Not really an urgent issue as there are upcoming electric trains, loads of flights and tons of express buses that serve both cities well. The high speed train is just a luxury and will still take about 1 and a half hours to both cities as opposed to 30-35 minutes by flight and flights are way cheaper. Let's not forget there is a super excellent highway system that connects Singapore to KL in about 3 hours plus.
This is how the 2 neighbor countries should do. Work together for the benefits of both countries. These 2 countries are like brothers and occasionally they may have some disagreements and disputes but at the end, working together is still better than fighting each other. Good for them.
Timestamps (Powered by Merlin AI) 00:05 - Singapore and Malaysia to collaborate on a massive economic hub. 00:29 - Malaysia and Singapore's economic zone aims to boost investment and job creation. 01:00 - Singapore and Malaysia's economic collaboration fosters complementary growth. 01:31 - AI and data centers to drive economic growth. 01:46 - Data centers will boost job creation with a multiplier effect. 02:04 - New initiatives aim to ease congestion at the busy Singapore-Malaysia border. 02:31 - Malaysia's political stability and challenges in economic development. 02:52 - Singapore and Malaysia advance plans for a special economic hub.
This is the third or fourth time I heard about economic zone with both countries, the first starting with growth triangle proposed by Goh Chok Tong and the last one before was the Iskandar. If it works, it would have worked a long time ago
Back then, trade wars and tariffs weren't a major problem. The world is fragmenting into different fractions and to make it worse, Trump is all about protectionism. Do you think Singapore can remain competitive with its limited size, population and resources?
@@Ken-nv2hl Hong Kong was very prosperous up until the political turmoil and China takeover. This same situation is very unlikely to happen in Singapore.
@@akane8615 they are going to lose a diversified economy. HK used to have a diversified economy representing 40% of China's GDP now it's down to 3%, as it just focused on a service economy in the finance industry and willing to lose all other industries. This will only work out in Singapore's favour if they attract highly skilled workers from all of Malay to live in the special economic zone and buy out the whole area along with its citizens essentially brain draining Malay.
I'm an international PhD student based in Singapore. In 2023, 2 months after moving here, I realized that Singapore-Johor-Riau is a de facto metropolitan area whose persistent border regime doesn't allow shared, regional planning. A SEZ is a no brainer, as well as a Special Ecological Zone to mitigate climate change, projected shared CO2 emissions, and to diversify Strait of Johor's economy
It’s technically and grammatically correct. ‘Most developed’ is a relative description, not absolute. Malaysia is not a developed country, but it is among the most developed in SEA. I thought Singaporeans had better education than us, didn’t think I would need to explain this to a Singaporean. But I suppose not all Singaporeans have a solid grasp of English 😂
@@rezzyg77 😂. Well, my point is you don't brag when you are the prettiest among a group of aunties. It's technically correct to say Malaysia is 2nd most developed in ASEAN but we all know all ASEAN countries are not developed except SG. I know Malaysians love to say Brunei is richer than SG, that's not true. Malaysians have problems with IQ and a sense of where they stand. 😂. Btw Sg English is definitely better than Malaysia in general. Again you are delusional.b
“Access to cheaper labour” sums up the Corporation of Singapore. Why hire qualified Singaporeans when you can just get cheaper labour from abroad? The worst part is much of the cheap labour isn’t even vetted properly and companies just end up hiring bums because managers are too lazy to conduct interviews
“These foreigners [- including dodgy permanent residents (PRs)] - are here [in Singapore] to contribute economically & who will want to come to Singapore if we subject them to the conscription & lifelong reservist liability which we compel onto all our local lads, regardless of how many male children the parents conceive? [...] THEY WILL LEAVE”! - 楊康海 (good riddance) Thank you very much for making all the males of காசிவிஸ்வநாதன் “city, not country” சண்முகம் look like FOOLS - now, I wonder what the abbreviations “NSF” & “NSman/NSmen” stand (no pun intended) for. However, MALE Singaporean ஜனில் ஆருஷா புதுச்சேரி cares about this concern as much as he does about his father in 冷藏行動 as well as why his father was banned from entering Singapore until less than three years after 光譜行動.
Dulu indonesia berencana membangun kawasan ekonomi khusus di pulau rempang batam krn dinilai letaknya yg strategis dan bisa membuka lapangan pekerjaan.. tpi krn terkendala berbagai masalah jdi nya proyek di hentikan... semoga saja indonesia khususnya batam bisa segera bersaing sama negara tetangga... apalagi ini malaysia - singapura sudah ber kolaborasi membuat kawasan ekonomi di perbatasan.. jangan sampai wilayah perbatasan indonesia makin terlihat tertinggal... hhhehehehee
Aku pikir Singapura merasa lebih nyaman bekerja sama dengan Malaysia, tapi jika Indonesia dapat menunjukkan bahwa mereka dapat beroperasi dengan lebih sedikit korupsi dan lebih serius dalam menangani investor asing, ini dapat memperkuat kemitraan dan ekonomi kedua negara secara signifikan!
@@SuryaSurya-re3vn indonesia rencana buat kawasan ekonomi bersama china untuk membangun pabrik kaca terbesarr bukan sama malaysia maupun singapura hhahhaa
Lebih baik langsung saja dibuat frameworknya untuk mengikutsertakan Batam (Kep. Riau) ke dalam wilayah ekonomi khusus SG-Johor. Hal ini akan menguntungkan semua pihak.
@@leealex24 If it is between JHR & SG, then why not the SEZ is discussed solely with Mentri Besar Johor? Whereas the many rounds of SEZ negotiations has been between Federal Ministers with SG
@@firstsealord Johor is part of Malaysia. And, especially in important matters. If Thailand southern state want to discuss key matters with Malaysia northern states, it has to go through federal govt as well. This is basic, you don't even understand.
@leealex24 you actually do not understand, the federal and state list under malaysian constitution to say there are only two stakeholders (JHR & SG) in the SEZ is totally far from right understanding
@@firstsealord No. Every state in Malaysia is governed by Federal govt, only certain provisions and rights for the state. That's why, 90% of taxes of every state in Malaysia goes to the Federal govt first. Please don't embarrass yourself.
All thanks to US inside from those dual citizenship of Tel Aviv to commit a terrorist act of explosion to blame on each other. That will be plot twist of the scheme conspiracy.
Malaysia could open a special zone for Singaporeans to buy unsold houses in Forest City with a special scheme and cheaper prices. This scheme would allow Singaporeans to stay in Malaysia for 15 years. That would be a win-win for both countries.
Actually Johor and Malaysia is safer than most European countries. Singapore can be considered safest statistically with Japan in there. And Singapore is an outlier in that.
bodoh or what? malaysia is still considered one of the most peaceful countries on earth. just last year we are at 10th on global peace index just above canada
Wonder how it is going to work. Singapore has robust labour laws to protect equality while Malaysia has entrenched racist laws to give unwarranted privileges to ethnic Malays
Funny that Singapore racist law is set to maintain 70% of the Chinese population. Chinese privilege is so rampant which contributes to their worst GINI coefficient aka wealth distribution. There is no protection in Singapore's labour law because there is no min wage and you're expected to work till you die. Moreover, Singapore's employees are not eligible to withdraw all their CPF money. This is because all the CPF is under the bond of Singapore 190% National Debt.
On top of coming single new rts likely both need at least 2 more add on Rts train connectivity between selected johor districts and Singapore before 2028😊
This area is not some undeveloped land. It is filled with housing estates, factories and towns. This won't benefit the locals in the long run. Cost of living in the area is already high. And it will also lead to development of whatever green spaces are left. If Singapore needed space to develop, go ahead and develop Sentosa Island
yes.. im johorean. the rent rate is very high. the same price i paid at JB, i can get better place in Cyberjaya,Selangor which is also a growing zone. most time they always target internationals and those expats. rarely locals
Singapore is the sucker in the deal, soon more and more businesses will move to Johor for cost efficiency supported by this SEZ draining Singapore. Even in the China SEZ China was the winner.
the difference is Singapore has good marketing. its know for good system and so on. Singapore is also known for startup companies to grow. these sentiments will be always part of singapore which Johor so far still not has same brand. Even jf the deal in Johor is better, but the trust will play bigger role. Ppl trust singapore as a country more than Johor as a state.
Management and expertisee. Do you know how many smart people migrate to Singapore? A lot. Singapore has experience handling tech stuff.. Johor is still newbie.
@@jengoh3826 Also the propserity from neighbouring countries will help to provide safety for Singapore too. Like Malaysia is surrounded by some unstable countries like southern Thai, souther philipine and some parts of Indo. These places are know for low economy activity. What happen to Malaysia states nearby? Flooded by them lol..
Before any of u children arguing in the comments for unrelated topic or criticising govt policy, just think of 5 countries that u feel better than malaysia in general category (tax rate, living expenses, safety, human right, health support, diversity) im sure its more than plenty but would u move there, or to be specific..can you? If u think malaysia racist..lol try live in those countries.
Sorry but Thailand wins this. Muslim Malay can become prime minister of Thailand. Non-Muslim and non-Malay can never become prime minister of Malaysia. There is a flood of Malay people working in Bangkok now since 2022. Most of them previously worked in Malaysia. It shows Thai economy is doing better. Medical facilities? Do you have examples? I only hear of all the good Malaysian doctors emmigrating to Australia. If human rights are so good, why are Sarawak people demanding more recognition? Safety? My friend went to Johor Baru and got his car windows smashed, passport stolen. Another friend got robbed at knifepoint by 2 guys on a motorcycle.
Apa2 pun untuk majukan kawasan johor / singapura mesti rancang dengan teliti , baik dan sempurna ,,,,,tanah yang di gunakan ada lah tanah kerajaan negeri johor ,,,,, apa2 keuntungan mesti berpihak pada kita dulu ,,,,,dari segi tanah termasuk teknology tinggi ,,,, jangan jadi macam perjanjian air johor / singapura ,,,,,, jadi kan ini tauladan buat kita semua ,,,, kalau kita gagal berbuat demikian seluruh dunia akan kata kita bodoh ,,,,, zaman dah berubah ,,,,,,tq
Perjanjian air mmg win-win pun. kau pikit Sultan Johor dulu tu bagi free2 ke?? Kesultanan Johor modern tu business family yee.. kita jual murah, kita beli air terawat pun murahh banding dgn harga pasarann. Singapore siap kena selanggara tebing air tuu tauu. Lpstuu, Singapore pun tkde la jahat sgtt. dia tau Johor jual mur2, tu dia tlg la bangunkan negeri johor. bawak masuk pelabur luar ke Johor. tepek muka singapore org percaya la sikitt. kalau stkt muka Johor, sape je kenal? letk muka Malaysia pulak org mcm was2.
But this one only focus on Johor state unlike other project like HSR. If only focus on Johor, its open secret there is hidden figure who play a big role. Tbh, this project will generate a lot of wealth for those who involve. im pretty sure Johor gov will work for it lol. If federal wants to bother, i think there will be some issue between someone with the federal laa
I am impressed that both sides have such open minded, wisdom -to cooperate instead of Hostilities at Russia as instigated by USA Dementia cum Senile leader.
More opportunities for scammer n loan sharks n pretty long legged chickens? 😂 Bravo to both neighbours. Hope Trumpet won't be jealous or sanction these old neighbours 😂
it depends lol. Malay shld step up the game. tbh many johoreans work in singapore for years. it ahld no be a problem for Bumis to involve more in other stuff or to improve their study. Also with this stuff, Bumis will have chance to involve in the development or industry and might as well learn how to run it
just bcs we are afraid to lose some lamd so we choose to stay low? we will nver be developed with that mentality. The fact that Malays still susah nk bayar zakat speaks a volume. u want to be helped but never bother to help😅.
Every new msia PM must announce new economic zone with SG. The SG every time just say ok. Since Abdulla Badahwi , muyiddin, Anwar except Mahathir find trouble. Every time Msia syiok ownself .
KL = high end services, including financial services and ICT design Penang = Semicon Johor = Data centres + special economic zone Sarawak = Hydrogen and renewable transition
This is such a no brainer, incredible to me there isnt high speed rail between KL and Singapore
Not really an urgent issue as there are upcoming electric trains, loads of flights and tons of express buses that serve both cities well. The high speed train is just a luxury and will still take about 1 and a half hours to both cities as opposed to 30-35 minutes by flight and flights are way cheaper. Let's not forget there is a super excellent highway system that connects Singapore to KL in about 3 hours plus.
Who is paying for it? You?
@@RodrigoJ-x4l exactly a HSR actually makes zero sense because it’s so close to each other. It’s a expensive waste of money
Exactly
HSR makes perfect sense.
This is how the 2 neighbor countries should do. Work together for the benefits of both countries.
These 2 countries are like brothers and occasionally they may have some disagreements and disputes but at the end, working together is still better than fighting each other. Good for them.
@@panyaboonc5621 I believe this would make Singapore a much more affordable country In the future hopefully 😃.
The Malaysian side tend to lag behind Singapore and that's why investors are hesitant. Also Sharia law doesn't sit well with foreigners.
i wont work with you people
@@downundabrotha you know nothing
@@downundabrothawhat sharia law? are you stupid?
Time for Malaysia, in particular Johor, to learn economic development without corruption.
As a Malaysian, I really hope so, laws and enforcement must not favor anyone.
Singapore ranks high in crony capitalism index.
@@enkryptron Is that why the state is so wealthy and successful?
Corruption in Malaysia is what hinders it's growth which is a shame because it's such a beautiful country.
LoL no ,....... without corruption developments would be very slow. Malaysian style of corruption is net positive corruptions.
Asia's people very hardworking
Singapore and Malaysia can benefit and uplift each other. Let us show the world what smart and good neighbours are like, and let's be proud of it.
Win win Mal & Sin. Peace and progress.
Timestamps (Powered by Merlin AI)
00:05 - Singapore and Malaysia to collaborate on a massive economic hub.
00:29 - Malaysia and Singapore's economic zone aims to boost investment and job creation.
01:00 - Singapore and Malaysia's economic collaboration fosters complementary growth.
01:31 - AI and data centers to drive economic growth.
01:46 - Data centers will boost job creation with a multiplier effect.
02:04 - New initiatives aim to ease congestion at the busy Singapore-Malaysia border.
02:31 - Malaysia's political stability and challenges in economic development.
02:52 - Singapore and Malaysia advance plans for a special economic hub.
bro it's a 3 minute video what do you need timestamps for
@@pokemonhacker01 How lazy and impatient some people are, right?! 😄
This is the third or fourth time I heard about economic zone with both countries, the first starting with growth triangle proposed by Goh Chok Tong and the last one before was the Iskandar. If it works, it would have worked a long time ago
Back then, trade wars and tariffs weren't a major problem. The world is fragmenting into different fractions and to make it worse, Trump is all about protectionism. Do you think Singapore can remain competitive with its limited size, population and resources?
It would work now cause Singapore needs it more today than ever before with its shortage of electricity, water, gas and land.
Definitely Malaysian will benefit more from the currency exchange back home
Malaysians should learn how to benefit from currency exchange even without sgd. Learn stock, freelance, and get all the usd as much as possible!
The whole situation sounds like Hong Kong - Shenzhen/Shanghai in the 1990s. Look at where that got Hong Kong.
@@Ken-nv2hl where Hong Kong get ?
@@Ken-nv2hl Hong Kong was very prosperous up until the political turmoil and China takeover. This same situation is very unlikely to happen in Singapore.
@@akane8615 they are going to lose a diversified economy. HK used to have a diversified economy representing 40% of China's GDP now it's down to 3%, as it just focused on a service economy in the finance industry and willing to lose all other industries. This will only work out in Singapore's favour if they attract highly skilled workers from all of Malay to live in the special economic zone and buy out the whole area along with its citizens essentially brain draining Malay.
Whatever is good for my country, I will gladly accept it.
Sort out the customs first
Is more Johor and Singapore joint co-operation economy, may Johor economy improve drastically
Everytime I hear Avril Hong's voice, I think I'm on CNA but in reality, she has already moved to Bloomberg. Good on her!
Dunno, doesn't putting a data center in that zone make it under the jurisdiction of Malaysian laws and courts?
China have been illegally using Malaysian waters and EES zones for years now and Malaysia doesn't seem to care...
Nope, the zone will be governed by its own laws, which aren’t mutually exclusive to each nation.
@@Flaminghotfire666 Technically, federal laws are above state laws, but it will most likely follow Shenzhen's SEZ model
In Malaysia states can place their own laws similar to the US, for many issues. But yes this is a SEZ, so the Federal law for SEZs apply.
Of course, it has to follow Malaysia laws, regulations - it's in Malaysian soil.
I'm an international PhD student based in Singapore. In 2023, 2 months after moving here, I realized that Singapore-Johor-Riau is a de facto metropolitan area whose persistent border regime doesn't allow shared, regional planning. A SEZ is a no brainer, as well as a Special Ecological Zone to mitigate climate change, projected shared CO2 emissions, and to diversify Strait of Johor's economy
I was expecting some news release on the signing today. Anyone know what is the latest update?
2 of the most developed countries in asean!
Malaysia is developed? LOL.
@sart3735 of coz u live in cave?
It’s technically and grammatically correct. ‘Most developed’ is a relative description, not absolute. Malaysia is not a developed country, but it is among the most developed in SEA. I thought Singaporeans had better education than us, didn’t think I would need to explain this to a Singaporean. But I suppose not all Singaporeans have a solid grasp of English 😂
@@sart3735 why so salty???
@@rezzyg77 😂. Well, my point is you don't brag when you are the prettiest among a group of aunties. It's technically correct to say Malaysia is 2nd most developed in ASEAN but we all know all ASEAN countries are not developed except SG. I know Malaysians love to say Brunei is richer than SG, that's not true. Malaysians have problems with IQ and a sense of where they stand. 😂. Btw Sg English is definitely better than Malaysia in general. Again you are delusional.b
will Johor finally have it's Shenzhen?
Johor is the new mini singapore. 😮
How would this work for crime though? Malaysia's justice system is less penalizing than SG.
what about the rising crime and murder case in Yishun singkapore?
What are the potential areas for entrepreneurship from this agreement?
“Access to cheaper labour” sums up the Corporation of Singapore. Why hire qualified Singaporeans when you can just get cheaper labour from abroad? The worst part is much of the cheap labour isn’t even vetted properly and companies just end up hiring bums because managers are too lazy to conduct interviews
pity Singaporeans in their racist tiny island shithole
“These foreigners [- including dodgy permanent residents (PRs)] - are here [in Singapore] to contribute economically & who will want to come to Singapore if we subject them to the conscription & lifelong reservist liability which we compel onto all our local lads, regardless of how many male children the parents conceive? [...] THEY WILL LEAVE”!
- 楊康海 (good riddance)
Thank you very much for making all the males of காசிவிஸ்வநாதன் “city, not country” சண்முகம் look like FOOLS - now, I wonder what the abbreviations “NSF” & “NSman/NSmen” stand (no pun intended) for.
However, MALE Singaporean ஜனில் ஆருஷா புதுச்சேரி cares about this concern as much as he does about his father in 冷藏行動 as well as why his father was banned from entering Singapore until less than three years after 光譜行動.
Dulu indonesia berencana membangun kawasan ekonomi khusus di pulau rempang batam krn dinilai letaknya yg strategis dan bisa membuka lapangan pekerjaan.. tpi krn terkendala berbagai masalah jdi nya proyek di hentikan... semoga saja indonesia khususnya batam bisa segera bersaing sama negara tetangga... apalagi ini malaysia - singapura sudah ber kolaborasi membuat kawasan ekonomi di perbatasan.. jangan sampai wilayah perbatasan indonesia makin terlihat tertinggal... hhhehehehee
Aku pikir Singapura merasa lebih nyaman bekerja sama dengan Malaysia, tapi jika Indonesia dapat menunjukkan bahwa mereka dapat beroperasi dengan lebih sedikit korupsi dan lebih serius dalam menangani investor asing, ini dapat memperkuat kemitraan dan ekonomi kedua negara secara signifikan!
Indonesia bisa belajar Singlish, dan Singapore bisa belajar bahasa Indonesia… tapi korupsi di Indonesia itu juara satu di dunia, Singapore mana mau ….
batam itu sendiri udah jadi kawasan ekonomi khusus kok.
@@SuryaSurya-re3vn indonesia rencana buat kawasan ekonomi bersama china untuk membangun pabrik kaca terbesarr bukan sama malaysia maupun singapura hhahhaa
Lebih baik langsung saja dibuat frameworknya untuk mengikutsertakan Batam (Kep. Riau) ke dalam wilayah ekonomi khusus SG-Johor. Hal ini akan menguntungkan semua pihak.
This sounds great, something I've thought about.
It won’t work, remember clob?
@@Nrylw-w6t yup. Don't trust Malaysia.
Use you upper head. It's toy different context and now it's Singapore that needs this SEZ more due to shortage of electricity, water, gas and land.
This project is really just Johor and SG, not Malaysia. Malaysia already have most important key growth hubs such as KL, Penang.
KL and Penang are shit. Many malaysians from both places want to work in SG.
@@leealex24
If it is between JHR & SG, then why not the SEZ is discussed solely with Mentri Besar Johor?
Whereas the many rounds of SEZ negotiations has been between Federal Ministers with SG
@@firstsealord Johor is part of Malaysia. And, especially in important matters. If Thailand southern state want to discuss key matters with Malaysia northern states, it has to go through federal govt as well. This is basic, you don't even understand.
@leealex24
you actually do not understand, the federal and state list under malaysian constitution
to say there are only two stakeholders (JHR & SG) in the SEZ is totally far from right understanding
@@firstsealord No. Every state in Malaysia is governed by Federal govt, only certain provisions and rights for the state. That's why, 90% of taxes of every state in Malaysia goes to the Federal govt first. Please don't embarrass yourself.
This can only work temporary, after Anwar terms, policy will change
All thanks to US inside from those dual citizenship of Tel Aviv to commit a terrorist act of explosion to blame on each other. That will be plot twist of the scheme conspiracy.
@@zenzen272 Cannot trust and do business with Malays one.
Why?
This is a G2G arrangement that will be signed between two countries which has clauses that won't change no matter the government of the day.
@theamici United States will use their proxy group to sabotage this again. Like they did against Russia with Uzbekistan.
❤Awesomeness ❤when will it happen 💡🕊🌙✨️🙏🔥🫶
Malaysia could open a special zone for Singaporeans to buy unsold houses in Forest City with a special scheme and cheaper prices. This scheme would allow Singaporeans to stay in Malaysia for 15 years. That would be a win-win for both countries.
dont be silly, sporeans not stupid to buy msian properties
@@ceeesscee7400 they already bought many commercial properties in forest city
@ceeesscee7400 I'm not referring to the PLS scheme property. 🤣🤣🤣 Real Singaporean invest in lease hold with MM2H pass 😁
How much is a 2 bed apartment in Forest City? Approximately
15 years? Not practical. it should be for as long as the property is owner occupied or when the lease expire after 99 years.
Data Centre eat a lot of electrical energy. I hope Malaysia's TNB will not incurred the cost due to subsidy given to Malaysian that use their grid.
Malaysia gotta fix all the crime in Johor first
@@CrzyD-cv8xz Get used to it, it happens more often elsewhere than inside your safety dome city-state 😂
Actually Johor and Malaysia is safer than most European countries. Singapore can be considered safest statistically with Japan in there. And Singapore is an outlier in that.
Singapore is a tiny island that is easy to govern. Malaysia's land size is over 330,000 km²
bodoh or what? malaysia is still considered one of the most peaceful countries on earth. just last year we are at 10th on global peace index just above canada
@@FrostWing-k5u Malaysia will never be "properly govern" irrespective of size if the Bumi policy does not change.
Iskandar project version 2… wonder why version 1 failed ?
Covid
project 1 was launched during covid. same as forest city. mainly bad timing.
Why is the QR code only for Malaysians? Singapore allowed both citizens
Better expect 70% that Johore will prata like they did for the HSR. Not trust worthy business partner...
Wonder how it is going to work. Singapore has robust labour laws to protect equality while Malaysia has entrenched racist laws to give unwarranted privileges to ethnic Malays
@@90taetaeya lol you think any malay gonna get special privilege as an employee in private???
stop projecting your hate towards the malays and malaysia, you're everywhere where malaysia is mentioned.
non malay always show they are stupid in the comment section, why ?
@@90taetaeya Is that why the Chinese own most private enterprises in Malaysia ?
Funny that Singapore racist law is set to maintain 70% of the Chinese population. Chinese privilege is so rampant which contributes to their worst GINI coefficient aka wealth distribution.
There is no protection in Singapore's labour law because there is no min wage and you're expected to work till you die. Moreover, Singapore's employees are not eligible to withdraw all their CPF money. This is because all the CPF is under the bond of Singapore 190% National Debt.
Batam how?
Rakyatnya ngg mau di relokasi jdi nya gatottt hhahahha pdhl dulu jga indonesia ada rencana bikin rempang eco park.. yg pabrik kaca terbesarr china itu
Good for economy
Frictioned and throttled by traffic jams, though improved significantly, going either way.
On top of coming single new rts likely both need at least 2 more add on Rts train connectivity between selected johor districts and Singapore before 2028😊
Terbaik
How much was being paid to get this info
Excellent 👍
This area is not some undeveloped land. It is filled with housing estates, factories and towns. This won't benefit the locals in the long run. Cost of living in the area is already high. And it will also lead to development of whatever green spaces are left. If Singapore needed space to develop, go ahead and develop Sentosa Island
yes.. im johorean. the rent rate is very high. the same price i paid at JB, i can get better place in Cyberjaya,Selangor which is also a growing zone. most time they always target internationals and those expats. rarely locals
Please fix the congestion at the causeway first.
Singapore is the sucker in the deal, soon more and more businesses will move to Johor for cost efficiency supported by this SEZ draining Singapore. Even in the China SEZ China was the winner.
the difference is Singapore has good marketing. its know for good system and so on. Singapore is also known for startup companies to grow. these sentiments will be always part of singapore which Johor so far still not has same brand. Even jf the deal in Johor is better, but the trust will play bigger role. Ppl trust singapore as a country more than Johor as a state.
@@Kuihkoswi Yes true for starting the game but finally Johor will be the winner.
YAAAY GOD BLESS THEM ❤✝️❤👏🏼🥰
It’s
About
Damn
Time
Literally.
Exactly!
so basically in this partnership Malaysia is providing land, resources, labour... Singapore is providing... not corruption...?
Management and expertisee. Do you know how many smart people migrate to Singapore? A lot. Singapore has experience handling tech stuff.. Johor is still newbie.
The map include Forrest City.
Sounds like Shenzhen 30 years ago
That's great
🎉🎉🎉
Like euros, someday onwards 1sgd=1myr. Look east, go east Singapore. Hooray
How will this work?
Yes, more details on the actual policies that comprise the SEZ would be helpful rather than just talking fluff about how it's a "win-win".
VEP how? Malaysia boleh
Singapore does not have any choice other than to enter into some kind of cooperation with Johor to access land that Singapore is running out of.
As a singaporean we might as well join back Malaysia
Would love to see that too
@@jengoh3826 Also the propserity from neighbouring countries will help to provide safety for Singapore too. Like Malaysia is surrounded by some unstable countries like southern Thai, souther philipine and some parts of Indo. These places are know for low economy activity. What happen to Malaysia states nearby? Flooded by them lol..
Like Hongkong and China ... 💡 who will benefit more? Businessmen and Rich for sure...
Nice Strategy
How will sg benefit from this really?
Investment 😅.. Johor is still growig economically. Obvsly Singapore ministy already think about what will they benefit from it, duhh.
The future is here
Before any of u children arguing in the comments for unrelated topic or criticising govt policy, just think of 5 countries that u feel better than malaysia in general category (tax rate, living expenses, safety, human right, health support, diversity) im sure its more than plenty but would u move there, or to be specific..can you? If u think malaysia racist..lol try live in those countries.
Sorry but Thailand wins this.
Muslim Malay can become prime minister of Thailand. Non-Muslim and non-Malay can never become prime minister of Malaysia.
There is a flood of Malay people working in Bangkok now since 2022. Most of them previously worked in Malaysia. It shows Thai economy is doing better.
Medical facilities? Do you have examples? I only hear of all the good Malaysian doctors emmigrating to Australia.
If human rights are so good, why are Sarawak people demanding more recognition?
Safety? My friend went to Johor Baru and got his car windows smashed, passport stolen. Another friend got robbed at knifepoint by 2 guys on a motorcycle.
Bro, they will never understand. They're too far brainwashed. Let them be.
Apa2 pun untuk majukan kawasan johor / singapura mesti rancang dengan teliti , baik dan sempurna ,,,,,tanah yang di gunakan ada lah tanah kerajaan negeri johor ,,,,, apa2 keuntungan mesti berpihak pada kita dulu ,,,,,dari segi tanah termasuk teknology tinggi ,,,, jangan jadi macam perjanjian air johor / singapura ,,,,,, jadi kan ini tauladan buat kita semua ,,,, kalau kita gagal berbuat demikian seluruh dunia akan kata kita bodoh ,,,,, zaman dah berubah ,,,,,,tq
Perjanjian air mmg win-win pun. kau pikit Sultan Johor dulu tu bagi free2 ke?? Kesultanan Johor modern tu business family yee.. kita jual murah, kita beli air terawat pun murahh banding dgn harga pasarann. Singapore siap kena selanggara tebing air tuu tauu.
Lpstuu, Singapore pun tkde la jahat sgtt. dia tau Johor jual mur2, tu dia tlg la bangunkan negeri johor. bawak masuk pelabur luar ke Johor. tepek muka singapore org percaya la sikitt. kalau stkt muka Johor, sape je kenal? letk muka Malaysia pulak org mcm was2.
When we have corruption-free leaders leading our countries, practically every difficult issue can be worked out.
Why is XAI211K doing so well? That is concerning to me.
Technically it’s a special economic zone between Johor and Singapore. Hire better journalists, facts matter
The biggest risk is that another Malaysian government will walk back or jeopardise this project.
But this one only focus on Johor state unlike other project like HSR. If only focus on Johor, its open secret there is hidden figure who play a big role.
Tbh, this project will generate a lot of wealth for those who involve. im pretty sure Johor gov will work for it lol. If federal wants to bother, i think there will be some issue between someone with the federal laa
Nohting but fatten those in power pocket..
By how failed was Iskandar Malaysia gone, I doubt SEZ is going to do anything.
Maybe might be a good time to invest in Forest City real estate while it's cheap
🇮🇩 Ketar Ketir gelabah tak percaya tengok nanti😂
Malaysia kicked out Singapore, but now their development is way behind Singapore. It is ridiculous!
Its actually a colonisation hub...
I am impressed that both sides have such open minded, wisdom -to cooperate instead of Hostilities at Russia as instigated by USA Dementia cum Senile leader.
not for long
not 4 long
More opportunities for scammer n loan sharks n pretty long legged chickens? 😂 Bravo to both neighbours. Hope Trumpet won't be jealous or sanction these old neighbours 😂
😊😅 0:11 😊😅
This was proposed way back when Badawi was in charge but dr m and Najib ended it citing Malays will lose their power and country.
it depends lol. Malay shld step up the game. tbh many johoreans work in singapore for years. it ahld no be a problem for Bumis to involve more in other stuff or to improve their study. Also with this stuff, Bumis will have chance to involve in the development or industry and might as well learn how to run it
just bcs we are afraid to lose some lamd so we choose to stay low? we will nver be developed with that mentality. The fact that Malays still susah nk bayar zakat speaks a volume. u want to be helped but never bother to help😅.
Every new msia PM must announce new economic zone with SG. The SG every time just say ok. Since Abdulla Badahwi , muyiddin, Anwar except Mahathir find trouble. Every time Msia syiok ownself .
This should happen 20 years ago tbh
Will be Shenzhen and HK in 50 years... Will see if SG will regret it.
I laugh. The Malays will never think like Shenzhen people.
Good move
Fifth prime minister?? 😅
I hope Singapore and Malaysia can go borderless like the Schengen Area in Europe.
This would definitely make the lives of both sides so much better and ease the hardship from the border.
it is hard todo because currency difference value
Borderless because of eventual reunification soon
@@tokroniunder Chinese leadership and dominance that is, Malaysia will cease to exist and become Sinosia.
Malaysia wanna more MONEY fr SG. Lesson never learn ??
You think Malaysian land and resources are free, is it?
Our cheap labour is considered as a win for our country? lmao
Ummm I think your comments section has been hijacked lol
If this economy zone were to go ahead will it be a company registration model like a Dubai UAE or Malaysia Labuan ？
But why let Najib go Scott free ?
Should grant the freedom of movement between two nation…to enter both immigration and custom should just using myKad and NRIC card only…
I think the problem is Singapore would face influx Malaysians entering on a whim and potential of social issues.
Cannot. bcs the movement is massive due to job seeking. This system will be abused to stay illegaly.
MURPHY'S LAW APPLY.
Singapore and Malaysia should kiss
Malaysia singapore with the love and hate relations
Dam its like 90% bots in the comments.
🙄🙄🙄
Cool
johor to SG is like kowloon to hk.
Where do you buy XAI211K?
And indonesia left to dust haha
Indonesia warganya ngg mau di relokasiii hahahahahha lihat noh proyek rempang gatott.. pdhl kan tujuanya sama 11 12 kaya gini 😅
XAI211K is going to $589
Singapore no more land..johore have land.malaysia more reliable then singapore only banker hub
INSTEAD OF DEVELOPING OTHER PARTS OF MALAYSIA, MALAYSIA LOVE TO HELP SINGAPORE DEVELOP THEIR COUNTRY. WELL DONE
KL = high end services, including financial services and ICT design
Penang = Semicon
Johor = Data centres + special economic zone
Sarawak = Hydrogen and renewable transition
Malaysia's development depends on the hardworking Chinese, while the Malays are lazy and privileged
This project is really just Johor and SG, not Malaysia. Malaysia already have most important key growth hubs such as KL, Penang.
Agree, this "economic zone" should benefit Johor first or cancel this nonsense asap!
@@shukriramlee Yes, scrap the project if it doesn't benefit Johor and Malaysia.