Etymologically and gramatically speaking what is the relationship between the Arabic terms al-lah and al-lat? And are they proper names or a generic word for god and goddess?
Doing etymological investigation, i found that Zeus means originally "Light". It is said that this word could be originally spelled Dyu (in sanskrit) like in french Dieu, or Dios in spanish. The final - s is a morphem used in greek, so it doesn't belong to the core of this name. I gather the proves that PIE languages have a semitic or proto-semitic cradle, many obvious proves, the first one it's the similar set of phones (alfabet). So Di- in PIE languages is related to Light, hence the Sun, one of the first worshiped divinity. And this word is also semitic, the D beeing the semitic ض thus the word ضوء. There is 2 words for "Light" in arabic : Noor is a special light, coming from the Moon, because the Moon in semitic culture allows to size the time, Noor gives information, it's a light for the mind, and there is a second word ضوء which is Light, coming from the Sun. The phone ض is very closed to the phone D, and for sure, the greek Z. The ض sound is between a D and a Z. In conclusion, many clues lead us toward a common cradle between sanskrit, latin, greek and semitic langue. The issue to identify semitic orgine of PIE languages is the alteration of the phones (B and P, F and V, T and D, ect.) but with help of semantic, we can make the connection between PIE's word and semitic ones.
Well your time consuming research into morpho semantics and etymologyical investigations indeed reveals a lot of hidden gems which many of us are unaware of. Please continue to enlighten us. By the way, have you come across the Hebrew sacred name "YHVH" and its morpho semantics?
@@frankly.speaking First you must realize God never give this name to Himself. When Ezra rewrote the Tanakh, he faced 2 mains tradition, the Elohists and the Yahvehists. The yavehists invented this YHWH upon what God revealed to Moses in Mont Sinai (I am who I am). So YHWH is not a word, nor a name, but a gathering of 1 concept. The letter Y is the Present, and the W is the Potentiality, means Conditional and Futur. The Y is the "here and now" and the W is without limit, all potential. YH and WH. The H is the archetyp of the Hidden, it's the ideation, something we have in mind, in "spirit" as said the Gospel, we can reach God in Spirit only. Hence, the translation of "I am who I am" doesn't reflect the correct meaning. In conclusion, YHWH is not a name God gives for Himself, it was built by hebrew linguists, and reflect the main principle and relation between human and God "to think God now, and tomorrow".
We also find similiar Hebrew terms in the Bible that phonetically sound the same as the Quranic term "allah" for example in Joshua 24:26; Psalms 10:7; Isaiah 24:6. If you only go by the above phonetic Semitic sounds, how do you reconcile them and their meanings?
Prior to Islam did the Arab Christians use the Syriac term for God or the Meccan term for God? Your research makes it clear that the Arab Christian term and the Quranic term phonetically sound similiar but are they etamologyically related? If so please elaborate.
One thing you made it clear and i absolutely agree with you, just as the ancient term EL is of pagan origins so is Arabain term "Allah". Similiarly as the Hebrews have adopted the term EL from the Canaanaites, so did Mohammed in the 7th century adopted the term allah from the Qurayshi tribe. But there is one essential thing you haven't made known... What is the proper name of EL (the Hebrew term for God) in the Bible? And what is the proper name for the Arabic term ilah in the Quran? But if you consider Allah has a generic Arabian word for God, what is his proper name in the Quran?
His proper name in qur’an is Allah which mean God. Thats it, its a semitic language which arabs is in it, so no surprise it has some similiarity between them but the point is Allah mean one god or the only god
@arifhendriyana4399 you claim Allah is a "proper name" but then you say allah means God? The term "God" is just an english word, a translation, like theos in greek, kudha in persian, bog in croatian, gott in german etc other term for God is deity. If allah is a "proper name" it should have proper significant meaning not that allah means "god" or "one god" or "only god".
@@frankly.speaking it is the beauty of it, god means god. The concept god in arabic is the one who dont have a start and and an end, the one that do not depend on anything, the one that has no gender. Allah has many name or nickname, 99 of them written in quran, but that just what is written to make human understand Allah in a human language. In islam, we cant depict Allah in an images or some word, thats why i said Allah means god, since God in an Unknown Dimension, even as a muslim its impossible to understand Allah but we know from the quran. Allah in quran from what i know has a name like : The most merciful, the most loving, the most fair judge, etc. You can search it up, 99 names of Allah. If my english is broken im sorry, not my first language hehe
@@arifhendriyana4399 please note those "99" numbers you mentioned are not names but attributes of Allah, but its also interesting to note that mohammed too has 99 names, in Arabic its known as "Asmā'u n-Nabiyy".
@@frankly.speaking the mosque near my house recite it everyday and we call it 99 names of Allah, the attributes is much much more than 99, becasue Allah's attribute is beyond human understanding. As muslim myself, its really hard to understand, even we argue about it🤣 usually we dont discuss all the things that considered "ghaib" or things that we cant see in islam such as hell, heaven, angel, death, and Allah. Btw you are quite literate about islam, as a muslim i respect you
Have you taken note of the consonants that form the 7th century Quranic term "allah" with the Christian Arab's term for God (which was used prior to islam)? Are the consonants used in them exactly the same? Don't you think it matters since they are both of Semitic origins and islam claims its the same God of the Bible?
Yes, same consonnant since bereshit 1.1 Eloh-ym. The arabic made clear distinction between a long "A" (pronunciated E in late hebrew) and the Hamza, a sharped "A", the A and the Hamza don't carry the same meaning, thus the aramaic, hebrew gather the A and the Hamza, and only the voweling makes the difference. So, Alaha in aramaic, and Allah in arabic : the suffixed "a" in alaha is a determinant (the), and in arabic it is prefixed Al-Lah and the Hamza is absorbed between Al and Lah. Arab linguists have various opinion on this. I choose the more rational.
@@victoremman4639 interesting, but from my study i have learnt that Syriac term for God, ALahaa has three consonants alif, lamed and ha while the Quranic term ALLAH has four consonants. The intial two consonants in the Syriac term ALahaa refers to either AL/IL/EL depending on the Semetic languages used, meaning "mighty ruler". This meaning is derived from Paleo-Hebrew script. While the first two consonants in the Quranic term ALLAH does not refer to God and there lies the major difference. The Quranic term allah does not adopt the same meaning found in the in the paleo -Hebrew, Aramaic or Syriac letters. 21st century muslims tried to formulate and manupilate the term "allah" by making a contraction of two words al and ilah, the problem here is how can one contract the term ilah ( alif lam =god) into Lah, detaching or breaking away the first essential Semetic consonant alif from the two that form the word IL (God). this is never done in the Akkadian, Hebrew, Aramaic, Syriac or the Christian Arabic term for God. EL/AL/IL is either used as a lone word for God or used as suffix to define an attribute of God. Phonetically they sound the same but etymologically they contradict.
@leoking8266 your confusing the two "judging" and "knowing/understanding" If you do have some interesting info on him, it will be kind of you to share so we can understand him better.
Allah is Pagan to the core, the God of the Bible is light years different to Allah. Peddling allah and equating the idol allah with the God of the Bible is gross blasphemy. Semantic gooblygook will not make allah the idol into God.
The Pagan Arabs before the revelation of Quran or before Prophet Muhammad pbuh used to worship Al- Lat, Al- Uzza and Al- Manat. They were also considered as the children of God. But Allah has dispelled all the doubts and misconceptions in the Holy Quran. The real name of all time God was/is/will be Allah. This video was done without reading the scriptures. Half done and half truth.
Sounds good! Please, keep it up blessing people
Thank you, your word of " Allah" is uniting three heavinly religions in one. Merry christmas🎉
Etymologically and gramatically speaking what is the relationship between the Arabic terms al-lah and al-lat? And are they proper names or a generic word for god and goddess?
Doing etymological investigation, i found that Zeus means originally "Light". It is said that this word could be originally spelled Dyu (in sanskrit) like in french Dieu, or Dios in spanish. The final - s is a morphem used in greek, so it doesn't belong to the core of this name. I gather the proves that PIE languages have a semitic or proto-semitic cradle, many obvious proves, the first one it's the similar set of phones (alfabet). So Di- in PIE languages is related to Light, hence the Sun, one of the first worshiped divinity. And this word is also semitic, the D beeing the semitic ض thus the word ضوء. There is 2 words for "Light" in arabic : Noor is a special light, coming from the Moon, because the Moon in semitic culture allows to size the time, Noor gives information, it's a light for the mind, and there is a second word ضوء which is Light, coming from the Sun. The phone ض is very closed to the phone D, and for sure, the greek Z. The ض sound is between a D and a Z. In conclusion, many clues lead us toward a common cradle between sanskrit, latin, greek and semitic langue. The issue to identify semitic orgine of PIE languages is the alteration of the phones (B and P, F and V, T and D, ect.) but with help of semantic, we can make the connection between PIE's word and semitic ones.
Well your time consuming research into morpho semantics and etymologyical investigations indeed reveals a lot of hidden gems which many of us are unaware of. Please continue to enlighten us.
By the way, have you come across the Hebrew sacred name "YHVH" and its morpho semantics?
@@frankly.speaking First you must realize God never give this name to Himself. When Ezra rewrote the Tanakh, he faced 2 mains tradition, the Elohists and the Yahvehists. The yavehists invented this YHWH upon what God revealed to Moses in Mont Sinai (I am who I am). So YHWH is not a word, nor a name, but a gathering of 1 concept. The letter Y is the Present, and the W is the Potentiality, means Conditional and Futur. The Y is the "here and now" and the W is without limit, all potential. YH and WH. The H is the archetyp of the Hidden, it's the ideation, something we have in mind, in "spirit" as said the Gospel, we can reach God in Spirit only. Hence, the translation of "I am who I am" doesn't reflect the correct meaning. In conclusion, YHWH is not a name God gives for Himself, it was built by hebrew linguists, and reflect the main principle and relation between human and God "to think God now, and tomorrow".
We also find similiar Hebrew terms in the Bible that phonetically sound the same as the Quranic term "allah" for example in Joshua 24:26; Psalms 10:7; Isaiah 24:6.
If you only go by the above phonetic Semitic sounds, how do you reconcile them and their meanings?
Prior to Islam did the Arab Christians use the Syriac term for God or the Meccan term for God?
Your research makes it clear that the Arab Christian term and the Quranic term phonetically sound similiar but are they etamologyically related? If so please elaborate.
Are you speaking from a muslim perspective or Judeo Christian perspective?
One thing you made it clear and i absolutely agree with you, just as the ancient term EL is of pagan origins so is Arabain term "Allah". Similiarly as the Hebrews have adopted the term EL from the Canaanaites, so did Mohammed in the 7th century adopted the term allah from the Qurayshi tribe.
But there is one essential thing you haven't made known...
What is the proper name of EL (the Hebrew term for God) in the Bible?
And what is the proper name for the Arabic term ilah in the Quran?
But if you consider Allah has a generic Arabian word for God, what is his proper name in the Quran?
His proper name in qur’an is Allah which mean God. Thats it, its a semitic language which arabs is in it, so no surprise it has some similiarity between them but the point is Allah mean one god or the only god
@arifhendriyana4399 you claim Allah is a "proper name" but then you say allah means God?
The term "God" is just an english word, a translation, like theos in greek, kudha in persian, bog in croatian, gott in german etc other term for God is deity.
If allah is a "proper name" it should have proper significant meaning not that allah means "god" or "one god" or "only god".
@@frankly.speaking it is the beauty of it, god means god. The concept god in arabic is the one who dont have a start and and an end, the one that do not depend on anything, the one that has no gender. Allah has many name or nickname, 99 of them written in quran, but that just what is written to make human understand Allah in a human language. In islam, we cant depict Allah in an images or some word, thats why i said Allah means god, since God in an Unknown Dimension, even as a muslim its impossible to understand Allah but we know from the quran.
Allah in quran from what i know has a name like : The most merciful, the most loving, the most fair judge, etc. You can search it up, 99 names of Allah.
If my english is broken im sorry, not my first language hehe
@@arifhendriyana4399 please note those "99" numbers you mentioned are not names but attributes of Allah, but its also interesting to note that mohammed too has 99 names, in Arabic its known as "Asmā'u n-Nabiyy".
@@frankly.speaking the mosque near my house recite it everyday and we call it 99 names of Allah, the attributes is much much more than 99, becasue Allah's attribute is beyond human understanding. As muslim myself, its really hard to understand, even we argue about it🤣 usually we dont discuss all the things that considered "ghaib" or things that we cant see in islam such as hell, heaven, angel, death, and Allah. Btw you are quite literate about islam, as a muslim i respect you
Have you taken note of the consonants that form the 7th century Quranic term "allah" with the Christian Arab's term for God (which was used prior to islam)? Are the consonants used in them exactly the same? Don't you think it matters since they are both of Semitic origins and islam claims its the same God of the Bible?
Yes, same consonnant since bereshit 1.1 Eloh-ym. The arabic made clear distinction between a long "A" (pronunciated E in late hebrew) and the Hamza, a sharped "A", the A and the Hamza don't carry the same meaning, thus the aramaic, hebrew gather the A and the Hamza, and only the voweling makes the difference. So, Alaha in aramaic, and Allah in arabic : the suffixed "a" in alaha is a determinant (the), and in arabic it is prefixed Al-Lah and the Hamza is absorbed between Al and Lah. Arab linguists have various opinion on this. I choose the more rational.
@@victoremman4639 interesting, but from my study i have learnt that Syriac term for God, ALahaa has three consonants alif, lamed and ha while the Quranic term ALLAH has four consonants.
The intial two consonants in the Syriac term ALahaa refers to either AL/IL/EL depending on the Semetic languages used, meaning "mighty ruler". This meaning is derived from Paleo-Hebrew script.
While the first two consonants in the Quranic term ALLAH does not refer to God and there lies the major difference.
The Quranic term allah does not adopt the same meaning found in the in the paleo -Hebrew, Aramaic or Syriac letters.
21st century muslims tried to formulate and manupilate the term "allah" by making a contraction of two words al and ilah, the problem here is how can one contract the term ilah ( alif lam =god) into Lah, detaching or breaking away the first essential Semetic consonant alif from the two that form the word IL (God). this is never done in the Akkadian, Hebrew, Aramaic, Syriac or the Christian Arabic term for God.
EL/AL/IL is either used as a lone word for God or used as suffix to define an attribute of God.
Phonetically they sound the same but etymologically they contradict.
You have not made it clear whether you are an historian or scholar in religious studies, specifically in the field of Judaism, Christianity and Islam?
He made it clear stop judging only god judge
@leoking8266 your confusing the two "judging" and "knowing/understanding"
If you do have some interesting info on him, it will be kind of you to share so we can understand him better.
Think about it. Th Islamic Allah apparently only understands Arabic so he is not the Living Almighty God.
Where on earth did you get this idea?
The Living and the Almighty is 2 of Allah's names, but in the language of Moses and Jesus, not in your english language. Understand now ?
@@victoremman4639 No I don't
No way Christianity makes sense. Merry Christmas 🎅.
Allah is Pagan to the core, the God of the Bible is light years different to Allah. Peddling allah and equating the idol allah with the God of the Bible is gross blasphemy. Semantic gooblygook will not make allah the idol into God.
Chat gpt😂
Its not clear whether you a Christian or a muslim? Adherent follower of Jesus the Messiah or follower of the 7th century Arabian prophet, Mohammed?
The Pagan Arabs before the revelation of Quran or before Prophet Muhammad pbuh used to worship Al- Lat, Al- Uzza and Al- Manat. They were also considered as the children of God. But Allah has dispelled all the doubts and misconceptions in the Holy Quran. The real name of all time God was/is/will be Allah. This video was done without reading the scriptures. Half done and half truth.
God means call to Indra Allaah means The Sovereignty so Allaah is NOT call to Indra.