Here is a mother who not only fights with what she has, but as the challenges grew formidable in the way of getting back her children, she kept building her capacities. Her love for her children and her unshakable will power, saw her through to the end of this difficult battle. She fought her way through the legal system of a country where she had lost footing. Hats off to her heroism.
Congratulations to the whole team for exposing the corrupt system of Norway. This is only a tip of the iceberg, it’s ongoing and very common in the Western world.
Watched it yesterday. Absolutely powerful, Sagarika's story played masterfully by Rani Mukerji. Originally from Pakistan, I am a mom of 4 and live in Norway.
Can you confirm that the reasons given in trailer are real, that they are illegal, and therefore the reasons for barnevern to take custody? Could you please confirm with an official website.
Hats off to sagarika . God you are a true inspiration. Thank you for bringing this to us Rani Mukherjee. The biggest let down the mother faced perhaps is the husband and inlaws. They go scot free. That is sooooo 😔
Lets give rounds of applauds for Burkha for being dextrous in her interviewing skills. The way she elicits information from her interviewee and deftly mould her conversational style based on the interlocutor is amazing! This is a stark different of journalism from that of Page3 ‘journalists’ aka Pinkvilla’s ‘journalists’
This is not only happening in Norway. I am living in Switzerland and my Indian friend is going through a similar problem for the last 7 years with her daughter that has been stolen from her by the Swiss system.
Your Friend, which you say is Indian, should be able to work with India since if what you're say is in fact similar... I suspect India Political Figures & Populace Would Get Involved...
Sharon's quite right that it has been happening with the Indian immigrants very oftenly these days around the western countries really. B'coz this is not a single case that is being published in print media from Bengal whose child had been taken away by foreign government for the reason of improper maintenance of the ward. But without Government's intervention & assistance the restoration of child 's custody to the respective parents is impossible. How manies get favour from the Government & how much timely & legally that obviously cannot determine the lost child's parents genuineness to be a true Indian.
I dont know anything about swiss law, but what could be the reason for them taking custody? Its difficult to say if it was justified or not, without knowing more about the case. Some parents just shouldnt have had kids, but if thats not the case here, and it had all been misinterpreted, then I am really sorry for them.
Just like the Bengali tigress, we always come back fighting. I have said it time and again. In our own way, regardless of the opposition, my children will come back looking for me. There's nothing more powerful than a mother's love, strength, and courage. And that's the truth. Many thanks for sharing our universal truth. ❤❤❤❤ Namaste...
Thanks Barkha for your brilliant interview taken from both the reel & real life mothers exposing their strength of fight fought for custody of those children taken away by the Norway Child Care Agency & thatway how true patriot & humane a mother could be of 'Sagarika'.. But as an early viewer of the fillm picturised named 'Mrs. MUKhrji Vs Norway ' it has not been clear to me from the interview that despite racial & cultural desparities the Bengali moher 'Devika' had been allegedly reasoned for an ' unstable ' & 'unpredictable' mother & therefore losing the custody of her children ( as been depicted in the film- dialogues) etc. has not been answered by 'Sagarika' in the interview.
Hats off Sagarika!! We were glued to our television when your story in real was unfolding on a daily basis .. Rani is such a good actor I m sure she must have done full justice to the character .. Nikhil Advani Thankyou for making this film on a subject which has to an extent disappeared from our minds .🙏🏼
Nice conversation. It could have been more commendable,if this panel would have mentioned or pronounced the name of director of this brilliant project, Ashima Chhiber.
It is really a tragic incident and should not happen to any parent. It requires a great amount of courage to fight the system and win your rights. It is definitely a great project. At the same time, I would like to point out Mr Advani's comment, the producer @16:55 mins, that Indians within India just cross the road easily and fear to cross the road abroad and would wait for the signal to turn green. In my view everyone of us should fear to violate the rules irrespective of the country. "It is ok to not follow rules in India" is not an acceptable mindset.
Any Mother Who Sincerely Loves Her Children Would Do Same... However, In This Specific Case... Assuming What I've Seen Is True.... Had India as a Nation Not Got Involved, She Most Likely Would Not Have Gotten Her Children Back... I'm So Grateful & Thankful India as a Nation & Especially It's Political Figures In High Rank, Influence & Power Got Involved... This may have occurred some time ago... But Aside From Monetary Greed, It's Racial Bigotry & Hate Crime... They Say It's Cultural Differences... Many, Countries Populations Feed Their Children By Hand & Parents & Families Also Eat With Their Hands... Without Media Making This Visible To Puplic & India as Nation Not Getting Involved The Positive Outcome Would Not Have Happened... And None of Us Would Have Heard About This Issue...
I have no doubt that Sagrika is still traumatized with her experience. However, she is star struck and actually appears more excited about Rani portraying her than her real life tragedy she has come out of. Perhaps she is still in shock.
I cannot believe what she has gone through! She has given all her courage for getting her children back. Kudos to her and her courage. She needs to focus on herself as an empowered woman now. Sagarika, you should feel and say to others that you feel blessed for where you are now and you have lost nothing by losing that husband of yours who does not care about children. Do not feel that you are a powerless woman. I also think that her husband should be interviewed. Why did he not support her in her difficult journey? Do men have anything to learn from this story?
Unfortunately Sagarika is probably unable to portray or communicate the trauma that she went through in this interview..maybe it's a language issue ... Women are like that ...just downplaying their own courage and achievement ...
so disappoineted with Rani that she did not meet Sagrika until the movie was completed. Her performance would have been different I am sure if she had done her due dilligence ! Most actors outside of India do that to get a better and true understanding of the part they are going to play. Her not meeting Sagrika makes me think that she thinks too much of her self!!!
Correct, she thought by her acting she could make it looks as if it was her own story. And I don't know why Sagarika was so impressed that Rani played her role. In fact I felt Rani was over dramatic in many scenes in the movie. Maybe she was thinking if she acted in her own style, she can claim all credit for her acting if she was given an award for her acting. I fi had been Sagarika i would have wanted being consulted in every aspect of the film right from the actress to the way that actress portrayed my role in the film for it to look really authentic. It is no good taking Rani's mother as an inspiration, and it has nothing to do with having a bengali accent,not being fluent in spoken English. Rani sounded very selfish. Sargarika is a very very strong woman, can never be compared to the likes of Rani mukerjee. But she is to innocent and broadminded in letting somebody else acting as if it had happened to them. I pray for all the parents and children living in those countries.
Why is the real mother talking so casually? It is her pain. It is her lifelong struggle. Why is she answering about celebrity? Somehow she is not able to answer that question
Barkha jee ! Can't you see (as usual), that India and Ms.Sagarika Chakraborty had acted against the law, all the while...that Norway was always just and respectful to us ?!😅
Best mother ❤️ best actress ❤️ also PPL understood what is India from covid... Why our culture must be valued bcoz it is science not superstition beliefs
The husband of Ms Chatterjee has not been adequately exposed. He has only been seen more bothered about his career related citizenship and a typical male chauvinist if not mysoginist.
I Wish i understood what she is saying... While I Don't Want or Wish See Any Family Break Up... Unfortunately & Sadly, It's Necessary Sometimes... She's Better Off Without Him... I Will Not Judge Her Ex... He Has His Own Concerns & Issues... But As Mother, She Did Right Thing... Did she mentioned She Eventually Got Degree?
What kind of logic Nikhilji is giving? Here in India we cross the road without fear( I would say without caring for our as well as other's lives and traffic rules.) But in London we will be scared to until the green light is on. (Which would be the case in any civil society) Is that a good thing to do? What culture are we bragging about? And being scared of the law in a foreign land, you sounded very naive sir, there are multiple cases of child and women abuse done by desi family members in the UK. We are very interested to disobey the law if no one is noticing. Only these kinds of 1 in a million cases come to light and we get crazy about how rules are bad and derogatory for our culture. For us the thought process is we do not accept such problems exist hence we do not create laws and rules to protect our children. Just look away from the fault in the name of culture and tradition. The Mrs Chatterji issue became way more complicated partly because of her husband and his family. Foreign country foreign language and the cultural approach to deal a problem so serious, made it even more difficult to communicate and resolve it.
Crux of her statement- she doesn't want the attention of media to go to the mother who suffered this, what she wanted is to make the film successful and get all the media's attention .
Fake story. Actually the real couple was into violent fights with each other. Neighbors complained to police for the sake of kids. Don't blackmail audience in the name of Indian culture and that stupid 'Ma' angle. And when you choose to live in a particular country, you have to follow rules/laws of the land.
What the real story is god knows but.... I myself seen a woman who become mad after the government took away her child based on tiny issue which is common between every mother and their children. She was brought to pakistan for treatment she was very young and her case was pending too. If the story of the movie is not matched with a story of this woman but i can claim that this story matches the story of all those million mothers whom their children are taken away of them. For your kind information, this is very common in europe to take away or abduct one's child sometimes based on very silly reason such as why did the child burn? Why u got angry on ur child?, and for such cruel act sweden, Norway, Denmark & UK are kind of well known their social workers are all the time destroying people lives in terms of divorcing between husband and wife or to separate their children of their parents because they get a higher pay for that so That's why in UK people are really cautious & afraid of social workers like any agency's secret agent.
Exactly with over dramatisation in B'wood style. But then again it is an Indian movie. Also the reality is severely twisted both the welfare authorities part in this and the father's role.
Nikhil has not done enough research on the subject. Stop making this a patriotic or immigrant issue. Having lived in the west most of my life, several such cases come to light where social services intervene and children are taken away. Director himself has not understood western culture and he's making it a race discrimination case!!! White Caucasian parents face the same issues. I would have happily watched this movie but after listening to Nikhil, it sounds like another typical bollywood melodrama just to appeal to mass Indian audience. No thanks!
Movie bekwas joht dekya gaya jo ke serf ek trafa johti kahane par or mirch masala dal kar drkayahaya hain me Narway me 20 sal rehre hon mere be bache hain or mere dosto ki be bache hain kabi to aysa nahe karte hay agar pokhta koi sabot hain bacho ki mabap ko to vo koi ise qadam otate hain ye log pehele warning detehe batme agar mabap bacho pe zolem karte hain marte hain to vo log bachoko mabapse lete hain ayse joht dekate hain hase film me kabe be nahae karete hain yaha qanon se chal te hain koi reshwat le or dkar se joht se nahi chalti ourat jhuti hain logo ko bewaquf banti hain or bewaquf log iske batume weshwaz karte hain
Stop your bewakuf ideas ignorance is bliss for some if it hasn't happened with you doesn't mean its false i have had same thing happening with one other person who is fighting with German govt who is illegally trying to steal a baby girl from her mom #ariha please google this is happening around the western countries who are so reluctant to have children so they try to steal children and upbring them as thier own google #ariha ariha indian baby ongoing crisis
Hope people are not like sheep, just following whoever is in media a that time. Hope people are able to do their own thing. Check out for themselves. Yes Rani Mukherjee is a great actress. Rest are probably good too. But it's not about the cast. I have said in multiple posts on multiple UA-cam videos, that there is more to the story than what appears. It can't be about cultural differences. Especially since the reasons mentioned in the trailer. They are NOT prohibited. Those are NOT against the law. Even here people do everything that is said to be the reason behind state custody. This is nothing more than one-sided story from mothers point of view. Right or wrong. They portrayed Norway to be a child kidnappers. They portrayed father to be the abuser. Did the producers actually contact the government to get their point of view? Did they contact the father to ask his side. No, they haven't. Father says nobody contacted him. I am saying that nobody, my commen sense says so, contacted Norwegian officials. Why I say that? Because if they had asked, they would have been told that these reasons aren't the reasons, because these reasons are not illegal in Norway. They would NEVER commented on this particular case, because of the confidentiality clause, but they would have given a comment generally about the rules. This has to be a case of something more than a cultural differences. This video from ten yrs back, prove my point. Pls watch until the end. It's originally about another parents loosing their kids, in Norway. These are Indians too. It happened ten years ago. Pls folks. Watch it. ua-cam.com/video/jRDCN-bC4U0/v-deo.html They should never have "attacked" a tiny nation of five million people, and made the father a villain and abuser, based on one persons version. Even if barnevern was right and father is right. None of them will be able to "fight" against hundreds of millions around the world, who WILL see this as the ultimate truth. I am indian mother in Norway. I personally am ashamed, of Indian Bollywood cinema. I have always believed that Bollywood movies are just whatever that sells the movie. Where plot is sellable. ONE MOTHER AGAINST A WHOLE NATION, is indeed a great story and maybe the next blockbuster. Too bad that it probably isn't the entire truth. Normal custody battles, is seen in every other movie. Nothing special. This is great story for the producers, so why would they stain it with facts. Mother could be right, or wrong, I wouldn't know. I wasn't there. What I do know is that producers should have checked thoroughly, before writing the script. They should be ashamed.
Exactly! I saw the children in a video, they looked like educationally lagged and the son seems to be mentally retarded.. He couldn't utter a word in English by himself and was just repeating words of someone who was there behind the camera (the program was in English) which seems so odd considering his age.. Even on sagarika's facebook profile I could hardly find any photo of her son.. And only 2 or 3 posts with her daughter among so many posts of her.. I dont think it's normal..
@@ric1666 Now that is something we can call cultural differences. People having their sleeping babies in pram outside of Cafe or their balcony at home, is normal. Nothing wrong with that. Babies are safe, they sleep better. I have never heard of any baby getting kidnapped from outside. Normally people sit right by the window, and watching their babies. Babies are safe here. If babies wake up, they are taken in, they don't have crying awaken baby, outside in pram. That is something people outside of Norway would never understand. I personally don't. I like to have my babies near me. That is cultural differences. People in Norway tend to not understand the concept of arranged marriages. Some accepts it as a cultural thing, but for others arranged marriages are equal to forced marriages. That is not true. Arranged marriages are arranged marriages, and forced marriages are arranged marriages that are forced. That is cultural differences. So there are some aspects of foreign cultures, people don't understand, whether they are Indians or Norwegians. I have yet to see the movie. My reaction is due to the trailer. There are no cultural difference in the reasons given. Even Norwegians Co-sleep, Hand-feed their babies. It's normal here that children have their own bed, but somehow they tend to end up with parents. My reaction is due to the fact there are hundreds of millions of people, from India and around the world, who are making big issue out of these "cultural differences". When there are none. Personally I thought at that time that children should be able to go back to India. As indian I knew that a bit slapping for discipline is not that uncommon. Its not allowed in Norway, but that doesn't mean that parents are not fit to be parents. Let them go back. So I am happy for her. My problem is the trailer. How much will I be able to believe in the movie, when trailer is false. Those reasons are not illegal. Just saying.
Me being hypocrite? How? You know I am indian mother, living in Norway for almost 40 yrs, and followed this case back then. Everything I know about is through media, as I reckon you too. I followed this case as it was happening, not now ten years later. What is NOT through media is the knowledge of Norwegian laws, some I know, other I find out if need be. I have NOT seen the movie YET. I will be seeing it and find out what else it will portray. One thing I know for SURE is that trailer itself is INACCURATE on main subjects. It doesn't matter what different UA-cam videos in support of the movie, will show. I have seen many videos, some i haven't. Seeing those videos will not affect the facts. Trailer is inaccurate on main points. Part of the trailer that are true : Yes they had their children taken away. Yes, there was a court case Yes, court gave custody to their uncle Yes, indian government was involved. Maybe barnevern were too harsh, maybe they overreacted, maybe they were mistaken. I am saying MAYBE, because none of us were there. I don't know for sure, neither do you, unless you were in the courtroom that day, or have seen court verdict. Part of the trailer that is not true: No, Co-sleeping with your children is NOT against the law. Even Norwegian parents do that. No, feeding them by hand is NOT against the law, even Norwegian parents do that. No, using facepaint/tikka is NOT against the law. Even Norwegian children use them. No, barnevern does NOT make money on children they allegedly "kidnap". None of these are true, and can't be, NEVER EVER BE, the reasons for filing for custody. You want to criticize Norwegian parenting or Norwegian culture, BE MY GUEST, but at least base it on FACTS. Parents love for their children is NOT any different in Norway, as it's in India. Parenting style can be different, but the underline is the same. It's based on culture and personal parenting style. Norwegian government does not interfere with personal choices. Health care professionals advice new parents, they give recommendations. They do NOT check if you are actually following them. As long as you don't do anything against the law. It's mandatory that you as parents are responsible for your childrens wellbeing. That you make sure that they are NOT physically, mentally, emotionally and se...ly, abused. Going to school is also mandatory. I am not against the mother in question. I would like to believe that there was a big misunderstanding, and barnevern overreacted. I know it must have been devastating for parents. I am mother myself. I am against the movie. One thing is that mother wrote a book, the other is that producers make their script based on the book. Did they actually check anything out themselves, before making false allegations on main points. I reckon you know how to Google, right? GOOGLE IT. Check out if above mentioned things are infact prohibited.
Since you claim to be living in Norway for long and since you mentioned welfare ppl did take away the children from parents; don’t you think it’s inhuman and reason enough to be hate Norway welfare policies. Parents can be warned or punished for disciplining their children aggressively. But forcefully taking away children is no way justified. Am not bothered about movie and want to check the real story. Happy to know that you are safe and sound in Norway!
This is a mother's point of view. It is how she perceived her plight. Norway must be doing good. But unfortunately it happened to Sagarika. We have to accept it instead of being judgemental.
Here is a mother who not only fights with what she has, but as the challenges grew formidable in the way of getting back her children, she kept building her capacities. Her love for her children and her unshakable will power, saw her through to the end of this difficult battle. She fought her way through the legal system of a country where she had lost footing. Hats off to her heroism.
Proud to be an Indian... Sagarika ji is a greatest mom no words beyond 🙏🙏🙏
Congratulations to the whole team for exposing the corrupt system of Norway. This is only a tip of the iceberg, it’s ongoing and very common in the Western world.
NoOne can Act like Ranii 👍 👌
Rani Mukherjee, The Bollywood queen 👸 ♥️
Watched it yesterday. Absolutely powerful, Sagarika's story played masterfully by Rani Mukerji. Originally from Pakistan, I am a mom of 4 and live in Norway.
Be careful out there
Can you confirm that the reasons given in trailer are real, that they are illegal, and therefore the reasons for barnevern to take custody?
Could you please confirm with an official website.
Hats off to sagarika . God you are a true inspiration. Thank you for bringing this to us Rani Mukherjee.
The biggest let down the mother faced perhaps is the husband and inlaws.
They go scot free. That is sooooo 😔
Rani maam ki mind-blowing performance hy
Lets give rounds of applauds for Burkha for being dextrous in her interviewing skills. The way she elicits information from her interviewee and deftly mould her conversational style based on the interlocutor is amazing!
This is a stark different of journalism from that of Page3 ‘journalists’ aka Pinkvilla’s ‘journalists’
True
This is not only happening in Norway. I am living in Switzerland and my Indian friend is going through a similar problem for the last 7 years with her daughter that has been stolen from her by the Swiss system.
Your Friend, which you say is Indian, should be able to work with India since if what you're say is in fact similar...
I suspect India Political Figures & Populace Would Get Involved...
Sharon's quite right that it has been happening with the Indian immigrants very oftenly these days around the western countries really. B'coz this is not a single case that is being published in print media from Bengal whose child had been taken away by foreign government for the reason of improper maintenance of the ward. But without Government's intervention & assistance the restoration of child 's custody to the respective parents is impossible. How manies get favour from the Government & how much timely & legally that obviously cannot determine the lost child's parents genuineness to be a true Indian.
Really? This is so hearttouching.
I dont know anything about swiss law, but what could be the reason for them taking custody? Its difficult to say if it was justified or not, without knowing more about the case.
Some parents just shouldnt have had kids, but if thats not the case here, and it had all been misinterpreted, then I am really sorry for them.
Barkha Dutt Excellent interview, WELL DONE! IT IS A MUST WATCH MOVIE.
Proud of you Rani maam
Just like the Bengali tigress, we always come back fighting. I have said it time and again. In our own way, regardless of the opposition, my children will come back looking for me. There's nothing more powerful than a mother's love, strength, and courage.
And that's the truth. Many thanks for sharing our universal truth. ❤❤❤❤ Namaste...
Rani Mukherjee is a versatile actor 👌👌👌👌👌
Difference between melodrama and powerful performance On the face of it, Rani's performance in Black seemed much better
Rani maam brilliant
Thanks Barkha for your brilliant interview taken from both the reel & real life mothers exposing their strength of fight fought for custody of those children taken away by the Norway Child Care Agency & thatway how true patriot & humane a mother could be of 'Sagarika'.. But as an early viewer of the fillm picturised named 'Mrs. MUKhrji Vs Norway ' it has not been clear to me from the interview that despite racial & cultural desparities the Bengali moher 'Devika' had been allegedly reasoned for an ' unstable ' & 'unpredictable' mother & therefore losing the custody of her children ( as been depicted in the film- dialogues) etc. has not been answered by 'Sagarika' in the interview.
Hats off Sagarika!! We were glued to our television when your story in real was unfolding on a daily basis .. Rani is such a good actor I m sure she must have done full justice to the character .. Nikhil Advani Thankyou for making this film on a subject which has to an extent disappeared from our minds .🙏🏼
Nice conversation. It could have been more commendable,if this panel would have mentioned or pronounced the name of director of this brilliant project, Ashima Chhiber.
Thank you Barkha for highlighting ladies issues
It is really a tragic incident and should not happen to any parent. It requires a great amount of courage to fight the system and win your rights.
It is definitely a great project.
At the same time, I would like to point out Mr Advani's comment, the producer @16:55 mins, that Indians within India just cross the road easily and fear to cross the road abroad and would wait for the signal to turn green. In my view everyone of us should fear to violate the rules irrespective of the country. "It is ok to not follow rules in India" is not an acceptable mindset.
Any Mother Who Sincerely Loves Her Children Would Do Same...
However,
In This Specific Case...
Assuming What I've Seen Is True....
Had India as a Nation Not Got Involved, She Most Likely Would Not Have Gotten Her Children Back...
I'm So Grateful & Thankful India as a Nation & Especially It's Political Figures In High Rank, Influence & Power Got Involved...
This may have occurred some time ago...
But Aside From Monetary Greed, It's Racial Bigotry & Hate Crime...
They Say It's Cultural Differences...
Many, Countries Populations Feed Their Children By Hand & Parents & Families Also Eat With Their Hands...
Without Media Making This Visible To Puplic & India as Nation Not Getting Involved The Positive Outcome Would Not Have Happened...
And None of Us Would Have Heard About This Issue...
Rani ❤️
Salute to Sagarika and Rani and Nikhil.
It is going to be a good movie 👍
It is. I saw it today.
Great movie
Rani wow
I watched the movie and liked it but unfortunately the Govt and Media's help was downplayed. I am learning that from this video.
I have no doubt that Sagrika is still traumatized with her experience. However, she is star struck and actually appears more excited about Rani portraying her than her real life tragedy she has come out of. Perhaps she is still in shock.
Hatts of to sagarika.proud tobe Indian and Bengali
I cannot believe what she has gone through! She has given all her courage for getting her children back. Kudos to her and her courage. She needs to focus on herself as an empowered woman now. Sagarika, you should feel and say to others that you feel blessed for where you are now and you have lost nothing by losing that husband of yours who does not care about children. Do not feel that you are a powerless woman. I also think that her husband should be interviewed. Why did he not support her in her difficult journey? Do men have anything to learn from this story?
Rani Rock's..Must Watch Movie
Sagarika...what a hero ❤️🙏
Unfortunately Sagarika is probably unable to portray or communicate the trauma that she went through in this interview..maybe it's a language issue ... Women are like that ...just downplaying their own courage and achievement ...
Hats of Sagarika👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Europe's population is declining, I wouldn't surprised if they were actually doing this.
so disappoineted with Rani that she did not meet Sagrika until the movie was completed. Her performance would have been different I am sure if she had done her due dilligence ! Most actors outside of India do that to get a better and true understanding of the part they are going to play. Her not meeting Sagrika makes me think that she thinks too much of her self!!!
Correct, she thought by her acting she could make it looks as if it was her own story. And I don't know why Sagarika was so impressed that Rani played her role. In fact I felt Rani was over dramatic in many scenes in the movie. Maybe she was thinking if she acted in her own style, she can claim all credit for her acting if she was given an award for her acting. I fi had been Sagarika i would have wanted being consulted in every aspect of the film right from the actress to the way that actress portrayed my role in the film for it to look really authentic. It is no good taking Rani's mother as an inspiration, and it has nothing to do with having a bengali accent,not being fluent in spoken English. Rani sounded very selfish. Sargarika is a very very strong woman, can never be compared to the likes of Rani mukerjee. But she is to innocent and broadminded in letting somebody else acting as if it had happened to them. I pray for all the parents and children living in those countries.
For a change, Indian govt tried to help out a citizen abroad. Thanks to Late Smt Sushma Swaraj for her role in this.
Why is the real mother talking so casually? It is her pain. It is her lifelong struggle. Why is she answering about celebrity? Somehow she is not able to answer that question
Barkha jee ! Can't you see (as usual), that India and Ms.Sagarika Chakraborty had acted against the law, all the while...that Norway was always just and respectful to us ?!😅
Subtitles 🙏🙏🙏
👍🏻👍🏻❤️
Why do I get so negative vibes from Burkha Dutt, Anyone else feel the same?
Best mother ❤️ best actress ❤️ also PPL understood what is India from covid... Why our culture must be valued bcoz it is science not superstition beliefs
Sorry, I didnt get what you mean. Could you please explain?
You should get a better mic.
পাজী মেয়ে,একতরফা কথা কারোর ই বিশ্বাস করা উচিত না।
তবে রাণী তো অভিনয়ে রাণী।
The husband of Ms Chatterjee has not been adequately exposed. He has only been seen more bothered about his career related citizenship and a typical male chauvinist if not mysoginist.
The husband is a true bokachoda chudi bhai from Kolkata.
I Wish i understood what she is saying...
While I Don't Want or Wish See Any Family Break Up...
Unfortunately & Sadly, It's Necessary Sometimes...
She's Better Off Without Him...
I Will Not Judge Her Ex...
He Has His Own Concerns & Issues...
But As Mother, She Did Right Thing...
Did she mentioned She Eventually Got Degree?
What kind of logic Nikhilji is giving? Here in India we cross the road without fear( I would say without caring for our as well as other's lives and traffic rules.) But in London we will be scared to until the green light is on. (Which would be the case in any civil society)
Is that a good thing to do? What culture are we bragging about?
And being scared of the law in a foreign land, you sounded very naive sir, there are multiple cases of child and women abuse done by desi family members in the UK.
We are very interested to disobey the law if no one is noticing. Only these kinds of 1 in a million cases come to light and we get crazy about how rules are bad and derogatory for our culture. For us the thought process is we do not accept such problems exist hence we do not create laws and rules to protect our children. Just look away from the fault in the name of culture and tradition.
The Mrs Chatterji issue became way more complicated partly because of her husband and his family. Foreign country foreign language and the cultural approach to deal a problem so serious, made it even more difficult to communicate and resolve it.
Crux of her statement- she doesn't want the attention of media to go to the mother who suffered this, what she wanted is to make the film successful and get all the media's attention .
Mai to Sagarika ke husband ke bare mey oi itna selfish kaise ho sakta hai
They're divorced
Fake story. Actually the real couple was into violent fights with each other. Neighbors complained to police for the sake of kids. Don't blackmail audience in the name of Indian culture and that stupid 'Ma' angle. And when you choose to live in a particular country, you have to follow rules/laws of the land.
What the real story is god knows but.... I myself seen a woman who become mad after the government took away her child based on tiny issue which is common between every mother and their children. She was brought to pakistan for treatment she was very young and her case was pending too. If the story of the movie is not matched with a story of this woman but i can claim that this story matches the story of all those million mothers whom their children are taken away of them.
For your kind information, this is very common in europe to take away or abduct one's child sometimes based on very silly reason such as why did the child burn? Why u got angry on ur child?, and for such cruel act sweden, Norway, Denmark & UK are kind of well known their social workers are all the time destroying people lives in terms of divorcing between husband and wife or to separate their children of their parents because they get a higher pay for that so That's why in UK people are really cautious & afraid of social workers like any agency's secret agent.
To be honest, the movie looks overtly dramatised because of cringing song and music. Even some of the Norwegian characters looked cliched "all evil".
Exactly with over dramatisation in B'wood style. But then again it is an Indian movie. Also the reality is severely twisted both the welfare authorities part in this and the father's role.
Nikhil has not done enough research on the subject. Stop making this a patriotic or immigrant issue. Having lived in the west most of my life, several such cases come to light where social services intervene and children are taken away.
Director himself has not understood western culture and he's making it a race discrimination case!!! White Caucasian parents face the same issues. I would have happily watched this movie but after listening to Nikhil, it sounds like another typical bollywood melodrama just to appeal to mass Indian audience. No thanks!
Movie bekwas joht dekya gaya jo ke serf ek trafa johti kahane par or mirch masala dal kar drkayahaya hain me Narway me 20 sal rehre hon mere be bache hain or mere dosto ki be bache hain kabi to aysa nahe karte hay agar pokhta koi sabot hain bacho ki mabap ko to vo koi ise qadam otate hain ye log pehele warning detehe batme agar mabap bacho pe zolem karte hain marte hain to vo log bachoko mabapse lete hain ayse joht dekate hain hase film me kabe be nahae karete hain yaha qanon se chal te hain koi reshwat le or dkar se joht se nahi chalti ourat jhuti hain logo ko bewaquf banti hain or bewaquf log iske batume weshwaz karte hain
Stop your bewakuf ideas ignorance is bliss for some if it hasn't happened with you doesn't mean its false i have had same thing happening with one other person who is fighting with German govt who is illegally trying to steal a baby girl from her mom #ariha please google this is happening around the western countries who are so reluctant to have children so they try to steal children and upbring them as thier own google #ariha ariha indian baby ongoing crisis
In Palestinian is happening everyday … nobody wants to know …
Hope people are not like sheep, just following whoever is in media a that time. Hope people are able to do their own thing. Check out for themselves.
Yes Rani Mukherjee is a great actress. Rest are probably good too. But it's not about the cast.
I have said in multiple posts on multiple UA-cam videos, that there is more to the story than what appears. It can't be about cultural differences. Especially since the reasons mentioned in the trailer. They are NOT prohibited. Those are NOT against the law. Even here people do everything that is said to be the reason behind state custody.
This is nothing more than one-sided story from mothers point of view. Right or wrong.
They portrayed Norway to be a child kidnappers. They portrayed father to be the abuser. Did the producers actually contact the government to get their point of view? Did they contact the father to ask his side.
No, they haven't. Father says nobody contacted him. I am saying that nobody, my commen sense says so, contacted Norwegian officials. Why I say that? Because if they had asked, they would have been told that these reasons aren't the reasons, because these reasons are not illegal in Norway. They would NEVER commented on this particular case, because of the confidentiality clause, but they would have given a comment generally about the rules.
This has to be a case of something more than a cultural differences.
This video from ten yrs back, prove my point.
Pls watch until the end. It's originally about another parents loosing their kids, in Norway. These are Indians too. It happened ten years ago.
Pls folks. Watch it.
ua-cam.com/video/jRDCN-bC4U0/v-deo.html
They should never have "attacked" a tiny nation of five million people, and made the father a villain and abuser, based on one persons version. Even if barnevern was right and father is right. None of them will be able to "fight" against hundreds of millions around the world, who WILL see this as the ultimate truth.
I am indian mother in Norway. I personally am ashamed, of Indian Bollywood cinema. I have always believed that Bollywood movies are just whatever that sells the movie. Where plot is sellable.
ONE MOTHER AGAINST A WHOLE NATION, is indeed a great story and maybe the next blockbuster. Too bad that it probably isn't the entire truth. Normal custody battles, is seen in every other movie. Nothing special. This is great story for the producers, so why would they stain it with facts.
Mother could be right, or wrong, I wouldn't know. I wasn't there. What I do know is that producers should have checked thoroughly, before writing the script.
They should be ashamed.
Exactly! I saw the children in a video, they looked like educationally lagged and the son seems to be mentally retarded.. He couldn't utter a word in English by himself and was just repeating words of someone who was there behind the camera (the program was in English) which seems so odd considering his age.. Even on sagarika's facebook profile I could hardly find any photo of her son.. And only 2 or 3 posts with her daughter among so many posts of her.. I dont think it's normal..
@@ric1666
Now that is something we can call cultural differences. People having their sleeping babies in pram outside of Cafe or their balcony at home, is normal. Nothing wrong with that. Babies are safe, they sleep better. I have never heard of any baby getting kidnapped from outside. Normally people sit right by the window, and watching their babies. Babies are safe here. If babies wake up, they are taken in, they don't have crying awaken baby, outside in pram. That is something people outside of Norway would never understand. I personally don't. I like to have my babies near me. That is cultural differences.
People in Norway tend to not understand the concept of arranged marriages. Some accepts it as a cultural thing, but for others arranged marriages are equal to forced marriages. That is not true. Arranged marriages are arranged marriages, and forced marriages are arranged marriages that are forced. That is cultural differences.
So there are some aspects of foreign cultures, people don't understand, whether they are Indians or Norwegians.
I have yet to see the movie. My reaction is due to the trailer. There are no cultural difference in the reasons given. Even Norwegians Co-sleep, Hand-feed their babies. It's normal here that children have their own bed, but somehow they tend to end up with parents. My reaction is due to the fact there are hundreds of millions of people, from India and around the world, who are making big issue out of these "cultural differences". When there are none.
Personally I thought at that time that children should be able to go back to India. As indian I knew that a bit slapping for discipline is not that uncommon. Its not allowed in Norway, but that doesn't mean that parents are not fit to be parents. Let them go back. So I am happy for her.
My problem is the trailer. How much will I be able to believe in the movie, when trailer is false. Those reasons are not illegal.
Just saying.
Me being hypocrite? How?
You know I am indian mother, living in Norway for almost 40 yrs, and followed this case back then. Everything I know about is through media, as I reckon you too. I followed this case as it was happening, not now ten years later.
What is NOT through media is the knowledge of Norwegian laws, some I know, other I find out if need be.
I have NOT seen the movie YET. I will be seeing it and find out what else it will portray. One thing I know for SURE is that trailer itself is INACCURATE on main subjects. It doesn't matter what different UA-cam videos in support of the movie, will show. I have seen many videos, some i haven't. Seeing those videos will not affect the facts. Trailer is inaccurate on main points.
Part of the trailer that are true :
Yes they had their children taken away.
Yes, there was a court case
Yes, court gave custody to their uncle
Yes, indian government was involved.
Maybe barnevern were too harsh, maybe they overreacted, maybe they were mistaken. I am saying MAYBE, because none of us were there. I don't know for sure, neither do you, unless you were in the courtroom that day, or have seen court verdict.
Part of the trailer that is not true:
No, Co-sleeping with your children is NOT against the law. Even Norwegian parents do that.
No, feeding them by hand is NOT against the law, even Norwegian parents do that.
No, using facepaint/tikka is NOT against the law. Even Norwegian children use them.
No, barnevern does NOT make money on children they allegedly "kidnap".
None of these are true, and can't be, NEVER EVER BE, the reasons for filing for custody.
You want to criticize Norwegian parenting or Norwegian culture, BE MY GUEST, but at least base it on FACTS. Parents love for their children is NOT any different in Norway, as it's in India. Parenting style can be different, but the underline is the same. It's based on culture and personal parenting style. Norwegian government does not interfere with personal choices. Health care professionals advice new parents, they give recommendations. They do NOT check if you are actually following them. As long as you don't do anything against the law. It's mandatory that you as parents are responsible for your childrens wellbeing. That you make sure that they are NOT physically, mentally, emotionally and se...ly, abused. Going to school is also mandatory.
I am not against the mother in question. I would like to believe that there was a big misunderstanding, and barnevern overreacted. I know it must have been devastating for parents. I am mother myself. I am against the movie. One thing is that mother wrote a book, the other is that producers make their script based on the book. Did they actually check anything out themselves, before making false allegations on main points.
I reckon you know how to Google, right? GOOGLE IT. Check out if above mentioned things are infact prohibited.
Since you claim to be living in Norway for long and since you mentioned welfare ppl did take away the children from parents; don’t you think it’s inhuman and reason enough to be hate Norway welfare policies. Parents can be warned or punished for disciplining their children aggressively. But forcefully taking away children is no way justified. Am not bothered about movie and want to check the real story. Happy to know that you are safe and sound in Norway!
This is a mother's point of view. It is how she perceived her plight. Norway must be doing good. But unfortunately it happened to Sagarika. We have to accept it instead of being judgemental.