@@m.l.8537Did you ever listen to the story where the doctor tried to help but he was stopped because he was black. The man dies and his family sue the doctor but he wins but that basically helps the insurance company so they don't have they pay them. That's real life.
Really where the idea of hindsight being 20/20 comes in. You can always think about what you could’ve done better. When the moment comes though and decisions have to be made, all you can do is rely on your training/experience and make the best choice. The worst choice is indecision.
@@hanaomer4419 IDK, but I believe it is cuz black people are more genuine (I mean it like easygoing) in general, so they don't use formal conversations usually like not shortining the words, etc. and that's very cool I hate formal conversations TBH 😂😂
@@hanaomer4419I think it's funny you not only assume that ONLY black people speak this way but that ALL of them do. While ignoring that fact that it is also a SOUTHERN accent. I don't know, one got dang idjit that says lyin with the dag-gon G
This is an interesting strategy. Normally you wouldn't admit wrong doing here, but in doing so, he shows his precision and extreme attention for detail. He knew what he did, exactly, and had the knowledge to justify it.
So paragraph gurl here: Original comment not quite correct. So yeah it came off in that way, but the man on stand is autistic, so he didn't necessarily realise what he said made him look more innocent, he saw it as directly answering the question. Hope this helps! ❤❤ Shows called the Good Doctor, about an autistic surgical resident, highly recommend. ❤
Nah. You have to do it in America otherwise you don't get health costs paid for. When you sue someone, you are actually suing their insurance. It's not personal. Other more enlightened countries have universal health care, but America is strange.
Australia has good Samaritan laws to protect those trying to help others. As long as the intention was good and done without malice, people who help others are protected by law.
Yes. But it doesn't stop the other person you helped from suing you, the time and money you need to spend in court to defend yourself, and how you will be viewed in the eye of the public thinking "he must have done something to land up in court. Personally I would've minded my own business
As someone who has listened to witness testimony for 30 years, it's so refreshing to hear someone who is totally honest and doesn't try to cover their azz. It's rare, and it does make an impression on the jury.
As someone who has served on multiple juries...it definitely would make an impression on me. I even served on a DUI case where the person in question admitted on cop car camera (audio) that he did indeed partake of an "influencing substance"...but we were judging him on the criterias for the *law,* which was to determine if he was *actually influenced adversely* during that point in time. All of us determined unanimously that he was *not* Under The Influence. We were instructed that the failure to stop at a red light before turning right was not being contested and thus was not to be considered, so we dutifully ignored that part. We determined, based on the audio & video evidence presented, that he did everything that was under consideration as safely and responsibly as any one of us would have done. But because he also admitted on the audio that he had failed to stop at the red light, "...my bad," we took everything else into considerration with equal consideration for his honesty. And we admitted to ourselves during our deliberations that if he'd tried to lie or weasel his way out of the red light part, it would have colored the rest of our deliberations. But we didn't have to consider that. We didn't have to consider, "If he lied about X, did he also lie about Y?" It was absolutely refreshing.
Such honesty in the time of absolute nervousness. The calmness in his voice portrays actial kindness 😢 Edit: 8k likes😳😳😳 thank Y'all so much🥂 I'm famous mom🤗
As someone who works in EMS we see this all the time. It’s sad because I genuinely love helping people and it breaks my heart when they wanna sue for a small mistake or I accidentally hurt them while attempting to save their life.
I'm a Norwegian paramedic. I went to an American first responder course as part of my diving certification. Our instructor said at one point "This chapter is only for the exam, forget about the whole thing afterwards" - it was a chapter about consent of helping. In Europe, we default to people wanting help. Actually, you might end up in prison if you don't help anyone in an emergency, even if they say they don't want help. As a medical professionals I'm even obligated to disrespect someone's wish to die in certain circumstances (like they're perfectly healthy other than they're in need of immediate medical help)
Total honesty raised to the power of integrity, and delivered with courageous objectivity and unencumbered compassion. The world needs more people like him - even if he’s merely a fictional character.
@@ReesesPieces6764okay so I am from the US and I greatly dislike the man child as well, but it’s kind of a win for him to have people outside the US hate him, is it not? Like isn’t that kind of a positive thing for his policy and intentions with how to run the country (into the ground)?
I haven't seen the result of this episode, but if I was on that jury, hearing his first two answers (the fact that a doctor can admit his mistakes and has been obviously deeply thinking on it since the incident) would put me strongly on Dr. Murphy's side. Reflection and lack of ego are incredibly important and unfortunately rare in the medical world, speaking as a chronic patient with 8 illnesses (mostly degenerative) that require constant care and attention.
I 100% agree with everything you’ve said. And I can relate with the issues in the medical field both my wife and kids have some pretty serious medical issues that weren’t always handled with the seriousness we deserved until we pushed for it to be taken seriously to find out what was going on. Now we’ve moved and found better doctors but its always something we’ve remained wary of
Meh, this is just a movie. But what you are saying is that you are easy to emotionally manipulate. Its a jury like you why people lie and manipulate in the first place.
@@mcmarkmarkson7115 and its a jury like you that doesn’t think for themselves and question wether the system of justice is actually justified in all cases. Their reasoning for being swayed was sound and not at all based solely on emotion 1. The individual showed a willingness to admit their faults. 2. The individual showed that they cared deeply about the mistakes they made and have a desire to do better. Now unfortunately the justice system isn’t really focused on justice otherwise it’d be focused on rehabilitation above all else and deterrent as a strong second with punishment last. However as things are today its focused on punishment first, deterrent second, and rehabilitation last if at all. People like you would just get your rocks off in the herd mentality of stoning the witch not even bothering to question if they even float
No its the voters fault. You could have made very punishing laws for lying Stupid runs the court system, because stupid elects the corrupt in the first place who make the rules the court is forced to obey. Liars just abuse those rules, but they don't make them. Its the stupid voters that did.
YYEAHHHH YEAHHHHH BIGGGG BLOCKKKKK DANJEKELELELEYYY FROMM AFWIAKAKAKAKAKA LETSSSS GOO MYYY AFIWKAKAKAKAKAKAKA I CANT BREATHHHH I DDIDNDNTT DO NOOOTHANNN WONGGG BECAUSE YOUR RACISTTTTTTTTTT AFWIAKAKAKAKAKAKBANANANANANANANANA SLAVVVVEERRRRRRRR YEAHHHHHH STOLEN CAR STOLEN DRUGS STOLEN GUN STOLEN BANANAN EXPORTED RO AFWIKAAA IN A CONTAINER WHERE WE BELONG BECAUSE WE CANT BREATH WE DIDNTT DO NOTHAHNNN WONGG BECAUSE OUR BIGG BLOCKK DANKELLLEYY MAMAMMAMAAA TOLD US ON TVV WE WERE GOD CHILD IN SCHOOL
Integrity is SERIOUSLY absent in the US these days. From voting, the criminal behaviors of our elected officials, to clergy, to the teachers and parents abusing children and how courts ignore the well-being of the children.
I work in the ER, and since I don't regularly watch this show I had to read the synopsis to figure out what was going on. As usual, he committed malpractice here. Let's go through every mistake I can find. Firstly, applying the tourniquet at the brachial artery was not a mistake. You want to place the tourniquet as high up as you can to stop the blood from escaping. In the synopsis, it says that the hand had no capillary refill and was dead. That just isn't the case. Unless there was four to six hour time skip that wasn't mentioned, just because the hand doesn't have blood flow does NOT mean it is dead, which means it's not actually leaking toxins into the bloodstream, which was the whole reason for the amputation. Also, there wouldn't be any bloodflow to the hand regardless, because there's a tourniquet on the arm. That stops the blood from getting to the hand. That is the tourniquet's entire job. And even if it had been six hours since the accident and the hand was dead, you still wouldn't amputate in the field. The tourniquet is going to stop those toxins from going anywhere but your arm, so it wouldn't kill him. The patient's breathing became labored and developed a thready pulse because he was going into shock from blood loss, not because of toxins reaching his heart. That hand almost certainly could have been saved by an actual surgeon in the OR. Shaun should lose his license.
I have autism. My honesty astonishes people, I find lying to be repulsive, and I feel as though I’m completely deflated when I do. Yet, I feel like I lie quite often, for defensive reasons. However, I do not lie even to a measurable fraction as frequently as most everyone else does. I have to be really good at being honest, which is easy if you try. We are all imperfect, and nearly every mistake we make, every sin we indulge in, other people have been guilty of the same. You explain something without malice or ego, they usually empathize. Bad people don’t. Evil, hypocritical people can be spotted this way. So in the moments where it feels most comfortable to be truthful, honesty isn’t such a bad thing after all, because it helps to identify those who we can trust and those who should be excised from our lives.
I don't lie because it's a waste of time. Why try to hide the truth when the truth ALWAYS finds a way to come out? Besides, I can lie all I need to without actually saying anything factually untrue. It's in how something is phrased. You say it in a way that they draw a conclusion that is incorrect because it can be taken multiple different ways. And it's always fun when you call someone mentally handicapped and see them try and call you a liar in response, when you're not lying, since they ARE mentally handicapped from your perspective, since you're a genius.
@@JuliaJuanaRodriguez1708 Are you out of your mind? The other option was letting him die. He's a doctor, he's literally taken an oath to do no harm. I'm sure this must have escaped your notice, but death is a tad bit higher on the scale of harm than amputation.
@dreamystone And who are you to decide that? I know humans like to play god but it's not your life and it's not the doctors life, it's up to the patient to decide what is worse for the life. I can tell you I would rather die than life as a cripple. So yeah if any doctor would cut of my hand without my knowlege or consent I sure as hell would sue him
@@JuliaJuanaRodriguez1708 You can sue them all you want, but that's why they have a code of conduct and laws protecting them too. In an emergency situation, where it's up to the doctor to decide, they'll always chose to save someone's life. In a hospital setting, where your death isn't as imminent, yeah, you get to make a choice and they have to let you. Rage all you want against it, that's how it works. I'm sorry you value your life so little as to believe it's an equal exchange for an arm though. You could use some more self-worth is all.
@dreamystone I value my life alot, but I want to live a life worthy of living. Living as a cripple who isn't able to do normal activities, live without help, do a normal job etc. isn't worth it for me though. Honestly in that situation I would rather un*live the doctor who did that too me. Quite funny though, americans love to say they live in a free country, yet you don't even have a choice over your own life and body. Doctors really have a god complex if they do that to another person
As someone with autism I really like how they portrayed it in this show. I can see myself in the character. And yes if I were up on the stand I would be just as honest as him.
@@melissasweatt6925 well as the saying goes, if you've met one autistic person you've met one autistic person. I see some of myself in him, but many of us are non verbal or have extreme ticks. It's a difficult thing to represent such a diverse group.
Sadly, such laws protecting people that stop are typically not applicable to medical professionals. Such laws almost always apply to "good samaritans" - well meaning citizens. Physicians, nurses, even paramedics, who are off duty, in most states, can be sued for not stopping and can STILL be liable for any help rendered when they do stop.
The legal protection for first responders mostly applies to off duty medical professionals as well. The level of grossly negligent mistakes necessary to justify legal measures, border on the brink of intentionally inflicted harm.
@@stevenichols2938 that’s not true. I recently completed my EMT-B training and we learned about Good Samaritan laws. As long as you are doing everything within the scope of your training to help, you’re protected. So accidentally applying a tourniquet in the wrong spot would be protected, but deciding to try to perform a tracheotomy with no training in it would not be protected.
@@Khobotov In a criminal case, yes. Civil juries can be fooled into poor decisions and ridiculous penalties. Both states I worked in, "Samaritan" didn't cover off duty. I still believed in stopping, but we were coached not to.
@@mr.doctorcaptain1124 From a former paramedic instructor: First, congratulations on completing your EMT-B. Let me share some advice. Do not accuse someone who disagrees with you as "not being true." What you may not have learned is that the Samaritan laws vary widely state to state. Follow the training you received in your state, but I speak from experience - every state has its own laws. Make sure you learn the laws if you move to another state through reciprocity, or if you challenge the test in a new state. Best of luck to you; you're going to do great.
Freddie Highmore is such an incredible and underrated actor, I’ve loved his acting since Spiderwick Chronicles, I honestly thought he was a twin for so long😂
I love this man as an actor and because his character in the “good doctor” is played so well by him I can’t imagine watching this show with anyone else playing is character. I love and adore you Shaun Murphy 😊❤
This happened to my lifeguard/first aid class teacher. He broke a guy's ribs while performing CPR, bought him enough time for the ambulance to arrive. He saved his life and all that man could think about is that the lifeguard must have done something wrong and that he could get money out of it. Luckily the case was dismissed by the judge since in Canada first responders are protected in such cases unless they did something outrageously wrong or malicious or if they ignore a person in distress they could save without endangering themself (or something along those lines). After dismissing the case the judge added a little comment to the man and told him he should set his priorities straight instead of wasting his money on legal fees, hire a therapist.
If you do CPR and you do not break multiple ribs, you have done it incorrectly, that crap you see as CPR on shows is fake and worthless for obvious reasons. No one should be allowed to even file a suit in a case like that. The Samaritan should not be put in financial or emotional stress for trying to be a human and showing compassion.
Law suits against people stopping to help is why most people don't stop. Like the drowning girl who was rescued and resuscitated, who then tried to sue for "sexual assault" over cpr!
@darthfrancium1166 yes it did, her videos are still up about the whole incident. She was angry about " i didn't give consent" . She was unconscious and drowning had a man not saved her.
Don’t admit that in court. The plaintiffs lawyer will not care if you did the correct thing by doing wrong things even if you don’t think it affected anything. They will latch onto “yes. I did four things wrong” and bury you with it.
This is why the American Justice System is HEAVILY FLAWED even stating the truth or literal facts your words can be twisted and manipulated against you No wonder why the "American Dream" is no longer a dream An Absolute Joke of a Country
With his "expert" testimony he noted that his errors did not affect the outcome, thus preempting the prosecution's possible avenue of attack for his mistakes. It would come down to who the jury would believe - the good doctor or the prosecution's doctor. A calculated gamble.
I agree with You 100%. But some are so evil 😈 that they don't know honesty that's why they are evil. Honest is God's Law & Truth to One Person to the nexted. Amen.
Why do these clips rarely have the name of the movie or tv show and episode in the heading out hashtag? Many times I would like to go watch the whole show.
During my divorce, my ex-wife and her father filed restraining orders against me after failing to instigate a fist fight with me. This meant I had to give up my guns. Fortunately I had mailed all but one of them to my dad (who lives on the other side of the country) a couple of days prior. During a deposition, I lied to her lawyer about where my pistol was. Yes, I lied under oath. Considering how much lying that lawyer had already done to me, I felt no need to be honest with her. A little while later, I gave the gun to my pastor, who kept it until the order was lifted following the court date. In court, her lawyer was determined to prove that I was dangerous because she felt she could prove I still had the gun. Seven months had passed and I still hadn't killed anybody with it, mind you. I had told my lawyer about this, and he advised that I just admit it on the stand. So I did. I've never seen somebody's sails deflate so quickly. It turned out that was a HUGE part of their case, and me admitting it like that took out her entire plan for the first day. When the judge passed his verdict ("I see no reason to keep these restraining orders in place") he acknowledged that I had lied under oath, but I had also demonstrated the entire time that I was not a threat to my ex or her father. He also acknowledged that her father stalking me for two weeks, and both of them lying under oath about having seen all of my guns in the house despite me having the documents showing they'd been shipped two days prior demonstrated that they were more of a threat to me.
In reality, there would probable be nearly zero reason to amputate at the scene of the accident in the US (unless perhaps the hand is crashed and stuck so that the patient can’t be released). A Dr. would stabilize and bring him to the hospital
Also a tourniquet mid forearm does nothing to stop bleeding, it has to be at the braquial artery to work, so that was not a mistake. you dont even need to be a doctor to know that, just basic first aid trainning.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Honesty at its highest peak!
Durned right!!! Dr Murphy!
Only in movies
@@m.l.8537Did you ever listen to the story where the doctor tried to help but he was stopped because he was black. The man dies and his family sue the doctor but he wins but that basically helps the insurance company so they don't have they pay them. That's real life.
Wish people were like this in real life.
@@m.l.8537nah a lot of us autistics are like this
"Were any of those mistakes relevant?" "They were to me"
. . . Beautiful
he sounds massively gay
@@ComeinCiderbox☠️
Really where the idea of hindsight being 20/20 comes in. You can always think about what you could’ve done better. When the moment comes though and decisions have to be made, all you can do is rely on your training/experience and make the best choice. The worst choice is indecision.
@@ComeinCiderboxBruh he’s autistic… and he has a wife and kid
@@ComeinCiderbox i love how bigoted people think how gay people sound like. go out touch some grass.
The judge was like "boy what did you say"😂😂
🤣😂🤣😂 the judge was like "I know u lyin"😂 😂😂😂😂
Yeah, that was definitely a "mom" look she gave Shaun... 😂
Why do people online always give an accent to black people. “Boy” “lyin’” it’s so weird.
@@hanaomer4419 IDK, but I believe it is cuz black people are more genuine (I mean it like easygoing) in general, so they don't use formal conversations usually like not shortining the words, etc. and that's very cool I hate formal conversations TBH 😂😂
@@hanaomer4419I think it's funny you not only assume that ONLY black people speak this way but that ALL of them do.
While ignoring that fact that it is also a SOUTHERN accent. I don't know, one got dang idjit that says lyin with the dag-gon G
This is an interesting strategy. Normally you wouldn't admit wrong doing here, but in doing so, he shows his precision and extreme attention for detail. He knew what he did, exactly, and had the knowledge to justify it.
Exactly!
It's a movie, right?
@@AbbasBinYounasit’s a show called The Good Doctor
He didn’t do this out of strategy, he is autistic and doesn’t know how to filter out unnecessary details.
So paragraph gurl here:
Original comment not quite correct. So yeah it came off in that way, but the man on stand is autistic, so he didn't necessarily realise what he said made him look more innocent, he saw it as directly answering the question. Hope this helps! ❤❤
Shows called the Good Doctor, about an autistic surgical resident, highly recommend. ❤
"You didn't save my life, you ruined my death!"
I believe with some therapy, you’ll come to forgive me 😅
Fly home Buddy, I work alone.
The line from The incredibles 😂😂😂❤
I still got time...
😂😂😂😂😂
I personally believe that anyone who would sue someone for saving their life, is the lowest of the low.
Nah. You have to do it in America otherwise you don't get health costs paid for. When you sue someone, you are actually suing their insurance. It's not personal. Other more enlightened countries have universal health care, but America is strange.
@@ryanthompson591I agree. "Strange" is an understatement, my friend! 😂 Universal health care just seems like such common sense, yet here we are.
Ehhh, I mean in the case of a known DNR being ignored, I wouldn’t say it’s really low.
But like this would be a veryyyyyy specific case
@@ryanthompson591 So they should pay too much for insurance in their whole life, in some situations he may not get insured again
@leeminhyung167
That's an exceptional case and is obviously not what I was referring to.
Australia has good Samaritan laws to protect those trying to help others. As long as the intention was good and done without malice, people who help others are protected by law.
rare Australian lawmaker W
So does the United States.
Yes. But it doesn't stop the other person you helped from suing you, the time and money you need to spend in court to defend yourself, and how you will be viewed in the eye of the public thinking "he must have done something to land up in court.
Personally I would've minded my own business
Isn't intent hard to prove tho?
@@bbrucet3then why do so many people get sued in the US?
As someone who has listened to witness testimony for 30 years, it's so refreshing to hear someone who is totally honest and doesn't try to cover their azz. It's rare, and it does make an impression on the jury.
sadly he's 100% dishonest, since he's an actor and he didn't do any of those things xD
@@leotello864 but very well done.
@@leotello864 Almost like the comment is talking about the character in the show and not the actor playing the character
@@cyanmarinesome people just have to literally invent ways to be negative lol
As someone who has served on multiple juries...it definitely would make an impression on me. I even served on a DUI case where the person in question admitted on cop car camera (audio) that he did indeed partake of an "influencing substance"...but we were judging him on the criterias for the *law,* which was to determine if he was *actually influenced adversely* during that point in time.
All of us determined unanimously that he was *not* Under The Influence. We were instructed that the failure to stop at a red light before turning right was not being contested and thus was not to be considered, so we dutifully ignored that part. We determined, based on the audio & video evidence presented, that he did everything that was under consideration as safely and responsibly as any one of us would have done. But because he also admitted on the audio that he had failed to stop at the red light, "...my bad," we took everything else into considerration with equal consideration for his honesty.
And we admitted to ourselves during our deliberations that if he'd tried to lie or weasel his way out of the red light part, it would have colored the rest of our deliberations. But we didn't have to consider that. We didn't have to consider, "If he lied about X, did he also lie about Y?"
It was absolutely refreshing.
Stupendous actor since he was small child in Finding Neverland.
Loved him much in 'August Rush'
Freddie isn't the most famous or highly paid actor, but the quality of what he does is some of the best.
@BryantButler-i3j absolutely
August Rush beatiful movie too. He was born to be an actor ❤❤❤❤❤❤
I HAD NONIDEA!!!!! I loved that movie❤@@viktodauda1371
Such honesty in the time of absolute nervousness. The calmness in his voice portrays actial kindness 😢
Edit: 8k likes😳😳😳 thank Y'all so much🥂
I'm famous mom🤗
in this he plays an autistic doctor
he always sounds like that
You do know this is not real?
@@johnbowman1076 Doesn't matter.
only who actually trust God can be that fearless and honest
As someone who works in EMS we see this all the time. It’s sad because I genuinely love helping people and it breaks my heart when they wanna sue for a small mistake or I accidentally hurt them while attempting to save their life.
I’m sorry people can be so ungrateful, but know that you are appreciated that you must❤
Thank you for all the times you helped.
What if they don't want to be saved in the first place?
@@masonnelson6710the person helping is still covered under good Samaritan law, at least here in the US. Plus, for EMS it's their job to help.
I'm a Norwegian paramedic. I went to an American first responder course as part of my diving certification. Our instructor said at one point "This chapter is only for the exam, forget about the whole thing afterwards" - it was a chapter about consent of helping. In Europe, we default to people wanting help. Actually, you might end up in prison if you don't help anyone in an emergency, even if they say they don't want help. As a medical professionals I'm even obligated to disrespect someone's wish to die in certain circumstances (like they're perfectly healthy other than they're in need of immediate medical help)
the legal system doesnt work right when people are honest
Amen
Couldn't agree with you more!!!
The legal system might not be needed, were everyone honest.
It’s not a legal proceeding, I don’t think. I believe he was sued. Not really the same thing
@@dexlovesgames_dlg its in a court, a civil court.
Total honesty raised to the power of integrity, and delivered with courageous objectivity and unencumbered compassion. The world needs more people like him - even if he’s merely a fictional character.
ALWAYS BE HONEST. A lie will ALWAYS catch up with you
Just ask Donald Trump.
@@SeytomAGREEEEE I’m not even from the US but I fucking hate him with my whole soul
-And lies will be his answer.
Guaranteed!
@@ReesesPieces6764okay so I am from the US and I greatly dislike the man child as well, but it’s kind of a win for him to have people outside the US hate him, is it not? Like isn’t that kind of a positive thing for his policy and intentions with how to run the country (into the ground)?
@@Ruska_o7 Trump is one of the worst things that’s ever happened to the US.
Man of Truth ❤
I haven't seen the result of this episode, but if I was on that jury, hearing his first two answers (the fact that a doctor can admit his mistakes and has been obviously deeply thinking on it since the incident) would put me strongly on Dr. Murphy's side. Reflection and lack of ego are incredibly important and unfortunately rare in the medical world, speaking as a chronic patient with 8 illnesses (mostly degenerative) that require constant care and attention.
That's why you'll never sit on a jury.
They filter out good people like you.
I 100% agree with everything you’ve said. And I can relate with the issues in the medical field both my wife and kids have some pretty serious medical issues that weren’t always handled with the seriousness we deserved until we pushed for it to be taken seriously to find out what was going on. Now we’ve moved and found better doctors but its always something we’ve remained wary of
Meh, this is just a movie. But what you are saying is that you are easy to emotionally manipulate.
Its a jury like you why people lie and manipulate in the first place.
@@mcmarkmarkson7115 and its a jury like you that doesn’t think for themselves and question wether the system of justice is actually justified in all cases.
Their reasoning for being swayed was sound and not at all based solely on emotion
1. The individual showed a willingness to admit their faults.
2. The individual showed that they cared deeply about the mistakes they made and have a desire to do better.
Now unfortunately the justice system isn’t really focused on justice otherwise it’d be focused on rehabilitation above all else and deterrent as a strong second with punishment last. However as things are today its focused on punishment first, deterrent second, and rehabilitation last if at all.
People like you would just get your rocks off in the herd mentality of stoning the witch not even bothering to question if they even float
You are not fit to be a judge then
Love you Shaun.. Such an honest person..
What's the name of the movie pls?
@ not a movie, it’s a show on Netflix.. The Good Doctor..
This episode was so amazing this whole storyline actually id love a series about the lawyer and her ocd
Can you give me the episode and the season please?
I also searched about that lawyer and if she has any shows about her
They wanted a spin off of her but I think it didn't happen yet, I am not sure
The spinoff was canceled due to covid
@@mohandkaml7583 The Good Doctor Season 6 Ep 16: The Good Lawyer (2023)
It's the boldness and confidence in his Honesty for me. Honesty gives peace
This is what you call. INTEGRITY.
Thank you Shawn❤
It is VERY SAD, that INTEGRITY in a court room RARELY equals JUSTICE. I weep that LIARS run our court system.
No its the voters fault. You could have made very punishing laws for lying
Stupid runs the court system, because stupid elects the corrupt in the first place who make the rules the court is forced to obey.
Liars just abuse those rules, but they don't make them. Its the stupid voters that did.
YYEAHHHH YEAHHHHH BIGGGG BLOCKKKKK DANJEKELELELEYYY FROMM AFWIAKAKAKAKAKA LETSSSS GOO MYYY AFIWKAKAKAKAKAKAKA I CANT BREATHHHH I DDIDNDNTT DO NOOOTHANNN WONGGG BECAUSE YOUR RACISTTTTTTTTTT AFWIAKAKAKAKAKAKBANANANANANANANANA SLAVVVVEERRRRRRRR YEAHHHHHH STOLEN CAR STOLEN DRUGS STOLEN GUN STOLEN BANANAN EXPORTED RO AFWIKAAA IN A CONTAINER WHERE WE BELONG BECAUSE WE CANT BREATH WE DIDNTT DO NOTHAHNNN WONGG BECAUSE OUR BIGG BLOCKK DANKELLLEYY MAMAMMAMAAA TOLD US ON TVV WE WERE GOD CHILD IN SCHOOL
calm down its a tv show, what are you talking about?
Integrity is SERIOUSLY absent in the US these days. From voting, the criminal behaviors of our elected officials, to clergy, to the teachers and parents abusing children and how courts ignore the well-being of the children.
@@omegaisdabomb real life! It's what TV is based on!
I work in the ER, and since I don't regularly watch this show I had to read the synopsis to figure out what was going on.
As usual, he committed malpractice here. Let's go through every mistake I can find.
Firstly, applying the tourniquet at the brachial artery was not a mistake. You want to place the tourniquet as high up as you can to stop the blood from escaping.
In the synopsis, it says that the hand had no capillary refill and was dead. That just isn't the case. Unless there was four to six hour time skip that wasn't mentioned, just because the hand doesn't have blood flow does NOT mean it is dead, which means it's not actually leaking toxins into the bloodstream, which was the whole reason for the amputation.
Also, there wouldn't be any bloodflow to the hand regardless, because there's a tourniquet on the arm. That stops the blood from getting to the hand. That is the tourniquet's entire job.
And even if it had been six hours since the accident and the hand was dead, you still wouldn't amputate in the field. The tourniquet is going to stop those toxins from going anywhere but your arm, so it wouldn't kill him.
The patient's breathing became labored and developed a thready pulse because he was going into shock from blood loss, not because of toxins reaching his heart.
That hand almost certainly could have been saved by an actual surgeon in the OR. Shaun should lose his license.
lmao, but he's a sturgeon
I guess we can only hope justice will be served...
this is one of the ten best medical shows ever aired. he is a brilliant actor
Man, aputating the word aputate is next level poetry
The reaction of the court room when they all realize the witness is an honest man, like they never could of imagined.
I have autism. My honesty astonishes people, I find lying to be repulsive, and I feel as though I’m completely deflated when I do. Yet, I feel like I lie quite often, for defensive reasons. However, I do not lie even to a measurable fraction as frequently as most everyone else does. I have to be really good at being honest, which is easy if you try. We are all imperfect, and nearly every mistake we make, every sin we indulge in, other people have been guilty of the same. You explain something without malice or ego, they usually empathize. Bad people don’t. Evil, hypocritical people can be spotted this way. So in the moments where it feels most comfortable to be truthful, honesty isn’t such a bad thing after all, because it helps to identify those who we can trust and those who should be excised from our lives.
Beautifully articulated 🥲
I’m also autistic and I relate very much to your comment.
Me too!!! It feels like it burns my soul, like it hurts me more than the other person.
None of you are autistic
I don't lie because it's a waste of time. Why try to hide the truth when the truth ALWAYS finds a way to come out? Besides, I can lie all I need to without actually saying anything factually untrue. It's in how something is phrased. You say it in a way that they draw a conclusion that is incorrect because it can be taken multiple different ways. And it's always fun when you call someone mentally handicapped and see them try and call you a liar in response, when you're not lying, since they ARE mentally handicapped from your perspective, since you're a genius.
He should be protected by Good Samaritan Law, period!
He cut someones hand off, forcing him to live as a disabled person so
@@JuliaJuanaRodriguez1708 Are you out of your mind? The other option was letting him die. He's a doctor, he's literally taken an oath to do no harm. I'm sure this must have escaped your notice, but death is a tad bit higher on the scale of harm than amputation.
@dreamystone And who are you to decide that? I know humans like to play god but it's not your life and it's not the doctors life, it's up to the patient to decide what is worse for the life. I can tell you I would rather die than life as a cripple. So yeah if any doctor would cut of my hand without my knowlege or consent I sure as hell would sue him
@@JuliaJuanaRodriguez1708 You can sue them all you want, but that's why they have a code of conduct and laws protecting them too. In an emergency situation, where it's up to the doctor to decide, they'll always chose to save someone's life. In a hospital setting, where your death isn't as imminent, yeah, you get to make a choice and they have to let you. Rage all you want against it, that's how it works.
I'm sorry you value your life so little as to believe it's an equal exchange for an arm though. You could use some more self-worth is all.
@dreamystone I value my life alot, but I want to live a life worthy of living. Living as a cripple who isn't able to do normal activities, live without help, do a normal job etc. isn't worth it for me though. Honestly in that situation I would rather un*live the doctor who did that too me. Quite funny though, americans love to say they live in a free country, yet you don't even have a choice over your own life and body. Doctors really have a god complex if they do that to another person
His confidence is so brilliant. I know he would do it again and again. He's so clever
As someone with autism I really like how they portrayed it in this show. I can see myself in the character. And yes if I were up on the stand I would be just as honest as him.
My son has a form of autism as well and he is brutally honest always. It’s great for me being his mom! ❤
I have 2 children who are autistic and I see them both in this character. Idk why or how people knock him or his portrayal of it
@@melissasweatt6925 well as the saying goes, if you've met one autistic person you've met one autistic person. I see some of myself in him, but many of us are non verbal or have extreme ticks. It's a difficult thing to represent such a diverse group.
Agree with the honesty bit. I've always found it particularly difficult to lie. So I just give the blunt truth . I'm autistic as well 🎉
♥️🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾👍🏿
"I would stop, I would help, and I would amputate" WHY DID THAT MAKE ME CRY?
I just love him and enjoy his character so much ❤❤
This dude was born for this role....damn it!
Too good.....this ain't human
The fact that someone could sue someone else who saved their life is just… mind boggling 😂
Thank you for sharing, very inspiring ,thank you
Excellent actor portraying courageous honesty and care. We need to follow the model.
Shawn and Matthew in The Chosen are extraordinary actors... I just can't believe how someone can be this consistently awesome
I'm glad that where I live you can only be sued for ignoring a person in need of help.
Everything else you do to help can't be used against you.
Sadly, such laws protecting people that stop are typically not applicable to medical professionals. Such laws almost always apply to "good samaritans" - well meaning citizens. Physicians, nurses, even paramedics, who are off duty, in most states, can be sued for not stopping and can STILL be liable for any help rendered when they do stop.
The legal protection for first responders mostly applies to off duty medical professionals as well. The level of grossly negligent mistakes necessary to justify legal measures, border on the brink of intentionally inflicted harm.
@@stevenichols2938 that’s not true. I recently completed my EMT-B training and we learned about Good Samaritan laws.
As long as you are doing everything within the scope of your training to help, you’re protected. So accidentally applying a tourniquet in the wrong spot would be protected, but deciding to try to perform a tracheotomy with no training in it would not be protected.
@@Khobotov In a criminal case, yes. Civil juries can be fooled into poor decisions and ridiculous penalties. Both states I worked in, "Samaritan" didn't cover off duty. I still believed in stopping, but we were coached not to.
@@mr.doctorcaptain1124 From a former paramedic instructor: First, congratulations on completing your EMT-B. Let me share some advice. Do not accuse someone who disagrees with you as "not being true." What you may not have learned is that the Samaritan laws vary widely state to state. Follow the training you received in your state, but I speak from experience - every state has its own laws. Make sure you learn the laws if you move to another state through reciprocity, or if you challenge the test in a new state. Best of luck to you; you're going to do great.
Dr. Phil: "What's wrong!?"
Shaq: "Wrong leg."
Returning evil for good is a new level of evil and the opposite of love
Freddie Highmore is an outstanding actor 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
I loved this show. He's one of the best actors I've ever seen. ❤❤❤
This kid is a tremendous actor.
He is staggeringly great in this show.
Freddie Highmore is such an incredible and underrated actor, I’ve loved his acting since Spiderwick Chronicles, I honestly thought he was a twin for so long😂
I love this man as an actor and because his character in the “good doctor” is played so well by him I can’t imagine watching this show with anyone else playing is character. I love and adore you Shaun Murphy 😊❤
I’m literally shaking- I’ve seen about a thousand of these clips at a time but never was as invested as in this one.
The best actor to play the character hands down!!❤
Bro is to honest for the world 😂😂😂😂
lol even the Jusge was like “you’re not supposed to say that”
I really miss this show. The acting was top notch.
This happened to my lifeguard/first aid class teacher. He broke a guy's ribs while performing CPR, bought him enough time for the ambulance to arrive. He saved his life and all that man could think about is that the lifeguard must have done something wrong and that he could get money out of it.
Luckily the case was dismissed by the judge since in Canada first responders are protected in such cases unless they did something outrageously wrong or malicious or if they ignore a person in distress they could save without endangering themself (or something along those lines). After dismissing the case the judge added a little comment to the man and told him he should set his priorities straight instead of wasting his money on legal fees, hire a therapist.
Well you know what they say - If you aren't breaking ribs, you aren't doing CPR right.
If you do CPR and you do not break multiple ribs, you have done it incorrectly, that crap you see as CPR on shows is fake and worthless for obvious reasons.
No one should be allowed to even file a suit in a case like that. The Samaritan should not be put in financial or emotional stress for trying to be a human and showing compassion.
Here in Germany, this case wouldnt even made it to court, maybe not even up to a judge
TRUTH is the BEST!
The judge was like, Boy you crazy!!
"Were any of those mistakes relevant?" "They were to me"
Judge: Okay. Guilty as charged. Bailiff, please arrest him.
To sue those who save your life. Geez lowest of them all
I still can't believe they were trialing Shawn for being the Bay Harbor Amputator
Beautiful attorney
such a powerful episode! loved the attorney and the shift of relationship between her and the boss.
He played this character so well. So proud of him and I wish more people were honest like him as doctors
Law suits against people stopping to help is why most people don't stop. Like the drowning girl who was rescued and resuscitated, who then tried to sue for "sexual assault" over cpr!
This never happened
@darthfrancium1166 this has in fact has happened. One guy was sued after preforming cpr on a car crash victim.
@darthfrancium1166 yes it did, her videos are still up about the whole incident. She was angry about " i didn't give consent" . She was unconscious and drowning had a man not saved her.
She sued him for apparently "groping" her, while getting her out of the water. Send the ungrateful woman back in the water.
Things that never happened for 1000 Alex
I just love Shaun...!❤ And i love the Good Doctor series...! 😊
Could you imagine if him and Dr House worked in the same hospital?
This level of honesty is very hard to find......
Well... this clip cutting where and how it does is either ingeniously meta or just accidentally hilarious 😂
He's looking at the Dr like the trial had to be done, not that he's angry at the amputation 😅
This young man,saved that man's life as a doctor 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
This fellow would be an absolute pain to socialise with. His integrity would be frightening!
That says far more about you than him, tbh.
This dude is crazy good
It's always a hoot coming across these randomly
So fucking honest knows what he did was wrong and yet did it to save another person’s life honestly a great guy
Most of the lawyers would interrupt you after the first sentence if you say that IRL. 😅
So beautiful. His truth.
Don’t admit that in court. The plaintiffs lawyer will not care if you did the correct thing by doing wrong things even if you don’t think it affected anything. They will latch onto “yes. I did four things wrong” and bury you with it.
This is why the American Justice System is HEAVILY FLAWED even stating the truth or literal facts your words can be twisted and manipulated against you No wonder why the "American Dream" is no longer a dream An Absolute Joke of a Country
Only in the USA.
With his "expert" testimony he noted that his errors did not affect the outcome, thus preempting the prosecution's possible avenue of attack for his mistakes. It would come down to who the jury would believe - the good doctor or the prosecution's doctor. A calculated gamble.
Brilliant acting, very well done❤
"if I had to do it all over again" such Joel like lines to say
They were to me. So powerful
the good doctor, it's a series
Always great acting!
Love his character. He is brilliant
His lawyer looked in panic like "What are you doing?"
"I would stop, I would help and I. AM. A SURGEON!."
Love honesty
I agree with You 100%.
But some are so evil 😈 that they don't know honesty that's why they are evil.
Honest is God's Law & Truth to One Person to the nexted.
Amen.
It's The Good Doctor. A series.
The old adage applies; No good deed goes unpunished.
Very true! I stopped doing nice things for people because of it.
And i would ampu........ Ending got me idk why 🤣 🤣 🤣
Thats where a tourniquet goes.
I enjoyed this episode so much. If also felt like a pilot for another great show.
which episode is this?
@ThandsTV Season 6, Episode 16, titled "The Good Lawyer"
I need to watch this program, have not seen it before.
But I am sure glad to see a clip like this , with the name of the program
Good doctor
Do it! I watched every episode. I cried when it ended 😢❤
His calm british accent came out in the I don’t know. Good scene.
And that's ok bc I know an autist that occasionally picks up an accent that sounds kinda British
i love shaun. "were any of those mistakes relevant?" "they were to me."
This series always makes me cry!
I’m sad that she didn’t get to get her own show. Because it would’ve been a hit just like the good doctor.
If you’re talking about the lawyer, she had her own show but as Nancy Drew!
Why do these clips rarely have the name of the movie or tv show and episode in the heading out hashtag? Many times I would like to go watch the whole show.
The Good Doctor
This is from Season 6 Ep 16 of 'The Good Doctor'.
Copyright.
Holy mankey that’s Houses Boy
Ikr
Good Samaritan laws protected the doctor here
Dude cant lie 🤣😂
During my divorce, my ex-wife and her father filed restraining orders against me after failing to instigate a fist fight with me. This meant I had to give up my guns. Fortunately I had mailed all but one of them to my dad (who lives on the other side of the country) a couple of days prior.
During a deposition, I lied to her lawyer about where my pistol was. Yes, I lied under oath. Considering how much lying that lawyer had already done to me, I felt no need to be honest with her. A little while later, I gave the gun to my pastor, who kept it until the order was lifted following the court date.
In court, her lawyer was determined to prove that I was dangerous because she felt she could prove I still had the gun. Seven months had passed and I still hadn't killed anybody with it, mind you. I had told my lawyer about this, and he advised that I just admit it on the stand. So I did.
I've never seen somebody's sails deflate so quickly. It turned out that was a HUGE part of their case, and me admitting it like that took out her entire plan for the first day. When the judge passed his verdict ("I see no reason to keep these restraining orders in place") he acknowledged that I had lied under oath, but I had also demonstrated the entire time that I was not a threat to my ex or her father.
He also acknowledged that her father stalking me for two weeks, and both of them lying under oath about having seen all of my guns in the house despite me having the documents showing they'd been shipped two days prior demonstrated that they were more of a threat to me.
The talent this man has I'll watch whatever he makes. The Good Dr, and bates motel are my favorites ❤❤❤
In reality, there would probable be nearly zero reason to amputate at the scene of the accident in the US (unless perhaps the hand is crashed and stuck so that the patient can’t be released). A Dr. would stabilize and bring him to the hospital
Also a tourniquet mid forearm does nothing to stop bleeding, it has to be at the braquial artery to work, so that was not a mistake. you dont even need to be a doctor to know that, just basic first aid trainning.
i never watched the episode... but what if there was severe infection? or gangrene?
Man saves your life and that's how he repays him
Love that actor. Such a pro at his roles.
Thats August Rush 😊❤
OMG it issssssss❤❤❤❤❤