Why Did Google Stadia FAIL?!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,1 тис.

  • @ActManTV
    @ActManTV  2 роки тому +1921

    Unthink the things you think are things.
    Buy product.

    • @christianmoreno638
      @christianmoreno638 2 роки тому +41

      yo this really sold me

    • @adityagarg3931
      @adityagarg3931 2 роки тому +34

      The moment Walter white became Heisenberg

    • @artvandalleigh7894
      @artvandalleigh7894 2 роки тому +28

      Unlearn everything you think you know about sound purchasing decisions!
      ...do you feel like buying our product yet?
      No?
      Well shit, better pull the plug.

    • @skidooshbag12
      @skidooshbag12 2 роки тому +18

      "Forget boxes, forget consoles, FORGET RESPONSIVE CONTROLS"

    • @Maverekt
      @Maverekt 2 роки тому +9

      I bought product… now what?

  • @SilverSpireZ
    @SilverSpireZ 2 роки тому +1708

    Imagine having a shorter lifespan than the Wii U

    • @Santoryu90
      @Santoryu90 2 роки тому +176

      and being worse

    • @ActManTV
      @ActManTV  2 роки тому +379

      oof

    • @fiercelypolygons3696
      @fiercelypolygons3696 2 роки тому +85

      It lasted just 1 more year than the Ouya lmao.

    • @gingeralebean5375
      @gingeralebean5375 2 роки тому +63

      Having asked for an Xbox 360 for Christmas 2013 (when I was 12) and getting a *more expensive* Wii U and being stuck with it until late 2018... I felt that one

    • @sacredbeastzenon
      @sacredbeastzenon 2 роки тому +38

      @@gingeralebean5375
      Wow. That's child abuse!

  • @AEUGH426
    @AEUGH426 2 роки тому +3806

    Let’s be real, stadia died before it ACTUALLY died…

    • @TruePT
      @TruePT 2 роки тому +36

      Fax

    • @kimikothetanuki314
      @kimikothetanuki314 2 роки тому +66

      The idea itself was stupid

    • @m4xw3ll75
      @m4xw3ll75 2 роки тому +102

      @@kimikothetanuki314 the idea wasn’t that bad actually, streaming your games and playing them were ever on whatever that’s dope, but in the year we’re in I’m not surprised it flopped. Maybe few more decades? Maybe never?

    • @jedoilar2937
      @jedoilar2937 2 роки тому +55

      Let’s be honest…. It was stillborn.

    • @GBomb9704
      @GBomb9704 2 роки тому +24

      The truth is, Stadia was dead from the start.

  • @RealTomahawk7
    @RealTomahawk7 2 роки тому +454

    It honestly felt that Stadia was doomed to fail.
    I remember only getting ads for Stadia only at the beginning of its life and nothing afterwards.
    and honestly, I don't think even Google themselves knew what it was they were promoting.

    • @Thanatos2996
      @Thanatos2996 2 роки тому +10

      They sent me a free Chromecast and controller bundle to try it out supprisingly late in its life (mid 2021), so they were still trying for a while. It was always going to fail, the model made no sense, but they gave it the ol' college try anyway.

    • @TheRealNintendoKid
      @TheRealNintendoKid 2 роки тому +1

      right? i heard about it before it came out, and then i heard nothing about it again. I honestly wasn't sure it ever even got off the ground at all.

    • @mrhamburgler480
      @mrhamburgler480 Рік тому

      got 6 months for free with DTV. used it to bear darksiders genesis/3. kinda a shane they effed it up so bad cause it worked just fine.

    • @GibsonHReviews
      @GibsonHReviews Рік тому

      I remember all my ads were Abt stadia and they didn't intrigue me one bit!

  • @JeremyBX
    @JeremyBX 2 роки тому +257

    If i recall correctly, The closest thing Google ever did to promoting Stadia was redesign the Game Controller emoji 🎮 to look like Stadia's own Controller.
    Well, 🎮.

    • @whosaidthat84
      @whosaidthat84 2 роки тому +33

      It's funny because the design is so generic that nobody even noticed, me included.

    • @theonlydiego1
      @theonlydiego1 2 роки тому +15

      I’m on iOS so it just looks like and Xbox controller with the stick layout of the Playstation with two red buttons and two black buttons like a Nintendo. It’s so! generic. 🎮

    • @felixnuwahid9879
      @felixnuwahid9879 Рік тому +1

      🎮 really? :o

    • @alexandredasilvavilasboasrosas
      @alexandredasilvavilasboasrosas Рік тому +1

      🕹️

    • @IceBlueLugia
      @IceBlueLugia Рік тому +2

      On iOS it just looks like an Xbox controller with symmetrical sticks

  • @flameguy8025
    @flameguy8025 2 роки тому +1639

    The fact that Google, a titan of modern software technology can’t get into the console market just shows how hard it is to join without an initial audience like Valve with the steam deck.

    • @SnifferSock
      @SnifferSock 2 роки тому

      I wouldn't trust Google with the data they would have got from this.

    • @Overlord598
      @Overlord598 2 роки тому +190

      Valve steadily built their influence over many, many years to get where it is now... Google is too lazy to do that and gives up early with every project that isnt an instant popular cash cow lol

    • @r.daneel.90
      @r.daneel.90 2 роки тому +44

      Yes, but actually not. Google didnt even tried.

    • @mandolorian9893
      @mandolorian9893 2 роки тому +86

      Google wasn't trying to get into the console market. They were trying to replace the console market by thinking they could use streaming.

    • @Internetismyfriend
      @Internetismyfriend 2 роки тому +7

      I'm pretty sure it was due to the lack of support and the amount they promised on release and failed to keep. It came out as a large and glitchy mess

  • @SethizFTW
    @SethizFTW 2 роки тому +761

    I hate not owning games

    • @discod992
      @discod992 2 роки тому +117

      We don't own games anymore we rent licenses. It's a whole lot of bullshit.

    • @NikkoNikko98
      @NikkoNikko98 2 роки тому +52

      Get into handhelds & retro gaming, that’s a great way to know you own your game

    • @MeltonCrest
      @MeltonCrest 2 роки тому +82

      @@discod992 If you pirate it you own it. It's your own fault, if you keep "voting with your wallet" you're telling them that's exactly what you want.

    • @theironrhino110
      @theironrhino110 2 роки тому +50

      Disc gang rise up!

    • @cerjmedia
      @cerjmedia 2 роки тому

      @@MeltonCrest good luck trying to pirate games on the xbox, playstation, and switch where a majority of the gaming marketplace is. Is it possible? Sure, but let's not sit here and act like it's just downloading a rom file

  • @Creed5.56
    @Creed5.56 2 роки тому +592

    Game streaming is not going to be a reality for a while. The #1 issue is response time/delay. If you’re listening to a song that’s delayed from Spotify’s servers by 5 seconds, the entire song will play back with the 5sec delay, sounding perfectly normal. With game streaming, players can interact with the video, and a 5 sec delay between pressing A and jumping will be immediately noticeable and a horrible experience

    • @winlover37
      @winlover37 2 роки тому +75

      At the end of the day I just don't see why streaming is necessary in the first place. While you're streaming a game, there's still a machine on the other end that's actually running the game locally. Why would I want to pay someone else to run the game for me? With latency added on top of it?

    • @Creed5.56
      @Creed5.56 2 роки тому +24

      @@winlover37 I feel like it’s coming, in the 90s nobody thought blockbuster or music CDs were gonna fade into obscurity… granted I wasn’t alive but still

    • @winlover37
      @winlover37 2 роки тому +24

      @@Creed5.56 I guess it's always possible, but music and movie distribution are a lot different from video games.

    • @fernandogimenez7520
      @fernandogimenez7520 2 роки тому +8

      Like those tv games in the 90´s that works with the phone when you press a button and the sounds travels to the "studio". (press 8 to jump) biip.... 3 seconds delays

    • @KaiserMattTygore927
      @KaiserMattTygore927 2 роки тому +17

      @@Creed5.56 The difference is, there's far more advantages in moving away from VHS and Cassettes for CDs and eventually downloading.
      I'm seeing way too many downsides with Streaming over where we're at now.
      I don't have any control over local files (already an instant no for me) the Latency issue, ownership issue, even a moment of bad internet can cause problems.

  • @matodragonespor5000
    @matodragonespor5000 2 роки тому +197

    The idea that I really liked about Stadia was that supposedly I could be able to play, for example, Cyberpunk 2077 in ultra with RTX in my old 2014 PC or my living room smart tv, without worrying about specs. Heck, apparently you could be able to play AAA games in your smart phone! But for some reason, their advertisement didn't focused on that and, well, Stadia itself had a lot of performance issues...

    • @Therealbrez
      @Therealbrez 2 роки тому +3

      Stadia was actually really good for my living situation, I don't have a lot of time to play many games and I don't have a lot of living space so Google stadia's low upfront price was attractive to me. Honestly haven't noticed the latency too. I'd buy the tech off of them if they're selling it.

    • @christophermccoy151
      @christophermccoy151 2 роки тому +10

      Gamepass cloud gaming > stadia

    • @EDARDO112
      @EDARDO112 2 роки тому +3

      The ideia was cool but input latency kills it, Nvidia tried that before. Computer and consoles are expensive and in streaming u don't need to pay that cost.

    • @DonJohn87_YT
      @DonJohn87_YT 2 роки тому +1

      There's still xbox cloud streaming and nvidia now, have way more faith in both those companies

    • @Frame_Late
      @Frame_Late 2 роки тому +1

      @@christophermccoy151 This. And it's cheaper because all the games are free. Plus more games. Plus Xbox worked with Razor to make custom hardware for mobile gaming.

  • @imightbeaz
    @imightbeaz 2 роки тому +116

    I remember rolling my eyes when I saw Stadia first launch. I had a gut feeling it wouldn't last.

    • @drbeavis4211
      @drbeavis4211 2 роки тому

      I feel that way about many big projects by companies that aren't already established in this industry. As soon as Amazon announced thier game, I was like.. meh. Maybe. Probably not.

    • @ThePhoenixScribe
      @ThePhoenixScribe 2 роки тому

      Same. Especially with PS Now which kinda was the precursor to this. I knew it wasn't gonna last long.

    • @qunt100
      @qunt100 Рік тому

      @@drbeavis4211 Amazon luna ironically is still around. I just checked.

  • @ZER-sc3pc
    @ZER-sc3pc 2 роки тому +115

    I love how the trailer is saying “it doesn’t take up any space” as a selling point, but the room they’re in has more than enough of it.

    • @FourDozenEggs
      @FourDozenEggs 2 роки тому +10

      Also, who the hell complains that consoles and PCs take up space?

    • @D3K018
      @D3K018 2 роки тому +1

      Maybe it was advertised for people that pay a ton of money on very tiny places in cities like NYC or London where there's literally no room for anything besides a bed and some clothes... 🤔

    • @HaohmaruHL
      @HaohmaruHL 2 роки тому +3

      Especially funny considering that it comes from an American who basically live in the biggest living space in the world. If even a tiny Japanese apartment can afford space for several gaming systems then so can everyone els e.

    • @KingSlimeProductions
      @KingSlimeProductions 3 місяці тому

      @@FourDozenEggs ikr lol "NOO MY GAMING PC TAKES UP A FOOT AND A HALF OF SPACE WHAT AM I GONNA DO?!?!?!?"

  • @Santoryu90
    @Santoryu90 2 роки тому +147

    It felt like Google really underestimated game development thinking it be easy and just kinda gave up on it half way through.

    • @toututu2993
      @toututu2993 2 роки тому

      Nah they just throw money around to show of to people with their stinking server infrastructure.

    • @Trigger99X
      @Trigger99X 2 роки тому +2

      Amazon is pretty similar in that regard

    • @falendemo546
      @falendemo546 2 роки тому

      @@Trigger99X --- they even have almost the same description on The Cutting Room Floor wiki.

  • @willko88
    @willko88 2 роки тому +427

    I could never figure out who Stadia was meant for. It's not going to appeal to hardcore gamers because of the inherent input lag with the whole concept. It's not going to appeal to casual gamers because of the pricing model. And, it's not going to appeal to non-gamers because they don't know what the eff it is.

    • @DonVigaDeFierro
      @DonVigaDeFierro 2 роки тому +60

      Plus, if you have enough to pay for an internet connection able to stream in 4k (even if Stadia ganes never truly ran in 4k), you have enough to buy a decent gaming PC...

    • @DonDadda45
      @DonDadda45 2 роки тому +16

      @@DonVigaDeFierro hm, not really. High speed Internet (enough for 4k at least) an be bought for quite cheap nowadays, and most people use their regular internet way more than they game. Saving up for a good PC can take quite a while

    • @AdmiralBison
      @AdmiralBison 2 роки тому +12

      @@DonDadda45 there are a lot of mid level pcs that can play AAA games good enough.
      Again
      Console gamers have their consoles already
      PC gamers get high end machines and now also have the option to play it anywahere with handheld gaming pcs (and boy are they becoming more numerous and more powerful now)
      Who is Stadia going to appeal to?
      Casuals are fickle and most likely just play games on their phones.
      I’ll never go ‘Games as a service/Streaming’
      Because I like to own my games and not have to keep paying for them every month.

    • @marcwilliams9824
      @marcwilliams9824 2 роки тому +15

      It takes a remarkable amount of skill to design something that is unappealing to everyone.

    • @toututu2993
      @toututu2993 2 роки тому +3

      @@DonDadda45 Really??? If you can't buy Switch, cheap PC parts that can run most games, or anything else,. Then you need to get a job and earn some money.

  • @haustyl12
    @haustyl12 2 роки тому +23

    My experience with Stadia is exactly how your experience went. I was at Pax West 2019 looking for a booth that had Doom Eternal and found that only Stadia had the demo. So I played it but found there were latency issues and the game ultimately crashed several times. At that point I didn’t even finish the demo and left. Never heard of Stadia again until they announced its end

  • @nickthemelon2438
    @nickthemelon2438 2 роки тому +2

    8:37 I do recall seeing a lot of Stadia ads on UA-cam, my friend said he had never seen any until a few minutes after I had brought them up (this was 5 months after they announced it or something, meaning he had no idea what Stadia was despite spending a lot of time on UA-cam). From what I remember of the advertisements, they never explained what Stadia was or showed what it really did. The name was mentioned but... that was just it.

  • @antonioavila7493
    @antonioavila7493 2 роки тому +185

    Stadia was a nice option for me when I first saw it (2019). I had no PC but a nice Internet connection. The idea of playing on a gaming PC remotely.... was nice for me. However, 3 years later i got a nice job and bought my own PC. The rest was history.

    • @MrHoovy-zo7bc
      @MrHoovy-zo7bc 2 роки тому +7

      Good for you man!

    • @IronicalChronical
      @IronicalChronical 2 роки тому +6

      Stadia would have been an option but then I realized I don’t have the best WeeFi, so games ran like dog scat compared to downloading, which is why downloading is king.

    • @yolsil775
      @yolsil775 2 роки тому +2

      Congrats on the good job!

    • @toututu2993
      @toututu2993 2 роки тому +1

      Stadia is like looking for an animal that is as small as an ant but have a force to lift a car like an Elephant

  • @1cooooolguy
    @1cooooolguy 2 роки тому +298

    I remember when stadia was first coming out. People in the industry pointed out “it’s Google. They won’t support this in a few years” and I agreed with that, remembering Google+ and hangouts being killed. But one of my relatives had decided to go for it, getting the hardware that was available for it and actively using it. I remember we talked about it once and that was it. It wasn’t anything groundbreaking, just a way to play games somewhere else. My biggest issue I saw with it was that I didn’t “own” the games. That if Google killed their service, all those games would be gone, which is exactly what happened (with a benefit that there would be refund (probably to a Google account so you have like $100+ in the Google play store)). Other than that, it wasn’t really cool or anything. No one I game with used stadia for anything. It was like… another launcher in my eyes. I try to avoid those whenever I can.

    • @MyHeadHz
      @MyHeadHz 2 роки тому +20

      Google is obsessed with launches, but not support. According to insiders if you launch as many products as possible you are highly rewarded, but nobody bats an eye if you maintain a product or service for years on end. If you don't incentivize the maintaining of your services, employees will just optimize launching as many half-baked products as possible to get promoted.

    • @Frank451Martin
      @Frank451Martin 2 роки тому +7

      If google actually cared supporting their console and listened to the criticism of the problems that stadia had, it ‘could’ stand out on competing with steam deck or switch in portable gaming
      For longevity, if stadia could access to your gaming accounts on various pc platforms from valve, epic and cd project, it would stand out… if they allow it.

  • @ILIKEP1E
    @ILIKEP1E 2 роки тому +462

    Stadia in a nutshell:
    Promising streaming hardware and technology. (When it works, it works pretty good.)
    Horrible business model and lack of creative direction. (People in charge really don't understand what or how they were selling)
    Tradition of lacking support from Google higher-ups. (They don't invest much and bailed as soon as stadia wasn't reaching their goal)

    • @sambauman69
      @sambauman69 2 роки тому +4

      I notice that in your nutshell on Stadia you didn't say anything about VIDEO GAMES! Did Stadia even have games? No one remembers. They tried to sell us the service itself, not the awesome games the service would let you play.

    • @aldovk6681
      @aldovk6681 2 роки тому +13

      @@sambauman69 they were dumb enough to turn down a kojima exclusive for being "single player"

    • @toututu2993
      @toututu2993 2 роки тому

      @@aldovk6681 While their platform is horrible for multiplayer lol. I love Google for being funny sometime but not their money

  • @jeffcarrier9808
    @jeffcarrier9808 2 роки тому +55

    Ex Stadia hard-core user here. Thanks for getting all the good points of Stadia right, you did your homework and I appreciate that. Too bad Google made it so necessary to do so. Also Doom Eternal played beautifully with no lag a little after it launched. The tech was sadly incredible.

    • @zarthemad8386
      @zarthemad8386 2 роки тому +5

      Pressing "F" to doubt

    • @jeffcarrier9808
      @jeffcarrier9808 2 роки тому +2

      @@zarthemad8386 doubt what exactly?

    • @-8h-
      @-8h- 2 роки тому +9

      The idea may have been cool, but the tech wasn't there. Not to mention it's completely redundant with the existence of steam and other consoles having some similar systems with guaranteed functionality.

    • @jeffcarrier9808
      @jeffcarrier9808 2 роки тому +3

      @@Unwise- with non-terrible internet, the lag was very comparible and sometimes actually better than console. Naturally it would not compete with 120fps twitch pc. They had the wizardry, Doom Eternal 60fps totally playable at max difficulty. The tech is the one thing they nailed.

    • @viewtifulviewer7282
      @viewtifulviewer7282 7 місяців тому

      The fact is existing gamers are locked into their platforms. Ps, xbox, steam. I think that if stadia kept on going and advertised properly etc etc. New younger audiences may have jumped on.

  • @fallen_8521
    @fallen_8521 6 місяців тому +3

    The fact that i just found this video a year later and still didnt know what the fuck stadia was.

  • @wmv8996
    @wmv8996 2 роки тому +123

    My favorite thing that came from stadia was "negative latency"
    It's like blast processing, but no where near as cool.

    • @thechugg4372
      @thechugg4372 2 роки тому +13

      Hey at least blast processing is an actual technology that exists just with a shiny name, "negative latency" is a litteral lie.

  • @Deley18
    @Deley18 2 роки тому +16

    2:17 Stadia's tombstone grave combined with the Taco Bell bong got me rolling in laughter.

  • @gold24k54
    @gold24k54 2 роки тому +28

    When you start a video with sad ODST music, you know it's a serious video.

  • @callumcoulson2982
    @callumcoulson2982 2 роки тому +1

    Bro I had to actively search for this, had no idea that you uploaded it I am subscribed.

  • @Muncible
    @Muncible 2 роки тому +44

    When Stadia was announced I knew that it would never work. It was always seen as a joke amongst my friends. I always thought of it as Google saying "I'm not a kid anymore! Look at what I can do too!" while everyone laughed like a parent does when their children play grown-up.

    • @thisismyyoutubecommentacco6302
      @thisismyyoutubecommentacco6302 2 роки тому +3

      That's funny cause I felt the opposite of your analogy. It felt like Google was doing the "how do you do fellow kids" thing and trying to wade into yet another industry that they had no history in but they figured since they were the big bad alphabet company on the block they would just be able to steamroll over established gaming developers. I have to think Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft, Valve, and Epic were all probably just laughing behind their back.

    • @KingSlimeProductions
      @KingSlimeProductions 3 місяці тому

      @@thisismyyoutubecommentacco6302 i think both your analogy and the original commenter's analogy drive home the same core point: this was Google's way of trying to get into a market they had no familiarity with and no experience in. It went just about as well as you'd expect.

  • @thekingofawesomeness9173
    @thekingofawesomeness9173 2 роки тому +84

    I actually remember tons of those camercials being on UA-cam but they had it advertised hard for like a short time and then it was just gone. I only ever heard about it after that is the angry Joe show would talk about it and even they eventually stopped having reason to talk about it.

    • @crackerjack0349
      @crackerjack0349 2 роки тому +1

      It was literally puff of colored smoke and people yelling stadia

    • @GojoGunning
      @GojoGunning 2 роки тому

      Exactly I remember it like a fever dream

    • @journeytree
      @journeytree 2 роки тому

      commercial* I have no clue what you were thinking when you typed "camercials."

  • @c.w.simpsonproductions1230
    @c.w.simpsonproductions1230 2 роки тому +156

    In hindsight, Microsoft introduced the Xbox at just the perfect time. The Wild West of the 90s console wars was coming to an end and Microsoft pretty much usurped SEGA’s place after their long decline. At this point the Big Three have pretty much solidified their places in the console market while Valve dominates PC.

    • @KaiserMattTygore927
      @KaiserMattTygore927 2 роки тому +17

      Nothing lasts forever. all that needs to happen is an affordable console at the next "perfect time" with an interesting and actually consumer friendly idea to nudge their way into the market.

    • @Daduu
      @Daduu 2 роки тому +13

      And Um.. halo

    • @scalycoronet5198
      @scalycoronet5198 2 роки тому +13

      @@Daduu Yeah it introduced itself at a good time but also quickly solidified itself as the home of the shooter. Something like Stadia isn’t going to work because it isn’t a good time, nobody took it seriously, and it had nothing new to offer

    • @Matanumi
      @Matanumi 2 роки тому +3

      And now value is coming to disrupt the console market with steam deck and Sony with the PS5.....
      Bruh what the fuck is Sony even doing? Hell what even is NEXT GEN anymore? I don't see an incentive to buy XSX and PS5.... I DO see an incentive for steam deck

    • @Matanumi
      @Matanumi 2 роки тому +1

      Current consoles are selling on legacy steam alone

  • @c3lmitz619
    @c3lmitz619 2 роки тому +140

    The moment I heard stadia was gonna be a subscription based service, I knew it was gonna fail. That concept in of itself is not impossible. But with everything becoming an intangible license with an expiration date, not many people would be willing to take that chance to embolden other corps.

    • @Hazzy113
      @Hazzy113 2 роки тому +6

      it wasn't a subscription service, you just had to buy the games...

    • @c3lmitz619
      @c3lmitz619 2 роки тому

      @@Hazzy113 really? Guess I had that whole thing wrong than. 😬

    • @Hazzy113
      @Hazzy113 2 роки тому +5

      @@c3lmitz619 more a problem with their marketing, i thought it was for a while too

    • @c3lmitz619
      @c3lmitz619 2 роки тому +2

      @@Hazzy113 ok I’m im glad I’m not the only one who thought so 😅.

    • @mechano6505
      @mechano6505 2 роки тому +2

      @@Hazzy113 I mean you're still buying licenses off of the service. I got screwed over already when Google shut down Google Play Music, if your reputation is that you kill all of your services where you own things in the cloud then I'm going to go to a different service. I doubt Steam will shut down any time soon.

  • @kempolar9768
    @kempolar9768 2 роки тому +2

    Stadia marketing was like watching a new trailer for a game and then coming out the other side saying "ok I don't even know what genre this game is all you did was show me CGI cutscenes. I don't know if it's a stealth game, a beat em up of even if it's a rythmn based dance game."

  • @supernightslash
    @supernightslash 2 роки тому +5

    As soon as Game Pass kicked in, it murdered any possible chance that Stadia ever had, if there even was any.

  • @PerunaMuayThai
    @PerunaMuayThai 2 роки тому +37

    Decentralized or streaming gaming will never work. Any service interruption ends your game and even if it is working you can't beat the speed of light and the signal's round trip just adds input lag. Find that gif of Gene Park pressing the jump button on a stadia game.

    • @staringcorgi6475
      @staringcorgi6475 6 місяців тому

      It makes sense for movies and music since they don’t require physical controls aside from fast fowarding and stopping movies for the former

  • @jacobyullman5005
    @jacobyullman5005 2 роки тому +85

    Google didn't advertise Stadia on UA-cam? They advertised it INCESANTLY in the beginning. Every video having a Stadia ad was the reason I finally decided to get UA-cam Premium.

    • @speed3414
      @speed3414 2 роки тому +5

      I guess UA-cam Vanced didn't exist at that time
      It's dead now anyway

    • @darkstriker00
      @darkstriker00 2 роки тому +6

      It's kind of hilarious that stadia ads ended up promoting UA-cam premium instead.

    • @comicsans1689
      @comicsans1689 2 роки тому +8

      Imagine not using an ad blocker in current year...

    • @LoliconSamalik
      @LoliconSamalik 2 роки тому +3

      @@comicsans1689 Or a Sponsor Blocker

    • @DRT1089
      @DRT1089 2 роки тому

      ​@@speed3414 look up revanced

  • @perturbedbatman2009
    @perturbedbatman2009 2 роки тому +21

    For the seemingly large investment Google put into the Stadia, the only times I heard of it were when it was announced to be released and when it was announced to be shut down. For four years, I completely forgot it even existed.

    • @fiercelypolygons3696
      @fiercelypolygons3696 2 роки тому

      Alot of the investment went into stadia studios, billions and billions wasted. Then paying devs to put their games on stadia pro. I believe there was even rumours alot of the money went back to Stadia execs and Harrison's wallets.

    • @Kmatt_9262
      @Kmatt_9262 2 роки тому

      @@fiercelypolygons3696 i'm sure they didn't spend billions on stadia

  • @flamingoodness4923
    @flamingoodness4923 2 роки тому +11

    I made fun of it when it got announced. Then I completely forgot about it until they said it’s shutting down. Honestly goes to show how successful stadia was.

  • @wolf-ranger
    @wolf-ranger 2 роки тому +1

    Some of their "selling points" were straight up contradictory.
    Like if my internet is so bad that it takes hours to download an update, then clearly my speed isn't going to support a high resolution/framerate.

  • @rainygamedays5873
    @rainygamedays5873 2 роки тому +37

    I feel like most people either didn't know what this was in the first place, or forgot about it if they did know about it at all 😂

  • @tylerdurden6992
    @tylerdurden6992 2 роки тому +47

    I think the biggest problem was the input lag due to the internet connection to the servers

    • @WIld-cHILd-1273
      @WIld-cHILd-1273 2 роки тому +1

      I can easily imagine so, Google might've had too much ambition in hindsight

    • @FightClass3
      @FightClass3 2 роки тому +1

      That's your internet problem.

    • @acoolrocket
      @acoolrocket 2 роки тому +1

      This here, the only case you'd be playing on a cloud gaming service is if the connections outside is good, but randomly switching between 4G, 3G and H+ just doesn't yield anyhing good.
      Its definitely bad timing but then again Geforce Now is doing good so Stadia definitely did other things wrong.

    • @FightClass3
      @FightClass3 2 роки тому +1

      @@acoolrocket 3G is still a thing?

    • @acoolrocket
      @acoolrocket 2 роки тому +1

      @@FightClass3 Dunno, but half the time I drop from H+ that feels like 3G when I'm trying to even watch a 720p video.

  • @SchazmenRassir
    @SchazmenRassir 2 роки тому +18

    I genuinely didn't realize Stadia came out before COVID. And it shows how badly Google screwed up with it. I never thought it'd gain traction at all, and I'm not surprised. But I do feel bad for the devs who signed up for it.

  • @skeletorishere4110
    @skeletorishere4110 5 місяців тому +1

    I remember how annoying the stadia ads were and said fuck that

  • @user-Jay178
    @user-Jay178 2 роки тому +8

    I felt like it was bound to happen as Google faced a lot lot problems with the Stadia. Great video

  • @CyonisCyberFox
    @CyonisCyberFox 2 роки тому +25

    There just simply wasn't a clear idea on what Stadia's identity was. I get there's a niche for cloud service gaming, but with the way it was executed just didn't cut the right jib like something like Game Pass does

    • @ressljs
      @ressljs 2 роки тому

      I thought they would focus on getting games on mobile devices to go after the Nintendo Switch. As long as you had a good connection (which would get easier as 5G spreads), you could play your games on the go and with Google's servers doing the heavy lifting, you wouldn't have the compromises you get with the Switch. But when I heard it was focused on hooking up a ChromeCast to your TV and paying full price for the games, I thought it was far too weak a sales pitch to compete head to head with PS/XB.

  • @SiskoSvK
    @SiskoSvK 2 роки тому +15

    The main problem is that, it is true that even in the poorest countries people have access to the internet, not everyone have a constant high-bandwith internet with close distance to the game servers. And that's where the ship starts sinking... Not to mention lag and input delay.

  • @felixmaldonado8091
    @felixmaldonado8091 2 роки тому +8

    Act Man did you hear about Red Dead Online Google Stadia, there’s a sad soul that spent thousands of hours on there enjoying the game. Then Rockstar announced that they will not be allowing character transfers from Stadia to other consoles/pc!

  • @wizardgaming6759
    @wizardgaming6759 3 місяці тому

    7:20 to this day, I still don’t know what they were thinking, with offering 50+ games monthly with the subscription service. They should’ve offered way less.

  • @ArtanBlacknight
    @ArtanBlacknight 2 роки тому

    UA-cam is becoming more and more sentient...
    8:53 when Actman is talking about adds on UA-cam and doing some self promotion, a pop-up add for an addblock showed up

  • @bruceelder208
    @bruceelder208 2 роки тому +19

    Not sure if being in the uk was different to the states, but I remember getting ads for stadia ALL THE TIME. I was so tired of them, because they were really safe ads that did nothing new.
    A good comparison to stadia would be geforce now, its runs a lot smoother and has ray tracing options which is pretty impressive.

  • @mitchellman32
    @mitchellman32 2 роки тому +41

    My extent of knowledge & experience of Stadia was seeing that ad once or twice, audibly speaking the word "cringe" and never thinking about it ever again.

  • @devinlain8203
    @devinlain8203 2 роки тому +8

    I smell a lawsuit on behalf of a lot of developers who invested significant sums

  • @ramadaboss5689
    @ramadaboss5689 2 роки тому +4

    I actually was receiving stadia ads on UA-cam. It’s how I even knew about the console. However when I asked my friends if they’d seen those same ads they all said no. Seems like google made a very low “effort” in pushing this thing.

  • @viscountrainbows2857
    @viscountrainbows2857 2 роки тому +1

    "Unthink the things you think are things."
    My head asplode

  • @juanjosetalerogarcia902
    @juanjosetalerogarcia902 2 роки тому +19

    I honestly think stadia had a lot of potential. I think the main issue was the price. Why would anyone would pay a MONTHLY subscription to play games but on top of that you had to pay for the game you wanted to play.

    • @frazierwillard9316
      @frazierwillard9316 2 роки тому

      You only had to pay for the 4k gaming. I bought and played RDR2 for $30 and never had to pay a subscription.

    • @TheRealNintendoKid
      @TheRealNintendoKid 2 роки тому

      no, the main issue is not everybody lives in a big city with gigabit download speed.
      I have 3 options: shitty DSL that maxes out at 4 megabit download on ancient copper phone lines
      even shittier local cable that provides internet with data limits and a crazy per-gigabyte pay scale for anything over the limit
      Cellular internet that's not limited and gives me like 90 megabit download speed... which, while it's not absolutely terrible, it's nothing compared to what comcast and verizon provide.

  • @asiberiantiger188
    @asiberiantiger188 2 роки тому +8

    Yeah, I don't think Google calling us "free range humans" was a very good angle

    • @coyote4326
      @coyote4326 2 роки тому +2

      Well obviously. You're literally a tiger. I'm a coyote. What are we not allowed to play it Google? And what the fuck does "free range humans" even mean?

    • @asiberiantiger188
      @asiberiantiger188 2 роки тому +1

      @@coyote4326 ikr? The nerve of these people to think they can just assume our species

  • @theprotagonist1311
    @theprotagonist1311 2 роки тому +19

    Maybe if Google put as much effort into Stadia as they do with people's data Stadia wouldnt be dead

  • @Blitzkrieg1YT
    @Blitzkrieg1YT 2 роки тому +3

    I remember getting stadia ads nonstop on UA-cam and thinking that for someone who hadn’t researched it like I had, it would be completely unclear what it was. I think they should have shown people actually using the product in the advertisements and it would have been at least a little better

    • @thechugg4372
      @thechugg4372 2 роки тому +1

      Its like they are trying to sell an idea and not an actual released products.

  • @umaydoruk4526
    @umaydoruk4526 2 роки тому +8

    something i didn't know about stadia: asmongold in the ads

  • @asiberiantiger188
    @asiberiantiger188 2 роки тому +9

    Google got rejected harder than me in middle school

    • @Knighthood5394
      @Knighthood5394 2 роки тому +1

      Tuff😔

    • @coyote4326
      @coyote4326 2 роки тому +3

      I remember a girl asking me to the dance in eight grade. I told her yes, then got high with my friends and forgot all about it. Whoops. I mean she's probably married with kids now, but uh, hey - if you're out there then uh... sorry and stuff.

    • @Knighthood5394
      @Knighthood5394 2 роки тому

      @@coyote4326 is it bad that this kinda made me laugh a little?

  • @gameragodzilla
    @gameragodzilla 2 роки тому +7

    I'm most worried about Stadia exclusives, since those games will be gone forever. It's why I always was hesitant about cloud gaming in general and its implication on games preservation.

    • @sambauman69
      @sambauman69 2 роки тому +3

      The sad thing is, that's how Modern Gaming is everywhere. If you play an always online game, you're accepting the fact that some day it will completely cease to exist. Look at the original Overwatch. It's completely gone now.

    • @thechugg4372
      @thechugg4372 2 роки тому +1

      I mean technically overwatch 1 still exists as data, someone could make a private server to revive it.

  • @Wolfmansgeneralchannel
    @Wolfmansgeneralchannel 2 роки тому +16

    Taking a swing myself but I feel it has something to do with the digital only focus they had going for it

  • @o-o0-043
    @o-o0-043 2 роки тому +1

    Nah man I got that Stadia ad on every fucking video and I hated myself everything I was forced to watch it. It made me not want to see what the product even was.

  • @ReclusiarchBraumBT
    @ReclusiarchBraumBT 2 роки тому +2

    I told some coworkers about Stadia's death. Most of them said "What's Stadia?"

  • @CrookGX
    @CrookGX 2 роки тому +38

    You're missing who the core audience for Stadia was; it was meant for people who couldn't afford their own gaming rig. But you're spot on about the rest of this. Cloud gaming just isn't quite where it needs to be yet tech-wise, and Google's business strategy was NOT it.

    • @lv1543
      @lv1543 2 роки тому

      it will never be. the laws of physics says no. the speed of light literally cannot get faster and their solution is some convoluded "ai predicts every input" bullshit.

    • @sgtcoffman
      @sgtcoffman 2 роки тому +14

      It was for someone who could afford to live in a place with good enough internet to run it, but couldn't afford a gaming rig. I live in Montana, it was never going to work well here, our infrastructure is too far behind.

    • @OKMBVideos
      @OKMBVideos 2 роки тому +17

      That's an oddly specific niche, which is part of the problem.
      I used to live in a state in the Midwest of the United States . Said state, particularly in the more up to date areas, had a deal with Comcast where Comcast had what was effectively a government-ordained monopoly. Comcast was the only provider with decent internet in a LARGE area and everyone else was McDonalds wi-fi (or worse). Comcast then took advantage of this position and instituted a Data Cap. You could only use about 1 TB worth of data in a month, and if you went over, you get ABSOLUTELY reamed by Comcast. Of course, you can pay substantially more for a plan without a Data Cap, if you really wanted to, but it wasn't economical. Funnily enough, they removed the Data Caps during the first few months of COVID, and the system ran totally fine. They were just there to take advantage of people and their position.
      I should mention that in virtually every other location that Comcast provides their "service," they also have Data Caps. So, in any location where Comcast is the de-facto internet provider and people can't afford to get the extremely expensive no-data-cap plan, Stadia is completely useless. If you want to do anything other than game on Stadia using your internet, it just isn't gonna happen.

    • @sambauman69
      @sambauman69 2 роки тому +10

      A gaming option for people who can't afford a gaming rig, but requires high cost internet at all times and is significantly more expensive than Xcloud & Gamepass or GForceNow.

    • @MrQ12elve
      @MrQ12elve 2 роки тому

      @@OKMBVideos not to kick you where it hurts, but in the US don't you guys have datacaps ? so if ya use up all ya data, stadia wouldn't run ay ?

  • @willcooper8028
    @willcooper8028 2 роки тому +15

    This news actually came as a surprise to me because I had been operating under the assumption that Stadia was already gone

  • @shinoku250_gaming
    @shinoku250_gaming 2 роки тому +9

    Because it was made by Google, easiest answer for the easiest question in the modern gaming history class.

  • @snakeyman5560
    @snakeyman5560 2 роки тому +1

    So glad that Jacksepticeye got roasted for saying "This is the future of gaming."

  • @scottthewaterwarrior
    @scottthewaterwarrior 2 роки тому +1

    I actually saw ads for Stadia on UA-cam for maybd the while first year it was out. The ads themselves were bad, but the larger issue was I already knew what Stadia was: cloud gaming, AKA, you give the corperate overloards even more control over your purchases then you already do. Heck, I am still a reluctant Steam user, most my PC library is on CDs!

  • @bk_nreynolds3278
    @bk_nreynolds3278 2 роки тому +10

    I remember getting bombarded with Stadia ads here on UA-cam, I’m not sure if I’m the only one

    • @kyle29185
      @kyle29185 2 роки тому +5

      I remember getting bombarded with Stadia ads as well.

    • @TruePT
      @TruePT 2 роки тому +2

      It. Was. EVERYWHERE!

    • @MeltonCrest
      @MeltonCrest 2 роки тому

      How can you still not have an adblocker ffs.

    • @TruePT
      @TruePT 2 роки тому

      @@MeltonCrest Mobile.

  • @peniparker7968
    @peniparker7968 2 роки тому +19

    Just so everyone knows the REAL important story here - the red water bottle at the bottom left of the screen is a brand called ThermoFlask(I recognize the tiny logo). I have 4 of them myself and use them almost every night when going to sleep. Why? - because the ice and water stays cold in the bottle for 8-10 hours easily. Wake up in the middle of the night to cold refreshing drink with no dust! unlike like a regular cup.

    • @Matanumi
      @Matanumi 2 роки тому +1

      Ah.

    • @Krystalmyth
      @Krystalmyth 2 роки тому +1

      Now that's how you advertise a product. Just bought two. Didnt even have to waste half a minute of my time. What a concept.

  • @chucklesdeclown8819
    @chucklesdeclown8819 2 роки тому +8

    it wasn't only that but people got dubious of the claims that the games could be played at 4k 60fps, i remember seeing a video where the games were clearly upscaled or something rather then being 4k so not only was stadia not delivering the games, their claims of being 4k 60 were half truths at best and input lag plagued stadia way too much as well which made it a non viable option.

    • @arrowknee7356
      @arrowknee7356 2 роки тому +1

      It wasn't half truths it was just lies. Some games where 1080 60fps (Destiny 2 for example from memory).

  • @vizthex
    @vizthex 2 роки тому +1

    glad to see the Wii U ad campaign team had more work afterwards.

  • @ssilent8202
    @ssilent8202 2 роки тому +1

    I’ve actually seen many stadia ads on UA-cam videos. So much so I actually started reporting them so I could skip them and get back to my videos

  • @willfantry2773
    @willfantry2773 2 роки тому +15

    Only thing I’ll counter is that I was being absolutely drowned in stadia ads on UA-cam at and around a few months after it’s launch. It never seemed worth the money even with good access to internet where I am

  • @nv7583
    @nv7583 2 роки тому +4

    When cyberpunk came out, PS5s were harder to get, and most didn’t have a powerful enough PC, Stadia was one of the best ways to play the game. The appeal is to ppl who can’t afford great game rigs, but the game list wasn’t too great and you had to have great wifi

    • @channel45853
      @channel45853 2 роки тому

      Yeah, but even in console, Cyberpunk can be choppy to play, normal cyberpunk plus the input lag would make it unbearable, I'd think

  • @DiscordedHaru
    @DiscordedHaru 2 роки тому +5

    It’s amazing how many times Phil has repeatedly been responsible for so many fuck ups.

    • @sambauman69
      @sambauman69 2 роки тому +1

      Skillup thinks he'd be perfect to lead Facebook's metaverse project.

  • @frankieM_
    @frankieM_ 2 роки тому

    10:06 oh no not a canceled death stranding, oh nooooo wherever will i go for my endless walking simulator now

  • @نونيم-ي4ح
    @نونيم-ي4ح 2 роки тому +1

    It’s kind of crazy to create a console without the exclusives to back it up.

  • @marcusmeins1839
    @marcusmeins1839 2 роки тому +3

    People want to own things not to rent them

  • @BusyDadGaming
    @BusyDadGaming 2 роки тому +9

    Stadia may not be it's own service, but it's now being licensed to other companies to use for cloud services. I kind of expected Stadia to fail, but it did push a technology forward, which has been pretty cool.

    • @thechugg4372
      @thechugg4372 2 роки тому

      Would any decent company want a service that failed?

  • @ethanlong4670
    @ethanlong4670 2 роки тому +4

    I genuinely thought the Stadia died like 2 years ago. I feel bad for the developers though. I forgot it was a thing until it was announced it was going to be shut down.

  • @Eggly69
    @Eggly69 5 місяців тому

    I didnt even know you had a second channel wtf. Hell yeah, spaghetti and more acting chad

  • @YDV669
    @YDV669 2 роки тому +2

    I'm honestly surprised that there were still any developers in mid to late 2022 actively developing new projects for Stadia.

  • @asneecrabbier3900
    @asneecrabbier3900 2 роки тому +7

    Act Man, when you mentioned stadia could be cool for people with bad internet, you seem to have forgotten that streaming itself would be horribly laggy, unfortunately

    • @Prplex.
      @Prplex. Рік тому +1

      As someone with bad Internet I thought of that too. I either suffer a long download or play a game immediately with horrible lag

  • @Kyanpepper25
    @Kyanpepper25 2 роки тому +14

    For me, this did really hurt.
    I was so excited cause I THOUGHT it gave you every game for free. like every game.
    However, it was a handful of games that were free. The advertising made me think you got a full free library.
    in like 3 months of having it I stopped playing it.
    For Christmas this year the family plans on getting a PS5 or XBox. Which we should've done for that Christmas anyways knowing now how the stadia really was.

  • @rewindproductions7261
    @rewindproductions7261 2 роки тому +5

    Honestly, I got so many ads on UA-cam and on other sites for Stadia, but the advertising didn't tell me shit, I didn't want to have to play games I play on my PC with a controller, and the ads themselves were usually un-skippable and annoying. I learned more about the product from this video than any of the marketing or publicity for the platform ever showed.

  • @WohlfePac
    @WohlfePac 2 роки тому

    I was an early beta tester for what was then called "Google Game Streaming." it was locked at 720p, required a good strong internet connection and a computer with chrome installed. The only game available was assassins creed odyssey and they let you play it in it's entirety. It honestly wasnt bad for what it was and they even let all the beta testers keep aco on whatever platform they wanted as sort of a thank you when the test ended. But if you could afford a good internet connection to run it (which I did at the time) you could probably afford to save up and buy a console or pc to install games.

  • @ODST_Buddy
    @ODST_Buddy 2 роки тому +1

    I remember seeing Stadia ads all the time on UA-cam… Weird.

  • @sansmoney8885
    @sansmoney8885 2 роки тому +7

    I never heard that stadia had a free multiplayer service until now. That would’ve been an extremely strong selling point

    • @thechugg4372
      @thechugg4372 2 роки тому

      God if only stadia made actual accurate ads instead of the cringe we got

  • @Ashtrid-i5f
    @Ashtrid-i5f 2 роки тому +4

    I find it so funny how hard they pushed stadia on UA-cam with the amount of adds I saw yet how little audience it actually had

  • @lukestowe7052
    @lukestowe7052 2 роки тому +4

    Do a BioShock Infinite review

  • @AndersonClips
    @AndersonClips 2 роки тому +1

    Oh no who could have possibly seen this coming

  • @Karloss00
    @Karloss00 2 роки тому

    11:32 - Then you have Facebook's 10 billion dollar investment into their VR and Meta ventures for a screenshot that looks like a scuffed version of Wii Sports. It's like all these tech giants who never invested in gaming before took one look at the industry and thought "Yeah, I'm rich enough to do that."

  • @Shadamyfan-rs8xc
    @Shadamyfan-rs8xc 2 роки тому +3

    With the amount of times that Google has shut a service down after only a short while, I'm surprised they didn't do this earlier with the search engine a lot earlier

  • @I_am_ENSanity
    @I_am_ENSanity 2 роки тому +7

    I love how my Steam Link outlived Stadia.

  • @sparxkzz
    @sparxkzz 2 роки тому +4

    I had no intention of getting Stadia, but it is good to have competition keep each other on their toes. That being said, competition in gaming tends to mean exclusives which force gamers to own multiple platforms or miss out.

  • @Strider-Ragnarok
    @Strider-Ragnarok 2 роки тому +1

    The future of gaming is frightening. They are all going for cloud gaming under the guise of “convenience.” The problem is that you can’t own digital, digital is tied to a server that’ll be eventually shut down, effectively killing games that can not be preserved. Stadia is The Prime Example of this.

  • @bamfyu
    @bamfyu 2 роки тому

    6:53 As someone with Terri Internet I can tell you that playing via cloud just doesn't work at all. It's like playing with a ping of 1000 or more. My Internet is the reason I play so many offline games. I have a laptop just so I can take it to friends houses and update there.

  • @blindpsychopath4368
    @blindpsychopath4368 2 роки тому +5

    I remember a couple of my friends talking up stadia when it was announced. Saying things like they could sell their consoles and PC since everything will be streamed. Noval idea to be true. But at the time we didn't have great Internet and seeing my Netflix buffer had me worried about what a game would feel on it. I also didn't really understand the subscription service google was offering. I actually thought at the time it was like a game pass like thing when you sign up for it and any game that gets added to the service will be yours to stream. But then I found out that you still had to buy games to my knowledge. So then any interest for it kinda died there

  • @MetalCharlo
    @MetalCharlo 2 роки тому +4

    I feel bad a bit for people I know who were relying on Stadia for gaming because they were new to the hobby. I tried it myself last year and the bugs were all gone. It's a shame Google was in charge.

  • @JayTeeAyy
    @JayTeeAyy 2 роки тому +3

    Rip bozo

  • @Sollace
    @Sollace 2 роки тому

    4:18 What's with the random fade to black? 😂😂😂
    It's like that gag-cut in shows where they fade out and back in 4 hours later and the character is rambling about random, disconnected subjects.

  • @ItsDeebs
    @ItsDeebs 2 роки тому +2

    Instead of creating a gaming device. Google should've created a games development division that developed and published games for all systems.