He was born in valinor and chose not to return. In some text it's written that he will not leave middle earth until every elven ship has return to valinor wich he does sometime during the 4th age
You didn’t read the books and are just saying this to complain. Cirdan, as written by Tolkien himself, canonically has a beard. Did you even see the video??
Thanks for the info! Its good we take the good where we can find it.
They had him cut the beard
Yes they did
And feanors father in law mahatan
Obviously because he is the only he-elf in middle earth.
but this are dei elfs....
If he's so old why has he never been called to Valinor?
He was born in valinor and chose not to return. In some text it's written that he will not leave middle earth until every elven ship has return to valinor wich he does sometime during the 4th age
@@mathieuetienne2293 ty , I know nothing of the books 👍
@@Winter-gf9nt np
The obvious explanation is a complete disregard for all of Tolkiens work and the adaptations that came before it.
Cirdan canonically has a beard in the book. We can criticize when they get things wrong but let’s not say this is a problem
Elves have 3 live staged . The third in wich he is has then grow beards . Its 100% canon .
Show runners need to make up their minds. Galadriel is nearly the same age as Cirdan, but doesn't look nearly as "old"
You didn’t read the books and are just saying this to complain. Cirdan, as written by Tolkien himself, canonically has a beard.
Did you even see the video??