Hey everyone, please don’t be too hard on Gaga when she says that she heard Amy died from going cold turkey. Please keep in mind that this interview took place only a week after Amy’s death. So the full details hadn’t come out yet, the autopsy/toxicology were still being done, and there were only theories being tossed around at this point.
Alcohol was her drug of choice, she died of alcohol poisoning Google it, most of her songs mentioned drinking . Wake up Alone= at least I’m not drinking No Good = meet me down stairs in the Bar
@@chatman4998 you just stop using or drinking without any rehab, help, or medicine to help with the withdrawals(usually painful)...you just say f this I'm not doing (insert drug or alcohol here) no more. However, your body chemistry has changed and is dependent on that drug .....this can work out well or not so well
Absolutely. But in general this happens to most ppl you know. Once you are dead you immediately become this amazing wonderful person ( not to say amy wasn't, I always liked her and as a drug addict I know all too well how painful it is and the last thing I would have wanted in ny life was paoarazzi taking pics of me while high and the while world laughing at me for sth extremely painful and serious). So yeah, hypocrites everywhere... I guess that means they have no clue what it feels like to want to die every second of your life... So good for them. The lavk of empathy in this world and in my opinion anongst millenials is ashtounding...the all post about womens rights and blm but if their closest friend is struggling with mental health and addiction thwy could care less. 1 out of 4 millenials have NO friends at all... That is sad. But nobody talks about it.
The media terrorised Amy, the British media are murderers. The way they treated Princess Diana, Amy and even Michael Jackson was absolutely despicable and unforgivable.
hi bro. how are we watching the same shit? and why did you give me hell the other day for talking about amy winehouse music, when your watching tributes to her? smh #caughtup
Yeah. I cried so much when she passed. The media is a piece of shit also. Gaga is right that everyone talked so much shit and brought her down. If only Gaga had got to meet her and talk to her
Kiki La Bouche I was just thinking the same, Gaga has a loving family who truly cares about her, she’s such a daddy’s girl. Unfortunately Amy’s dad was enjoying her fame rather than worrying about her daughter, and her mom was very submissive
You can see it in his behaviour in the doco, especially when she was in St Lucia. He was a failed jazz singer and loved the fame as much as Amy hated the same fame. She just wanted to make music...
@chima chibi amy was a adult,you are responsible for your own actions,if she was your kid ,you would tryvto keep her working or she was going to sit at home more doing drugs and drinking,amy wasdepressed soul,i think in the end amy really regretted the drug thing,knowing it was the cause of most her problems for herself and her husband,come on now ,amy wouldnt blame her dad or mum or anyone else for her problems,she was a cool chick,you would have owned it herself
This is such a tone deaf interview. Doing drugs and having an addiction are two totally different things. Lady Gaga did drugs. Amy Winehouse had severe addictions. Saying that Gaga controlled herself while Amy couldn't and died is awful. Barbara Walters should be ashamed of this line of questioning.
I agree Summer. It seemed to me like Barbara's focus in bringing up Lady Gaga's history of drug use was to compare the two and highlight how Gaga could get out of it and how Amy couldn't. This doesn't begin to touch on the depths of addiction. I don't blame Gaga at all, more the focus that the interviewers took
I feel the older lady asking gaga about "why is it this woman has fallen and you havent" is very insensitive to the situation. Respect to gaga for taking it in stride. But idk....that's just my opinion.
"The older lady" doesn't ask questions out of her own curiosity. Barbara Walters asks for the audience. That would be because she is a seasoned journo.
I think she hit the nail on the head when she said you can't expect someone making deeply moving songs about heartbreak to be a cool-headed optimist. Artists are often very sensitive people, and what they give the world reflects how they feel inside. It's just a shame Winehouse passed before reaching the next stage in her life. Most people, no matter how turbulent, eventually find peace.
@Rock Gailhard Lol absolutely not? she was 3 years clean of drugs when she died,and could go lenghty periods without drinking. Don't talk if you don't know
@Kore Gailhard yeah, I know. She did a lot of things that were not good for her. But she was in her twenties. Then we all make mistakes. It's just so sad that the mistakes she made killed her at 27. Poor girl. And poor us.
Amy never said she struggled with fame. She had a toxic man in her life. He got her hooked on hard drugs. She loved life. He will always be the man that killed her in my opinion.
No one is talking about how Amy was bulimic and malnourished. I love her to pieces, I hate seeing her labeled as an addict. She was so kind. So kind that she took everything out on herself.
We create our own labels by our actions. If you are addicted to drugs you are an addict. If you truly care about someone, you see the whole person - the ugly and the pretty. When you only see the pretty - well I guess that's the difference between just being a fan and being someone who was in her life 24/7.
She was bulimic yes, but she was also an alcoholic and a heroin addict. Downplaying or ignoring the fact that she did and was addicted to heroin might feel “more respectful” but it’s part of the problem. If we can’t talk about this stuff, the problems get hidden in the shadows and then kill people.
And you think that you are somehow being respectful to people? Your comment makes it sound like addicts are generally bad, making the term addict an insult. Amy Winehouse engaged in drug use and probably disordered eating until she died as a result, after months and months of wasting away. That is exactly what an addict is.
I watched the Amy documentary on Netflix awhile back. They an interviewed one of her closest friends. She claims that directly after Amy won a Grammy and she was sober at the time, she told her something along the lines of “This moment isn’t half as good without my drugs. I really can’t feel much happiness at all without them.” That has always stuck in my mind. The fact that for some addicts, they lose their ability to have joy in their hearts once they stop using. No wonder so many people relapse.
@@miawallace2306 no it never gets better, meth is a drug you MUST stay away from at all costs it’s highly addictive and makes you feel extremely alert, lustful, aggressive, bipolar, the list goes on. Infact Meth attaches itself to the nervous system which is why lots of tweakers clench their jaws or are always moving. You sweat alot and smell like cat litter, your face becomes elongated and deformed….you lose the sense of reality, You literally become a whole different conscious. I forgot to mention the hallucinations and the voices you hear 👂 I personally am convinced I saw demons…like shadows
Well, consuming certain drugs causes you to actually lose the ability to "properly feel". So it's not that they need drugs to be happy, it's that every time they stop, their brain and body isn't operating normally anymore. With drugs, better don't start, they kill you.
Isn't it so sad that Amy is remembered for addiction and not for her amazing talent she brought to the world her voice, her amazing dress sence, the music songs, that made us feel something inside an amazing human being is and always will be. We're all only here for the time that we're meant to be here Amy brought something great into our world like we all should be doing.love you Amy. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
@@fayeart5277drugs being her choice doesnt make it less sad imo. Humans are weak and make shitty decisions. Better to be self destructive than destroying others
Gaga had a family, a father, that delivered unconditional love and support that came with essential boundaries. Amy didn't have that it seems - at least from her father's actions during and after her life and other information from documentaries. I do wish her grandmother survived long enough to guide her through these rough times. Comparing them is incredibly unfair. Their upbringings were completely different in most ways, including financial.
this is the thing that I have a hard time accepting. Accepting the fact that some people are blessed With love from everyone , unconditional love from the very people that should love them so, like their family. Some aren't and .. I just ask god why..
@@veetee4826 You have a good heart. Events happen down the family line that leaves certain people (who are links in that chain) broken and weak....they're not strong enough for their own kids and often times not strong enough for themselves. Many of us come from these types of families, or so it seems. Sometimes these weaknesses in the chain can be felt for many generations until it's a type of family dysfunction that everyone simply accepts as a way of life. Other times, the weaknesses are addressed by an aware individual who is determined to create strength for themselves and their offspring. When we have the discernment to know we come from an incredibly weak link (perhaps as weak or weaker than Amy Winehouse's dad for instance), we have the gift of being able to intimately understand what the lives of our children will be if we don't work on becoming strong ourselves. I don't know if you have also come from this type of family - but I sincerely hope that you have found, or will find, the strength that is inherent within you....a strength that was hidden from you as a child from the people who should've loved and enforced you the most. That strength is always going to be within you and I hope you know you are deserving of love and happiness.
@@sputniksweetheart5187 it's hard. It's hard because I feel like have to face everything alone. You could be in public balling your eyes out, desperate and people still wouldn't care .. I've experienced that. It's not fair that the world gives the nicer treatment to those with wheelchair or down syndrome. They recieve all the affection n assistance. But me, yeah either do the work yourself if you can* or die, jump off a cliff do whatever etc
It's silly to ask someone why they could handle a certain situation more than another. Maybe when a person has anxiety or depression they don't cope with things like other people
Lady Gaga is so right. Everyone was hard one her especially the fucking media! Pieces of garbage. The lesson is huge in this. Media probably made her situation even worse. People were judging her and they didn't even know her or what she was going through. I wish Lady Gaga had a chance to talk to Amy. I really wish I had the chance to meet and talk to Amy. I had a lot of the sadness she had even though I'm young and beautiful and seemingly have the "Life" friends, well off etc. Sometimes it's not enough and although there are people living in squalor with reason to be sad and depressed it doesn't make mine or Amy's sadness any less real. Heartbreaking
My father was a bad alcoholic and got sober and he was the only one in my family to be open and encourage me to get sober and if it weren’t for him I wouldn’t be alive today!
She died on my birthday, as did my father... It's sad cause I loved Amy, and I was actually celebrating my birthday the day she died , after years of avoiding the day because of my dad dying in 2007.. And when my friend told me she died right after blowing out the candles..I thought : wow, the first birthday in years that I decide to celebrate.. and my favorite singer dies. I really feel like my birthday isn't that happy after all 😢 RIP Amy
Number 27 in numerology symbolizes compassion and philanthropy. This number is a combination of energies that people who resonate with this number are tolerant, kindhearted, intelligent, team workers, and working to enhance humanity. They often support humanitarian organizations and groups. Source- some random Google Web page about numerology
She started to go through her Saturn return at 27 we all do. Significant changes happen during Saturn return. The second Saturn return is age 58. It last for 4 years btw way. Most of us won't live long enough to see the 3rd Saturn return....... Look it up it's very interesting.
Over time there have been many pop artists who have died in their late twenties, even back in the 1960s and 1970s. Many of the them were related to drink or drugs either directly or as a result of accidents after taking either. There's only so much abuse that the body can withstand and the late late twenties tends to be the age at which people have their last chance to get away from serious addiction. By that time they simply have to get better if they're going to lead a longer life. Although Amy technically died of drink, she was already weakened by all the earlier abuse her body had taken. She also had an eating disorder so everything together created the perfect storm. I so wish that Amy was still with us. She would be 37 now though I feel that a recovery would have been long and gradual, but a recovery all the same.
So heartbreaking that Amy Winehouse didn’t have the right people surrounding her 😔 when you’re surrounded by yes people it destroys you 😔 Lady Gaga is such a beautiful soul and absolutely deserved every single award she’s ever won x love her x
at 1:13 Gaga wiggles her fingers in frustration as Barbara is quick to manipulate the conversation as a negative "No that's not what the article said" (in her mind- Shut up Stephanie, you let a cat out of the bag with your previous statement! "She was 27 you are 25!" Look into the realness of Gagas eyes... Gaga, flipped it eventually back into a joke moment... ANyone else notice?
I seen that right away. Nice you picked it up as well. Not a huge fan of GaGa but I see she is doing 3rd remake of A Star is Born. Original was fabulous. Then in 74 Streisand and Kris Kristoferson did the remake and it was better then the original. Anxious to see how GaGa does with the role of Esther.
@@danielhubley3335 i don't blame her either 😅 but i don't think she doesn't like her, it's hard to communicate with someone like her and not feel uncomfortable. She seems like one of those people that is just tone deaf about ANYTHING and WILL ASK
Gaga told no lies. I’ll never forget the way the public & the media treated her. Imagine what happened to Britney in 2006-2008, triple that & that’s how they did Amy. They were harassing her for photos with a pipe in her hand & blood running down her body. At a time when she needed love & support, the world just laughed in her face. I’ve never seen such a vile act of public humiliation.
gaga changed the world for the better idc what anyone says. being gay even 10 years ago around this time was still not okay at all but she made it ok she did. thank you gaga 🙏🏼 been listening since 2008 went to her first tour i was 12 🙂❤️
Gaga didn't make being gay okay. She helped. But there were so many other artists, singers, musicians, actors, etc. before her that paved the way. Lady Gaga is very young. You never thought that there were others who have been around for years that made it okay to be gay way before Lady Gaga? You must be very young and very naïve.
Well as an Amy fan I never considered her an addict even tho she did drugs I never saw her that way..I saw her as an artist and a legend ..she made great music and she made music that was relatable..so I saw her as an artist and a relatable human being :) we miss u Amy ❤️❤️❤️
Tony Bennett said Amy Winehouse and lady gaga were/ are the best singers of our century , amy loved Joanne...ms gaga , mark Ronson said he put there voices together, and it worked, they harmonized, I think _ amy ,adele, celeste, lady gaga, whitney Houston. That would of been a mature proper ladies band .a lovely dream. Xxxxx
Lady Gaga talks about how her dad held her accountable and explained his concerns in a relatable way. We can only hope Amy's dad did the same... that the parents didn't ignore it, or try to control it, or just try to push her into performing as a 'cure' for addiction. They certainly profited regardless
Amy died of alcohol poisoning, had previously used drugs but her real struggle was with alcohol . That said, agree wi the poster below, this was a week after her passing and the prevalent theory was she died of an overdose. So no hating on Gaga.
Kind of insulting of Barbara to compare Gaga's dabbling with drugs to Amy's full blown addictions in order to imply that Amy might've lived if she'd just had someone tell her to "knock it off". Even in death, addicts get no respect or empathy. We're human, you know? Amy deserved better. I sure do miss her.
That was it. She had sobered up then had a bender and her sober body couldn't handle it. Most alcoholics are always drinking aka it's usually in your system. Her blood was flooded
+Hey - I agree. Amy had abused her poor body since her first eating disorder at the age of 15. Her body had gone through a lot. That is a lot of stress on your heart muscles, kidneys, liver, etc... Surprised that Charlie Sheen is still living.
If you watch the woman to gaga’s left, the one next to her on the right of screen, she clues on to the fact that Lady Gaga is Amy Winehouse, when the woman mentions that Winehouse is 27 that she’s 25
She was so hurt, heartbroken, the love of her life also encouraged substance abuse and was a substance abuser. she was in pain. do not ever accuse or blame ANYONE. anyone couldve helped her, some people encouraged her, she chose to do them, and she was in pain. there is no specific party at fault.
The addict has the brain receptors that turned "ON" and provide euphoria for the addict. As I told my orthopedist when he told me I'd need a 7th shoulder surgery, and he asked why I do mountain biking as "Your shoulders weren't designed to take it" I said "If I didn't mountain bike and do these athletic things, I'd be taking 700mg of Zoloft a day." One has to find something that gives as much enjoyment as a drug but has positive, long term benefit i.e. mountain biking is great for my heart and makes me higher than any drug around.
When I was struggling to beat a 10 year addiction to intravenous amphetamines (speed) my psychiatrist said basically the same thing as you did.He said "You have to find something in your life that stimulates you as equally as the drug you're addicted to is & replace it with that".....Those words had a powerful & therapeutic effect on me & apparently he was right.Now I own 3 houses & have hundreds of thousands of dollars in the bank & the future doesn't have either death or jail staring me perennially in the face. It didn't happen overnight, but the craving for drugs dissipated over time & I no longer feel like my life is a lesser thing for not having them in it.It's a shame Amy wasn't able to transcend her addictions & enjoy 6 or 7 more decades of a happy & drug/alcohol free life.
*"The lesson was the for world to be kinder"* That's what it just takes for someone to be happy but I guess the highest living organisms in this damn planet couldn't do something like that.
im part of the green club too gaga ,thats why we are still alive,i lost friends that did what amy did ,or just booze and that kiled them ,excessand too much money
I absolutely adored Amy but seeing my close family members and friends die from addiction them selfs you can only support them self's they have to take accountability for their actions before any thing else move forward relapse is all part of the recovery but also every relapse gets harder and harder to over comb RIP Beautiful Amy
I’m sorry I have to defend Gaga here. This was filmed a week after Amy’s death and by that time her coroner report wasn’t released. It wasn’t until late October it was clarified that Amy died of alcohol poisoning. But I do think that Gaga was very reckless and insensitive to be throwing around gossip on national television and stating it was fact only a week after the event.
no one can judge the past of others if they do not go through the same situations. it is easy to talk about others ..... especially about their problems and weaknesses .... have you tried to put yourself in the same shoes? no one will know what others endure in order to self-destruct .... respect for Amy.
Gaga is right and found the right words , and I agree with her. I knew a pretty lot of people dying by drugs, over the years. It gets worse with age of course . Amy was not one of these toxic "girlish type people like Cyrus and her tongue cramps, Perry who looks half dead, Rhianna or equal dolls, you could replace and noone'd realize, cause they are somehow "empty" And Gaga is not that ignorant and stands out of those always envying and judging plastic dolls. And I'm sure, She has not only a better voice and artwork and is a great actress, but is far more intelligent, as these wax-like "girl's", who find themselves sexy or offending, but I am sure, no man over 15 years of age would find one of them appealing. Hope Amy is in a good place now. She was such an outstanding talent. Her father was a shady Figuren to me. Maybe she would not have tried cold Turkey, when this guy had not let her stay away from Rehab. I don't know, how the English handle it. But nothing else could have had a worst outcome!
I have manic depression and there were times I wanted to get messed up off of something just to calm it down (I went through a mixed episode and to stay calm, i binged on alcohol, marijuana, and Valium pills, basically all "downers") but then there's also the part of me that's like well do I want to be a junkie for the rest of my life and hide all my problems and substance usage or do I want to get on my way despite my condition and look for ways to stay stress-free and positive as much as possible? I'm not going to throw my life away over some mental illness. I see too many people do that and that's not the direction I want to go. It's about choices. You can choose to get help or stay miserable and fckd up on drugs or booze.
@@LittleWing1985 u do know that drug dependency is heavily genetic right? For some its easy to do a few lines of coke every week and stop after a brief moment of introspection. For others it derails much faster to other drugs and self control in no longer as easy to achieve. Amy is also heavily theorized to have been borderline on top of manic depressive. Add there the fame, the uncountable money and the spotlight and I would bet her situation is much much harder than ur average folk. And yet she still managed to fully stop taking any hard drug and was on the process of quitting alcohol. She died by misadventure, she actually tried and she should also be respected by that.
Amy was an exceptional talent who had mistaken the idea of being in love for true l believe she was looking for true love and had the misfortune of finding Blake. I don't believe he is to blame entirely as you don't make people do dope. But he knew exactly what heroin makes you become and admitted he should never had let her try it.It becomes your Lover and then he's just someone to get high with that she could trust. He may be hurt by all of it but if he truly had loved her he'd never be able to talk about anything The shared together. Fuck people, who cares what they think when you know the truth. We lost a beautiful , beautiful woman who is missed and will be missed forever. Rest in peace gorgeous I'll miss you also.
Hey everyone, please don’t be too hard on Gaga when she says that she heard Amy died from going cold turkey. Please keep in mind that this interview took place only a week after Amy’s death. So the full details hadn’t come out yet, the autopsy/toxicology were still being done, and there were only theories being tossed around at this point.
What does cold turkey mean?
Alcohol was her drug of choice, she died of alcohol poisoning Google it, most of her songs mentioned drinking .
Wake up Alone= at least I’m not drinking
No Good = meet me down stairs in the Bar
@@chatman4998 you just stop using or drinking without any rehab, help, or medicine to help with the withdrawals(usually painful)...you just say f this I'm not doing (insert drug or alcohol here) no more.
However, your body chemistry has changed and is dependent on that drug .....this can work out well or not so well
@@chatman4998 never go cold turkey on a drug like alcohol or Xanax you will die or have seizure
It was true though.
The media ridiculed her during the height of her addiction and depression, but once she passed they all talked about how incredible she was...
@Abby A media is motheruckers assholes the reaon i thought amy was died
Absolutely. But in general this happens to most ppl you know. Once you are dead you immediately become this amazing wonderful person ( not to say amy wasn't, I always liked her and as a drug addict I know all too well how painful it is and the last thing I would have wanted in ny life was paoarazzi taking pics of me while high and the while world laughing at me for sth extremely painful and serious). So yeah, hypocrites everywhere... I guess that means they have no clue what it feels like to want to die every second of your life... So good for them.
The lavk of empathy in this world and in my opinion anongst millenials is ashtounding...the all post about womens rights and blm but if their closest friend is struggling with mental health and addiction thwy could care less. 1 out of 4 millenials have NO friends at all... That is sad. But nobody talks about it.
The media terrorised Amy, the British media are murderers. The way they treated Princess Diana, Amy and even Michael Jackson was absolutely despicable and unforgivable.
Let's see which musician is going to be theor next victim
Лицемеры!
gaga and amy could be the best duet in this world.
marie lebedeva I wish it would have happened
taissia lebedeva OMGGGG YESS! Man i wish to :((( 💔💔💔I love Winehouse and Gaga
@@ElSauxy02 it's sad we only have one.
Yes, this would have been interesting.
Wish they could of done a collab together if amy was still alive. RIP amy
Can't believe its been 7 years since Amy died. She was my favorite artist. She had an amazing gift and soul.
hi bro. how are we watching the same shit? and why did you give me hell the other day for talking about amy winehouse music, when your watching tributes to her? smh #caughtup
Chris Kolumbice Couldn’t agree more. Amy was a fantastic artist.
Yeah. I cried so much when she passed. The media is a piece of shit also. Gaga is right that everyone talked so much shit and brought her down. If only Gaga had got to meet her and talk to her
I thought she died in the 90s, everyone makes it seem like it was so long ago.
8
Gaga's father called her out, Amy's father was enjoying the fame far too much...that's the big difference
Kiki La Bouche I was just thinking the same, Gaga has a loving family who truly cares about her, she’s such a daddy’s girl. Unfortunately Amy’s dad was enjoying her fame rather than worrying about her daughter, and her mom was very submissive
You can see it in his behaviour in the doco, especially when she was in St Lucia. He was a failed jazz singer and loved the fame as much as Amy hated the same fame. She just wanted to make music...
and do copious amounts of lethal drugs
Exactly!
@chima chibi amy was a adult,you are responsible for your own actions,if she was your kid ,you would tryvto keep her working or she was going to sit at home more doing drugs and drinking,amy wasdepressed soul,i think in the end amy really regretted the drug thing,knowing it was the cause of most her problems for herself and her husband,come on now ,amy wouldnt blame her dad or mum or anyone else for her problems,she was a cool chick,you would have owned it herself
This is such a tone deaf interview. Doing drugs and having an addiction are two totally different things. Lady Gaga did drugs. Amy Winehouse had severe addictions. Saying that Gaga controlled herself while Amy couldn't and died is awful. Barbara Walters should be ashamed of this line of questioning.
this interview was 6 days after amy died they didn’t know the full details yet
Summer Gillen, I completely agree
You are absolutely right..
True
I agree Summer. It seemed to me like Barbara's focus in bringing up Lady Gaga's history of drug use was to compare the two and highlight how Gaga could get out of it and how Amy couldn't. This doesn't begin to touch on the depths of addiction. I don't blame Gaga at all, more the focus that the interviewers took
It’s crazy to see how much Lady Gaga has changed.
Oh Wow (?)
Oh Wow
True....People get older and mature. She in a better place in life in 2019.
exactly! I was thinking the same thing
If you look closely, you would've noticed she has never changed internally
@@horacewong4281 so true
I feel the older lady asking gaga about "why is it this woman has fallen and you havent" is very insensitive to the situation. Respect to gaga for taking it in stride. But idk....that's just my opinion.
The 'older woman' is Barbara Walters a well known journalist.
@@pierina1705 thank you. I had no idea who she was. This also gives better context.
She is right, anyway.
What a stupid question, not everyone is the same. I can't believe she asked that.
"The older lady" doesn't ask questions out of her own curiosity. Barbara Walters asks for the audience. That would be because she is a seasoned journo.
Amy needed a dad like Gaga’s
Amy's dad loved her and tried to help her. She had tons of support, she just felt too much.
@@forestnymphconfessions3596 Yeah that’s true he loved her, but also he did always say that she didn’t need rehab and that she was fine
@@forestnymphconfessions3596 He loved her money
No-
Gaga is a dad!!!!
I think she hit the nail on the head when she said you can't expect someone making deeply moving songs about heartbreak to be a cool-headed optimist. Artists are often very sensitive people, and what they give the world reflects how they feel inside. It's just a shame Winehouse passed before reaching the next stage in her life. Most people, no matter how turbulent, eventually find peace.
Most people find peace?
"People blamed her for her addiction?" Blame the father. Blame Blake. Not Amy.
i said the same thing he enjoyed her fame and the money way too much!
@Rock Gailhard Lol absolutely not?
she was 3 years clean of drugs when she died,and could go lenghty periods without drinking.
Don't talk if you don't know
@Rock Gailhard well, she stopped many times and she cared big time to continue her life. Most people do not want to die at 27.
@Kore Gailhard yeah, I know. She did a lot of things that were not good for her. But she was in her twenties. Then we all make mistakes. It's just so sad that the mistakes she made killed her at 27. Poor girl. And poor us.
@rezdout Periodt
Amy never said she struggled with fame. She had a toxic man in her life. He got her hooked on hard drugs. She loved life. He will always be the man that killed her in my opinion.
you weren't part of their relationship so do one. If you looked at the paparazzi videos you wouldn't say that she didn't struggle with fame again..
Luke Prentice you do one weirdo
Here there he was all about the money sadly xx
Fame and blake killed her
Louise Close once the heroin gets introduced into the mix, that’s usually the road downhill. Fuck that dude, for real.
No one is talking about how Amy was bulimic and malnourished. I love her to pieces, I hate seeing her labeled as an addict. She was so kind. So kind that she took everything out on herself.
Exactly.. it wasnt just drugs and fame..
We create our own labels by our actions. If you are addicted to drugs you are an addict. If you truly care about someone, you see the whole person - the ugly and the pretty. When you only see the pretty - well I guess that's the difference between just being a fan and being someone who was in her life 24/7.
YES this. I hate how demonized she is in such a weird variety of ways. Her music got me through so many dark nights.
She was bulimic yes, but she was also an alcoholic and a heroin addict. Downplaying or ignoring the fact that she did and was addicted to heroin might feel “more respectful” but it’s part of the problem. If we can’t talk about this stuff, the problems get hidden in the shadows and then kill people.
And you think that you are somehow being respectful to people? Your comment makes it sound like addicts are generally bad, making the term addict an insult. Amy Winehouse engaged in drug use and probably disordered eating until she died as a result, after months and months of wasting away. That is exactly what an addict is.
I watched the Amy documentary on Netflix awhile back. They an interviewed one of her closest friends. She claims that directly after Amy won a Grammy and she was sober at the time, she told her something along the lines of “This moment isn’t half as good without my drugs. I really can’t feel much happiness at all without them.”
That has always stuck in my mind. The fact that for some addicts, they lose their ability to have joy in their hearts once they stop using. No wonder so many people relapse.
As an ex addict you do feel “dead” without the drugs no emotions, no nothing. Literally you feel empty.
@@NobleWolf33 Does it ever get better?
@@miawallace2306 no it never gets better, meth is a drug you MUST stay away from at all costs it’s highly addictive and makes you feel extremely alert, lustful, aggressive, bipolar, the list goes on. Infact Meth attaches itself to the nervous system which is why lots of tweakers clench their jaws or are always moving. You sweat alot and smell like cat litter, your face becomes elongated and deformed….you lose the sense of reality,
You literally become a whole different conscious.
I forgot to mention the hallucinations and the voices you hear 👂 I personally am convinced I saw demons…like shadows
Well, consuming certain drugs causes you to actually lose the ability to "properly feel". So it's not that they need drugs to be happy, it's that every time they stop, their brain and body isn't operating normally anymore. With drugs, better don't start, they kill you.
@@miawallace2306yes, you can overcome any addiction, but it can be very hard and you need good people around you and strength to make the change
Isn't it so sad that Amy is remembered for addiction and not for her amazing talent she brought to the world her voice, her amazing dress sence, the music songs, that made us feel something inside an amazing human being is and always will be. We're all only here for the time that we're meant to be here Amy brought something great into our world like we all should be doing.love you Amy. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Not me I will always remember Amy as the power house she truly is ❤️💯
She had a few good hits, had the potential to really go big. She chose a different direction...drug's. End of story.
@@fayeart5277drugs being her choice doesnt make it less sad imo. Humans are weak and make shitty decisions. Better to be self destructive than destroying others
This was a classy moment with Lady Gaga. Good for her for standing up for Amy.
@@sophiamarquisyou mad 😂
Look at Whoopi's face when she mentions the green lol
Charles Blake 2:10
Charles Blake Goldie like yup girl we all do just stay honest hunni (:
That was fantastic!😂✌🏻👍🏻⭐️🌇🎉
what s that
Başak weed sis
In Amy's song Rehab she sings "And if my daddy thinks I'm fine..." It shows how Dad's opinion truly matters.
I think that’s all she ever wanted, her dads attention and unconditional love…
@@NobleWolf33 we all do
Not Whoopi nodding along when she said “I’m part of the green club” 😂😂😂
I had to think for a minute "green club" then I thought about it!!!🤣🤣🤣🤣
Gaga had a family, a father, that delivered unconditional love and support that came with essential boundaries. Amy didn't have that it seems - at least from her father's actions during and after her life and other information from documentaries. I do wish her grandmother survived long enough to guide her through these rough times. Comparing them is incredibly unfair. Their upbringings were completely different in most ways, including financial.
this is the thing that I have a hard time accepting. Accepting the fact that some people are blessed With love from everyone , unconditional love from the very people that should love them so, like their family. Some aren't and .. I just ask god why..
@@veetee4826 You have a good heart. Events happen down the family line that leaves certain people (who are links in that chain) broken and weak....they're not strong enough for their own kids and often times not strong enough for themselves. Many of us come from these types of families, or so it seems. Sometimes these weaknesses in the chain can be felt for many generations until it's a type of family dysfunction that everyone simply accepts as a way of life. Other times, the weaknesses are addressed by an aware individual who is determined to create strength for themselves and their offspring. When we have the discernment to know we come from an incredibly weak link (perhaps as weak or weaker than Amy Winehouse's dad for instance), we have the gift of being able to intimately understand what the lives of our children will be if we don't work on becoming strong ourselves.
I don't know if you have also come from this type of family - but I sincerely hope that you have found, or will find, the strength that is inherent within you....a strength that was hidden from you as a child from the people who should've loved and enforced you the most. That strength is always going to be within you and I hope you know you are deserving of love and happiness.
@@sputniksweetheart5187 it's hard. It's hard because I feel like have to face everything alone. You could be in public balling your eyes out, desperate and people still wouldn't care .. I've experienced that. It's not fair that the world gives the nicer treatment to those with wheelchair or down syndrome. They recieve all the affection n assistance. But me, yeah either do the work yourself if you can* or die, jump off a cliff do whatever etc
@@sputniksweetheart5187beautiful comment
Bingo
Amy was incredible she’s a legend 🌹❤️😭
Omara Oliver are you really hating on the comments of this video ?
Yes she was!!!👏👏👏
Nobody is debating Amy's talent.
The way they ask questions seems so souless
It's because they are soulless. Lady gaga can't say nothing the little satan worshipper
I love how she looked at Whoopi when mentioning she’s part of the ‘green club’ 😂
Daniyal A 2:10
Why ?
@@hamlet3480 Whoopi is open about her use of the "green" and even has a company that sells CBD-infused products
And Whoopi gave her the mutual eye. They had a telepathic communication “we know we both do it right hun?”
Why do people always got something to say torward people's comments. There just comments. Research don't make you right or wrong.
RIP Amy almost 10 years now. Everybody misses her.
I still think about her every now and then and I listen to her music constantly
Amy my baby girl. Rest in paradise my beautiful angel
On an unrelated note, I can’t believe Gaga is 25 here. So poised and mature
It's silly to ask someone why they could handle a certain situation more than another.
Maybe when a person has anxiety or depression they don't cope with things like other people
Even with anxiety and depression people handle things differently. Lady Gaga hasn't been free of those things.
Lady Gaga is so right. Everyone was hard one her especially the fucking media! Pieces of garbage. The lesson is huge in this. Media probably made her situation even worse. People were judging her and they didn't even know her or what she was going through. I wish Lady Gaga had a chance to talk to Amy. I really wish I had the chance to meet and talk to Amy. I had a lot of the sadness she had even though I'm young and beautiful and seemingly have the "Life" friends, well off etc. Sometimes it's not enough and although there are people living in squalor with reason to be sad and depressed it doesn't make mine or Amy's sadness any less real. Heartbreaking
Lady Gaga is so understanding and has so much empathy I love her!!!!!
My father was a bad alcoholic and got sober and he was the only one in my family to be open and encourage me to get sober and if it weren’t for him I wouldn’t be alive today!
I am so proud of you and your father!!💕
She died on my birthday, as did my father...
It's sad cause I loved Amy, and I was actually celebrating my birthday the day she died , after years of avoiding the day because of my dad dying in 2007..
And when my friend told me she died right after blowing out the candles..I thought : wow, the first birthday in years that I decide to celebrate.. and my favorite singer dies.
I really feel like my birthday isn't that happy after all 😢
RIP Amy
That's actually so horrible I'm so sorry, I hope you're doing okay right now!
@Lupe GT I'm sorry for you, I hope that you feel better now
since Amy passed....always have felt that Lady GaGa would be the perfect person to play Amy Winehouse in a biopic
Literally. I thought they look and looked so much alike. I wish she would have done that b4 a star is born and then move onto these other roles.
Always thought this too
Why is it always age 27 for these amazing artists to meet their demise?
The Divine Venus mentions it in her recent Saturn video. Check it out.
@@dianeaishamonday9125 I will check it out
Number 27 in numerology symbolizes compassion and philanthropy. This number is a combination of energies that people who resonate with this number are tolerant, kindhearted, intelligent, team workers, and working to enhance humanity. They often support humanitarian organizations and groups.
Source- some random Google Web page about numerology
She started to go through her Saturn return at 27 we all do. Significant changes happen during Saturn return. The second Saturn return is age 58. It last for 4 years btw way. Most of us won't live long enough to see the 3rd Saturn return.......
Look it up it's very interesting.
Over time there have been many pop artists who have died in their late twenties, even back in the 1960s and 1970s. Many of the them were related to drink or drugs either directly or as a result of accidents after taking either. There's only so much abuse that the body can withstand and the late late twenties tends to be the age at which people have their last chance to get away from serious addiction. By that time they simply have to get better if they're going to lead a longer life. Although Amy technically died of drink, she was already weakened by all the earlier abuse her body had taken. She also had an eating disorder so everything together created the perfect storm. I so wish that Amy was still with us. She would be 37 now though I feel that a recovery would have been long and gradual, but a recovery all the same.
😭😭😭😭😭 people were so rude to her and she was legendary 😭😭😭😭
I love Gaga so much. And Amy will always be a legend. People need to be kinder, that’s totally true.
She didn't die from Cold turkey. She binged after a period of abstinence and her body couldn't handle it. Big difference
this was a week after her death, it wasn’t clear how she died at that point.
So heartbreaking that Amy Winehouse didn’t have the right people surrounding her 😔 when you’re surrounded by yes people it destroys you 😔 Lady Gaga is such a beautiful soul and absolutely deserved every single award she’s ever won x love her x
at 1:13 Gaga wiggles her fingers in frustration as Barbara is quick to manipulate the conversation as a negative "No that's not what the article said" (in her mind- Shut up Stephanie, you let a cat out of the bag with your previous statement!
"She was 27 you are 25!"
Look into the realness of Gagas eyes...
Gaga, flipped it eventually back into a joke moment...
ANyone else notice?
I seen that right away. Nice you picked it up as well. Not a huge fan of GaGa but I see she is doing 3rd remake of A Star is Born. Original was fabulous. Then in 74 Streisand and Kris Kristoferson did the remake and it was better then the original. Anxious to see how GaGa does with the role of Esther.
@@lorst55 how did you like it?
Omg Gaga does not like Barbara 🤣 I don’t blame her
@@danielhubley3335 i don't blame her either 😅 but i don't think she doesn't like her, it's hard to communicate with someone like her and not feel uncomfortable. She seems like one of those people that is just tone deaf about ANYTHING and WILL ASK
Gaga told no lies. I’ll never forget the way the public & the media treated her. Imagine what happened to Britney in 2006-2008, triple that & that’s how they did Amy. They were harassing her for photos with a pipe in her hand & blood running down her body. At a time when she needed love & support, the world just laughed in her face. I’ve never seen such a vile act of public humiliation.
gaga changed the world for the better idc what anyone says. being gay even 10 years ago around this time was still not okay at all but she made it ok she did. thank you gaga 🙏🏼 been listening since 2008 went to her first tour i was 12 🙂❤️
@Randy L Just periodt !
Gaga didn't make being gay okay. She helped. But there were so many other artists, singers, musicians, actors, etc. before her that paved the way. Lady Gaga is very young. You never thought that there were others who have been around for years that made it okay to be gay way before Lady Gaga? You must be very young and very naïve.
"There's a way to be young and rebellious and have fun and not hurt yourself." Yeah!
Gaga is so open, vulnerable, and talented ❤️
Lady Gaga is Cool. She is a great artist and she speaks honestly. 👍
her music is good
@@Antoine_Bizans You are right
And she worships Satan.
@@onesong2001 Her music is amazing 💖
Well as an Amy fan I never considered her an addict even tho she did drugs I never saw her that way..I saw her as an artist and a legend ..she made great music and she made music that was relatable..so I saw her as an artist and a relatable human being :) we miss u Amy ❤️❤️❤️
Tony Bennett said Amy Winehouse and lady gaga were/ are the best singers of our century , amy loved Joanne...ms gaga , mark Ronson said he put there voices together, and it worked, they harmonized, I think _ amy ,adele, celeste, lady gaga, whitney Houston. That would of been a mature proper ladies band .a lovely dream. Xxxxx
Lady Gaga talks about how her dad held her accountable and explained his concerns in a relatable way. We can only hope Amy's dad did the same... that the parents didn't ignore it, or try to control it, or just try to push her into performing as a 'cure' for addiction. They certainly profited regardless
Amy died of alcohol poisoning, had previously used drugs but her real struggle was with alcohol . That said, agree wi the poster below, this was a week after her passing and the prevalent theory was she died of an overdose. So no hating on Gaga.
Another reason to respect Lady Gaga. I love Amy Winehouse and I like how she responded with care.
She didn’t know Amy and should not have commented
I feel like lady Gaga would be such amazing friend to Amy if she was still here 💓
She’s a class act with such empathy love Gaga 🥰
don't ever get into hard drugs. DONT
@Mind traveling Sagittarius I hope u can get out of it and stay safe.
Well done Britt. That should sort the problem out.
Weed is all you need
@@Yellowshirtmann no idc
Gaga has always been sensible and nice. Always pointing out somewhere no one could
The lady in the red is spilling all lady Gaga’s stuff 😂😂😂
she really came swinging with the "you said you've done cocaine 🤔" 😭😭😭
“I am apart of the green club sometimes” haha
Amy and Gaga give off such a similar vibe, in terms of their looks and soul
Gaga is so awesome. We need more like her.
Gaga is so amazing and classy and informed and real omg I love her so much ❤️❤️ to hear her speak so kindly on Amy 😭🥰🥰🥰
In tears. I appreciate lady gaga
Kind of insulting of Barbara to compare Gaga's dabbling with drugs to Amy's full blown addictions in order to imply that Amy might've lived if she'd just had someone tell her to "knock it off". Even in death, addicts get no respect or empathy. We're human, you know? Amy deserved better. I sure do miss her.
Lady Gaga is Amy Winehouse
I have fallen inlove with Gaga more and more over the years. I’d love to meet her 🥺
Rip Amy Winehouse what a legend 💔✌❤
It's been almost a decade since the passing of Amy Winehouse and Whitney Houston. Unbelievable
Amy's music still makes me feel better.
I think gaga looked kinda like Amy
She originally dyed her hair blonde to differentiate herself from Amy. In her early days she had dark hair and they looked like twins!
Was thinking tat
wish they could have worked together, they’re both amazing artists
I think now that Amy's passed Lady Gaga sort of was okay to venture into the space she occupied--Jazz duets with Tony Bennett and the like
Because they have the same body type^^
Gaga and Amy resembles in looks.
That was it. She had sobered up then had a bender and her sober body couldn't handle it. Most alcoholics are always drinking aka it's usually in your system. Her blood was flooded
+Hey - I agree. Amy had abused her poor body since her first eating disorder at the age of 15. Her body had gone through a lot. That is a lot of stress on your heart muscles, kidneys, liver, etc... Surprised that Charlie Sheen is still living.
+Larry;;; Yes, Charlie is alive with his aids. Add Mick Jagger to my list of "wow their body takes a lickin and dem boys are still a tickin." LOL
@@valvacious2793 mick...keith richards for sure
No she died because she had bulimia and she drank alot and her body couldn't handle it
If you watch the woman to gaga’s left, the one next to her on the right of screen, she clues on to the fact that Lady Gaga is Amy Winehouse, when the woman mentions that Winehouse is 27 that she’s 25
Amy Winehouse..I get sad every time her names pops up. I miss Amy❤️
We all miss her so much !!!
She was so hurt, heartbroken, the love of her life also encouraged substance abuse and was a substance abuser. she was in pain. do not ever accuse or blame ANYONE. anyone couldve helped her, some people encouraged her, she chose to do them, and she was in pain. there is no specific party at fault.
The addict has the brain receptors that turned "ON" and provide euphoria for the addict.
As I told my orthopedist when he told me I'd need a 7th shoulder surgery, and he asked why I do mountain biking as "Your shoulders weren't designed to take it"
I said "If I didn't mountain bike and do these athletic things, I'd be taking 700mg of Zoloft a day."
One has to find something that gives as much enjoyment as a drug but has positive, long term benefit i.e. mountain biking is great for my heart and makes me higher than any drug around.
When I was struggling to beat a 10 year addiction to intravenous amphetamines (speed) my psychiatrist said basically the same thing as you did.He said "You have to find something in your life that stimulates you as equally as the drug you're addicted to is & replace it with that".....Those words had a powerful & therapeutic effect on me & apparently he was right.Now I own 3 houses & have hundreds of thousands of dollars in the bank & the future doesn't have either death or jail staring me perennially in the face.
It didn't happen overnight, but the craving for drugs dissipated over time & I no longer feel like my life is a lesser thing for not having them in it.It's a shame Amy wasn't able to transcend her addictions & enjoy 6 or 7 more decades of a happy & drug/alcohol free life.
Literally no one was shocked but Gaga. She literally wrote a song about not going to rehab. Everyone saw it coming.
Lady Gaga could be a fantastic Amy in a biopic.
Absolutely ...I love you Lady Gaga.❤️
*"The lesson was the for world to be kinder"*
That's what it just takes for someone to be happy but I guess the highest living organisms in this damn planet couldn't do something like that.
Just imagine gaga and Amy today hadn't she passed, I think it would have been a world wind I'd give up bieber to have Amy back😘😘😘 rip pretty angel
hum... at 1:11.... Gaga's demeanor kinda says : don't you dare apply that route to my future!
Wow lady gaga speaks so elegantly. It made me think you rarely hear these artist actually speak
I’m not a Lady Gaga found but she’s extremely gentle and sincere here..
One thing has absolutely nothing to do with the other.
I wish she answered Barbara's question about how she handles the massive fame the way she does.
“people blamed her for her addiction” if she hadn’t met blake she would be here. i truly believe that.
Goodness ask one question at a time, not all at once. Ga ga handled that well.
Never knew how eloquent Lady Gaga was
They the same person... deep it... gaga blew up when amy died.. look very alike...
This Is mockery in plain sight😂
@@YUNGMAGIK333no it’s probs just delusions on your behalf. seek help.
@@prodbykotlas probably.. but do yo homework hit different
Devastating and in shock still.
Thank you Ga Ga xxx❤❤❤
I love Amy Winehouse and lady Gaga ❤️
Amy was a rare talent
im part of the green club too gaga ,thats why we are still alive,i lost friends that did what amy did ,or just booze and that kiled them ,excessand too much money
I absolutely adored Amy but seeing my close family members and friends die from addiction them selfs you can only support them self's they have to take accountability for their actions before any thing else move forward relapse is all part of the recovery but also every relapse gets harder and harder to over comb RIP Beautiful Amy
So humbling of Lady Gaga! Amy is super talented!
I love Gaga but Amy clearly had a lot to learn. And it wasn't true that Amy died from quitting cold turkey, it was over drinking.
I’m sorry I have to defend Gaga here. This was filmed a week after Amy’s death and by that time her coroner report wasn’t released. It wasn’t until late October it was clarified that Amy died of alcohol poisoning.
But I do think that Gaga was very reckless and insensitive to be throwing around gossip on national television and stating it was fact only a week after the event.
@@depressedchip2322 and that's why I CAN'T stand lady gag hoe🤷
no one can judge the past of others if they do not go through the same situations. it is easy to talk about others ..... especially about their problems and weaknesses .... have you tried to put yourself in the same shoes? no one will know what others endure in order to self-destruct .... respect for Amy.
i feel like gaga is a nice woman who means well
Amy always be remembered abt her voice and music, not abt her problems. She had a great voice
Amy is the legend! She is so unique! No doubts on that!
my two queens 🙏🏼💚
Gaga is right and found the right words , and I agree with her. I knew a pretty lot of people dying by drugs, over the years. It gets worse with age of course . Amy was not one of these toxic "girlish type people like Cyrus and her tongue cramps, Perry who looks half dead, Rhianna or equal dolls, you could replace and noone'd realize, cause they are somehow "empty" And Gaga is not that ignorant and stands out of those always envying and judging plastic dolls. And I'm sure, She has not only a better voice and artwork and is a great actress, but is far more intelligent, as these wax-like "girl's", who find themselves sexy or offending, but I am sure, no man over 15 years of age would find one of them appealing. Hope Amy is in a good place now. She was such an outstanding talent. Her father was a shady Figuren to me. Maybe she would not have tried cold Turkey, when this guy had not let her stay away from Rehab. I don't know, how the English handle it. But nothing else could have had a worst outcome!
Amy suffered with manic depression, it's not as easy to just be fine or stop an addiction when you have that. God bless her
I have manic depression and there were times I wanted to get messed up off of something just to calm it down (I went through a mixed episode and to stay calm, i binged on alcohol, marijuana, and Valium pills, basically all "downers") but then there's also the part of me that's like well do I want to be a junkie for the rest of my life and hide all my problems and substance usage or do I want to get on my way despite my condition and look for ways to stay stress-free and positive as much as possible? I'm not going to throw my life away over some mental illness. I see too many people do that and that's not the direction I want to go. It's about choices. You can choose to get help or stay miserable and fckd up on drugs or booze.
@@LittleWing1985 u do know that drug dependency is heavily genetic right? For some its easy to do a few lines of coke every week and stop after a brief moment of introspection. For others it derails much faster to other drugs and self control in no longer as easy to achieve.
Amy is also heavily theorized to have been borderline on top of manic depressive. Add there the fame, the uncountable money and the spotlight and I would bet her situation is much much harder than ur average folk.
And yet she still managed to fully stop taking any hard drug and was on the process of quitting alcohol. She died by misadventure, she actually tried and she should also be respected by that.
Amy was an exceptional talent who had mistaken the idea of being in love for true l believe she was looking for true love and had the misfortune of finding Blake. I don't believe he is to blame entirely as you don't make people do dope. But he knew exactly what heroin makes you become and admitted he should never had let her try it.It becomes your Lover and then he's just someone to get high with that she could trust. He may be hurt by all of it but if he truly had loved her he'd never be able to talk about anything The shared together. Fuck people, who cares what they think when you know the truth. We lost a beautiful , beautiful woman who is missed and will be missed forever. Rest in peace gorgeous I'll miss you also.
...why I love her.