Rape is one of the most common and one of the least spoken aftermaths of war. One of the many dark sides of war and one of the many reasons we should be against war.
Correct? Yet no mention of how these men are made ,condition to fight. And if they choose not to,what happens to them. Worst upon becoming a soilser than will be judge harshly for what they are made to do. Go awol, abandon station, or become trader, you are hunted,hated, and despise.
@@navyseal1689 rape is not just any war crime. It is worse than death. To "enjoy her body" is a ridiculous formulation only a man who's never been raped could come up with 🤬
@@AntjeRoestenburg if it was worse than death they would charge at the soldiers and try kill or get killed, in the end they bragged how many times they have had sex so I guess it wasnt that hard of choice for them.
Mistreatment of civilian populations in Europe during war goes back centuries and didn't start in WWII. This woman was exceptionally brave. She was right to seek out the higher ranking Soviet officers. They were better educated and could offer some protection.
Citezens and soldiers are two different things., any man who hurts a women or child, or anyone weaker then them unprovoked, has a compromised moral compass.
@tempest411 I don't know any of either personally, but I've met nice men and women from all over the world. Evil begets evil, people reciprocate in kind. So we need to treat others like we want treated.
Hitler didn't have a problem in turning the Hitler Youth into German soldiers ... in those circumstances, how long does it take to turn a civilian into a soldier 🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️ 5 maybe 10 minutes
@Brian Hodgson so your saying what?, all German people are guilty by proxy, or it's pointless to instill Cristal thinking,an healty conscience, and moral fortitude into our own children,because evil is just a brief indoctrination away? Elaborate.
@Brian Hodgson or are you drawing parallels between modern indoctrination on the radical education front, that teaches " Biological facts", are just a social construct?..
"Nobody wins in war, Vi." - Vander, Arcane ...to anyone who seriously thinks that any human being deserves that kind of 'treatment'. You are sick in the head. No matter what country on earth started a war or had a part in any kind of war, it's always the innocent or naive people who suffer the horrible consequences. And pain and unfair circumstances can never be repaid or avenged by causing more pain. It will only become an endless cycle of violence and suffering. We are meant to HELP each other, not DESTROY each other. Some of the replies in the comment section are truly disgusting.
It saddens me to live in a world full of retards..... People don't understand life.... I learned different martial arts throughout the years, I'm still the type whether I win or lose a physical fight, I still end up losing, my body starts to shake I get paranoid, my peace of mind is scattered.... We have enough land and food to provide 20 times the population, but we instead act greedy with such products... We have enough natural resources to look for a new home, if not built more in space
I couldn't agree more. Those who advocate for the rape and genocide of innocent civilians are monsters, whether they be Nazis who were responsible for the murder of six million Jews or Russian soldiers who were responsible for the rape and murder of numerous innocent German citizens. Justice was served at the Nuremberg trials, but the atrocities committed against German citizens who had no personal involvement in the holocaust were nothing but barbarism.
My grandmother and her three daughters lived through this, while waiting for my three times wounded grandfather to come back from the Russian front. They all lived happily, got married, had kids ----and were married till the end of their days. If they suffered PTSD----we were never aware of it. My mother and her two sisters were a different breed. I miss them all terribly.
You never asked what grandfather did in soviet Union they did far worse them what Russians did to germans. Germans considered them sub human and treated them in same manner.
I find it hard to believe that the Germans at the party at the start of the film didn't know how close the Russians were? They bombarded Berlin for days before their soldiers appeared.
@@comradeleppi2000 but the people at the bottom of the political hierarchy, aka the soldiers and anyone who is involved in the military, suffer the most because of injuries and mental trauma. And those people mainly consist of men
A friend of mine - her mother was 16 at this time. She was a depressed alcoholic. I think something happened to her that she never revealed to her daughter
Lots of comments saying that they lack sympathy for the German population. It is true that the Germans committed despicable atrocities on populations they occupied, especially on Slavic nations. Its also true that the Soviets committed terrible atrocities as reprisals. Listening to first hand accounts of Soviet soldiers really shows how brutal and disgusting these reprisals could be. I think it's wrong to simply dismiss these and state how you have a lack of sympathy, although I understand completely the anger towards the Germans in this time.
War was the same 1000 years ago as it is now I've served and can tell you the safest place to be (although obviously still dangerous) is in the army at least your an armed combatant doing the job your paid and trained for you'll have some form of rations/medics/communications/chain of command etc I cried for the poor civilians there just fucked sometimes literally
Here is a link to a personal account of a soviet soldier on atrocities committed by the Red Army. ua-cam.com/video/5Ywe5pFT928/v-deo.html&si=EnSIkaIECMiOmarE
Understandable but when atrocities are committed by the "higher evolved races" against the inferior races it's common for those lowly races to want to destroy anything related to the "superior race" aggressors.
@@dzejzi1757 Russian liberation. Are you for real. Stalin invaded Poland with Russia and exterminated thousands of polish officers. You have no idea what you are talking about. Russians started WW2 also..Russians and Germans both started ww2
@@maximusvonce1381 dude exactly. She was crying becouse it was no liberation but further occupation, death, rapes and looting. Much worse than Germans did. I thought it was abvious
@@steffenrosmus9177 Sure, women are physically weaker so they were not able to do as much damage. If they were as strong as men, you would have nothing to say except, "done by human beings".
Folks dont understand it was them soldiers (no matter who's side there on) that did the evil deeds not the citizens bruh how dare them say that such people deserve it.lots of horrible folks here.
Suggesting 'they deserve it' has been used since the beginning of time to excuse all kinds of horrible acts by human beings everywhere, down to the petty criminal on the street.
You mean like the NAZI'S? Sorry,pal,there is no way in hell I can feel any remorse for the enablers of living,breathing,bloodthirsty,monsters.If you can then that's your business.But don't judge me because of what those Aryan low life's did.
@@shashankdixit8949 you are in error.What the NAZI'S did was not for joy it was revenge about how Germany was treated after World War one.That's how Hitler rolled into power.The Russians were simply pissed that the NAZI'S thought that they could steamroll them as they had small countries in Europe.That,my friend,is the difference
@@theonlyonestanding8079Do you really want to know what war does to the people, the Russian soldier, the video is on YT but can't figure out the name of it,was part of the Red Army and was forced to witness women being tortured i.e. hot coals in the private type of sadistic the Russians did and where encouraged to do. It was soo bad that every time the women see a soldier they immediately start undressing. There are a lot of Nazi and other sympathiser that think that war was nothing like that and Hitler was good person protecting his country. Ukraine is going through the same thing but it's more like trafficking.
My Oma and my mother just a child at time when the War ended. They were lucky since they lived just outside of Hannover in the British sector and didn't experience these atrocities. My Opa came back alive and became successful after the war.
Europeans will pay with their existence for being quiet when the "small hat" tribe did take over their countries But Reparation ..lmao ... learn your own history You come from hell ...Europeans did give you more and did treat you better than your own ever did
My Oma was lucky enough to sail out of Ost Prussia but had to leave her father there. No doubt to Die. My Opa escaped the east to surrender to the Yanks. He was sent east for some not so clever comments about the Boss.
The horrible story aside… this is a perfect example of how out of touch journalists are. For her to be at a party, telling her friends she thinks they’ll surely win. Then, happily sell themselves, bragging about it because they have protectors. Really? Russia was at the door, and a journalist didn’t know anything?
My grandmother was German, the vast majority of the population has been so brainwashed for years into believing until the last minute they would win and were on the right side. Journalist also didn't had the same ways as today to verify informations....but most of all, a journalist under a dictatorship is only still alive because it's a journalist that believe the government.
That's what always will happen during war...for example the invasion of Nanjing by the Japanese where all the young girls and women being used as comfort women for the Japanese soldiers.
there's been much said. written and filmed about that. This film covers an aspect of that war not often mentioned. I'm pretty interested to see stories of both the German and Japanese people after that war, good and bad.
@twlowe19 where? which film or book? Nobody talked about what soviet women went through (rape, summary execution, separation from their loved ones and slave labour for german aryan race) much like they glossed over what German women.
@@karrole88 That's a good point! In a more general sense however there is an immense sea of liturature and media decrying the absolute evil of Germany while a nation that was guilty of murdering even more people was never pilloried in the same way, at least in my country. Growing up I didn't hear word one about Stalin and Mao and had the evils of Hitler paraded nonstop. Having said that, Id very much watch or read some personal accounts of soviet women during that time!
Sins of some are not the sin of all. Never let anyone be an exception for humanity, this is a disgrace that people dont realize the true story here is what war do to innocent civilians and victims experience REGARDLESS of where they come from. WAR WILL NEVER BE A GLORIOUS BATTLE NOR A BLESSED ONE. SHAME to those who victimize others.
Small technical detail: the women absolutely knew Germany was slowly being strangled by early 1945. Round the clock bombing of Berlin, food and fuel shortages, rounding up of young boys and old men to go and fight.
I seriously had a dream exactly like this movie. And it was when I was like 12, I never knew of any of this stuff back then. But I remember being a young German woman during World War I. I had just gotten married and my husband went to war. I was r@ped but in order to survive I had to try to pick my best protector. I remember feeling so ashamed, hoping my husband never came back to me so I wouldn’t have to tell him what happened. I’ll never forget that dream. It’s like I lived another life, and I’m so glad I woke up from it.
Everyone suffers in war. Especially the citizens that await the victors punishment. War is also very hard on the soldiers. The salt of the earth does the dirty work for the industrial and corporate class
yeah, if you are depraved stupid fuck, you can think like that. If you are a human being with a brain and a moral compass, you cannot. Even as a soldier, facing an enemy. What a bunch of horseshit. Also, nowadays we have something like Rules of Engagement. War is always dirty, but with the above you'd fit right in with the Wehrmacht or Red Army, not with most modern armies today.
"Revenge" is an excuse used by Russian soldiers. Bullshit, they raped even the women of cities occupied by Germany. They do not have distinction. It's not for revenge, it's for their raging hormones and being drunk of power play by using women as an outlet. And before anyone could say about Americans, no, the US army leadership tried as much as they could to prevent their soldiers from raping women in liberated cities. The most common tactic is showing care to local women, giving them food and warmth, with physical intimacy within the sequence, before choosing whether to leave them or stay. But with the Russians, it is straight up forced, in short, rape.
This is what happens in war and invasions...... That's why in ancient India women of fallen soldiers and kings did sati i.e. Jump into fire alive to protect one's own dignity
now you understand why a lot of German soldiers fight until the end. I also would prefer to be killed in a fight while i try to defend my people than to survive and regrets to have done nothing
gee,from the comments this is a HOT topic .heaps of raw passionate intense emotion being expressed. i've wondered over the years about this film wondering how the german women dealt with this abuse . did they process it or just bury it and put a lock on it with a sign "never to be thought or felt about again " did that work or have you got a ticking timebomb that's been passed on that is causing internal trauma,which is just waiting for an opportunity to act out . and manifest .or is it showing up in the German society in other ways .from what i've heard when the book came out it caused one hell of a hullabaloo.which to me indicates a lot of pain etc was being touched
I'm not sure the author intended the audience to feel sad for the woman. Perhaps we are meant to feel happy or grateful for what she endured, or even envious of her situation and prospects after the war's end. I am uncertain whether this is a sad movie. I will have to re-watch the rape(s), hunger, violence, destruction of her home, rejection by her husband and loss of her only remaining potential for love and companionship in order to determine whether sadness is a reasonable response to this film.
The idea that one night all of a sudden the Russians were outside of Berlin is super unrealistic to me. They had known in Berlin for months ahead of time that the Russians were in circling and coming in closer and closer. Young boys and old men were mobilized into militias, and the civilian population was mobilized to dig trenches and defenses all around Berlin for weeks in anticipation of the Russians arrival. Hitler forbid much of the civilian population from leaving and instituted “fortress cities” they were supposed to fight until death. Many civilians fled, and were massacred by SS units, and by the oncoming Russians. Civilian population that chose to stay in many cases did die and knew that that was gonna happen. The idea that she might’ve been spared by this because she was in the upper class is also far-fetched because specifically at that time a lot of high class collaborators and German military, we’re all eating bullets in anticipation of the Russians arrival. Winning the war was long ago out of reach, they all knew it..
only German women? and what about Soviet women and children and pregnant women. I want to remind you that the USSR lost about 27 million of which 17 million were civilians. troops of the Third Reich, Romania, Hungary and SS divisions killed 17 million Soviet civilians. the Third Reich built death camps all over Europe (by the way, an interesting fact is that for the first time the British began to use death camps during the Anglo-Boer War).
@@user-ln6xv2qs4i millions of germans, japs, italians and other allies of axis died in the fake liberators death camps. I don't even get deeper about the criminal raids on civilians, the various massacres after the war with no trials and last but not least the millions of rapes on women but no one is interested or cares about it. Where is justice about that??
@@Emy-fv5nyPeople need to stop trying to bring the US or British troops into it. Russia and Nazi germany were by far the worst and Russia continues to do it. I think theu should be frightened because if they collapse some countries may want to take revenge.
I am from Poland and my grandmother used to tell me that there were the “bad Germans” and the “good Germans”. She called the “good Germans” those who were trying to help them during the war. There are good and bad people in every nation. Let’s hope that the good ones outweigh the bad ones, so we no longer have any wars. Peace!
@@kimhesketh2016 😅we will overlook the fact they were partying while their husbands were dying in millions on battlefield. It was all fun and they were so sure of victory, looking forward it, until their sons and husbands were obliterated on battlefield and they were left alone to bear the consequences.
@Magdalena Repar the point is not YOU but like there is 1 person like Hitler, Stalin or whatever lider who starts, but than someone is on the side of being attacked, so they have to defend themselves. The logic is man dont have a choice, they are obliged to die in the front...you want to equalize that? I didnt start a war, and you are not a victim of it.
@Magdalena Repar oh...ok, so you were a victim and I am responsible, because I am a man. Tell me whats best way to protect your family when some country invades your fatherland? Hide in the basement? Run? Where? Or maybe fight? How, with a kitchen knife? The best your grandfather could have done to protect his family was to fight off the enemy...unless we speak about country like deuchland, or japan that really started the WW2, yeah that would make no sense more than going after some wicked ideology.
Documentaries on the war said that once Germany was defeated, the soldiers who won forced the German populace to walk through war camps because they believed them complacent in all of the atrocities. At this point, they no longer considered many of these people human bc no human could hear soldiers sexually tormenting children in the street and turn a blind eye or hear the screams of torture and go about that day like so many Germans had. I suppose they weren't considered innocent because the horror was happening in front of them and they still helped the Germans committing such acts. I understand the anger of the winning side but I don't understand not just putting a bullet in the women's heads like they did the soldiers and being done with it.
no, they were not often, but compared to the Germans and the Russians, you could've mistaken them for such. Good way to get a general idea; East Germanys treatment under the Soviets vice the Japanese treatment under the US. Hmmm. You could make a good case that the conduct of both of those nations didn't warrant a lot of consideration after their defeat, but setting that aside, how they were all treated was sure illuminating.
Of course the USA and UK soldiers were not saints and did not get every situation correct. The thing is the reason for which they fought was correct and justified, if you cannot agree with that then you need to find the truth and understanding. The world is not simply Good vs Evil or colored black and white. It’s more complicated and more middle ground than just one sided, the fact is you benefitted from What the USA and UK soldiers fought for!
The japanese did very bad things to the chinese and westerners and also had their own internment camps for westerners. They did so many unspeakable things and especially to the chinese.
my dad was a sergeant in a front line battalion landed in normandy finally wounded at the bulge He participated in liberation of several camps and at one time a guard in a POW camp where he nearly murdered a german officer he saw physically attacked an enlisted man. He saw it all. He told me at some point ,likely in the late 90s as it took him that long to speak, that Eisenhower had given direct orders that NO AMERICAN OR ALLIED SOLIDER UNDER HIS COMMAND WAS TO ASSAULT ANY FEMALE. He said these orders were followed. Issues were with the russians who raped their way thru eastern europe and after it was over stalin ordered that every town have a statute of the "great liberator" i guess either him or a generic russian foot soldier. the locals called these monstrosities the "great rapists" and were gleefully engaged in tearing them down after the federation fell. I certainly cannot say no allied soldiers did such but i believe there were very few.
In any war, it is ALWAYS the women and the children in the countries where the fighting takes place who, other than the soldiers doing the fighting, suffer the most. I saw this even in Iraq and Afghanistan.
@@T15L94 There were a few Nazi spies in America. But for any Nazi spy there were 500 communist spies in America. The Reds were everywere. Even in the Manhattan Project. Only because of that the Commies could develop the A-Bomb.
@@GenThomasSPower .But now you know if Germany wasn't the one defeated then north america would be the next target and there is no chance for US against Germany which actually suffered 80% of its military casualties in eastern front. If you are thinking letting Germany first defeat USSR and then crushing it when it is weaken, then just look at allies and Soviets who thought the same but both suffered at the hand of NAZIs.
@@T15L94 The Soviets would have lost the war already in 1941 without the US and the aid from Lend-and-Lease. The Nazis and the Soviets would have fought on in war of attrition in the areas east of Moskow (Volga Areas) if the US didn’t send aid to either side until the D-Day. The Germans would have suffered casualities as well as the Russians. The Russians would have suffered more because of their inhuman strategies and human-wave-tactics. But the Front would eventually end in a stalemate until D-Day. The Soviets could have never brought whole Eastern Europe under Communist Tyranny and commit Mass-Rapes against Millons of Women and Girls from Romania, Poland, Bulgaria, Germany and Austria. The Reds also killed millions of Civilians in their advance (alone 2 Million Germans and 0.5 Million Poles) and they deported 1.5 million german Civilians to Siberia to work in Slave-Labour-Camps as ,living reparations‘ or ,reparations in kind‘. Without Lend-and-Lease the Soviets would have never got enought Trucks to wage an offensive war and most of Eastern Europe would have been liberated by the Western Allies. In the end it would have been much like a successfull ,Operation Unthinkable‘
After you said for the third time that the soldiers "enjoyed the German women's body" I stopped listening. They were RAPED. Using any more romantic or meaningless expression is demeaning to those women who had to endure this hell.
@@aaaaaceghhhiimmnnnrstu3273 It's called the spoils of war ...and a man invented that revolting idea ..? Men are good at making women suffer throughout history
Bad take on this. Humans need to evolve mentally already, not use the "there will always be wars because it's in human nature ' excuse. Enough of this already. Wars must be avoided in the future altogether. It's embarrassing for something like this to still be happening. Humans need to do better. Still starting wars like humans did thousands of years ago? Pathetic, really. Humanity should have been too civilized for that already.
@@fabiana7157 Yet your ilk calls for the destruction of Christians, Russia and anyone standing in the way of your feminazi liberal-leftist agenda. "Peace-loving" my ass.
@@fabiana7157 Unfortunately war is and has never been about being civilized, it is about getting control of resources. With an expanding world population don't expect war to go away any time soon until the population shrinks or technology increases where we utilize resources more effectively.
@@fabiana7157 unfortunately the way things are, war will never end. It is synonymous with human civilization and unfortunately has been a part of it since almost the very beginning. Look at middle East and Africa now, there's war going on over there right now, and we all know what's happening to Ukraine. There will be war at least some place on the planet. I hate it. But at the same time, it's true.
Many german women actually committed suicide after the first time they were raped. This movie is probably woke, just to weaken the best nation that ever lived, to the eyes of the world
It's ironic. Poland was screwed from all sides and I cannot begin to fathom what must have happened to polish women, yet here we are focusing on german women. Suffering happened on both sides but this is borderline historical revisionism.
I don't want to burst your righteous bubble, but the movie was about the women of Berlin. As stated in its title. Take it up with the filmmakers, love. Even better, go watch a Polish movie. P.S. your last sentence is the most excellent word salad I read today.
@@susivarga7303 Righteous hehe, you're funny. You sound like someone who'd use the term "polish concentration camps". Also, word salad? Time to learn some new words.
This is what happens as well when only the military or bad guys have firearms. Citizens with firearms are Citizens, citizens without firearms end up as slaves
Is this voice a robot? The name sounds like Gretta, not Greta, with a hard E. I know you just made the name up to give her one, but that like pronouncing Brad as Braid.
Rape is one of the most common and one of the least spoken aftermaths of war.
One of the many dark sides of war and one of the many reasons we should be against war.
This was Stockholm Syndrome
YES! It is something nobody talks about. COMMITED BY ALL SIDES!
The long bitter truth of losing a war - the men die, their women are raped and their children enslaved.
Why men fight...
Correct? Yet no mention of how these men are made ,condition to fight. And if they choose not to,what happens to them. Worst upon becoming a soilser than will be judge harshly for what they are made to do. Go awol, abandon station, or become trader, you are hunted,hated, and despise.
@@ASimpleHorse Some armies are better than others. It depends what values people have.
War doesn't decide who is right. War only decides who is left
In the case between the NAZIs and Soviets under Stalin that is surely the case. Although I think the Soviets were worse.
Yeah Yeah, heard that tired cliche a hundred times. Tell that to the Ukrainians.
Congratulations, you just explained the meaning of "I'm 14 and this is deep"
only heard this today for the first time...i was confused cos i was like right vs left?
What a 2 digit IQ comment 🤡
"Enjoy her body" is a ridiculous understatement of criminal, brutal abuse
Rape is always about violence and dominance. It is a weapon. Never pleasure.
Brutal but remember every country committed war crimes even the Americans in Iraq
@@navyseal1689 rape is not just any war crime. It is worse than death. To "enjoy her body" is a ridiculous formulation only a man who's never been raped could come up with 🤬
And how many Russian girls were killed and rape by naciz? About 20 milion Russians you killed?
@@AntjeRoestenburg if it was worse than death they would charge at the soldiers and try kill or get killed, in the end they bragged how many times they have had sex so I guess it wasnt that hard of choice for them.
Mistreatment of civilian populations in Europe during war goes back centuries and didn't start in WWII. This woman was exceptionally brave. She was right to seek out the higher ranking Soviet officers. They were better educated and could offer some protection.
I understand, but it seemed a bit classist to me the way the narrator said it. I'm not sure if it is like that in the film.
This exactly happened to my aunt in Berlin.
@@MrChopsticktech it's about survival. it gets to a point where your brain chooses the most obvious decisions for you.
Thank you for your comment , this type of thing is an old byproduct of war .
She would have only been in the Right if she had kept herself pure. Never let your enemy gain happiness.
Citezens and soldiers are two different things., any man who hurts a women or child, or anyone weaker then them unprovoked, has a compromised moral compass.
That would definitely describe the average Russian soldier, and most all NAZIs as well.
@tempest411 I don't know any of either personally, but I've met nice men and women from all over the world.
Evil begets evil, people reciprocate in kind.
So we need to treat others like we want treated.
Hitler didn't have a problem in turning the Hitler Youth into German soldiers ... in those circumstances, how long does it take to turn a civilian into a soldier 🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️ 5 maybe 10 minutes
@Brian Hodgson so your saying what?, all German people are guilty by proxy, or it's pointless to instill Cristal thinking,an healty conscience, and moral fortitude into our own children,because evil is just a brief indoctrination away? Elaborate.
@Brian Hodgson or are you drawing parallels between modern indoctrination on the radical education front, that teaches " Biological facts", are just a social construct?..
"Nobody wins in war, Vi."
- Vander, Arcane
...to anyone who seriously thinks that any human being deserves that kind of 'treatment'. You are sick in the head. No matter what country on earth started a war or had a part in any kind of war, it's always the innocent or naive people who suffer the horrible consequences.
And pain and unfair circumstances can never be repaid or avenged by causing more pain. It will only become an endless cycle of violence and suffering.
We are meant to HELP each other, not DESTROY each other.
Some of the replies in the comment section are truly disgusting.
It saddens me to live in a world full of retards.....
People don't understand life....
I learned different martial arts throughout the years, I'm still the type whether I win or lose a physical fight, I still end up losing, my body starts to shake I get paranoid, my peace of mind is scattered....
We have enough land and food to provide 20 times the population, but we instead act greedy with such products...
We have enough natural resources to look for a new home, if not built more in space
haha
Finally a perspective with humanity and empathy 🙏🏼
I couldn't agree more. Those who advocate for the rape and genocide of innocent civilians are monsters, whether they be Nazis who were responsible for the murder of six million Jews or Russian soldiers who were responsible for the rape and murder of numerous innocent German citizens. Justice was served at the Nuremberg trials, but the atrocities committed against German citizens who had no personal involvement in the holocaust were nothing but barbarism.
Yah....we must wage war against war.
My grandmother and her three daughters lived through this, while waiting for my three times wounded grandfather to come back from the Russian front. They all lived happily, got married, had kids ----and were married till the end of their days. If they suffered PTSD----we were never aware of it. My mother and her two sisters were a different breed. I miss them all terribly.
You never asked what grandfather did in soviet Union they did far worse them what Russians did to germans. Germans considered them sub human and treated them in same manner.
Did they collaborate with Nazis and turn their Jewish neighbors in?
So your Grandpa fought for the Nazis...
RESPECT +
@@hishamalaker491 My grandfather fought for his country that was ruled by the Nazi party at that time.
So ---yes.
Is that what you wanted to hear?
@@hishamalaker491Nobody should go through this.
I find it hard to believe that the Germans at the party at the start of the film didn't know how close the Russians were? They bombarded Berlin for days before their soldiers appeared.
The party at the start of the film takes place just before the start of the war,before Germany attacked Soviet Union.
I stopped watching from that point on. who would even party at that late stage
@@rickmorgan1441 its a flashback !
Exactly. The film might or might not have merits but the commentary is Hollyweired idiotic with no real knowledge of history.
This is a BS account
Very sad. Women and children always suffer from war.
Man dont, ok
Men suffer way more
Very true but most men don't want acknowledge it
@@briangan3133 men start war..
@@comradeleppi2000 but the people at the bottom of the political hierarchy, aka the soldiers and anyone who is involved in the military, suffer the most because of injuries and mental trauma. And those people mainly consist of men
A friend of mine - her mother was 16 at this time. She was a depressed alcoholic. I think something happened to her that she never revealed to her daughter
you should not want to know, let her pain and shame die with her.
Maybe you are russian 😏 check your dna
She realized she was part of a horrible murdering psycopaths
Lots of comments saying that they lack sympathy for the German population. It is true that the Germans committed despicable atrocities on populations they occupied, especially on Slavic nations. Its also true that the Soviets committed terrible atrocities as reprisals. Listening to first hand accounts of Soviet soldiers really shows how brutal and disgusting these reprisals could be. I think it's wrong to simply dismiss these and state how you have a lack of sympathy, although I understand completely the anger towards the Germans in this time.
Especially on the Slavic nations?
War was the same 1000 years ago as it is now I've served and can tell you the safest place to be (although obviously still dangerous) is in the army at least your an armed combatant doing the job your paid and trained for you'll have some form of rations/medics/communications/chain of command etc I cried for the poor civilians there just fucked sometimes literally
These soldiers are criminals and scums before been recruited during the war time, they are mindless war machine, most red army died in Stalingrad
Here is a link to a personal account of a soviet soldier on atrocities committed by the Red Army.
ua-cam.com/video/5Ywe5pFT928/v-deo.html&si=EnSIkaIECMiOmarE
Understandable but when atrocities are committed by the "higher evolved races" against the inferior races it's common for those lowly races to want to destroy anything related to the "superior race" aggressors.
This is really sad.. war brings out the monsters & animals in us. 💔
During WW2, my friend's city was first occupied by the Germans, then "liberated' by the Russians. She said they were treated worse by the Russians.
I'm from Poland. My grandma could tell you stories about german occupation no problem. Tears came with russian liberation. Every time
@@dzejzi1757 Russian liberation. Are you for real. Stalin invaded Poland with Russia and exterminated thousands of polish officers. You have no idea what you are talking about. Russians started WW2 also..Russians and Germans both started ww2
@@maximusvonce1381 dude exactly. She was crying becouse it was no liberation but further occupation, death, rapes and looting. Much worse than Germans did. I thought it was abvious
@@maximusvonce1381 Neither Russia nor Germany started ww2🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️
@@spartafilife4722 So who started WW2 then?
That what women sadly happened in any war since the beginning of mankind untilll today.
yep, and men too
@@cautarepvp2079 yep, and in mostly cases by men!!!!!!!
The powerless to be precise
Men, women or children or animals who are powerless are bound to be exploited.
@@steffenrosmus9177 Sure, women are physically weaker so they were not able to do as much damage. If they were as strong as men, you would have nothing to say except, "done by human beings".
Not true but most of wars.
Folks dont understand it was them soldiers (no matter who's side there on) that did the evil deeds not the citizens bruh how dare them say that such people deserve it.lots of horrible folks here.
Suggesting 'they deserve it' has been used since the beginning of time to excuse all kinds of horrible acts by human beings everywhere, down to the petty criminal on the street.
You mean like the NAZI'S? Sorry,pal,there is no way in hell I can feel any remorse for the enablers of living,breathing,bloodthirsty,monsters.If you can then that's your business.But don't judge me because of what those Aryan low life's did.
One did for joy other did for revenge that's the difference
@@shashankdixit8949 you are in error.What the NAZI'S did was not for joy it was revenge about how Germany was treated after World War one.That's how Hitler rolled into power.The Russians were simply pissed that the NAZI'S thought that they could steamroll them as they had small countries in Europe.That,my friend,is the difference
@@shashankdixit8949 you really are a reprehensible and extremely dumb individual.
Tks u for recapping this good movie.
This is a filtered down version to what really happened, a Russian soldier explained the horrors of the red army of the German women
Red army the coward army. Still today those people are barbarians
What did they do besides rape?
@@theonlyonestanding8079Do you really want to know what war does to the people, the Russian soldier, the video is on YT but can't figure out the name of it,was part of the Red Army and was forced to witness women being tortured i.e. hot coals in the private type of sadistic the Russians did and where encouraged to do.
It was soo bad that every time the women see a soldier they immediately start undressing. There are a lot of Nazi and other sympathiser that think that war was nothing like that and Hitler was good person protecting his country. Ukraine is going through the same thing but it's more like trafficking.
@@RiversBliss More confirmation that we are in hell.
And what about the version were naciz killed 20 milion Russians. You don't like that version?
My Oma and my mother just a child at time when the War ended. They were lucky since they lived just outside of Hannover in the British sector and didn't experience these atrocities. My Opa came back alive and became successful after the war.
Europeans will pay with their existence for being quiet when the "small hat" tribe did take over their countries
But Reparation ..lmao ... learn your own history
You come from hell ...Europeans did give you more and did treat you better than your own ever did
Good for them. God bless them bruder
My Oma was lucky enough to sail out of Ost Prussia but had to leave her father there. No doubt to Die.
My Opa escaped the east to surrender to the Yanks.
He was sent east for some not so clever comments about the Boss.
Where exactly I was in Bergen Hohne
Hi. Where were they near Hannover? My grandfather went close to Hannover April 45 on the way up to Wismar.
Coming back to this video and hearing your voice and words I recognize your joy about all these things.
This is what happens to women once home soldiers are all dead.
STALINGRAD really pissed the Russians off.
Not Stalingrad but murdering of millions of civilians by German nazis
Yep and I guess adding to that is the fact the Germans viewed Slavic people as inferior
How about we film a movie, say, about Alamo, in which Mexicans soldiers of Santa-Anna will be portrayed as heroes?
@@marluxia8832"Texas Rising " check it out.
The horrible story aside… this is a perfect example of how out of touch journalists are. For her to be at a party, telling her friends she thinks they’ll surely win. Then, happily sell themselves, bragging about it because they have protectors. Really? Russia was at the door, and a journalist didn’t know anything?
And lie to their husband......imagine that.
My grandmother was German, the vast majority of the population has been so brainwashed for years into believing until the last minute they would win and were on the right side. Journalist also didn't had the same ways as today to verify informations....but most of all, a journalist under a dictatorship is only still alive because it's a journalist that believe the government.
Propaganda most likely fooled them
Propaganda most likely fooled them
1940s were not the era of social media, internet and globalization. It was a world overrun by propaganda and lies.
Wow! Incredible film! Thanks!
IIRC Berliners call the Soviet War Memorial the "Tomb of the Unknown Rapist."
I highly recommend reading the book this is based on, which seems rather different from the movie.
As they say, the saddest thing to losing a war, is winning it. Everyone suffers.
Still, better to win
@@sandrahatherley2184no one wins.
That's what always will happen during war...for example the invasion of Nanjing by the Japanese where all the young girls and women being used as comfort women for the Japanese soldiers.
It's Not just the Soviets who did it It was The Americans The British and the French were big part of it
1:11 bro didn’t even move his gun….
I hate how you say 'enjoy' the woman. Rape is an evil act.
Old man start, young man fight it, everyone in the middle dies, and no one....Tells the truth. I can see how this story shows it...
Next tell us about what happened to soviet women from 1941-43.
there's been much said. written and filmed about that. This film covers an aspect of that war not often mentioned. I'm pretty interested to see stories of both the German and Japanese people after that war, good and bad.
@twlowe19 where? which film or book? Nobody talked about what soviet women went through (rape, summary execution, separation from their loved ones and slave labour for german aryan race) much like they glossed over what German women.
@@karrole88 Most of the western people have no idea what Generalplan Ost was. They're only taught about the Final Solution.
@@karrole88 That's a good point! In a more general sense however there is an immense sea of liturature and media decrying the absolute evil of Germany while a nation that was guilty of murdering even more people was never pilloried in the same way, at least in my country. Growing up I didn't hear word one about Stalin and Mao and had the evils of Hitler paraded nonstop. Having said that, Id very much watch or read some personal accounts of soviet women during that time!
Probably got raped by fellow soviet comrades
Her name was Marta Hillers, as was revealed in 2003
War is horrendous
Sins of some are not the sin of all. Never let anyone be an exception for humanity, this is a disgrace that people dont realize the true story here is what war do to innocent civilians and victims experience REGARDLESS of where they come from. WAR WILL NEVER BE A GLORIOUS BATTLE NOR A BLESSED ONE. SHAME to those who victimize others.
Small technical detail: the women absolutely knew Germany was slowly being strangled by early 1945. Round the clock bombing of Berlin, food and fuel shortages, rounding up of young boys and old men to go and fight.
Hitler had plans to.send women to the front if war had continued. They were forbidden to.surrender.
I seriously had a dream exactly like this movie. And it was when I was like 12, I never knew of any of this stuff back then. But I remember being a young German woman during World War I. I had just gotten married and my husband went to war. I was r@ped but in order to survive I had to try to pick my best protector. I remember feeling so ashamed, hoping my husband never came back to me so I wouldn’t have to tell him what happened. I’ll never forget that dream. It’s like I lived another life, and I’m so glad I woke up from it.
This is why we don't start wars.
Everyone suffers in war. Especially the citizens that await the victors punishment. War is also very hard on the soldiers. The salt of the earth does the dirty work for the industrial and corporate class
Eloquently verbalised.
The humiliation will never came to light even the name never revealed
Guilt has no place in a war. Not if you've taken up the sword. The only ones who can do wrong are the enemy.
yeah, if you are depraved stupid fuck, you can think like that. If you are a human being with a brain and a moral compass, you cannot. Even as a soldier, facing an enemy. What a bunch of horseshit. Also, nowadays we have something like Rules of Engagement. War is always dirty, but with the above you'd fit right in with the Wehrmacht or Red Army, not with most modern armies today.
How disgusting and horrible. Poor innocent ppl who suffer from the wars a small group of men start.
Wars were started to protect there own people from invasion it was not avoidable.
And women proudly support.
@@DNTMEE Yes. Some women support wars. I dont get it?
@@DNTMEE Stupidity knows no gender.
@@DNTMEE when things are going well…
Same things happen since the history of human regardless the any part of the world or believe....
This movie is a good one.
On the day the Soviets entered Berlin, this woman and her friends believed Germany would win the war? THAT is a special category of clueless!
"Revenge" is an excuse used by Russian soldiers. Bullshit, they raped even the women of cities occupied by Germany. They do not have distinction. It's not for revenge, it's for their raging hormones and being drunk of power play by using women as an outlet. And before anyone could say about Americans, no, the US army leadership tried as much as they could to prevent their soldiers from raping women in liberated cities. The most common tactic is showing care to local women, giving them food and warmth, with physical intimacy within the sequence, before choosing whether to leave them or stay. But with the Russians, it is straight up forced, in short, rape.
This is what happens in war and invasions...... That's why in ancient India women of fallen soldiers and kings did sati i.e. Jump into fire alive to protect one's own dignity
now you understand why a lot of German soldiers fight until the end. I also would prefer to be killed in a fight while i try to defend my people than to survive and regrets to have done nothing
Name of movie please?
Sad but true
Yup👍
One will reap what one will sow. Action-reaction.
gee,from the comments this is a HOT topic .heaps of raw passionate intense emotion being expressed. i've wondered over the years about this film wondering how the german women dealt with this abuse . did they process it or just bury it and put a lock on it with a sign "never to be thought or felt about again "
did that work or have you got a ticking timebomb that's been passed on that is causing internal trauma,which is just waiting for an opportunity to act out . and manifest .or is it showing up in the German society in other ways .from what i've heard when the book came out it caused one hell of a hullabaloo.which to me indicates a lot of pain etc was being touched
War is necessary to teach those who craves for crimes against humanity
Every action has a reaction
The narrator voice is perfect and he explained everything so perfectly... 😍👌
She looks like the actress in that series on Netflix about post WW2 Berlin/Germany.
Yes it’s the same actress
@@user-hb4zz4gh5e nina hoss
Ya, women,kids & animals.
In battles & war, they lose no matter who wins. To the Victor's go the spoils.
Started a long, long time ago.
ALL German apologists and historical revisionists should try reading SOLDATEN by German historian Sonke Neitzel and Harald Welzer
i feel sad for that woman
Never feel sad for a woman, they were lavishly waiting in their homes while their men were getting gunned down. This is what she deserves.
I'm not sure the author intended the audience to feel sad for the woman. Perhaps we are meant to feel happy or grateful for what she endured, or even envious of her situation and prospects after the war's end. I am uncertain whether this is a sad movie. I will have to re-watch the rape(s), hunger, violence, destruction of her home, rejection by her husband and loss of her only remaining potential for love and companionship in order to determine whether sadness is a reasonable response to this film.
@thesheeshmancongratulations from having no morality and fear from god ?
The idea that one night all of a sudden the Russians were outside of Berlin is super unrealistic to me. They had known in Berlin for months ahead of time that the Russians were in circling and coming in closer and closer. Young boys and old men were mobilized into militias, and the civilian population was mobilized to dig trenches and defenses all around Berlin for weeks in anticipation of the Russians arrival. Hitler forbid much of the civilian population from leaving and instituted “fortress cities” they were supposed to fight until death. Many civilians fled, and were massacred by SS units, and by the oncoming Russians. Civilian population that chose to stay in many cases did die and knew that that was gonna happen. The idea that she might’ve been spared by this because she was in the upper class is also far-fetched because specifically at that time a lot of high class collaborators and German military, we’re all eating bullets in anticipation of the Russians arrival. Winning the war was long ago out of reach, they all knew it..
The Nazi's were great at propaganda.
She was partying too much and didn't pay attention, I guess😂
What is the name of the movie?
name of movie?
Only in War will the victors rewrite history.
Praying for all these german women that loved their country
only German women? and what about Soviet women and children and pregnant women. I want to remind you that the USSR lost about 27 million of which 17 million were civilians. troops of the Third Reich, Romania, Hungary and SS divisions killed 17 million Soviet civilians. the Third Reich built death camps all over Europe (by the way, an interesting fact is that for the first time the British began to use death camps during the Anglo-Boer War).
@@user-ln6xv2qs4i millions of germans, japs, italians and other allies of axis died in the fake liberators death camps. I don't even get deeper about the criminal raids on civilians, the various massacres after the war with no trials and last but not least the millions of rapes on women but no one is interested or cares about it. Where is justice about that??
@@user-ln6xv2qs4i we all know the atrocities comitted by the nazis but very few speak of all the atrocities comitted by the other countries
Both the Germans and Russians were cruel back then in WW2
Everybody were cruel. American soldiers commited sexual crimes too. War unleash the lower human behaviours.
American drop atom bomb on civilians
They were not the only countries unfortunately all through conflict women have been the spoils of war
@@Emy-fv5ny Some, sure, but probably not even 1% of the ones committed by Germans or Soviets. Same with the British.
@@Emy-fv5nyPeople need to stop trying to bring the US or British troops into it. Russia and Nazi germany were by far the worst and Russia continues to do it. I think theu should be frightened because if they collapse some countries may want to take revenge.
explosions will indeed ruin your party
I don't know, with some of my friends, that's when the party really gets going! (Preferably outdoors and at a distance, though.)
War is horrible.
Poor german women
Theirs no winners in wars just a horrible sight of victims .
I am from Poland and my grandmother used to tell me that there were the “bad Germans” and the “good Germans”. She called the “good Germans” those who were trying to help them during the war.
There are good and bad people in every nation. Let’s hope that the good ones outweigh the bad ones, so we no longer have any wars. Peace!
Title 0f the M0vie pls
Rape is wrong
Dont start a unprovoked war, torture and kill other people indiscriminately and expect mercy when you lose.
Go back to school.
At least someone understands. God bless
@@wedenganey8091 saying gods name and justifying r@pe ?
Exactly. Perfectly put.
@@niksur7113Soviets were equally responsible
This s&it is going to repeat in another part of the world until the end of times. Wars make me sick.
Sad story.
My Mom told me that When russians pushed through in 1945 , they had watches going up both of their arms, this was in eastern poland
Same in Hungary. They were subject of secret jokes for decades because of it.
I heard that from my grandmother.
She thought they had never seem a watch before.
At least they didn't have gloves made out of human skin. Any jokes about that? No?
If Germany didn't start the War in the first place ... 🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️
didn't the ussr invade poland too? if i understand you this rape and crimes are justified cause the german government "started" the war"
Not to pick a nit but the women didn't start the war.
@@kimhesketh2016 😅we will overlook the fact they were partying while their husbands were dying in millions on battlefield. It was all fun and they were so sure of victory, looking forward it, until their sons and husbands were obliterated on battlefield and they were left alone to bear the consequences.
@Magdalena Repar the point is not YOU but like there is 1 person like Hitler, Stalin or whatever lider who starts, but than someone is on the side of being attacked, so they have to defend themselves. The logic is man dont have a choice, they are obliged to die in the front...you want to equalize that?
I didnt start a war, and you are not a victim of it.
@Magdalena Repar oh...ok, so you were a victim and I am responsible, because I am a man. Tell me whats best way to protect your family when some country invades your fatherland? Hide in the basement? Run? Where? Or maybe fight? How, with a kitchen knife? The best your grandfather could have done to protect his family was to fight off the enemy...unless we speak about country like deuchland, or japan that really started the WW2, yeah that would make no sense more than going after some wicked ideology.
Collective guilt and punishment are slippery slopes that what caused the atrocities.
Movie name please
Documentaries on the war said that once Germany was defeated, the soldiers who won forced the German populace to walk through war camps because they believed them complacent in all of the atrocities. At this point, they no longer considered many of these people human bc no human could hear soldiers sexually tormenting children in the street and turn a blind eye or hear the screams of torture and go about that day like so many Germans had. I suppose they weren't considered innocent because the horror was happening in front of them and they still helped the Germans committing such acts. I understand the anger of the winning side but I don't understand not just putting a bullet in the women's heads like they did the soldiers and being done with it.
Because the russians were the bad guys.
Yeah right. It's like the US and UK soldiers were saints...
no, they were not often, but compared to the Germans and the Russians, you could've mistaken them for such. Good way to get a general idea; East Germanys treatment under the Soviets vice the Japanese treatment under the US. Hmmm. You could make a good case that the conduct of both of those nations didn't warrant a lot of consideration after their defeat, but setting that aside, how they were all treated was sure illuminating.
Of course the USA and UK soldiers were not saints and did not get every situation correct. The thing is the reason for which they fought was correct and justified, if you cannot agree with that then you need to find the truth and understanding. The world is not simply Good vs Evil or colored black and white. It’s more complicated and more middle ground than just one sided, the fact is you benefitted from What the USA and UK soldiers fought for!
U.K. was the worst aha seriously
@@twlowe19 Do you know that on the order of the British colonial government, several million people in ww2 India were left to starve?
The japanese did very bad things to the chinese and westerners and also had their own internment camps for westerners. They did so many unspeakable things and especially to the chinese.
my dad was a sergeant in a front line battalion landed in normandy finally wounded at the bulge He participated in liberation of several camps and at one time a guard in a POW camp where he nearly murdered a german officer he saw physically attacked an enlisted man. He saw it all. He told me at some point ,likely in the late 90s as it took him that long to speak, that Eisenhower had given direct orders that NO AMERICAN OR ALLIED SOLIDER UNDER HIS COMMAND WAS TO ASSAULT ANY FEMALE. He said these orders were followed. Issues were with the russians who raped their way thru eastern europe and after it was over stalin ordered that every town have a statute of the "great liberator" i guess either him or a generic russian foot soldier. the locals called these monstrosities the "great rapists" and were gleefully engaged in tearing them down after the federation fell. I certainly cannot say no allied soldiers did such but i believe there were very few.
In war only Victor is righteous!
In any war, it is ALWAYS the women and the children in the countries where the fighting takes place who, other than the soldiers doing the fighting, suffer the most. I saw this even in Iraq and Afghanistan.
So women and children suffer more then men? Nice lol
,,We have defeated the wrong Enemy“
- George S. Patton
NAZI spies were in north america gathering information about Jews.That should make you think again if George S.Patton was right.
@@T15L94 There were a few Nazi spies in America. But for any Nazi spy there were 500 communist spies in America. The Reds were everywere. Even in the Manhattan Project. Only because of that the Commies could develop the A-Bomb.
@@GenThomasSPower .But now you know if Germany wasn't the one defeated then north america would be the next target and there is no chance for US against Germany which actually suffered 80% of its military casualties in eastern front.
If you are thinking letting Germany first defeat USSR and then crushing it when it is weaken, then just look at allies and Soviets who thought the same but both suffered at the hand of NAZIs.
@@T15L94 The Soviets would have lost the war already in 1941 without the US and the aid from Lend-and-Lease. The Nazis and the Soviets would have fought on in war of attrition in the areas east of Moskow (Volga Areas) if the US didn’t send aid to either side until the D-Day. The Germans would have suffered casualities as well as the Russians. The Russians would have suffered more because of their inhuman strategies and human-wave-tactics. But the Front would eventually end in a stalemate until D-Day. The Soviets could have never brought whole Eastern Europe under Communist Tyranny and commit Mass-Rapes against Millons of Women and Girls from Romania, Poland, Bulgaria, Germany and Austria. The Reds also killed millions of Civilians in their advance (alone 2 Million Germans and 0.5 Million Poles) and they deported 1.5 million german Civilians to Siberia to work in Slave-Labour-Camps as ,living reparations‘ or ,reparations in kind‘.
Without Lend-and-Lease the Soviets would have never got enought Trucks to wage an offensive war and most of Eastern Europe would have been liberated by the Western Allies. In the end it would have been much like a successfull ,Operation Unthinkable‘
No we did not
The Germans did the exact same in Eastren Europe . Both sides where animals
After you said for the third time that the soldiers "enjoyed the German women's body" I stopped listening. They were RAPED. Using any more romantic or meaningless expression is demeaning to those women who had to endure this hell.
He didn't mean it , UA-cam will censor it, just like suicide is called "Unaliving" , cuz words like these are censor, due to limitation of platform
@@ameytipre9699: There are still more accurate ways to circumnavigate the word. "Forced themselves on the women" for example. It really triggered me.
200 Years Together
An Eye 👁️👀 for an eye 👁️👀 makes the whole world 🌎🌍 blind.
Gandhi
That's why take 10 eyes alone
If you lose the war you started, you get special prizes. 🎉
If you win the war and suffered a lot of pain just to do the same shit right back to the enemy than maybe you deserved that pain
@@aaaaaceghhhiimmnnnrstu3273 It's called the spoils of war ...and a man invented that revolting idea ..? Men are good at making women suffer throughout history
These women didn't start the war
@@cornfednebraskaneerBut they supported . Specifically this woman lived an opulent life while putting Jewish women into a horrible death
@@thushanjanith8744 sure let me say get the woman out of there oh shit i died because i tried to help
You can show movie which shows what was happening to Polish women at the war.
Makes humans behave more primal than animals, really.
Which is why we need strong men to defend a nation so our women and children don’t get raped.
Bad take on this. Humans need to evolve mentally already, not use the "there will always be wars because it's in human nature ' excuse. Enough of this already. Wars must be avoided in the future altogether. It's embarrassing for something like this to still be happening. Humans need to do better. Still starting wars like humans did thousands of years ago? Pathetic, really. Humanity should have been too civilized for that already.
@@fabiana7157 Yet your ilk calls for the destruction of Christians, Russia and anyone standing in the way of your feminazi liberal-leftist agenda. "Peace-loving" my ass.
@@fabiana7157 Unfortunately war is and has never been about being civilized, it is about getting control of resources. With an expanding world population don't expect war to go away any time soon until the population shrinks or technology increases where we utilize resources more effectively.
that jist means they'll be raped by their own menfolk when the menfolk come home.
@@fabiana7157 unfortunately the way things are, war will never end. It is synonymous with human civilization and unfortunately has been a part of it since almost the very beginning. Look at middle East and Africa now, there's war going on over there right now, and we all know what's happening to Ukraine. There will be war at least some place on the planet. I hate it. But at the same time, it's true.
All women should be treated as if they are your own mother. Or the holy mother. (Mary)
But certainly don’t be a Simp
Privjet izvini mi a film cime ?
This is the most saddest story I ever heard please can someone tell me that German woman later returned to her husband
No i believe that the husband left after reading the diary
@@oreki8707 that woman suffered so much it's broken my heart
In Japan, women aborted pregnancies from being raped by ally troops before their POW husbands return.
Many german women actually committed suicide after the first time they were raped. This movie is probably woke, just to weaken the best nation that ever lived, to the eyes of the world
@@user-qf1wr3nu8t true it's so sad German women has go through such a painful situation
She's not only intelligent, she is also brave. She had been through a lot, imagine a woman from that era getting her pants ripped multiple times.
brave would be if she immolated herself (like Indian women did) instead of selling herself.
Nobody wins in war, not the men, nor the women, nor the victors, nor the vanquished.
Eine Frau in Berlin, Marta Hillers 📖
It's ironic. Poland was screwed from all sides and I cannot begin to fathom what must have happened to polish women, yet here we are focusing on german women. Suffering happened on both sides but this is borderline historical revisionism.
I don't want to burst your righteous bubble, but the movie was about the women of Berlin. As stated in its title.
Take it up with the filmmakers, love. Even better, go watch a Polish movie.
P.S. your last sentence is the most excellent word salad I read today.
@@susivarga7303 Righteous hehe, you're funny. You sound like someone who'd use the term "polish concentration camps". Also, word salad? Time to learn some new words.
It is but one universal story regarding war and occupation.
Speaking of historical revisionism, Poles committed war crimes and atrocities on German civilians.
@@Colton-1117 next thing you know Poles started WW2 and built concentration camps 😂😂
This is what happens as well when only the military or bad guys have firearms. Citizens with firearms are Citizens, citizens without firearms end up as slaves
Found the american 😂
Sure let's add more fuel to the fire
So we can have more school shooting right?
@@armergamer2179 I mean there really isn’t much more fuel you can add. They’re just going to beat or kill you.
sure. the one thing the germans lacked during ww2 was guns, if they'd just had those they'd have come out fine.
Is this voice a robot? The name sounds like Gretta, not Greta, with a hard E. I know you just made the name up to give her one, but that like pronouncing Brad as Braid.