Are you really taking Dr. Phil seriously??? Maybe they should have the muffin man on next. Dr. Phil is a disgraced “psychologist” TV personality. It’s truly telling that their “expert”witnesses are Dr. Phil and John Grisham. Would love to know how much they were paid for this nonsense. Bless their hearts. (But not Robert Roberson’s)
@@rebeccarice1209I agree with all you've said. How much was he paid? Calling him a Dr. Is like calling Pirone a real judge, imo. Paid tv personalities making big money from ignorant people.
You have a radical leftist democrat as the director that’s why - take a second look at the people in power of these agency’s they are really Ed’s up wit Trans kids, atheist, America hating, Trump hating Christian hating people that’s why!
@@Famr4evrexactly. Changes will only happen if we unite and stand up ourselves. We are the power the state or fed gov wields. They need us. We pay taxes for them to screw us over any chance they get.
i'm impressed w this Texas House Committee Board. they are engaged asking the right questions and seem to understand science. awesome panel texans should be proud⭐️
They don’t know what an eptopic pregnancy is or that incest/rape babies aren’t a good thing, but sure, they’ve *totally* got this one that requires pediatric neurologists, immunologists, traumatic specialists, pathologists to understand. Good thing they have disgraced psychologist/tv personality “Dr. Phil” and John Grisham to sort it out for them! Have all critical thinking skills gone out the window? Do we all have collective brain rot?? What is happening??
@@briannacc3983 its good they are listening and it is a good sign when leaders listen had this committee not stopped the attorney general that man would have been executed already
My 29 year old autistic son has flat affect. Law enforcement harrassed him as a teenager and young adult PRIOR TO EDUCATION ON AUTISM. They believed he was "high" or "drunk" "weird", etc... I had to contact Sheriffs in 3 countied and many Police Cheifs to present education materials to Law Enforcement on Autism. My son has a 4 year old development. He is unable to defend against false allegations. I am afraid of the State of Texas and am extremely relieved we do not live there.
You don’t have to be autistic to not react to traumatic emotional situations. I love my children more than life itself, but if something happened to either of them I know that no one on the outside would see an expected response from me. When something impacts my heart..all my senses shut down. I’m tired of people being judged because they do not display appropriate behavior!
Thank you Dr Phil for explaining in short term Austim spectrum and it is a lifetime disability even if he was diagnosed in 2018 it is disgusted that the men in suits have know knowledge about disability
Thank you dr Phil for being a voice for this man !lord have mercy on this poor innocent man !set him free and compensate him from all his suffering and struggles!he needs someone to take care of him and to show ❤️ him some love !
This is such a miscarriage of justice! The medical examiner, and doctors who prescribed medication for the baby that were not meant for a small child, and a medication that was counter indicated should be held acceptable, and prosecuted.
Dr. Phil is articulate and passionate when he believes something and I have always enjoyed listening to his advice. He has laid an extraordinarily detailed case out for reasonable doubt in this matter. I believe this person did not get a fair trial and should be released as it is impossible to determine beyond a reasonable doubt what happened. Under such circumstances a person should never be charged, let alone executed, when there is doubt and only circumstantial evidence.
Absolutely, self-preservation is the worst human trait. The true enemy are those who sell their beliefs and knowledge for money. Even worse are those who refuse to disrupt their lives due to fear or even want to think for themselve. They're aware that they use the population for profit for an entity(State and Federal ) in order to maintain their job/career. This included doctors that have been letting insurance/CEO keep them from treating their patients due to restriction. Dhs workers taking kids from good families and leaving the abused in the homes due to $$$. READ THE CONSTITUTION. Everyone is afraid to stand alone, our children are suffering.
So sad I know what this man went through 25 years ago this was the go to. When a child passed away. This baby had so many of the same things my son had. Thank god we had family that paid. For my son to see a doctor that is an expert on bleeding behind the eye.
Glad he stepped in and made these comments about spectrum illness and how it can effect folks I’m a bit of the same way but never been to a doc about it
I totally agree! Dr. Phil is NEVER the answer. What a disgrace. “I’m no expert but I can read.” Sure, board certifications and ability to read - definitely equivalent!
My father always taught me growing up the most corrupt professions in this country: doctors and attorneys. I'll never forget it. Dad you were so right (he passed in 2109) and today the two largest lobbyists for the democratic party are: Healthcare (pharmaceutical) and the Attorneys association. Free this man this is SO FUCKING SAD!!! Autistic ppl DO NOT LIE at least my experience is they are PAINFULLY HONEST, i know this bc my son is autistic and my BIGGEST fear for him at 16 years old is ppl (law enforcement) not understanding his social reactions to things WE react to completely differently then a person on the spectrum. I feel awful for this man....
God bless you Dr.Phil!🙏💪🫶🙏Its always been normal for the long arm of the law to " play "God" ! And lord knows we have a long road ahead reforming the justice system! When its going to require people to accurately perform there job in this day and age! Surveillance...works both ways!!
The problem is that early studies of Shaken Baby Syndrome (SBS), SIDS, & other baby & early Childhood Injuries & deaths were based on ersatz studies. The early advocates of causes & early studies have evolved and subsequently many have disputed their own earlier conclusions. DNA, Genetic & other studies have evolved & provide better & more determinate explanations and some have disputed perfunctory autopsies
I wish someone would fight for Sirhan Sirhan who has been in prison for over 50 years for something he DIDN'T do. Dr. Noguchi (L.A. coroner) said that RFK's fatal shot came from a shot about 1 inch from his head and witnesses said they knew Sirhan wasn't ever close enough for that.
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, for bringing up representation. The fat cats, go to lunch, and the public defender eats at their desk. I see it as students need extensive education to work in our judicial system. Same with Doctors. The education process is minimal, and there needs to be interviews to prove these people will be effective on the job. More, and especially the past twenty years or more, there is a lack of caring, compassion, interest, and more in the medical and law professions. There seems to be more of an interest with money, position, and power.
Justice reform! Now the time! S are changing and its only logical that the justice system changes along with the rest of society!and with that ....protect inocent lives!! We only live once!!
Thank you Dr. Phil. Was his counsel a court appointed attorney? They scare me. They have too close of relationships with the courts and feel they tend to try to help the court as much, if not more than the client. My son received 9 years for something he did while in psychosis. I’m so sad and disappointed with our justice system. No longer have much trust in any of them. They put him isolated confinement for 6 months, an already mentally ill person. 😢😢😢
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Dr Phil😂😂😂😂 I can't stop laughing😂😂😂😂 I can't believe they have him testifying😊😮 a TV personality instead of a real licensed psychologist from some college or clinician psychiatric Hospital😂😂😂😂🎉
He is a licensed psychologist and had let his renewal regarding his registration fees lapse for a time but he reinstated such with his PhD in forensic psychology!
@@kathyborthwick6738LakotaEmoji he lost his license in 2006. His guests sign a contract that they will accept advice from an individual not a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist. He is a tv personality.
I missed where suppositories could be ruled out as a possible cause for “Anal Tears?” Its an obvious connection so where is it ruled out and disregarded?? Poor little thing. So many would have fought so hard for you kid. We have to do better.
Great hurdle, everyone in these field's should live and learn! Lets grow and learn .rather than stay stuck although its the easiest! The justice system is broke! It isnt working ! Not for the average human! The other side see no problems...of course ! But its time that borh sides are justified equally! To be held accountable for actions wrong and or right!!
No emotions, I would say no to the death penalty. But this is an individual who barely can take care of himself, he is not to care for a child or anyone
Thank you, Dr Kilp for the information and you must be human too because I see a little nervous in the beginning. What a good story facts doesn’t lie. What a good job you did and this team behind you thank you folks for looking into this case.
Lets tell the whole story and the history of frequent doctor visits for the child and why was a Autistic man raising a child. Im speaking for the dead little🕊️Girl🥀🕊️ The proof is in a dead little girl🥀🕊️
No dr Phil we got alot more people that are catching that death penalty in the next 5 years you just go on home you’ve had your chance and you created a generation of kids and adults that can’t hold themselves accountable and expect the rest of us to be just as okay with crimes as they are
Medico legal society have a way of appointing defense attorneys that protect medicine as a priority , via media targeting and other routes : meaning your defence team will not be acting in the accused best interests : i have experienced this with medical protection society:. As a 3o year critical care practitioner:
This sounds wayy to one sided at the time! With his minor charges of drug use was a ticket to fabricate 🤷♀️😉😮💨😒Happens everywhere....all the time! ( Had happened) i mean since i truly see and feel a ray of light possibly breaking through
Our Heavenly Father Lord Jesus Christ always their for us always encouraging us lifting us up and when everyone else and everything else in life fails you their is one person who will NOT fail you because He can’t NOT
@@183-aD I don't need to. Before shoving junk food inside my piehole, I like to check my food. What is this guy history? He is fraud and scam. But great at marketing himself with logotype.
We are tired of hearing about the certain circumstances under the right moon with the stars just right that their actions should be left unchecked y’all let Ted Bundy fight his case for 16 months
If the ability to change not just someones injust, acknowledge the facts ,and right the new situation ( and by the grace of God) things happen for a reason! Have this opportunity in front of God and country, then what is the future?
I used to have respect for Dr. Phil until I found out that he is pro Trump. I refuse to listen to one word that comes out of his pie hole. Absolutely zero respect. He lost all credibility. He can go back n the same hole Dr. Oz went into 🤡
Then, you go ahead and support Harris. You support illegal immigrants abortion at any stage of pregnancy. You support the American people paying for criminals and defunding the police a political person that is clearly not for this country.
Thank you Dr. Phil for your caring to bring justice to our broken system more now than ever.
Are you really taking Dr. Phil seriously??? Maybe they should have the muffin man on next.
Dr. Phil is a disgraced “psychologist” TV personality.
It’s truly telling that their “expert”witnesses are Dr. Phil and John Grisham. Would love to know how much they were paid for this nonsense.
Bless their hearts. (But not Robert Roberson’s)
He's one of the few who's testimony on any subject I would trust the account given on any investigation.
@@rebeccarice1209I agree with all you've said. How much was he paid? Calling him a Dr. Is like calling Pirone a real judge, imo. Paid tv personalities making big money from ignorant people.
@@teresawachter3020
Why?
Because he was on TV?🤪
He had training?
He hasn't kept up with it and does NOT have a license to practice!
Dr Phil please be a voice for all the parents being abused by CPS and our judiciary system
That is to much work for one person.
You have a radical leftist democrat as the director that’s why - take a second look at the people in power of these agency’s they are really Ed’s up wit Trans kids, atheist, America hating, Trump hating Christian hating people that’s why!
@@kat-75agreed.
We all need to take a stand and speak up for the families in our communities.
@@Famr4evrexactly. Changes will only happen if we unite and stand up ourselves. We are the power the state or fed gov wields. They need us. We pay taxes for them to screw us over any chance they get.
No crime has been committed he should be set free.
This man has suffered enough. It does sound as if he was prosecuted wrongly. He should be vindicated. 🙏
Doctors need be held accountable too.
i'm impressed w this Texas House Committee Board. they are engaged asking the right questions and seem to understand science. awesome panel texans should be proud⭐️
They don’t know what an eptopic pregnancy is or that incest/rape babies aren’t a good thing, but sure, they’ve *totally* got this one that requires pediatric neurologists, immunologists, traumatic specialists, pathologists to understand. Good thing they have disgraced psychologist/tv personality “Dr. Phil” and John Grisham to sort it out for them!
Have all critical thinking skills gone out the window? Do we all have collective brain rot?? What is happening??
I'm 40 minutes in and this group is barely asking Dr. Phil any questions. Don't seem too bright or don't care.
@@briannacc3983
You're only a third the way.
Use at least a third of your brain.
@@briannacc3983 its good they are listening and it is a good sign when leaders listen had this committee not stopped the attorney general that man would have been executed already
This man and 3,600 others waiting for exoneration . Something’s very wrong with this country and the corrupt people in power!!
Justice reform🥳🙏💪The time is now!
It's called judges owning prisons and needing to keep them full.
What did he do?
My 29 year old autistic son has flat affect. Law enforcement harrassed him as a teenager and young adult PRIOR TO EDUCATION ON AUTISM. They believed he was "high" or "drunk" "weird", etc...
I had to contact Sheriffs in 3 countied and many Police Cheifs to present education materials to Law Enforcement on Autism.
My son has a 4 year old development. He is unable to defend against false allegations. I am afraid of the State of Texas and am extremely relieved we do not live there.
You don’t have to be autistic to not react to traumatic emotional situations. I love my children more than life itself, but if something happened to either of them I know that no one on the outside would see an expected response from me. When something impacts my heart..all my senses shut down. I’m tired of people being judged because they do not display appropriate behavior!
Thank you Dr Phil for explaining in short term Austim spectrum and it is a lifetime disability even if he was diagnosed in 2018 it is disgusted that the men in suits have know knowledge about disability
Outstanding summary by Phil McGraw. A total mis-carriage of justice. Roberson should be released from custody.
Thank you dr Phil for being a voice for this man !lord have mercy on this poor innocent man !set him free and compensate him from all his suffering and struggles!he needs someone to take care of him and to show ❤️ him some love !
❤❤❤
Thank you Dr Phil for your input on this case in this matter I believe he was railroaded in this
This is such a miscarriage of justice! The medical examiner, and doctors who prescribed medication for the baby that were not meant for a small child, and a medication that was counter indicated should be held acceptable, and prosecuted.
Thank you Dr Phil for studying and speaking about this man and his case.
Should be set free paid for being locked up
It’s weird how before we didn’t hear a thing about this
Now here it is ……
Many people have been following this & other doubtful convictions.
We need more Dr’s like Dr Phil
Okay! Now you got it and it’s broken. Now how are you going to fix it?
Dr. Phil, as a southeast Texas man, you have you have affirmed my faith in men that stand for the truth. Thank you sir.
Free him.
Dr. Phil is articulate and passionate when he believes something and I have always enjoyed listening to his advice. He has laid an extraordinarily detailed case out for reasonable doubt in this matter. I believe this person did not get a fair trial and should be released as it is impossible to determine beyond a reasonable doubt what happened. Under such circumstances a person should never be charged, let alone executed, when there is doubt and only circumstantial evidence.
Oh please, keep Oprah out of any of this air time 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
She is part of injustice…
Absolutely, self-preservation is the worst human trait.
The true enemy are those who sell their beliefs and knowledge for money.
Even worse are those who refuse to disrupt their lives due to fear or even want to think for themselve.
They're aware that they use the population for profit for an entity(State and Federal ) in order to maintain their job/career.
This included doctors that have been letting insurance/CEO keep them from treating their patients due to restriction.
Dhs workers taking kids from good families and leaving the abused in the homes due to $$$.
READ THE CONSTITUTION.
Everyone is afraid to stand alone, our children are suffering.
All evidence should be brought before the jury. Period.
It was.
Who needs a Johnny Cochran when Phil is around.
lmao classic dr phil "now im not a lawyer, dont mean to brag" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 love dr phil!!✨❤️✨
Our system is very ill.
Very
Set this guy free
i do too dr phil! i appreciate you and your team all the work and research done here. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Kudos to dr. Phil!
So sad I know what this man went through 25 years ago this was the go to. When a child passed away. This baby had so many of the same things my son had. Thank god we had family that paid. For my son to see a doctor that is an expert on bleeding behind the eye.
Correction: “should be held accountable!”
Glad he stepped in and made these comments about spectrum illness and how it can effect folks I’m a bit of the same way but never been to a doc about it
Too often all the courts care about is getting a conviction. So wrong and so sad b
Wow. Dr Phil is the man!
Thank you
He is not guilty, sadly the doctors should be held accountable.
Wow! Dr Phil is one powerful man
God Bless you ✝️🇺🇸
Thank-you for saving this sweet man❤
I'll have my day with you sir and you will be held accountable!!
The court systems are broken!!
This is why the DP is not the answer.
I totally agree! Dr. Phil is NEVER the answer. What a disgrace. “I’m no expert but I can read.” Sure, board certifications and ability to read - definitely equivalent!
He is on DR.... .Casey anthony jumps around in the free world....
Did he sexually abuse her though? If he did, he shouldn't be set free. He should be tried and sentenced for that.
My father always taught me growing up the most corrupt professions in this country: doctors and attorneys. I'll never forget it. Dad you were so right (he passed in 2109) and today the two largest lobbyists for the democratic party are:
Healthcare (pharmaceutical) and the Attorneys association.
Free this man this is SO FUCKING SAD!!! Autistic ppl DO NOT LIE at least my experience is they are PAINFULLY HONEST, i know this bc my son is autistic and my BIGGEST fear for him at 16 years old is ppl (law enforcement) not understanding his social reactions to things WE react to completely differently then a person on the spectrum. I feel awful for this man....
Thank you Dr. Phil
Robert was NEVER EVER GUILTY of anything! Roberson LOVED his child!
did you read the autopsy report?
Or hear the testimonies of his own family members??? Or read the Supreme Court Ruling??
Thanks Dr Phil. That was redemption for the Netanyahu interview… and much needed. Everyone is pulling for this dude.
God bless you Dr.Phil!🙏💪🫶🙏Its always been normal for the long arm of the law to " play "God" ! And lord knows we have a long road ahead reforming the justice system! When its going to require people to accurately perform there job in this day and age! Surveillance...works both ways!!
Thank you Dr Phyill. You are so right,
The problem is that early studies of Shaken Baby Syndrome (SBS), SIDS, & other baby & early Childhood Injuries & deaths were based on ersatz studies. The early advocates of causes & early studies have evolved and subsequently many have disputed their own earlier conclusions. DNA, Genetic & other studies have evolved & provide better & more determinate explanations and some have disputed perfunctory autopsies
'she's a burden. That's our excuse for murdering her.'
Maybe if the feds handled paying defense attorneys and not the state responsible for prosecution paying said public defense. This will stop happening
I wish someone would fight for Sirhan Sirhan who has been in prison for over 50 years for something he DIDN'T do. Dr. Noguchi (L.A. coroner) said that RFK's fatal shot came from a shot about 1 inch from his head and witnesses said they knew Sirhan wasn't ever close enough for that.
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, for bringing up representation. The fat cats, go to lunch, and the public defender eats at their desk. I see it as students need extensive education to work in our judicial system. Same with Doctors. The education process is minimal, and there needs to be interviews to prove these people will be effective on the job. More, and especially the past twenty years or more, there is a lack of caring, compassion, interest, and more in the medical and law professions. There seems to be more of an interest with money, position, and power.
Justice reform! Now the time! S are changing and its only logical that the justice system changes along with the rest of society!and with that ....protect inocent lives!! We only live once!!
This is why I am against the death penalty; there are to many innocent people in jail. It's wrong.❤
Free Mr.Roberson!
How horrible 😢 Bless you Dr. Phil!
Thank you Dr. Phil. Was his counsel a court appointed attorney? They scare me. They have too close of relationships with the courts and feel they tend to try to help the court as much, if not more than the client. My son received 9 years for something he did while in psychosis. I’m so sad and disappointed with our justice system. No longer have much trust in any of them. They put him isolated confinement for 6 months, an already mentally ill person. 😢😢😢
I’m so sorry to hear that. I hope things are better for you both now.
This will be the seventh seal
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Dr Phil😂😂😂😂 I can't stop laughing😂😂😂😂 I can't believe they have him testifying😊😮 a TV personality instead of a real licensed psychologist from some college or clinician psychiatric Hospital😂😂😂😂🎉
He is a licensed psychologist and had let his renewal regarding his registration fees lapse for a time but he reinstated such with his PhD in forensic psychology!
@@kathyborthwick6738LakotaEmoji he lost his license in 2006. His guests sign a contract that they will accept advice from an individual not a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist. He is a tv personality.
Where is this hearing being held ?
Evil people on the boards 😮beware 😅
I missed where suppositories could be ruled out as a possible cause for “Anal Tears?” Its an obvious connection so where is it ruled out and disregarded?? Poor little thing. So many would have fought so hard for you kid. We have to do better.
Great hurdle, everyone in these field's should live and learn! Lets grow and learn .rather than stay stuck although its the easiest! The justice system is broke! It isnt working ! Not for the average human! The other side see no problems...of course ! But its time that borh sides are justified equally! To be held accountable for actions wrong and or right!!
That is malpractice against his own attorneys.
He can understand it but not able to empathize with other human being suffering
No emotions, I would say no to the death penalty. But this is an individual who barely can take care of himself, he is not to care for a child or anyone
The New Stupid is crawling out of the woodwork!! 😮💨🥳🙏Bittersweet!
He is a real doctor, I thought it was a lie.
Set me and my name free dr Phil and America
What on earth did the person do? Wow so many issue.
Thank you, Dr Kilp for the information and you must be human too because I see a little nervous in the beginning. What a good story facts doesn’t lie. What a good job you did and this team behind you thank you folks for looking into this case.
Lets tell the whole story and the history of frequent doctor visits for the child and why was a Autistic man raising a child. Im speaking for the dead little🕊️Girl🥀🕊️ The proof is in a dead little girl🥀🕊️
Neglected his duty of care. Remand and retry. Tort claim. Sue tx for malicious prosecution.
No dr Phil we got alot more people that are catching that death penalty in the next 5 years you just go on home you’ve had your chance and you created a generation of kids and adults that can’t hold themselves accountable and expect the rest of us to be just as okay with crimes as they are
All these idiots in the comment section with Trump Derangement Syndrome...😂😂😂
Then what happened
Wow!
Medico legal society have a way of appointing defense attorneys that protect medicine as a priority , via media targeting and other routes : meaning your defence team will not be acting in the accused best interests : i have experienced this with medical protection society:. As a 3o year critical care practitioner:
What is this?
This sounds wayy to one sided at the time! With his minor charges of drug use was a ticket to fabricate 🤷♀️😉😮💨😒Happens everywhere....all the time! ( Had happened) i mean since i truly see and feel a ray of light possibly breaking through
Our Heavenly Father Lord Jesus Christ always their for us always encouraging us lifting us up and when everyone else and everything else in life fails you their is one person who will NOT fail you because He can’t NOT
❤❤❤
What are Dr Phil authority and expertise? (if any)
Duh...watch the video
Did you watch the video? When a witness is called thats one of the first things they say.
@@tishku8885 duh....
Please! Move to ukraine!
@@183-aD I don't need to. Before shoving junk food inside my piehole, I like to check my food.
What is this guy history? He is fraud and scam. But great at marketing himself with logotype.
@GoPoundSalt watch the video he list his education and expertise. I'm not your nanny to be writing it for you.
Thus saith the Lord preserve justice and do Righteousness for my salvation about to come and my righteousness to be revealed.
Is he a Dr. again? I though all hic doctorates expired.
We are tired of hearing about the certain circumstances under the right moon with the stars just right that their actions should be left unchecked y’all let Ted Bundy fight his case for 16 months
If the ability to change not just someones injust, acknowledge the facts ,and right the new situation ( and by the grace of God) things happen for a reason! Have this opportunity in front of God and country, then what is the future?
Shorten title cant read it
That happened in Australia with a lady in Australia with shaken baby
Doctor phil the count de monte cristo.
Kiss of death😂😂😂😂
He is unable to fill empathy
I used to have respect for Dr. Phil until I found out that he is pro Trump. I refuse to listen to one word that comes out of his pie hole. Absolutely zero respect. He lost all credibility. He can go back n the same hole Dr. Oz went into 🤡
Then, you go ahead and support Harris. You support illegal immigrants abortion at any stage of pregnancy. You support the American people paying for criminals and defunding the police a political person that is clearly not for this country.
At this time we call Dr. Phillip "Charlatan" McGraw
Dr. Phil
🤢🤢🤢🤮
🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤮
🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤮
Pathetic
Vote blue
🔵🇺🇸🔵
This would help Kamala, she could help this guy!!!! Give him another trail!!! She might actually win if she helped this man!!
Help kamala? Are you ok?
why are so many dull people even watching this clip? oh because its dr phil. listen to the entire discussion before u comment ditz
Phil is old school Republican. Sad he won't speak out on Trump and his groupies like liz Cheney did
Phil is not a medical doctor and is just as fake as a three dollar bill.
you should delete that lame comment it's absolutely false.
@@jensheahan7522 , sorry to offend you, but which part of the statement is false?
@@jensheahan7522seriously? Have you followed his BS show? He’s a charlatan and just loves to hear himself talk.