Xbox 360 vs. PS3: Round 5 (GPU)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 сер 2024
- Xbox 360 vs. PS3: Round 5 (GPU)
Console Wars: Season 1
Catch up on previous rounds:
Round 1: Controller: cuthut.com/jGY
Rounds 2 & 3: Hardware: cuthut.com/zP7
Round 4: CPU: cuthut.com/h0l
Round 5: GPU: cuthut.com/e4u
Round 6: UI: cuthut.com/e2J
Round 7: Online Experience: cuthut.com/cwA
Round 8: Media Playback cuthut.com/sti
Round 9: cuthut.com/9mO
Round 10 Part 1: Exclusive Games: cuthut.com/cYN
Round 10 Part 2: Exclusive Games: cuthut.com/Die
Round 11: The Future: cuthut.com/neT
Here in 2022! Can we take the time to acknowledge how ahead of it’s time this review series is. Almost every UA-cam video is like this one now. Well produced and researched.
i agree, this man is a legend.
2023here
loved watching this when i was like 9 years old lmao
Real Gamers don't care about what console you play on. Who cares if you play Wii, PS3, Xbox 360, WiiU, PS4, Xbox One or PC. We are gamers, not politicians.
That's like saying a real car enthusiast doesn't have any knowledge or care about what's actually under the hood and what those components do.
No real gamers like the one you talk about don't care where their money goes. Real gamers eventually save up for a Gaming PC and that's it. No need to upgrade every so years because the top processor now is very capable and in the futurw becomes cheaper so an SLI set up becomes apparant which power that system to immense power
kapil busawah yeah
+Kazuto Kirigaya Hell Ya Buddy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kapil busawah Except when its too expensive that parents wont buy it :3
It really sucks.
"Anti-aliiiiiasing" lol
Ya Wtf lol alayasing?
FroztiProductions it cleans up rough edges
And has to say it like 50 times too.
Except for that one time while talking about Uncharted 2.
What an amazing video for 14 YEARS AGO!
The PS3 is right strange system. It looks as though they have handed off some of the work from each component on to the next, and so on. I get both side of the story now. Sony had some great ideas and Xbox was already a good solid system, more simple to code for. The PS3 was a slightly more powerful system as a whole but something very different than the 360. I think the PS3 still has more to give to new games. Whoever invented the architecture must have been on some strong drugs at the time :)
Michael F I've see speculation saying that Sony only made the PS3 to launch the Cell and bring down the production costs. I don't know if it is true but it sounds like business as usual to me.
Michael F Yea, the minimum selling cost was going to be over $1000! PC already had that market, and did the job better.
I wouldn't say it was a little more powerful. The PS3 was a lot more powerful then the Xbox when taking 100% advantage of the CPU/GPU, but yes I agree it was a pain in the ass to develop for therefore games were just ports of an Xbox 360, well they were not as good, but man I wish devs would take the time to put more effort in the PS3 durring it's life cycle devs could have created beautiful games. Just look at the last of us, uncharted serious etc etc.
@@Fazer1971 as a whole yes the ps3 was a lot more powerful when it was utilized properly, problem is the only people that truly utilized it was naughty dog and pse titles. because they didn't have to develop for another platform. this is very telling that developers were not willing to risk their profit to try and code properly for the ps3, and this leads directly back to the way sony designed the ps3. powerful console, with crap design.
@@Fazer1971 Just look at RDR 1 frame rate and graphics between PS3/Xbox 360.I'm sure Xbox 360 had a superior GPU.
Thank you for this video series. I have both consoles, and I also work as a systems engineer, so I have some detailed knowledge of the hardware on both consoles. I love both systems, and each has its own share of pros and cons. I find your videos to be truthful, unbiased, and straightforward.
Wow i miss watching these videos for the first time when the last gen console war was raging
12 years ago... the battle of a lifetime... how tf is this video so high quality?
Man, i love your reviews! You actually take a look at the facts and your reviews aren't biased. About time i can actually learn about these two systems in depth without bias. Ive subscribed! :D
this was the shit back on 2009 lol , even HD5870 was high end ,
times really change since i saw this vid last time
imagine now with RTX 3090
@@EricCartman056imagine now with rtx 4090
@@vdvdjdjdsimo imagine now with Tegra X1+
I had a HD 5850 and that thing was almost as fast. I upgraded to gtx 960 in 2015 and didnt felt it was much faster than I bought the gtx 970 and yes that would considerably faster.
Ps4 owns Xbox one
Okay fanboy..now go home.
PLAYSTATION 4 LYF
Geoff you too xb fan
I came from the future to tell you that the XBOX ONE X owns ;)
Carlos Plascencia lol you replied to that comment 3 years later rofl
Great work putting this series together this way.
If alias is pronounced a-lee-ess why would you say aliasing differently lol you sounded like Microsoft Sam.
This was the last interesting console generation. Each consoles were very unique to each other. The generations that followed were all amds and doesn’t have much difference at all.
This 4 year old video was helpful, I lowered my Xbox 360 resolution to 720p and now Borderlands' textures looks way better with decent anti aliasing too. :D
Best advanced fair versus ever made!
I've seen this comparison in early 2010 and it's still going strong
like for look in 2017
I love PlayStation 3, but i have to admit that Xbox360 is better... in the exclusive games of PS3 there's a lot of lag!
+Seitan Alba I havent
+Fco Fjellström well your ps3 must have been a piece of shit cause i played games on ps3 and they worked fine when i played on 360 omg it was awful just awful.
+A_Salty_Gamer cuz u have bad internet
but ps3 rock graphics watch gta 5
@@a_salty_gamer7720 you are talking out your asshole my friend, cause even the developers stated the ps3 was a nightmare to develop for.
What is the game being shown at 5:22? At first I thought it was Red Dead Redemption but I don't remember the graphics being that good or that type of font used for the on screen text.
Call of Juarez
I did look up Wii U teardown but none of the articles said anything about GHz. I Looked up Wii U tech specs instead and found an IGN article saying it uses a Triple-core, 3 GHz PowerPC-based 45 nm CPU, very similar to the Xbox 360 chip with 768kb of DRAM “embedded” with the CPU, and shared between CPU and GPU.
again there is a massive issue with your analysis, when you did this analysis, the only games on the ps3 that looked really good was uncharted games. and this was directly because the setup between the gpu ram and cell processor, which means the ps3 had to work harder to get close to the same effect, where as the 360 shared the memory, as you stated unified. which made communication between the xenos and xenon processor so much more smooth, some might even say that the memory configuration on the ps3 was an actual bottle neck. due to how it had to communicate and share the load.
An upated edition of this series prior to the 8th-gen consoles would've been interesting considering the later years of both consoles definitely were interesting, especially for the PS3. Skyrim running poorly on the PS3 comes to mind due to the split pools of RAM, along TLOU pushing the PS3 to its limits right as the PS4 was coming out a year later.
*later that year.
In a simple way.
PS3 can reach Life-Like graphics.
Xbox can reach Shiny graphics.
aah the good old days of Console Wars. PS2,Ps3.. and Xbox`s .... Miss these times so much
Everyone makes mistakes, or you think that you are perfect?
i have both 360 and ps3
I liked my ps3 better
now I only play on ps4
you are fucked
bruh xbox is wayy better
u got shit
@@mohammadsohelahmed679 My switch are way better than your old xbot
LOL Anti ali-asing ;P
I remember when the first time I watched this video 5 years ago, I was really blown away by the graphics of the games shown in this comparison. Fast forward this year, I'm laughing to myself realizing that these visuals were just comparable to Android and iOS :p
lmao ps3 has way better graphics then android
Depends on how much you're willing to invest in your computer. The way it works is the more you spend on the best parts available at the time the computer should last longer than the specs I listed above. Most people don't upgrade their computer every year though, I update my PC every 3-4 years. I usually spend $1000-$1500 on my pc's, sometimes I might update the GPU and CPU in-between the 3-4 years.
So wait if I have my xbox 360 running at 720p with hdmi I'll get better textures?
Xbox 360
guys if you want a fantastic gaming experience just move along to pc gaming
you explained me the GPU perfectly for my computer classes
"Maybe next generation"
11 years later and the Xbone runs certain games at 720p
have u heard about xbox one X? heheheh it can move 4K, unlike PS4 pro.
@@nightwisher23
And it only took 12 years
@TheLegend well the series X is more powerful than ps5
Yeah u wish next generation will have always 1080p resulution always "D
he didnt say 1080p, he said hopefully next generation will always be hd.. technically 720p counts as hd
And here we are ;) 4K
Jodie Frampton only on PC and the Xbox One X though
Ps4 managed to be 1080p on most games last gen. Can't say the same about the base xbox one
XBOX 360 have a good HD graphics, more realistic lighting and effects. But PS3 is little bit uglier. The lighting and the effects (such as explosions, lightning strikes, bullet shots, etc..) are not good as XBOX 360.
*****. Sorry i'm newbie at english and also auto correction
***** Dont make fun of people if they dont come from a english speaking country.
***** how are they supposed to chat to most people in these videos.
***** Wow you have some serious swearing, racial and homophobe issues that i'd recommend getting checked out. And do that soon before you get in some serious trouble with racism or something. And judging by your one cuss word use, i'd say that your way to young to be on the internet. Just saying
Good battle!!!
Oh, I played Kinect Adventures with my cousin. It was fun. I just have a feeling motion gaming is going to be mainly used in the 8th and 9th gen.
Well the PS3 exclusive games has an AMAZING stories.
Xbox 360 is better
Yahya Elgayar U suck and swallow
xbox is the best and in this video the guy only has the cheapest version of xbox 360 i have slim the highest price one and its deffinetly better than ps 1-4
Mile0 and you are 10 years old kid,stfu .
Yahya Elgayar Best comeback, so original, like you haven't used that one before.
Mile0 i don't get what you are saying.
ps4 runs at 1080 natively
At times. Quite a few games actually.
***** Atleast most of its games run higher than 720p, unlike the Xbox One that most of its games run at 720p.
Xbox one runs at 900p not 720p
+DuBsTeP Bro 13 Well more than 50 percent of xbox's games are running on 1080p
True
"there are no games that run at 1080p on either console."
Kratos would beg to differ
Hola...is anybody still alive here?
you forgot about the most important thing. PS3 has GDDR3 memory which is just a lot faster than the DDR3 xbox 360 has. every one knows that PS3 handles graphics and frame rates better than xbox.
Nope.avi
XB360 uses GDDR3 as well. Also, when comparing multiplatforms at least, the Xbox 360 always wins with better framerates and sometimes better graphics. One major exception being GTA V. PS3 won both the graphics and framerate rounds on that one.
true. but XBOX has only GDDR3. but PS3 has also half of XDR memory which is clocked at 3.2 GHZ. way faster than XBOX.
I think texture loading has more to do with asset streaming from HDD and ODD than RAM, though
I do wonder what made Sony do that split ram shit..imagine 512MB of 3GHz XDR Ram in 2006. :D
lie ps3 is worsted when it comes to frame rates
Everyone? no, just you invented that, check out all the multiplatforms, PS3 sucked in framerates and texture quality.
whats the game at 4:05
Ghost busters
Cole Intrieri Thank U Very Much Buddy!!!
Cole Intrieri i love you man
Damn this video is so well done for 2009
really high quality videos for the time!
wii u has better graphics
Wii master race
Wii has the worst graphics
Search wii vs ps3 or x360
+YOURNAME Gamer wii U (U) (U) (U are an idoit) jk
lol
+YOURNAME Gamer he said wii u
the xbox 360 is the best
that's your opinion
lol xbox is not win on Controllers and the power......ps3 are the win in controllers and the power
Xbox Controllers are using AA Battery........PS3 controllers are not using aa battery and rechargeable...........
do any of these kids know how to use grammar in proper vernacular?
Ps3 had far better exclusives...
nobletea 3400 Kid, get on with your sad excuse for a 'life' and stop wasting my time.
Dude, the thing has been out for 3 fucking months, they'll be plenty awesome games coming
Nice comeback, who came up with that? And really do you know what anti aliasing really is?
I JUST got this PC in the summer. It's been a game changer (no pun intended) and you could build a PC that performs just as well for $500, but I went all out with the case, fans, CPU cooler because I need it for audio engineering. Give it a try, you'll never go back. Come join the master race.
The XBOX 360 proportion is like an i7 to an RTX3080. The PS3 proportion is like an i7 to an MX330.
I noticed that with FFXIII and XIII-2. The color are much brighter, makes the PS3 counterparts look a little lifeless sometimes.
It was the Xbox 360 that was holding gaming back during the 7th generation due to it using DVD while PlayStation was using Blu-ray which had more space on it then a DVD
Wanna know something that acutally makes sense? The Xbox has a better GPU as know, with 48 unified shaders. The WiiU's GPU has over 500 Unified Shaders which leads to less bottlennecking. WiiU was also the first console to run a Native HD resolution which means it cans easily upscale to 1080p. The GPU is embedded with the graphics processor and aside from the main system memory which is used as a framebuffer.
This video did not age at all. This looks like the future compared to other creators in 2009. Most can't even get this in 2022.
The major downside of the Cell architecture is that it requires a lot of knowledge, time and money to use its full potential. But if you have the knowledge, time and money, the end result you can get is very impressive. The architecture for the Xbox 360 CPU is simular to those of PC's. It's already for a couple of years now that developers say the Xbox 360 has reached its limits. The Cell processor in the PS3 can still do more than what we have seen to date. Cell is underrated, not a mistake.
GUYS DONT FORGET THIS WAS 3 YEARS AGO!
I couldn't agree more. I was so frustrated when they switched from the original 'Blade' Xbox 360 dashboard to the 'Next Xbox Experience' dashboard. I thought it was nice looking at first. But then I noticed how every page was filled with ads which I didn't care about at all. And with the most recent updates (together with the release of Windows 8), they made it even worse. One page is about your games, 4 pages are about apps and advertisements. It's horrible. >:(
This guy should be awarded a medal for being the most unbiased person in the world!
Yes, I know I made mistakes, I was in a rush. I'm not a 24/7 computer guy. I also am more of a PC gamer because gaming computers have better graphics and other sorts of stuff. Thank you for your information, I got to go.
plz update these videos and make a new series of these xboxes and playstations have evolved their controllers have too.
I think its apparent that Sony and NVidia make some very odd choices on the ps3, if you listen to developers and more importantly how cpu and gpu hardware have progressed since the release of these consoles. You will see that Microsoft made some more intelligent choices of hardware that was ultimately more favourable for most developers. I'm glad to see that the next gen consoles are using similar hardware designs that will enable easier development. I just hope Microsoft doesn fuck it up
And yes, Shadowing, high-res textures, Folliage, reflection, and lighting make or break a game, especially when it's a game like Skyrim. I play with mods such as HD Flora, More/lush grass,lush trees, weather mods, 2K HD texture pack, Sky UI, some amazing ENB lighting mods. Step 1. Go to Skyrim Nexus Mods. Step 2. Acquire some glasses. Step 3: Paste: SKYRIM ENHANCED SHADERS FX - ENB. Step 4. Admit it looks 100x better on PC. There's no denying it.
In 0:02 you said cpus
Both have changed a great deal. I think he needs to redo some of the episodes for season 3!
Yep, it definantly shows too on in-depth comparisons.
I can't tell you how many multi-plats I bought for Xbox over Ps3 just because the Xbox 360 version will end up with better graphics, framerates, etc.
very very very incorrect. most ps3 games have a 1080p/i UPSCALE option. Most ps3 games (not sure about exclusives) run at 576p and can be upscaled to 720p or 1080p/i to compensate for the lower resolution.
OK...why are you comparing consoles that are not even out yet?
Well there are seven SPE's on the PS3's Cell processor, since one is always blacked out (in order to increase yields, as a Cell processor with one defective SPE still remains usable) and one of those is dedicated to the operating system. What games have on their disposal is thus the core, six SPE's and the RSX. And a SPE isn't really a core but a co-processor on which the single core can offload some (read: most) of its workload.
Microsoft actually payed IBM to have the RSX design prints. The time of the 360's release the GPU found in the 360's motherboard was EXACTLY if not identical to the RSX prototype found in the DEH-R1000 (Older Variant of the DECR-1000) This version of the RSX was known to crack easily to thermal shock. This is why retail ps3's were less prone to YLOD's because they had I finalised version of the RSX. NOT some stolen RSX prototype found in units DEH-R1000, older than the Developer DECR units.
He also forgot to mention PS3 has ANOTHER GPU, which means Both Xbox and PS3 have 48 pixel pipelines. But Xbox doesn't have any vertex pipelines and PS3 has 16. This video gave you the wrong info.
Comparing modern PCs to these 7 year old consoles would be the same as me comparing a PS1 to an Atari 2600.
If it's about GPU. Xbox 360 wins this round!
Yeah, no. You can build a dual-GPU APU rig for $400, add in massive bulk discounts and a deal with AMD for future-tech and they could sell a PS4 for $350 that's more powerful than a similar $700 rig. Not only that but you pay $400 or less for the PS4(don't kid yourself, it won't cost more than that) and you're set. You pay $600 for a decent computer rig at the moment and you'll have to upgrade it to compare with a PS4, plus the longer they work with the PS4 the more advanced the games get.
that explanation was amazing, you´re the boss :D
Jesus the score is even, and you guys still debating? I'm going back to play my gameboy
i own an Xbox but honestly i like both the consoles im sick of all the people arguing over which is better,yes you can argue about the little things that are better on each but at the end of the day their both game consoles, they both get the jobs done.
At least you're being respectful.
5:22, which game?
Your statement depends whether the developers use the CBE or not.
Not at similar pricepoints, also retail purchases without DRM are an option on console- that choice has been taken away from gamers on PC due to platforms like Steam.
All rumors are pointing toward a dual-GPU APU PS4, and when you optimize games for one set of hardware the performance can nuke that of generalized development(PCs, smartphones). PCs can be more powerful, but only if they have waaay better specs than the PS4- this means $400 graphics cards, etc.
I'd like to have a comparisson between these GPUs and the Wii U's. To find out how much more powerfull it really is, or is not.
What LP is saying is that the Blu-Ray format is capable of storing uncompressed textures on the disc thanks to the 25GB of space it has (i'm fairly certain that the PS3 doesn't use the 50GB Blu-Ray format). Also, i would have to strongly disagree with your statement regarding Assassin's Creed III looking better than any of the PS3 exclusives. Being an owner of both consoles, and ACIII on 360, I can say that it is inferior in terms of graphics compared to Uncharted 3 and other exclusives I own
The Xenos CPU (Xbox 360) is also PowerPC so if they're both PowerPC then what the hell is it that makes dev's complain?
The RSX came in because Toshiba wasn't making progress on their own custom GPU, so Sony went to NVidia to get a GPU for the PS3. Would that Toshiba GPU been better than the NVidia RSX?
i cant wait until our systems can play all games at 1080p and high res textures
Yes, when you look at it now a days. But this video was uploaded in '09, and most things aren't relevant anymore.. consolewise and gameswise.
Fifa street, god of war, gt 5, Tekken 5 dark resurrection, wipeout hd and more...
Umm.. You're probably looking at the Cell processor which is right next to the GPU...
Jesus, this shit is so over my head.
still watching in 2020, just bought a PS3
Blu ray is used solely for movies not games and that is what a lot of people fail to understand. A lot of PS3 game graphics have inferior graphics to PS3 and if you don't believe me you can watch graphic comparisons on youtube.
Rosewill Stallion RD 500 PSU - $50
AMD FX 6300 = $120
MSI 970-A G46 - $80
CM HAF 912 - $55
XFX Double D Radeon - $179
WD Blue 500GB Hard drive - $55
Crucial Ballistix 8GB Sport Ram - $64
Total - $603
There's your gaming PC, It's priced the same as the Xbox1/PS4
The title doesn't say Xbox 360 vs PS3 vs PC
like if you were to busy experiencing his game play rather than listening
I love how you're taking PS3 vs Xbox 360, and you aren't taking into consideration that the Xbox 360 Elite is better then the original Xbox 360
its common knowledge that most games that run on consoles are played at lower resolutions and up scaled to 1080p.
Also I'd hope they are putting something equivalent to a 680 into their consoles as they expect the life span of the consoles to be another 6 - 9 years.
What would be the point of releasing a "next gen" consoles with lower specs then current generation PC?
Can we please take into account that, if you decide to upgrade the hardware of your console midway through its life cycle, developers are going to have to design these games to run on this new hardware, as well as release an update for the old games to run on this new hardware. Then there will have to be software management on this new console so the new games will run on the old hardware. It's either that or put another CPU/GPU on the board and hardware emulate it, thus raising the price.
By the way Forza Motorsports 3 and 4 runs at 1080p and Halo 4 so there is some 360 games that run at 1080p native
What game is that? 5:13
It's ghostbuster the video game
@@dragonfistX200 thank you! I’m surprised someone responded haha
1.Consoles have more AAA games because they have less piracy.
2.yes I have and have you ever seen a PSN sale?