The Butcher Is Better | Putting an End to a Long Discussion

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 34

  • @Dudisfludis
    @Dudisfludis  25 днів тому +1

    You know, I’m still waiting for literally anyone to address what I said in the video instead of just saying something like “bad take” or arguing something else entirely.
    You’re just proving me right.

  • @Effect_FX
    @Effect_FX 28 днів тому +5

    1:22 "3 factions" oof shot through the heart
    But seriously though, the butcher is so underrated to the point of being baffling

  • @Ahw1231
    @Ahw1231 26 днів тому +1

    Forgot about this game. Going to have to re-install and see where its at. I was on this game 24/7 the first few months it was out. So many fun memories.

  • @seanmacnamara4049
    @seanmacnamara4049 10 днів тому +1

    Dude fluids

  • @a-fvs3269
    @a-fvs3269 28 днів тому +3

    Minus 273 kelvins take
    Also, the butcher is probably a more enjoyable gun to acquire since you have a more diverse lmg arsenal to play with instead of the Orion, a worse Anchor and the rest.

  • @redtsun67
    @redtsun67 26 днів тому

    I find that the majority of people who say "[X] weapon is OP" have never even used said weapon before. Specifically the directive weapons. Sat in platoon once listening to a guy with 0.70 k/d go on and on about how the BG was way too strong and that they needed to nerf it, only for him to immediately admit that he's never even played VS. Like brother, how are you gonna sit there and say a weapon is OP when you have never even used it?

  • @BlackRodger
    @BlackRodger 27 днів тому +1

    Betel/Orion are gonna be better for direct 1v1's thanks to much better hipfire (especially Betel with it's bugged laser sight) but it's planetside, playing live server Butcher will always be comfy gun to use, Butcher will always be better on pointholds and pushes.
    Personally I don't think there's even that many cases when you need 300 rounds, 150 is plenty, it's veeeery rare that you have to spend whole 150 rounds without getting any downtime to reload, and if really needed one can run scavenger for all of those rounds back on revive.

    • @Stanislav-i5s
      @Stanislav-i5s 26 днів тому

      Bugged laser sight?

    • @BlackRodger
      @BlackRodger 26 днів тому

      @@Stanislav-i5s Betel has bugged laser sight, it gives 40% instead of 33%, and Orion already has one of the best lmg hipfires so it makes it ever so slightly bit too strong for 1v1's imho

    • @Dudisfludis
      @Dudisfludis  24 дні тому

      1) Butcher can run a laser if you’re fine with 150 rounds. Not as good as the Betelgeuse for hipfire though, sure.
      2) Butcher range and Betelgeuse range is basically the same as I establish fairly well in the video.
      3) You’re right that there aren’t many situations where you actually do need 300 rounds. And, as I point out in the video, that also means there aren’t many situations where someone needs 7 magazines worth of Betelgeuse.

    • @BlackRodger
      @BlackRodger 24 дні тому

      @@Dudisfludis Yeah, I found cutting that massive hipfire cof by 30% to improve both ads time and hipfire is much more beneficial than boosting already massive mag.
      There's no argument on range though, I don't think I phrased it in that way, like you said, they have same ads stats and easy to deal with recoil. It's the close range 1v1 fights that might give you better edge with betel, but again, it's almost never 1v1's anyways.

  • @HeftyBandit
    @HeftyBandit 25 днів тому

    Ignoring the fact that betel has higher headshot multiplier, no bulletdrop, infinite ammo, and its VS!!!! This is ludicrous.

  • @xWHITEx
    @xWHITEx 28 днів тому

    As a VS main, I have all 4 ARX LMGs, with over 3,000 frags on all of them except Gallilei, and I'll say that TRs really underestimate Butcher. It's one of the few guns in the game that can stop a crowd if positioned correctly. However, most TRs are tied to the MSW-R, which, along with the Orion, GD-22, Anchor and Maw, are essentially heavy assault rifles, not LMGs.
    The Watchman could also compete with the Butcher if it had at least 200 rounds in the magazine, but its reload time is just awful.
    But I still think the Godsaw is the best machine gun in the game.

  • @MoonzTJ
    @MoonzTJ 26 днів тому

    2KD VS heavys falling to their knees finding out the Betelguese isnt the best gun in the game :)

  • @ZealousVidya
    @ZealousVidya 27 днів тому +3

    The time it takes to switch back to a butcher after utility/launcher/pistol seems like a pain. *if it has extended mag - same for other weapons with ext mag
    Secondly, as you partially pointed out, 99% of players are not going to be killing more than two people per life, let alone chain killing enough people that the lower ammo pool is a factor. Shield regen delay and chip damage is far more important for pacing than ammo for 99% of players.
    Third, as you briefly mentioned people mainly blame weapons as cope; the weapon isn't that important. Go aimlabs and get a 40% hsr/acc if you really care that much.
    On the other hand, something I didn't see mentined is with many NC and TR weapons(butcher included) you have the ammo to pre-fire into a corner/room which arguably has a lot of value for the average planetman.

  • @HPmcDoogle
    @HPmcDoogle 26 днів тому +1

    The betelgeuse is bullshit, but the Butcher will always be Better bullshit.
    Fuck VS anyway though.

  • @plasma5656
    @plasma5656 28 днів тому +1

    you didn't mention it shoots faster

    • @Dudisfludis
      @Dudisfludis  27 днів тому +2

      @@plasma5656 This is because adding such a small RPM difference doesn’t really change the TTK to any degree really worth mentioning as a strong point. But, yes, it does fire faster.

  • @littletweeter1327
    @littletweeter1327 27 днів тому

    hello? based department?

  • @bluepaperclipfastens3559
    @bluepaperclipfastens3559 26 днів тому

    Butcher has too much muzzle flash. Hate that trash weapon. Luv mswr, betel

    • @Dudisfludis
      @Dudisfludis  25 днів тому

      Maybe I’m missing something because in the video I have none.

  • @chrisstinson3250
    @chrisstinson3250 28 днів тому +6

    Look at the millstream going on in this video. If this was infiltrator there'd be thousands of comments, screaming for nerfs.

    • @Dudisfludis
      @Dudisfludis  27 днів тому +6

      Weird to bring up infiltrator when discussing LMGs, but ok bro…
      Can heavy assault go almost completely invisible so you can get ignored and hide mid-fight or are you just one of those infil mains inhaling that military grade copium I was talking about?
      Do you play with more than 40fps?
      Do you use infiltrator 98% of the time you play?
      Can you get any kills in the game without waiting for someone to look away from you then uncloaking and shooting them in the back because they never saw where your potted plant looking dude was?
      Edit: Liking your own comment is pretty cringe by the way.

  • @Hopkai
    @Hopkai 26 днів тому

    This is obviously such a non biased video. It really does not have nothing to do with hating the TR much. Pot.Kettle.Black.

    • @Dudisfludis
      @Dudisfludis  26 днів тому

      @@Hopkai Explain how I’m wrong then.

  • @Grethko
    @Grethko 27 днів тому

    TR wins again

  • @BaBaNaNaBa
    @BaBaNaNaBa 28 днів тому

    no suprise there, most TR players were always braindead

  • @mg-jf5ld
    @mg-jf5ld 28 днів тому

    But the Betelgeuse has no bullet drop, Vanu OP plz nerf

  • @BaBaNaNaBa
    @BaBaNaNaBa 28 днів тому

    also msr-w is just objectively the best LMG. TR just salty plebs