What the student loan payment restart means for the economy

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 155

  • @Pilotpaulie
    @Pilotpaulie Рік тому +15

    We paid ours. You pay yours. You’re NOT special.

    • @christinastaggs5882
      @christinastaggs5882 Рік тому +2

      Give us back OUR social security a lot of the ones who’ve PAID their loans are currently using up.

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому

      @@christinastaggs5882 I’m 44 and have punched a time sheet since I was 14. I’ve paid into social security, and I paid off my student loans. Guess what? You will not win this.

  • @danavelez5615
    @danavelez5615 Рік тому +8

    Boo hoo...you will have to cut back on vacations and eating out. Life is rough. Pay up!

  • @stockpile2137
    @stockpile2137 Рік тому +10

    Makes $80k/year and struggles to pay off $28k in student loans. This is the perfect example of schools not teaching financial literacy.

  • @GenK1991
    @GenK1991 Рік тому +31

    He needs to get out of his own financial hole before he starts thinking about taking care of his parents, especially if he’s claiming that on 80k / year he can’t pay off a 28k student loan. I had 25k in student loans making 45k and paid it off.

    • @primezeroth
      @primezeroth Рік тому +5

      Looks like hes in california. Plus with inflation of the last 3 years, 80k is nothing

    • @luisrpachecojr
      @luisrpachecojr Рік тому

      He can claim them as defendants if they live with him?

    • @autobotdiva9268
      @autobotdiva9268 Рік тому +3

      Was your eggs .99 cent vs now $12.99? Asking for a friend

    • @diegolara4202
      @diegolara4202 Рік тому

      @@autobotdiva9268 Last time I saw eggs were on longer 12.99. You can get a 18 pack of eggs for less than $2 in walmart. Stop lying. I'm as conservative as they come but I will keep it real instead of exaggerating numbers only to make a point.

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому

      We are a family of four living on only my husbands teaching salary. In 2021 we finally paid off over $100k in student loans on (at the time) a max salary of around $55k/year gross. It took us six and a half years of working the Dave Ramsey debt snowball... but we did it ourselves. Now we have decided to keep going and are on schedule (God willing) to pay off our mortgage in three more years (10 years early). People *choose* to be victims (of their own choices), and they *choose* to make excuses instead of acting like a grown adult. Let them live with the consequences of their *choices*

  • @froggore52
    @froggore52 Рік тому +10

    He makes $80k per year yet ~$200 a month is enough to put him out of his house? Something isn't adding up here.

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому +2

      He spends money like everyone else his age on “little luxuries”.

    • @CocoaPuff01
      @CocoaPuff01 9 місяців тому

      Exactly. Add in the other working adults in his home, and their income is well over 100k. He just doesn't want to pay his debts.

  • @mlecarre2057
    @mlecarre2057 Рік тому +35

    Taxpayers should not be in the business of lending 19 year olds money…

    • @deftuncut
      @deftuncut Рік тому +1

      I see this argument but we also need to invest in our future. Unfortunately it’s not cheap

    • @rickysampson8759
      @rickysampson8759 Рік тому

      @@deftuncutdoctors and lawyers are literally spewing over our borders. We have plenty of future

    • @johng1738
      @johng1738 Рік тому +2

      Should be free.
      Our economy would be stronger if the young didn’t need debt to get a stable, no physical career.

    • @rickysampson8759
      @rickysampson8759 Рік тому

      @@johng1738 how would it be stronger? All the big tech ceos are college dropouts. If you want a nonphysical job then you need to give each physical workers 400k the very moment they enter the workforce fair is fair isn’t it. Oh that’s right you hate the working class

    • @RM-jb2bv
      @RM-jb2bv Рік тому

      @@johng1738what a Sikh thing to say. Nothing is free. You think goods and services grow on trees? Seriously.
      Why would you even think it should be free? What sense does that make?
      What about food l? Tires? Computers? Coats? Cars? Houses?
      Should that all be “free” too?

  • @1132539
    @1132539 Рік тому +29

    Take out a loan and have to pay it back. What a strange concept?!

    • @djm2189
      @djm2189 Рік тому

      Agree. But why is it not a problem when people go bankrupt but student loans stay? How about the companies that got bailed out with our taxes but the C suite folks keep their huge bonuses and killer pay? Just super funny to me how many hated the thought of every day folks getting max 10k off their loans for an education that is basically needed nowadays, but love paying for companies, rich people, and idiots who buy actually useless things.

    • @autobotdiva9268
      @autobotdiva9268 Рік тому

      Strange ro keep fubding ukraine from citizens tax dollars without asking them

    • @DoodleThis
      @DoodleThis 11 місяців тому

      Ppl always seem to forget the BS certain banks do to ppl like selling their loans off to sharks who then increase the interest and add tons of fees making it seem near impossible to pay off.

    • @emilionarvaez1415
      @emilionarvaez1415 11 місяців тому +2

      Thank God for student loans. I have a completely different outcome in my life cause of the ability to borrow. Upper middle class now, beautiful life. I am more than willing to pay back what I promised.

  • @Chopsuey087
    @Chopsuey087 Рік тому +5

    He wouldn't be making 80k if he didn't go to college. He can pay his loans back.

  • @BecauseBroward
    @BecauseBroward Рік тому +15

    I know a couple people who REFUSE TO take responsibility and even BEGIN TO
    to pay back those LOANS.

    • @Pilotpaulie
      @Pilotpaulie Рік тому +1

      Hope their credit reflects this.

    • @faerierosepress4133
      @faerierosepress4133 Рік тому +1

      @@Pilotpaulieit won’t reflect on the credit reports for at least a year from now.

    • @williamshaw5388
      @williamshaw5388 Рік тому +3

      I hope no one pays them back.

    • @sublimetrance
      @sublimetrance Рік тому +4

      Until the economy improves, many of us simply do not make enough income to pay them back.

    • @Pilotpaulie
      @Pilotpaulie Рік тому +2

      @@sublimetrance I remember that feeling. I got a second job.

  • @mrmustangman
    @mrmustangman Рік тому +5

    i tried to tell you people biden was going to lie to you but you wouldn't listen.!!!!

  • @Goodiebar18
    @Goodiebar18 Рік тому +19

    Should have paid it down during the pandemic…too many people figured it would just go away…

    • @djm2189
      @djm2189 Рік тому +1

      You're partly right. Problem was with inflation now. Everything is crazy expensive and rent costs are off the charts. Most are newer grads who never even had a chance to get a home ahead of time. Thus, yes loans need to be paid but will destroy many people when the rest of the economy is dog shiii.

    • @rickysampson8759
      @rickysampson8759 Рік тому

      @@djm2189then you should have voted for trump. Didn’t they teach you economics in that fancy school of yours

    • @johng1738
      @johng1738 Рік тому

      @@rickysampson8759economics wise, Biden is a better choice.
      By a lot.

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому

      That is exactly what we did. A family of 4, living on my husband’s teacher salary. We had already been very strict with our budget for 5 years to pay off our $100k+ in student loans, we took another year and a half and threw all those stupid “stimulus” checks at them. $100k+ in debt, over 6.5 years, making a high of $55k/year gross (no welfare). People do not want to change their ridiculous spending habits. Fine - they can have “little luxuries”, but I’m going to actually *own* my own home. But I don’t want a cent of tax payer dollars going to bail these fools out.

    • @zack1610
      @zack1610 11 місяців тому

      @@katiejon17Just curious how do you feel about us sending tax dollars over to Ukraine? Isn’t that wasting our money as well?

  • @casienwhey
    @casienwhey 11 місяців тому +2

    My heart breaks for them, having to cut back on vacations and restaurants. It's simply tragic to do that to a person.

  • @catus-cactus
    @catus-cactus Рік тому +12

    My college no longer exists and it was officially closed years before the pandemic. I still have to pay smh

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому +1

      Yeah... lesson learned to do better research.

  • @LatexFreeLiving
    @LatexFreeLiving 8 місяців тому

    Should of paid them off when you had no interest for 3 years on the loans

  • @rsimmons1980
    @rsimmons1980 Рік тому +12

    This guy makes $80,000, but has $30,000 in debt. He should be able to pay that off easily in 3 years at most!

    • @fakename2956
      @fakename2956 Рік тому +6

      He has other family members to support

    • @crecasens
      @crecasens Рік тому +9

      Exactly Lee completely missed the fact that he has a whole family of people who did not attend college that he is trying to support. And I really wish people would stop counting $80,000 in an outlay, New York, or San Francisco like it was $80,000 in San Antonio Texas. That $80,000 is like 50,000.

    • @rsimmons1980
      @rsimmons1980 Рік тому +4

      @@crecasens The other family members shouldn't be his priority. They should get a job too. If they might be young, children do not cost that much. If the parents aren't working, they can provide daycare. $80,000 is still a lot of money and well above the median. If he had a budget or if he delivered pizzas or did Uber, he could easily pay that off in 3 years. He probably wouldn't even need a second job. I live in a high cost city and could easily pay off $30,000 making $80,000.

    • @pirateparker
      @pirateparker Рік тому +2

      he gambled all his money on dodge coin!

    • @kesilame2590
      @kesilame2590 Рік тому

      ​@@fakename2956get these other family members to do something and help.

  • @eddiekulp1241
    @eddiekulp1241 Рік тому +7

    80 ,000 income . He can pay

    • @christinastaggs5882
      @christinastaggs5882 Рік тому +2

      Depending on where he lives that’s not necessarily true. I’m many cities 80k isn’t much.

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому

      @@christinastaggs5882 he can move. Either way - that is *his* debt. Taxpayers already pay for 13 years of free education.

  • @SamA-ho8uj
    @SamA-ho8uj Рік тому +8

    Means adults need to be responsible for their life choices. And the media needs to stop showing losers stories

    • @cruzcrstar
      @cruzcrstar Рік тому +6

      Means your outtta touch with the world

    • @djm2189
      @djm2189 Рік тому

      Agree. But why is it not a problem when people go bankrupt but student loans stay? How about the companies that got bailed out with our taxes but the C suite folks keep their huge bonuses and killer pay? Just super funny to me how many hated the thought of every day folks getting max 10k off their loans for an education that is basically needed nowadays, but love paying for companies, rich people, and idiots who buy actually useless things.

  • @robertmargadona8969
    @robertmargadona8969 Рік тому +10

    Let's get this straight everyone...right now they are training AI for free(AI isn't independent enough to take on debt) to use and save companies money on labor costs while leaving us real people who helped them in the first place, out in the "who cares about you" zone. When the internet came we were scared about our data being sold off and our privacy being intrude. Not only did our information find it's way to businesses but we have massive amounts of spam callers, business ID's that follow us around forever giving hints to companies about our interests and how to get the most out of us no matter if it's good for us or not. And now deja vu with AI. Same people, basically the same lie, plus people have lower trust and interest in people because of burnout. People everywhere just want to be happy but instead....dread.

  • @pegerickson
    @pegerickson Рік тому +6

    Why does the media try to make it abnormal to have to now pay back a student loan ????? I paid back my loan I currently work 12 hours a day I pay my mortgage I pay over $600 to Kaiser Insurance every month and car insurance. I had a car loan I paid it off. If you need more money you work more hours or you get a second job. People need to stop complaining for debt that they create. So sick of it. I can say this.... they have had 3 fricken years to save. OMG...

    • @lunarrobot9714
      @lunarrobot9714 Рік тому +5

      You shouldn't need two jobs to live off of. That's the problem. Living wages are not an unreasonable aak.

    • @zack1610
      @zack1610 11 місяців тому

      @@lunarrobot9714exactly isn’t the whole point of bettering yourself to have more financial freedom? These anti forgiveness people contradict themselves all the time 😂

    • @Shaolin91z
      @Shaolin91z 9 місяців тому

      Pay what you owe. Don't be a slacker

  • @mlecarre2057
    @mlecarre2057 Рік тому +10

    1.7 trillion dollars of student debt outstanding.The federal government is on the hook for a majority of that number.Taxpayers should not be loaning 19 year olds money….

    • @sublimetrance
      @sublimetrance Рік тому

      Going forward, who are you going to train for the technology sector? Who is going to be your next generation of engineers? Software developers? Nurses? Etc?
      People voted in politicians that shipped all of our manufacturing overseas...
      Now people are taking exception to people getting loans for education???
      And people increasingly wonder why we are looking like a third world country...
      You did it to yourselves America and you CONTINUE doing it to yourselves.

    • @electrodynamicorb6548
      @electrodynamicorb6548 Рік тому

      We shouldn’t be printing fake fiat currency but beggars can’t be choosers.

  • @BobbaFett312
    @BobbaFett312 Рік тому +1

    this is will be good for economy, we are fighting inflation. people will buy less, therefore helping to bring inflation down.

  • @Anthony-wm5of
    @Anthony-wm5of Рік тому +1

    Berkeley ain't cheap!😊

  • @gitchygitchyyaya
    @gitchygitchyyaya Рік тому +1

    No vacations or a second home? 😢

  • @marybowers6090
    @marybowers6090 Рік тому +1

    Well the first guy may be living in an area he can’t afford, also a community college or in state university is easily paid off every semester while working a couple of jobs. These students with high student loan debt went to school that they could not afford, meaning it was out of their budget. That is making poor financial choices. That is no one’s fault but their own. You don’t buy a Bentley if ur flipping burgers . That’s called life 101. Currently you can go to community college for 5 k a year and in state college university from 12-15 k. I earned two degrees and paid my bill each semester working 3 jobs. Had absolutely no help, no grants or loans. Walked out with two degrees and no debt. I also managed to split rent and utilizes since I was 19 while doing this . Oh and my wage 2.25 plus tips , my rent 550.00 for a 1 bedroom, not including utilities. Also had a car and insurance. Everything is relevant. It wasn’t any cheaper than it is now because we were making Pennie’s compared to what kids make now. My 15 year old made 8k working in the summer, so these college kids are mismanaging their money and want taxpayers to bail them out

  • @eddiekulp1241
    @eddiekulp1241 Рік тому +3

    Most wont or can't start paying back

    • @sublimetrance
      @sublimetrance Рік тому +1

      I have two science degrees. Physics and biomathematics. I haven't been able to get a decent paying job since COVID.
      I live in my car... A divorce last year wiped me out. I am effectively homeless.
      I would LOVE to pay back these loans. I simply cannot. Exploding prices and no decent job in this economy means little options except loan default.
      I am seriously looking at jobs overseas now!!!
      Look at the comments. The blame is put on people like me when the blame should be on our corrupt leaders. People that have student loans debt did NOT ruin the economy.
      Maybe if I was a banker people would have empathy????

  • @tarawhite4419
    @tarawhite4419 Рік тому +5

    I'm so glad I walked away from college 15 yrs ago

    • @ayeflippum
      @ayeflippum Рік тому

      *Tara White* I walked away, too, after I received my master's degree.

  • @sublimetrance
    @sublimetrance Рік тому +4

    I have two science degrees. Physics and biomathematics. I haven't been able to get a decent paying job since COVID. And now AI makes matters worse...
    I live in my car... A divorce last year wiped me out. I am effectively homeless.
    I would LOVE to pay back these loans. I simply cannot. Exploding prices and no decent job in this economy means little options except loan default.
    I am seriously looking at jobs overseas now!!!
    Look at the comments. The blame is put on people like me when the blame should be on our corrupt leaders. People that have student loans debt did NOT ruin the economy.
    Maybe if I was a banker people would have empathy????

    • @zack1610
      @zack1610 11 місяців тому +1

      It’s ridiculous. These people complain about the government helping fellow Americans but don’t bat an eye with our government sending money overseas. It makes no sense

    • @Shaolin91z
      @Shaolin91z 9 місяців тому

      Thanks Lord for your salvation 🤘

    • @Shaolin91z
      @Shaolin91z 9 місяців тому

      So glad I only owe $400. Credit card debt. That's it😂

  • @nickboyko1017
    @nickboyko1017 Рік тому

    Boo, $28k, cry me a river. Owed $80k, $62k in private. Paid over $20k. Life goes on. Deny yourself something you want to pay it.

  • @robtarqs4647
    @robtarqs4647 Рік тому +1

    lol asking a guy making 80 k you guys are not asking real people who make a lot less than that

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому +1

      LetKs not forget that he has extra mo ey coming in as well. Either his parents have saved for retirement, or they receive social security, or they are on welfare. But he won’t ever say that, and the media will never bring it up.

  • @MrTJP777
    @MrTJP777 Рік тому +7

    I'm not on earth to chase a dollar!
    Respect TIME, or regret the consequences of these actions...
    I'm sure that robberies and shootings wouldn't occur as much if we weren't consistently driven into a financial dependence.

  • @stevelavella8625
    @stevelavella8625 10 місяців тому

    Yeah... numbers aren't adding up. This guy is most not be very good with his money

  • @Theartofhappytravels
    @Theartofhappytravels 11 місяців тому

    I’m sorry but I don’t have sympathy for the guy in the video. I had the same amount of debt. Paid half of it back. Now focusing on completely paying it off by next year. I make much less than 80k. You have to pay back your loans before buying a house. Don’t get me wrong, it’s great that he wants to, but you took out the loan. Now you have to pay it back.

  • @x-men69-96
    @x-men69-96 Рік тому +11

    You borrow it. You pay it. Stop complaining.

    • @crecasens
      @crecasens Рік тому +9

      Again, I want you to have that same rigor with all of the wealthy politicians that borrowed money during the pandemic, and had all of those loans forgiven! There’s always empathy for the wealthy, but not for the middle class. Something very backwards about that!

    • @cruzcrstar
      @cruzcrstar Рік тому +7

      Right 😂 when did the banks pay back the Wall Street crash 08? Did I misss that year?

    • @djm2189
      @djm2189 Рік тому

      Agree. But why is it not a problem when people go bankrupt but student loans stay? How about the companies that got bailed out with our taxes but the C suite folks keep their huge bonuses and killer pay? Just super funny to me how many hated the thought of every day folks getting max 10k off their loans for an education that is basically needed nowadays, but love paying for companies, rich people, and idiots who buy actually useless things.

    • @midnightcaptain8344
      @midnightcaptain8344 Рік тому

      @@crecasensthe middle class are the ones that they want to pay for engineer and doctor’s degrees… 2 wrongs don’t make it right. They have to pay their own bills.

    • @crecasens
      @crecasens Рік тому

      @@midnightcaptain8344 - the middle class is the ones they want to pay for everything if you are rich, you don’t need student loans. If you are poor, you can get grants. But if you’re middle- or lower middle class, you’re stuck with loans! 🤣 in addition, every other western country has free education, because they actually want their populations to be intelligent. In the US it’s all about keeping you dumb so you can be manipulated.

  • @marybowers6090
    @marybowers6090 Рік тому

    Loan services are burdened? We’ll hire more people, he didn’t blink in eye to hire thousands of IRS agents

  • @Krranski
    @Krranski Рік тому +4

    This is bigger than is being it's made out to be here. It's going to be a huge burden on a ton of people and a reduction in local spending. It hurts everyone except for the already wealthy.

    • @sublimetrance
      @sublimetrance Рік тому +3

      I have two degrees. One in physics and the other in biomath. I have been unable to get a job in the tech sector since COVID...
      The only jobs I have been able to get have been low paying no skilled jobs.
      I currently live in my car. I cannot afford rent. Barely able to afford food. A nasty divorce wiped me out last year. My student loans will be $400 a month. I simply cannot afford it. They have jacked up the economy. Now AI is taking jobs.
      I got a passport last month as job prospects are looking better overseas. Especially in Asia. I started learning Mandarin 4 months ago.
      What have we come to when you have better prospects of economic prosperity OUTSIDE of the USA?????

    • @Krranski
      @Krranski Рік тому +2

      @@sublimetrance Same, brother. I have considered working abroad as well and just not paying the loans back. Skills like yours and mine (atmo science BS & MS, math minor) are seemingly more valuable other places these days, where people want to explore and create, and without such extreme pressure on immediate return. We're being pushed out. I could go on, but I am sure I have nothing new to say.

    • @johng1738
      @johng1738 Рік тому +1

      Pretty much, that being said it’s another tool against a recession.if we can make payments and not fall to a recession, then it becomes another tool that can be used to boost demand.

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому

      None of these people are reducing their spending. That’s the problem. If they did reduce their spending, they’d be able to pay off their debt. They don’t.

    • @katiejon17
      @katiejon17 Рік тому

      @@sublimetrance Bye! The US doesn’t need anymore self-made victims.

  • @louismatassa8489
    @louismatassa8489 7 місяців тому

    Student loan forgiveness? What's next credit card forgiveness car loan forgiveness mortgage loan forgiveness pay you're own bills 💸💵

  • @jamesvincent414
    @jamesvincent414 Рік тому +3

    Everyone is a victim when there to lazy to think and work. I’m a victim of working and paying taxes for every dirt bag that expects free college through loan forgiveness. This world isn’t easy….so either swim or drown. I figured it out without college and it starts with dedication…followed by mistakes…. Learning from your mistakes… and never giving up.

    • @CocoaPuff01
      @CocoaPuff01 9 місяців тому +2

      You struggled so everyone else should too 😅 you're miserable

    • @jamesvincent414
      @jamesvincent414 9 місяців тому

      @@CocoaPuff01 I’m miserable because I’ve been working for the last 35 years and Bidenomics is making me pay thousands of dollars more every year for the same things. I’ve had a hard time encouraging people to vote for Trump, but people need to learn from their mistakes and I need to suffer along with them because of that choice. Either way I’m pretty close to retiring and I’ve made great choices with my investments and wish I wouldn’t be judged by others by the nice things I have because they weren’t given to me by Uncle Sam , I had to work hard to achieve them.

  • @Rob-xv6bx
    @Rob-xv6bx Рік тому +1

    So where does the forgiven debt go ? Who is held liable ? It's a loan!

  • @thomasauslander3757
    @thomasauslander3757 Рік тому

    Free government money

  • @midnightcaptain8344
    @midnightcaptain8344 Рік тому +2

    Oh no! Less vacations, impulsive spending and Starbucks? How ever are they going to survive?? 😂

  • @Chandankumar-qw6hb
    @Chandankumar-qw6hb 9 місяців тому

    Financial Capital of world new york , london
    Silicon vally of world
    California, Guangdong,

  • @mrmustangman
    @mrmustangman Рік тому

    it will take him OVER 30 YEARS to pay that back....

  • @datthebigboss4532
    @datthebigboss4532 Рік тому

    Nothing. There I saved you time

  • @USERNAMEUA
    @USERNAMEUA Рік тому +2

    Yea I’m a college student and just got Covid and now y’all want me to start paying again smh how convenient

    • @marklewen9384
      @marklewen9384 Рік тому +6

      Yes, PAY YOUR DEBTS..

    • @Fiftycents50
      @Fiftycents50 Рік тому +4

      It’s called being an adult and accepting accountability!! Don’t borrow someone else’s money, regardless if it’s a lender or a friend, to spend on college/living expenses etc and sign a promissory note to pay them back once you graduate from college. The lender honored his end and loaned you the money for years and years!! Accept accountability!! Stop with the pity and “I’m too stupid” story!!! If you are smart enough to go/graduate from college…and you should be smart enough to Be Responsible and Accept Accountability!!

    • @lyraserpentine894
      @lyraserpentine894 Рік тому

      Yes, why don't the corporations that took the PPP money pay back that debt to the American people? Oh, the govt forgave that debt? But not student loans. Cool. Millennials will have political power by the end of this decade and we'll forgive all student debt then. So, we'll pay for now.@@marklewen9384

    • @marklewen9384
      @marklewen9384 Рік тому

      @@lyraserpentine894 yes, dont pay your debts FREELOADER. What a quality person you must be. WAH WAH WAH....i entered a mutual contract, knew the terms, AND NOW THE OTHER PARTY WANTS ME TO HONOR MY END OF THE DEAL!!# How dare they ?? ?

    • @djm2189
      @djm2189 Рік тому

      ​@@Fiftycents50Agree. But why is it not a problem when people go bankrupt but student loans stay? How about the companies that got bailed out with our taxes but the C suite folks keep their huge bonuses and killer pay? Just super funny to me how many hated the thought of every day folks getting max 10k off their loans for an education that is basically needed nowadays, but love paying for companies, rich people, and idiots who buy actually useless things.

  • @Lp78Ch
    @Lp78Ch Рік тому +4

    Your Harvard degree is worthless now

    • @crecasens
      @crecasens Рік тому

      If they went to Harvard, I’m sure they’re making decent money and can pay their student loans. Unless they are the legacy students who come from wealthy families and so they don’t have any student loans.