For people struggling, drop the afk spot. 42 blocks with sim 4 (which is what this farm is supposed to be made for) doesnt seem to spawn any witches. I dropped the spot by 4 blocks and it started working. Dropping it by 1 didnt work. Not sure if the update also changed spawning ranges, but 42 seems to be incorrect.
@@Foefii understandable, I play on windows 10 but I use my ps5 to afk farms and it was working on my pc but was not getting drops on ps5 and I figured out it was because of this issue and it fixed it 👍
Works like a charm . I did use another piston on the cauldron side to kill them faster so you get hardly any potions . Yes glass bottles but not tons of potions . Alway check spawning rate of hut some spawn one and slow. Find one that alway spawns 4 or more is best tested and tested this on xbox. Found one that always spawned 7 each time
Just built this in 1.21. I can't believe I didn't build this earlier! No more mining for redstone! I added an item sorter to collect the redstone and glowstone then I added a compactor to condense the redstone and dumped the rest, as I don't need it. Thanks Silent !
To those whos farms not spawning witch's..... i had the same problem and through troubleshooting i found that i had my sculk catalyst net to the spawn spot. I removed it and put a solid block in its place than put it down and it solved my issues. Working great now. Thanks again Silent!
Just built this today because of the new minor update that makes redstone drops from witches a 100% drop in large quantities, and was blown away when I checked the chest 15 minutes later and already got a stack of redstone blocks (or 9 stacks of redstone dust, but even then, I had a stack and a bit left over) Definitely would recommend this farm ESPECIALLY with 1.21.20 now out, and also considering the fact that once I got all the materials around and found the witch hut, this only took me 10 minutes to build!!!
My PS4 finally updated to 1.21.20 and I'm getting an insane amount of Redstone now. I was getting too many potions and added another trident to kill them faster. Thanks again for the great Bedrock content!
I glossed over the part about filling in under the witch farm, but after seeing that in another video and building this again, I took the time and resources to fill in a lot of stuff under the hut. It improved my rates a lot. I believe the area that needs to be filled in is just the chunk where the witch hut is.
Will build this as soon as i have tridents with impaling V. I made a witch farm without tridents. I'm using a sticky piston holding a solid block that suffocates witches. Works great as a starter 👍🏻
Yo build the portal like for a gold/pigman farm, but instead of building the water slide that feeds them into a trident killer; instead just building the portal part of it and build a giant fence/boxed in area below the portal. Let it run for like 60 mins and you'll have like 100s of pigmen, spawn wither in the middle and his spawn explosion will execute all pigman instantly giving you tons of roses. Very simple. Optional Put water in fenced in area if pigman are taking too much fall damage. (Wither cannot be spawned if the soul sand is wet). Alternatively you could breed tons of bees with flowers and spawn wither, they get agro at him I believe so they will eventually all eleminate themselves if the spawn explosion doesn't get them all
thanks so much! not even 10 minutes has passed, and i already got a stack of redstone! thanks so much for this update: not even 10mins has passed, and i already got 8 stacks of redstone, its OP gonna modify the storge later.
Nice, although I think I prefer your previous witch farm for getting them to drop fire resistance potions. This still ought to be handy for many though
this farm is crazy fast, to the point where i realized i may need to add a crafter system for the red stone to make them into blocks hahaha thank you for the guide! i think like 20 minutes will fill up a chest but that’s also bc potion bottles don’t stack
It’s still working 1.21 bedrock. I made it exactly as he did except without the tinted glass, my simulation distance is max at 10 chunks and it still works just like in the video… he’s right about needing to pick up the trident when you are done it will fall through the glass blocks and the farm will break kinda like how you armor stands can be moved by pistons and be inside glads blocks. Also don’t kill the frogs!!!!!
Seems to be working, thanks for the tutorial! Would’ve sucked to get red stone without this as my base is primarily made of cobblestone and red stone blocks.
If you remove the existing structure and put the minimum blocks needed to block light you'll be able to clearly see the witches death animation popping out the side
Works great. Tried Prowl's first (double trident killer) but the spawn was painfully slow. Don't know why. Switched over to this one (same hut), pulling in gobs of stuff. I use Tinted glass for all glass parts, no issues. Guessing the regular glass parts were a matter of taste/conservation of resources point. Off to planning the next mayhem --- some more farms at the AFK spot (8 chunk, +123 Y) here to maximize productivity while AFK... Pie is the best.
Sick of seeing comments complaining about not having a lot of gunpowder from this. My buddy and I been doing sorting systems and it doesn’t really matter what farm you use or what rate it gives. If you can OBTAIN any said item from a farm. You have the ability to ONLY have that put into chests. Stop shitting on farms that don’t give you an ultra perfect gunpowder only drop rate. That doesn’t exist. Just utilize the fact that you CAN get gunpowder and overnight afk and you’ll have all the gunpowder you need with this.
10/10 quick and easy build, witches spawned as soon as I left the area to AFK .. lots of loot .. (next time, I’ll come to you first for farm builds - had no success with the other tutes here)
Great build , however I had some issues with the items floating on the water and above the scaffolding so wasn’t getting collected , managed to use a kinda drain by knocking a couple of blocks and letting water flow out to a bubble column 😃
@@GuckFoogle507 Sculk catalyst is optional. And, yeah, I somehow couldn't find bamboo but found deep dark. There is like no jungle 3,000 blocks in any direction. But now that doesn't matter. I lost that world and am playing in a new one, where I literally spawn in a jungle.
Question, with Witch Huts, is the highest spawn spot +1 Y Level? Like 1 block up from the middle block? Used to be when I was experimenting. Not that it helps anything, but ya get to go up 1 more block. LOL Also, I wonder about using a block of mud as a spawn spot for the witches. A hopper can pull through mud and I've been trying to incorporate it more in my builds. Otherwise, love that you're putting water in there to get water breathing potions, and setup a simple trident killer at the Y Level of the structure spawn spot. Now I gotta recalculate my raid farm to get 2 blocks higher for the afk spot. I was only dropping them down a block instead of like 4-5 like what most people seem to like. I really like to run the numbers and see how far I can push it. Your knowledge of redstone and game mechanics is impressive. Loved the video. :)
@@silentwisperer No he meant at min 8:00 you said if we replace the roof block directly above the spawning block with tinted glass we will get pillager patrols in the farm so it might be possible to get omi bottles
I made this farm with my friend in bedrock edition, when the farm was complete a witch spawned but the items that dropped from the witch didn't go to the hopper it just stayed there and despawned, dont know what i did wrong
If it's the piglin nether portal farm they might be filling the mob cap and therefore not letting witches spawn? Should only be an issue while active though.
For me (bedrock 1.21.44 Xbox) the glass pains in the corner of the witch hut actually blocked the spawning. I had to get rid of those and stand at y:101 (37 blocks above the spawning block) to get them to spawn. Otherwise works great!
Tridents only loose durability if the player is actively using them. Trident killers update the position of them without reducing durability. No need for mending
Built this with a basic item collection system with item sorter at the ground then later changed it to item sorter in the sky where my afk platform is and as soon as i made the switch the rates dropped catastrophically to the point of uselessness. Do you have any way to fix this? I was thinking of going back to the old collection system i had, but would I prefer to be able to have a collection system at the afk platform. Do bubble columns drop rates? Im not sure what to do to fix this.
Yooooo, I just commented on your old video a few days ago asking you to upload a new one so we didn't have to follow the comments, and you did it 😅❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Just in time for my gunpowder farm. I want to build a gunpowder farm from witch hut because my ghast and creeper farm doesn't produce enough gunpowder. Thank you so much.
witch farms produce very little gunpowder compared to other farms usually was this better? my general mob farm produces about 2 1/2 double chests per night of afk
The bug with tridents you talked about at the end of the video, is it a known bug, are there any plans to fix it? I've built your guardian farm and farmed all tridents for every single killing chamber, and having to place and remove them each time is a hassle. Great video btw.
Does anyone know if I can make an iron farm and bamboo farm(flying machine version) near the afk platform with water streams from all three farms directed to a auto crafter array? Or would it mess up the spawns of the witches
im having issues getting the witches to spawn, this is my second attempt at building a redstone farm and this version is so straight forward im upset that i cant get it to work, i built my thing at the northwest corner and everything just like the video, i need to go back to the glass pane step and see why i cant get a witch to spawn. did they change how witches spawn since changing their loot drop?
Great video. Would using scaffolding to get to the AFK spot cause any problems? I have an elyta, but my flying skills are "embarrassing". Edited for the kind person who noticed my spelling mistake.
Thanks a lot for all your tutorial. I'm french and i can understand all you said, you speak very clearly and it's really cool :) Hope to see more and more tutorials from you ;) Already did from you: Wich farm, gold farm, bamboo farm, and soon guardian farm :)
Not required. Like he said it just keeps the xp orbs from over accumulating which can cause lag and issues eventually. I built it without it and it ran fine. You can even occasionally go down and open the top and get a flood of xp. Likely without doing so eventually it may cause issues.
I’ve been using this for last 2 weeks no problems however today after the update it wasn’t working, been trynna tweak it see if I can get it to work again, will keep posted if I find anything
My friend does this still work with the change of mob spawns being in the centre rather than NW, bc I know a few farms that were messed because of that change. Additionally, skulk veins have been spreading. I don’t think this affects the farms function, but I wouldn’t mind a second opinion. Also, do Pillager parties still spawn and if so, how often? Thank you
@@Uauauaz1 yeah I just hooked it up to a full sorting system using the softer designs silent had uploaded a few months ago with the target blocks it works well
Hey silent! I built your Moss Bonemeal farm from 2 years ago;everything works fine without any single change. But the comparators in the minecart unloaders breaks and stops the minecarts evertime the farm is used once but the comparators needs to be replaced again to fix the problem. Its annoying to replace the comparators after single use. You have any solution for that?
Are you on a realm server??? Sounds like you’re trolling around. But if you’re telling the truth I suggest re ticking the clock for the pistons. And if that doesn’t work rebuild it. Removing any water of any kind and if need be. Enchant the trident with mending to ensure yourself.
i toggle my world between peaceful and hard mode often to run my farms, i had trouble getting one to spawn so i cleared the whole room out and i still cant get a witch to spawn in the hut, can anybody help me? is it possibly because im arriving at the witch hut in peaceful mode and despawning them so they will never spawn there now when i change it to hard mode? I had that problem pulling up on the ocean monuments and despawning the elder guardians forever but I dont know about witches in the witch huts. I have already messed up the three closest witch huts to my base in my world and i only have one more reasonable attempt. please help
Hey silentwisper what do I do if I have a swamp with multiple witch huts relatively close to each other how would I go about putting the afk spot if you need the seed and the cords for the area I can give them to ya
They need to be in the 44blocks radius and u can link them in the middle but dont link it if its not in the 44block radius otherwise is not working, and as same he said 42/44 block above
I'm making a mini advent calendar this year! Subscribe so you don't miss all the extra tutorials :D
So excited for the advent calender! Keep up the amazing videos! ❤
Loved the advent calander a few years back... can't wait 😁
Does anyone remember the crystals that are made with amethyst?😆 😆.
Where to get world download i want to check rates
My Nearest Witch Hut Is 10K Blocks Away From Spawn 😢 I Guess I Need To Rely On Raids Now But It Works Guys I Tried In Creative
As soon as I had seen the change happening with Witches dropping more redstone, I knew it was time to build a farm. Thanks as always!
Yeah same. Didn't feel like fixing my raid farm (raids have witches) due to the changes to that mechanic, so I'm hopping on this bandwagon
Same
For people struggling, drop the afk spot. 42 blocks with sim 4 (which is what this farm is supposed to be made for) doesnt seem to spawn any witches. I dropped the spot by 4 blocks and it started working. Dropping it by 1 didnt work. Not sure if the update also changed spawning ranges, but 42 seems to be incorrect.
ty so much bro
thank you bro, had the same issue and as i started playing around with the height, it started working
@@Foefiido you play on console?
@@Spaghetti0426 yes
@@Foefii understandable, I play on windows 10 but I use my ps5 to afk farms and it was working on my pc but was not getting drops on ps5 and I figured out it was because of this issue and it fixed it 👍
This video is seriously giving me nostalgia idk why..
It is reminding me of watching ur videos during my online classes in lockdown during winter❤
Works like a charm . I did use another piston on the cauldron side to kill them faster so you get hardly any potions . Yes glass bottles but not tons of potions . Alway check spawning rate of hut some spawn one and slow. Find one that alway spawns 4 or more is best tested and tested this on xbox. Found one that always spawned 7 each time
Just built this in 1.21. I can't believe I didn't build this earlier! No more mining for redstone! I added an item sorter to collect the redstone and glowstone then I added a compactor to condense the redstone and dumped the rest, as I don't need it. Thanks Silent !
Worked straight away before id even built access to the afk platform.
Well worth the effort 👌
This is working super well (once I dropped my AFK platform by a block, because I can't number good). Thanks for another fantastic guide!
To those whos farms not spawning witch's..... i had the same problem and through troubleshooting i found that i had my sculk catalyst net to the spawn spot. I removed it and put a solid block in its place than put it down and it solved my issues. Working great now. Thanks again Silent!
Does it need the catalyst?
@@lgchoman if you know how to remove xp another way then the catalyst no you dont have to
so how we do that?@@Svxn.164
@@dylanm1199 You can make a water stream to let the xp stream into the lava so the xp burns
What happen if we collect the xp
Thanks, I just built your previous model, but this one solves some issues and is easier to build!
Just built this today because of the new minor update that makes redstone drops from witches a 100% drop in large quantities, and was blown away when I checked the chest 15 minutes later and already got a stack of redstone blocks (or 9 stacks of redstone dust, but even then, I had a stack and a bit left over) Definitely would recommend this farm ESPECIALLY with 1.21.20 now out, and also considering the fact that once I got all the materials around and found the witch hut, this only took me 10 minutes to build!!!
My PS4 finally updated to 1.21.20 and I'm getting an insane amount of Redstone now.
I was getting too many potions and added another trident to kill them faster.
Thanks again for the great Bedrock content!
2:11 they actually will posibly only improve Phantoms path finding towards players, so maiby, only changing the afk platform a bit
I didn’t think you could make this farm any more simple this is going straight into my redstone playlist
Did you make this farm in 1.21?
I was gonna ask the same thing. Does this still work?@@facundomoralesdiorio3802
Really didn't know witch farms were that simple. I know what I'm building next
yeah they're super easy on bedrock 😂
I glossed over the part about filling in under the witch farm, but after seeing that in another video and building this again, I took the time and resources to fill in a lot of stuff under the hut. It improved my rates a lot. I believe the area that needs to be filled in is just the chunk where the witch hut is.
This works even better than I expected. Almost a full double chest of redstone dust in about an hour. It also works fine without the skulk catalyst.
For some reason witches are not spawning when I'm checking the spawn spot I've made sure to have the right y cord and everything
Same problem
@@lachlanscott259 i don't know if it fixed for you , but cover all the light source (Block all the windows) will help
Witches are hostile mobs, which only spawn when there's no light surrounding them
Works amazing, thank you
Thanks silent! Ive been looking for a good sugar, spider eye and empty bottle farm since forever.
Will build this as soon as i have tridents with impaling V.
I made a witch farm without tridents. I'm using a sticky piston holding a solid block that suffocates witches.
Works great as a starter 👍🏻
This farm is crazy. I used to spend hours trading for red stone.
This farm just gave me 8 stacks in 10 minutes.
Hey silent, love the farm, but do you think you could make updated farms like you did in the past, like example an obsidian, sand or wither rose farm?
Yo build the portal like for a gold/pigman farm, but instead of building the water slide that feeds them into a trident killer; instead just building the portal part of it and build a giant fence/boxed in area below the portal. Let it run for like 60 mins and you'll have like 100s of pigmen, spawn wither in the middle and his spawn explosion will execute all pigman instantly giving you tons of roses. Very simple.
Optional
Put water in fenced in area if pigman are taking too much fall damage.
(Wither cannot be spawned if the soul sand is wet).
Alternatively you could breed tons of bees with flowers and spawn wither, they get agro at him I believe so they will eventually all eleminate themselves if the spawn explosion doesn't get them all
If your stopped working since 1.21 try breaking the bottom scaffolding and replacing it back, mine broke after the update and this fixed it 👍🏻
thanks so much! not even 10 minutes has passed, and i already got a stack of redstone! thanks so much for this
update: not even 10mins has passed, and i already got 8 stacks of redstone, its OP gonna modify the storge later.
I am planning to make one and here it is,thanks man
Great farm, thanks for the build. I added a simple red stone sorter to mine so I can AFK for hours without filling up the box
Nice, although I think I prefer your previous witch farm for getting them to drop fire resistance potions. This still ought to be handy for many though
One piglin bartering farm and you'll have more fire res potions than you'll know what to do with
@@ajayh21 sure, but then before you build the gold farm and piglin bartering farm then a witch farm has utility
Works great. First try. Thanks a ton!
this farm is crazy fast, to the point where i realized i may need to add a crafter system for the red stone to make them into blocks hahaha thank you for the guide! i think like 20 minutes will fill up a chest but that’s also bc potion bottles don’t stack
But You can’t craft redstoneblocks into redstone
@@Anthony_Gogglinstf yes you can
It’s still working 1.21 bedrock. I made it exactly as he did except without the tinted glass, my simulation distance is max at 10 chunks and it still works just like in the video… he’s right about needing to pick up the trident when you are done it will fall through the glass blocks and the farm will break kinda like how you armor stands can be moved by pistons and be inside glads blocks. Also don’t kill the frogs!!!!!
can confirm that if a trident falls below the farm won’t work
Seems to be working, thanks for the tutorial! Would’ve sucked to get red stone without this as my base is primarily made of cobblestone and red stone blocks.
Did you make it in 1.21?
@@facundomoralesdiorio3802 Yep!
@@epiccm4023 Thank you!
does this work in 1.21 now that they dont spawn on the corners of blocks?
Thanks tons for frequent and relevant content ⚔️
If you remove the existing structure and put the minimum blocks needed to block light you'll be able to clearly see the witches death animation popping out the side
Works great. Tried Prowl's first (double trident killer) but the spawn was painfully slow. Don't know why. Switched over to this one (same hut), pulling in gobs of stuff. I use Tinted glass for all glass parts, no issues. Guessing the regular glass parts were a matter of taste/conservation of resources point. Off to planning the next mayhem --- some more farms at the AFK spot (8 chunk, +123 Y) here to maximize productivity while AFK...
Pie is the best.
such a good build, thank you!
Java: find a witch hut surrounded by water. Bedrock: no water, definitely no water...😅
Silent you are so close to 600k. You will get there soon man, love the new content. ❤❤
so close! :D
So excited for 600k!
If o do without skull catalyst would it create problem @@silentwisperer
Sick of seeing comments complaining about not having a lot of gunpowder from this. My buddy and I been doing sorting systems and it doesn’t really matter what farm you use or what rate it gives. If you can OBTAIN any said item from a farm. You have the ability to ONLY have that put into chests. Stop shitting on farms that don’t give you an ultra perfect gunpowder only drop rate. That doesn’t exist. Just utilize the fact that you CAN get gunpowder and overnight afk and you’ll have all the gunpowder you need with this.
10/10 quick and easy build, witches spawned as soon as I left the area to AFK .. lots of loot .. (next time, I’ll come to you first for farm builds - had no success with the other tutes here)
integrate lava into the farm and you also get fire resistance spells, which is then good for the nether
How to integrate ??
Great build , however I had some issues with the items floating on the water and above the scaffolding so wasn’t getting collected , managed to use a kinda drain by knocking a couple of blocks and letting water flow out to a bubble column 😃
how did you solve the problem in partiular bc i have it too
Can we substitute the scaffolding with something else? I don't have a jungle near me.
You need a sculk catalyst for this, how could you possibly get that but not bamboo?
@@GuckFoogle507 Sculk catalyst is optional. And, yeah, I somehow couldn't find bamboo but found deep dark. There is like no jungle 3,000 blocks in any direction.
But now that doesn't matter. I lost that world and am playing in a new one, where I literally spawn in a jungle.
Question, with Witch Huts, is the highest spawn spot +1 Y Level? Like 1 block up from the middle block? Used to be when I was experimenting. Not that it helps anything, but ya get to go up 1 more block. LOL Also, I wonder about using a block of mud as a spawn spot for the witches. A hopper can pull through mud and I've been trying to incorporate it more in my builds. Otherwise, love that you're putting water in there to get water breathing potions, and setup a simple trident killer at the Y Level of the structure spawn spot. Now I gotta recalculate my raid farm to get 2 blocks higher for the afk spot. I was only dropping them down a block instead of like 4-5 like what most people seem to like. I really like to run the numbers and see how far I can push it. Your knowledge of redstone and game mechanics is impressive. Loved the video. :)
it might be, ive always just used the floor layer.
Heads up. Had to replace the glass block with quartz blocks in order to have witches spawn.
8:02 With the new update, would you be able to get bad omen bottles with the extra tinted glass?
you cant get omi bottles from witches
@@silentwisperer No he meant at min 8:00 you said if we replace the roof block directly above the spawning block with tinted glass we will get pillager patrols in the farm so it might be possible to get omi bottles
I made this farm with my friend in bedrock edition, when the farm was complete a witch spawned but the items that dropped from the witch didn't go to the hopper it just stayed there and despawned, dont know what i did wrong
You may not have directed the hopper in the chest, remember to place it directly on the back of the chest.
Hopper leads to nothing. Replace hopper INTO the chest.
Just glitch a hopper minecart with a hopper under it into the block the witches die on
Did you kill frogs? He warned about killing frogs
Question. My farm stopped working after i added a sorting system below and gold farm above it near the afk platform
If it's the piglin nether portal farm they might be filling the mob cap and therefore not letting witches spawn? Should only be an issue while active though.
@@kotydragon thanks mon
Can you use a campfire or like a magma block instead of a trident killer?
And would you put that on the blocks surrounding the spawn spot?
No because witch’s would just drink fire resistance potions
Is there a way to use this farm to get fire resistance potions? @@500benz1
i build the exact same thing yes also to the north, and it doesnt work in my realm
Rates for redstone drops? This farm seems kinda slow, do you know of any faster farms for redstone?
Fr
The rate will increase when 1.21.20 drop. There will be a change where witches always drop 4-8 redstone
@@loris_099 isn't it already there? Or am I fooling myself?
@@loris_099 and when is it releasing?
This is more for an overnight AFK farm with a sorting system. If you’re trying to get quick stuff with this. Wrong farm.
For me (bedrock 1.21.44 Xbox) the glass pains in the corner of the witch hut actually blocked the spawning. I had to get rid of those and stand at y:101 (37 blocks above the spawning block) to get them to spawn. Otherwise works great!
would mending keep the trident from losing durability or no because the sculk catalyst that's there?
Tridents only loose durability if the player is actively using them. Trident killers update the position of them without reducing durability. No need for mending
works! Thanks
I've tried about 5 different creeper farms and none of them work so at least i can get some gunpowder with this, thanks!
how much does it make tho?
I discovered your channel some days ago searching for an item filter, I was looking for copper, and just found gold here
Update: Broo, it worked perfectly!! Thx for the video; also, is there an issue if I cover this farm with a deco-ish things?? Around it
Question, can i decorate it? Or build a house around the farm? Or will that effect the farm?
yeah you can do whatever, just dont let any light in there:)
Built this with a basic item collection system with item sorter at the ground then later changed it to item sorter in the sky where my afk platform is and as soon as i made the switch the rates dropped catastrophically to the point of uselessness. Do you have any way to fix this? I was thinking of going back to the old collection system i had, but would I prefer to be able to have a collection system at the afk platform. Do bubble columns drop rates? Im not sure what to do to fix this.
did you find a fix to this?
Sweet! My witch farm broke a while ago snd this has reminded me to fix it! The catalyst to soak up xp is smart
Yooooo, I just commented on your old video a few days ago asking you to upload a new one so we didn't have to follow the comments, and you did it 😅❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Just in time for my gunpowder farm. I want to build a gunpowder farm from witch hut because my ghast and creeper farm doesn't produce enough gunpowder. Thank you so much.
witch farms produce very little gunpowder compared to other farms usually was this better? my general mob farm produces about 2 1/2 double chests per night of afk
I had that same trident issue with the guardian farm but it still works amazing
What issue?
yeah the bug affects all trident killers sadly:/
i mention it near the end btw
how necessary is the skulk catalyst?
Was wondering same thing, couldn’t we just bubble elevator up the XP?
Nope not important because the bug which made xp push mobs was fixed
@@maxstronish ok cool, i really couldn't be bothered to go fight a warden😭
@@noahenglishby-allen5987lmfao you don’t need to fight one for a skull catalyst there easy to get
How big do you make the ground around the witch hut when it's in water?
With mobs spawning in the center of blocks now (instead of the nw corner), any issue with building this farm? I was going to try this next.
That change doesn't effect structures:)
@@silentwispererthen why did it affect the raid farm? Isn’t that a structure?
@@kiidkiefnot the raid itself
The bug with tridents you talked about at the end of the video, is it a known bug, are there any plans to fix it? I've built your guardian farm and farmed all tridents for every single killing chamber, and having to place and remove them each time is a hassle.
Great video btw.
no fixes on the way from what ive seen, very popular report though so hopefully
@@silentwisperer its been a couple months since i've experienced it for the first time, so yeah, hopefully soon we'll get a fix for it.
Does anyone know if I can make an iron farm and bamboo farm(flying machine version) near the afk platform with water streams from all three farms directed to a auto crafter array? Or would it mess up the spawns of the witches
Remember: DON'T KILL THE FROGS!
I KILLED THEM ANYWAY!!!!!
no
@@TelliriaYEAAAAAHHHH
Mmmmm frog legs
mhmm frog feet 🤤
im having issues getting the witches to spawn, this is my second attempt at building a redstone farm and this version is so straight forward im upset that i cant get it to work, i built my thing at the northwest corner and everything just like the video, i need to go back to the glass pane step and see why i cant get a witch to spawn.
did they change how witches spawn since changing their loot drop?
I wasn't getting any either then dropped my afk platform and started getting witches.
@jjiggly9571 this is what I ended up having to do, I guess I can't count lol
Between 40 and 25 blocks up should work, it can't be less than 25 because you can't have other mobs around in order for a witch to spawn
Is it possible to have quad witch farms on bedrock similar to Java?
No
@@Jamesbaiden Deep sadness.
thanks for all the amazing farms cant find better bedrock farms anywhere else!!
How many blocks would I need to afk up if I am on sim 8?
Sim 10 here and also curious about the answer to that question.
120 or so
Your creativity is very good. Love from India plms response ❤
Great video. Would using scaffolding to get to the AFK spot cause any problems? I have an elyta, but my flying skills are "embarrassing".
Edited for the kind person who noticed my spelling mistake.
you can use whatever you want to get up there:)
Are your flying skills even more embracing than your spelling skills
@@silentwisperer Thanks Silent 👍
@@QwertyS3 100% 👍
@@silentwisperer Is there any replacement for the middle scaffolding? I have not found a jungle yet.
How many witches do you get from this per hour vs a raid farm?
In my experience, my raid farm gave me almost no witches. This was much faster for redstone + way easier to build
@@PayMeToThrowThanks for the info!
Thanks a lot for all your tutorial. I'm french and i can understand all you said, you speak very clearly and it's really cool :)
Hope to see more and more tutorials from you ;)
Already did from you: Wich farm, gold farm, bamboo farm, and soon guardian farm :)
Highly recommend his new gold and guardian farms both work flawlessly and the XP rates are amazing
Is the skulk catalyst required? Do the witches drop any xp with or without the skulk catalyst?
Not required. Like he said it just keeps the xp orbs from over accumulating which can cause lag and issues eventually. I built it without it and it ran fine. You can even occasionally go down and open the top and get a flood of xp. Likely without doing so eventually it may cause issues.
I dont relly like tridint killers is it possible to replace it with a camp fire or dose the player haft to kill the witchs to drop loot
you need to build it as shown
Cool thx
very ease thank you
Is it alright if I build this farm without the skulk sensor in it? Or will it not function properly without it?
The trident got stuck. Any fixes? Do you think I can make a full size trident killer under it?
Will this still work in 1.21 with the change to mobs spawning in center of blocks?
Curious about this as well!
I’ve been using this for last 2 weeks no problems however today after the update it wasn’t working, been trynna tweak it see if I can get it to work again, will keep posted if I find anything
If your having any problems with it not working after the update, try simply breaking the scaffolding and replacing it back this fixed it for me
My friend does this still work with the change of mob spawns being in the centre rather than NW, bc I know a few farms that were messed because of that change. Additionally, skulk veins have been spreading. I don’t think this affects the farms function, but I wouldn’t mind a second opinion. Also, do Pillager parties still spawn and if so, how often? Thank you
No, witches have a set spawn and don’t spawn on the nw corner.
@@Mr.Monkey16579 ty brother
My Witch hut is on a deep river. Do I need to fill all water with blocks or just the water surface?
just the surface
Hello wisperer, does this still work? I wanna build it
I just built it, it works
@@diveaker412 yea I built it and it’s good idk what item sorter I should use tho
@@Uauauaz1 yeah I just hooked it up to a full sorting system using the softer designs silent had uploaded a few months ago with the target blocks it works well
Hey silent! I built your Moss Bonemeal farm from 2 years ago;everything works fine without any single change. But the comparators in the minecart unloaders breaks and stops the minecarts evertime the farm is used once but the comparators needs to be replaced again to fix the problem. Its annoying to replace the comparators after single use. You have any solution for that?
seems like you might have built it wrong
Was literally just deciding what farm to build next... guess its this one 😊❤
The momment chunkbase was mentioned i know this was a good one
Someone help! The witches are spawning but ever so often they stop dying and I have to replace the Trident
Idk bro
Are you on a realm server??? Sounds like you’re trolling around. But if you’re telling the truth I suggest re ticking the clock for the pistons. And if that doesn’t work rebuild it. Removing any water of any kind and if need be. Enchant the trident with mending to ensure yourself.
@@Lunarkendama thanks bro
@@jacobhaymond1 Np!
@@jacobhaymond1 Working?
Is the sculk block optional?
kinda. the exp in there can push around the witches though
Thank you I’ve been waiting for a good bedrock which farm
How high up should my afk platform be?
25 blocks or more
Can I use anything instead of the scaffolding?
no it needs to be scaffolding
Is the one from last year still working? Fire res potions are so handy.
yep, just need to lower the hopper minecart a block and put it on a rail:)
i toggle my world between peaceful and hard mode often to run my farms, i had trouble getting one to spawn so i cleared the whole room out and i still cant get a witch to spawn in the hut, can anybody help me? is it possibly because im arriving at the witch hut in peaceful mode and despawning them so they will never spawn there now when i change it to hard mode? I had that problem pulling up on the ocean monuments and despawning the elder guardians forever but I dont know about witches in the witch huts. I have already messed up the three closest witch huts to my base in my world and i only have one more reasonable attempt. please help
Hey silentwisper what do I do if I have a swamp with multiple witch huts relatively close to each other how would I go about putting the afk spot if you need the seed and the cords for the area I can give them to ya
They need to be in the 44blocks radius and u can link them in the middle but dont link it if its not in the 44block radius otherwise is not working, and as same he said 42/44 block above
I run sim distance 10, does anyone have a recommendation for the AFK spot height? I’ve searched for the math but can’t find a consistent answer.
120~ above the farm:)
Thank you. I did some playing around and found out about 90 above the spawn point works best for me.
Hey silent I keep forgetting to ask on streams but how do you have the optifine zoom in bedrock?
its an fov changer program:)
could you make a tutorial for a reliable 8gt moss and bonemeal farm?