Tatsuya Naka is a treasure. This celebrates the universal family of martial arts, respecting differences, always being a student and being humble. This is inspirational!
Wikipedia : Fujian White Crane is one of the constituent styles of Five Ancestors, who, in addition to the various styles of Karate (notably Goju-ryu, Shitō-ryū and Uechi-ryu), use the routine "San Chian" from Fujian White Crane. San Chian is best known by the Japanese pronunciation of its name, Sanchin. Sanchin (三戦) is a kata of apparent Southern Chinese (Fujianese) origin that is considered to be the core of several styles, the most well-known being the Okinawan Karate styles of Uechi-Ryū and Gōjū-Ryū, as well as the Chinese martial arts of Fujian White Crane, Five Ancestors, Pangai-noon and the Tiger-Crane Combination style associated with Ang Lian-Huat. Tam Hon taught a style that was called simply "Saam Jin" (Cantonese for "Sanchin").
At 6yrs old my substitute school teacher said "at lunch time i will teach white crane" 6 months later i was still pursuing this incredible energy. Now i am teaching KunLun Quan in proctorville ohio. I love this video. Thank you
Are there any English subtitles available on the DVD of this training session? As an ITF Taekwon-Do practitioner I'm also very interested in White Crane Kung Fu.
Well, the UA-cam auto-translate (English) subtitles are as hilarious inaccurate as expected :) Favourite auto-translated sentence: "After all Chinese martial arts are deep and smelly" ( 3:54 )
Sensei Tatsuya i love this kind of exchance Videos and i like to watch some more. Sadly i don't u understand a Single Word. Arigato gozaimasu.🙏 Onegeashimasu
My thoughts exactly. Typical gung fu.they expect superior technique to beat a motivated attacker regardless of the size of the defender. Xu Xaidong is dealing to thier delusions
It's a demonstration. Do you see boxers moving about when they're demonstrating things? If they did....you wouldn't be able to see what was happening. Has anyone in any type of knowledge ever demonstrated anything for you in anything other than a simplified fashion? When you were in school and had Physics demonstrations did anyone tell you, "So in real life when you use an inclined plane.", or did you accept that you were learning a principle that could be applied elsewhere? Same thing here. You honestly act like you don't understand what a demonstration is.
You brought them? Does it necessary for a grand master to fight with a small potato, will you challenge or accept the challenge? The basic rules of learning martial arts are 第一年俾人打（1st year, being beaten/bullied by others), 第二年行埋去俾人打（2nd year, step forward to your opponent either to challenge or being challenged and being beaten) So if these so called super masters lost in the ring, it is only because it might be able their first or second year of learning. Can every UFS fighter in the ring can win if both of the fighter are UFS fighter? What's the implication of the fight? That is to say, martial arts or kung fu is not the most important. It is mainly because of power, energy and power, etc. Seems you know nothing at all so you'd laugh..........
Legend has it that the 4 elders that gathered at Shaolin during the crackdown were arguing which style was superior, in the typical male machism dominance style. Ng Mui was casually strolling through the garden and laughed. One of them went up to her and asked why she was laughing, and she replied that they needed a bit of softness to support all that rigid movement. The elders didn't take too kindly to her remark and challenged her, and she soundly defeated them all!
No black belts on the chinese I see. Seems like the belt is more for social structure than actual skill. Chinese use a duan system as well. Great learning.
Black belts is something that all japanese styles borrow from judo schools because at the beginning of the 20th century it was easy to students always move from another city to study or work.but even okinawa karate masters only accept it after the second World war,specifically because of their foreigners students. Black belts don't tell who's the best fighter, just the level of knowledge they have inside a particular style
I love such videos. Not just because of styles many people may think are opposites, but also the different cultures sharing. It is my experance thatcmany times different styles of martial arts tend to use the same moves. Though may have an unique way of doing it from many other styles. As a person becomes more experanced, the more the gap of unique aspects close and evolves more and more simular. It is a great way for both to trade thos aspects, to merge in simular ways much quicker and easier, rather than spend years to subconsciously develop those aspects on their own to a conscious level of doing.
The true style of kanryo higaonna is white crane. Between shotokan and kanryo higaonna has a far difference because of the different master that funakoshi has learnt before
Ville-Pekka Turpeinen there is a monument of white crane in fujian written that kanryo higaonna learnt from Xie chong siang ini 1900s. Morio higaonna also stated ini goju Ryu old document that his grandpa studied white crane to avenge his father death under Xie chongsiang
@@ahmadinejad606 Like I said, there is no credible evidence. Since the monument does is no older than a decade or two, it is not very believable. Even the Fuzhou Martial Arts Association has denied the claim.
@@Veepee92What evidence would satisfy you other than him saying he did? Karate was a secretive practice back then and people didn't feel the need to obsessively document everything for obnoxious future generations.
This is what I always wanted to see from Kuro - Obi! Now, it would be great to reconcile & clarify the combat benefits of JKA style training vs White Crane Kung Fu. Or is JKA training geared MORE towards competition? This video is incredibly motivating, inspirational and educational! Based upon the techniques of Tatsuya Naka, it would be fantastic to seem him practice against Sensei Morio Higaonna.
eastern martial arts are codified. that's why it may seem weird to outsiders.. in order to understand it, you need to delve deeper. unlike western martial arts that shows what their martial arts truly is. eastern people are secretive. But it is always up to the practitioner if he/she can weaponize its art or not. Salute to you Naka Tatsuya Sensei.
i saw how to purchase the discs but i only speak english and there are no subtitles. as valuable as this is to okinawa karate practitioners the world over who don't speak japanese/okinawan is there any plan to do subtities in various languages particularly english ?
"Karate meets White Crane"? An odd title because the origin of "Karate", which originally meant "Chinese Hand" and later changed to "Empty Hand", IS from Crane system.
I bet this old Kung Fu master has never had a real fight. No one offers you an arm like that and stands there for you to do your moves. No wonder too many got knocked out in the ring.
@@ronki23 I trained in a really old style called Yama Bushi Ryu Jujutsu. Karate as most know it is relatively new, 100 years +- with influences from china, japan and korea mostly culminating in okinawa. I was taught that anything the battlefield warrior that lost his weapon could do to destroy their enemy, was jujutsu. For the most part, punching and kicking an armored opponent was ineffective. So, restraining, breaking, throwing, disarming and grappling techniques evolved. And karate incorporates some jujutsu. Yes.....we spell it jujutsu
Tatsuya Naka is a treasure. This celebrates the universal family of martial arts, respecting differences, always being a student and being humble. This is inspirational!
As a master and still being humble, it's rare nowadays! I deeply respect him from my heart.
達也先生いつも笑っているように見えるけど、実は誰よりも真剣なんでしょうねー 達也先生からの素晴らしい空手が新しく生まれるのを楽しみにしてます。大ファンです。
世界一の人が他の流派や他の武術も尊重し、素直に受け入れ、謙虚に学んでるのが素晴らしい！
どんな世界でもそーだけどトップになる人は謙虚でもありますね
だから様々な知識が吸収できるのだとも思いました
Wikipedia :
Fujian White Crane is one of the constituent styles of Five Ancestors, who, in addition to the various styles of Karate (notably Goju-ryu, Shitō-ryū and Uechi-ryu), use the routine "San Chian" from Fujian White Crane. San Chian is best known by the Japanese pronunciation of its name, Sanchin.
Sanchin (三戦) is a kata of apparent Southern Chinese (Fujianese) origin that is considered to be the core of several styles, the most well-known being the Okinawan Karate styles of Uechi-Ryū and Gōjū-Ryū, as well as the Chinese martial arts of Fujian White Crane, Five Ancestors, Pangai-noon and the Tiger-Crane Combination style associated with Ang Lian-Huat. Tam Hon taught a style that was called simply "Saam Jin" (Cantonese for "Sanchin").
中達也という天才がいて成り立つ価値のある作品
止まらず攻守流れの中で、封じ居着かせ、悟られず反撃する。中国武術奥の深さは素晴らしい！
At 6yrs old my substitute school teacher said "at lunch time i will teach white crane" 6 months later i was still pursuing this incredible energy. Now i am teaching KunLun Quan in proctorville ohio. I love this video. Thank you
詠春拳も女性が作った拳法という話を聞いたことがあります。筋力や体重だけに頼っていては修得するのが難しい精妙な技術があるんでしょうね。
白鶴拳、狭い空間での超接近戦で威力を発揮しそうな拳法ですね
中国武術はモチーフがあるのが面白いですね
中国の歴史と同じでルーツを知ると更に興味深くなる
WingChun - White Crane also use Fan lan Jin 翻浪勁, but I think, the Okinawa master 宮平保 who teach Baiji Juan 八極拳, explained it and demostrate it better.
いろんな流派があって本当に面白い。
この動画投稿の５年後に
ほしみんの白鶴拳を
見ることになるなんて
武術のネットワークって
面白いな。ಠωಠ
僕もここで習った！
八極拳凄くカッコいい…
3:47 Sensei Naka's face ....lol
白鶴って日本酒があるから酔拳かと思ったわ
ハッキリ言って、尊重の上に学んで己の腕を上げるのが一番。どっちの武術が優れている視点でモノを言うのも語るのも聞くのも好きじゃない
どっちの武術が優れてるかどうかなんてその人の技量で大きく変わってくるから決めようがないと思う。
＞どんな武術であれ、組手やっている方が強くて、やらなければ弱いのは当たり前。
その考え方もナンセンスで、居合や抜刀術のように、突発的に起こる戦いを想定した武術や技術では組手自体が成立しない。
中国拳法や空手の型、合気道なども本来そういうものではないかと思う。
＞それで本当の「実戦」を潜り抜けたなら言うことはないけど、そこまでやっている人はなかなかいないだろう。
相手が身構える前に、隙を突いて一発で倒す。
結構「本当の実戦」は組手の強さと関係ないのが多いと思うよ。
＞遠くから撃たれるとか、用を足してる時に撃たれるとか、バイクに跳ねられるとか、本当の戦場を、戦い抜いたとかそういう広範な意味での実戦を潜り抜ける
それは武術の範疇を超えてると思うよ。
まぁ考えは人それぞれやけど。
＞実際に格闘になった際に組手で養える力は全く役に立たないとは思えないなあ。
殺し合いとは言わずとも、本当に何でもありの戦いになったら組手の癖が命取りになることが多いというのが俺の考えね。
目つき噛みつき金的何でも有りの組手をしてるなら別やけど。
じゃんけんですら一番強い手は分からんのにな、やった事も無いだろうにどっちが強いかなんてわかるわけ無いよね
The true spirit of Mixed Martial Arts
原理不錯，使出來有難度，要對手很配合才行，我是沒找到，，我太弱了。
What is it about watching Chinese people doing kung fu to music that just makes the world a better place?
Maybe they realize your most likely to get in a fight at a nightclub.....with music in the foreground
Are there any English subtitles available on the DVD of this training session?
As an ITF Taekwon-Do practitioner I'm also very interested in White Crane Kung Fu.
自分の胸に鶴のクチバシやったらむせましたｗ フックの動作で人に打つと見かけより危険かも、世の中まだまだ知らないことが溢れていますね！
Thank you for your videos, very interesting. Osu!!
はっかくけんじゃなかったっけ？。沖縄に伝わる秘伝書、武備誌は白鶴拳の奥義書なので、空手とは深いつながりがありますね。
中華のものは現地語で呼ばないならせめて音読みですよね
Beautiful tour respect for arts martials!!
Well, the UA-cam auto-translate (English) subtitles are as hilarious inaccurate as expected :)
Favourite auto-translated sentence:
"After all Chinese martial arts are deep and smelly" ( 3:54 )
nice video but I would liked to have seen more of the white crane bunkai.
I have all series WC Kung fu of that White Crane master :-)
@@Ratva666Does he go through the applications in that video series? Are there English sub titles?
東映のDVD購入ページが機能停止してるのが残念ですねー
Going back to the roots of karate
Sensei Tatsuya i love this kind of exchance Videos and i like to watch some more. Sadly i don't u understand a Single Word.
Arigato gozaimasu.🙏 Onegeashimasu
足の運びというか体重移動が独特でカッコイイなぁ
武術であると同時に文化的な芸術であると感じた
Awesome!
Look how good it works when the opponent just stands there and let's it happen.
My thoughts exactly.
Typical gung fu.they expect superior technique to beat a motivated attacker regardless of the size of the defender.
Xu Xaidong is dealing to thier delusions
They are demonstrating technique. It becomes more real once you begin partner training. Attack/defend, etc. Hello?
It's a demonstration. Do you see boxers moving about when they're demonstrating things? If they did....you wouldn't be able to see what was happening. Has anyone in any type of knowledge ever demonstrated anything for you in anything other than a simplified fashion?
When you were in school and had Physics demonstrations did anyone tell you, "So in real life when you use an inclined plane.", or did you accept that you were learning a principle that could be applied elsewhere?
Same thing here. You honestly act like you don't understand what a demonstration is.
these super masters should be brought to the ring with a UFS fighter. that's where we'd laugh...
You brought them? Does it necessary for a grand master to fight with a small potato, will you challenge or accept the challenge? The basic rules of learning martial arts are 第一年俾人打（1st year, being beaten/bullied by others), 第二年行埋去俾人打（2nd year, step forward to your opponent either to challenge or being challenged and being beaten)
So if these so called super masters lost in the ring, it is only because it might be able their first or second year of learning.
Can every UFS fighter in the ring can win if both of the fighter are UFS fighter? What's the implication of the fight? That is to say, martial arts or kung fu is not the most important. It is mainly because of power, energy and power, etc. Seems you know nothing at all so you'd laugh..........
Legend has it that the 4 elders that gathered at Shaolin during the crackdown were arguing which style was superior, in the typical male machism dominance style. Ng Mui was casually strolling through the garden and laughed. One of them went up to her and asked why she was laughing, and she replied that they needed a bit of softness to support all that rigid movement. The elders didn't take too kindly to her remark and challenged her, and she soundly defeated them all!
No black belts on the chinese I see. Seems like the belt is more for social structure than actual skill. Chinese use a duan system as well. Great learning.
Black belts is something that all japanese styles borrow from judo schools because at the beginning of the 20th century it was easy to students always move from another city to study or work.but even okinawa karate masters only accept it after the second World war,specifically because of their foreigners students. Black belts don't tell who's the best fighter, just the level of knowledge they have inside a particular style
サンチンやニーパイポのある空手の源流とされている白鶴拳とはちがう白鶴拳ですかね？
剛柔流や上地流の元になった鳴鶴拳の、そのまた源流とされるのが、この永春白鶴拳らしいですね
食鶴拳には繋がらないのか…
食鶴拳の源流は何だろう？
White Crane decedent = Karate , Wing Chun
This was very enjoyable to see
Muy buen estado excelente me gusta su estilo pero no hay que olvidar que una vez que aprendes el camino debes crear el tuyo
I liked the video, I only wish I could understand more. I lost faith in the auto-translated when it said "An elephant flying in 10 companies"...
I really dig this oriental style music.
Same, I hope someone knows the title
Não faz mais filmes? Assisti bons filmes seus ! Like.👍☺
I love such videos. Not just because of styles many people may think are opposites, but also the different cultures sharing.
It is my experance thatcmany times different styles of martial arts tend to use the same moves. Though may have an unique way of doing it from many other styles. As a person becomes more experanced, the more the gap of unique aspects close and evolves more and more simular.
It is a great way for both to trade thos aspects, to merge in simular ways much quicker and easier, rather than spend years to subconsciously develop those aspects on their own to a conscious level of doing.
Que importante que Sensei Naka siga los pasos del Budo. Camino que recorrió Sensei Asai.
Like for Shito-Ryu
グレートジャーニーはやく、ストリーミングコンテンツにならんかな？
Amazon primeに出て欲しい
The beautiful of different style of martial art 😍
The true style of kanryo higaonna is white crane. Between shotokan and kanryo higaonna has a far difference because of the different master that funakoshi has learnt before
There is no credible evidence of Kanryo Higaonna having ever studied White Crane.
Ville-Pekka Turpeinen there is a monument of white crane in fujian written that kanryo higaonna learnt from Xie chong siang ini 1900s. Morio higaonna also stated ini goju Ryu old document that his grandpa studied white crane to avenge his father death under Xie chongsiang
@@ahmadinejad606 Like I said, there is no credible evidence. Since the monument does is no older than a decade or two, it is not very believable. Even the Fuzhou Martial Arts Association has denied the claim.
@@Veepee92What evidence would satisfy you other than him saying he did? Karate was a secretive practice back then and people didn't feel the need to obsessively document everything for obnoxious future generations.
This is what I always wanted to see from Kuro - Obi! Now, it would be great to reconcile & clarify the combat benefits of JKA style training vs White Crane Kung Fu. Or is JKA training geared MORE towards competition? This video is incredibly motivating, inspirational and educational! Based upon the techniques of Tatsuya Naka, it would be fantastic to seem him practice against Sensei Morio Higaonna.
eastern martial arts are codified. that's why it may seem weird to outsiders.. in order to understand it, you need to delve deeper. unlike western martial arts that shows what their martial arts truly is. eastern people are secretive. But it is always up to the practitioner if he/she can weaponize its art or not. Salute to you Naka Tatsuya Sensei.
Very good,Naka Sensei...
昔、リングの魂で紹介された拳法ですね。
リングの魂に出てたね。
たしか中国人の先生が黄土色のパジャマみたいな道着(？)着てて印象に残ってる。
そうですね、たしか台湾ロケで。
台湾でしたか。
だから日本語も喋れたんですね。
@@user-qk2ho5vi3x さん
ええ、日本語が堪能な先生でしたね。たしかに黄土色のような、オレンジ色のような、空手着みたいな道着でしたね。
リン魂懐かしすぎる
20年ぶりぐらいに聞いた気がするw
Прекрасный и очень познавательный канал!
i saw how to purchase the discs but i only speak english and there are no subtitles. as valuable as this is to okinawa karate practitioners the world over who don't speak japanese/okinawan is there any plan to do subtities in various languages particularly english ?
中国の拳法は型の動きが実際の用法の逆方向だったりするそうですね
CAN ANYONE DIRECT ME TO INFORMATION ABOUT TESTSUI NAKANO, his style teachers and lineage please. domo arigato
Silat please
Come fate a ricordare tutti i kata...... per me sarebbe impossibile, non ricordo nemmeno cosa ho mangiato ieri.... 😅
Beautiful
"Karate meets White Crane"? An odd title because the origin of "Karate", which originally meant "Chinese Hand" and later changed to "Empty Hand", IS from Crane system.
I suppose it's not "an odd title". They must have chosen white crane PRECISELY because it's one of the main sources of karate
Great job visiting China! Will Tatsuya Sensei be visiting Korea? It would be great to compare Karate with Taekwondo!
Excellent
白鶴拳は、ハクツルではなくハッカク・ケンと読むのではないでしょうか。
まあ結局は外国語ですからね
例えば「イギリス」と呼ぼうが「ヱゲレス」呼ぼうが同じ意味ですし
作品内で呼称が統一されていればよろしいんじゃないでしょうか
伝承のために生活に溶け込ませたがゆえの型なのか、暗殺を意図した型なのか色々妄想出来て楽しい
Very good styles. But please do not allow the gracie family to come in and start talking crap how bjj is better lol
looks like aikido except with more offense.
Vocês do canal deveriam traduzir para entendermos.
Concordo.
はくつるか・・・はっかくかと思った。
色々見たが習うならこの先生がいいかな。ほかの先生は・・・・ちょっと
I’m sorry, but is the elder statesmen growing a ponytail out of the mole on his neck?🤔
How dare you point that out cause now I can't unsee it😟
Most of Okinawa karate came from white crane kung fu. Shotokan in different. A more jujutsu/kenjutsu approach.
Funakoshi was Okinawan.
@@sullyb23511 yes, but his students created Shotokan and Wado. He did not get happy with it anyway.
Let go fight with MMA or UFC !
御老師ご立派な福毛
Nice
For “white crane meets shotokan” join the JKS!
That's really bullshit, no one will stay here and no response if you hit him
美しい拳法ですね♪
僕7年空手してたけど
型のジオンをずっとジュオンだと
思ってました
子供の頃ガンダムのジオンだと思ってました
目が奪われる。達人の技と・・・
ホクロから生えてる毛に
やられちゃう、、
やってんだよね、、自分で
Very goot ! Oss !
いろいろなところにDNAが隠されていますね😆 それを発見するのは楽しい。
Good karate master!
White Crane vs Xu xiaodong? Who u got?
OK.)..
I bet this old Kung Fu master has never had a real fight. No one offers you an arm like that and stands there for you to do your moves. No wonder too many got knocked out in the ring.
Respect
傳武誰會站著給你打?
ネット配信ありますか？？
「はくつる」じゃなくて「はっかく」拳でしょ？
どちらも日本語発音での読みだから、どちらでも良いのでは？？
バイフゥチエン
中国語読みだとね
『はくつる』だと日本酒かな？って思うのは自分だけかな？
とにかく『はっかく』
日本の勝手な読み方なんてどうでもよくね？
あーだこーだ文句つけるならちゃんとした読み方しなよ
Karate vs kung fu....=.....hard vs soft....
Tatsuya Naka can easily knock that king fu master. He looks undernourished and weak , karate is too strong and fast.
A real master!
っぱ格闘技に国境は無いな。
Japanese gonna take it home and improve 100x better.
蟷螂にも近い動作があるなとおぼろげに。
蛇拳を変にした感じか
Hope there will be Taiwan one day.
Wasn't Karate also influenced by Ju Jitsu? Because gi and belts are Japanese, not Chinese
yes. Influenced
@@rougarou1559 which style of Ju Jitsu?
@@ronki23 I trained in a really old style called Yama Bushi Ryu Jujutsu. Karate as most know it is relatively new, 100 years +- with influences from china, japan and korea mostly culminating in okinawa.
I was taught that anything the battlefield warrior that lost his weapon could do to destroy their enemy, was jujutsu. For the most part, punching and kicking an armored opponent was ineffective. So, restraining, breaking, throwing, disarming and grappling techniques evolved.
And karate incorporates some jujutsu.
Yes.....we spell it jujutsu