+Pellazget 123 You are possibly the most annoying person I've ever seen on UA-cam. What's wrong with you? Go and gain your own achievements instead of trying to leach off the past. Seriously, nobody cares.
+Pellazget 123 1. At what point did I put forth an argument? 2. You've made a load of claims in this comment section without a shred of evidence. The burden of proof is on you. 3. Nobody gives a shit about Albania.
17:40 Those rotating rectangles made me laugh way harder than they should. Amazing how much character you can show just with basic shapes and speech bubbles.
He should of made some spin around and others go back and forth or side to side. Or make lots of tiny little pink dots or squares walking around like a busy market.
It is good that you released the video right now. I have something to watch and can stop researching this topic - was meaning to get in Alexander business. :-)
@@demilung I find it difficult that all of this, to this level of detail, were documented through stone carvings(the only form of documentation back then) and it is most likely his personal speculation. His description of that battle was completely nonsensical.
Almost all material on Alexander the Great focuses on the Persian campaign so its really awesome to get more on other battles he fought. Especially since so many of Alexander's battle strategies are so audacious
This is what I was told about that episode at Delphi. The word in Greek(which I don't remember, sorry) the oracle called Alexander meant something like "arrogant" or "brash", but could also be interpreted as "great". Now guess which way Alex took it.
@@ΠαναγιώτηςΜ-ξ2ζ He didn't lose a battle, parts of it to adapt and completenwith afjust d approach, many times. Similar to aniva and the Romans in a battle before Chanae.
And all of the other background music (the "dududududn dun dun dun" low hum drums) during narration - same vibes with Caesar's series! Just found out he cited all the songs in the descriptions, this is the outro - ua-cam.com/video/DFLnx9m4cgU/v-deo.html
@@Omar_ayach *man takes living tanks across mountains losing most but still getting one giving him a massive advantage tactically* HE DIDNT KNOW MOUNTAIN BAD REEEEEE
I want to say good job sir. I had a 9 Hour Drive today and binge watching your channel (listening) Made it seem very short. Excellent presentation and superb topics selection
You're doing great work, great delivery, noting when something that happened is uncertain, neat animations and I particularly love that you're keeping everything "dry" and not trying to make everything overly dramatised. Keep up the good work!
Seriously, I’m really not a fan of overly dramatic retellings. I can’t watch most documentaries for that reason. This style of video making is so much better
@John Toas it's so sad that generation Z is the most libertarian, and conservative generation in American history. As much independent, conservative, liberal, and libertarian studies have concluded. And how the republicans, have even more control, over the Senate, and the "blue wave" has failed miserably. and the house doesn't have as much importance, as much as you think, or feel it does. Or how the unemployment rate is at a 49 year low, and thousands of jobs have been created. or as 11 steel and metal factories have been opened, and 28 are on the way, in the next year alone. And 68% of Hispanics, say they have it better now, then 2 years ago in 2016. Boohoo, you Americans have it so bad down there, there's no way you can live now. Unlike let's say Europe, Australia, and canada, where "hate speech" has been censored.
I'd like to think that Alexander was so unnerved by the never before thought about prospect of the sky falling down that afterwards he was like "Can you believe those Gauls disrespecting me like that I mean I think they just made that stuff up!"(glances nervously up at the sky)
Well the sky is literally gasses and when compressed they turn into liquid so when it rains the sky is literally falling on our heads. I'll take my chances and grovel at the Macedon boy' feet.
Superb! As someone who has read extensively on Alexander, 'The Siege of Pellium' has often been the most problematic to visualise. This video is an absolute credit to the ancient historians who preserved Alexanders history and must have been painstaking. Only one small piece of constructive criticism though: the delegation of Celts is said to have arrived after Alexanders victory on the Danube and before the Illyrian campaign.
There were no fucking Gauls in modern day Albania at the time.. it was Illyrian territory.. He should have referred to them as Celts.. not Gauls... and he most likely encountered them near the danube.. where the were actual Celts.
Alexander might have been the most privileged child of all time and he used everything that he was given to dominate pretty much everything in his path for about 12 years. He made Greece the most unified it'd ever been since the Myceneans and then made the seemingly vast and powerful Persia submit. The only thing that stopped him was that he just kept winning. A good loss helps you consolidate inventory and he spread his lines way too thing just to get to India. If he survived the return home I have no doubt that both Carthage and the Roman Republic would have fallen. If he made it to like 60 his empire would have been like, most of Europe, all of North Africa, the entire Middle East, and parts of Central/North Asia. Would have loved to see how he counters the Steppe tribes and their superior cavalry. Legendary life, him, Napoleon, Caesar and Ghengis Khan were all crazy as fuck but beautifully tuned to warfare.
Imagine being part of that army: "Yo we are just gonna run drills" "all right" "Use our siege weapons as artillery" "if you say so, this shit all seems to work out every time"
I hate hearing that music at the end. Not because its a bad song on the contrary but, alas because its the end of the video and i have to wait another 3 centuries for you to release the next one!
the logistics of his conquest alone are absolutely staggering.. But his army's discipline, adaptability, mixed with his cunning and his ability to see the changes on the battlefield is amazing. This is why we still talk about the man today.
You should cover Alexander's Bactrian & Sogdian campaign. A perfect example of one of the toughest and most difficult anti-guerilla campaigns in history.
In the Illryian ambush Alexander's Dad reached out of the grave to saved his kid, by creating that ultra trained army which could act with such timed precision. It took some creative thinking, which served Alexander throughout his life, and he definitely learned from that encounter. I think it's hard to argue though, that if the Illyrian's and Alexander's places been reversed the Illyrians would not have gotten the same effect from using that crazy ass strategy.
DM: You find yourself surrounded by Illyrian rebels. Do you flee through the pass or cross the river? Alexander: I roll to intimidate. DM: Okay, but you'll have to roll at least- Alexander: Natural 20.
@mugur de fluier Alexander III of Macedon (Greek: Αλέξανδρος Γʹ ὁ Μακεδών; 20/21 July 356 BC - 10/11 June 323 BC), commonly known as Alexander the Great (Ancient Greek: Ἀλέξανδρος ὁ Μέγας, romanized: Aléxandros ho Mégas), was a king (basileus) of the ancient Greek kingdom of Macedon[a]
Some have complained that these videos take slightly longer to produce, but keep in mind he is making them around 20 minutes, so he is not shortening us on our doses of education drugs
Usually being told that you're invincible, sarcastically or not back then and believing it; you'd act more reckless, which he sort of did but I got this feeling that Alexander also at some point thought "Well if *_I'm_* invincible, that doesn't mean my troops are so I gotta plan carefully lest I stand alone an immortal victor on an empty battlefield." or something like that. Could be why he wins.
Your videos are a delight to see. Each time I see an upload of your videos I grab popcorn and watch you take events from times past and make them sound as if it just happened. It also helps how you occasionally throw in a joke or two Really makes not enjoying your videos difficult. I remember going to a summer camp and I began throwing references to Roman politics and battles. And than this other guy started getting the references. We talked some more and it turns out we where both watching a channel called historical civilis. For the rest of the two weeks that I was there people referee to me and the other guy as walking encyclopedias but I must confess that the only reason I know any of this is because I watched your videos at summer school ironically learning more about Rome than the Washington state history I was supposed to be learning. The only reason I made it through summer school with my sanity intact is because you could take something obscure like Roman elections, and make it interesting beyond reason. So I feel the need to say thank you for making your videos
I think Aleander was drilling his army to survive rockfalls, and the wagon attack was similar enough to use same tactics. It's all just speculation, though.
@@maybemaeb Do the sources mention how many wagons? The width of the front? At this time he just had 1000 men right? So it doesn't take too much space. It seems like they also could've side stepped them or the wagons fell off before reaching them by bouncing on random rocks.
Well it doesn’t take long for one to simply go duck and search for cover when something is falling towards you, and whatever the problem is someone who’s much of a genius as Alexander would’ve probably done it better.
The most disciplined were the Spartans. And after that other southern Greeks. The macedonian phallanx was designed taking into account the fact that they couldn't train infantry as well as southern greeks. this was one of the reasons for Phillip making the modifications he made with the macedonian phallanx. of course it also had great advantages. But with the other phallanxes ( Spartan, Athenian, Theban) more training and discipline were required for good functioning of the phallanx.
again a history channel focussing on alexander, and still it's unique and top quality content, this is great also 'they swished their sarissas'', what did it sound like, can you describe it more?
lol. I'm more impressed that the drilling, which was basically just a massive interpretive dance, actually scared the Illyrians away. It's like, "wow these guys have really sick dance moves. Imma' leave out of respect."
maybe they just left because it took so long, they where tired or hungry, or maybe just horny and there was a village with protitues nearby, we'll never know
I'm curious if you are at the point where it would be prudent to pay someone to animate your videos so you could release them faster? (Not offering, just love your content and wish there was more of it.)
You know, some people blame the fall of Persia not to Alexander but just to the instability of the empire... this entire campaign proves them wrong. Alexander was a genius.
Trygve Plaustrum Persia was weakend after the greco-persian wars They lost darius and xerxes because of it (And lets be honest darius the III wasn.t the most competent persian ruler they had) But still it was one of the biggest super powers of ancient antiquity Alongside rome, seleucids, parthia, sassanids
While Persia had suffered defeats to the Greeks earlier, it was still unquestionably the biggest superpower in the Mediterranean world in Alexander's time. Their huge advantage in resources compared to the Macedonians is clearly illustrated by the course of Alexander's campaign. The Persians were initially able to assemble an army roughly as large as Alexander's just from Asia Minor for the Battle of the Granicus. Then Darius was able to assemble a force twice as large as Alexander's for Issus, then another army at least as large for Gaugamela, and could well have raised a third if his satraps had stayed loyal, all despite suffering massive losses at each battle. Alexander, by contrast, would never have had the resources to rebuild his entire army if he had suffered a similar defeat. Alexander did have a very effective, well-trained force to face the larger Persian armies, but it still required a commander of his genius to overcome his disadvantages and win each of those battles, let alone maintain a multi-year campaign that involved fighting all three major battles in succession without suffering crippling losses at any of them.
A good portion of Persian troops were levied farmboys not worth shit... Training men to become warriors is much more expensive and time-consuming than forcibly conscripting civilians in your army with little to no pay. Alexander's achievements are great but many people seem to overestimate Persia here, the Achaemenid Empire was declining and morale was low after consecutive defeats, plus an incompetent idiot was at the head. As HC said, Alexander was lucky. If he was born during the same era as say, Darius I, who was at the very least capable of keeping his empire in 1 piece, things wouldn't have gone so smoothly.
These videos are so interesting to watch. Not one moment when I thought I would want to skip a part. Please, keep up with the quality, these are awesome
On this occasion, he [Alexander] made a very long speech to the Thessalians and the other Greeks, and when he saw that they encouraged him with shouts to lead them against the Barbarians, he shifted his lance into his left hand, and with his right appealed to the gods, as Callisthenes tells us, praying them, if he was really sprung from Zeus, to defend and strengthen the Greeks. [Plutarch. Alexander (ed. Bernadotte Perrin) XXXIII
Gannis, ALEZANDROY TITLE OF ALBANIA, ALEZANDROY TITLE MEANINGS, ALBANIA ALE ZAN TROY, GREECE MEGALO KATARTITI, INGLES GREAT CONQUEROR, ALEZANDROY BILONGS TO ALBANIA.
I love the special effects of your troop movements and the well coordinated battlescenes you give us. It so much better done than any other Hollywood movie.
Pellazget 123 Alexander was not Illyrian nor was he Albanian. There was no such thing as Albanians back and then. And nor are they Illyrians. He was Greek. Please stop spreading your propaganda. It is getting really annoying
Pellazget 123 Hes mother was Epirotan Greek and hes was Greek Macedonian not Albanian not Illurian. And Epirus is Greek not Albanian. Greece was formed in 1821 that's true, but that doesn't mean that they weren't Greek people living before that. Greeks are by far the oldest race in Europe.
I don't want these video to come up every 3 days or anything, but at this rate we'll only get 12 videos a year, a slightly faster upload rate would be more fruitful in my opinion.
It's nice that you made the balkan campaign of Alexander, but there are already 2 chanells who covers Alexander campaigns. I think Caesar deserve a complete series. You finished the gallic wars... please start the civil war
+The Equalizer There was a battle during the balkans campaign against the thracians in which Alexander was fighting up a slope and the phalanx had dozens of carts rolled down at them and Alexander ordered his soldiers to lay on the ground and hold their shields up so that the carts just harmlessly passed over.
Tony, i know. The battle was presented here. If Historia Civilis will do videos on Alexander, i hope he doens't make the usual Granicus, Issus, Gaugamela and Hydaspes but the unknown campaigns and battles of Alexander.
+The Equalizer Yeah when people think of alexander they only remember gaugamela or the hydaspes battles. Jaxartes, Arigaeum, Halicarnassus,Tyre, Aornos, Gaza, Cophen campaign, etc don't nearly get as much coverage unfortunately.
I think for almost a year or more I've been searching this particular clip which I watch and forgot and was so desperate to watch again. I found it tonight
In 422BC, at Macedonian town Amphipolis, Macedonians and Spartans were allies against Athens. Spartan General Vrasidas with Macedonian king Perdikkas fought against Athenian genera Kleon Macedonians+Spartans won
I always try to watch your shows as soon as they come out, you and Military History Visualized are my two most favorite historical visualizations channels! Great work!
what did it mean to the northern tribes to surrender? did it mean they had to give up resources or what? if so, it wasn't like they were going to get their taxes deducted from a paycheck or something. how does it work
It meant that the tribes would predominantly avoid causing any hassle to the Macedonian kingdom through revolt or aggression. This was what Alexander needed in order to secure his borders at home before heading towards Persia.
Pellazget 123 Stop posting thid everywhere. While the official country of Greece wasn't established until 1824, the Greek national identity and basic borders were already well established by Alexander's reign.
"Greeks mistrusted the Macedonians but hated the Spartans". Somehow, this statement is wrong on so many levels. It is as if neither the Macedonians nor the Spartans were Greeks themselves, which is of course not true. I appreciate the videos and effort put into them, but those kind of details do matter.
pls continue this alexander serie. i like your style and i loved your ceacar serie. you have a clear voice, simple style and very informative. keep up good work m8. (ill patreon as soon as i haz money)
He was bold more than any of those things, that’s where his luck came from. Also he was a great tactician, people call that luck? No, he has foresight and great instincts and that might show up as luck to people
@@missionpupa You basically rephrased, what Hephaestus just said. Neither luck, nor tactics will carry 100 000 marching men for a decade across three continents. He was good, like really good.
>Religious man
>Beats priestess and drags her onto her sacred chair to tell him a prophecy
A curious character indeed.
Wow weird hearing from Ghengis Khan who rape so mang women.
Keep in mind they don't know that for sure. I've heard versions where he was just very pushy rather than violent.
If he was unreligious man he wouldn't have cared what the prophesy was
Javier Tham Jun Lin+ Hey Genghis Khan was respectful to other religions, gave Muslim and Christian priests tax breaks and shit.
Caesar: Did someone say siege within a siege?
+Pellazget 123 You are possibly the most annoying person I've ever seen on UA-cam. What's wrong with you? Go and gain your own achievements instead of trying to leach off the past. Seriously, nobody cares.
Caesar has this thing for forts and besieging his besiegers it's like a fetish
+Pellazget 123 1. At what point did I put forth an argument?
2. You've made a load of claims in this comment section without a shred of evidence. The burden of proof is on you.
3. Nobody gives a shit about Albania.
+Bob Clover
He's just a bad troll. Don't feed him.
Scipio albanian, lol.
This is exceptional. Glad you're back.
BazBattles time to rewatch every Alexander video you guys put
I love both your channels
The one that you decided not to do, eh? :-)
BazBattles And are you planning to release a new video?
3 of my favorite channels in one !
"Fine, whatever"
-Alexander the Great
I now see why this man was such a great conqueror.
"GIVE. ME. MY. PROPHECY!"
-Alexander the Great
A reserved man well spoken and polite.
"OH. MY. GOD" - Alexander The Great witnessing lazy people
He didn’t really say that though
Illyrian troops: " D A N G ! "
"Fine, whatever"
"Baby come over." "Can't, Historia Civilis just dropped a new video." "But I'm home alone." "Well that's not my problem."
@@alexandrine1558 sorry baby; it's just not the same :-(
@@abanuverse You just know she'd talk through it.
🤣
😂😂
When she's alone is the perfect time to surround her camp with companion cavalry.
17:40 Those rotating rectangles made me laugh way harder than they should. Amazing how much character you can show just with basic shapes and speech bubbles.
Illirians had glitched out according to historians
P K Lol you can almost hear them singing stupidly like "La lalala we won bad 'xander go bye bye" with little kid voices xD
Maybe the AI at launch of Rome 2 TW wasnt so unrealistic
Federico Eiriz The best comment I've read today.
He should of made some spin around and others go back and forth or side to side. Or make lots of tiny little pink dots
or squares walking around like a busy market.
It is good that you released the video right now. I have something to watch and can stop researching this topic - was meaning to get in Alexander business. :-)
all of you keep up the great work, we all appreciate it
Thanks!
We all want Napoleon!
Glad you are not doing another Alexander videos.
Kings and Generals..well, now you can start with a Caesar series LOL
Illyrians: oh my gods, look at those moves! How can we hope to beat such swagger? Retreat!
this video is not accurate
@@mikeny5020 elaborate?
Don't believe everything you see on the internet
@@thebalkanguy5256 Elaborate?
@@demilung I find it difficult that all of this, to this level of detail, were documented through stone carvings(the only form of documentation back then) and it is most likely his personal speculation. His description of that battle was completely nonsensical.
Almost all material on Alexander the Great focuses on the Persian campaign so its really awesome to get more on other battles he fought. Especially since so many of Alexander's battle strategies are so audacious
He literally believed he could not lose. Crazy plans tend to work when executed with 100% confidence and zero doubt.
@@dylanb4494 That is called the placebo effect.
@@thomasmillward3671 ...no.
@@Xanthopathy 🗿
@@thomasmillward3671 closer to the pygmalion effect
This is what I was told about that episode at Delphi. The word in Greek(which I don't remember, sorry) the oracle called Alexander meant something like "arrogant" or "brash", but could also be interpreted as "great". Now guess which way Alex took it.
ἀνίκητος εἶ ὦ παῖ.
She said he was invincible. "You cannot be defeated, my son"
@@Polydopamine she had a point, he never lost a battle
@@yuhyuh5674 he did lose by an ambush in persia by Darius's satrap
@@ΠαναγιώτηςΜ-ξ2ζ He didn't lose a battle, parts of it to adapt and completenwith afjust d approach, many times.
Similar to aniva and the Romans in a battle before Chanae.
Please never change the outro song! It fits so well!
Agreed! Never change it!!
And all of the other background music (the "dududududn dun dun dun" low hum drums) during narration - same vibes with Caesar's series!
Just found out he cited all the songs in the descriptions, this is the outro - ua-cam.com/video/DFLnx9m4cgU/v-deo.html
My personal favorite was "He'd be back-next spring." *outro*
Totally awesome !!! Dope outtro gets me ready/ pumped for the next video !
@@asve2369 .
Boxes shall be shattered!
Rectangles shall be splintered!
A Civil day!
A historic day!
As historia civilis uploads!
I read that in Lotr voice.
John Cedrick Reyes I played the Rohan soundtrack in my head
You forgot skulls rising from the dead.
Theodin, King
martyn kalendar please refrain from singing
Thank you
"This winter he gave his army a crash course in mountain warfare"
"MOUNTAINS ARE BAD"
lol
Honestly thats all you need to know
Hannibal wasn't paying attention during class
" if You pizzaro when you should french fry, your gonna have a bad time"
Ya see what Hannibal did he pizza when he should have French-fried
@@Omar_ayach
*man takes living tanks across mountains losing most but still getting one giving him a massive advantage tactically*
HE DIDNT KNOW MOUNTAIN BAD REEEEEE
Yet another wonderful video. So so good.
I want to say good job sir. I had a 9 Hour Drive today and binge watching your channel (listening) Made it seem very short. Excellent presentation and superb topics selection
I’ve done this as well and it works great
Be careful on the road bro! Love u
Nothing to say apart from you're the highlight of my week
Well that's kinda depressing.
You're doing great work, great delivery, noting when something that happened is uncertain, neat animations and I particularly love that you're keeping everything "dry" and not trying to make everything overly dramatised. Keep up the good work!
You said it chief
Seriously, I’m really not a fan of overly dramatic retellings. I can’t watch most documentaries for that reason. This style of video making is so much better
0:25 "Had cognitive disabilities and did not participate in politics." Nowadays cognitive disabilities are a requirement for politics.
RuleofVicus yep
It's both parties
"Sigh, women am I right"
Lib: "OMFG SEXIST REEEE"
"Happy holidays"
Con: "OMFG ITS MERRY CHRISTMAS REEEE"
@John Toas it's so sad that generation Z is the most libertarian, and conservative generation in American history. As much independent, conservative, liberal, and libertarian studies have concluded. And how the republicans, have even more control, over the Senate, and the "blue wave" has failed miserably. and the house doesn't have as much importance, as much as you think, or feel it does. Or how the unemployment rate is at a 49 year low, and thousands of jobs have been created. or as 11 steel and metal factories have been opened, and 28 are on the way, in the next year alone. And 68% of Hispanics, say they have it better now, then 2 years ago in 2016. Boohoo, you Americans have it so bad down there, there's no way you can live now. Unlike let's say Europe, Australia, and canada, where "hate speech" has been censored.
Yup libtards.
Oooooh burn
I'd like to think that Alexander was so unnerved by the never before thought about prospect of the sky falling down that afterwards he was like "Can you believe those Gauls disrespecting me like that I mean I think they just made that stuff up!"(glances nervously up at the sky)
Lmao
@@triangulum8869 can you imagine an entire culture just perpetually glancing up at the sky and thinking “is this gonna be the day?”
"we dun goofed, y'all" - Alexander the Great 335 BCE
"git 'er done" - Alexander the Great, regarding the Delphic prophet.
Who knew Alexander was a good ole boy?
Zuck 101
Consequences will never be the same
You spelled BC wrong. There is no common era and never has been.
These will always be my favorite videos to see in my subbox
better than bazbattles?
Hey, if the sky fell on my head, i'd probably forget about those scary Macedonians for a second too
Well the sky is literally gasses and when compressed they turn into liquid so when it rains the sky is literally falling on our heads.
I'll take my chances and grovel at the Macedon boy' feet.
Floods can be scary too?
@Primarch Alpharius they probably didn't know that those lights in the sky were huge though, if I was convinced that was possible I'd be scared af
you don't say
The sky by definition "the region of the atmosphere and outer space seen from the earth." is indeed predominantly filled with gasses.
Superb! As someone who has read extensively on Alexander, 'The Siege of Pellium' has often been the most problematic to visualise. This video is an absolute credit to the ancient historians who preserved Alexanders history and must have been painstaking.
Only one small piece of constructive criticism though: the delegation of Celts is said to have arrived after Alexanders victory on the Danube and before the Illyrian campaign.
There were no fucking Gauls in modern day Albania at the time.. it was Illyrian territory..
He should have referred to them as Celts.. not Gauls... and he most likely encountered them near the danube.. where the were actual Celts.
Din Sel I assumed he just misspoke since he probably knows the Gauls lived in Gaul
@@dinsel9691 MAKEDONIJA 25 CENTURIES ! !
Albania 130 years.
Can you imagine having Aristotle as a tutor? What a privilege.
Alexander might have been the most privileged child of all time and he used everything that he was given to dominate pretty much everything in his path for about 12 years. He made Greece the most unified it'd ever been since the Myceneans and then made the seemingly vast and powerful Persia submit. The only thing that stopped him was that he just kept winning. A good loss helps you consolidate inventory and he spread his lines way too thing just to get to India. If he survived the return home I have no doubt that both Carthage and the Roman Republic would have fallen. If he made it to like 60 his empire would have been like, most of Europe, all of North Africa, the entire Middle East, and parts of Central/North Asia. Would have loved to see how he counters the Steppe tribes and their superior cavalry. Legendary life, him, Napoleon, Caesar and Ghengis Khan were all crazy as fuck but beautifully tuned to warfare.
@@geordiejones5618 Eh.
Macedon didn't have the population to do much of that.
Yeah Macedonia didn't have the population but thats why Alexander got conquered people to join in his army..
Ryan Sansaricq he wasn’t privileged, he had great teachers.
@@geordiejones5618 The things i would give for that knowledge.
Imagine being part of that army:
"Yo we are just gonna run drills"
"all right"
"Use our siege weapons as artillery"
"if you say so, this shit all seems to work out every time"
Yep most great generals is stuff that shouldn't work but it totally worked. It has to be wild to serve under a dude like that
I hate hearing that music at the end. Not because its a bad song on the contrary but, alas because its the end of the video and i have to wait another 3 centuries for you to release the next one!
Is UA-cam doing something weird, or have you been watching that Adam Neely video too?
hehehe not me
God I know. I've started to develop a hatred for that tune
the logistics of his conquest alone are absolutely staggering.. But his army's discipline, adaptability, mixed with his cunning and his ability to see the changes on the battlefield is amazing. This is why we still talk about the man today.
You should cover Alexander's Bactrian & Sogdian campaign. A perfect example of one of the toughest and most difficult anti-guerilla campaigns in history.
In the Illryian ambush Alexander's Dad reached out of the grave to saved his kid, by creating that ultra trained army which could act with such timed precision. It took some creative thinking, which served Alexander throughout his life, and he definitely learned from that encounter. I think it's hard to argue though, that if the Illyrian's and Alexander's places been reversed the Illyrians would not have gotten the same effect from using that crazy ass strategy.
DM: You find yourself surrounded by Illyrian rebels. Do you flee through the pass or cross the river?
Alexander: I roll to intimidate.
DM: Okay, but you'll have to roll at least-
Alexander: Natural 20.
Keep these videos up, man, you're slowly making up for my shitty, forgotten school education.
Every time you upload I get so happy and excited. Your uploads are so much fun and so informative
The moment when you see a "historia civilis" video in your subscriptions is just great.
Thanks for the amazing content.
Caranus died under suspicious circumstances
Every CK2 player loves this method of securing the succession 😂
What my only rival for power was bitten by a snake I am shocked- some inbred genius
@@caesarion4975 It's peak CK2 if you have an inbred genius of a ruler mate.
Ck2 `? Lik EU? Grand Strategy game
been watching your videos religiously for months now. Always super excited to see you upload. Great stuff man
Take a shot everytime he says: "Alexander led the Companion Cavalry."
Then we would be more drunk then when Alexander murdered Parmenion!
All hail Alexander the Great, Third of His Name, King of Macedon and Hegemon of the Hellenic League!
mugur de fluier agree alexander was hungaryans bulgaryans
@Sommersby Nobodyev lol
@mugur de fluier Alexander III of Macedon (Greek: Αλέξανδρος Γʹ ὁ Μακεδών; 20/21 July 356 BC - 10/11 June 323 BC), commonly known as Alexander the Great (Ancient Greek: Ἀλέξανδρος ὁ Μέγας, romanized: Aléxandros ho Mégas), was a king (basileus) of the ancient Greek kingdom of Macedon[a]
@mugur de fluier there wasn't Hungary back then noob
ⰔⰂⰑⰁⰑⰄⰅⰐ agree alexamder was bulgaryans or romanians
"lets spin around" "good idea general"
Try spinning it's a good trick
do a barrel roll
It's deff worth it to have these advertisements. Your videos are some of the best on UA-cam, and we understand you gotta make your money!
Some have complained that these videos take slightly longer to produce, but keep in mind he is making them around 20 minutes, so he is not shortening us on our doses of education drugs
Historia Civilis, BazBattles or Kings and Generals uploads make my day
Usually being told that you're invincible, sarcastically or not back then and believing it; you'd act more reckless, which he sort of did but I got this feeling that Alexander also at some point thought "Well if *_I'm_* invincible, that doesn't mean my troops are so I gotta plan carefully lest I stand alone an immortal victor on an empty battlefield." or something like that.
Could be why he wins.
Do a video about marius and sulla
Your videos are a delight to see. Each time I see an upload of your videos I grab popcorn and watch you take events from times past and make them sound as if it just happened. It also helps how you occasionally throw in a joke or two
Really makes not enjoying your videos difficult. I remember going to a summer camp and I began throwing references to Roman politics and battles. And than this other guy started getting the references. We talked some more and it turns out we where both watching a channel called historical civilis. For the rest of the two weeks that I was there people referee to me and the other guy as walking encyclopedias but I must confess that the only reason I know any of this is because I watched your videos at summer school ironically learning more about Rome than the Washington state history I was supposed to be learning. The only reason I made it through summer school with my sanity intact is because you could take something obscure like Roman elections, and make it interesting beyond reason. So I feel the need to say thank you for making your videos
Fascinating! Can't wait for more content focusing in Alexander The Great's journey, thank you for your hard work.
I just love how Kings and Generals and BazBattles show their love on fellow history channels. My favorite trio.
*sees that an entire army has been replaced by spinning pink rectangles*
"Oh my god"
This is what my life has been leading up to.
You are by far my favorite history channel on youtube. I've missed you.
This is fantastic, you do a comprehensive job of covering everything and presenting it in an intelligible order. Thank you
If the wagon trick by the Thracians was so unconventional then how did Alexander know to prepare his army for it?
I think Aleander was drilling his army to survive rockfalls, and the wagon attack was similar enough to use same tactics. It's all just speculation, though.
what about tactics for dealing with scythed chariots?
@@maybemaeb Do the sources mention how many wagons? The width of the front? At this time he just had 1000 men right? So it doesn't take too much space. It seems like they also could've side stepped them or the wagons fell off before reaching them by bouncing on random rocks.
Spies?
Well it doesn’t take long for one to simply go duck and search for cover when something is falling towards you, and whatever the problem is someone who’s much of a genius as Alexander would’ve probably done it better.
"Yo dawg, I heard you like sieges so I put a siege inside a siege" - Some Illiryan
17:21
The illyrian army: you spin my head right round right round and
That one macadonian guy: 0_0
This channel has taught me more about history than any other channel. Thank you man
The insane discipline. Holy Cow. I am still trying to wrap my head around these guys. Great video as always!!!
The most disciplined were the Spartans. And after that other southern Greeks. The macedonian phallanx was designed taking into account the fact that they couldn't train infantry as well as southern greeks. this was one of the reasons for Phillip making the modifications he made with the macedonian phallanx. of course it also had great advantages.
But with the other phallanxes ( Spartan, Athenian, Theban) more training and discipline were required for good functioning of the phallanx.
again a history channel focussing on alexander, and still it's unique and top quality content, this is great
also 'they swished their sarissas'', what did it sound like, can you describe it more?
Just imagine the sound that comes from swinging a 4.5 meter spear around in the air.
swisss
SWISSSH
*SWOOSH*
*_S W W O O O S S H H_*
almost feels like I'm there
lol. I'm more impressed that the drilling, which was basically just a massive interpretive dance, actually scared the Illyrians away. It's like, "wow these guys have really sick dance moves. Imma' leave out of respect."
maybe they just left because it took so long, they where tired or hungry, or maybe just horny and there was a village with protitues nearby, we'll never know
I'm curious if you are at the point where it would be prudent to pay someone to animate your videos so you could release them faster? (Not offering, just love your content and wish there was more of it.)
"swisss
SWISSSH
*SWOOSH*
*_S W W O O O S S H H_* "
- Those sarissas, probably.
Lmao
I'm back for a third round of watching this particular video. I think this might be my favourite channel on YT
NEVER STOP! Your content and presentation are superb!!!
I didn't get the notification
and pls make more great videos
13:00 Siegeception
Braderz1506 yo,man, we heard you like sieges,
So we are sieging your siege so you can siege while you siege
Alesia??
They did siegeception before it was cool
"We need to go deeper..."
Braderz1506 *BWWWOOOONNNGG*
You know, some people blame the fall of Persia not to Alexander but just to the instability of the empire... this entire campaign proves them wrong. Alexander was a genius.
Trygve Plaustrum
Typical indians and iranians who also insisted that he lost to porus on hydaspes.
Trygve Plaustrum
Persia was weakend after the greco-persian wars
They lost darius and xerxes because of it
(And lets be honest darius the III wasn.t the most competent persian ruler they had)
But still it was one of the biggest super powers of ancient antiquity
Alongside rome, seleucids, parthia, sassanids
16:55
While Persia had suffered defeats to the Greeks earlier, it was still unquestionably the biggest superpower in the Mediterranean world in Alexander's time. Their huge advantage in resources compared to the Macedonians is clearly illustrated by the course of Alexander's campaign. The Persians were initially able to assemble an army roughly as large as Alexander's just from Asia Minor for the Battle of the Granicus. Then Darius was able to assemble a force twice as large as Alexander's for Issus, then another army at least as large for Gaugamela, and could well have raised a third if his satraps had stayed loyal, all despite suffering massive losses at each battle. Alexander, by contrast, would never have had the resources to rebuild his entire army if he had suffered a similar defeat.
Alexander did have a very effective, well-trained force to face the larger Persian armies, but it still required a commander of his genius to overcome his disadvantages and win each of those battles, let alone maintain a multi-year campaign that involved fighting all three major battles in succession without suffering crippling losses at any of them.
A good portion of Persian troops were levied farmboys not worth shit... Training men to become warriors is much more expensive and time-consuming than forcibly conscripting civilians in your army with little to no pay. Alexander's achievements are great but many people seem to overestimate Persia here, the Achaemenid Empire was declining and morale was low after consecutive defeats, plus an incompetent idiot was at the head. As HC said, Alexander was lucky. If he was born during the same era as say, Darius I, who was at the very least capable of keeping his empire in 1 piece, things wouldn't have gone so smoothly.
These videos are so interesting to watch. Not one moment when I thought I would want to skip a part. Please, keep up with the quality, these are awesome
17:20 - "I'll try spinning, that's a good trick!"
so when is that "caesar marched on rome" sentence deconstruction video happening? (love macedonian history too btw)
This plz
LOL
Connor O'Brien waiting for that for so long
Eagerly waiting for that too
Yeah it kinda sucks he's moved on to Alexander which has already been done by a handful of youtubers. Hopefully he goes back to Roman videos soon. :/
great video! :)
Your humor with the dialogue bubbles is genius.
Thank you for these videos, you make learning about these eras of history easy and fun...without these, I don't think I would ever know about them.
"The oracle's wifi connection to the gods suffers from interference during winter"
Interestingly enaught, Alexander's campaign on the Danube is considered one of the first mentioned battles that took place on the teritory of Romania
On this occasion, he [Alexander] made a very long speech to the Thessalians and the other Greeks, and when he saw that they encouraged him with shouts to lead them against the Barbarians, he shifted his lance into his left hand, and with his right appealed to the gods, as Callisthenes tells us, praying them, if he was really sprung from Zeus, to defend and strengthen the Greeks.
[Plutarch. Alexander (ed. Bernadotte Perrin) XXXIII
Gannis, ALEZANDROY TITLE OF ALBANIA, ALEZANDROY TITLE MEANINGS, ALBANIA ALE ZAN TROY, GREECE MEGALO KATARTITI, INGLES GREAT CONQUEROR, ALEZANDROY BILONGS TO ALBANIA.
@@albertrexhepaj8330............... eat ............. yellow .
Excellent! You really broke this campaign down for me. Can't believe I haven't come across your channel before. Definitely subscribed
I love the special effects of your troop movements and the well coordinated battlescenes you give us. It so much better done than any other Hollywood movie.
Damn this Alexander sounds pretty impressive, I wonder if we are going to see more of him, but I doubt He acomplished much more in his live.
Religion of peace turning you into pieces
I dont know he seems like the sort of man who would ruin his empire on his deathbed just to spite everyone.
Pellazget 123 Alexander was not Illyrian nor was he Albanian. There was no such thing as Albanians back and then. And nor are they Illyrians. He was Greek. Please stop spreading your propaganda. It is getting really annoying
he probably turned his empire into pieces like your name
Pellazget 123 Hes mother was Epirotan Greek and hes was Greek Macedonian not Albanian not Illurian. And Epirus is Greek not Albanian. Greece was formed in 1821 that's true, but that doesn't mean that they weren't Greek people living before that. Greeks are by far the oldest race in Europe.
Pellazget 123 seriously, you people are so uneducated that its not even funny any more.
Can you do a video about Trajan and his campaigns in Dacia ?
Just an idea...
I hate to wait a month for one of those videos. :'(
No pain, no gain! ;)
2 months actually
I don't want these video to come up every 3 days or anything, but at this rate we'll only get 12 videos a year, a slightly faster upload rate would be more fruitful in my opinion.
All other similar channels are here commenting. You''re the godfather, so glad to see your videos.
Your channel is awesome, its a great way for an amateur like me to get a simple but informative snapshot on history.
20:14 = The birth of this Channels Golden Age.
It's nice that you made the balkan campaign of Alexander, but there are already 2 chanells who covers Alexander campaigns. I think Caesar deserve a complete series. You finished the gallic wars... please start the civil war
BazzBattles and Epic History TV
+The Equalizer There was a battle during the balkans campaign against the thracians in which Alexander was fighting up a slope and the phalanx had dozens of carts rolled down at them and Alexander ordered his soldiers to lay on the ground and hold their shields up so that the carts just harmlessly passed over.
Tony, i know. The battle was presented here. If Historia Civilis will do videos on Alexander, i hope he doens't make the usual Granicus, Issus, Gaugamela and Hydaspes but the unknown campaigns and battles of Alexander.
+The Equalizer
Yeah when people think of alexander they only remember gaugamela or the hydaspes battles. Jaxartes, Arigaeum, Halicarnassus,Tyre, Aornos, Gaza, Cophen campaign, etc don't nearly get as much coverage unfortunately.
lol yeah i only just started watching it, just mentioned it as it's cool how he dealt with them.
19:06 asterix and obelix
I think for almost a year or more I've been searching this particular clip which I watch and forgot and was so desperate to watch again. I found it tonight
Man these videos kick ass. Such a treat whenever one comes out.
Alexander was not just lucky, he was bold and inteligent. Truely a god among men.
You should do "The Anabasis," Zenophon's account of the campaign of the 10,000
He's name is not Zenophon ffs. All those mispronunciations by English speakers are so annoying. It's pronounced: Ksenophon
I LOVE YOU. PLEASE DO VIDEOS ON JAPANESE AND/OR CHINESE BATTLES/HISTORY AS WELL...
Your videos are a gift from the gods.
Shine on you crazy diamond.
I've just been binge-watching all of your videos. They are great. Wish there were more.
More Caesar vids please!
In 422BC, at Macedonian town Amphipolis, Macedonians and Spartans were allies against Athens.
Spartan General Vrasidas with
Macedonian king Perdikkas
fought against
Athenian genera Kleon
Macedonians+Spartans won
17.23 cracks me up. Spinning around seems like the perfect representation of doing nothing useful.
I always try to watch your shows as soon as they come out, you and Military History Visualized are my two most favorite historical visualizations channels! Great work!
Yes!!!! A new video by Historia Civilis. And about Alexander no less. Athena be praised.
what did it mean to the northern tribes to surrender? did it mean they had to give up resources or what? if so, it wasn't like they were going to get their taxes deducted from a paycheck or something. how does it work
i don't know but either submiting to Greek law or conscription maybe
I suppose they got taxes in the form of food/ores/whatever of value one has and in manpower, like everyone else back in the day.
Alex Raxach post to Reddit on r/askhistorians and u get an answer quick
It meant that the tribes would predominantly avoid causing any hassle to the Macedonian kingdom through revolt or aggression. This was what Alexander needed in order to secure his borders at home before heading towards Persia.
Pellazget 123 Stop posting thid everywhere. While the official country of Greece wasn't established until 1824, the Greek national identity and basic borders were already well established by Alexander's reign.
I loved Greek history because of Alexander the Great
ALEXANDER THE GREAT IS MACEDONIAN. you love... carrot.
"Greeks mistrusted the Macedonians but hated the Spartans". Somehow, this statement is wrong on so many levels. It is as if neither the Macedonians nor the Spartans were Greeks themselves, which is of course not true. I appreciate the videos and effort put into them, but those kind of details do matter.
Macedonians Spartans athenians were all hellenes .....But hated each other like all polis greek states....
@@Peterkonto maceonians are not hellens
@@chris9473 of course they are stop the crap of the slavic propaganda
Many Greeks like Demosthenes called the Macedonians barbarians
@@tomasrocha6139 MACEDONIANS IN MAKEDONIJA ! !
you in... rock.
I just watched all your videos in a week. I needed this.
pls continue this alexander serie. i like your style and i loved your ceacar serie. you have a clear voice, simple style and very informative. keep up good work m8. (ill patreon as soon as i haz money)
"Alexander was lucky" AND good
He was bold more than any of those things, that’s where his luck came from.
Also he was a great tactician, people call that luck? No, he has foresight and great instincts and that might show up as luck to people
@@missionpupa You basically rephrased, what Hephaestus just said. Neither luck, nor tactics will carry 100 000 marching men for a decade across three continents. He was good, like really good.