Why Sonic The Hedgehog 3 & Knuckles Is The Pinnacle Of 2D Sonic

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 гру 2020
  • Hope you enjoy the video and my takes on Sonic 3 and Knuckles.
    If you enjoyed don't forget to subscribe and like and if you have any questions or additional comments let me know down below! Love u all and have a Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays
    #sonic #SonicOrigins #sonic3K #Sonic3 #sonic3review #sonic3retrospective #sonic3Kretrospective #sonic3Kreview #sonic3kost #gaming
    __________________________________________________________________________
    Sources:
    First and foremost, check these people out.
    Sonic 3 Re-Imagined - Ice Cap Zone by Tee Lopes (t.ly/JHCE)
    Nemesis' Sonic Hacking Site by Nemesis (web.archive.org/web/200411280...)
    Fred Bronze's Twitter ( / freddybneo )
    UA-cam videos used(A-Z):
    FIRST EVER SONIC 3D PROTOTYPE - AND IT HAS SPLTISCREEN! by GameHut (t.ly/J4sK)
    Sonic the Hedgehog Gametap Retrospective Pt. 4/4 by Gametap (t.ly/k9Mb)
    Garfield Caught in the Act PC: Alien Landscape Gameplay by Signal and Noise (t.ly/KVIW)
    Sonic 3&Knuckles Part 7: Mushroom Hill Zone (Super Tails) by Carls493 (t.ly/uCx8)
    Sonic 3 Re-Imagined - Ice Cap Zone by Tee Lopes (t.ly/JHCE)
    Sonic 3 8th Special Stage - The Easy Way & The Hard Way (Sonic 3 AIR) by Retro Master (t.ly/lEX3)
    The Evil Ghost | Epic Hybrid Horror Orchestral Music by Christophe Le Guen (t.ly/lSS0)
    Articles and Websites used (A-Z):
    Fred Bronze's Twitter ( / freddybneo )
    How Sonic 3 Became Two Separate Games - Gameinformer.com (t.ly/MsaV)
    Nemesis' Sonic Hacking Site by Nemesis (web.archive.org/web/200411280...)
    Sonic 3 Development - Sonicretro.com (t.ly/AEqg)
    Sonic the Hedgehog 3 - Sonicretro.com (t.ly/Ix5A)
    Sonic 3 Hidden Content - Sonicretro.com(t.ly/eQSb)
    Sonic 3 Limited Edition - Sonicretro.com (t.ly/7F7f)
    Sonic 3 - sonic.fandom.com (t.ly/ZVGr)
    Sonic 3 - Wikipedia.com (t.ly/RxEo)
    Sonic & Knuckles - sonicretro.com (t.ly/Lbau)
    Sonic & Knuckles - sonic.fandom.com (t.ly/R6Nd)
    Sonic & Knuckles - Wikipedia.com (t.ly/nqGj)
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 310

  • @Eldarin
    @Eldarin  3 роки тому +44

    Hey everyone! Hope you all have a Merry Christmas/Happy Holidays! Mean't to get this out before Thanksgiving but holidays+college finals+me getting COVID threw a screwball in my plans lmao..enjoy the video!

    • @caseyhoward4986
      @caseyhoward4986 3 роки тому +6

      Eldie got cov 😳

    • @wudlorff1888
      @wudlorff1888 3 роки тому +7

      God tier

    • @Cliffordlonghead
      @Cliffordlonghead 3 роки тому +8

      Awesome Video

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +5

      @@Cliffordlonghead thank you! glad you enjoyed it :)

    • @guilhermefranco2930
      @guilhermefranco2930 3 роки тому +6

      You kept referring to a flying battery in sonic 2. What flying battery in sonic 2? Do you mean the wing fortress or...

  • @Schnort
    @Schnort 3 роки тому +103

    29:22 I had always headcannoned that Eggman built Carnival Night Zone for his entertainment. He would totally be the kind of person to threaten many lives, take advantage of the last of a nearly extinct species, and burn down a forest just to turn around and go play in his amusement park.

    • @thecannedslap
      @thecannedslap 2 роки тому +2

      That is in fact, the entire plot of Sonic CD

    • @RoshiBro08
      @RoshiBro08 2 місяці тому

      But it was on angel island before him? How would he have had time to build all of it in like what? 12 hours? He just met knuckles in the island and his repairing the death egg. His badniks surely couldn't build all of it in that time too. Idk just my thoughts on it.

    • @natelederp
      @natelederp Місяць тому

      @@RoshiBro08 Sonic 3 happens some time after Sonic 2 but Robotnik met knuckles after his death egg crashed into angel island right after Sonic 2 so while sonic and tails haven't arrived yet, he built all of that

    • @RoshiBro08
      @RoshiBro08 Місяць тому +1

      @@natelederp still, you know how huge that carnival really is? Even if it was a pretty good while like 3 - 4 weeks, that's not really possible

  • @jesterssketchbook
    @jesterssketchbook 3 роки тому +57

    this channel is CRIMINALLY under-rated

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +11

      It really means a lot to hear thanks so much!

    • @glenhaven721
      @glenhaven721 3 роки тому

      aha I get it. Smooth criminal. But seriously, agreed

  • @mediamuncher6982
    @mediamuncher6982 3 роки тому +112

    Fun fact: sonic mania has the insta sheild as an unlockable.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +43

      I didn't know that at the time, I've only played mania once and played the whole thing without knowing the drop dash was even a thing LMAO so im excited to replay it and see how it stacks up!

    • @brolookatthatthingbehindyo1324
      @brolookatthatthingbehindyo1324 3 роки тому +11

      wasn't it in the advance games as well? and the christian whitehead ports

    • @miguelaguilar5115
      @miguelaguilar5115 3 роки тому +10

      @@brolookatthatthingbehindyo1324 Yep, I'm prerty sure the advance games had it, but it wasn't as useful

    • @b0xE_
      @b0xE_ 3 роки тому +5

      The Peel Out is also an unlockable as well!

    • @GuilitoDoinks
      @GuilitoDoinks 3 роки тому +6

      There's a cheat code were you can do all the moves in no save mode

  • @d3-penguin954
    @d3-penguin954 3 роки тому +37

    56:06 funfact: You can defeat the death ball boss really quickly by using the upside down gravity and spindashing at the flipped spiked cars. Doing that will launch them straight at the robot.
    Edit: (somebody already beat me to this in the comments lol)

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +7

      Thanks for the heads up, once I play this again I really need to try that. Thanks for watching also!

  • @mjallen1308
    @mjallen1308 3 роки тому +38

    I know some ppl complain about the length of videos. I enjoyed listening/watching while traveling and while walking my dog. It was well presented and just what I was looking for. You’ve got a new sub!

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +3

      Thank you so much! I’m glad you enjoyed it, I’m gonna be cutting the length down on the next ones here on out. Stay tuned for the next one and thanks for subbing :)

    • @jarlwhiterun7478
      @jarlwhiterun7478 Місяць тому

      You can actually spell the word "people" now. It's negligible in the amount of time it takes.

    • @mjallen1308
      @mjallen1308 Місяць тому

      @@jarlwhiterun7478 how bout you mind your business.

  • @BWF6_Official
    @BWF6_Official 3 роки тому +34

    Sonic 3 & Knuckles is amazing. This time I don't have much to say as most of it is in the video. Everything this game has to offer is great. All three characters are great to play as, level design is very good and Special Stages aren't poorly made. The soundtrack is my favourite from the Classic games and still holds up to this day. The game has it's problems like Marble Garden (which has my favourite music in the game) not being suited for first-time players but is mostly fair to new players and well made for returning ones like Super Mario World. Since November 2019 we all know the prototype music (which was used in S&K Collection 22 years before it was discovered) and I personally like it more than what Jackson composed. Sega can easily port the game with prototype music (CNZ, ICZ, LBZ, Competition Menu etc.) to avoid problems with copyright yet they don't want free money. While playing Sonic Mania I sometimes felt bored. This never happened while playing S3&K - it's that entertaining! I even have an entire playthrough of S3&K (in S&K Collection) on my channel - that's how much I love it (no, I'm not self-promoting myself). This game easily gets an easy S+/S+ for me.
    I've only played all main 16-bit and 8-bit Classic Sonic titles but I will play through 3D Blast, SA1, SA2 and Generations in the near future.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +4

      I 100% agree its crazy as while I am not a fan of Marble Garden I could definitely see why some people like it. I had a similar feeling with Mania but I'm curious how I am going to like it now that I've played all the classics its remixing. I saw your longplay its funny you mention that because for me at least, I finished Sonic 3 in one sitting, and the same with S&K those games are just so replayable. I highly recommend SA1&2.SEGA is full of dunces, Whitehead gave them an easy way to port 3K and they passed it up, along with Whitehead's team eventually getting the boot, it's a disgrace. I feel you'll really SA1 especially since to me at least, its the perfect 2D to 3D transition for Sonic's gameplay while SA2 changes it up a bit (not in a bad way though just the design shift changes). I'm looking to play 3D blast as I haven't played that or any of the games in the 2008-2016 era. Thanks for watching the videos always enjoy your take on the games :)

  • @hayond656
    @hayond656 3 роки тому +20

    51:33
    I didn't notice Sonic's run in 3&K had a third phase with his spikes stretched out
    Cuz I always thought of the Arms behind him and his body leaning forward as the 3rd phase

  • @TheMGMfan
    @TheMGMfan 3 роки тому +17

    Fun fact: The reason for Sonic's new move being called the W Spin Attack in Japan is that they actually use W to represent double, so it's really called the Double Spin Attack, which makes sense considering that it basically is a second Spin Attack. Don't understand why they called it the Insta-shield internationally when it's pretty useless as a form of defense and wasn't made to be that, but a form of offence; I understand that the Japanese name doesn't make sense outside of Japan (or maybe other East Asian countries, but I don't know if that's true), but you could just call it the Double Spin Attack, that's what the original name means after all.

    • @KidPrarchord95
      @KidPrarchord95 2 роки тому +7

      Actually, the insta-shield was meant to be used as a shield as well. Due to a programming error, it does not deflect projectiles like it was supposed to in the final game.

    • @Munkle555
      @Munkle555 Рік тому +4

      Because it gives you a few frames of invincibility aka insta-shield and double spin dash makes serious sense because you do it from a jump including a standing jump so theres no first spin dash for it to be the double of

  • @nicholasharlan6504
    @nicholasharlan6504 3 роки тому +13

    The mural is a foreshadow of doomsday and eggmans mech as perfect chaos does not use the master emerald to achieve it's super form.

  • @hurricaneian09L
    @hurricaneian09L 9 місяців тому +2

    Ah yes, Sonic 3. The game that released in my birthday and became my favorite Sonic game. This game is just perfect.

  • @caseyhoward4986
    @caseyhoward4986 3 роки тому +16

    This vid was SO awesome, just what I want to see in the Sonic community, keep it up :)

  • @Schnort
    @Schnort 3 роки тому +12

    You have me laughing not even 40 seconds into the video. I am seriously impressed by your commentary and humor. Thank you so much for making videos!

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +3

      Hey thanks so much! Im happy to hear you liked it :)

  • @ViewpointProd
    @ViewpointProd 2 роки тому +7

    A really subtle detail, the death egg zone bg dose NOT have any kind of paralax scroll or any scrolling at all, showing it's Sheer size, no matter where you go, it isn't moving

  • @Aodhanbaby
    @Aodhanbaby 3 роки тому +17

    The Game Apologist has a rival

  • @Aodhanbaby
    @Aodhanbaby 3 роки тому +15

    JUST DROP IT ALREADY I CAN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE!

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +7

      AAAAAAAAAAAAAA

  • @hankosanko
    @hankosanko 3 роки тому +7

    if they do bring a new sonic adventure, maybe they should look back to this game for inspiration. this is my favorite sonic game of all time, i can play this over and over.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +4

      YES! I still feel theres alot left on the table with the mythos of Angel Island that was just dropped basically post-SA2. Would love to see a return and maybe instead of retreading Green Hill, we get a fully 3D Angel Island zone for a change!

  • @caseyhoward4986
    @caseyhoward4986 3 роки тому +5

    Get in here bros

  • @fan0000
    @fan0000 2 роки тому +4

    This game was my childhood as much as I loved Sonic 2 this one will always be number one a true classic in every sense of the word#memories

  • @PoisonousPen
    @PoisonousPen 2 роки тому +2

    Absolutely no one:
    Eldarin: “…..ekspecially”

  • @aprilstegall6002
    @aprilstegall6002 3 роки тому +2

    58:19 Am i the only one who wonders how tails got back to mobius after the death egg exploded?

  • @pinkyoshi9339
    @pinkyoshi9339 3 роки тому +6

    This is a great review, I'll watch all your future sonic reviews and videos

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому

      I’m so happy to hear that thank you so much :D

  • @Canalbiruta
    @Canalbiruta 3 роки тому +4

    i still recall the first time i played doomsday zone, while sweating, super engaged in the game, the music getting more and more intense, that was the moment i realized i was playing my fav sonic game, end one of my fav games ever. great review man loved it (also sonic 3 air is the def version of the game and you can't change my mind suhaushaushaus)

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      I'm really happy to hear you enjoyed the review, I need to check out AIR! I agree with Doomsday Zone as when I was playing it for the first time this summer, I was down to only a couple of rings making it a really tense finale to this grand epic of a game! Thanks for watching :)

  • @doctorquack1399
    @doctorquack1399 3 роки тому +4

    Sonic 3 & Knuckles blew my frickin' mind.
    Getting into the game, I was afraid that my experience with S3K wouldn't live up to the high praises I heard, and oh boy was I glad to be wrong.
    The sheer scope of this game astounded me. A built-in save system? 14 zones? Different shields? Different BGM's for each act? Bonus Stages? Chaos Emerald Hunt 2: Electric Boogaloo?
    WHAT DO YOU MEAN THIS GAME WAS ON THE SAME CONSOLE AS SONIC 1 AND 2?!
    Just finished my Hyper Knuckles save and I'm working on Tails.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      That’s awesome! I felt the same way first playing 3K especially the sonic 3 part I was kinda just whemled but after replaying a few months later for the video and was completely blown away. What did you think about the Knuckles story especially the final fight...I had no clue the mecha sonic fight at the end and it was so awesome and surprising!

    • @doctorquack1399
      @doctorquack1399 3 роки тому

      @@Eldarin Before I watched the video it didn't occur to me that Knuckles's story actually occurred AFTER Sonic's. I thought it was just more or less just inserting Knuckles into Sonic's campaign with some changes to accommodate, which had me puzzled when it cut straight to a final boss fight in Sky Sanctuary. Now that I see it here, it makes sense with Angel Island already up in the air and stuff.
      Aside from that, I enjoyed how Knuckles controlled, unless you drop me in Lava Reef Act 1. Many rings were dropped that day. I also timed-out a LOT more as Knuckles whereas I only timed-out twice as Sonic. I spent too much time climbing around looking for the giant rings. (Speaking of which I never knew the classic games had a time limit until this game)
      As for the final boss fight with Mecha Sonic, I thought it was really interesting. I thought Mecha's gold palette was a fan-made sprite by Mark Haynes for that one scene in Super Mario Bros Z. In fact, when people associated the Doomsday theme with Mecha Sonic, I thought it was because of SMBZ's Mecha Sonic, not from the original in S3K. So yeah, fun surprise.

  • @demetriuskafkoulas5005
    @demetriuskafkoulas5005 2 роки тому +4

    Yes, man! I agree with basically everything you say here! Sonic 3 really is a masterpiece, fantastic video!

  • @Alganoob
    @Alganoob 3 роки тому +4

    Hands down, best review/breakdown of an all time childhood favorite!

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому

      Aww thank yoy so much it really means a lot to hear that!

  • @Zikar
    @Zikar 3 роки тому +7

    19:50
    Size comparisons work way better when the images haven't been stretched to the same size.

  • @CutBackDropTurn
    @CutBackDropTurn 3 роки тому +5

    Excellent video! I’m glad you love S3K so much. It’s honestly my favorite game of all time, alongside Sonic Unleashed (360/PS3). I played this game when I was 4 and I am so lucky I did. Sonic was really on top of the world back then and I feel so fortunate to being around during that time.
    This game is just incredible how this game really does combine the gameplay, music, and lore together almost perfectly.
    I only wish Amy Rose could’ve been a part of this game in some capacity because I see her on the same level of importance as the 3 boys and Eggman. She was a character before Knuckles, so it makes sense.
    Regardless, your extensive look felt like a great conversation with a friend about one of the greatest platformers ever!

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you so much for the kind it really means alot! I 100% agree, I would say although S3K is not my "favorite" game in the franchise per say, I can see objectively its the closest (if not IS) the "perfect" game in the franchise where just about everything feels like it was completely thought through, fleshed out and executed fully! I also wish we would've gotten a little bit of Amy in it too as it would've just added a tad more depth to the game even if she was just an unlockable character! I've never played SU so im incredibly excited to try it...looks fantastic (my biggest hurdle is finding out HOW im going to play it LOL) Thank you so much for watching!

  • @Aodhanbaby
    @Aodhanbaby 3 роки тому +6

    Where boys became men

  • @yoNikma
    @yoNikma Рік тому

    amazing presentation, this is my favourite childhood game, gameplay, music, maps, story + hypersonic. Your video really explained everything so good + back lore and i never realized the eggman robot from deathegg was the same from lava reef :D

  • @Toycadet
    @Toycadet 3 роки тому +6

    These videos are so well made, you deserve so much more recognition
    Love your stuff man

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому

      Thank you so much! Im so happy to hear you are liking the videos, I hope you enjoy the ride!

  • @TheGeneReyva
    @TheGeneReyva 3 роки тому +4

    Funny that. Sandopolis is the zone that comes to mind when I think of Sonic 3 & Knuckles as well.
    E: I am 90% sure my S3&K kept screwing up. I only ever got the same boss as in Sonic and/or Tails which meant I was just off screen and the boss was just there till I timed out. I certainly do not remember the spike ball lines.
    E2: But I do remember the Super Mecha Sonic fight... what?
    E3: Awesome video. Makes me want to play S3&K... Looking forward to SA and SA2.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks for watching! Yeah, I feel Sandopolis covers alot of what makes Sonic 3K great in a way but it isnt my favorite zone..its very odd lmao. I'm glad you enjoyed the video! If you have a PC, highly recommend picking up 3K especially since its like $2 right now if you don't have access to it:)

    • @TheGeneReyva
      @TheGeneReyva 3 роки тому +1

      @@Eldarin I think my actual favourite zone if Lava Reef, but there's something particularly iconic about Sandopolis.
      Oh. It's actually on steam. Never thought to look there... and I already own it. Thanks mate.

  • @Slightly_Sadistic
    @Slightly_Sadistic 2 роки тому +2

    If I recall correctly, “Mobius” is not canon. From the start, the games were apparently taking place somewhere on Earth, or at least a fictionalised version of Earth. The planet was never explicitly stated but that was the general assumption. The Mobius planet/name was all made up by the people working on the American cartoons in the '90s and doesn't factor into the main games really.

  • @JohnTK
    @JohnTK Рік тому

    When I was a kid, I used to think the bitcrunched “Go!” sound effect in launch base was supposed to be the sound of power tools and whatnot that were being used to repair the death egg.

  • @krxxc.kk6
    @krxxc.kk6 3 роки тому +1

    Been re-watching all of your videos for some reason, banger channel

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  2 роки тому

      You are living up to your accounts name! Seriously though, it means alot..thank you so much for the kind words :))

  • @aortaplatinum
    @aortaplatinum 3 роки тому +5

    I'm not sure if you're still debating on whether to keep your new shorter video style, but I really enjoy your long form videos like this, providing a deep dive into these awesome games and Sonic CD lol

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +2

      Don’t worry!! (I should probably make a update video just to put everyone on the same page) but for the spin-off games I plan on doing the “retrospective” style (like the advance series) etc and all
      Also I loved the “awesome games *AND* sonic CD bahahaha”

  • @ShaneTSMackey
    @ShaneTSMackey 2 роки тому +1

    Just stumbled across this. Phenomenal piece brah! Blown away

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  2 роки тому

      Thank you! It means alot

  • @aprilstegall6002
    @aprilstegall6002 3 роки тому +1

    Man this was great! Hope you can do mania next

  • @Cliffordlonghead
    @Cliffordlonghead 3 роки тому +6

    43:53 this was reuse in Sonic Mania for not make it really hard the Breathe because of the smoke from the Oil in Oil Ocean Zone from Sonic 2. and same in sonic 3 and Knuckles in Mania both Mania and Sonic 3 and Knuckles lead to Lava Reef Zone in Sonic Mania like in 3 and Knuckles.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      geez I dont remember any of that from mania...its been so long I need to replay that asap! That's really awesome how to incorporated all of that while also doing a callback to Sandopolis

  • @poisonivy9062
    @poisonivy9062 3 роки тому +5

    Now we just need a Knuckles Chatoix Video

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      i promise it will come ;)

    • @razorionxvii638
      @razorionxvii638 3 роки тому

      Eh. Chaotix was Chaotic. An underdeveloped version of Sonic CD

  • @anthonybarber3220
    @anthonybarber3220 5 місяців тому +1

    Thankfully Big Arms was added into not only Origins, but also Sonic 3 AIR.

  • @yoshisdeepdive2244
    @yoshisdeepdive2244 3 роки тому +1

    Another great video dude! I genuinely cannot express how grateful I am to have such a high quality video play in the background as I work from home. First off, I can only imagine how long it took you to write this script and edit the video. Bravo! 👏🏽 I can’t believe you tackled both games at once. Listening to this review as well as the Sonic 1 & 2 videos made me realize what a critique actually is. Just because I don’t mind a gimmick or an annoying boss fight doesn’t take away from the fact that I have an issue with the game. Marble Garden Zone for instance, was pretty fun because I enjoy flying in games. However, that spinning top had a mind of its own and it was trivial having to come back for it. My only critique with this and the last video are you not displaying the multiplayer sections. It seems like your focusing on the single player experience which is fine, but I would like to know the entire product if possible. I wanted to hear your thoughts about the competition mode of Sonic 3. I wanted see some game play of Single Player Tails in Sonic 2. I know I’m asking for a lot, but it’s just food for thought. Well I’m on my way to your next video. Have a great day man!

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      Hey there! Taking the time out to comment the feedback and everything really means alot to me and I genuinely appreciate it! The script for this was 11 pages at 7pt font (15,122 words in total)...so it took a while hahaha. The process of making this was crazy also as I got COVID, moved back for Winter break, etc etc so I was able to finish it while quarantined funny enough. I didn't display the multiplayer sections just because I didn't think anyone was interested in those but that's my mistake for assuming so I'll definitely work on that in the future..thank you for bringing that to my attention! I really liked the MP music in the 3K multiplayer also. Again thanks so much for the kind words and I hope you enjoy the videos :D

  • @RicardoakaApostle
    @RicardoakaApostle 3 роки тому +1

    I loved this video. Thanks for making it. S3&K is my favourite game of all time since Genesis, so I thoroughly enjoyed your analysis and your humour.
    I look forward to watching more of your videos. 😊
    PS. I sincerely never took in the fact that Knuckles' campaign took place after Sonic and Tails'. I always just thought it was separate. Wow. That blew my mind. 🤯

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      Hey Ricardo! Thank you so much for watching!!! Im super happy you enjoyed the video, this game BLEW MY MIND playing it for the first time this past year. I hope you enjoy the other videos on my channel!

  • @JonathanHolt1988
    @JonathanHolt1988 8 місяців тому

    Amazing video!
    Some noteworthy things I wanted to add:
    1) Big Arm is actually in Sonic's campaign as the final boss of Sonic 3 (not S3&K). What is particularly memorable with this boss is that he could knock Sonic out of his super form if he got ahold of him.
    2) People who have used Super Tails a fair amount probably remember the pain that was trying to beat the Death Egg boss with Super Tails because the flickies will destroy the spike robots that you need kept alive to attack the boss with lol
    3) The blue sphere special stages don't get faster the longer you are in the stage, it's related to how many blue spheres and coins you get. The more you get, the faster it goes.

  • @razorionxvii638
    @razorionxvii638 3 роки тому +4

    I’d always imagined that Sega would contract Studio Junio to make the cutscenes for this game. It would have been even HIGHER received than it already was. If anything, for S3&K they should have done hand drawn instead of sprites, to bring out the full potential of the Artist’s sprite design. The levels in flat out form rather than pixelated would be a game to keep playing over and over. The Sonic CD Video, and this video cover both games perfectly

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +3

      I'd love to see a game that is handdrawn instead of sprites that would be so cool..I believe theres a sonic fan game that did something similar. called Sonic Freedom, check it out! Also thanks so much for the kind words Im really happy to hear you enjoyed the videos :)

  • @davidogunmodede2032
    @davidogunmodede2032 2 роки тому +1

    I've heard of this quote before from many sonic UA-camrs, but what I think how Sonic gets more used to the stage he's in is how he interacts with his environment, if you know what I mean.

  • @symphomaniac
    @symphomaniac 2 роки тому

    Great video, this is just a nitpick but I think it's really funny when people try and describe music.
    Like when you said Ice Cap Act 2's song was slower paced when it's exactly the same as Act 1, just with certain instruments muted at certain times

  • @user-sf7uh5nn5d
    @user-sf7uh5nn5d 18 днів тому

    i am actually really a huge fan of marble garden. Its catchy music, is inredible speed, mixed with thoughtful platfrming, creative level gimmiks, and while the level is long, its a blast all the way. Carnivial nights is a cool zone, but also while i'm playing it Im constantly thinking about ice cap and wanting to play that instead.

  • @jdrobin1
    @jdrobin1 2 роки тому

    That barrel on the carnival stage took me 2 years to beat. Never could get past it until one day it just happened

  • @mrrod6973
    @mrrod6973 3 роки тому +3

    Ahhhh yes my favorite sonic 3 port sonic 3 for the atari 3000

  • @matthewgaming2408
    @matthewgaming2408 2 роки тому +2

    OOOHH! THAT'S WHY sonic 3 rarely gets re-releases! It's because the game's composer was Michael Jackson, I already knew he worked on the music, but I didn't know this was why they don't re-release it AS MUCH AS sonic 1 or 2, thank you SO MUCH for explaining WHY it HARDLY EVER gets re-releases, dude! THANK YOU!

  • @Schnort
    @Schnort 3 роки тому +3

    Edit: you ended up mentioning it a bit later, so ignore this :)
    3:10 It is also worth mentioning that a McDonald's sponsorship may also have contributed to this. Yep. I know Cyberhsell talked about it in his Sonic 3 Bonus video, and I think Game Apologist mentioned it at some point. It is just an interesting tidbit and doesn't really change anything.

  • @TheSonicGuy12
    @TheSonicGuy12 3 роки тому +4

    How do you only have 755 subscribers I will subscribe now
    Edit:in hidden palace it didn't reference perfect choas it actoully references the doomsday zone
    Edit 2: wow you have 777 subscribers now

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks so much Im happy to hear you liked the video and subbed...it means alot! Also, thanks for pointing that out!

  • @thegeeg1748
    @thegeeg1748 2 роки тому

    I love this video a lot, but one thing I do want to mention is that even if you don’t necessarily do a video on it PLEASE check out sonic 3 AIR. I know you mentioned it briefly, but basically all of these things are even further improved in that version and it’s just such a great sonic 3 experience. You can even select music options from s3 prototype and s3 if you’d rather it from the s&k soundtrack. You can unlock the super peel out and drop dash through achievements too.I’ll shut up, but like I said you don’t need to make a video on it but I think you would love it based on what you talked about here, it’s great.

  • @bchristian85
    @bchristian85 7 місяців тому

    I've always looked at Carnival Night as the reward for getting through Marble Garden. The first time I played this as a kid, I had the hardest time with Marble Garden. I always loved it though because the boss was so damn cool.

  • @DaWrecka
    @DaWrecka 2 роки тому +1

    Fun fact; Carnival Night gets a bit of a story in the Fleetway comic series. TL:DR; version; Robotnik built it without Knuckles knowing as a way to make some extra money. (Unexplained is why Robotnik needs money - at this point he's taken control of the entire planet) When Knuckles learns about it, it's after he's learned that Robotnik was tricking him, but he doesn't initially realise that Robotnik is involved - it's being run by the Marxio Brothers. (you have permission to groan at that one) Once Knuckles learns that Robotnik is the one funding Carnival Night, he finds a fault line and breaks the entire zone off the island. (Yes, Knuckles can apparently sense fault lines in a floating island. Don't question it.)

    • @gianni50725
      @gianni50725 Рік тому

      Fleetway isn’t canon at all but I like that they tried to explain weird things about the games like the big rings or the tripiness of the special zone.

  • @mattyboy2024
    @mattyboy2024 Місяць тому +1

    Gotta be my fave game, or double game ever ha. I never got all the emeralds as a kid actually but this retrospective makes me wanna dust off my console n try again

  • @Ryra7X
    @Ryra7X 2 роки тому

    in sonic mania, with medals you get from blue orbs bonus stages, you can get the peelout and the insta shield (what you called the wsa)

  • @soronexle2681
    @soronexle2681 2 роки тому +1

    Excellent video. Though, I think the Sonic Ultimate Genesis Collection doesn't have S3&K. It has the games individually, but not together. Mega Collection and Classic Collection do however.

  • @chaoraiser2338
    @chaoraiser2338 3 роки тому +2

    You know you can spindash into the spikes when it hits the top right it switches it upside down same with on the ground if its stuck in the ground shoots it into the robot

  • @Schnort
    @Schnort 3 роки тому +2

    52:36 One can also think of this as a harder Knuckles fight. This represents the entirety of S3&K, the whole journey that the player just went through. It is a really cool way to show the development in the series and player.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому

      100% agree! It always blows my mind talking about this game how there is not a single piece of dialogue to go along with any of this. Just fantastic environmental storytelling!

    • @Schnort
      @Schnort 3 роки тому +1

      @@Eldarin The fact that the developers made such a fantastic game even with the time and hardware constraints is mind boggling. Thanks for bringing up how crazy the development process of Sonic games tends to get. That is something that I would be interested in hearing more about, and I plan to do a bit of research!

  • @onile425
    @onile425 2 роки тому +2

    The W/ Spin Attack reappears in the Advance Games, but that's it.

  • @Livonade
    @Livonade 2 роки тому

    Hey dude, great video. Its just that at 22:34 you seemed to have accidently mispronounced Hydrocity. You see it's actually "Hydrocity" (like velocity) not "Hydro-city."

  • @trevinodude
    @trevinodude 2 роки тому

    Does anybody else notice Eldarin’s love of T Bagging after he beats a boss? It took me a while, but now that I see it, I can’t un see it! 😂😂

  • @relld05
    @relld05 3 роки тому +5

    Hey, where did you get that plot synopsis from? Was that official? I don't recall there being any connection from Sonic 3&K to Adventure back when the games were originally released. I like it, tbh, just never heard it. For example, the mural depicts Robotnik in his mech from the Final Boss fight, not Chaos

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +3

      Hey there! I got the plot synopsis from the Japanese translated manual of Sonic 3 which is located on sonicretro.org (I'll link). It talks about a "legendary dragon" but again it could've just been my hiccup or a mistranslation error. Hope that clears it up! (info.sonicretro.org/Sonic_the_Hedgehog_3#Story) 5th stanza down on "Story"

    • @glenhaven721
      @glenhaven721 3 роки тому

      I was looking for someone who noticed the same thing. But Sa1 does imply that the echidna tribe had a lot of murals and prophecies

  • @AstroTibs
    @AstroTibs Рік тому

    11:33 "and protects against electrical damage
    It's funny that your clip showed the one source of electrical damage that can break the shield: those plasma arcs from the neon floors!

  • @onile425
    @onile425 2 роки тому +1

    I love Knuckles in this game. This is how to make replayability in a 2D Sonic game. Sonic Advance 2 is the example of how to *NOT* make good replayability in a 2D Sonic game.

  • @cffybnny
    @cffybnny 3 роки тому +2

    i always thought the prophecy was about doomsday zone

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +2

      I think self contained it certainly is but taking a step back and viewing at the whole scope of the franchise it could be interpreted as Perfect Chaos or Doomsday. Either way it’s quite amazing how Sonic Team was able to do so much worldbuilding without a single line of dialogue

    • @razorionxvii638
      @razorionxvii638 3 роки тому

      technically yes, with the part of super sonic being on the mural, with a enlarged eggman looking figure.

  • @bigmikeobama5314
    @bigmikeobama5314 2 роки тому

    my first video game ever was sonic the hedgehog 2 on sega genesis when I was 8 years old in 1995.

  • @Milennin
    @Milennin 3 роки тому +2

    For the Death Egg act 2 regular boss, you do know you can also launch the bots by spin-dashing into them? You can take the thing out within a minute, it's not tedious at all. It's pretty fun, actually.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      I didn't know that, thanks for the heads up..next time I play 3K I'll keep this in mind, wasn't trying to misrepresent anything. Hope you enjoyed the video and thanks for watching:)

    • @Milennin
      @Milennin 3 роки тому +1

      @@Eldarin Yeah, it was a a good video. Just had to watch it because S3K is my favourite game of all-time, lol.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      Yeah I would 100% say 3K is the only game in the franchise that is near to or perfect in the franchise. Completely blew me away playing it for the first time for the video, was stunned!

  • @bigmikeobama5314
    @bigmikeobama5314 2 роки тому

    this game was the cause of the 8-year-old me throwing the controller many a time. never owned it but rented it at blockbuster. still absolutely love the music and sound effects from this game.

  • @finnthomas7014
    @finnthomas7014 2 роки тому +1

    ok so apparently i watched an hour and 15 minute long video about sonic 3 without realizing it

  • @Axos_Abode
    @Axos_Abode 9 днів тому

    How the hell Sonic destroy like 30 egg robos in a single zone yet ONE annoys knuckles his entire campaign

  • @tatertot64
    @tatertot64 2 роки тому +1

    Oh Punxatawny hosted lots of Sonic 3 hype because Hedgehog Day was jokingly going to supplant Groundhog Day! Punxatawny Phil is the groundhog that looks for his shadow on the holiday. Now if only he could find that DAMN fourth Chaos Emerald.

  • @callinater6133
    @callinater6133 2 роки тому +1

    Eldarun it seems you’re misunderstanding how the spin top in marble garden works. It only moves super quick when it’s touching the ground. The more you move the higher it goes, so if you want to go down to the ground and move super quickly don’t press anything.

  • @WillTheHuman84
    @WillTheHuman84 Місяць тому +1

    fitting that this vid is THREE years ago isnt it

  • @ultrairrelevantnobody1862
    @ultrairrelevantnobody1862 3 роки тому +4

    0:00 - 0.08
    For the best, I would include Spyro: Year of the Dragon, Sonic Advance 3, and a few others
    For the worst, I can't really think of any, but I haven't played as many game franchises as I should.
    Then there are the ones in the middle like Mega Man 3 and Tomb Raider III. For these ones, I like them more than the second entries, potentially even have them be my favourite, but I wouldn't say they're as well made as the first. That and I prefer Mario 2 to Mario 3, though that's just me.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      Ah, a man of culture...Sonic Advance 3! I need to play the mega man games they look so fun! Thanks for watching and hope you enjoyed. Also, I've never touched really any of the 2D classic mario games...have any suggestions on where to start? I had a port of 3 on the GBA when I was very young along with the DS game but I've been playing thru 3DW recently and have LOVED IT!

    • @ultrairrelevantnobody1862
      @ultrairrelevantnobody1862 3 роки тому +1

      I would definitely say start with 1 because it's the shortest, then 2 which I feel has the best balance in difficulty and length, and then finally 3 which is the most polished and refined.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      @@ultrairrelevantnobody1862 thanks! That’s really funny as that’s pretty similar to Sonics first 3 games in terms of quality!

    • @publiccrown2382
      @publiccrown2382 2 роки тому

      Mega Man 3 is definitely a better made game than the first one, at least in my opinion.

  • @b0xE_
    @b0xE_ 3 роки тому +2

    Its not flashing the colors of a rainbow its actually flashing the colors of the emeralds

  • @KidPrarchord95
    @KidPrarchord95 2 роки тому

    The insta-shield actually appears in a number of games. It's in the Sonic Advance series, for example.

  • @MicahBuzanANIMATION
    @MicahBuzanANIMATION 2 роки тому +1

    Can you imagine if we got Sonic 3D Blast instead of Sonic 3? It's a blessing in disguise that the technology wasn't ready yet.

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  2 роки тому

      A cursed timeline for sure

  • @aprilstegall6002
    @aprilstegall6002 3 роки тому +2

    Im so glad im not the only one who thinks Flying battery is the best level ever 😃😃

  • @jdrobin1
    @jdrobin1 2 роки тому

    Favorite Sonic game of all time and my favorite game of all time period

  • @patrickestrelacanalsecunda7845
    @patrickestrelacanalsecunda7845 2 роки тому +2

    My Ranked From Mainline Sonic 2D Games:
    7. Sonic The Hedgehog 4: Episode 1
    6. Sonic The Hedgehog 4: Episode 2
    5. Sonic CD
    4. Sonic The Hedgehog
    3. Sonic The Hedgehog 2
    2. Sonic Mania
    1. Sonic 3 & Knuckles
    Sonic 3 & Knuckles is the most perfect Sonic 2D game

  • @matthewgaming2408
    @matthewgaming2408 2 роки тому +2

    Also, I have the classic collection on my ds!

  • @NickNoobles
    @NickNoobles 3 роки тому +2

    yep.

  • @chickenbites8877
    @chickenbites8877 4 місяці тому

    Sonic Jam FTW!

  • @toxin8571
    @toxin8571 2 роки тому

    In marble garden most of the tops let you just tap forward and it will automatically send you into the breakable walls

  • @SuperMechSonic
    @SuperMechSonic 3 роки тому +1

    0:09 Sega turned into valve

  • @Koko-pm4qq
    @Koko-pm4qq 8 місяців тому

    49:25 Uh... I'm pretty sure it's just a mural of Doomsday Zone, including missiles and Eggman's literal face on it.

  • @babynuggethead5576
    @babynuggethead5576 2 роки тому +1

    Lovely

  • @crownlotus6007
    @crownlotus6007 3 роки тому +5

    The insta shield actually shows up again in the sonic advance series

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +3

      havent played them in so long, happy to hear its in them though! Geting ready to play the advance series soon so thatll be fun

  • @yuan713
    @yuan713 3 роки тому +1

    My favorite 2d Sonic game

  • @LiquaFusion
    @LiquaFusion 3 роки тому +1

    err... i'd like to correct you at 49:19 I believe that mural is foreshadowing the doomsday zone, not perfect chaos lol

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому +1

      You are right! I was talking more in the grand scheme of things as it could be interpreted either way in my eyes but certainly looking solely at 3K its about Doomsday. Thanks for watching, hope you enjoyed!

  • @desmondstallworth2934
    @desmondstallworth2934 Місяць тому

    1:00:41 I know there are things that long Tails and KTE can reach but the one you showed Sonic can reach with a well timed jump

  • @ritaandrunt5767
    @ritaandrunt5767 2 роки тому

    Ice cap zone is very beautiful

  • @pixel6894
    @pixel6894 9 місяців тому

    So for some reason Sonic’s ultimate genisis collection has sonic 3 and sonic and knuckles as separate games on the list but you can’t connect them at all. Also the back of the box I’m pretty sure mislabeled every game shown on the back.

  • @cloudair4154
    @cloudair4154 2 роки тому

    sonic's ultimate genesis collection has sonic 3 and sonic and knuckles with all the original music.. its on ps3 and 360.. only issue some people may have is its not sonic 3 and knuckles combined, its sonic 3 and sonic and knuckles.. but i modded my ps classic and it has sonic 3, sonic and knuckles, AND sonic 3 and knuckles.. u can play whichever one u want.. if anyone has a ps classic and wants details just ask

  • @Sydney_Angelyt
    @Sydney_Angelyt 3 роки тому +1

    I went to subscribe before I realised I already was

  • @allytall90
    @allytall90 3 роки тому +1

    I’m not going to get into sonic 3 air: the guy using sonic 3 air footage

    • @Eldarin
      @Eldarin  3 роки тому

      Lawl, it was sonic 3 complete ;) Hope ya enjoyed the video :)))

  • @deathmetalmaniac9647
    @deathmetalmaniac9647 3 роки тому

    They brought back the W-Spin Attack in Sonic Advance