Ach ja, noch eine Bemerkung: Sehr schön auch, dass der Beifall nicht abgewürgt wird. Ich finde zu einer Konzertübertragung gehört auch der Beifall und das Feiern des Dirigenten und des wunderbaren Orchesters dazu! Weiter so beim HR!
Yup, I saw her little face, totally into it. It amazes me how these audiences can just sit there like statues, not moving a muscle while listening to this soul-stirring music. See, they'd have to come and contain me--I'd be standing up shouting amen at some parts and clapping lol (I just love 34:22). There's no way I could sit still like a stump hearing all this magnificence.
I adore this orchestra and seek it for whatever work I want to hear. Such a fine orchestra who you just know knows the rep. Especially the German composers. It's so sad that only 133,000 people have sought out this magnificent Brahms creation in the last 6 years. Please, God, don't let this splendid music fade out. Whoever thought we might live to see the end of great music? What else separates us from the jungle?
IMPRESIONANTE LECTURA, AFINACION, ENERGÍA Y PODER SONORO . TODO UN EJEMPLO, CON UNA INTEGRANTE ESPAÑOLA LA JOVEN Y MUY GUAPA CLARA GARCIA DE LA CALLE SOLISTA DE FLAUTA. ZARAGOZANA..
What a contrast there is between Orozco-Estrada's more traditional, classical Brahms First and Skrowaczewski's gut-wrenching emotional one! Both achieve greatness, this one with its energetic, even urgent, forward momentum is exhilerating, and the other probes the depths of the soul. The FRSO responds equally well to both conductors, bringing out their individual concepts and the strength of the music. I feel privileged to have heard them both.
@@hilariopalaciosmartin7398 Wait a minute, they were great but Mahler was the best especially his Symphony No. 1 it,s considered by many people to be the greatest composed symphony by any composer of all time !!!!!
Brahms is clearly paying homage to Beethoven’s Fifth by incorporating the four-note “fate knocking at the door” motif throughout the first movement. Brilliant!
I fully get how we are influenced by the greats that precede us. Brahms did not enjoy that perspective. For him, to compose in the tradition where Beethoven is the chief exemplar, is another matter. I think he felt deeply unworthy, how dare he, etc. My hunch is the Schumanns bolstered his courage to give a try, not to hide. Let us be grateful he was supported by intimates who saw his talent and knew he had something to add to the tradition he felt connected. Oh, don’t forget that Wagner was cutting new trail as Brahms labored in older vineyards. Greatness does not equal cutting edge production. Depth and sturdy construction will always count for something. JS Bach will always remind of of that.
MAGNÍFICA interpretación por esta orquesta alemana dirigida magistralmente por Andrés Orozco-Estrada de la Primera Sinfonía del genial compositor del Romanticismo Johannes Brahms. Cuando se unen tres características esenciales como son una excelente obra musical, una gran orquesta y un buen director el resultado final es indudablemente una JOYA para deleite de nuestros oídos. BRAVO !!! Saludos desde España.
I can't say enough about this orchestra and conductor...he manages to get the tempos "right" in every video I've seen. If you agree, check out his performances of the Brahms 2nd an Beethoven symphonies with the same orchestra.
I love deeply Brahms 's symphonies (especially the 3th) , this orchester .. and especially the marvellous Clara Andrada de la Calle :-) .... she gives me nice emotions when I m listening Brahms...
Wonderful performance with shared passion of the orchestra and conductor. I agree that the relationship between this orchestra and conductor is excellent. I wish I were there to hear this live.
What a great piece of music this is! And Beethoven's influence is there right from the start with that percussion-rhythmed intro. That the orchestra is great goes without saying now!
probablemente debes escuchar más a las otras. Me pasó lo mismo con la primera que me tuvo asombrado al máximo. Gracias a esta, comencé a oir las otras y créeme que después de un tiempo van a gustarte igual
I only discovered the performances of Andre's Orozco-Estrada on this UA-cam channel with the Hessischer Rundfunk Orchestra after I started listening to many and various symphonic readings here. I long knew he had a sizeable tenure with HR, and he is no longer there, he's on his "way up" as he certainly deserves to be...but as I hear his Beethoven and Brahms interpretations now, I realize what a pity it is he's no longer in Frankfurt. Perhaps in comparison with Vienna, Berlin, London, New York et al., Frankfurt might be considered a backwater, but a musician of his caliber lifts/lifted it considerably out of the ordinary. A shame he's not with "us" any more! This Brahms 1st is audible proof of that. JAT
I know him since he conducted Houston Symphony. His farewell to Houston was Mahler "Resurrection" 2nd Symphony. He's definitely my favorite symphonic maestro
I love this orchestra. I wish I could hear this performance without all the compression of dynamics. It completely changes the shapes of the music, removing so much of the drama. Nevertheless, the last movement was terrific.
Brahms desde su juventud fue concertista pero el fuerte fueron sus 4 sinfonías Para la primera todo 10 años porque se sentía inseguro son para mí 4 joyas de la musica clasica.Fue proclamado como el heredero de Beethoven
Difícil de calificar a Brahms junto a Beethoven. En cuanto a conciertos para piano y orquesta y/o sinfonías no puedo decidirme cual me gusta más. Pero si aseguro que son los dos músicos más grandes de la historia
We believe Mr. Andres Orozco-Estrada is a superior conductor, and his recordings of 3 of the Brahms 4 symphonies are jewels. It would be nice if Mr. Estrada will record Brahms Symphony 3 with the hr-Sinfonieorchester, to complete the cycle he started. Will he ever record it, Meghann? Thanks.
@Bob Trenwith And what exactly is the difference between the two? Except that "disagree" needs an informed opinion which is much more useful for a discussion than a more intuition (which of course doesn't hold any less value). There was no mention of "This is clearly wrong"
Can someone explain to me why contemporary composers can't make great stuff like this and instead make atrocious compositions with no melody and dissonant sounds? (It's a rhetorical question, because they cannot make melodies. Or just to be different)
Some modern composers write good listenable music but I know what you mean. I listen to some pieces and I'm thinking what is this rubbish get this off.
You could probably write a book on that subject (and I’m sure some people have done so). I think it has something to do with the excesses of romanticism (emphasis on originality and freedom from formal constraints) leading eventually to its demise-the pressure to pen something obscure and difficult to understand became a tyranny in its own right that inhibited expression of anything with emotional resonance. Maybe the anxieties of the 20th century could only be expressed by ugly, dissonant music. Or maybe too many composers were writing for the critical evaluation of academic musicologists? 🤷🏻♀️
Nobody was in a hurry. He worked on this symphony 14 years, and released it in 1876. People took enough time to think, read, pray, camp in the forest on horseback...which Herr Brahms enjoyed, as he exchanged melodies with Roma while sharing food, wine, and stories at the fire circle. (Hungarian Dances origin). Somewhere, in a home-office, or a trailer park, a music school drop-out is composing lovely music. The record companies, the Labels won't pick up their offering. From time to time I hear some outstanding music and gifted performances in my former travels. (I'm old: speak four languages, play 3 instruments at small venues). Thing is, some of the wonder-filled performers were not white, not European, no English speakers and no money was asked. The regions were unpaved and not everybody had electricity.
Well, the main theme of the finale of the First Symphony is also reminiscent of the main theme of the finale of Beethoven's Ninth, and when this resemblance was pointed out to Brahms he replied that any dunce could see that! In 1876, when the work was premiered in Vienna, it was immediately hailed as "Beethoven's Tenth"!
Дайте оружие, оружие, оружие, оружие и ещё оружие; а также боеприпасы, боеприпасы, боеприпасы, боеприпасы и боеприпасы. 🇺🇦❤️🖤 Концерт понравился; дай бог не играть ему в бомбоубежище!!!
Ach ja, noch eine Bemerkung: Sehr schön auch, dass der Beifall nicht abgewürgt wird. Ich finde zu einer Konzertübertragung gehört auch der Beifall und das Feiern des Dirigenten und des wunderbaren Orchesters dazu! Weiter so beim HR!
Andrés Orozco-Estrada has become my most favorite Brahms conductor on UA-cam.
He,s very good yes he is !!!!!
7:30 Her facial expression explains everything...No words needed. That's why I love classical music
Yes indeed... She's living it. Beautiful to behold. Thanks for the time stamp.
Clara Andrada is both highly talented and beautiful.
Lekker.
Yup, I saw her little face, totally into it. It amazes me how these audiences can just sit there like statues, not moving a muscle while listening to this soul-stirring music. See, they'd have to come and contain me--I'd be standing up shouting amen at some parts and clapping lol (I just love 34:22). There's no way I could sit still like a stump hearing all this magnificence.
I adore this orchestra and seek it for whatever work I want to hear. Such a fine orchestra who you just know knows the rep. Especially the German composers. It's so sad that only 133,000 people have sought out this magnificent Brahms creation in the last 6 years. Please, God, don't let this splendid music fade out. Whoever thought we might live to see the end of great music? What else separates us from the jungle?
Although this music is certainly great, there is still new great music being made today in various genres, including classical and classical hybrids.
IMPRESIONANTE LECTURA, AFINACION, ENERGÍA Y PODER SONORO . TODO UN EJEMPLO, CON UNA INTEGRANTE ESPAÑOLA LA JOVEN Y MUY GUAPA CLARA GARCIA DE LA CALLE SOLISTA DE FLAUTA. ZARAGOZANA..
Quieres decir, Clara Andrada de la Calle!
21:20 The guy with the glasses in the audience is all of us listening to this piece.
What a contrast there is between Orozco-Estrada's more traditional, classical Brahms First and Skrowaczewski's gut-wrenching emotional one! Both achieve greatness, this one with its energetic, even urgent, forward momentum is exhilerating, and the other probes the depths of the soul. The FRSO responds equally well to both conductors, bringing out their individual concepts and the strength of the music. I feel privileged to have heard them both.
... which says a lot about this orchestra. They seem to throw themselves into whatever they're playing with tremendous gusto and enjoyment.
Brahms, Schubert, Beethoven : incredible magnificent performance in all their symphonies. Totally outstanding!!
00ñ
@@hilariopalaciosmartin7398 Wait a minute, they were great but Mahler was the best especially his Symphony No. 1 it,s considered by many people to be the greatest composed symphony by any composer of all time !!!!!
@Mirco Kreuter They were but their music wasn't as stimulating but they were brilliant as well!
And Bruckner
@@OuwenH101 He was great as well!
guter soundtrack für hausarbeiten aller art
Brahms is clearly paying homage to Beethoven’s Fifth by incorporating the four-note “fate knocking at the door” motif throughout the first movement. Brilliant!
I also hear the Ode to Joy from Beethoven's ninth in the fourth movement.
As expected from the piece that got titled "Beethoven's 10th" by the people when it premiered!
I fully get how we are influenced by the greats that precede us. Brahms did not enjoy that perspective. For him, to compose in the tradition where Beethoven is the chief exemplar, is another matter. I think he felt deeply unworthy, how dare he, etc. My hunch is the Schumanns bolstered his courage to give a try, not to hide. Let us be grateful he was supported by intimates who saw his talent and knew he had something to add to the tradition he felt connected. Oh, don’t forget that Wagner was cutting new trail as Brahms labored in older vineyards. Greatness does not equal cutting edge production. Depth and sturdy construction will always count for something. JS Bach will always remind of of that.
The main theme of the second movement is also built on it.
Brilliant orchestra. Brilliant conductor. Working my way through all his Brahms symphonies!
Great music, great directing and camera angles. Love the movements of the flutists near the end of the second movement.
I love Maestro Andres Orozco-Estrada and this amazing orchestra. Bravo!!
MAGNÍFICA interpretación por esta orquesta alemana dirigida magistralmente por Andrés Orozco-Estrada de la Primera Sinfonía del genial compositor del Romanticismo Johannes Brahms. Cuando se unen tres características esenciales como son una excelente obra musical, una gran orquesta y un buen director el resultado final es indudablemente una JOYA para deleite de nuestros oídos. BRAVO !!! Saludos desde España.
I enjoyed every moment,thank you.
From 44:18 to the end I is one of my favourite parts! Really so outstanding so inspiring !
1:40 A
2:42 Allegro
4:22 D
5:16 E
9:10 F
11:00 einsatz nach I
11:28 K
12:56 N
17:15 oboe solo einsatz
18:45 B
20:18 C
22:07 solo vn hr
28:14
31:33
33:55 C
36:30 solo nach F
37:15 solo vir G
38:38
39:53 L
A wonderful rendition! Only outstanding! Viele Grüße from the Münsterland in Northwestern Germany Bernd.
I can't say enough about this orchestra and conductor...he manages to get the tempos "right" in every video I've seen. If you agree, check out his performances of the Brahms 2nd an Beethoven symphonies with the same orchestra.
El audio casi no se escucha, lo tengo al máximo ,¿Error de grabación?
@@ernestorenandiazcabrera6538 ++++++++++++±±+++++++±
3rd Beethoven symphony with this orchestra is insane !!!
I love deeply Brahms 's symphonies (especially the 3th) , this orchester .. and especially the marvellous Clara Andrada de la Calle :-) .... she gives me nice emotions when I m listening Brahms...
Brahms 3rd is my favorite work of art, in any medium, by any artist.
Wonderful performance with shared passion of the orchestra and conductor. I agree that the relationship between this orchestra and conductor is excellent. I wish I were there to hear this live.
What a great piece of music this is!
And Beethoven's influence is there right from the start with that percussion-rhythmed intro. That the orchestra is great goes without saying now!
I remember playing in this hall on tour... excellent sound ! Thanks for this grand video...!
32:14 parte mais tocante. Bravo!!!
The more rhythmically relentless the pace of the first movement the more I like it personally. So no complaints from me. Very good performance.
Very nice performance ❤
Para mi De las 4 sinfonías de Johannes Brahms la primera es la que mas me impacta
probablemente debes escuchar más a las otras. Me pasó lo mismo con la primera que me tuvo asombrado al máximo. Gracias a esta, comencé a oir las otras y créeme que después de un tiempo van a gustarte igual
34:30 - The best
02:07
Esta sinfonía es sublime.
Cada vez me encuentro con más frecuencia a este director español dirigiendo diversas sinfonías. Me gusta mucho su propuesta.
Es Colombiano.
Gran interpretación !
And the Oscar goes to... Mrs. Flutist 😅
I only discovered the performances of Andre's Orozco-Estrada on this UA-cam channel with the Hessischer Rundfunk Orchestra after I started listening to many and various symphonic readings here. I long knew he had a sizeable tenure with HR, and he is no longer there, he's on his "way up" as he certainly deserves to be...but as I hear his Beethoven and Brahms interpretations now, I realize what a pity it is he's no longer in Frankfurt. Perhaps in comparison with Vienna, Berlin, London, New York et al., Frankfurt might be considered a backwater, but a musician of his caliber lifts/lifted it considerably out of the ordinary. A shame he's not with "us" any more! This Brahms 1st is audible proof of that. JAT
I know him since he conducted Houston Symphony. His farewell to Houston was Mahler "Resurrection" 2nd Symphony. He's definitely my favorite symphonic maestro
I love this orchestra. I wish I could hear this performance without all the compression of dynamics. It completely changes the shapes of the music, removing so much of the drama. Nevertheless, the last movement was terrific.
I am glad to live in Frankfurt. Have heard them many times. Amazing performances all the time
Brahms desde su juventud fue concertista pero el fuerte fueron sus 4 sinfonías Para la primera todo 10 años porque se sentía inseguro son para mí 4 joyas de la musica clasica.Fue proclamado como el heredero de Beethoven
Difícil de calificar a Brahms junto a Beethoven. En cuanto a conciertos para piano y orquesta y/o sinfonías no puedo decidirme cual me gusta más. Pero si aseguro que son los dos músicos más grandes de la historia
22:09 A very sensitive person in the audience! But he was surprised by Brahms! Great!
34:19 Thank me later. The best part begins here! LA
38:10 recapitulation
You are correct
Ein großartiges Orchester und eine prachtvolle Musik!
Wonderful!
Brahms es el mejor clásico romantico
So clear, great
bravi tutti~!!
Bravo to the composer and orchestra. At the time they must have felt, Beethoven lives on with Brahms still doing it his own way.
My favourite one.
Brilliant !
33:22 The Trombones’ chorus
That flautist, man.
32:46 her movement ..🥹
This makes me feel like sinfonieorchester (frankfurt sinfonie orchestra) should bring back maestro orozco estrada!
Concertmaster solo (1st movement) Reh#E starting 22:04
Thanks for letting the winds sound! Some performances are string-heavy.
The 1st flute player ❤❤
좋습니다!
Happy Birthday, Johannes Brahms!
Sublime
That was a propper applause.
Aber eines ist auch klar: Es gibt neben BRUCKNER nichts Besseres! Natürlich Geschmackssache! Ich wünsche dem Orchester das aller Beste!
I'm in love with the flute player... any chance for a fine horn player...?
The most present contrabassoon I remember hearing…
8:23 Audition Excerpt
That second movement is just sublime. This recording doesn’t do justice to it. Look for the Blomstedt/Gewandhausotchester recording.
😍😍😍
Greatness
Nodame cantabile :3
We believe Mr. Andres Orozco-Estrada is a superior conductor, and his recordings of 3 of the Brahms 4 symphonies are jewels. It would be nice if Mr. Estrada will record Brahms Symphony 3 with the hr-Sinfonieorchester, to complete the cycle he started. Will he ever record it, Meghann? Thanks.
So beautiful.. but left signal is approximately and constantly 7-8dB louder than the right.. :(
Hola, me gustaria saber por favor en que ciudad y teatro fue hecho este concierto? gracias
Alte Oper Frankfurt, 5. November 2015 ∙ OPERA DE FRANKFURT
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
La sinfonía número 1 expreso un mundo y muy propio de carácter patético. Su alegre tropas es una de la cumbres del género sinfónico. Su allegretto
Furtwängler ❤️
16:21 Andante sostenuto
Rare to hear the greastest music played by the greastest musicians. I think this the greatest
❤❤❤
Like
Picking up the pace
35:28 22:09/ 18:20 19:40
Just before the final allegro the camera director ran to the bathroom and left his kid at the controls.
Oh no... Horn at 28:57
0:13
5:20
coda audition excerpts :P
Who else came from Barbie in the Diamond Castle🏰💎 starts at 34:22
Neither me!
I already have heard this symphony 4 years before.
Why Mr. Orozco-Estrada goes so fast at the coda of final mov. I don't agree with it, but totally this is good performance.
@Bob Trenwith And what exactly is the difference between the two? Except that "disagree" needs an informed opinion which is much more useful for a discussion than a more intuition (which of course doesn't hold any less value). There was no mention of "This is clearly wrong"
who edits these kinds of videos i just realized
Perdón por el dato equivocado. Alguien me hizo el favor de corregir la nacionalidad del director. En realidad es colombiano
4楽章fl.solo物凄く気持ちよく奏でている、クララアンドレア首席奏者！
Can someone explain to me why contemporary composers can't make great stuff like this and instead make atrocious compositions with no melody and dissonant sounds? (It's a rhetorical question, because they cannot make melodies. Or just to be different)
I agree with you; dissonance is not progress!
Some modern composers write good listenable music but I know what you mean. I listen to some pieces and I'm thinking what is this rubbish get this off.
You could probably write a book on that subject (and I’m sure some people have done so). I think it has something to do with the excesses of romanticism (emphasis on originality and freedom from formal constraints) leading eventually to its demise-the pressure to pen something obscure and difficult to understand became a tyranny in its own right that inhibited expression of anything with emotional resonance. Maybe the anxieties of the 20th century could only be expressed by ugly, dissonant music. Or maybe too many composers were writing for the critical evaluation of academic musicologists? 🤷🏻♀️
You must know Alma Deutscher, a prodigy composer, now at her 17 years old.
Nobody was in a hurry. He worked on this symphony 14 years, and released it in 1876. People took enough time to think, read, pray, camp in the forest on horseback...which Herr Brahms enjoyed, as he exchanged melodies with Roma while sharing food, wine, and stories at the fire circle. (Hungarian Dances origin).
Somewhere, in a home-office, or a trailer park, a music school drop-out is composing lovely music. The record companies, the Labels won't pick up their offering.
From time to time I hear some outstanding music and gifted performances in my former travels. (I'm old: speak four languages, play 3 instruments at small venues).
Thing is, some of the wonder-filled performers were not white, not European, no English speakers and no money was asked. The regions were unpaved and not everybody had electricity.
02:07
Horn solo 32:13
Well, the main theme of the finale of the First Symphony is also reminiscent of the main theme of the finale of Beethoven's Ninth, and when this resemblance was pointed out to Brahms he replied that any dunce could see that! In 1876, when the work was premiered in Vienna, it was immediately hailed as "Beethoven's Tenth"!
34:14, 39:19
22:09
5:15
there are two performances of this work by this Orchestra and conductor
this one isn't the best one.
Great Bs
Beethoven bach und Brahms
36:30
16:18
DID ESTRADA RECORD BRAHMS SYMPHONY 3 WITH THIS ORCHESTRA? IF YES, CAN YOU PLEASE UPLOAD IT???
Yes they did
Дирижер витирає чоло
Невже він сокирою махав?
Чи може мішки таскав?
Ні.Легенькою паличкою,він прискорював серця биття, і сльози з очей визивав.
Trotz sehr rhythmischer Leitung von diesem genialen Dirigenten klingt das Orchester manchmal ein bisschen schleppend.
+notaire2 Das stimmt. Und zu höflich irgendwie auch! Erster Brahms ist doch kein lustiges stück!
+Oscar Rubilar Du hast ganz Recht. Danke!
You will love the version conducted by Stanisław Skrowaczewski.
ua-cam.com/video/9Ij6I_zhBdU/v-deo.html
Hello, waiting for Brahms Symphony 3. Will you upload it?
Im waiting for Brahms Symphony n.5
@@JafuetTheSame Me too, very intriguing!
@@JafuetTheSame Brahms only wrote 4 symphonies
Don’t turn up the volume on the out of tune bassoon player
Дайте оружие, оружие, оружие, оружие и ещё оружие; а также боеприпасы, боеприпасы, боеприпасы, боеприпасы и боеприпасы.
🇺🇦❤️🖤
Концерт понравился; дай бог не играть ему в бомбоубежище!!!