Thank you for helping me better understand The Fall of the House of Usher. I read the short story for class and I quite didn't understand the plot. Also, I didn't know this story had supernatural ties.
Summary and additional analysis : Spoiler alert! The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book: Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him . He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one. Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman. And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc. In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
As a student from Taiwan, though I don't have English literature in my school, I enjoy reading such novels. This summary video helped me a lot on giving me background knowledge of the book, which makes my reading much easier. Thank you.
I wish the incestous affair of the Usher lineage, hinted at earlier in the story (“the entire family lay in the direct line of descent”)was also discussed, but I realize this was meant to be a more wholesome take on the story.
thank you sooo much for this video ! i'm french and i have a test tomorrow about the fall of the house of usher and i was totally lost ! now i think i'm ready thanks to your video. just one advice : please put english subtitles and maybe other languages like french...
Thank you so much this gave me a deeper understanding of this story I felt screwed since I had to make e presentation about this book and I didn't really understand the event in the story but this video cleared it up for me!
hello, here's some late night analysis to add: This story we’re invited to read is a story of a point of view infected by the madness of the master of the place, which is Roderick User, from the start the point of view is totally dart, and the narrator wants to change it, right from the 1st paragraph in L20 “It was possible, I reflected, that a mere different arrangement of the particulars of the scene, of the details of the picture, would be sufficient to modify, or perhaps to annihilate its capacity for sorrowful impression” = what affects him in his relation with reality is his interpretation to reality, reality simply is, the way he interprets the words his choosing , in fact his talking about reality as a scene L8 he interprets the scene as a picture
Summary and additional analysis : Spoiler alert! The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book: Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him . He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one. Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman. And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc. In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
thank you for the video//i would love to read it myself//but due to sight problems,,have alot of wotk for uni in front of cumputer or and tons of essays to write i can't read it fully//so you and your video -lifesaver for me)
Thank you for the wonderful review and commentary of this fantastic story. It is by far my favorite writing of Edgar Allan Poe. Your insights are wonderful and made the story even more enjoyable. However, and is always a however, the story clearly states that the unnamed narrator arrives on horseback and you graphic artist keeps showing him in a carriage. Not sure if the artist extra read the story. In any depth. Thanks for posting this.
Summary and additional analysis : Spoiler alert! The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book: Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him . He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one. Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman. And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc. In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
your analysis is super interesting! but where in the story does it hint at Roderick being possessive over his sister and that she wanted to marry someone else? @@quirogatnonerrat3214
Unfortunately, the story seemed ridiculous to me. The characters were not well developed with some of them just dropped there just out of convenience and then completely forgotten, including the physician. The elements of fear at this time and age just seem cheesy and the overly descriptive prose doesn't help. It was a slow and rigorous read with the collapse of the house of Usher feeling like a relief rather than a shock.
Actually, everything conveyed was carefully thought out and planned by Poe himself. Your points are understandable, and i see where your coming from, however, those could easily be justified by the sheer fact that they were most likely intentional. Por wanted to leave readers edged, just as you are. Anyone reading this, feel free to reply or comment your own thoughts, these were just mine
@@フアン-f6e Well said. If the commentor' was left feeling a sense of relief he (or she) may have taken more from the tale than they are aware, if at the surface level. I think one should also consider taking themselves back to the simpler times (?) of Poe's whilst reading his... tales. Lets face it, they have been received well and withstood the test of time with many still enjoying reading his works. I know I do.
TheOmnipresent12 yep. the fall of thr house of usher is brilliant and i see no fault or flaw in it, everything in poe’s stories has came about from a great effort and expression to make readers feel a specific way after reading it
@@フアン-f6e Thank you. You might want to have a look/listen to Alan Parsons 'Tales Of Mystery & Imagination' (music). Which is predominantly based on some of Poe's writings. It's a bit perhaps like his (Poe's) stories, one must give it a chance before deciding on their level of enjoyment... Here's a link: ua-cam.com/video/y7htAlPqwBI/v-deo.html
Summary and additional analysis : Spoiler alert! The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book: Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him . He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one. Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman. And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc. In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
Summary and additional analysis : Spoiler alert! The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book: Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him . He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one. Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman. And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc. In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
I wish my teachers explained it like this.
Sylvia Davila yupp that’s why I’m here
same
Me to kid
Me too
L
As a French student, I am working on this short story in my English litteratury class. This helped me a lot ! Thanks !
Me Too (btw it's "literature*)
I also need it, but I did not understand very well. can you help me ?
@@renadnabe8629 hey are you good? Did you understand it?
Ah tu parles l'anglais, moi aussi(je connais 4 langages)
Why do all teachers call it by "Short Story" tho?
Thank you for helping me better understand The Fall of the House of Usher. I read the short story for class and I quite didn't understand the plot. Also, I didn't know this story had supernatural ties.
Ue! Short Story is the name. Lol
Summary and additional analysis :
Spoiler alert!
The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book:
Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him
.
He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one.
Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman.
And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc.
In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
I got the incest hint at the mention of "will be the last of his line". LOL Roderick is guilty of something.
Thanks a lot, this came just in time for my literature course tomorrow ^^
First
Wow! Thank you so much! I really needed a video to summarize and explain the story. You did just that. Once again, Thank you! What an amazing video.
As a student from Taiwan, though I don't have English literature in my school, I enjoy reading such novels. This summary video helped me a lot on giving me background knowledge of the book, which makes my reading much easier. Thank you.
Well done, good analysis. A short glimpse at the physicians reaction to the narrator´s visit would have been a nice bonus...
A great analysis ! It made me forget that i'm preparing for the lit exam and just enjoy the story 👌🏻
It seems to me that mental illness was common among gothic characters. Thank you for your video! Well written and insightful
I wish the incestous affair of the Usher lineage, hinted at earlier in the story (“the entire family lay in the direct line of descent”)was also discussed, but I realize this was meant to be a more wholesome take on the story.
I was wondering if the twins had an intimate relationship and if that was the reason the house was haunted. Thank you for saying this!
thank you sooo much for this video ! i'm french and i have a test tomorrow about the fall of the house of usher and i was totally lost ! now i think i'm ready thanks to your video.
just one advice : please put english subtitles and maybe other languages like french...
ça c'est une très très bonne idée
Love you Russell!!!❤❤voice,tone, hand movements...❤
Thank you so much this gave me a deeper understanding of this story I felt screwed since I had to make e presentation about this book and I didn't really understand the event in the story but this video cleared it up for me!
hello, here's some late night analysis to add:
This story we’re invited to read is a story of a point of view infected by the madness of the master of the place, which is Roderick User, from the start the point of view is totally dart, and the narrator wants to change it, right from the 1st paragraph in L20 “It was possible, I reflected, that a mere different arrangement of the particulars of the scene, of the details of the picture, would be sufficient to modify, or perhaps to annihilate its capacity for sorrowful impression” = what affects him in his relation with reality is his interpretation to reality, reality simply is, the way he interprets the words his choosing , in fact his talking about reality as a scene L8 he interprets the scene as a picture
im working on an essay due 2 months ago on this story, thanks for the refresher
So basically Poe writ Monster House. Nice
Summary and additional analysis :
Spoiler alert!
The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book:
Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him
.
He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one.
Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman.
And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc.
In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
I can’t wait to see Flanagan’s version of it
Whatd you think?
Thanks you Sir, for this great contribution for us...
Omg u legit explained it to me so good tysmm
thanks i don't have to read the book all my class will know this video
thank you so much, you made it way easier to analyse and understand !!!!
Thank you for this information in this It helped me understand this short story
Thank you so much! This is a huge help for my American Literature college course. God bless you!
Thank you so much for this!
i have a test on the fall of the house of usher and this definitely helpped ! thank you so much!!
thank you for this!the explanation is clear and I can understand it better
great informative video, thank you!
thank you for the video//i would love to read it myself//but due to sight problems,,have alot of wotk for uni in front of cumputer or and tons of essays to write i can't read it fully//so you and your video -lifesaver for me)
This is beyond best...
We saw this video in our English Class!
This is COMPLETE
Thank you for the wonderful review and commentary of this fantastic story. It is by far my favorite writing of Edgar Allan Poe. Your insights are wonderful and made the story even more enjoyable. However, and is always a however, the story clearly states that the unnamed narrator arrives on horseback and you graphic artist keeps showing him in a carriage. Not sure if the artist extra read the story. In any depth. Thanks for posting this.
Thanks man really do appreciate it
Literal course hero
great video
Thank you so much, this helped a lot.
POV you are cramming for a test
\
more like an essay lmao
@@danceproject7849 samee
@@evabrummer1145 bruh you're literally from my school i- i see u on mrs r (not gonna say the whole name cuz privacy lol) docs all the time😭😭😭😭😭
@@danceproject7849 lmaooo, I never close out of my tabs.
very cool video. I have a further understanding of this novel!!!
Should have watched this before my test
Thank you so much.
Awesome, thank you!!!
This was an amazing analysis!!!
Tremendous explanation..👌👌👍👍
Whose the one guy who dislked the video??!
Optimistic Onon madman
A bad teacher probably lol.
A grade 10 student
a troll
Roderick Usher, because he was disturbed by the voice of the video.
When you say that before her death, Madeline worried about being buried alive, I was wondering where that is mentioned in the story?
same I'm like how did you know that she feared that lol
Summary and additional analysis :
Spoiler alert!
The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book:
Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him
.
He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one.
Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman.
And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc.
In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
your analysis is super interesting! but where in the story does it hint at Roderick being possessive over his sister and that she wanted to marry someone else? @@quirogatnonerrat3214
Helpful
This book made zero sense Buh when I listened to your video it made perfect sense,thank yu
Thankyou so much ...🤗😍
Thank you
what about the physician?
thankssss!!!!
No doubt, Stephen King's 'The Shining' was partly inspired by this gothic classic.
i love this guy!!!
can you do house taken over by julio cortazar?
Get the book here --> amzn.to/2OCZEyY affiliate
Thank u I really misunderstood the plot
beast thanks dude
Awesome
thanks a lot
Que Dieu te remercie, tu ma bien aidé frere
Symbols 6:05
Thank's 💜
Hi there, can u make a video on " The masque of red death"...If yes it will be sooo great!
Please try if y'all can make it (this is a request video)
3:23 the first key character is the house.
outstanding
hello from france
Unfortunately, the story seemed ridiculous to me. The characters were not well developed with some of them just dropped there just out of convenience and then completely forgotten, including the physician. The elements of fear at this time and age just seem cheesy and the overly descriptive prose doesn't help. It was a slow and rigorous read with the collapse of the house of Usher feeling like a relief rather than a shock.
Actually, everything conveyed was carefully thought out and planned by Poe himself. Your points are understandable, and i see where your coming from, however, those could easily be justified by the sheer fact that they were most likely intentional. Por wanted to leave readers edged, just as you are. Anyone reading this, feel free to reply or comment your own thoughts, these were just mine
@@フアン-f6e I'm well aware that it was done on purpose but, instead of suspense, it mostly ended up being frustrating...
@@フアン-f6e Well said. If the commentor' was left feeling a sense of relief he (or she) may have taken more from the tale than they are aware, if at the surface level. I think one should also consider taking themselves back to the simpler times (?) of Poe's whilst reading his... tales. Lets face it, they have been received well and withstood the test of time with many still enjoying reading his works. I know I do.
TheOmnipresent12 yep. the fall of thr house of usher is brilliant and i see no fault or flaw in it, everything in poe’s stories has came about from a great effort and expression to make readers feel a specific way after reading it
@@フアン-f6e Thank you. You might want to have a look/listen to Alan Parsons 'Tales Of Mystery & Imagination' (music). Which is predominantly based on some of Poe's writings. It's a bit perhaps like his (Poe's) stories, one must give it a chance before deciding on their level of enjoyment... Here's a link: ua-cam.com/video/y7htAlPqwBI/v-deo.html
5:14 lmao Minecraft zombie sound
i have a question, is there more than 1 narrator in the story? No right?
Poe: "I had been passing alone, on horseback."
Video: He arrived in a carrage with a driver and 4 horses.
Me, an English teacher: 🤦♂
Can anyone please tell me what type of essay it this?
What about the dragon ??
So was madeleine alive or was it just a ghost???
I'm going to need the background music 🥱
anyone else heard Minecraft zombie noises from madeline
What??
Oh
What is a thesis statement for this?
uhhhh
Summary and analysis?! Hmmmmm...... 🤔
Using words in the summary that aren´t in the text is a sin
9:00
up up up up
I Wish If You Can Do Video About Comprehension QUESTION of house of usher
Summary and additional analysis :
Spoiler alert!
The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book:
Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him
.
He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one.
Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman.
And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc.
In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
I need someone who could help me to write critical questions on Edgar’s Allan Poe ‘s short stories 🙏
Summary and additional analysis :
Spoiler alert!
The characters were well developed if you treat the story like a puzzle, as Poe leaves hints and clues all throughout the story about the entire book:
Roderick loved his sister in a romantic incestuous way. She wanted to marry someone else, of course. He didn't wanna let her so he buried her alive. (It is foreshadowed by Roderick himself as he once again makes up what "would" upset his sister: being buried alive.) After he did so, he got consumed by his so called guilt. And she finally came as a ghost to punish him
.
He was possessive of his sister, he forced her to stay indoors as not to have any other man look at her, then made it up that he knows she doesn't like it despite her never saying such a thing. He gaslighted her and then he killed her when he couldn't take her (normal) rejection anymore. She is a victim, a silent invisible one.
Here one of Poe favorite things: the death of a beautiful woman, happens again. If you recall, Poe said there is nothing more incredible/amazing/etc than the death of a beautiful woman.
And he used that idea in a ton of his stories: Ligeia, The Oval Portrait, The house of Usher, Bernice, etc.
In all these stories, the perpetrator is different and the means by which the beautiful woman dies are also different, but that is the entire highlight, intrigue of the story: the death of a beautiful woman.
U speak so quickly 😪
I'm french and perfectly understood ! Yes he speeks rather quickly but with a very intelligible voice
You can change the playback speed in your settings
There is also a transcript of the video in the description-box you can read.
i love you
This story does not make for a pleasant reading experience. Thanks for making it easier
Sir......plz tell me...how to clear to speak English..?????😒
Sa7a
ratio
Also I’m looking for answers not this bs
this helps u understand not just to give u answers
L story
Your life is an L story