Cheap VS Expensive Battery Cable Crimpers | Harbor Freight and Temco Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 86

  • @theheathkitshop2424
    @theheathkitshop2424 2 роки тому +56

    Most of the less expensive crimpers do the same thing and leave little wings on the crimp. Try this! Crimp about half way, release pressure, rotate the wire/crimp 90º and finish the crimp. When you rotate the crimp, the second crimping action will smash those wings down and you'll get a much nicer looking crimp.

    • @theheathkitshop2424
      @theheathkitshop2424 Рік тому +8

      @Johnathan Thomas I've been doing this for years, and I have zero issues with heating of the connectors. In fact, the connectors are on so tight, I could pull a car out of a ditch.

    • @asherdie
      @asherdie Рік тому +4

      @Johnathan Thomas holy crap your comprehension is low.

    • @Lilmiket1000
      @Lilmiket1000 Рік тому +2

      Thank you. Because im here trying to make sure im doing the right thing and I thought I was fucking up but its actually the damn tool. I dont like these wings because it could cut into any nearby wires.

    • @jacobhendrickson8935
      @jacobhendrickson8935 Рік тому

      @@Lilmiket1000 when I get the wings before sliding the heat shrink over I file them dull.

    • @LTVoyager
      @LTVoyager Рік тому +2

      @VonderbachNo, he isn’t. What he suggests is perfectly fine. It takes more time than using a more precise tool, but the end result likely will be a very serviceable crimp. The only way to know for sure is to make a crimp that way and then section it. I am betting the crimp will be fine.

  • @LTVoyager
    @LTVoyager Рік тому +24

    It would have been interesting to pull the cable apart and see which end fails first. Looks is one thing, but staying together is what really matters.

    • @1nvisible1
      @1nvisible1 Рік тому +1

      *The most important thing is how much contact resistance is in the lug.*
      *Comparing copper vs copper and tin vs tin would reduce variables.*
      *I never use the 0 awg and I just ground it a little bigger to have a perfect fit for my most common crimp.*

  • @MrMandala1111
    @MrMandala1111 11 місяців тому +7

    Ideally shrink wrap is used to finish it off nicely and then the wings are not a concern really.

  • @ControlTouchMaster
    @ControlTouchMaster 11 місяців тому +8

    My Harbor Freight crimpers work great and never give me any problems.

  • @weavercattlecompany
    @weavercattlecompany Місяць тому +1

    I have the TEMCo hydraulic crimper and if anything goes wrong with it, TEMCo stands behind their product. TEMCo makes quality tools and it's worth the extra money especially if you own a business where you repair all your own equipment 😉
    Can't say the same for Harbor Freight products 🤭

  • @asherdie
    @asherdie Рік тому +8

    My temco will leave wings depending on terminal wall thickness, that varies by type and manufacturer you know.
    Rotate 90° before wings form and it will be fine.

  • @norman7179
    @norman7179 10 місяців тому +1

    I have the H F crimper. The blade or wing etc. on the sides isn't a problem. I just turn the cable 120 degrees and re crimp. Bingo, it's now smooth all the way around.
    Got to admit the Temco is nice and I like having the extra sizes. You get what you pay for.

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  9 місяців тому

      Not as worried about what's happening on the outside of the crimp as much as what's going on on the inside. If the crimper is leaving wings, I'm not confident it is producing a properly cold welded crimp. With the temco I can be sure.

  • @JeffinTD
    @JeffinTD Рік тому +2

    Nice video. Partly crimping, then turning the lug 1 flat and finishing can reduce winging.
    Also I went with a TEMco factory referb on their e-bay store. Other than some oily residue I couldn’t tell it from new. I suspect it had a leak and got new seals, and I saved a bunch.

  • @chefbgordon8892
    @chefbgordon8892 Рік тому +5

    Tbh I would just put heat shrink around those anyway to make them more resistant to weather and what not and it’ll make it look nicer so to me at least can’t justify the $50 dollar difference

  • @nunyabusiness863
    @nunyabusiness863 2 роки тому +4

    Thanks for putting this up. Theyre both made in China, but there are still big quality differences.

  • @Nickolision
    @Nickolision 2 роки тому +2

    Thanks for making this video Irvin! I still an old worn out one it doesn’t even crimp anymore lol

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  2 роки тому +1

      I was rocking the hammer one for the longest time 😂 thought it was finally time for an upgrade lol

  • @coreylewandowski6084
    @coreylewandowski6084 11 місяців тому +1

    Best jacket/band ever!!!!

  • @jeepfarmer
    @jeepfarmer Місяць тому

    I'm curious if the temco dies will fit in the harbor freight crimper?

  • @geraldhenrickson7472
    @geraldhenrickson7472 2 роки тому +4

    Did you use the wrong die on the Pittsburgh crimper? It seems you are working with 2/0 Cable rather than 2. It would leave wings.

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  2 роки тому +1

      Nope it is not 2/0 it is 2g

    • @jlindstrom3807
      @jlindstrom3807 2 роки тому +2

      @@RotaryDaddy I heard they mislabeled the die converting the size from whatever unit of measure they use in China. Have to use larger die than what is printed on them.

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  2 роки тому +2

      @@jlindstrom3807 yup! That's exactly what it looks like, just not really cool since they are all labeled as awg, like I said, you can make it work but for a bit more money I'd rather get the one that just works you know?

  • @photondebuger45
    @photondebuger45 Рік тому +2

    ... tis do the temco dies fit in the harbor freight one???

  • @stephenfurr8769
    @stephenfurr8769 2 роки тому +4

    Nice video, however, most likely you would be using heat shrink with those connections. Therefore, your size marking and how the crimp shows, those will not be seen. 🤷‍♂️

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  2 роки тому +3

      Very true, the size marking is a bit of a gimmick but the fact that the harbor freight dies are undersized is enough for me not to trust it. Thanks for watching! 🤘🏼

  • @Bellgrande
    @Bellgrande 2 роки тому +7

    That UA-cam money is starting to roll in I see 😂😆

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  2 роки тому +4

      I bought all this before I was monetized 😂

  • @pimptrizkit
    @pimptrizkit 2 роки тому +2

    Looks good, I've been looking for a better crimper.

  • @photondebuger45
    @photondebuger45 Рік тому

    Did some homework on those the dies fit the harbor freight one.....

  • @moonolyth
    @moonolyth 2 роки тому

    North T. Caries a 10 ton $45 or so. There a little more fastidious but they have advantages if getting creative, for the price me liky!! Not working for the Ford line factory so teniselbow is no proba!. And Yup, choose the right die r you'll get mayonnaise drip!! The game changer are the dies if purchased separately $$. I usem backwards to flatten stuff, reshaped a couple for special items. I've crimped plugs for cables on mower levers and could work on bikes (DO NOT DO BREACKS)!!!
    Also used them for deck rails. And attaching stops (end caps) on rods. Not much to em, they push together and squeeze, otherwise I ain't gona hangem next to my family photos, finish is less than glossy. I may even angle some carbon steel and make a lock type cutter eith them. Any how there as usfull as your imagination can take them..... get the pricy ones for the dies though, wished I had. more.... cash that is 😉.

  • @JamesReedy
    @JamesReedy Рік тому

    I tried the TEMco lever style one that’s like $110, no thanks. I’ll try this hydraulic one and hope it works.
    The lever one is nice in that it’s dieless but the issue is it’s a crush/dent type which frankly I don’t mind but the issue is the top support die is too wide so if you want the crush to face up perpendicular to the bolt hole it may deform the ears or it may deform the flared part where the wire goes in, you have to choose which part you wanna have suck. It’s going right back quick fast…

  • @DaltonWhittle-dx6yc
    @DaltonWhittle-dx6yc 10 місяців тому

    I have had the harbor freight crimpers blow apart on me. Literally cracked the cast head and flew across my job site. To be fair i was doing som 0/4 gauge or something and putting my body weight into the crimper against a metal skid.

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  10 місяців тому

      I’m not gonna lie I think I’ve gotten close lol they started making some weird noises so I backed off that’s wild that you actually got them to break 😂

  • @CrAzYDr1veR
    @CrAzYDr1veR 7 місяців тому

    sooo the copper terminal is bigger so it leaves wings and the tinned one has the correct size...

  • @brianb9410
    @brianb9410 2 роки тому +3

    Very helpful, thank you.

  • @jamesalles139
    @jamesalles139 2 роки тому

    uh, what is the largest size terminal each will crimp?
    thanks for the video

  • @jesserodriguez4350
    @jesserodriguez4350 10 місяців тому

    Can you use the dies from the temco in the harbor freight one?

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  9 місяців тому

      Haven't tried but maybe...?

  • @Coodeville
    @Coodeville Рік тому

    I just looked at HF. It doesn’t have 1/0. I’m going to by the TEMco

  • @CorbinFeauto
    @CorbinFeauto 20 днів тому

    Harbor freight one doesn’t do 1/0 gauge

  • @Irishcream216
    @Irishcream216 7 місяців тому

    Crimp+solder+heat shrink = bulletproof

  • @donp2474
    @donp2474 2 місяці тому

    You will not see either crimp once you put the heat shrink insulation on the end.

  • @steveherwig4353
    @steveherwig4353 3 місяці тому +1

    You should have done both with same type lugs ,you failed

  • @SebastianBrown-yh3zm
    @SebastianBrown-yh3zm 2 роки тому

    where can i find one?

  • @bang2loud1981
    @bang2loud1981 2 роки тому

    If you would of used the 1/0 in the harbor freight one it wouldn't of winged out like that all dies are mad the same been using my hydraulic crimper since 2014 and always used the 1/0 instead of 2 awg

  • @thudang3039
    @thudang3039 Рік тому

    Thanks for sharing! =)

  • @complexity5545
    @complexity5545 4 місяці тому

    Good Video --

  • @patrickmckowen2999
    @patrickmckowen2999 Рік тому

    👍

  • @johnr5545
    @johnr5545 4 місяці тому

    Thanks god bless

  • @Juniorrrrrm
    @Juniorrrrrm Рік тому +1

    Just because you have an is300 ill be buying the expensive one so I can start my battery relocation on my is!

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  Рік тому

      The temco is nice as hell and if you're doing this more than once it's VERY worth it 😎

  • @bert1913
    @bert1913 10 місяців тому

    The chinese crimp dies are metric sizes not awg

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  9 місяців тому

      They say awg on them and all of the packaging...

  • @bobit8742
    @bobit8742 Рік тому +1

    no one going see the crimp after heat shrink lol

  • @WizzRacing
    @WizzRacing 2 роки тому +2

    Just buy the Temco dies.. As who cares what the crimp looks like. As I cover them up with Heat Shrink and Dialectic grease...

    • @Keifsanderson
      @Keifsanderson 2 роки тому

      If the "wings" are sharp, they can cut your heat shrink.

  • @windward2818
    @windward2818 10 місяців тому

    There are crimping "systems" (lugs, tool, and die all from the same manufacturer with an NEC (National Electric Code) specified AWG cable used for AC power distribution) which will produce a certified (UL, UAW) crimp. Certified crimps that are circumferential (circular in shape and not hex) can produce wings (as it is called in the video) as certified for AC busbar lugs, meaning wings are expected when using U dies, in fact you are looking for the creation of wings.
    W dies are also circumferential but do not necessarily produce wings because they bottom out (bottoming dies like hex dies with no side gaps). When we move away from crimping AC UL approved (also UAW) cable and lugs there is really no standard result that is approved. What this means is you have to select your own lugs, crimpers and dies to get the results you want. Once you decide on a system you have to saw through some test crimps to see the cross sectional area and how the strands are compressed. If your test crimp looks good (cold forming complete) then you have a good crimp.
    There is a lot of variability in making battery or high power cables terminations for transportation applications (auto, marine, off road). If we start with the tooling for copper cable lugs up to 4/0 you will need a 6 Ton hydraulic crimper. If you limit your lug size to 2/0 you can use the Temco tool which is 5 Ton and comes with both standard and HD lug hex dies. A 6 Ton crimper is very common in the industry with either W or Hex dies. The Greenlee EK622LX (as just one example, not cheap) uses Hex dies from Greenlee with an adaptor for W dies (made by Burndy, Greenlee, Panduit and many others).
    In regards to the video, which is an automotive application, 2 AWG is being used so the Temco will work. The best lugs are actually made by Burndy, Panduit or Others and are color coded. I like Panduit tin plated long barrel no window and no entry flare for automotive 2 AWG. The best wire is high stranding tin plated Marine wire, which is more flexible than welding cable which is not commonly tin plated but is high stranding with a good jacket (covering). Production automotive battery cable is usually not tin plated or fine stranded or very flexible, so I don't use it very often. With a long barrel lug you can do either one, two or three crimps of either W or Hex depending on the cable size. Always use dual wall heat shrink to seal the cable to lug joint. Lugs with inspection (witness) windows are usually not used for automotive applications.
    With many car builders a hex crimp will be used. The approach is to select a die that matches the cable size and lug as a starting point and see if the crimp produces side wings. What you will find is you want a die to bottom out and just produce the start of side wings. Which you can then remove by rotating the cable and crimping again if needed. If the die is a bottoming die (like a hex die or a W die) a good crimp is one that produces no side wings (or very slight) while still bottoming out. If you use this rule of thumb and then look at some crimp cross sections you will see a solid mass with no gaps, meaning it is properly cold formed (or sometimes called cold welded).
    If you produce a proper cold formed crimp on a long barrel lug (three hex crimps on 2 AWG) it will outperform any soldered connection. The main advantage of the crimp connection is the soldered joint will be weaker and more prone to cracking, but if the cable is properly dressed and secured I have never seen a soldered cable fail (I have worked with techs that like to solder). They only fail if allowed to move due to vibration which I have seen. Another disadvantage with soldering is to heat up a large lug takes a lot of heat which can degrade the tin plating (Panduit lugs are not inexpensive) on the lug and also damage the cable jacket. Also, you should have a good mechanical connection before soldering as a rule of thumb, which many do not do. Overall though if you have a 6 Ton battery operated crimper with the proper hex dies you can terminate cables 10x faster than soldering. You can triple crimp a long barrel lug in about 15 seconds.

  • @anthonymarino4260
    @anthonymarino4260 Рік тому

    have a temco never go back you get what you pay for

  • @DSMetal14
    @DSMetal14 10 місяців тому

    Heat shrink. Problem solved.

    • @RotaryDaddy
      @RotaryDaddy  10 місяців тому

      The issue with the winged crimp isn’t only a cosmetic one. Crimping with an incorrect die will lead to a less reliable connection and may never allow you to get the correct pressure needed to create the cold weld you’re looking for

  • @nvkulk
    @nvkulk 2 роки тому +1

    Get what you pay for!

  • @30all
    @30all Рік тому +1

    After you shrink the connector tube, you don't see a thing.

  • @johnr5545
    @johnr5545 2 роки тому

    Nice god bless

  • @lambodingus6986
    @lambodingus6986 2 роки тому +1

    Just use Little common sense if want save the $ lol
    1) use next size up die so don’t get that crimp spill out ….
    2) don’t overcrimp it usually what causes that
    3) crimp then rotate and crimp again for perfect finish ….
    4) could very easily just cut the “wings” as u call them off with pair dikes lol
    However I personally own tempco(older version) mine has no color die marks and sizes not marked to operate 100% properly and case is wayyy smaller …mines actually closer to HB FT version performance wise and case look wise from ur video so had use bit common sense lol …. But I do like tempco(urs must be recent upgrade version) products very much and their warranty is literally SECOND TO NONE HAHA ….

  • @stevenmendez9259
    @stevenmendez9259 8 місяців тому

    embarrassed really?

  • @ls_812
    @ls_812 Рік тому

    I spend more than my viewers because i dont want my stuff to look like shit that they would do.
    Maybe you spend more money buying tools qe already have 😂

  • @christhomas4260
    @christhomas4260 Рік тому

    Go ahead count