I was and then the first album came out. Stopped following her because the first album was (in my opinion) a sad departure from the EPs and singles. Guess I was wrong and she's popular now.
@@thezeek2745 I fell in love with her stuff from the first singles and EPs, saw her open in a small 200 seat theater before the first album came out.... then the first album came out and I didn't like how much production there was. Basically stopped listening to the new stuff. But she keeps getting more and more famous. Now she's opening for taylor swift on an arena tour.
sita is always refreshing to me because i start to appreciate a new song every time. i may like punisher more, but sita is great for when i miss her old voice :)
listen to the first EP and her first singles. I don't know what she became, I didn't like the first album compared to the EP/singles so I stopped listening, and all of her modern fans are like "oh wow I can't believe phoebe bridgers sounds like phoebe bridgers"
@@MrEL91N Of course we can blame them, they create the demand that makes people like Phoebe make albums like Stranger In The Alps. Or we blame the producers? Anyway good for Phoebe. When I first saw her it was in a 200 seat theater opening for Conor Oberst before they did that collab project and before her first album. Now she's playing stadiums, opening for Taylor Swift. There's a lot more money in selling over produced pop music to kids than there is doing blood on the strings acoustic folk pop, even with a voice like phoebe. Maybe I'm just bitter, I fell in love with the singles and EPs and then many of my favorite parts of my favorite songs were so different on the album. Punisher is decent, but if it's gonna grow on my it hasn't yet.
This version of Georgia might be my favorite song of all time. Still after all these years the line, "If I fix you. Will you hate me?" devastates me to no end. The idea of someone so broken, they'd resent you for such a kindness is something I've been on both ends of in my life.
If I may: to 'fix' someone is first off impossible, and 2nd is it the wrong idea altogether. Why not, instead, consider accepting them and being at their side to support them in their struggles as best as possible (with boundaries of course)?!
@@david_oliveira71 I do agree completely, in my experiences both instance only drew resentment despite how noble to cause might have been. Validation and support are infinitely better than trying to, "Fix someone." Granted, when I was clinically depressed and in and out of hospitals, my best friend reached out to me annoyingly so, I look back and am thankful for his efforts, despite how unworthy I felt of such attention at the time. I always drew a parallel to this lyric due to this, though yes a softer approach on his behalf would have been preferable, but hey, we were just teenagers at the time.
I think a lot of songs (specifically Georgia and Chelsea) could’ve benefited from a more interesting and unique sound like this. I still love the studio versions of those songs, but they’re pretty boring in comparison to say Smoke Signals or Would You Rather
I’m going to one of her concerts in September and I AM taking a sign that says “phoebe please play Georgia red flannel version” don’t worry pharbz I’ll get us a new performance of this.
i really came into this video expecting a good, but less fine tuned performance than phoebes current stuff since this was from a while ago. but this is the best acoustic live performance ive ever seen. her head voice is amazing but her chest voice....holy shit
Georgia, Georgia, I love your son When he gets older, he might be the one He might be the one (Whoa) Georgia, Georgia, he has beautiful bones And he never lies or picks up his phone (Oh) And sometimes, in the pouring rain He'll fall in the mud and get back up again And if you find me Will you know me? Will you take me Or will you fall? (Fall) Here is my day plan, here's my new machine He is a fine new addition, so young and so clean So young and so clean He came up through the water without a sound With my back to the shoreline, I dreamt that he drowned I dreamt that he drowned (Whoa) And sometimes, when he looks at me I know that he needs you, you're all that he sees And if I breathe you Will it kill me? Will you have me Or watch me fall? If I fix you Will you hate me? And would you fuck this And let us fall? (Fall)
Very few songs give you an actual physical response. Her new stuff is still good, but this is by far the most powerful expression of Phoebe Bridgers. It's insanely amazing.
i think her exploration in instrumentals or whatevs made her prioritize the kind of,, volume??,, in her songs. like in sita she sang kinda loudly and the instrumentals were quiet and not too detailed when compared to punisher. idk if that makes sense
Lyrics for anyone who wants! :) Georgia, Georgia, I love your son And when he gets older, he might be the one He might be the one Georgia, Georgia, he has beautiful bones And he never lies or picks up his phone And sometimes in the pouring rain He'll fall in the mud and get back up again And if you find me Will you know me? Will you take me Or will you fall? Here is my day plan, here's my new machine He is a fine new addition, so young and so clean So young and so clean He came up through the water without a sound With my back to the shoreline, I dreamt that he drowned I dreamt that he drowned And sometimes, when he looks at me I know he needs you, you're all that he sees And if I breathe you Will it kill me? Will you have me Or watch me fall? If I fix you Will you hate me? And would you fuck this And let us fall?
She is a total star, saw her last night in a small venue in Glasgow, Scotland. Truly magnificent. This gave me goosebumps, her voice is incredible live.
I’m 36 and only recently discovered her earlier this year. I’ve never been bewitched by an artist like I have with her. If I could inject this song in my veins I would. I can barely listen to anyone else rn.
I'm 48 and have discovered her in 2019, but only because I knew of Conor Oberst, which gave me a chance to stumble upon her Better Oblivion project she did with him. She has been hugely influenced by Eliott Smith, whose music I sadly listened to very little, but I think what really draws me into her performances so much is that she has that passion, nuance, complexity and just this raw ache to her music which is what originally got me to listen to Kate Bush and Suzanne Vega when I was much younger. And I think she's very much a Kate Bush or Suzanne Vega of this generation, and I think most people don't yet realize just how good she is. I honestly think she's not even aware of it herself, and probably doesn't give herself enough credit, either, but she's solidly on the road of becoming one of the most amazing & influential songwriters of the 21st century. I love that outro ending on "Scott Street", and her vocals saying "Anyway, don't be a stranger" totally echo that sweet melancholy that Kate Bush was so good at channeling. She even sounds a bit like Kate in that part.
I'm sitting in a coffee shop waiting for my bus and I'm now covered in goosebumps. It's incredible to me that a single person can be so powerfully talented.
Wow. I listen to a lot of indie folk music and this is by far the best I've heard in a long while - the best i've heard since the likes of Daughter/Ben Howard. Keep on keeping on' Phoebe.
Thats a pretty big statement you've made. I fully disagree tho. Shes good but we've heard something like this a million times before, therefor -> not classified as indie
She still channels this kind of raw emotion, but I would be a liar if I said I didn't hope for her to do some new songs in this style. Busking and belting.
Georgia is my favorite Phoebe song and this version definitely rivals the original.... I can see a whole movie play out in my head while I listen to this song
Saw her Sat in Vancouver, this was her (acoustic) encore, it was iconic. The whole show was like a spiritual experience, the vibe of the crowd singing along with her was 🤌
Phoebe before she got REAL sad. Love this version when she sang less distantly in a way, more emotionally direct. Punisher is a fantastic record tho. Love it all.
He vocal range is so crazy and for some reason all the album versoins and recent recordings she sings very low and monotone... especially this song, i think this is 100000 times better than what they ended up with on the Album.
[Verse 1] Georgia, Georgia I love your son When he gets older, he might be the one He might be the one Georgia, Georgia he has beautiful bones And he never lies or picks up his phone [Chorus 1] Sometimes in the pouring rain He'll fall in the mud and get back up again And if you find me Will you know me Will you take me Or will you fall [Verse 2] Here is my day plan, my new machine He is a fine new addition, so young and so clean So young and so clean He came up through the water without a sound With my back to the shoreline, I dreamt that he drowned I dreamt that he drowned [Chorus 2] Sometimes when he looks at me I know that he needs you, you're all that he sees And if I had breathed you Will it kill me Will you have me Or watch me fall If I had fixed you Will you hate me Would you fuck this And let us fall
Loving someone from Georgia for the past 3 years, I have revisited this countless times. Here’s hoping that in a year when I revisit this it’s only with nostalgia
I think I account for half of the views on this vid for how many times I have watched this for the past 6 years😭 I can’t let it go and if they ever delete this I’ll end it all
almost forgot to watch this today
daily ritual required for basic human survival
I feel this. It's past 11pm for me right now, and I almost forgot to play it today. Just in the nick of time
Don't forget to play ot today.
and today?
I swear to god I’ve watched it multiple times a day for a month.
phoebe dressed up like she's about to give my favorite album a bad review
🍈
LMAO
ROFL
LMAO!
Lolll
I'm fucking ashamed that I wasn't listening to this 5 years ago.
As you should. But the important part is you’re here now friend. Welcome🥰
@@kileywinks1574 6 now, apparently. ❤️
I was and then the first album came out.
Stopped following her because the first album was (in my opinion) a sad departure from the EPs and singles.
Guess I was wrong and she's popular now.
ME TOO
tell me abt it
This version is insane. I thought I would miss the harmonies, but she's SO powerful on this.
Dammit, already upthumbed
^
best version
Yeah, I replaced the cd version with this one in my iTunes, lol
Nothing good about insanity.
Too bad she can't play guitar.
Phoebe has some incredible one-liners, but “if I fix you, will you hate me?”, will forever be the best one. Shit breaks me into a million pieces.
every single time 🥲
“I’m gonna kill you if you don’t beat me to it”
Same
@@kevinkent5299 i dont understand this one
Are yo u ashamed when you say my name. Oh wait. The drummer wrote that. But she did make a song out of it
"If I fix you, would you hate me." That line breaks me.
Savior complex
@@lucaunderground codependency
She really put her entire Phoebussy into this and we love her for it
Yeah, and her phussy
My eardrussies are greatful for it too
You are now Banned from The Computer
This is why we can’t have nice things
cringe
Wow, she sounds completely different here. She's a great singer but I feel like this video really shows how skilled she is.
Must have been what it was like to see her busking
From 2014
I am so in love with this her takent is on full display im so excited i came across this version.
@@thezeek2745 I fell in love with her stuff from the first singles and EPs, saw her open in a small 200 seat theater before the first album came out.... then the first album came out and I didn't like how much production there was. Basically stopped listening to the new stuff.
But she keeps getting more and more famous. Now she's opening for taylor swift on an arena tour.
@jamesmorgan8157 the best one imo. Flawless performance. Her big voice on full display
funny how this is the only video to ever exist
this will always be the best thing that has ever happened
agreed
ya
Oh yeah def
AGREED
I really love Punisher but I kind of miss Phoebe just belting out those powerful but incredibly smooth notes.
I feel ya. Whole album does no justice to how beautiful and nuanced her voice is.
agreed
@@Jytube231 her first album didnt either. honestly it took me watching her live to realize that shes an amazing power house of a singer
sita is always refreshing to me because i start to appreciate a new song every time. i may like punisher more, but sita is great for when i miss her old voice :)
you could tell punisher was inspired by asmr and stuff like that. while I loved it as well I hope to see more of this kind of singing in the future!
can't believe i get to breathe the same air as this woman
Well sort of .... you're wearing a mask lol
@@sparkyblast2745 lol
Lucky to have any air left after all her yelling.
That's stupid
Think a little higher of yourself.
i feel like she never sings as hard a she did in this vid as she does in other performances. this is so fire
It's like she got possessed by Julien Baker
This comment just opened a door to a really weird concept that might forever be contemplated in the back of my mind.
Julien Baker wishes she could wail like Phoebe!
@@tjmoon1857 😩😩
@@tjmoon1857 hey lets not compare the girls they're both so so talented
i'd literally kill just to watch this version of georgia live
you're pretty much doing that now, without the need to kill anyone
i think about this video at least 40 times a day
PIPER LMFAO
@@lindsayvanover6704 AHHABAHAH LINDSAY U FOUND ME
this has got to be laced there’s no reason i should’ve watched it over 100 times now
I've never heard her sound like that, this suits her so much, she should belt more!
look up her singing me & my dog live and thank me later
@@communist_kirby i will thank you now and TAKE THAT THANK YOU WITH EVERY BONE IN YOUR BODY. THANK YOU
listen to the first EP and her first singles.
I don't know what she became, I didn't like the first album compared to the EP/singles so I stopped listening, and all of her modern fans are like "oh wow I can't believe phoebe bridgers sounds like phoebe bridgers"
@@SpicyTrifongo well I mean you cant blame them. at this point hasnt she spent more time not sounding like this than she has spent sound like this?
@@MrEL91N Of course we can blame them, they create the demand that makes people like Phoebe make albums like Stranger In The Alps.
Or we blame the producers?
Anyway good for Phoebe. When I first saw her it was in a 200 seat theater opening for Conor Oberst before they did that collab project and before her first album.
Now she's playing stadiums, opening for Taylor Swift.
There's a lot more money in selling over produced pop music to kids than there is doing blood on the strings acoustic folk pop, even with a voice like phoebe.
Maybe I'm just bitter, I fell in love with the singles and EPs and then many of my favorite parts of my favorite songs were so different on the album. Punisher is decent, but if it's gonna grow on my it hasn't yet.
This version of Georgia might be my favorite song of all time. Still after all these years the line, "If I fix you. Will you hate me?" devastates me to no end. The idea of someone so broken, they'd resent you for such a kindness is something I've been on both ends of in my life.
If I may: to 'fix' someone is first off impossible, and 2nd is it the wrong idea altogether.
Why not, instead, consider accepting them and being at their side to support them in their struggles as best as possible (with boundaries of course)?!
@@david_oliveira71 I do agree completely, in my experiences both instance only drew resentment despite how noble to cause might have been. Validation and support are infinitely better than trying to, "Fix someone." Granted, when I was clinically depressed and in and out of hospitals, my best friend reached out to me annoyingly so, I look back and am thankful for his efforts, despite how unworthy I felt of such attention at the time. I always drew a parallel to this lyric due to this, though yes a softer approach on his behalf would have been preferable, but hey, we were just teenagers at the time.
@@Vincanniglad to hear, and also that you're doing better now (so it sounds)
this girl is going to be a superstar! I have so much hope and admiration for her, such a great vocalist!!
and now she's nominated for 4 grammys! :)))
@@lise1637 makes me so happy 😌😌
This aged well
this aged very well
This version is better than the studio one by a mile
Two miles
Three miles
@@cheaseaflame 4.5 miles
8 mile
I think a lot of songs (specifically Georgia and Chelsea) could’ve benefited from a more interesting and unique sound like this. I still love the studio versions of those songs, but they’re pretty boring in comparison to say Smoke Signals or Would You Rather
The thing her voice does at 3:10 is spiritual
I honestly wasn’t expecting that much power. Damn. Loved this more than the original. Phoebe rocks.
if georgia live has 1000 fans, im one of them. if georgia live has 10 fans, im one of them. if georgia live has one fan, i am that fan.
Phoebe, phoebe i love your voice
shes BELTING belting here i need more of this from her she’s incredible
This is so much better than her album version.
Check out the version of the song on her earlier EP Killer. It's similar to this one. I also love it more!
she tunes her guitar down to C# standard if anyone was wondering
i came to ask this thanks!
:)
Nope
Might be something she picked up from Elliot Smith; Waltz #2 XO was in C#. Love them both so much.
What chords is she playing??
to think that girl from six years ago is nominated for several grammy's will never not make me emotinal
I’m going to one of her concerts in September and I AM taking a sign that says “phoebe please play Georgia red flannel version” don’t worry pharbz I’ll get us a new performance of this.
Update y/n
i may just have to steal this idea when i see hear twice next month
i think she played this version on the eras tour 😭
do you have a video??
@@summiiii my phoebe concert was canceled, so I REALLY hope that happened!!
because of this song i am a homosexual
lol
same
same
Welcome to the club lmao
same
Her voice is SO powerful in this, one of her best songs
i really came into this video expecting a good, but less fine tuned performance than phoebes current stuff since this was from a while ago. but this is the best acoustic live performance ive ever seen. her head voice is amazing but her chest voice....holy shit
listen to the EP and first couple singles.
After all these times listening to her and I still want to cry.
rare footage of Phoebe not in all black lol. I positively love her voice.
This is just one of those rare perfect, flawless performances that probably can’t be replicated too often
istg i come back to this video every second day i’ll never get enough of this performance
same, multiple times a day for the past few weeks
Georgia, Georgia, I love your son
When he gets older, he might be the one
He might be the one (Whoa)
Georgia, Georgia, he has beautiful bones
And he never lies or picks up his phone (Oh)
And sometimes, in the pouring rain
He'll fall in the mud and get back up again
And if you find me
Will you know me?
Will you take me
Or will you fall? (Fall)
Here is my day plan, here's my new machine
He is a fine new addition, so young and so clean
So young and so clean
He came up through the water without a sound
With my back to the shoreline, I dreamt that he drowned
I dreamt that he drowned (Whoa)
And sometimes, when he looks at me
I know that he needs you, you're all that he sees
And if I breathe you
Will it kill me?
Will you have me
Or watch me fall?
If I fix you
Will you hate me?
And would you fuck this
And let us fall? (Fall)
Thank you omg
Phoebe belting to this song can cure everything in me!!!
phoebe bridgers belting is the only reason my heart is still beating
she sings every word so beautifully idk how she does it
talent!
Very few songs give you an actual physical response. Her new stuff is still good, but this is by far the most powerful expression of Phoebe Bridgers. It's insanely amazing.
why doesn’t she sing like this anymore 😭😭
i know she doesn't really sing this high anymore
she’s probably not confident in her higher register but i love the power in her voice here omg
i think her exploration in instrumentals or whatevs made her prioritize the kind of,, volume??,, in her songs. like in sita she sang kinda loudly and the instrumentals were quiet and not too detailed when compared to punisher. idk if that makes sense
It puts a lot of strain on the vocal folds to sing like this all the time so I wouldn’t blame anyone for wanting to switch it up
We might get something idk it’s only the beginning of her career
Lyrics for anyone who wants! :)
Georgia, Georgia, I love your son
And when he gets older, he might be the one
He might be the one
Georgia, Georgia, he has beautiful bones
And he never lies or picks up his phone
And sometimes in the pouring rain
He'll fall in the mud and get back up again
And if you find me
Will you know me?
Will you take me
Or will you fall?
Here is my day plan, here's my new machine
He is a fine new addition, so young and so clean
So young and so clean
He came up through the water without a sound
With my back to the shoreline, I dreamt that he drowned
I dreamt that he drowned
And sometimes, when he looks at me
I know he needs you, you're all that he sees
And if I breathe you
Will it kill me?
Will you have me
Or watch me fall?
If I fix you
Will you hate me?
And would you fuck this
And let us fall?
She is a total star, saw her last night in a small venue in Glasgow, Scotland. Truly magnificent. This gave me goosebumps, her voice is incredible live.
I’m 36 and only recently discovered her earlier this year. I’ve never been bewitched by an artist like I have with her. If I could inject this song in my veins I would. I can barely listen to anyone else rn.
I'm 48 and have discovered her in 2019, but only because I knew of Conor Oberst, which gave me a chance to stumble upon her Better Oblivion project she did with him. She has been hugely influenced by Eliott Smith, whose music I sadly listened to very little, but I think what really draws me into her performances so much is that she has that passion, nuance, complexity and just this raw ache to her music which is what originally got me to listen to Kate Bush and Suzanne Vega when I was much younger. And I think she's very much a Kate Bush or Suzanne Vega of this generation, and I think most people don't yet realize just how good she is. I honestly think she's not even aware of it herself, and probably doesn't give herself enough credit, either, but she's solidly on the road of becoming one of the most amazing & influential songwriters of the 21st century. I love that outro ending on "Scott Street", and her vocals saying "Anyway, don't be a stranger" totally echo that sweet melancholy that Kate Bush was so good at channeling. She even sounds a bit like Kate in that part.
I'm sitting in a coffee shop waiting for my bus and I'm now covered in goosebumps. It's incredible to me that a single person can be so powerfully talented.
i watch this video religiously
Wow. I listen to a lot of indie folk music and this is by far the best I've heard in a long while - the best i've heard since the likes of Daughter/Ben Howard. Keep on keeping on' Phoebe.
You should check out David Ramirez.
Thats a pretty big statement you've made. I fully disagree tho. Shes good but we've heard something like this a million times before, therefor -> not classified as indie
Gauderic Perignon if you love Phoebe check out Julien baker!
Ricardo Treehi, Julien is absolutely amazing!!!! Guarderic Perignon you should check out Lucy Dacus too!
BAAP indie means independent
i won’t rest until this is on spotify
She still channels this kind of raw emotion, but I would be a liar if I said I didn't hope for her to do some new songs in this style. Busking and belting.
guys this is the reason i’m alive i swear
I come back to this video every so often to just listen to her belting and it gives me goosebumps every single time
this version makes me feel something i’ve never felt before
Holy shit these vocals
This is sublime. She's melted me like butter.
i come back to this video daily
this performance is flawless
One of the best live performances of all time.
she will never know how much her music means to me :(
i'm in tears this is perfect holy fuck
Georgia is my favorite Phoebe song and this version definitely rivals the original.... I can see a whole movie play out in my head while I listen to this song
woah okay! She has a really soothing voice i didnt realize shes got pipes like these tho
Saw her Sat in Vancouver, this was her (acoustic) encore, it was iconic. The whole show was like a spiritual experience, the vibe of the crowd singing along with her was 🤌
Phoebe before she got REAL sad. Love this version when she sang less distantly in a way, more emotionally direct. Punisher is a fantastic record tho. Love it all.
I will continue to come back to this video for the rest of my life
god she sounds so amazing in this
currently watching my daily dose of red flannel georgia
That belting!! I think I'm in love
i watch this 5 times a day istg. And i'm not even kidding.
best video on the internet i fear
one day i want my music to have the power that hers does
ive watched this 10 times today
U can really hear her voice here just belting her heart out !!!!
Live how her voice developed, but i also love this gritty vocal style. Like damn this woman can do anything
He vocal range is so crazy and for some reason all the album versoins and recent recordings she sings very low and monotone... especially this song, i think this is 100000 times better than what they ended up with on the Album.
wow, i didn't think i could love her any more
The amount of times I have watched this video over the years is uncountable
FR
This version makes me miss live music
Same. I miss playing live too
her vocals oh my GOD SHES SO GOOD
this version changed my life and i think about it every day
I’ve been I love with phoebe for a while but my goodness is she jaw dropping in this one
i cannot tell you how many times i’ve watched this
This is so much more talent than anyone mainstream pop star ever even faked having
she just casually smiles after the performance while I'm here bawling my eyes out.
Anyone else come back to this all the time?
i love this version! i think it's far better then the ep version
i come back here too often
Me too. Free therapy
i have never been the same since i discovered this performance 3 years ago
Just saw her at The Fillmore in SF last night and she rocked her set. She is such a cute and talented soul. I hope she goes far!
aspiringfawn yea hope she has someone to watch over her, she’s crystal😇
she’s nominated for four grammys now
Safe to say she has gone far haha
she made it 10000%
I love you Georgia Red Flannel acoustic version
this is the most incredible thing i’ve ever seen
such a talented musician
my roman empire
[Verse 1] Georgia, Georgia I love your son When he gets older, he might be the one He might be the one Georgia, Georgia he has beautiful bones And he never lies or picks up his phone [Chorus 1] Sometimes in the pouring rain He'll fall in the mud and get back up again And if you find me Will you know me Will you take me Or will you fall [Verse 2] Here is my day plan, my new machine He is a fine new addition, so young and so clean So young and so clean He came up through the water without a sound With my back to the shoreline, I dreamt that he drowned I dreamt that he drowned [Chorus 2] Sometimes when he looks at me I know that he needs you, you're all that he sees And if I had breathed you Will it kill me Will you have me Or watch me fall If I had fixed you Will you hate me Would you fuck this And let us fall
this is the closest we will get to world peace
I am forever grateful that this version exists
back for my daily viewing of this video
not a bad routine
update: i still watch this far too often
Loving someone from Georgia for the past 3 years, I have revisited this countless times. Here’s hoping that in a year when I revisit this it’s only with nostalgia
I come back to this video every day bro
I think I account for half of the views on this vid for how many times I have watched this for the past 6 years😭 I can’t let it go and if they ever delete this I’ll end it all