I always found it how convenient it was that Rick found his family, let alone that fast, perhaps a good what if is, what if the group left the Quarry and Rick didn't find them, would he find them eventually? Would he go up north and become a saviour? Would he join the Governor? I find it pretty cool.
I think time wise it would be interesting if he found howes and joined the 400 days cast. His story starts just after the first season of the game ends so i think it would be neat to see him cross into the games
@@bobafett5399 problem is, the telltale games happen in the comic universe, now they could adapt the games to the show, but the characters would look slightly different and sound completely different.
I'm very impressed, I'm over half way through and have been entertained the whole time. Well structured, well told, absolutely fantastic. Another very well done story rewrite. Good job man, keep it up
What if Lee saving Sean allowed Lee and Clem to stay at the farm? They'd meet Rick's group. You could even do a little side story that shows what happened to the others. We know at least Glenn would make it out ok.
Awesome Video man ! I know it makes no sense because it was strategically perfect for Negan to take out Abraham but what if he killed Daryl instead....We wouldn't be forcing ourselves to watch him tread water in France at least. Just a thought cuz you're good at this.
3:37 Lightro: just because they survived there first death doesn't mean they get permanent plot armor 41:50 Lightro: let's kill Javier (who is the main character) so Carly can live
Andrew was my favorite prisoner. I also liked him as a villain, but I really would’ve liked if he would’ve joined the group as something of a shifty rogue.
I need a ‘WHAT IF SAM THE DOG WAS NICE’ basically it would cover what if the dog didn’t bite clementine in season 2. Sam would be like a companion and helps with stuff like wouldn’t it be so cool to have a dog with you
Shane is one of the only characters I feel didn’t get enough screen time or I wanted to see more of him it feels like he was only on the show for 3-4 episodes
The 30 days is just referring to them losing people. But it's actually about 6 months since the end of Season 3 (hence the Governor's beard, many more survivors in the prison, Morgan learning Aikido during this time, Tyreese and Karen being in a relationship, and Rick's mental health being better)
No, I don't think so. But we can assume it was some sort of failed supply run. The directors/writers did say it was 6 months in audio commentary for Episode 1 of Season 4 though.
Next what ifs for the show you could do next that I’d watch every day: What If Carl Survived? What If Glenn Survived and Negan killed Maggie at the lineup? And What If T-Dog survived?
Could you do what if carver found Clementine in season 1 I wondered how she would be like if Lee never found her but someone that was a villain in one of the stories found her
4:00 I think Shane would call them all liars and look to dominate the house I don’t think he would leave and I don’t think Lori would go with him and he knows that He needs to take the house or he needs to use the rest of those people as shields until he finds another
I feel like the group would have never made it to Alexandria in this timeline. Since they hadn’t met Abraham’s group they had no reason to go to DC, so they would’ve stayed in Georgia. In the canon timeline Aaron found them after a couple weeks or maybe months of them migrating towards DC and he wouldn’t have been recruiting that far from Alexandria. Also the prison would’ve been a toss up of a win, even though Woodbury had more soldiers, and our survivors didn’t have as many guns as the original timeline Woodbury also didn’t have a tank, and our group had more survivors than the original attack so theirs a chance that while the prison could’ve been damaged I don’t think it would’ve been uninhabitable. Whole lot of butterfly effect stuff but that was just my own personal thoughts on it.
Without Beth getting kidnapped, they wouldn’t have ended up in Northern Virginia, and so couldn’t have met Aaron. Alexandria only happened because they decided to help Noah get home for Beth.
To be honest, there's not even a chance you're gonna see this, but I'm gonna tell you anyway because we'll it's all I can do and i tried to get member so there would be a higher chance but I had to change my card so this is a walking dead game what if and my what if is what if st John brothers weren't cannibals just hoping you see this I really like your what if and I would really like if you did this
I always found it how convenient it was that Rick found his family, let alone that fast, perhaps a good what if is, what if the group left the Quarry and Rick didn't find them, would he find them eventually? Would he go up north and become a saviour? Would he join the Governor? I find it pretty cool.
I think time wise it would be interesting if he found howes and joined the 400 days cast. His story starts just after the first season of the game ends so i think it would be neat to see him cross into the games
@@bobafett5399 problem is, the telltale games happen in the comic universe, now they could adapt the games to the show, but the characters would look slightly different and sound completely different.
@@bobafett5399Can’t do that, Telltale games takes place within the comic universe.
@@DaLegend-nz6litrue but it would still be cool as hell, also i was thinking of this from a comic rick perspective but regardless.
Imagine if Daryl and Merle did rob the group and left like they intended to, and later got found by the Saviors
I'm very impressed, I'm over half way through and have been entertained the whole time. Well structured, well told, absolutely fantastic. Another very well done story rewrite. Good job man, keep it up
This is perfectly well said keep it up brother
I think the best what if for shane is if both him and Rick survived because if it's just shane I see him dying off pretty fast tbh
I love the thumbnail. So badass
Its from thr film sweet Virginia, pretty good film
What if Lee saving Sean allowed Lee and Clem to stay at the farm? They'd meet Rick's group. You could even do a little side story that shows what happened to the others. We know at least Glenn would make it out ok.
Awesome Video man ! I know it makes no sense because it was strategically perfect for Negan to take out Abraham but what if he killed Daryl instead....We wouldn't be forcing ourselves to watch him tread water in France at least. Just a thought cuz you're good at this.
Thanks!
Thanks for your donation! (:
Fantastically done, thank you lad.
The goat is back at it again
"And then Carol starts taking Carl and Judith" Oh..oh no...
3:37 Lightro: just because they survived there first death doesn't mean they get permanent plot armor
41:50 Lightro: let's kill Javier (who is the main character) so Carly can live
Javi literally jumped last in canon (with the exception of Tripp). Why would he let Carley go last 😭😭
Ok but what if neither shane and rick died
“I’m sorry, man. It’s not my fault. you couldn’t do it. I had to because you couldn’t and I gotta protect them. I gotta protect them.”
Andrew was my favorite prisoner. I also liked him as a villain, but I really would’ve liked if he would’ve joined the group as something of a shifty rogue.
I need a ‘WHAT IF SAM THE DOG WAS NICE’ basically it would cover what if the dog didn’t bite clementine in season 2. Sam would be like a companion and helps with stuff like wouldn’t it be so cool to have a dog with you
Shane is one of the only characters I feel didn’t get enough screen time or I wanted to see more of him it feels like he was only on the show for 3-4 episodes
22:35 Wasnt s4 placed just one month after s3 ending?
Thats why s4e1 is called “30 days without an accident”
Or am I worng?
The 30 days is just referring to them losing people. But it's actually about 6 months since the end of Season 3 (hence the Governor's beard, many more survivors in the prison, Morgan learning Aikido during this time, Tyreese and Karen being in a relationship, and Rick's mental health being better)
@ so what happened those 30 days before s4 starts? Do we know what accident? I always thought that the “accident” was loosing Andrea.
No, I don't think so. But we can assume it was some sort of failed supply run. The directors/writers did say it was 6 months in audio commentary for Episode 1 of Season 4 though.
Next what ifs for the show you could do next that I’d watch every day: What If Carl Survived? What If Glenn Survived and Negan killed Maggie at the lineup? And What If T-Dog survived?
Day one asking for what if Luke survived 🙏🏽🙏🏽
I need to know Scott’s fate in this version of the story
Could you do what if carver found Clementine in season 1
I wondered how she would be like if Lee never found her but someone that was a villain in one of the stories found her
Amazing
4:00 I think Shane would call them all liars and look to dominate the house
I don’t think he would leave and I don’t think Lori would go with him and he knows that
He needs to take the house or he needs to use the rest of those people as shields until he finds another
I feel like the group would have never made it to Alexandria in this timeline. Since they hadn’t met Abraham’s group they had no reason to go to DC, so they would’ve stayed in Georgia. In the canon timeline Aaron found them after a couple weeks or maybe months of them migrating towards DC and he wouldn’t have been recruiting that far from Alexandria. Also the prison would’ve been a toss up of a win, even though Woodbury had more soldiers, and our survivors didn’t have as many guns as the original timeline Woodbury also didn’t have a tank, and our group had more survivors than the original attack so theirs a chance that while the prison could’ve been damaged I don’t think it would’ve been uninhabitable. Whole lot of butterfly effect stuff but that was just my own personal thoughts on it.
Got an idea for a video, what if the group joined Negan after terminus.
Can you plz do what if rick and shane both survived.
Without Beth getting kidnapped, they wouldn’t have ended up in Northern Virginia, and so couldn’t have met Aaron. Alexandria only happened because they decided to help Noah get home for Beth.
Day 2 asking for what if Luke survived 🙏🏽
10:14 epic edit 😂😂😂
What would have happened if Telltale's The Walking Dead story took place in the beta version of the game?
Day 3 of asking what if Luke survived 🙏🏽
damn milton got done dirty
What if Ben survived?
Do one for Morgan or the governor
Can we get a what if Luke survived?
nothing would really change i feel like since he died in the last episode
To be honest, there's not even a chance you're gonna see this, but I'm gonna tell you anyway because we'll it's all I can do and i tried to get member so there would be a higher chance but I had to change my card so this is a walking dead game what if and my what if is what if st John brothers weren't cannibals just hoping you see this I really like your what if and I would really like if you did this
3:36
What if the group never met Christa and omid
What if Clem met Christa instead of Lilly in season 4
What if Clem met Christa instead of Kenny in season 2
Please do what if about Luke
What if Jane survived
ALL I SEE IS RED
What if Lightro wrote telltales the walking dead season 5 and please do not let it be like the Clem comics it’s very overrated
9th
🙄 yeah, no.
Everyone would have died. Shane would most likely join Negan if it even got that far, which is unlikely. The series would have sucked. The end.
Definitely not lol. Highly recommend watching because it takes an approach you wouldn't expect.
What ifs are just dumb to me. Sorry
Somebody who criticizes someone else's hard work is dumb to me 😢
What if Jane survived