle
@Cherry.pandeysare brahmin mai nhi hai bs ek ya do section of brahmin mai hai aur usme Pandey nhi aate
@Cherry.pandey Pandey ji tumhare naam mai Pandey hai yahi bta raha hai ki tumhari anscetory panditayi krke dakshina mang kr khane ki hai 😌isme uncha kuch nhi hota self uncha proclaimed krne wale brahmin ji. Mai haryana se hu hmare yaha brahmin ki shadi mai jimte tak nhi hai . 😭😭😭😭bechara online hi apni frustration nikal leta hai . Feeling sad for you.
@Cherry.pandey ek baar report pdh le pta chl jaega . Aur kad Kathi mai to brahmin Yadavo ko kbhi takkar na de skte .🤣🤣🤣
BASED Thanks for this knowledge
Sir please review the channel of
" Survive the jive " He uses certain logical Falacies to push the idea of Eurocentric origin of R1a .
I would love to see that
@@shauryaveerrajkumar3950 David Reich's research is flawed not Scientific
Survive the jive is the bigot in this AIT community. He carries on brainwashing and false mainstream narratives
yeah i saw how logical he was😜😝 he is just copy pasting other's articles who were not even historians
In Europe we learn that Aryans came from India
Can you tell me more about it
When they talk about R (R1a1 mostly) clades, they confuse folks with percentages. What they hide is the Age- the oldest R clades including R1a1 are in India. How can the oldest R clades be derived from young R? They avoid it so they can perpetrate baseless theories. #NoAryans
@@alokbejai5250 follow Dr. Lavanya ph. D on twitter and read her paper on this issue.
@@alokbejai5250 also search about max muller what he was before he was hired by British. He was a like novelist .so he cooked a story for aryan when there is no word aryan for a particular group in any text or any where there is a word called arya arya putra or aryaman which is purely a religious term used for who follows vedic ideology or ideology related to it.
@@alokbejai5250 cool down chiled, indians don't save body under ice or soil, they burnt it.
So be chill aryans were india and they spread across the world we don't need proof we have enough.
Main proof is our history and veda
Note muslims are Arabs not Aryans 😁
What about the sindhi people in pakistan they were the most extremist hindu before mughals but when peaceful community appears other religion dissappears.har har mahadev🚩🕉️🕉️🕉️
But Iran is the land of Aryans, meaning of Iran is land of Aryans..
@@cleanpull999 but they are defeated by Arabs or Slavs of arab culture or religion
@@human8454 yes Persian culture was different, it was completely overridden by Arabs
@@ArcanumArcanorum17 Okay, I think I may misinterpret your comments, but if you wanna say that Mughals were Persian by this comment, then you are wrong here man! Cause Babur's origin was in Uzbek region, and his ancestory was Turkic, but when and indigenous king Sher Shah suri defeated and expelled his son humayun, then he became refugee in Persia and through Persian help, he established his empire back, that's why you can see influence of Persian culture in Mughal Empire like use of Persian language as Court language, but they were not Persian at all!
Another factual correction: before brits, india was ruled by two major power, Maratha and Sikhs, not Mughals.
Har har mahadev 🚩🕉️
That’s completely untrue, the highest historical diversity of yDNA haplogroup R1a was found in Eastern Europe and Central Asia, not in India. Indians (especially) northern Indians) have the highest levels of yDNA haplogroup R1a and central Asian yamnaya ancestry. Rors, Kashmiris, and Sindhis have the highest levels of Yamnaya ancestry (20-40%) and that’s why they look much lighter than other south Asians who lack this ancestral component/have it in a very low percentage.
According to most anthropologists and scientists today Indo-Aryan languages are related to sintashta-Andronovo cultures which are related to east-central European corded ware culture, they all belonged to yDNA haplogroup R1a (Z93) and had blue eyes, fair hair, and fair skin. They lacked the ancestral south Asian component AKA AASI.
It is totally proven that Aryans invaded India and bred with native Dravidian women. It is not vice versa! Original Indians are Dravidians not Indo-European.
Yup it's the fact we should confront it
Avrg Aryan invasion Picnic bullshit theory believer spotted 🤡🫵🤣
Yeah so much that there aren't even mass genocidal bodies like when the yamanayas did to Europe
And the battle of ten kings is historical even written in rig veda
Like what kind of source is going to say that the dumb Europeans were the ones that wrote the rig veda
Source wikipedia page 😂
Like he has already proven it wrong many times but still you will believe this🏳️🌈🤡
The ancient DNA record has shown the first R1a during the Mesolithic in Eastern Hunter-Gatherers, from Eastern Europe, c. 13,000 years ago. Data has a Comb Ceramic Culture (CCC) male that belongs to related R1a5-YP1272, from Estonia.
Yep and at the same time Indian skeletons from Indus Valley which are 4600 years old have a total lack of R1a. As usual Indians can't accept that anything that goes againts the idea of India not being first place.
I don't understand how in serbian language we have more than 5000 words from Sanskrit...
@@Kukhyaati Serbia is not on Middle east
@@Kukhyaati I am not going to answer on your offensive language! There is at least one more rout for migration and it is "gate of people" in Russia and Kazakhstan. Do you for really think that answer on my question is "Indians have migration to Middle East"? In another word you didn't answer anything.
PS: I am not Western
Because of Gypsies
Good day to you Abhijit.
I am a Czechoslowakia born Slav, with R1a1a1a1 genome.
I am certain that the Vedas say that once there was a one unified world population, Vedic population. After Kali begun, Europe was repopulated by breakaway unruly ksatriya kings fleeing from the old Bharatavarsa capitol Hastinapur. That is why we are Indo Europeans, better still Indo Aryans, Aryans meaning of high class, noble. So we Euroeans came from the Indian Asian region. Not the other way round, that is some nonsense and misinformation that the likes of Smithonian Institute would spread. The ksatriya kings established many cities that are the capitols to this day. Praha, the capitol of Czechs was originally called previously Pragalbha. Varsava - the capitol of Poland - both cities carry sanksrit root in the names.
As the quest of world parasites continues to wipe out the remnants of the old Vedic culture based on principles and order so that chaos and discord can be spread, we see the group of todays people that are being persecuted the most - the Slavs.
Genetically Slavs are the biggest carriers of R1a gene. (ancient Scythians)
There are lot of words based on Sankrit in Slavic languages. The symbolism is the same (swastika), the name of old Gods is the same.
Eventually it is important to remember that the separation between races, nations, religions are not really significant IF you can realise that we are all of one origin.
Many greetins to you from the heart of Europe and Slavic land.
Namastaey
White skin is adaptation to the cold weather. -> as more R1a you have as more white skin you have->north India brown skin-> Afghanistan yellow-> Siberia white
From Siberia my friends
From India my friend.
From southern Siberia and after that Northern Himalayan Indian region@@AJAYSINGH-ns1vv
Is the Kingdom of Lechistan one of the kingdoms started by the mass migrations out of India?
Genetic Evidence for Westward Indo-Aryan expansion
Recent DNA evidence shows that Europe experienced a massive population influx from the east, beginning around 4,500 years from the present. Several haplogroups were involved in this expansion, including the Indian-origin R1a1a. This was almost a total replacement event, which indicates that Indo-Aryans, among others, expanded westward into Europe and to a large extent, replaced indigenous European males and their Y-chromosome strata (Sharma and his associates, 2009)
This genetic evidence indicates that several Y-chromosomal (patrilineal) lineages, one of which was the Indian-origin R1a1a, gave rise to the modern European population. Out of these lineages, R1a1a is the most widespread and numerous.
1. The R1a haplogroup originated in India.
2. The Indo-Aryan people have lived in India for at least 15,450 years, which invalidates the theory that the Indo-Aryans invaded India 3,500 years ago.
3. The hundreds of millions of members (possibly over a billion) of the R1a family living across the world today - a very large fraction of humanity - are all descended from one single male ancestor who lived in India at least 15,450 years ago.
This discovery demonstrates the close genetic (and hence linguistic and cultural) affinity of Indians with the Russian and Polish people, the Vikings and Normans, and with the ancient Scythians and Tocharians, among many others (Sharma et al, 2009).
This is irrefutable scientific proof that not only did the Indo-Aryan people originate in India over 15,450 years ago, but also that they expanded out of India and settled in lands far to the west in Europe. It thoroughly invalidates the AIT (Aryan Invasion Theory) and AMT (Aryan Migration Theory).
Literary Evidence for Westward Indo-Aryan expansion
Consider the Baudhayana Shrauta Sutra, a Vedic text. Baudhayana Shrauta Sutra @ records:
“Amavasu migrated westward. His people are Gandhari, Parsu and Aratta.”
This refers to a Vedic king called Amavasu, whose people are the Gandhari (Gandhara - Afghanistan), the Parsu (Persians) and the Aratta, who are tentatively identified as living in the vicinity of Mt. Ararat, which is located in Turkey (eastern Anatolia) and Armenia.
Afghanistan (Gandhara) was historically part of the Indian civilization until the Islamic invasions. The name “Persia” comes from the ancient Parshva people (an Aryan clan). The word “Parshva” is derived from the Sanskrit/Avestan (Old Persian) word “Parshu”, which means “battle-ax”. There are clear linguistic and cultural similarities between India and Persia.
The traditional Armenian name for Mt. Ararat is Masis. It is named after the legendary Armenian king Amasya. The name “Amasya” is linguistically related to the name “Amavasu” of the Indian king recorded in the Baudhayana’s Shrauta-Sutra. This establishes literary evidence for the westward expansion of Indo-Aryans, via Afghanistan, to Persia, Armenia and Anatolia.
The ancient kingdom of Mitranni, of the people who used to worship Mitra, the Vedic God, located in present-day Syria and Anatolia, had an Indo-Aryan, Sanskrit-speaking ruling class. Mitranni kings had Indo-Aryan names. The oldest recorded (Vedic) Sanskrit words are found in a horse training manual by a Mitranni horse master named Kikkuli. Although the text is written in the Hittite language, it appears that Kikkuli was not familiar enough with that language to use technical terms, which made it necessary for him to use the terminology of his own language (Vedic Sanskrit) instead.
Inscribed clay tablets discovered in Boğazkale, Anatolia (Turkey), record a royal treaty and invoke the Vedic gods Indra, Mitra, Nasatya & Varuna by the Hittites, another Indo-European tribe, as witnesses. The Boğazkale clay tablets are dated to about 1380 BC. This is around the same time as Kikkuli’s horse training manual.
The Mitranni and Hittites belonged to the Indian-origin haplogroup R1a1a. This is clear evidence of a large-scale westward expansion of Sanskrit-speaking Indo-Aryans, and their presence as the ruling aristocracy in lands thousands of kilometers west of India.
The children of Goddess Danu.
The primordial Rig Vedic river goddess Danu is the mother/progenitor of the Danava clan of Indo-Aryans. The Danavas revolted against the Devas and were eventually defeated and got banished. As it turns out, that was far from the end of their story. The word dānu means “fluid, drop” in Rig Vedic Sanskrit. The Avestan (old Iranian) word for “river” is “dānu”. The Scythian (Saka/Shaka) & Sarmatian words for “river” are also “dānu”.
Now consider this: linguistically, the names of the European rivers Danube, Dnieper, Dniestr, Don, Donets, Dunajec, Dvina or Daugava, and Dysna are all derived from the Rig Vedic Sanskrit root word “dānu”. These rivers flow across eastern & central Europe. These rivers, all named after the Rig Vedic goddess Danu, seem to trace the gradual westward migration through Europe of the Danava clan of Rig Vedic Indo-Aryans.
According to Irish & Celtic mythology, the Irish & Celtic people are descended from a mother goddess - a river goddess - called Danu. The ancient (mythological) people of Ireland are called the Tuatha Dé Danann (Old Irish: “The peoples of the goddess Danu”).
Is there genetic evidence to support this story? As it turns out, there is. The R1a1a haplogroup is rare in Ireland, at 2.5% of the population. This can be explained by the fact that Ireland has suffered many invasions since the Bronze Age, which would have led to the gradual replacement of the R1a1a haplogroup with those of the various invaders. The fact that R1a1a is still present in Ireland proves that people of Indo-Aryan origin settled there in the past (Sharma et al, 2009).
Elsdon Best (1972) in his book wrote that the ancestors of a tribe Tuhoe in New Zealand came from India via Peru. DNA tests on some of them proved the origin of their ancestors. They said that they traveled from India after the Mahabharata war to New Zealand. Thus, the story of Manu dividing up the world among his sons maybe not a myth. (@
In a report published in Nature, a group of scientists and archeologists of the ASI (Archeological Survey of India) and IIT (Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur) proved that the cities of Indus valley were at least 9000 years old, not just 3500 years. The cause of the decline was not any Aryan invasion, but a continuous lack of rainfall since that 9000 years when most rivers dried up. That might have caused the outward migration of the Aryans from India (Sarkar, 2016).
(This is quoted from our (Victoria Miroshnik and Dipak Basu), forthcoming book, Ethics, Morality and Business, to be published by Palgrave-Macmillan. )
Tracing the R1a origin, it evolved in central Eurasia, between the Indian and European clusters. You can trace the mutations backwards to the steps. And the proto-R haplogroups evolved even futher into the East, in Asia. European scolars are not trying to "prove a European origin". Not even the German nazi researchers in the 1930:s tried to do that. Evidence has always pointed towards the step, towards the Kurgans, the Yamnaya, the Andronovo culture. Present day scientists are so woke that they would love to place it far away from Europe but evidence points clearly to the step. Very interesting with all the genetic evidence of human migration gathering. Interesting to hear your thoughts.
Everyone would invade and do large migrations, but yes the biggest and most important migration was into India but India also sent out their own migration floods but like very small and it’s attributed to different peoples.
That last point is false. Scythians were horse riding nomads far different than Southern Indian culture. And their appearance is also more European Aryan than southern Aryan.
The oldest known sample of haplogroup P1, which is ancestral to R, was found in the north of Yakutia, the most ancient R was found in the Mal'ta-Buret' culture near Baikal. The oldest R1a was discovered in Russia, in the Arkhangelsk region (11 thousand years old). The oldest R1a-z93 were found in the Fatyanovo-Balanovo culture in Eastern Europe, where they originated. The population of the Fatyanovo culture spoke the Proto-Indo-Iranian language and was closest in autosomal DNA to the North European populations and had a high continuity with the Corded Ware culture. The CWC heritage is at its peak among northern and eastern Europeans.
nothing you said changes my statements. R1a z93 is literally the most common haplogroup among the Indo-Aryans, with the largest concentration among the upper castes in India, and we can say for sure that it did not appear in India and where it migrated from.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 European cattle have an admixture of zebu due to the fact that about 4 thousand years ago in the greater Middle East there was a drought due to which zebu mixed with Middle Eastern domestic cows as a result of migration
z93 that originated in Europe is most common among the population of India with the highest concentration among the upper castes. Plus Europeans or CWC populations do not have an autosomal Indian component, while Northern Indians have a European component, as do Tajiks and Pashtuns who have more r1a distribution than Indians as well as a European component. In fact, this is already enough to close the topic. I can even ignore the rest of your arguments.
There is literally a r1b haplogroup in europe that is not found in india, so that invalidates your hypothesis of prehistoric gypsy migration
A few percent of the haplogroup r1b can hardly be the source for half of Europe
Yaani brahman bharat choro tum videshi ho is true😂😂
R1a (R-Z93 - R-Y57) from north of France since at least 1650, an idea ?
Why any research about india become a controversial topic?
Because its almost always outlandish claims, questionable logic and the fact that nobody else wants to be associated with you
First migration about 44k years ago k came to India from Africa and then its branches migrate to South East Asia and then branches to china to Lake baikal there p1 branches to r1a r1b some moved to India some moved to Central steppes. So it round tripping which mutated K to P to R. K is well established its origin in India
Aryan genetic line comes from Northern Iran before it spread into Eastern Europe and created the Slavs.
Hi Abhijit,
Firstly can't thank you enough for all the knowledge you provide in these videos!
I belong to the community of chitpavan/koknashtha brahmans from Maharashtra. As we usually have white skin, blue/green eyes- I have heard theories from different people that we originated from the Jews/British, etc. I am not sure if that is entirely true..i know this is too specific! But could you explain a bit about that? Where did the koknashtha/chitpavans come from?? (There are even some superstitious theories that the parshrurama created us!)
Chitpavans are indo greek origin.greeks mostly setteled in gandhar region of North Pakistan and Pakistani Punjab but some Greek people want to return Europe by sea route . Some people settled in konkan coast during this journey. The physical appearance of chitpavans Brahman resembles greek ancestral link.
@@RajeevRanjan-uk6bx Greeks are brown or fair skinned but have no blonde and brown eyes , or blue eyes .
@@tarunbhadana2722 are you stupid ? Greeks are more blonde then most Germans you will meet lol, don’t let foreigners fool you, Greeks are more white then most Europeans you will meet, bactrians and other Greek settlements gave rise to white looking Indians
Hello to all my R1a1 brothers.
All hail the GRANDfather
I agree us Eastern Europeans and North Indians have a paternal link, but I believe it originated in steppes of Russia, anyway R1a people are of noble blood.
R1a Z93 are afghan pathan people
No way it’s from India.. reasons are as follows;
India is populated recently.. R1a origins also has a sibling R1b.. fair skin itself develop in cold environment.. India is home for others but no indo-European originated in India
Not an invasion but movement from saptasindhu to different parts of India
Need billions investment to establish this fact.
Ex. China pouring huge money into research and publications
R1a found oldest genetics diversity in india. Indian tribal population from south to north both carry oldest r1a genetics which is more than 20k years old. So maybe aryan were native to iran .Small migration happened in indus valley civilization from west asia. Yamanaya don't carry r1a so no aryan invasion happened.
Hum yam culture did have R1a, Slavic gave India R1a
Sir do you have any idea about R1B , specifically R-CTS1843 ?
The descendent of british people
#AskAbhijit
If you think Haplogroup R1a originated in India then why according to Karafet et al they say that Haplogroup R which holds the lineage R1a evolved from another Haplogroup called Haplogroup P, which originated in South East Asia?
Muvh of southeast asia waa hindu, civilisational continuity
Haplogroup P originated in South Asia and gave rise to R and Q, the R and Q were ANE (Ancient North Eurasians) the Q gave rise to Native Americans, the R1 gave rise to Europeans, a lineage of the R1 gave rise to the Indo-Iranians of the Middle East, a group of Indo-Iranians came to India and mixed with the Dravidian
Indo aryan Scythian Jat sikh r1a1 bloodline yes it all comes from Indian
@3 AMRITANSHU SINGH Read Sharma report , highest frequency occurs in Bengali Brahmins 😁 , second is UP Brahmin , them Bihar . Sikhs and Jats have lesser frequency
Basically it most present in Indian Upper caste mainly Rajputs of India
the most successful species in the west are Indo aryan
Scythian were descendants of aryan males by malecha mothers and then scythians got absorbed in Indic populations (jats,rors etc)
O is the haplogroup with the largest population by far.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 Check again.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 Pretty sure O is larger. I saw a comparison one time by percentages.
Abhijith Chavdaji Namasthey
I have only one ☝️ sincere question to you.
Can you replace our present Prime Minister Modiji in the next election 🗳 that’s 2014?
Three ancillary queries
(A) if so how and if not why?
(B) Is it possible or impossible?
(C) Is it relevant or irrelevant to our Indian 🇮🇳 context?
Thanks 🙏
Pandu Kuchibhotla
Anaheim CA USA 🇺🇸
😂😂😂
...2014 ????
@@universeofopulence 2024😂😂
Sir please allow closed caption
A person with no medical background blurting out lies. Study actual data on R1a gene oldest samples have been detected in and around Ukraine. So Aryan race originated there and migrated to western Europe and Asia.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 nonsense comment krne ke bajae kuch actual argument do
@@shahanshahpolonium Aisa hi hai toh Jaipur dialogues ne prize money rakha hai AMT prove karne ke liye. Toh kyun kisi ne accept nahi kiya. AMT propaganda is brutally crushed and is now on its last leg.
Haha😂 oldest r1a gene was found in roopkund uttarakhand with 0 % steppe
R1a was originated in India, that's it
@@yogainstructorpradeepsingh3040can I have the source for your claim please?
Funded
In the book of Esther it is said that Ahasuerus the Persian/Iran king ruled part of India and Ethiopia. Plus Zoroastrian/Iranian were the earliest Abrahamic group that sought refuge in India to escape the Muslim persecution. Iran and Vedic have the same astrological deity. I study Vedic and Abrahamic religion :) pretty much part of the huge Indo-European family 😁
All people have U2b2, not one tribe. This is selective interpretation. clade U originated in India & it’s subcldes a-c are widely spread among all folks of India.
Mt.Ararat . That’s the final answer.
I have given my students of 12 std to research on Haplogroups and perform on project on these topic.
5:10
This is untrue, again, the Scythians indeed belonged to haplogroup R1a but they lacked the ancestral ancient south Asian ancestry also known as AASI, autosomally they shared more with present day Northern and Eastern Europeans, not present day south Asians, and their cultural similarities with current North Indian people is due to their own influence on South Asia, but they weren’t south Asians themselves as Autosomal analyzes have already shown.
The Scythians were blue eyed, fair haired and fair skinned too, typically for corded ware cultures which had a central/eastern European origin.
Who is R1b and R1a? From which race?
Sir,.we take uncooked natural food that can be naturally digested,, healthy and variety. That kind of food is only in India, none other. How come human come from Africa?
Bruh, diets change over time
The delusion is strong here😅
The burn is strong in your comment. 😂😂
R1a is very very old. Its even found in Indian tribals. Now I'm more interested in L-M357 which is common in Jats and Afghan Pashtun males, but also being found in Indian Muslims.
Gujarat rajputs 100%r1a gene
Rathore mewar -r1a y7
Jhala-r1a y7
Manhas-r1a y7
Shekhawat-r1a z94
@AskAbhijit
SIR WHAT ARE YOUR VIEWS ON RAVISH KUMAR
Aryan's = Mauryan's 🧬💀🤚🏻
R1a is native to the steppes.
Euro-centric and Indo-centric views are equally idiotic.
No it's not, it's definitely of Indian South Asian origins, it's found even among isolated tribes in Southern Asia and even in even in remote island regions like the Maldives OFF OF THE COAST OF SOUTH INDIA OF ALL PLACES, steppes was barely and sparsely populated to have originated such a major genetic haplogroup found among such a high concentration of people in a highly populated place like Southern Asia
Central Asians called their land Otter korus , which comes from Uttar Kuru of the rig Veda . Uttar Kuru means Northern Kuru . Kuru was the capital of Aryavartha ( india ) present day Haryana .
Which indicates the Central Asians considered themselves as a part of Indian subcontinent .
@@stardust2045 I didn't say that the Andamanese have steppe admixture, I said the steppes had the Andamanese ADMIXTURE COMPONENT at significant amounts, even remains like M'alta boy all the way in Siberia among others. The fact that the ANDAMANESE DO NOT HAVE THE STEPPE ADMIXTURE COMPONENT BUT THE STEPPES HAS THEIR GENETIC COMPONENT PRETTY MUCH SEALS THE DEAL THAT THE OOI MIGRATIONS DID INFACT HAPPEN!!!
Also the Andamanese DO NOT REPRESENT ANY ARCHAIC SOUTH ASIAN POPULATIONS ONE BIT!! The Andaman islands are GEOGRAPHICALLY IN SOUTH EAST ASIA AND NOT SOUTHERN ASIA-INDIA REGION!!! The closest land masses to the Andaman Islands if one were to use a boat are SOUTH EAST ASIAN COUNTRIES LIKE INDONESIA OR BURMA etc etc NOT EVEN INDIA OR OTHER SOUTH ASIAN COUNTRIES LIKE SRI LANKA!! In addition the Andamanese are so genetically isolated and have been isolated on their islands for almost ten thousand years approx that they form their own distinct genetic pool and group COMPLETELY DIFFERENT FROM ANYONE THAT EVER EXISTED IN MAINLAND SOUTHERN ASIA!!!!
The fact that the steppes had the Andamanese admixture COMPONENT in significant amounts considering all the above IS A HUGE GIVEAWAY THAT THE OOI DID HAPPEN!!!
Also using a single remain or sample for R on steppes doesn't mean that IE people's originated from there or that said R carrier spoke an IE language as many Turkic and even Semitic people's carry R haplogroup.
@@shauryaveerrajkumar3950 R1a isn't found in Western , Southern europeans too , so what's your point ?
Indian male DNA: C is oldest 73KYA, later CDF 50KYA-and mutation that gave rise to R is Indian. R 43KYA (oldest/may have originated in India). R1a, 36KYA& later derivatives oldest in India. #NoAryans continuous evolution
You are correct sir.
Eastern Europe.
2019 genetic research: Absence of R1a gene in Harappan people.
And knowing that Harappan Civilization preceded Vedic civilization archaeologically too..
It becomes obvious to conclude that Aryan were not present when Harappan Civilization was in prime.
Aryan didn't originate in India.
That's true.
I am surprised you are not taking account of 2019-20 research regarding R1a1 genetic research of Harappan People.
Aryan came later on and spread in Indian Subcontinent.
Illogical to say when their is no single paternal dna is research in Harappan or any site of indus civilization ( from main sites)
Genetic studies happened in female skeleton
Female have no y haplogroup
R1a is y haplogroup
Jestem polka (polaki- po-lachy lachy=lechici ) jestem słowianka- R1A1
आर्यवर्त
🙏
Hey can you plz tell whats the status of research and who is doing it ?
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 isn't oldest r1a found in northern Russia? And veda mention arctic circle as original homeland of Aryans?
This gen R1a its most buy as Roma who are the descent off India
*When you realise Bharat is more than 60000 years old.*
R1 dna are aryans of pamir, tian shan, siberia,khotan and descendants of grand parent R.....
R2 dna are proto tamizhis of sindhu river and descendants of grand parent R.....
Both were one ppl of same coin....
I proud my Ancestors🙏🙏🙏
Jay Jagannath 🙏🚩🚩🚩
Jay shree Ram🙏🚩🚩🚩
Jay khandayat🙏🚩🚩🚩
pajiet delusions
Haplogroups; mtDNA: U2-C1 , and yDNA: OF-8
🇱🇰
Really? If your ydna is O-F8, that means you are the descendent of Chinese Royal family who created Han dynasty
Once people understand that persians and indians are related everything makes sense. There is enough evidence in our texts. The R1a is from Iran.
You were left, so you also started boasting😏
It is from india
are you sure?
R1a1 is Kyrgyz!!!
I am from punjab how can i check my genetic is R1a
You share paternal lineage with Russians, haha maybe this is why Indians love Russia, long lost brothers by same father
But it is proven R1a originated in Siberia, near lake Baikal, also this guy said there is a narrative ? How western Europeans and the britishers control the media and hate that Indians have a relationship with Russia. Western Europeans have always looked down on slavs, the word slaves actually comes from slav, because the ottoman Turks enslaved slavic people, we share that both Turks invaded and made y'all Muslims this also happens in Bosnia a slavic country, and they tried to convert all but the slavs kicked them out luckily.
@@joemama4473bro can u explain me my dna
60%r1a
20% L
20 %H
Its obviously originates from northern iran / caucases. Iranians invaded india and brought with them aryan culture. Thats why northern india is lighter skin than the south. Zoroastrianism is older than hinduism.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 r u blind ?
bcz i see physical traits difference
@greek nationalist Atleast have some sense before speaking lie....Its originated in India
You must make videos in hindi please
You are all come from Kyrgyzstan
No invasion, assimilation
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 My profession lets me understand this better than you. You probably dont know about the differential dating of Yamnaya vs Sinthastha Vs Androvo haplogroups , your ignorance is appalling .
not true
is central europe
Not to mention R2 and R3 the descendant /evolved Version of R1 (white/Euro dna is only found in Indian! its proof the Sub-continent is the homeland because it contains the most genetic diversity even they don't have
R1a Z93 is afghan people
R1A1 and r1b ✋ pashtuns