@@mariee.5912no, I’ve been medical for over 50 YEARS- the drugs given this child were prescribed erroneously and medical MUST BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE!!!! Drugs kill more people than are admitted to EVERY SINGLE FDA APPROVED DRUG IS A CHEMICAL STRESSOR BECAUSE THEY ARE ALLLLLLL SYNTHETIC- our bodies are NEVER SYNTHETIC- therefore on top of all genuine needs, drugs kill!!!!
And the prosecutor. He or she saw felony convictions and was looking for something to get re-elected on. No due diligence here and the defense, who works with the prosecution everyday just wanted to push the case through.
i'm impressed w this Texas House Committee Board. they are engaged asking the right questions and seem to understand science. awesome panel texans should be proud⭐️
They don’t know what an eptopic pregnancy is or that incest/rape babies aren’t a good thing, but sure, they’ve *totally* got this one that requires pediatric neurologists, immunologists, traumatic specialists, pathologists to understand. Good thing they have disgraced psychologist/tv personality “Dr. Phil” and John Grisham to sort it out for them! Have all critical thinking skills gone out the window? Do we all have collective brain rot?? What is happening??
@@briannacc3983 its good they are listening and it is a good sign when leaders listen had this committee not stopped the attorney general that man would have been executed already
Are you really taking Dr. Phil seriously??? Maybe they should have the muffin man on next. Dr. Phil is a disgraced “psychologist” TV personality. It’s truly telling that their “expert”witnesses are Dr. Phil and John Grisham. Would love to know how much they were paid for this nonsense. Bless their hearts. (But not Robert Roberson’s)
@@rebeccarice1209I agree with all you've said. How much was he paid? Calling him a Dr. Is like calling Pirone a real judge, imo. Paid tv personalities making big money from ignorant people.
Thank you dr Phil for being a voice for this man !lord have mercy on this poor innocent man !set him free and compensate him from all his suffering and struggles!he needs someone to take care of him and to show ❤️ him some love !
@elouise5593 Don't be stupid! I have a grown man son (50yrs) with ADD/BI POLAR. IT was not easy throughout the years, but he made the life he now lives!
@@sassylady54LOUSE5593 is a damaged troll. It doesn’t know how to self-reflect and has no capacity for critical thinking. It’s tantrums and diatribes are its only means of regurgitating the divisive talking points and hate that it ingests copiously every day. I raised a special needs child, as you did. A creature like the LOUSE above is incapable empathy, let alone even a hint of understanding. Bless you for standing up to the ⬇️IQ troll.
SOUNDS LIKE THERE WAS MEDICAL MALPRACTICE GOING ON FROM THE BEGINNING. AND EVERY TIME THEY TOOK HER TO THE HOSPITAL SHE GOT WORSE. THERE SHOULD HAVE BEEN A TOXICOLOGY INVESTIGATION, INDEPENDENT.
I agree! The hospital kept sending her home rather than keeping her in the hospital. They neglected to take care of her properly. They over medicated her with opiates too. She needed to be on IVs, antibiotics, steroid inhaler, oxygen, & monitoring her breathing & heartbeat. Not sent home with Codeine Cough Syrup (Promethazine) & an opiate suppository. Two opioid medications that suppressed her breathing while her lungs were literally being eaten by pneumonia. She had necrotic tissue in her lungs, dead rotting tissue in her lungs. The doctor should have ordered chest X-rays, or if they already had in the beginning, they should have taken more to show the pneumonia & the patient’s condition had gotten worse. The X-rays would show the pneumonia spreading in the lungs. Every time I or a family member ever had gotten sick with a really bad cough, they snapped chest X-rays. I looked at the X-rays & could see my lungs had white spots from pneumonia, instead of black spaces should be showing clear lungs. Chest rads are really easy to figure out for anyone with the slightest medical knowledge. A Veterinarian Technician could look at the X-rays & see there was a major problem. Children & Elderly patients are much more vulnerable to pneumonia, so the hospital should have immediately checked her in! Yes, I believe the hospital is guilty of malpractice & tried to pass the buck onto the father. He wasn’t even there during one of his daughter’s respiratory distress incidents. Wasn’t it the hospital that called the law & CPS on the father. Maybe it was the hospital pushing for his arrest & indictment by saying things that made the father look bad, since they didn’t check this toddler into their hospital & basically sent her home to die & didn’t hospitalize her until he brought her back again.
@angelas3872 This is what you get with medical privatization, HMOs, Insurance medicine, and overall corporate medicine. You get junk medical care. What makes anyone think that businessmen, who only care about profits, bottom lines, cutting corners, buy low sell high, care anything about the delivery of top notch medicine? Our medical doctor community has been flooded with foreign doctors, primarily from conservative countries who have the same political values as the MAGA Right. I haven't had or even seen a Anglo physician since I was a child. How is this explained? We need to stop corporate privatization. Once a corporation gets a hold of a company, they drain its assets and reduce it to its lowest functioning capabilities, if not destroy it out of existence altogether. This has been going on for decades.
It's good to know that there's people who care about justice and other people. Dr Phil thank you for caring about such important issues in this country.
Can we talk about the ineffectiveness of the State? This didn’t happen solely because of ineffectiveness of defense counsel. The State went after this man to seek a win-not to seek justice. This happens every, single day in every , single state of the United States. And yes, the legislators at that table are accountable, too.
YES!! There are far too many innocent people in prison because the goal is conviction not justice...Texas and Florida are the worse...why is there a committee? He shoulda been released years ago.
Well said I agree 100%. I didn’t like how the one guy was trying to lay all the blame on the defense. He’s already jumping to conclusions before he hears everything. Just like the DA did 21 years ago. Shame on him.
This is chilling! The horror of being wrongfully convicted of a crime and being sentenced to death row while actually trying to do what's best for your child! I hope Robert gets a new trial and is exonerated.
Sad but so true. We are so broken as a system. Ppl are wrongfully sent to serve time for crimes they didn't commit. I don't know this case but yes it happens
At this point, a medical examiner can examine the evidence & a DA can just drop the case & the Governor can give him a full pardon, I think. No more trials, just a formal hearing to exonerate & pardon Robert. Then a Lawsuit to get several million dollars in a settlement!
@@jW-vh4tsYeah, just ask the J6 Political Prisoners. They received No Due Process & No Equal Justice & Exculpatory Evidence was withheld &/or destroyed!
Have to commend Dr Phil for going through all the research work and taking the time to present testimony at this to save just one man’s life and/or the justice system.
they didn't kill her either. They tried to save her, but didn't have the knowledge or tools available, at that time, to it. They didn't know, yet, that the phenergan with codeine would suppress her breathing OR give her a brain bleed. (Though I think it's been known for a century that codeine suppresses the respiratory system in ANYONE). the investigators, prescription, DEFENSE attorney AND the witnesses who perjured themselves, as well as the CPS caseworkers who told them to should be investigated themselves and possibly charged with SOMETHING
As an RN that is not familiar with this case…the first thing that came to mind in the beginning when he said Phenergan was given to a baby under two years of age, I knew that was an unbelievable mistake by the prescribing physician!! Thankfully Dr Phil has brought this case to attention !!!!
@@JoanAlderson-rv2ec It's much easierier to prosecute a poor man than a rich man. It's much easier to fit "facts" into tunnel vision to form a narrative for an easy conviction against an easy target.
This RN (who works in peds) agrees as well! Never heard of this case either. I can’t believe the pharmacist didn’t catch it and question the prescriber…. Wrong and sad.
For real!!! I’m neurodivergent and I struggle with screens, learning, or doing zoom, is not stimulating enough for my brain. When I hear the one asking if when Dr.Phil has to have the meetings in video is equally effective I was impressed. I’ve never hear someone that is maybe neurotypical getting that idea on their own, that could be more difficult on video.
I didn't know Dr. Phil was from SE Texas. I am too. Lots of boots just like the guy on the front row to Dr. Phil's left. What Dr. Phil is reading is inhuman, everything about it is criminal.
The goals of state attorneys clearly are get many locked up as possible wether guilty or not, it looks good on them prosecuting a person who killed a child, not go after the Dr's who failed this sick child just pin it on the dad that's easier. Don't want to state Dr's failed patients.
He’s wrong. That’s what it once was & SHOULD be. I’m an avid trial watcher, more & more often judges, & especially DA’s, withhold valuable evidence, are corrupt & only want the W!! 3 recent trials: 2 hung juries & 1 deemed guilty & sentenced to life. They ALL are💯 innocent based on the evidence/lack there of at trial. Prosecution did not prove their case. Seems juries convict on feelings vs facts & evidence. It’s sickening beyond comprehension.
@@lindalucia6334 I don't know about that. But I have seen a lot of prosecutorial misconduct.... Do you ever read The Marshall project and or project innocence?
You don’t have to be autistic to not react to traumatic emotional situations. I love my children more than life itself, but if something happened to either of them I know that no one on the outside would see an expected response from me. When something impacts my heart..all my senses shut down. I’m tired of people being judged because they do not display appropriate behavior!
When I was told when I was 34wks n 4days pregnant on the scan the bitch turned and said no heartbeat no empathy from her nothing just flat out said no heartbeat. I was numb didn't react didn't really say much told them I needed to go home I had get washing out the machine. It only hit me when I got flown to main city hospital they had to confirm noheart beat. Then it hit me like tonne of bricks. He'd of been 15 this year. So yeah people can react in so many different ways to traumatic things not everyone is the same x
@jessicawright6743 if there was "no heartbeat" thats how they usually tell people. They might say "we cant find a heartbeat, so you have to go here to see if they can find it"
Well said facts and happens way too often. Many reasons for not acting appropriately could happen Thank you because no two people are alike. Be different but don't be different
When Dr Phil drops his resume, you know he speaks from experience! Ya best be listening with humble curiosity on how things can be improved for the better!!
I know a toddler named Trenton, whose foster parents truly killed him the daycare kept reporting his bruises and abuse CPS ignored it. In the end they just changed the hardwood floor where the child bled to death from blunt force trauma and no one was investigated or prosecuted. You see how this works? No due process for parents, and no investigations for foster parents. CPS has some explaining to do!
Lots of victims in this country go unheard, unseen. Criminals get to be free and never held accountable. Never trust a Nancy teen thief in parachute colorado. She was reported to law for stealing and they did nothing to stop her crimes. Her dad just moves her around to avoid being caught. Never trust a Nancy teen thief in western colorado!!!!
Dr. Phil is articulate and passionate when he believes something and I have always enjoyed listening to his advice. He has laid an extraordinarily detailed case out for reasonable doubt in this matter. I believe this person did not get a fair trial and should be released as it is impossible to determine beyond a reasonable doubt what happened. Under such circumstances a person should never be charged, let alone executed, when there is doubt and only circumstantial evidence.
After hearing this testimony and the current science, I think a retrial would be another miscarriage of justice. The Texas house should find Robe innocent released and fully compensated for this miscarriage of justice.
@@pix2Purple2025 As a pro in WHAT? Unless it is public speaking, why does that bother you? The uhms are not more than anyone else would say. He at least doesn't say "like" every other sentence. That is what drives me a bit nuts. His uhms were very few.
LOTS (too much) evidence is withheld from trials/juries. Recently it seems juries base their decisions more on feelings vs facts & evidence. Many judges don’t seem to care & MOST DA’s don’t prove their case, are corrupt & ONLY want the W!
LOTS (too much) evidence is withheld from juries. Recently it seems juries base their decisions more on feelings vs facts & evidence. Many judges don’t seem to care & MOST DA’s are corrupt & ONLY want the W!
You have a radical leftist democrat as the director that’s why - take a second look at the people in power of these agency’s they are really Ed’s up wit Trans kids, atheist, America hating, Trump hating Christian hating people that’s why!
@@Famr4evrexactly. Changes will only happen if we unite and stand up ourselves. We are the power the state or fed gov wields. They need us. We pay taxes for them to screw us over any chance they get.
America has blood on there hands of death row innocent people s3nt to death 3700 so far. Robert should immediately get clemency. Now. 21 years American justice from politics to fake nurse and prosecution. I hope the lawyer are disbarred from ever bringing a death row case or any case. In Ireland 🇮🇪 American whitehouse get clemency on Robert now. Billions of money will not gave Robert 21 years of his life back. And being calked a baby killer and s3xual abuse never in the jury room. Defence for Robert. I say how do u sleep at night. If not fir this commitee and Dr Phil and innocent project and a jurors Robert would be dead . This is a human life . Shame on America
This should not be a retrial. There is no case. That poor child died at the hands of the medical team that saw her. They are the people that should be on trial. Robert needs to be released now.
They rigged the trial to avoid someone making that phone call to the DA's office to avoid a medical mal practice million dollar law suit, and they preyed on this autistic man, just trying to do the right thing for his child. 42 times that child went into medical professional hands they they are telling us not one of them, noticed this baby had long term illness?
Not so much “celebrity,” but well educated within the pertinent fields directly related to this case. Yes, his celebrity is extremely helpful. Celebrities in general, can be extremely detrimental in other matters, in which they have absolutely zero expertise, such as politics, etc. 😅😬
I'm not sure we need celebrities coming forward. Their #1 priority is their own narcissism and glory. There are plenty of respectable Psychologists and Psychiatrists who have much better credentials than "Dr" Oprah Phil.
Not Celebrities! They are Woke Morons! Dr Phil is qualified, not because he is a celebrity, but because of his education & massive experience & intellect. Obviously it doesn’t hurt because of his star power, but his show is serious & educational, not so much for entertainment.
@@jstsayn9133Dr Phil no longer answers to Oprah. He is syndicated & is too popular to be canceled by the likes of Oprah. He is qualified too. He has decades of experience & knowledge under his belt. I personally think he is very intelligent. I have a very low opinion of Oprah. She is gross, especially after Maui. Thankfully Dr Phil has come forward to speak up about this blatant miscarriage of justice.
This is such a miscarriage of justice! The medical examiner, and doctors who prescribed medication for the baby that were not meant for a small child, and a medication that was counter indicated should be held acceptable, and prosecuted.
I agree with the death penalty in certain crimes like my rapist should got it but he walks about scot free failed justice system and that's UK justice system. To many of them walk free. Sarah boone just got convicted yest sorry but she should got death penalty shouldn't be allowed to walk free one day. But this man is innocent and they should be letting him walk out of that prison and given the support including ££££££ to compensate him for what they took his life and then prosecute Dr's the states attorneys of that case and anyone else who need be locked up for this
17 people were proven innocent after being put to death. Over 200 people once in death row were later exonerated. Please look into Jarvis Jay Masters case. He's already spent way too long on DR.
I would say they played a huge role in not only her death but the shift of blame for their guilt into the look to Distract from the reality of their own fault and the physical condition the tramma the would have allowed he to take blame for aswell ...there is a serious need to address that at some point ...and The heart break and sorrow her father has been let with not only the burden of them but for the last 20 something year ❤ I thank you for having the guts and the entergy to address that !
That is the reason I do not go to the hospital even if I am really sick. I don’t trust them and the last time I went I ended up being sick for three months afterwards. Trying to find out what they gave me to make me so Ill. I will find out!!!
As the grandmom of a autistic grandson who is now 21, everything doctor Phil described is exactly how Andrew responds in a conversation, no emotions, no eye contact and flat in his words.
@@mitchdevi6432 What are NORMALLY misdemeanors, were changed to felonies for that specific trial and many of the prosecutions witnesses lied. It was all a sham, but you support a former prosecutor who unjustly convicted and imprisoned many people and isn't called "heels up" for nothing! You still believe people who said there was nothing wrong with Biden, many times when his dementia was apparent, until CNN outed themselves and everyone else who lied about his condition with his disastrous debate performance. You cannot say that they didn't know and that they didn't cover it up!
@@mitchdevi6432je supports a patriot for president. What stupid shit are you going to say when those felonies are overturned. Dr. Phil is smart enough to know all the indictments are bs and election interference. And Trump will be your next president. Get your tissues ready
@@mitchdevi6432 do you mean Biden and Harris 🤣😂 open your eyes 👁️👁️ 👈 and your brain 🧠👈 before too late.? I think you got brainwash by socialism and communism Democratic…………….
This guy needs to be released, not retried. It must be a mistrial and not be recharged. Evidence was withheld and no prosecutor should have brought charges in the first place. He is clearly innocent.
@@lisajeter9511The prosecutor can only go with what they know. I think in this case, they may not have even had the full picture because the ME didn’t do their job. So to me, it’s the ME that needs to be held accountable and now the current DA needs to step up and do something about this case.
Under a mistrial. A new trial can be set by prosecutors. How about grant him clemency. Cant be tried for the same case twice; DOUBLE JEOPARDY! Unconstitutional!
If your own attorney tells in a closing argument it is a shaken baby syndrome then you convict your own client. His defense attorneys did a horrible and disgusting job . They never looked into the evidence or brought an expert to his defense
Hospital staff and Doctors . Attorneys as well . Courts should not disallow evidence especially if it can lead to questions of a person's innocence or guilt. I would imagine the State could be sued. Rightly so . The child's doctor should be sued along with the hospital . After all, there was negligence in all of their part in this case . Hearing the evidence that was not presented would give one the impression, there may have been a coverup or that those that were involved in any shape or form, were not dedicated to their jobs and the oaths they took .
My 29 year old autistic son has flat affect. Law enforcement harrassed him as a teenager and young adult PRIOR TO EDUCATION ON AUTISM. They believed he was "high" or "drunk" "weird", etc... I had to contact Sheriffs in 3 countied and many Police Cheifs to present education materials to Law Enforcement on Autism. My son has a 4 year old development. He is unable to defend against false allegations. I am afraid of the State of Texas and am extremely relieved we do not live there.
California has a very ineffective CPS and child welfare system that causes A LOT of problems for society and damage to child victims of abuse. They don't protect. If you want to talk about how government should be dismantled (and rebuilt), start with the State of California CPS.
Most people don’t understand that it is extremely easy for prosecutors and judges to wrongly convict innocent people. It’s a huge problem in America. When evidence of innocence or Brady (withheld evidence) comes to light, the prosecution and judges will do almost everything to ignore, and have the conviction remain in place
It is very easy to get a wrongful convicton. And I hate to say it, but police are allowed to lie in order to get a confession - say people were seen doing such and such or are on video doing it when they weren't. I'm not for more rules or laws, but if we can't lie to police, they should not be able to lie to us.
THE ONLY CRIME COMMITTED was by the doctors for WRONG ADMINISTRATION OF RESPIRATORY DEPRESSANTS Bad legal representation in trial This whole case is obviously a sham!!! No retrial is necessary since no crime by accused was committed; only crimes by medical medical examiner counsel courts -- everybody dropped the ball Cudos to Robert for forgiving them of destroying his life & Nearly killing him!!! Poor dad doing his best, grieving over the legitimate loss of his daughter and having to suffer such collective incompetence!!!!
Agree. ALL evidence. No matter what. Phil said the child had anal tears, and then said that info was dropped. Why? In any event, that poor child suffered life and is now gone. May she rest in peace 🙏
Scientific results do not lie. As well as medical errors have been documentated, regarding medicine given to the child, when it was written--not to give to a child under 2 yrs old, & given twice, with second dose of medicine having codeine in it. This man did not get a fair trial, like Dr Phil said, because of of a misdiagnosis & no proper attorney knowledge, of the client & medical knowledge not being provided during the trial by his attorney.
Absolutely, self-preservation is the worst human trait. The true enemy are those who sell their beliefs and knowledge for money. Even worse are those who refuse to disrupt their lives due to fear or even want to think for themselve. They're aware that they use the population for profit for an entity(State and Federal ) in order to maintain their job/career. This included doctors that have been letting insurance/CEO keep them from treating their patients due to restriction. Dhs workers taking kids from good families and leaving the abused in the homes due to $$$. READ THE CONSTITUTION. Everyone is afraid to stand alone, our children are suffering.
I reported a teen thief Nancy to law and the school. They did nothing to stop her crimes and hold her accountable. Her dad just moves her around to avoid being caught. She's currently in parachute colorado. She's still stealing from others. This must be their goal. They want more crime I guess.
That would have helped me when I had a known felon attacked me at my house...... he had just gotten out of prison I was drinking the night before at the carnival or I would have never had him there most likely.. but anyway here's the story it's long.. I was at my crappy apartment 112 Ellsworth Avenue Batavia New York.... he had spent the night with this girl that will do anyone while his wife was at home... anyway people were having a cookout Outback on my grill we always cooked out on would everyday... he was eating people's food they were complaining to me.. I said Tom you got to ask before you eat people's food..... he was drunk probably an 18 pack I was not going to drink the day after I was drunk I wasn't drinking.... I said you should ask before you eat people's food he said I take what I want he grabbed a butter knife and said I can kill you with this!!! And yes he could...... well I have a really big knife and I pulled it out and I said yeah well I can really f*** you up with this but I know he was drunk I threw the knife in the sink and then he threw me on the floor and he was choking me nearly to death while all the people outside just stand there watching nice friends.... finally my kids mother got him off me she was out in the yard running around saying he's going to kill me... I was on my knot enclosed porch telling him you better never come up here I'm going to hurt you!! I thought my kids mother called the cops nobody did..... so he came up there and I had a ether can and I know what it can do if you light it and he was pumped up from being in prison and I'm handicapped... so he comes running up and I thought I killed him and I actually kind of felt bad it didn't hurt him cuz it burned so fast it burned his hair off it burnt his T-shirt a little I did not want to kill him I wanted him to leave me alone.... a cop came named Milam I know him I told him the truth which I never should have done and he took me to jail..... I got released after a couple days... it went to what is that before court? Grand jury I don't think they told the grand jury the truth about him nor were allowed to that he's a criminal on parole.. during the whole court case nobody ever mentioned he was back in prison for attacking a man and ripping his eyeballs out he was in prison when I went to court on Christmas Eve in Genesee County New York... I was supposed to get 5 years probation I got a year in jail.... if the judge had known which he should have the whole story it should have made a difference.. after I got a year in jail they judge the judge ask the district attorney Friedman I can't stand him why would you let him off so easy on such a heinous crime...... he said because I would have won in the court of law nobody told the judge anything about Tom people were praising me for doing what I did cuz he did really bad things to a lot of people I missed the first 8 months of my son's life..... years later they want me to go be on a jury and I said no I'm not going to be on a jury she goes why I go because I'm going to find everybody innocent unless I was there if you got any circumstantial evidence I'm going to find them innocent I will sit there for years... I think people actually get found guilty that are not guilty and they are not guilty because people get tired of waiting in the juror room for days and weeks I really think it's possible cuz one person against 11 or whatever people being bitching at you telling you to get it over with okay get it over with put them in jail and kill them you're right all testimony should be allowed but it wasn't not in this County Genesee County New York if all of the evidence was shown it wouldn't even have gone to court they would not allow anybody to talk about him being a prison inmate on parole at the Grand Jury it was so screwed up..... I'm physically disabled I was about to be attacked or killed by someone who can lift 350 lb working out at prison and I went to jail I should have got a prize.... also he was not seriously injured left the hospital cuz he was drunk and he's on parole he immediately went back to prison he took me to court when I was in jail for a carton of cigarettes and his freaking t-shirt so I come out of jail and go to court for 1 minute the judge said did I have his cigarettes and I said no he goes you going to pay for his T-shirt I said no I'm not and it was over.... maybe I shouldn't say this but I'm glad he's dead he probably would never learned his lesson fighting with people because the reason he died he had his tooth in his lung for 8 years it traumatized me I am very careful I don't let anybody in my house unless I know them really well I don't understand why circumstantial evidence is ever allowed it doesn't prove anything
Thank you Dr Phil for studying and speaking about this man and his case.
Good to see Dr. Phil standing up for what he feels is right.
Yeah, whatever. did you hear him speak at the Trump nazi rally in madison square garden?
Phil is a fascist. Booooooo!
that s why he is called ****DR. PHIL****
Yes
What he knows is right.
🎉 40:32 😅eyyyyyyyyyyy e@@annieleouzon6598
Doctors need be held accountable too.
Why? They were guided by the science at the time.
Absolutely 💯
Medical Examiner they made too many mistakes in many court cases.
@@mariee.5912no, I’ve been medical for over 50 YEARS- the drugs given this child were prescribed erroneously and medical MUST BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE!!!!
Drugs kill more people than are admitted to
EVERY SINGLE FDA APPROVED DRUG IS A CHEMICAL STRESSOR BECAUSE THEY ARE ALLLLLLL SYNTHETIC- our bodies are NEVER SYNTHETIC- therefore on top of all genuine needs, drugs kill!!!!
And the prosecutor. He or she saw felony convictions and was looking for something to get re-elected on. No due diligence here and the defense, who works with the prosecution everyday just wanted to push the case through.
i'm impressed w this Texas House Committee Board. they are engaged asking the right questions and seem to understand science. awesome panel texans should be proud⭐️
They don’t know what an eptopic pregnancy is or that incest/rape babies aren’t a good thing, but sure, they’ve *totally* got this one that requires pediatric neurologists, immunologists, traumatic specialists, pathologists to understand. Good thing they have disgraced psychologist/tv personality “Dr. Phil” and John Grisham to sort it out for them!
Have all critical thinking skills gone out the window? Do we all have collective brain rot?? What is happening??
I'm 40 minutes in and this group is barely asking Dr. Phil any questions. Don't seem too bright or don't care.
@@briannacc3983
You're only a third the way.
Use at least a third of your brain.
@@briannacc3983 its good they are listening and it is a good sign when leaders listen had this committee not stopped the attorney general that man would have been executed already
Yes! And other states should definitely sit up and pay attention. Imo
Thank you Dr. Phil for your caring to bring justice to our broken system more now than ever.
Are you really taking Dr. Phil seriously??? Maybe they should have the muffin man on next.
Dr. Phil is a disgraced “psychologist” TV personality.
It’s truly telling that their “expert”witnesses are Dr. Phil and John Grisham. Would love to know how much they were paid for this nonsense.
Bless their hearts. (But not Robert Roberson’s)
He's one of the few who's testimony on any subject I would trust the account given on any investigation.
@@rebeccarice1209I agree with all you've said. How much was he paid? Calling him a Dr. Is like calling Pirone a real judge, imo. Paid tv personalities making big money from ignorant people.
@@teresawachter3020
Why?
Because he was on TV?🤪
He had training?
He hasn't kept up with it and does NOT have a license to practice!
Dr. Phil thank you for standing up to this outrage !
One of the best testimonies and research of a case with commitment and conviction. Thank you Dr. Phil.
I know. Becuase of his show, most people have ZERO clue his background and expertise
Thank you dr Phil for being a voice for this man !lord have mercy on this poor innocent man !set him free and compensate him from all his suffering and struggles!he needs someone to take care of him and to show ❤️ him some love !
❤❤❤
PERHAPS THE RICH GREG ABBOT SHOULD PAY FOR HIS DISABILITIES. IT IS NOT EASY TO CARE FOR CHILDREN, who then become ADULTS WITH THESE ISSUES. 😢
@@sassylady54 OK, so you would murder your child after it was born because it was disabled? That's horrible.
@elouise5593 Don't be stupid! I have a grown man son (50yrs) with ADD/BI POLAR. IT was not easy throughout the years, but he made the life he now lives!
@@sassylady54LOUSE5593 is a damaged troll. It doesn’t know how to self-reflect and has no capacity for critical thinking. It’s tantrums and diatribes are its only means of regurgitating the divisive talking points and hate that it ingests copiously every day. I raised a special needs child, as you did. A creature like the LOUSE above is incapable empathy, let alone even a hint of understanding. Bless you for standing up to the ⬇️IQ troll.
Can you imagine the amount of hell this person been through in prison by other inmates that think his charges were true.
SOUNDS LIKE THERE WAS MEDICAL MALPRACTICE GOING ON FROM THE BEGINNING. AND EVERY TIME THEY TOOK HER TO THE HOSPITAL SHE GOT WORSE. THERE SHOULD HAVE BEEN A TOXICOLOGY INVESTIGATION, INDEPENDENT.
Very possible ..
She should have been hospitalized! Not just given more meds.
@@HolyMoly432absolutely, especially considering she was under the age of two, her temperature being 104.5
I agree! The hospital kept sending her home rather than keeping her in the hospital. They neglected to take care of her properly. They over medicated her with opiates too. She needed to be on IVs, antibiotics, steroid inhaler, oxygen, & monitoring her breathing & heartbeat. Not sent home with Codeine Cough Syrup (Promethazine) & an opiate suppository. Two opioid medications that suppressed her breathing while her lungs were literally being eaten by pneumonia. She had necrotic tissue in her lungs, dead rotting tissue in her lungs. The doctor should have ordered chest X-rays, or if they already had in the beginning, they should have taken more to show the pneumonia & the patient’s condition had gotten worse. The X-rays would show the pneumonia spreading in the lungs. Every time I or a family member ever had gotten sick with a really bad cough, they snapped chest
X-rays. I looked at the X-rays & could see my lungs had white spots from pneumonia, instead of black spaces should be showing clear lungs. Chest rads are really easy to figure out for anyone with the slightest medical knowledge. A Veterinarian Technician could look at the X-rays & see there was a major problem. Children & Elderly patients are much more vulnerable to pneumonia, so the hospital should have immediately checked her in! Yes, I believe the hospital is guilty of malpractice & tried to pass the buck onto the father. He wasn’t even there during one of his daughter’s respiratory distress incidents. Wasn’t it the hospital that called the law & CPS on the father. Maybe it was the hospital pushing for his arrest & indictment by saying things that made the father look bad, since they didn’t check this toddler into their hospital & basically sent her home to die & didn’t hospitalize her until he brought her back again.
@angelas3872
This is what you get with medical privatization, HMOs, Insurance medicine, and overall corporate medicine. You get junk medical care.
What makes anyone think that businessmen, who only care about profits, bottom lines, cutting corners, buy low sell high, care anything about the delivery of top notch medicine?
Our medical doctor community has been flooded with foreign doctors, primarily from conservative countries who have the same political values as the MAGA Right. I haven't had or even seen a Anglo physician since I was a child. How is this explained? We need to stop corporate privatization.
Once a corporation gets a hold of a company, they drain its assets and reduce it to its lowest functioning capabilities, if not destroy it out of existence altogether. This has been going on for decades.
Admire and respect Dr. Phil, thank you Sir for standing for justice !
It's good to know that there's people who care about justice and other people. Dr Phil thank you for caring about such important issues in this country.
Can we talk about the ineffectiveness of the State? This didn’t happen solely because of ineffectiveness of defense counsel. The State went after this man to seek a win-not to seek justice. This happens every, single day in every , single state of the United States. And yes, the legislators at that table are accountable, too.
Agree 100%
@@kathyborthwick6738LakotaEmojiMe too.
YES!! There are far too many innocent people in prison because the goal is conviction not justice...Texas and Florida are the worse...why is there a committee? He shoulda been released years ago.
His defense sucked.
Well said I agree 100%. I didn’t like how the one guy was trying to lay all the blame on the defense. He’s already jumping to conclusions before he hears everything. Just like the DA did 21 years ago. Shame on him.
This is chilling! The horror of being wrongfully convicted of a crime and being sentenced to death row while actually trying to do what's best for your child! I hope Robert gets a new trial and is exonerated.
This happens every day in this country.
Sad but so true. We are so broken as a system. Ppl are wrongfully sent to serve time for crimes they didn't commit. I don't know this case but yes it happens
At this point, a medical examiner can examine the evidence & a DA can just drop the case & the Governor can give him a full pardon, I think. No more trials, just a formal hearing to exonerate & pardon Robert. Then a Lawsuit to get several million dollars in a settlement!
@@jW-vh4tsYeah, just ask the J6 Political Prisoners. They received No Due Process & No Equal Justice & Exculpatory Evidence was withheld &/or destroyed!
The charges should be dropped!
💯 exactly! The court should be about seeking justice, not a win-lose outcome.
Same in the Karen Read case
Have to commend Dr Phil for going through all the research work and taking the time to present testimony at this to save just one man’s life and/or the justice system.
Did they say Dr
@louemmett3333 yes sir, they did...
Great job Dr. Phil!!
Release Robert and retry the doctor and council and medical examiner.PERIOD😮😮
they didn't kill her either. They tried to save her, but didn't have the knowledge or tools available, at that time, to it. They didn't know, yet, that the phenergan with codeine would suppress her breathing OR give her a brain bleed. (Though I think it's been known for a century that codeine suppresses the respiratory system in ANYONE). the investigators, prescription, DEFENSE attorney AND the witnesses who perjured themselves, as well as the CPS caseworkers who told them to should be investigated themselves and possibly charged with SOMETHING
As an RN that is not familiar with this case…the first thing that came to mind in the beginning when he said Phenergan was given to a baby under two years of age, I knew that was an unbelievable mistake by the prescribing physician!! Thankfully Dr Phil has brought this case to attention !!!!
As an RN, I concur.
And it seems like that doc should be charged!
😮
@@JoanAlderson-rv2ec It's much easierier to prosecute a poor man than a rich man. It's much easier to fit "facts" into tunnel vision to form a narrative for an easy conviction against an easy target.
This RN (who works in peds) agrees as well! Never heard of this case either. I can’t believe the pharmacist didn’t catch it and question the prescriber…. Wrong and sad.
Dr. Phil, as a southeast Texas man, you have you have affirmed my faith in men that stand for the truth. Thank you sir.
For real!!! I’m neurodivergent and I struggle with screens, learning, or doing zoom, is not stimulating enough for my brain. When I hear the one asking if when Dr.Phil has to have the meetings in video is equally effective I was impressed. I’ve never hear someone that is maybe neurotypical getting that idea on their own, that could be more difficult on video.
Hes still a lost soul by supporting a Felon for president
❤❤❤❤
I didn't know Dr. Phil was from SE Texas. I am too. Lots of boots just like the guy on the front row to Dr. Phil's left. What Dr. Phil is reading is inhuman, everything about it is criminal.
He a lier an friend with Don the felon I don't trust him
Dr. Phil “The goal of prosecution is to seek justice not conviction”
The goals of state attorneys clearly are get many locked up as possible wether guilty or not, it looks good on them prosecuting a person who killed a child, not go after the Dr's who failed this sick child just pin it on the dad that's easier. Don't want to state Dr's failed patients.
He’s wrong. That’s what it once was & SHOULD be.
I’m an avid trial watcher, more & more often judges, & especially DA’s, withhold valuable evidence, are corrupt & only want the W!!
3 recent trials: 2 hung juries & 1 deemed guilty & sentenced to life.
They ALL are💯 innocent based on the evidence/lack there of at trial. Prosecution did not prove their case. Seems juries convict on feelings vs facts & evidence. It’s sickening beyond comprehension.
Not , necessarily true in all cases.
And Dr Phil even says that as I am typing
@@JaneDoe-m6w I think we can agree it’s in the majority of cases
@@lindalucia6334 I don't know about that.
But I have seen a lot of prosecutorial misconduct....
Do you ever read The Marshall project and or project innocence?
Good for you Dr Phil, these Cases need to be brought to light.
You don’t have to be autistic to not react to traumatic emotional situations. I love my children more than life itself, but if something happened to either of them I know that no one on the outside would see an expected response from me. When something impacts my heart..all my senses shut down. I’m tired of people being judged because they do not display appropriate behavior!
When I was told when I was 34wks n 4days pregnant on the scan the bitch turned and said no heartbeat no empathy from her nothing just flat out said no heartbeat. I was numb didn't react didn't really say much told them I needed to go home I had get washing out the machine. It only hit me when I got flown to main city hospital they had to confirm noheart beat. Then it hit me like tonne of bricks. He'd of been 15 this year. So yeah people can react in so many different ways to traumatic things not everyone is the same x
@jessicawright6743 if there was "no heartbeat" thats how they usually tell people. They might say "we cant find a heartbeat, so you have to go here to see if they can find it"
@@justmissjamey They could at least show SOME sympathy!
@@jessicawright6743I’m so sorry that you didn’t get the kindness and compassion that you needed that sorrowful day.
That wasn’t right. 😔
Well said facts and happens way too often. Many reasons for not acting appropriately could happen
Thank you because no two people are alike. Be different but don't be different
When Dr Phil drops his resume, you know he speaks from experience!
Ya best be listening with humble curiosity on how things can be improved for the better!!
Absolutely ❤
Outstanding summary by Phil McGraw. A total mis-carriage of justice. Roberson should be released from custody.
If he released from prison I hope they will provide help for him since he is on the spectrum and in prison for 21-22 yrs. So very sad.
@ institutionalized
I know a toddler named Trenton, whose foster parents truly killed him the daycare kept reporting his bruises and abuse CPS ignored it. In the end they just changed the hardwood floor where the child bled to death from blunt force trauma and no one was investigated or prosecuted. You see how this works? No due process for parents, and no investigations for foster parents. CPS has some explaining to do!
That's truly sad and beyond disgusting.CPS is so corrupt
Lots of victims in this country go unheard, unseen. Criminals get to be free and never held accountable. Never trust a Nancy teen thief in parachute colorado. She was reported to law for stealing and they did nothing to stop her crimes. Her dad just moves her around to avoid being caught. Never trust a Nancy teen thief in western colorado!!!!
There would still be blood under the floor boards that forensics could test.
Nothing is ever truly destroyed.
INDEED, IN DUE COURSE 😢
CPS DFS needs to be completely overhauled & reimagined. They have lunatics & morons on their payroll.
Dr. Phil is articulate and passionate when he believes something and I have always enjoyed listening to his advice. He has laid an extraordinarily detailed case out for reasonable doubt in this matter. I believe this person did not get a fair trial and should be released as it is impossible to determine beyond a reasonable doubt what happened. Under such circumstances a person should never be charged, let alone executed, when there is doubt and only circumstantial evidence.
After hearing this testimony and the current science, I think a retrial would be another miscarriage of justice. The Texas house should find Robe innocent released and fully compensated for this miscarriage of justice.
I love Dr. Phil. A true professional and caring human being. ❤️
He is not human anymore ! It’s a clone.
@@annlyon.2040omg
I am not a Dr. Phil's fan, but I really like that he's helping in this case.
The “uhms” bother me a lot as a pro.
@@pix2Purple2025 As a pro in WHAT? Unless it is public speaking, why does that bother you? The uhms are not more than anyone else would say. He at least doesn't say "like" every other sentence. That is what drives me a bit nuts. His uhms were very few.
Doctor Phil has helped a lot of ppl. What's not to like
This man doesn't deserve a retrial..... he deserves CLEMENCY, immediate release, and a big fat check from the Prosecutors office that tried him.
💯💯💯
💯 agree.
Totally ☝🏽
absolutely 💯
Indeed he does!
Wow. I had no idea that Dr. Phil was anything other than a talk show host. Much respect!
Try watching the TV series “Bull.” That series is based on Dr. Phil’s career as a legal jury consultant. It’s fascinating.
I used to watch his shows. He's a very astute psychologist.
A great legal background.
Thank you so very much for this God bless you😊
@@karencole1037Wow! I never heard of that show. Thanks for sharing.
Thank-you for saving this sweet man❤
No evidence should ever be withheld in any trial case
LOTS (too much) evidence is withheld from trials/juries. Recently it seems juries base their decisions more on feelings vs facts & evidence.
Many judges don’t seem to care & MOST DA’s don’t prove their case, are corrupt & ONLY want the W!
LOTS (too much) evidence is withheld from juries. Recently it seems juries base their decisions more on feelings vs facts & evidence.
Many judges don’t seem to care & MOST DA’s are corrupt & ONLY want the W!
You're correct. It's known as a Brady violation and the DA can be held accountable.
@@terryruggiero1718nah DA’s have sovereign immunity
@@terryruggiero1718nah DA’s have sovereign immunity
Dr Phil please be a voice for all the parents being abused by CPS and our judiciary system
That is to much work for one person.
You have a radical leftist democrat as the director that’s why - take a second look at the people in power of these agency’s they are really Ed’s up wit Trans kids, atheist, America hating, Trump hating Christian hating people that’s why!
@@kat-75agreed.
We all need to take a stand and speak up for the families in our communities.
@@Famr4evrexactly. Changes will only happen if we unite and stand up ourselves. We are the power the state or fed gov wields. They need us. We pay taxes for them to screw us over any chance they get.
THIS 🎉🎉🎉 BEING COURT ORDERED TO BE ABUSED CONTROL BY OUR EX AND ABUSED OVER AND OVER WITH OUR KIDS IS HELL. HELL ON EARTH.
Robert has been horribly wronged and needs SPECIAL HELP and to be GREATLY COMPENSATED!
Excellent work Dr Phil. One of your life long fans who watched your Dr Phil shows every day. ❤❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Maybe you should turn off the TV and get a job.
@jamesschwartmahne you should mind your damn business Karen z3837
Not very nice ...
I bought all his books....helped me so much .
@@leoniea138 😆
This man and 3,600 others waiting for exoneration . Something’s very wrong with this country and the corrupt people in power!!
Justice reform🥳🙏💪The time is now!
It's called judges owning prisons and needing to keep them full.
What did he do?
@@74the_magpie Took his sick toddler to the hospital that killed her by not treating her illness, then blamed him for her death.
@@74the_magpie his baby thought to have died from shaken baby syndrome but Drs say that’s not correct.
Dr Phil is a righteous dude. ❤
No crime has been committed he should be set free.
SYSTEM FAIL! I agree!
America has blood on there hands of death row innocent people s3nt to death 3700 so far. Robert should immediately get clemency. Now. 21 years American justice from politics to fake nurse and prosecution. I hope the lawyer are disbarred from ever bringing a death row case or any case. In Ireland 🇮🇪 American whitehouse get clemency on Robert now. Billions of money will not gave Robert 21 years of his life back. And being calked a baby killer and s3xual abuse never in the jury room. Defence for Robert. I say how do u sleep at night. If not fir this commitee and Dr Phil and innocent project and a jurors Robert would be dead . This is a human life . Shame on America
This should not be a retrial. There is no case. That poor child died at the hands of the medical team that saw her. They are the people that should be on trial. Robert needs to be released now.
They rigged the trial to avoid someone making that phone call to the DA's office to avoid a medical mal practice million dollar law suit, and they preyed on this autistic man, just trying to do the right thing for his child. 42 times that child went into medical professional hands they they are telling us not one of them, noticed this baby had long term illness?
I have never been a fan of Dr Phil but his speech was amazing. Also he brought up great points about due process being denied.
I've changed my mind.
John Grisham likewise.
I have never followed Dr. Phil of himself as I call him but he spoke nothing but truth here!
Phul
I have found new respect for Dr Phil. We need more celebrity coming forward against injustice. Thank you Dr Phil
Not so much “celebrity,” but well educated within the pertinent fields directly related to this case.
Yes, his celebrity is extremely helpful.
Celebrities in general, can be extremely detrimental in other matters, in which they have absolutely zero expertise, such as politics, etc. 😅😬
Same
I'm not sure we need celebrities coming forward. Their #1 priority is their own narcissism and glory. There are plenty of respectable Psychologists and Psychiatrists who have much better credentials than "Dr" Oprah Phil.
Not Celebrities! They are Woke Morons! Dr Phil is qualified, not because he is a celebrity, but because of his education & massive experience & intellect. Obviously it doesn’t hurt because of his star power, but his show is serious & educational, not so much for entertainment.
@@jstsayn9133Dr Phil no longer answers to Oprah. He is syndicated & is too popular to be canceled by the likes of Oprah. He is qualified too. He has decades of experience & knowledge under his belt. I personally think he is very intelligent. I have a very low opinion of Oprah. She is gross, especially after Maui. Thankfully Dr Phil has come forward to speak up about this blatant miscarriage of justice.
Thank you, Dr, Phil. For the truth.
i do too dr phil! i appreciate you and your team all the work and research done here. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This man has suffered enough. It does sound as if he was prosecuted wrongly. He should be vindicated. 🙏
He should be released asap .
This is such a miscarriage of justice! The medical examiner, and doctors who prescribed medication for the baby that were not meant for a small child, and a medication that was counter indicated should be held acceptable, and prosecuted.
"Seek justice, not conviction" - a statement that should be tĥe goal of every courtroom in this country!
@DrAnnBlakeTracy. PRAY TELL 😢 😮
The word is contraindicated, NOT counter indicated.
Dr. Phil is spot on about the situation in the appeal process😢😮
Thank you Dr.Phil for coming forward and telling your story
This is why I am against the death penalty; there are to many innocent people in jail. It's wrong.❤
I agree with the death penalty in certain crimes like my rapist should got it but he walks about scot free failed justice system and that's UK justice system. To many of them walk free. Sarah boone just got convicted yest sorry but she should got death penalty shouldn't be allowed to walk free one day. But this man is innocent and they should be letting him walk out of that prison and given the support including ££££££ to compensate him for what they took his life and then prosecute Dr's the states attorneys of that case and anyone else who need be locked up for this
17 people were proven innocent after being put to death. Over 200 people once in death row were later exonerated. Please look into Jarvis Jay Masters case. He's already spent way too long on DR.
It is necessary to have the death penalty BUT IT IS NECESSARY to get to the truth.
OMG 😳
THE HOSPITAL KILLED THAT BABY!!!!
I would say they played a huge role in not only her death but the shift of blame for their guilt into the look to
Distract from the reality of their own fault and the physical condition the tramma the would have allowed he to take blame for aswell ...there is a serious need to address that at some point ...and The heart break and sorrow her father has been let with not only the burden of them but for the last 20 something year ❤ I thank you for having the guts and the entergy to address that !
Just like many of other Americans during Covid can you see a trend hear? We must wake up:)
Dr phil is spot on regarding autism. It was very interesting to listen to him off of his show...
Thank you DR Phil it’s very honorable of you .
Incompetence in the medical field is legendary.
That is the reason I do not go to the hospital even if I am really sick. I don’t trust them and the last time I went I ended up being sick for three months afterwards. Trying to find out what they gave me to make me so Ill. I will find out!!!
As the grandmom of a autistic grandson who is now 21, everything doctor Phil described is exactly how Andrew responds in a conversation, no emotions, no eye contact and flat in his words.
❤❤❤🙏❤❤❤
My son as well. It really scares me
Wow! It appears that this whole trial was screwed up! Should be dismissed.
Doc Phil & Mrs. Compton , Thanks for stepping up & doing the right thing!
Too often all the courts care about is getting a conviction. So wrong and so sad b
Thanks Dr. Phil you’re doing great job thanks sir ❤️🥰✊💪👍👏👏👏!!!
Problem though… he supports a Felon for President
@@mitchdevi6432 do you mean Biden and Harris 😂🤣 open your eyes 👁️👁️👈 and your brain 🧠👈 don’t be brainwash by Democratic communism…………
@@mitchdevi6432 What are NORMALLY misdemeanors, were changed to felonies for that specific trial and many of the prosecutions witnesses lied. It was all a sham, but you support a former prosecutor who unjustly convicted and imprisoned many people and isn't called "heels up" for nothing! You still believe people who said there was nothing wrong with Biden, many times when his dementia was apparent, until CNN outed themselves and everyone else who lied about his condition with his disastrous debate performance. You cannot say that they didn't know and that they didn't cover it up!
@@mitchdevi6432je supports a patriot for president. What stupid shit are you going to say when those felonies are overturned. Dr. Phil is smart enough to know all the indictments are bs and election interference. And Trump will be your next president. Get your tissues ready
@@mitchdevi6432 do you mean Biden and Harris 🤣😂 open your eyes 👁️👁️ 👈 and your brain 🧠👈 before too late.? I think you got brainwash by socialism and communism Democratic…………….
This guy needs to be released, not retried. It must be a mistrial and not be recharged. Evidence was withheld and no prosecutor should have brought charges in the first place. He is clearly innocent.
There will never be Justice in cases like this until the Prosecutors are tried for Misconduct! Which will never happen in this Country!
@@lisajeter9511The prosecutor can only go with what they know. I think in this case, they may not have even had the full picture because the ME didn’t do their job. So to me, it’s the ME that needs to be held accountable and now the current DA needs to step up and do something about this case.
Under a mistrial. A new trial can be set by prosecutors.
How about grant him clemency. Cant be tried for the same case twice; DOUBLE JEOPARDY! Unconstitutional!
@@lisajeter9511right! All because prosecutors and judges have super immunity. If you will.
Police have qualified immunity.
Kudos to dr. Phil!
If your own attorney tells in a closing argument it is a shaken baby syndrome then you convict your own client. His defense attorneys did a horrible and disgusting job . They never looked into the evidence or brought an expert to his defense
💯🇺🇸Thank you Dr. Phil for being for the innocent, and vying for justice where it is sue.🇺🇸🙏🏻🌹🙏💯
Sounds to me the hospital messed up and lied on the dad!!!
Hospital staff and Doctors . Attorneys as well . Courts should not disallow evidence especially if it can lead to questions of a person's innocence or guilt. I would imagine the State could be sued. Rightly so . The child's doctor should be sued along with the hospital . After all, there was negligence in all of their part in this case . Hearing the evidence that was not presented would give one the impression, there may have been a coverup or that those that were involved in any shape or form, were not dedicated to their jobs and the oaths they took .
"Was there remorse?" Why should there be remorse if no crime was committed?
I agree. People looking for parole who consistently deny their guilt MUST show remorse. Absurd.
Exactly! What an inappropriate question.
Exactly my thought
Thank God for Dr. PHIL and his testimony and may they get that man out of jail.
Dr Phil explains it in away an idiot could understand it.
Wow, 104 fever is not shaken baby syndrome. It's the hospital not doing it's job IMO.
Our system is very ill.
Very
The world"....... I'm the real alien passing through this hot mess on the planet.
that's no maybe..
My 29 year old autistic son has flat affect. Law enforcement harrassed him as a teenager and young adult PRIOR TO EDUCATION ON AUTISM. They believed he was "high" or "drunk" "weird", etc...
I had to contact Sheriffs in 3 countied and many Police Cheifs to present education materials to Law Enforcement on Autism.
My son has a 4 year old development. He is unable to defend against false allegations. I am afraid of the State of Texas and am extremely relieved we do not live there.
That could happen in ANY state. Washington state isn't much better as far as CPS goes.
Oklahoma is even worse. We have much room for growth in our judicial system
California has a very ineffective CPS and child welfare system that causes A LOT of problems for society and damage to child victims of abuse. They don't protect. If you want to talk about how government should be dismantled (and rebuilt), start with the State of California CPS.
What a blessing to hear you stood in the gap.
Most people don’t understand that it is extremely easy for prosecutors and judges to wrongly convict innocent people. It’s a huge problem in America. When evidence of innocence or Brady (withheld evidence) comes to light, the prosecution and judges will do almost everything to ignore, and have the conviction remain in place
💯 I have a cousin wrongfully convicted since 2008.
@@nancysmith9147unfortunately your cousin is not the only one
It is very easy to get a wrongful convicton. And I hate to say it, but police are allowed to lie in order to get a confession - say people were seen doing such and such or are on video doing it when they weren't. I'm not for more rules or laws, but if we can't lie to police, they should not be able to lie to us.
Agree! 100%
@@song9119 agree!
It is nice to have a man like Dr. Phil to get involved in this type of case
He a crook lies an got on stage with Don the con who's a felon I don't trust him
We need more Dr’s like Dr Phil
Imagine losing your sweet baby girl 😢 And then Imagine spending the rest of your life in prison, on death row.
THE ONLY CRIME COMMITTED was by the doctors for WRONG ADMINISTRATION OF RESPIRATORY DEPRESSANTS
Bad legal representation in trial
This whole case is obviously a sham!!!
No retrial is necessary since no crime by accused was committed; only crimes by medical medical examiner counsel courts -- everybody dropped the ball
Cudos to Robert for forgiving them of destroying his life &
Nearly killing him!!!
Poor dad doing his best, grieving over the legitimate loss of his daughter and having to suffer such collective incompetence!!!!
All evidence should be brought before the jury. Period.
It was.
@@marciawade8813 Incorrect. Judge kept some things out. That's how it works. I don't like it.
Agree. ALL evidence. No matter what. Phil said the child had anal tears, and then said that info was dropped. Why?
In any event, that poor child suffered life and is now gone. May she rest in peace 🙏
@@auntiedotal not all evidence is actually evidence.
Scientific results do not lie. As well as medical errors have been documentated, regarding medicine given to the child, when it was written--not to give to a child under 2 yrs old, & given twice, with second dose of medicine having codeine in it. This man did not get a fair trial, like Dr Phil said, because of of a misdiagnosis & no proper attorney knowledge, of the client & medical knowledge not being provided during the trial by his attorney.
Wow. Dr Phil is the man!
I watched Dt.phil for yrs, hes definitely knows his history. Very smart educated man right there !!
What I thought to until week or so ago
The court systems are broken!!
Sadly, a lot of it is intentional...
It's not broken. It's working as it was intended to do.
It's not broken. It's working as it was intended.
This man deserves a new trial. Absolutely!!
❤❤🙏❤❤ Bringing the Truth to Light ✨🕯️✨, Amen 💯👍❣️
What would be the charge? He needs exoneration.
@@jeanie8831 they need to investigate and try the hospital and staff!
@@christinaw6264apparently it was 21 years ago though would the staff even be alive?
No he doesn't, he should've NEVER gone to trial! Clemency is what he needs
I'm unfamiliar with this case... but the things hes saying about jury and perception is dead on. He's absolutely correct.
Thank you to the righteously pissed Juror. She kept up following this, good trouble.
Free him.
I'm with Dr Phil
Totally discusting and frightning that soooo much information can either be ignored or supressed that could be used in a trial for justice.
Everybody I know loves Dr Phil, he is the best❤❤❤
Wow! Dr Phil is one powerful man
...in his own mind.
@@drawingmomentum He has a DOCTORATE in clinical psychology, do YOU?
@@drawingmomentumsuch a hater
How horrible 😢 Bless you Dr. Phil!
Oh please, keep Oprah out of any of this air time 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
She is part of injustice…
Absolutely, self-preservation is the worst human trait.
The true enemy are those who sell their beliefs and knowledge for money.
Even worse are those who refuse to disrupt their lives due to fear or even want to think for themselve.
They're aware that they use the population for profit for an entity(State and Federal ) in order to maintain their job/career.
This included doctors that have been letting insurance/CEO keep them from treating their patients due to restriction.
Dhs workers taking kids from good families and leaving the abused in the homes due to $$$.
READ THE CONSTITUTION.
Everyone is afraid to stand alone, our children are suffering.
Absolutely agree with you 💯💯💯💯💯💯
I agree with you 💯💯💯💯
I reported a teen thief Nancy to law and the school. They did nothing to stop her crimes and hold her accountable. Her dad just moves her around to avoid being caught. She's currently in parachute colorado. She's still stealing from others. This must be their goal. They want more crime I guess.
💯💯💯💯💯💯
THANK YOU DR PHIL FOR INVESTIGATING THIS CASE AND LOOKING AT ALL THE EVIDENCE.
THE MEDICAL AND LEGAL PROFESSIONALS NEED TO BE FIRED.
Should be set free paid for being locked up
It should NEVER NOT BE ALLOWED FOR ALL EVIDENCE to be presented in EVERY trial!!!
That would have helped me when I had a known felon attacked me at my house...... he had just gotten out of prison I was drinking the night before at the carnival or I would have never had him there most likely.. but anyway here's the story it's long.. I was at my crappy apartment 112 Ellsworth Avenue Batavia New York.... he had spent the night with this girl that will do anyone while his wife was at home... anyway people were having a cookout Outback on my grill we always cooked out on would everyday... he was eating people's food they were complaining to me.. I said Tom you got to ask before you eat people's food..... he was drunk probably an 18 pack I was not going to drink the day after I was drunk I wasn't drinking.... I said you should ask before you eat people's food he said I take what I want he grabbed a butter knife and said I can kill you with this!!! And yes he could...... well I have a really big knife and I pulled it out and I said yeah well I can really f*** you up with this but I know he was drunk I threw the knife in the sink and then he threw me on the floor and he was choking me nearly to death while all the people outside just stand there watching nice friends.... finally my kids mother got him off me she was out in the yard running around saying he's going to kill me... I was on my knot enclosed porch telling him you better never come up here I'm going to hurt you!! I thought my kids mother called the cops nobody did..... so he came up there and I had a ether can and I know what it can do if you light it and he was pumped up from being in prison and I'm handicapped... so he comes running up and I thought I killed him and I actually kind of felt bad it didn't hurt him cuz it burned so fast it burned his hair off it burnt his T-shirt a little I did not want to kill him I wanted him to leave me alone.... a cop came named Milam I know him I told him the truth which I never should have done and he took me to jail..... I got released after a couple days... it went to what is that before court? Grand jury I don't think they told the grand jury the truth about him nor were allowed to that he's a criminal on parole.. during the whole court case nobody ever mentioned he was back in prison for attacking a man and ripping his eyeballs out he was in prison when I went to court on Christmas Eve in Genesee County New York... I was supposed to get 5 years probation I got a year in jail.... if the judge had known which he should have the whole story it should have made a difference.. after I got a year in jail they judge the judge ask the district attorney Friedman I can't stand him why would you let him off so easy on such a heinous crime...... he said because I would have won in the court of law nobody told the judge anything about Tom people were praising me for doing what I did cuz he did really bad things to a lot of people I missed the first 8 months of my son's life..... years later they want me to go be on a jury and I said no I'm not going to be on a jury she goes why I go because I'm going to find everybody innocent unless I was there if you got any circumstantial evidence I'm going to find them innocent I will sit there for years... I think people actually get found guilty that are not guilty and they are not guilty because people get tired of waiting in the juror room for days and weeks I really think it's possible cuz one person against 11 or whatever people being bitching at you telling you to get it over with okay get it over with put them in jail and kill them you're right all testimony should be allowed but it wasn't not in this County Genesee County New York if all of the evidence was shown it wouldn't even have gone to court they would not allow anybody to talk about him being a prison inmate on parole at the Grand Jury it was so screwed up..... I'm physically disabled I was about to be attacked or killed by someone who can lift 350 lb working out at prison and I went to jail I should have got a prize.... also he was not seriously injured left the hospital cuz he was drunk and he's on parole he immediately went back to prison he took me to court when I was in jail for a carton of cigarettes and his freaking t-shirt so I come out of jail and go to court for 1 minute the judge said did I have his cigarettes and I said no he goes you going to pay for his T-shirt I said no I'm not and it was over.... maybe I shouldn't say this but I'm glad he's dead he probably would never learned his lesson fighting with people because the reason he died he had his tooth in his lung for 8 years it traumatized me I am very careful I don't let anybody in my house unless I know them really well I don't understand why circumstantial evidence is ever allowed it doesn't prove anything
Not true. Some evidence is not evidence but opinions & tampered with fake evidence.
There is some evidence that isn't relevant or is prejudicial, so shouldn't be allowed. Allowing a free for all isn't okay either.
Thank you Dr Phil for all you do. I pray this man is set free. 🙏
Shaken baby is with infants not 2 year olds. 104 temp is an infection not from being shaken!
Thank you Dr Phil for your input on this case in this matter I believe he was railroaded in this
Dr. PHIL HAS MY FULL RESPECT. I TOTALLY TRUST HIS OPINION. HE DOES HIS HOMEWORK BEFORE HE GIVES HIS OPINION
He is not guilty, sadly the doctors should be held accountable.
Doctors have a license to unalive someone with no consequences.
lmao classic dr phil "now im not a lawyer, dont mean to brag" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 love dr phil!!✨❤️✨
Free Mr.Roberson!