Hilary Putnam and Alvin Plantinga - The God Problem

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 20

  • @BugMateo
    @BugMateo 23 години тому

    Excellent stuff good sir...

  • @Phorquieu
    @Phorquieu 2 роки тому +19

    Thanks for this posting... You've preserved something here that otherwise would probably be lost forever. So many things to think about.

  • @maxheadrom3088
    @maxheadrom3088 Рік тому +8

    Dude, where do you find these things? The opening is awesome - the music and the text are fantastic. Do this radios still exist?Broadcast radio isinteresting - fiddling with the dial a taxi driver, a construction worker or someone selling hot-dogs will eventually find it. Here on youtube the chance of someone not interested in Philosophy finding your videos is, unfortunately, lower than zero.
    ... and, yes: Pascal invented Game Theory centuries before John von Neuman was even born!

    • @maxheadrom3088
      @maxheadrom3088 Рік тому

      I don't have my glasses so any typos you can blame my fingers.

  • @вернат
    @вернат Рік тому +5

    7:00

    • @meshzzizk
      @meshzzizk 8 місяців тому

      hahahaha 😂

  • @fredadler3955
    @fredadler3955 2 роки тому +5

    😀

  • @bobgenesis2387
    @bobgenesis2387 2 роки тому +10

    Music is too loud

  • @acaciogarciaromero9509
    @acaciogarciaromero9509 7 місяців тому +1

    Sorry would be better for me this video legended, I'm a little hard hearing and english student at 74 years old. Thanks.

  • @lonelycubicle
    @lonelycubicle Рік тому +2

    Seems a little odd to discuss the “God Problem” with two believers of God, but was nice to avoid stale arguments

  • @felipevalencapereira1194
    @felipevalencapereira1194 11 місяців тому

    Who is the interviewer?

  • @apolodoro11
    @apolodoro11 5 місяців тому

    What a stupid noise called music.

  • @markacohen1
    @markacohen1 Рік тому +2

    God is a person? So let him appear in Church like anyone else. Until he does, or do something equally perceptible to all, then he is not a proven thing. He is indeed no more a person than Zeus Hamlet or Spiderman. No accident that both of these philosophers ended up in a religion rooted in their family traditions. That is the way it is has worked mostly through human history.
    Let’s see how say a Christian views the world and those who do not believe: I’m going to hell forever for not believing in precisely the way they believe.
    Let’s see how most atheists view the world: there is no ultimate punishment for those who don’t believe the way I do, in fact there is NO punishment. Atheists don’t view the universe as a universal torture machine supposedly created by an all powerful creature who demands belief or else. If god loves me so much then he wouldn’t make such an unrealizable demands. More proof that it is human beings who make such demands and not some nonexistent force.

    • @22julip
      @22julip Рік тому +1

      At the time of Jesus to today 98% of the earths people were alive that doesn’t mean they all heard the word . We have the Bible we have Jesus we have over 2,000 years of the Christian church . Today a lot of Muslims are joining the Christian faith , and there are more , so you can’t say there’s no evidence.there’s no mathematical proof , nor can atheists prove there’s no God . I think there is plenty of evidence if you look with an open heart and open mind

    • @TravelingPhilosopher
      @TravelingPhilosopher Рік тому

      That is a question of epistemology, and there are epistemic subtlties and clear ontological and epistemic differences in those two comparisons.

    • @22julip
      @22julip Рік тому +2

      I understand that everyone wants to be the smartest person in the room, but in reality, the question of wether or not God exists can’t be answered with mathematical certainty. But one thing that gets lost is the debate is Jesus, if he was real like most people think he was , then that tips the scale pretty far in the direction that God does actually exist..then the question is due you believe or don’t believe that the apostles were with Jesus and that they were honest in their belief he was the son of God . They saw the miracles that why they believed. and nothing has to this day been found to debunk the life and ministry of Jesus. Until that day if it comes I will my faith in Jesus . ✝️☮️