Real Art vs AI Art - Can Pro Artists Spot the Difference?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 34

  • @ChristianSulger
    @ChristianSulger 2 дні тому +12

    I was 8 for 8. When you've looked at ai generated images for a while, you'll start noticing certain characteristics. But the technology is progressing so fast that it will be probably indistinguishable in no time. What sets apart a real life artist is the unique point of view. Ai can only recycle and mash up, not truly create.

  • @leahlambertphotography
    @leahlambertphotography 23 години тому +2

    I love the comment “as a human being there is something real that you bring to the table.” … I feel that AI has provided a greater opportunity for artists to show just how amazing they are. Authenticity is real. AI is a tool and should not be mistaken for artistic integrity 🙂

  • @catibreil3535
    @catibreil3535 3 дні тому +7

    The one that fooled you fooled me too because it was done in Gwenn Seemel's style !!! I hesitated... this kind of content is really super cool thank you all it was fun !!!! 😃💛🙌🏼

  • @marissathornberry3323
    @marissathornberry3323 3 дні тому +10

    The Eiffel Tower had a bite taken out of it! 😂

    • @VioletFeatherWind
      @VioletFeatherWind День тому

      @@marissathornberry3323 That's what I was almost thinking! 😅

    • @joannaplichta9677
      @joannaplichta9677 День тому

      I think it was meant to be postapocalyptic. :D

  • @joannaplichta9677
    @joannaplichta9677 День тому +1

    I didn't get all of them right but towards the end I started to be more correct. I started to notice that the real ones are more planned for example as far as distribution of colors goes while AI are more random - especially visible with the last two ones, where every drop of color made sense in the first one and some of them were pretty random in the second one (the colours filtered by trees onto the path for example made no sense). I noticed something similar when I was "inviting" AI to make botanical art - the individual elements were perfect but the whole drawing together did not reflect the habit of the real plant.

  • @lisengel2498
    @lisengel2498 День тому +1

    Well it was fun to Watch but for me the real interesting question would be something like: what makes a Work of Art attractive for you? What do you value? What are you attracted to? The experience of Art are interesting because it is a Way of sharing experiences in a multidimensional way … experiencing, perceiving, seeing, feeling, touching ( if allowed), moving, imagining, dreaming reflecting, wondering , sharing and much more 😀🎵♥️🎶

  • @simplyme135
    @simplyme135 3 дні тому +7

    Small, elite part of art lovers , will still buy a real art from the real artists, if they can afford. But, a lot of them if not most, will continue to buy art from Home Goods or start buying from AI artist ( at some extend, the same)....What we, artists, can alternatively offer to the Home Goods audience?... great technique? Fancy art school diploma? or...selling for a very low price our " masterpieces" ( the most practical way, in my opinion, followed by the most painters). That's why I am transitioning to sculptures: hard to reproduce with AI.

  • @tinacluff2793
    @tinacluff2793 3 дні тому +8

    I don't care for AI that much, like one of them said it's alot of copy and paste.

  • @donitafichter8298
    @donitafichter8298 День тому +2

    Sorry, doesn’t teach me anything BUT it was very entertaining!!!😂

  • @MichelleBrown_Artist
    @MichelleBrown_Artist 3 дні тому +2

    I'm shocked that AI mimicked Erin Hanson's art. I love her art. 😊

    • @ArtJourneyUK
      @ArtJourneyUK День тому +1

      That's because the AI has been trained on her artworks and now can replace her by someone just saying "create me an artwork in the style of..."

  • @shannamcguire9008
    @shannamcguire9008 3 дні тому

    When is your next competition?

  • @rachelflint2319
    @rachelflint2319 День тому +1

    Quirky Fun!🤗

  • @MelliaBoomBot
    @MelliaBoomBot Годину тому +1

    6/8. But I really liked that waterfall one ❤ soz humans

  • @anniecourtney3905
    @anniecourtney3905 6 годин тому

    7 out of 8. Im an Art teacher. Students will try to fool us, but most won't!

  • @comeonhohoya
    @comeonhohoya 2 дні тому

    awsome!! I was wondering what tools you use with AI ? so funny

  • @JoyAZrebiec
    @JoyAZrebiec 3 дні тому +2

    That was fun😊

  • @maryumarshed9081
    @maryumarshed9081 2 дні тому +1

    round 5 blown me out , now its useless to be an artist :(

  • @christinaps
    @christinaps 5 годин тому

    As a photographer I can easily spot AI photo's, art is a bit more difficult, I had 5/8
    I do find it scary as most people are fooled all the time

  • @ArtJourneyUK
    @ArtJourneyUK День тому +2

    AI art has no soul.

  • @Sominadi
    @Sominadi 3 дні тому +1

    So we are safe for now

  • @gepetogromit9625
    @gepetogromit9625 День тому

    Do you think an AI could have spotted thé différence ?

  • @CathyCawood
    @CathyCawood 22 години тому

    I was also 8 for 8. But I've seen a lot of AI images that are more convincing than the ones you showed. At least your real paintings were also not the highest quality.

  • @thegreatestpuzzleever
    @thegreatestpuzzleever 22 години тому +1

    AI/Satan cannot be original and there is no real love in his art.

  • @AliciaRaeTheSicilianWitch
    @AliciaRaeTheSicilianWitch 3 дні тому +3

    I like to play with ai but I prefer human generated art. Ai misses a lot of things or over exaggerates a lot or random things wind up in them .. while ai can do it quick humans can do it best!

  • @jjsc3334
    @jjsc3334 2 дні тому +1

    It doesn't matter, creativity is number one.
    Forget these creepy artists.

  • @bluewren65
    @bluewren65 15 годин тому

    I couldn't watch this because of the awful music. Mercifully not behind the speech, but still very jarring.

  • @lilypad8922
    @lilypad8922 3 дні тому +1

    With better prompts, you absolutely could not tell the difference. These AI images were about 1/8 of AIs full potantial for image generation.