Do Jews and Arabs Really Have Different Ancestors?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 кві 2022
  • In this episode, you can check the current distribution of Y-DNA haplogroup J1 by country and the famous individuals belonging to J1. Also, through the phylogenetic tree of Haplogroup J1, the time of occurrence and prominent formation places of descendants by era are introduced. Finally, the ancient DNA of J1 was mapped by period.
    00:33 introduction
    01:40 Present frequency of J1
    03:59 Famous individuals belong to J1
    07:52 J1 phylogenetic tree
    09:33 Ancient Y-DNA of J1

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,2 тис.

  • @geonomad1
    @geonomad1  2 роки тому +36

    00:33 introduction
    01:40 Present frequency of J1
    03:59 Famous individuals belong to J1
    07:52 J1 phylogenetic tree
    09:33 Ancient Y-DNA of J1

    • @KA-be7fk
      @KA-be7fk Рік тому +5

      The J1 strain in Saudi Arabia constitutes 74%

    • @AbuAhmad.i
      @AbuAhmad.i Рік тому +10

      @@KA-be7fk all Arabian tribes Arabian peninsula

    • @thomasaloysiusgilhooley5148
      @thomasaloysiusgilhooley5148 Рік тому

      @yitzhak shekkelsteingoldmanberg do yoy believe that?, upper class?, Seriously?
      My wife is jew from Israel, by the way.

    • @thomasaloysiusgilhooley5148
      @thomasaloysiusgilhooley5148 Рік тому +3

      @yitzhak shekkelsteingoldmanberg I am gently goy because in my language goy (I'm not a Jewish guy) means high or higher depending on the moment, just the opposite or goy, more or less. This is something that the friends in Israel don't understand. Who is possible to be better than them if I am not jew?! Very easy, being us because according to us we are the best in the universe. As you can see, this is a simple question of EGO. If you don't believe me, come to my country and ask the people. The truth is with us. You believe one thing and we believe another very different.
      I like Darwin and Genetics because they are show that the humankind comes from a monkey descending from a tree in Africa and religious people can't stand with it.

    • @thomasaloysiusgilhooley5148
      @thomasaloysiusgilhooley5148 Рік тому +1

      @yitzhak shekkelsteingoldmanberg God...which one? There were and there are a lot of them.

  • @scoobydoo936
    @scoobydoo936 8 місяців тому +115

    Interesting, though people have mixed and intermingled over the millennia. A linguistic study, which in fact is a cultural study, clearly shows that both Jewish, Aramaic and Arabic languages share the same Semitic root/origin and are relatives. Interestingly enough, they also share the same religious root, as they are both abrahamic religions.

    • @nesne2167
      @nesne2167 7 місяців тому +1

      Christianity sprung out of Judaism. Islam sprung out of Christianity.

    • @DieFlabbergast
      @DieFlabbergast 7 місяців тому +22

      There's no such thing as the "Jewish language." Jews originally spoke Hebrew, then Aramaic, and then later various languages indigenous to the countries in which they were living, including Yiddish (a blend of German with Hebrew and various Slavic languages) in Western, Central and Eastern Europe, and Ladino (a blend of various Spanish dialects with Aramaic, Hebrew, Turkish and God knows what else). Saying Hebrew and Arabic are relatives is like saying fire is hot or ice is cold.

    • @scoobydoo936
      @scoobydoo936 7 місяців тому +2

      @@DieFlabbergast you are absolutely right! my bad!

    • @shalevedna
      @shalevedna 7 місяців тому +10

      You got it. Islam (a much later offshoot of Moseic monotheism (religion of Moses and Israel, aka “Judaism”), is much closer to Judaism than Christianity. It is actually the same, with ethnic differences. But the basic-belief in one God, no deities, no statues, is the same.
      The war between them is a Muslim invention . It has no basis in reality. Islam is simply a continuation of Moses’s monotheism (Judaism).

    • @hurataimad136
      @hurataimad136 7 місяців тому +2

      Yiddish is related to Arabic??? That is news.

  • @defender714
    @defender714 8 місяців тому +162

    This is why saying anti-Semitic doesn't really apply unless you hate all of them.

    • @enumaelis5048
      @enumaelis5048 7 місяців тому +12

      The ancient Phoenicians, from whom all the peoples of the Mediterranean derive (Spain, France, Italy, Tunisia, Algeria, etc.) were Semites because to be Semites you don't have to have a certain DNA, but just learn a Semitic language!!

    • @MarMirza
      @MarMirza 7 місяців тому

      . Parece que no funciona: ley primera los hermanos sean unidos.

    • @Sufganiyot
      @Sufganiyot 7 місяців тому +11

      Thats the etymology of the word, since Jews are semitic people,but etymology =/= meaning.

    • @defender714
      @defender714 7 місяців тому +15

      @@Sufganiyot So are Arabs.

    • @Sufganiyot
      @Sufganiyot 7 місяців тому +15

      @@defender714 That is true. But I am saying that "semitic" is the ideology of the word. The meaning has always referred to Jew hatred.

  • @user-dg5vx8li8f
    @user-dg5vx8li8f Рік тому +2

    Great video and rich information, thanks for the introduction

    • @walkietalkietraveller2932
      @walkietalkietraveller2932 Рік тому

      you have the most appropriate name ! :D

    • @user-dg5vx8li8f
      @user-dg5vx8li8f Рік тому

      ​@@walkietalkietraveller2932
      Honestly, my name has nothing to do with the hubble group J. I just like the name John and I put my name in the first letter J

  • @Miki-fl9ez
    @Miki-fl9ez 2 роки тому +17

    It would be cool that you commented where J1 is one of many.
    And in which remains is the dominant in your map of fossils throughout time

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +5

      최대한 많은 데이터를 가져와서 지도에 올리려고 하는데 데이터가 부족합니다.

    • @Miki-fl9ez
      @Miki-fl9ez 2 роки тому +1

      @@geonomad1 ???? Can't translate

    • @robertolang9684
      @robertolang9684 Рік тому +5

      rb1 is dominant in europe but its origins is near est levant anatolia

    • @Freeflier1978
      @Freeflier1978 Місяць тому

      @@Miki-fl9ez hence the horrible AI Narrator.

  • @matityahubenavraham2970
    @matityahubenavraham2970 2 роки тому +140

    I am J2 and I love J1 brothers and all the other people I love, all the people in the world are brothers ❤️

    • @smprjeas5053
      @smprjeas5053 2 роки тому

      We are from Haplogroup J1 and we hate isreal
      Free plastine👍

    • @prometheus4523
      @prometheus4523 Рік тому +14

      I am also j2 from Iran, unfortunately the Arab government of my country is hostile to you against the will of the people.

    • @matityahubenavraham2970
      @matityahubenavraham2970 Рік тому +4

      Absolutely True@@prometheus4523

    • @AbuAhmad.i
      @AbuAhmad.i Рік тому +14

      Thanks brother we all are semetic ❤️ j1 & j2

    • @yoniwolf6008
      @yoniwolf6008 Рік тому

      @@prometheus4523 Arabic government of your country? Is that a joke ? Your government is all Persians like your people you los,er

  • @user-lz5dz1qx2q
    @user-lz5dz1qx2q Рік тому +49

    The study in Khartoum can be generalized to more than 20 million people. Khartoum is not an isolated region in Sudan. Most Khartoum inhabitants are called Arabs in Sudan. They are the inhabitants of most major cities in Sudan

    • @user-lz5dz1qx2q
      @user-lz5dz1qx2q Рік тому +4

      @Melissa Robert's
      The sudanese arabic dialect is the only common thing we can build a national identity on it , Kush hadn't the same borders of sudan

    • @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942
      @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942 Рік тому

      ​@Melissa Robert's c'est grâce au arabes que vous avez une identité d'ailleurs vous communiquer entre vous en arabe notre langue.vous n'avez aucune civilisation et la preuve vous n avez pas des lettres pour écrire et vous utilisez nos lettres nos vocabulaires nos chiffres........ De plus vous jouez les victimes c est vraiment incroyable vous avez eté des peuples primitifs sans histoires avant l'arrivé des arabes

    • @alinaqirizvi1441
      @alinaqirizvi1441 Рік тому +6

      ​@Melissa Robert's No, Arabic is the native language of most of Sudan. Also there have been major migrations of Arabs to Sudan compared with the rest of North Africa so it would be wrong to say that they aren't Arab and are only Cushitic

    • @alinaqirizvi1441
      @alinaqirizvi1441 Рік тому

      ​@Melissa Robert's 66% of Sudanese people are Arab

    • @user-ir2fu4cx6p
      @user-ir2fu4cx6p Рік тому

      ​@@alinaqirizvi1441 The Arabs annihilate all other ethnic groups in Sudan, so his claim are accurate.

  • @quadejaworski8377
    @quadejaworski8377 2 роки тому +16

    Nice Video! I'm excited for J2. My friend's paternal line is from France and his haplogroup is J-M172. Is J2 and J-M172 considered the same branch?

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +6

      J2 and J-M172 are from the same haplogroup. M172 is the SNP of J2.

    • @targariandjon1266
      @targariandjon1266 Рік тому +5

      Я осетин у меня J2a1b

    • @maxwolf8055
      @maxwolf8055 Рік тому +4

      ​@@targariandjon1266​​Ваши предки Нахи . Много осетинских родов произошли от ингушей и чеченцев. J2a1b больше всего у ингушей 89% . У чеченцев 60% .

    • @lollolowski8956
      @lollolowski8956 5 місяців тому

      Do bigY so you have more precise haplogroup

  • @joanhuffman2166
    @joanhuffman2166 8 місяців тому +16

    Even in the Bible, Abraham and Isaac had sons whose descendants were not among the Jews. Abraham was the father of Isaac by his wife Sarah, and father of Ismael by Hagar, and the father of Zimran, Jokshan, Medan, Midian, Ishbak, and Shuah, by Keturah the concubine he took after the death of Sarah. Isaac was the father of Jacob and Esau. Other men who shared the same Y chromosome as Abraham were Lot and his sons Moab and Amnon, Laban and his sons too as they were descendants of Terah, the father of Abraham. Only Jacob's children are considered Jews, but they had relatives.

    • @Simon.the.Likeable
      @Simon.the.Likeable 7 місяців тому +2

      No one knows the precise composition of the chromosomes of the people who concocted the mythology of the ancient Hebrews. They were certainly on the crossroads of civilization. If you think you have scientifically verifiable information which may be a breakthrough regarding the current paradigm, please collate the information and publish it for peer review. We will all be grateful for the addition to our wealth of knowledge. Otherwise, be honest and preface it as your opinion.

    • @joanhuffman2166
      @joanhuffman2166 7 місяців тому +6

      @Simon.the.Likeable if we're discussing the Y chromosome haplotype of Jews, what the Bible has to say is relevant. What it tells us is that there are many closely related peoples descended from the same Ancestor, that is Terah the father of Abraham. History outside of the Bible tells us that people who were not descended from Israel converted to Judaism. Therefore, I don't expect Jews to have Y chromosomes that only Jews have, nor do I expect them to not have other less closely related Y chromosomes.

    • @Simon.the.Likeable
      @Simon.the.Likeable 7 місяців тому +2

      @@joanhuffman2166 Believing their mythology makes me Esau. Esau is Edom. No thanks. It's your opinion, not mine.

    • @yawos9024
      @yawos9024 7 місяців тому

      Jews only come from Judah!

    • @Factsmatter16
      @Factsmatter16 7 місяців тому +6

      ​@@Simon.the.LikeableMythology????Hebrews/Jews have archeological proof of their history, unlike, let's say, Arabs in Israel, who were mainly nomads.

  • @lizharmon3451
    @lizharmon3451 2 роки тому +23

    Nicely done-keep up the excellent work

  • @MissRenee_X
    @MissRenee_X 9 місяців тому +4

    Where can I get this testing done? I have such a rare blood type, there’s only 13 of us in the world with it, so I’m so curious as to know the details of these groups.

    • @Anakbek
      @Anakbek 8 місяців тому +5

      Blood type has nothing to do with haplogroups, haplogroups are just information about the male or female lineage of someone.

    • @michaeljhirz
      @michaeljhirz 6 місяців тому

      @@Anakbek Your blood type is passed on through your parents DNA, as are all your traits.

    • @LeadByExample2911
      @LeadByExample2911 Місяць тому

      Female as it comes from the mitochondrial DNA which is passed down from the mother

    • @freemind1923
      @freemind1923 10 днів тому

      You have a blood type that only 13 other people have in the world.. get out of here :)

  • @hipretty
    @hipretty 6 місяців тому

    How does one find their haplogroup? I did a DNA test, but none of that info is available to me.

  • @brpp19
    @brpp19 2 роки тому +5

    Hi, thanks for the video! I am J2 and looking forward to the next video J2

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +2

      I'm working on it now. I plan to upload it within a day or two.

    • @targariandjon1266
      @targariandjon1266 Рік тому +2

      Я осетин у меня J2a1b

  • @gaz6439
    @gaz6439 Рік тому +14

    J1 here from Manchester UK, not sure how my paternal ancestor got here but this city was Roman in the past and had three forts nearby (Mamucium, Castleshaw & Ardotalia). All could have had auxillary soldiers from the middle east stay at those forts. Traders also came to the UK from the middle east too in Roman times. Interesting how big noses (Roman nose) also run on my father's side. I wonder if there's a genetic trait there with J people?

  • @beautycirclepro
    @beautycirclepro Рік тому +5

    I'm J2a2 which wasn't mentioned here. I wonder where I can discover more about my maternal haplogroup, which is around 150,000 years old.

  • @chrisclassical7
    @chrisclassical7 8 місяців тому +15

    i would imagine every christian and every muslim was once in some way related to a person with the jewish faith. myself personally an irish roman Catholic can trace my genes according to 23 and me to be scandanivan and european. not a hint of middle eastern in me despite even having neanderthal genes. what people can't seem to get their heads around that there is no connection between a faith belief, ethnicity and genetic groups.

    • @user-wc7ku7ud3e
      @user-wc7ku7ud3e 7 місяців тому

      عزيزي الانسان قديم جدا من ملاين السنين تطور عبر مراحل كثيره وطويله استمرت ملاين السنين فمن خلايا اوليه تطور من الماء ومن التراب تطور من الطين عبر رحله طويله حتي تكونت مجموعات البشر الاواءل وهم همج لايعون شيئا ومفسدين ويسفكون الدم كالحيوانات لايدركون شيئا وكانت مشيئه الله الرحيم القادر ان تأخذ الملاءكه مجموعه من تلك الكاءنات الهمجيه=البشر الأول في محميه طبيعيه اسمها جنه وهي منعزله ليتم تعديلهم جينيا من كروموسوم خنسي الي كروموسوم منفصل زكروانثي xx xy ويتم تعديل العمود الفقري ليستقيم منصبا بعد ان كان اسلافنا الاواءل يمشون علي اربع وتحررت اليدان لتصنع وتبدع وايضا كانت الحكمه من الله ان يطور العقل لينتقل من مرحله التصور البداءي للاشياء التصور الحسي المعتمد علي المشخص والمجسد الي قفزه كبيره يكون العقل قادرا علي التفكير والابتكار وتوليد الافكار ليكون عقلا معتمدا علي توليد الافكار والتطوير وبهذا اصبح الانسان مهيئا ومجهزا لتقبل الرساله من الله ليخلف الارض ويعمرها وينشر الامن والسلام في الارض مؤمنا بالله وفاعلا العمل الصالح والحسن وتتابعت الرسالات والانبياء ليعلموا الانسان الفضيله والاخلاق بجانب التعلم من خبرات الواقع فالانسان رحله طويله لذلك تجد التنوع الجيني الهاءل بين الناس هذا طويل وقصير وابيض وانف مدبب وشعر مجعد واسود والاف الصفات الوراثيه اللتي نتجت عبر ملاين السنين من التباديل والتوافيق والاحتمالات المقوده والمقصوده الطفرات فالبشر اصلهم مجموعه من البشر الاواءل الهمج فنحن الان انسان تحياتي كتبت لك تطور البشر من خلال ماعرضه وعلمنا اياه القران الكريم وهو ايضا متوافق مع مثيلوجيا منطقتنا عبر رسالات الله لها لبابل واشور وكنعان وو وو فالله ارسل نبي لكل قوم لكل شعب لكل مكان لايوجد مكان في العالم لم يرسل له الله نبي فالقران الكريم يقول لكل قوم رسول وهادي وهناك ايه مفصليه ماكنا معذبين حتي نبعث رسولا لكي لايكون للناس علي الله حجه القاعده القانونيه الاعلام لاعقوبه الا بنص واعلام الناس بالقانون فالله كيف يحاسب البشر ان لم يعرفهم الصح والخطأ؟ لذلك الله ارسل انبياء بالالاف لكل الناس

    • @edwardkantowicz4707
      @edwardkantowicz4707 7 місяців тому

      @chrisclassic As to your last point about there being NO CONNECTION between faith, ethnicity, and genetic groups, I believe the Kohanim and many Levites beg to differ with you. How would you explain the existence and prevalence of the CMH amongst Kohens/Priestly class?

    • @chrisclassical7
      @chrisclassical7 7 місяців тому

      @@edwardkantowicz4707 my point is that there are people which are animals an then there are religions which are made up for reasons unknown. everything one does on a daily basis is totally non dependent on religion. it is as if religion is a handicap imposed on us.

    • @edwardkantowicz4707
      @edwardkantowicz4707 7 місяців тому

      @@chrisclassical7 I see. No argument there, and religion shouldn't be imposed on anyone.

    • @ajeeli_travels
      @ajeeli_travels 6 місяців тому +1

      I find it quite intriguing that you have no Middle Eastern traces in you considering that Europeans had to descend from the Middle East at some point. This could be down to the fact that there wasn't enough data samples from the Middle East to compare to, and would probably get updated to show more accurate results as more samples are gathered.

  • @Ramesses1000
    @Ramesses1000 Рік тому +3

    I just found out from YSEQ that my y-dna haplogroup is J-Z1865. Where exactly does this haplogroup originate?

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  Рік тому +1

      It is estimated that it originated in Western Asia about 7900 years ago. Ancient samples 3500 years old have been found in the Levant.

    • @user-zl7cq9db3c
      @user-zl7cq9db3c 5 місяців тому

      The J gene was established in the Arabian Peninsula, specifically in the southwestern coast of the island, and the greatest concentration and purity of the J gene is found in that place among the tribes, and this is consistent with the Islamic narrative, as there were the ancestors of the current Arabs, such as: the Prophet Ibrahim, Ismael, and Ishac.
      It also agrees with the popular Arabic narrative about the ancestors of the Arabs of Yemen, such as: Saba / Hud Aber / Qahtan / Ya’arub / karbeal / sharhabeal
      I do not believe that there is a relationship between the Arabs (people with olive skin) and the Scandinavian race (people with white skin) in southern Europe and the northern Arab world. There is a natural mixing between the two parties. It is a demographic border.

    • @user-zl7cq9db3c
      @user-zl7cq9db3c 5 місяців тому

      ربما أنت أزدي

  • @AdultThirdCultureKid1971
    @AdultThirdCultureKid1971 Рік тому +6

    Would you please do a video on the J haplogroup, mitochondrial DNA, too? Thanks!

  • @wannacashmeoutside
    @wannacashmeoutside 7 місяців тому +5

    Will you please tell me why your videos focus on Y chromosome haplogroups rather than Mitochondrial Haplogroups? (I know it’s YOUR videos and your channel so I’m asking if there’s a scientific reason you’re focusing on that)

  • @superpilzer
    @superpilzer Рік тому +22

    Thanks for the video. I would still have a small criticism, namely that they didn't mention the European branch L1189 at all. I think it would be an interesting contribution to report on the rare subgroups of the J haplogroup rather than what is already obvious!

    • @orlandovelastegui1391
      @orlandovelastegui1391 Рік тому +8

      Genesis 10:2-3 KJVS
      [2] The sons of Japheth; Gomer, and Magog, and Madai, and Javan, and Tubal, and Meshech, and Tiras. [3] And the sons of Gomer; Ashkenaz, and Riphath, and Togarmah.
      Ashkenazi is son of Gomer son of Japheth you are not Jew by blood.!!!! Only Shems Descendants are actually Jew by blood. Ashkenazi just follow are religion.!!!

    • @TheWolfthunder0
      @TheWolfthunder0 Рік тому +2

      Yup 👍🏽 Truth is in the Blood 🩸 line’s Not by be coming religiously or claim to be Revelation 2:9,3:9. Jesus say They’re descendent of the Viper’s Bloodlines of the Viper’s.

    • @anthonyproffitt5341
      @anthonyproffitt5341 Рік тому +7

      What’s the Bible racism have to do with this video?

    • @orlandovelastegui1391
      @orlandovelastegui1391 Рік тому

      @@anthonyproffitt5341 your the racist!!!? May the Lord have mercy on you and not strike you for your blasphemy.

    • @orlandovelastegui1391
      @orlandovelastegui1391 Рік тому +2

      @@anthonyproffitt5341 Ashkenazi Jews come from the lineage of Japheth first son Gomer fathered Ashkenaz.!!! The Jews that call themselves Ashkenazi Jews come from the Son of Gomer. Also the real Jews are from the lineage of Shem.! Genesis 10:2-3 KJVS
      [2] The sons of Japheth; Gomer, and Magog, and Madai, and Javan, and Tubal, and Meshech, and Tiras. [3] And the sons of Gomer; Ashkenaz, and Riphath, and Togarmah.

  • @davidchurch3472
    @davidchurch3472 11 місяців тому +23

    Ah, but the ancient distribution of J1 does not reflect where it was most common in anceint times, necessarily; instead, it represents only those places where suitably-preserved bodies from which we could isolate DNA, have happened to be found, and tested. Any inferences made from this very limited sampling of the ancient DNA, being less than 1 per million (or even more!) could be extremely inaccurate.

    • @michaeljensen4650
      @michaeljensen4650 7 місяців тому +7

      Good point. It does however show that European, Middle Eastern and Central Asian people are related and that they must have a common ancestor. Which part of the world that genetic composition originated from or has spread to can only be speculated on. I am of the belief that it spread out from Central Asia moving westward and branching out to the south and the north as is the current consensus among academics.

    • @TJ-Judge
      @TJ-Judge 7 місяців тому

      It clearly shows that there are higher levels of semitic DNA in Arabic countries in the current day. So Arabs are more closely related to thr original semites

    • @Newtons3rdLore
      @Newtons3rdLore 4 місяці тому

      Rubbish

    • @uniformityofnature1488
      @uniformityofnature1488 Місяць тому

      We can be compare ancient samples from the different time periods. For example Late Epipaleolithic period through to the Bronze Age.

  • @dude3277
    @dude3277 8 місяців тому +14

    Japheth would dwell in the tents of Shem. DNA has proven it.

  • @jasoncuculo7035
    @jasoncuculo7035 Рік тому +16

    Interesting how the origin point is between the Caspian and Black Seas. One origin was west of the Black Sea. Yet, it is rare in Europe despite this location around the Black Sea having been cited as the source of Indo-European migration. There were many Indo-European migrations. An earlier group than the Hellenes in Greece
    ? A separate haplogroup that migrated mostly south into the Middle East and North Africa?

    • @deadbeat5165
      @deadbeat5165 Рік тому +4

      haplogroup IJ originated in west Asia ,Haplogroup I did go to Europe and J did stay

    • @user-dg5vx8li8f
      @user-dg5vx8li8f 11 місяців тому +9

      There is no relationship between J and the Indo-European peoples. Indeed, even haplogroup I has nothing to do with the Indo-Europeans, as it already existed in Europe before R. And J is originated in West Asia and stayed in it, and only the I branch went to Europe

    • @robertolang9684
      @robertolang9684 8 місяців тому

      @@user-dg5vx8li8f i'm j1 , and shintasha , andronovo is in my DNA how that can be possible

    • @whatabouttheearth
      @whatabouttheearth 7 місяців тому

      ​​@@user-dg5vx8li8f
      ALL life on earth descended from LUCA and of course all Homo sapiens are related.
      These haplogroups are only arbitrary origin groups, they all have many haplogroups before that that go towards and into Africa.

    • @metacomet2066
      @metacomet2066 4 місяці тому

      Sorry, there are plenty of us J1 people in Europe. @@user-dg5vx8li8f

  • @friedrichengels2475
    @friedrichengels2475 Рік тому +9

    It's an interesting stereotype that many people think that most proto-Y-chromosomes like IJ are located in the Caucasus where they are absent. Examples of the haplogroup IJ* (M429) were first reported in a 2012 study of genetic diversity in Iran, by Grugni et al.

    • @uniformityofnature1488
      @uniformityofnature1488 Місяць тому

      Well yes but the location isn’t the more significant component, the date is. J1 mutated and originates in the caucuses and migrated.

  • @maxwolf8055
    @maxwolf8055 Рік тому +43

    The world's highest frequency of J2 is found among the Ingush (88% of the male lineages) and Chechen (56%) people in the Northeast Caucasus. Both belong to the Nakh ethnic group, who have inhabited that territory since at least 3000 BCE.

    • @user-tr8yw9xs4q
      @user-tr8yw9xs4q 11 місяців тому +4

      че ты несешь ,у вас это гаплогруппа имеет эыыект основателя она вам пришла из анатолии или армянского нагорья изначально на совточном кавказе быда одна гаплогруппа j1

    • @fakefakefake7952
      @fakefakefake7952 9 місяців тому

      How did you find that out?

    • @user-tr8yw9xs4q
      @user-tr8yw9xs4q 9 місяців тому

      @chechen99965 у армян больше всего генетическог разнообразия гаплогруппы J1 что говорит о ее происхожденние на армянском нагорье ,J2 скорее имеет ибо иранское либо восточноанатолийское происхождение

    • @user-tr8yw9xs4q
      @user-tr8yw9xs4q 9 місяців тому

      @chechen99965 я имею ввиду родина ее в иранском загросе

    • @XY-jw6hu
      @XY-jw6hu 8 місяців тому

      ​@@user-tr8yw9xs4qIt's in Anatolia. Then spreaded to rest of the world. The oldest J itself is found in somewhere in georgia.

  • @travelingva
    @travelingva 2 роки тому +5

    Would this include J-CTS5368

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому

      I have no data Ancient DNA of J-CTS5368.

    • @robertolang9684
      @robertolang9684 Рік тому

      @@geonomad1 is't j1

    • @koopon3900
      @koopon3900 Рік тому +1

      Yes, J-CTS5368 is what 23&ME calls J1

  • @stellajohnson-vives7055
    @stellajohnson-vives7055 8 місяців тому +4

    I am of Italian descent. My haplop is J1. FGC13863. I do not see this in your tree distribution. Is it under another group?

    • @Gorgina010
      @Gorgina010 8 місяців тому +2

      FGC13863 is a descendant of ZS241.
      ZS241 appears in the video at 10:06 in what is Lebanon and North Israel today. You had a Jewish or Phoenician male ancestor at some point in the last 5000 yrs.
      Likely origins in chronological order: Roman Empire, Byzantine refugee escaping Islamic expansion, Crusades & Crusader Kingdoms, or a Jew originating from the Northern Kingdom of Israel converted to Christianity (assuming, you're an ethnic Italian, not Jewish.).

    • @stellajohnson-vives7055
      @stellajohnson-vives7055 8 місяців тому

      @@Gorgina010 I agree with your response except tested negative to zs241. Still have some Ashkenazi Jewish at very small percentage. Male is from polinuro italy

    • @al3izmyy
      @al3izmyy 4 місяці тому

      So it is possible that you are a son of Abraham, either from Israel, or from (Ishmael, the father of the Arabs) lol the There will no longer be anyone who claims to be a son of Israel after today. We are Arabs here and Isaac and Ismail are brother. Either you are J1 or you do not claim to be Semitic.

    • @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942
      @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942 2 місяці тому

      Tu es d'origine arabe

  • @kurdishcivilengineer3144
    @kurdishcivilengineer3144 Рік тому +1

    Where does J-CTS5368 originate from? What country or what people it is associated with? Does anyone know?

  • @RobinHerzig
    @RobinHerzig Рік тому +2

    Except for that irritating auto voicing I love this content. Great work

  • @jaggg.3821
    @jaggg.3821 Рік тому +4

    Recognizing my answer won't be to thrilling but from what I've read in The Bible everybody currently dwelling in Asia/Asia Minor whose Nick Name is The Middle East are All Ancestors of Shem the first born Son and favored Son of Noah.
    Although, Bangladesh, India, Indonesia, Myanmar are split by Shem's Brother Japheth Father of the Aryan Race through the Indo-Aryans who migrated from Europe ah Russia, I think? into Bangladesh, India, Indonesia, & Myanmar.
    The point is This History Book; that I read when 15 year's old provided good
    Information about the whole meaning of Semites and Anti-Semitism.
    The name "A Nightmare in History"
    From 1933-1945 written by Miriam Chiklin the book immediately identifies Noah as Great-grandfather and Shem their father which is why they're identified as Semites the surname most likely of Shem.

  • @Mr.w5
    @Mr.w5 8 місяців тому +9

    I am Saudi and Arab, and the thing I am most surprised about is that I have cousins in Scotland

    • @danakaleb4882
      @danakaleb4882 8 місяців тому +1

      You’ve had naughty ancestors.

    • @s.smalls7449
      @s.smalls7449 7 місяців тому +3

      85% من السعوديين جيناتهم واحده ومرتبطه باسماعيل ويلتقون مع اليهود مباشره في ٤٠٠٠ سنه اليهود الكوهينم ابناء هارون وبعض الاشكناز

    • @maskfal9600
      @maskfal9600 7 місяців тому

      عبيد وجواري الأسر الحاكمة

    • @mahmoudaltanashi7412
      @mahmoudaltanashi7412 7 місяців тому

      ​@@s.smalls7449The Caucasian Khazars, who are called Ashkenazi, have the right to convert to Judaism, but they do not have the right to kill and displace the indigenous inhabitants of Palestine and seize their lands.

    • @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942
      @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942 2 місяці тому

      ​@@s.smalls7449les Hébreux est une tribu de sud de l'Arabie il faut faire la différence entre la religion et l'ethnie..tous les messagers et les prophètes sont arabes génétique et culturel et ils sont sur J1

  • @WayOfAges
    @WayOfAges 8 місяців тому +1

    What about mitochondrial DNA? This is inherited only through the maternal line, which sorts well with rabbinical law concerning ethnic Judaism.

  • @baranertas4799
    @baranertas4799 Місяць тому +1

    You explained it well. Haplogroup E is the one that spreads the Afroasiatic languages. Hebrew and Aramaic are in the Afroasiatic language group. Haplogroup J is the one that spreads the Caucasian languages ​​in general.

  • @BobJohnson648
    @BobJohnson648 7 місяців тому +3

    Has this channel explored the Khazar connection?

  • @dadsonworldwide3238
    @dadsonworldwide3238 Рік тому +4

    The mutation rates are causing problems for the age hypothesis. Very interesting data to watch. The evolutionary filters are problematic.

  • @wjf0ne
    @wjf0ne 7 місяців тому

    Should I just turn off the sound and read the subtitles or should I just pick another video as the robot voice is rubbish?

  • @whatabouttheearth
    @whatabouttheearth 7 місяців тому +2

    🤔 Is it actually accurate to say that Ydna R is the youngest?

    • @Andalusic
      @Andalusic 2 місяці тому

      Yes

    • @asimraja2431
      @asimraja2431 Місяць тому

      It is a younger haplotype but not the youngest.

  • @zaramot2796
    @zaramot2796 2 роки тому +7

    Спасибо, всё так же жду про E1b1b))

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +5

      It will be included within the next 4 or 5 episodes to be written.

    • @idostuff220
      @idostuff220 2 роки тому +1

      Awsome video idk if yout doing l3b1a ,but on the lookout. Keep up the good work

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому

      @@idostuff220 thanks

    • @amonali1464
      @amonali1464 2 роки тому +2

      @@geonomad1 eb1b1 123

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +2

      @@amonali1464 OK

  • @samer1900
    @samer1900 5 місяців тому +5

    20% of Jewish are semitic and belong genetically to the middle east area.. they r brothers to Arabs… however, 80% of Jewish r not semitic and not belong to middle east.. they r slavic and Caucasian.. Netanyahu is a good example of 100% European who claim he s semitic

  • @squid-squad
    @squid-squad 7 місяців тому

    The robot you use to convey this information causes me to look for this with a human speaking.

  • @multiolshop5894
    @multiolshop5894 Рік тому

    I wonder the progress of J1 project, if it still going on ?

  • @caink9142
    @caink9142 7 місяців тому +3

    Yes, we are all human and we often fight for resources, power, and land

  • @kenanhasan9784
    @kenanhasan9784 2 роки тому +8

    Thank you. I also include J1 haplogroup.

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +2

      👍👍👍👍👌

    • @matityahubenavraham2970
      @matityahubenavraham2970 2 роки тому

      If that's your picture you look like my Half sister's husband is an incredible coincidence

    • @kenanhasan9784
      @kenanhasan9784 2 роки тому +4

      @@matityahubenavraham2970 yes, thats may own picture. May be my ancestors came from Mediterranean coasts to eastern Anatolia )

    • @matityahubenavraham2970
      @matityahubenavraham2970 2 роки тому +3

      @@kenanhasan9784 Definitely yes!!

    • @matityahubenavraham2970
      @matityahubenavraham2970 2 роки тому +2

      @@kenanhasan9784 You really look Mediterranean and as Sicilians!! I have the same part of the Mediterranean look but I'm more like Atlantic Mediterraneans I am an extremely tall and brunette man

  • @carlosashkenazi
    @carlosashkenazi 10 місяців тому +2

    Dentro de um cromossomo y pessoal há várias informações da origem étnica antiga, essas informações estão espalhada no norte de de Portugal.

  • @timjb19621
    @timjb19621 Рік тому

    I can't tell if the narrator is a person or a computer generated voice, but it really bugs me that there are so many mispronounciations in this video.

  • @Theo-fc7et
    @Theo-fc7et Рік тому +23

    I’m Yemeni and I have 99% J-cts5368 according to 23andMe… 😅 my family comes from the mountains and we look mixed, I have relatives who have green eyes and blonde hair and relatives who would be considered black in America…

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  Рік тому +1

      👍👍👍👍👍

    • @EliyahuBenYehudahLevi
      @EliyahuBenYehudahLevi Рік тому +6

      Im Ashkenazi jewish and J1-CTS5368

    • @Theo-fc7et
      @Theo-fc7et Рік тому +2

      @@EliyahuBenYehudahLevi We aren’t so different aren’t we.

    • @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942
      @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942 Рік тому

      ​@@EliyahuBenYehudahLevitu es un vrai sémite 👍👍👍👍👍

    • @robertolang9684
      @robertolang9684 Рік тому +1

      @@EliyahuBenYehudahLevi right you were Ashkenazim Jew 40.000 years ago ha ha ha

  • @leoreid4805
    @leoreid4805 Рік тому +12

    Why did the Scottish clan of Graham have a J1-P58 haplogroup which is found around the middle east? I found out I have a subclade of this haplogroup and I am Scottish on my paternal side of the family. I also tested for 3% Jewish and this haplogroup is common in Jews so I am not sure if this haplogroup could relate to the Clan of Graham or a possible paternal Jewish ancestor from a few generations ago.

    • @mohamedalhaseey1749
      @mohamedalhaseey1749 Рік тому +4

      اليهود هجروا عندكم لفترات كبيره من الزمن وفي معتقدهم النسب للمراه ابن اليهوديه يهودي فشي طبيعي الزيجات منهم أكثر من في دوله اسرائيل من حاملي الR ومنهم العديد أريين

    • @Aeham_
      @Aeham_ Рік тому +13

      A lot of Caananites migrated to Scotland and Ireland.

    • @listenup2882
      @listenup2882 Рік тому +2

      Does this mean you're an Arab? Lol

    • @listenup2882
      @listenup2882 Рік тому

      @@Aeham_ evidence?

    • @listenup2882
      @listenup2882 Рік тому +1

      @@Aeham_ who says that Canaanites were J1?

  • @archeewaters
    @archeewaters Рік тому

    fascinating. wishing the automatic voice had a better capacity for correct pronounciation. other than that, excellent video

  • @DeanDana
    @DeanDana 7 місяців тому

    Interesting but can you fix the pronunciation? Audio sounds pretty janky

  • @ahmedaljamal6675
    @ahmedaljamal6675 2 роки тому +12

    يعني طلعنا نحنا J1 يا سلام حبيت هالسلالة 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸👌🏼

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому

      👌👌😊😊😊👍👍😍

    • @user-zl7cq9db3c
      @user-zl7cq9db3c 5 місяців тому

      لا تصدق هؤلاء الحاقدين

  • @danielch6662
    @danielch6662 Рік тому +5

    TLDR: yes, they do have different ancestors. They also have the same ancestors.
    Some of their ancestors are different, some are the same.

    • @Rai2M
      @Rai2M 8 місяців тому

      I can say the same thing about anyone but my brothers and sisters ))

  • @hassanalishah333
    @hassanalishah333 Місяць тому +1

    Not all Arabs are descendants of Ishmael, but most of the Jews and Arabs are the descendants of Ishmael Isaac, but their appearance are so similar to each other, there physical features are quite similar, their teeth, their noses, Their eyes, Their hair

  • @velvetunderpants44
    @velvetunderpants44 7 місяців тому +2

    Genetics are weird.
    They raise more questions than they answer.
    I'm Irish, but most of my ancient ancestors seem to have the Clovis signature...
    I'm assuming that people traveled across the Berring Strait several times in both directions

    • @labas9817
      @labas9817 5 місяців тому

      That's neat!

  • @edge2science
    @edge2science Рік тому +3

    A good reason to be fighting like the Hatfield's and McCoy's for the past 3000 years LO

    • @user-cg2tw8pw7j
      @user-cg2tw8pw7j Рік тому +3

      You know that these are from the Turkic Khazars, right?

    • @cl9615
      @cl9615 8 місяців тому

      @@user-cg2tw8pw7jDid you not watch the video? Or are you just dumb?

  • @robertab929
    @robertab929 8 місяців тому +4

    Y -haplogroups are not enough to describe ancestry.
    Remember that they are also mt-haplogroups and comparative genomics using whole genomes or multiple genes/SNPs.

    • @mujemoabraham6522
      @mujemoabraham6522 8 місяців тому +2

      It's more than enough to know your real origin / root .

    • @robertab929
      @robertab929 8 місяців тому +3

      @@mujemoabraham6522 No, it is not. Haplogroups show only partial information.
      Y-haplogroups show only inheritance in the male (paternal) line.
      mt haplogroups show only inheritance in the female (maternal) line.
      Whole genome analysis show all genetic information inherited from ancestors.

    • @mujemoabraham6522
      @mujemoabraham6522 8 місяців тому +3

      @@robertab929 We ( Arabs / Jews ) descendants of Ishmael / Isaac sons of Abraham belong to the same Haplogroup J1

    • @robertab929
      @robertab929 8 місяців тому +2

      @@mujemoabraham6522 You are mixing mythology with some genetics.
      Ishmael / Isaac are not real. Y-haplogroups are not enough to show full lineage.

    • @robertab929
      @robertab929 8 місяців тому +1

      @@mujemoabraham6522According to Bible, Abraham lived for 175 years. It simply not possible, and this makes difficult to believe that person existed as described.
      But this person has still important symbolic meaning.
      Other examples of Biblical longevity:
      (name) (age in years)
      Methuselah 969
      Jared 962
      Noah 950
      Adam 930
      Seth 912
      Kenan 910
      Enos 905
      Mahalalel 895

  • @shafialbanadir8334
    @shafialbanadir8334 Рік тому +1

    Where does J-L24 originate from?

  • @sheikowi
    @sheikowi 7 місяців тому +1

    If you find this confusing, it's because it's a weak science, constantly changing. This publicization game has been going on since the 1960s at least, and their "findings" are constantly changing. Hope they get it together quicker.

  • @natanyaaberra8735
    @natanyaaberra8735 Рік тому +11

    Arabs and European Jews are related. Haplogroup J originated in Asia not Africa. But, they are visitors in Egypt.
    Moreover, J1 is found in the Arabian peninsula. This Haplogroup was brought there by General Pompeii of Rome and his armies invaded the peninsula and were then bought J1 . Arabs came to Africa in the in the 7th Century A.D and brought J1 there too.

    • @farouk5753
      @farouk5753 Рік тому +7

      My wife is an Ashkenazi Jew, they are of French origin, the dnk test showed that she is Middle Eastern Levantine 72%, the rest is Greece and Mesopotamia

    • @farouk5753
      @farouk5753 Рік тому +2

      Since all European Jews are and Jews in the world are genetically related, Hitler did not like them because they are Semites and the people who joined their race Hitler said it himself, people still claim that he did not kill them because they are Semites, people are stupid

    • @farouk5753
      @farouk5753 Рік тому +6

      Jews and Samaritans have the same genetics

    • @farouk5753
      @farouk5753 Рік тому

      @user-lm2bn6tk7s Do you have an elongated face and tight narrow jaw?

    • @farouk5753
      @farouk5753 Рік тому +2

      @user-lm2bn6tk7s Most Jews mostly have and some Arabs also most members of Haplogroup IJ-J-I have elonget face narrow jaw

  • @tomorrowhowever7488
    @tomorrowhowever7488 5 місяців тому +3

    WOW! It's amazing that so many wealthy, important and powerful people made their DNA test results public! NOT.

  • @leroidaviD.
    @leroidaviD. 11 місяців тому +2

    Greetings. Brazilian here. Im part of j1 Haplogroup.

  • @Youve_GotABeard
    @Youve_GotABeard 8 місяців тому +2

    What is J-L556? This came out as my Y haplogroup.

    • @user-yr3dd3zb1q
      @user-yr3dd3zb1q Місяць тому +1

      Germany. Poland and Ukraine not related to J1

    • @Youve_GotABeard
      @Youve_GotABeard Місяць тому

      @@user-yr3dd3zb1q That’s amazing. Thank you. Do you know something more?

  • @anthonysimon4991
    @anthonysimon4991 Рік тому +3

    I am J-m267 and I am Scandinavian Lombard Italian, Blnd/Blue.

    • @DreamworldAkB
      @DreamworldAkB 4 місяці тому

      Haplogroup has nothing to do with race/ethnicity
      It only means one of your thousand of ancestors belonged to that origin , in reality haplogroup test is bullshit, only autosomal DNA test shows your true ethnicity/race/origin

  • @LBUKRK
    @LBUKRK Рік тому +3

    So nice

  • @bigthurl5613
    @bigthurl5613 Рік тому

    What are the Sub-groups of the J Halopgroup?

    • @robertolang9684
      @robertolang9684 Рік тому

      ho man so many branches, to be honest i don't pic religious topics in genetics because believes are not connected to DNA but the tora the most old religious book started with moses a egyptian a Hebrew, a black man a north afrikaner ,Abraham is a story not well written , at his times the writing was not yet invented no tora yet so no records of anything

  • @jglenn2282
    @jglenn2282 Рік тому

    When did J1 arrive in Egypt, North Africa and east Africa?

    • @robertolang9684
      @robertolang9684 8 місяців тому

      in egypt sice as 18 dinasty , there is a mumy j1 , but they hide its genetic origins to not change the set narratives

  • @ADAM-lc9xb
    @ADAM-lc9xb 2 роки тому +22

    I'm from Yemen ❤️🇾🇪.
    The original features of the Arabs have a long nose like a sword, eyes as wide as a falcon, thick black hair, a white face and brown eyes. These are the features of the people of Yemen and the features of the inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula.

    • @AbuAhmad.i
      @AbuAhmad.i Рік тому +5

      عاش لكن قبل ثلاثين سنة مافي شي اسمه دوله اليمن

    • @ayahaqeel1782
      @ayahaqeel1782 Рік тому +3

      White face that means you guys are ghost 👻 😭🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @user-yl3mc8ix7l
      @user-yl3mc8ix7l Рік тому +3

      @@AbuAhmad.i قصدك قبل ثلاثين سنة ما شيء اسمه دول الخليج

    • @AbuAhmad.i
      @AbuAhmad.i Рік тому +1

      @@user-yl3mc8ix7l قبل ثلاثين سنة مافي شي اسمه دوله اليمن هذي قمهورية صنعانية عفاشية طلعت بعام تسعين بعد احتلالهم للجنوب العربي وحضرموت باسم اليمن الجهوي

    • @a.r2714
      @a.r2714 Рік тому

      @@AbuAhmad.i جاك العمليقي المستعرب
      المتأزدن

  • @TheHamburglarHelpster
    @TheHamburglarHelpster Рік тому +7

    I'm south Italian, Germanic and Jewish and have haplogroup J1

    • @TheHamburglarHelpster
      @TheHamburglarHelpster Рік тому +1

      @@splat496 and another site said H as maternal and r1b I'm so confused bro 😂

    • @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942
      @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942 Рік тому +2

      Tu es un un vrai hébreu et Sémite 👍👍👍👍

    • @Sa-k50350
      @Sa-k50350 8 місяців тому +1

      👍J1 ابراهيمي

    • @MohamedAhmed-eg3mh
      @MohamedAhmed-eg3mh 8 місяців тому +3

      There was a tunisian Arab Emirate in southern Italy

    • @AbuAhmad.i
      @AbuAhmad.i 7 місяців тому +1

      J1-Z640 🇸🇦

  • @franciscoosuna259
    @franciscoosuna259 2 роки тому

    Is the title being facetious? I listened to most of this but stopped as the narrative makes no statement (so far, and does not appear to be the intent). I gather that Jews and Arabs share a lot of the same ancestry. Is that the bottom line?

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +5

      Their common ancestor is thought to have had Y-DNA J.

    • @omaratamimi2372
      @omaratamimi2372 2 роки тому +2

      @Francisco Osuna Nope, we are not related. But if you are saying as in general (humans) then yes humans are all related in one way or another.

    • @franciscoosuna259
      @franciscoosuna259 2 роки тому +1

      @@omaratamimi2372 you are saying that there is no relation, and then later say that there is a common ancestor. Can you clarify? For example my family story says that in the late 1500's 3 brothers arrived in Vera Cruz Mexico. One, Diego, started a family line that eventually arrived in San Diego California in early 1700's and is now converted to Protestant. The other brother, Francisco, started a family line that eventually arrived in Albuquerque in 1625 and still Catholic. Using this as a model of Arab and Jewish DNA links: I believe you are saying that Francisco and Diego are not related although they share a common ancestor. Is that what you assert?

    • @omaratamimi2372
      @omaratamimi2372 2 роки тому

      @@franciscoosuna259 “you are saying there is no relation, and then later say there is a common ancestor. Can you clarify?” Yes, Arabs and Jews aren’t related to one another. We share a common ancestor like everyone else, humans are one species that originate from north east Africa. There has been a lot of migration and incest for everyone to be connected to another person somehow. Diego and Francisco and the other unnamed brother are related to each other because they are brothers.

    • @xdan0263
      @xdan0263 2 роки тому +1

      Its complicated, since not all jews and not all Arabs have the same haplogroup , jews can be j1 or j2 or ep1 p1 or even R . Also Arabs can be j1 or j2 or T or others .people mix and migrate, change language or religion, but certainly, the true descendants of Ismael and and true descendants of Isaac are cousins.

  • @charlesdaniels-kg7bj
    @charlesdaniels-kg7bj Рік тому

    Yes but why please tell me why black Americans blood DNA keeps coming up abo by the 23and me tell me if we aren't the Hebrew Jews of the bible why it matches the blood on the sgt of Turin

  • @boulanuaryesaf1989
    @boulanuaryesaf1989 2 роки тому +42

    I'm from Algeria 🇩🇿 and my haplogroup is j1 (I'm arabien)

    • @yakmi1116
      @yakmi1116 2 роки тому +18

      مرحباً بكم إخواننا العرب في الجزائر.
      عربي سعودي j1
      🇩🇿❤️🇸🇦

    • @boulanuaryesaf1989
      @boulanuaryesaf1989 2 роки тому +11

      الله يبارك فيك أخي كلنا عرب و كلنا إخوة في الدين و الأصل 🇩🇿❤️🇸🇦

    • @larbichehmat8999
      @larbichehmat8999 Рік тому +4

      You are Karghouli(كرغولي).

    • @lukman_427
      @lukman_427 Рік тому +1

      @@larbichehmat8999 لا اعتقد سنغولي

    • @lukman_427
      @lukman_427 Рік тому

      من اي ولاية انت؟

  • @aimenaymen8692
    @aimenaymen8692 8 місяців тому +6

    Actually you have to differentiate between Israelites and Jews Israelites are 12 arabic tribes formed by the 12 sons of Isaac however Je some of the Jews are Nordic and kzar tribes that doesn't have to do with the area and they embraced the Judaism most of them are ishkinaz

    • @tatertots0046
      @tatertots0046 8 місяців тому +4

      Polish Jews & Austrian Jews have the same ancestry as Polish & Austrian Catholics they are not related at all to the brown skin Hebrew Speaking Jews of Jerusalem in the 1800s 1700s 1600s etc

    • @user-zl7cq9db3c
      @user-zl7cq9db3c 5 місяців тому

      ​@@tatertots0046
      The J gene was established in the Arabian Peninsula, specifically in the southwestern coast of the island, and the greatest concentration and purity of the J gene is found in that place among the tribes, and this is consistent with the Islamic narrative, as there were the ancestors of the current Arabs, such as: the Prophet Ibrahim, Ismael, and Ishac.
      It also agrees with the popular Arabic narrative about the ancestors of the Arabs of Yemen, such as: Saba / Hud Aber / Qahtan / Ya’arub / karbeal / sharhabeal
      I do not believe that there is a relationship between the Arabs (people with olive skin) and the Scandinavian race (people with white skin) in southern Europe and the northern Arab world. There is a natural mixing between the two parties. It is a demographic border.

    • @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942
      @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942 2 місяці тому

      Bravo .les Hébreux sont des Arabes de sud de l'Arabie y a une différence entre la religion et l'ethnie.la majorité des juifs de nos jours sont des descendants de convertis .les vrais Hébreux sont seulement sur J1

    • @mybodyisamachine
      @mybodyisamachine День тому

      ​@@tatertots0046 who told you this

    • @tatertots0046
      @tatertots0046 День тому

      @@mybodyisamachine research + common sense

  • @ALI44344
    @ALI44344 6 місяців тому +1

    اريد اسماء الكتب المختصه بهذا البحث والتقرير

  • @Professional_Youtube_Commenter
    @Professional_Youtube_Commenter 8 місяців тому

    I want to know where this youtuber got dna samples of saudis and emirate ruling familes

  • @aphelios9157
    @aphelios9157 Рік тому +3

    Both are descendents of Abraham, whether he was a real person or not, the point is a common ancestor.

  • @MariaNI-yf1bz
    @MariaNI-yf1bz 7 місяців тому +7

    @01:40 North Africa is predominately E1b1-M81(the Berber or Amazigh marker) and E1b1b-M78(not macro E-M78*=Iberomaurusian)and indigenous to the Nile Valley, so this map is wrong and based only on assumptions. North Africa is not " Arab" its Amazigh (Berber) and Egyptian/ Coptic, still of indigenous, predominantly local North African(100 precent Eurasian) origin. The near Eastern conquest that converted the people into Islam made virtually no impact on the genomic local scale. It was mainly about leadership, not to 'replace' nor that there is any evidence of any sort of "ge n ocide" Do not confuse the European migrations to the new world with the history of the MENA region.

  • @danchokonstantinov6735
    @danchokonstantinov6735 8 місяців тому +1

    The most recent sequencing of Y chromosome - T2T Consortium sequencing has shown surprisingly that nearly 1/2 or roughly 30 M Y chromosome DNA bp are palindromic repeats ! How bizzare to say that 1/2 of Y Chromosome is subject to mutations and 1/2 is not ! The Haplogroups are PRESUMED mutations in time started from a SINGLE patrilineage / one male . Secondly if mutations have occurred over this extended period , how come these mutations have NOT caused azospermia /sterility and testes dystrophies / i.e. the first male had the same libido, fertility , testicular volume and morphology as present day males ! Furtheremore if we accept future mutations, it natural to expect disappearance of the Y Chromosome ! I my opinion haplogroupings are simply proginy of polymorphysm, which has been PRE-PROGRAMMED ! Evidence - no one has done Y Chromosome sequencing on male older than 100 years ! Thus said there is no EVOLUTION but genetic pre determined polymorphysm and inter-breeds !

  • @matthieucql1074
    @matthieucql1074 Рік тому +1

    Hi ! i'm J-L26 but i don't find it. Is it J1 or J2 ? thanks for the video !

  • @joedee1863
    @joedee1863 7 місяців тому +2

    A very close related family who havent learned family unity or how to share...😢

    • @marylou3995
      @marylou3995 7 місяців тому +1

      Join the club!

    • @joedee1863
      @joedee1863 7 місяців тому

      I take it back, I've just been corrected by an Ishmaelite prince....
      Palestinians are not Arabs! They are Turks and Syrians and many other ancient races botched together.
      They are not offspring of Abraham.
      So apologies for that ...
      I stand corrected.

  • @AbuAhmad.i
    @AbuAhmad.i Рік тому +22

    We The Azd Arabian Sabaean tribe in Hijaz mountains region 🇸🇦 and Oman(magan) region 🇦🇪🇴🇲 are J1-‎Z640 👍🏻

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji Рік тому +7

      Salam alaykom brother. I am from South Tunisia and i am an arab that belong to banu hilal and banu hilal is a adnani in lineage.
      But my paternal haplogroup is j-m267 known as j1.
      All adnani Arab tribes are majority j1.
      It’s a surprise that qahtan and Adnan belong to j1 haplogroup❤

    • @user-mp5jo6yn6o
      @user-mp5jo6yn6o Рік тому +1

      انتم على zs4740

    • @robertolang9684
      @robertolang9684 Рік тому +3

      @@Football-ko1ji tuniasian are not arabs they are africaine , the same of egyptian africaine , vos etre afrikaine

    • @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942
      @abdelkaderbenchamakh8942 Рік тому +4

      @@robertolang9684 nous sommes des arabes nous n'avons aucun lien avec les barbares et les africains

    • @thamer6025
      @thamer6025 Рік тому

      ظافر ابي اسآلك عن هذا التحور لانه طلع لي بفاميلي تري، ممكن تعطيني تويتر او الانستا حقك

  • @ranro7371
    @ranro7371 8 місяців тому

    j2 is an artificial haplogroup, last common ancestor it had with j2 was estimated at 1000 years ago, It also OBVIOUSLY originated in Yemen with basically 100% j* haplotype.

  • @__-zr6ry
    @__-zr6ry 8 місяців тому +1

    It's from Khazaria?

  • @azadmamedov7123
    @azadmamedov7123 Рік тому +4

    I am J1c3d FTDNA. kit 206175 Azerbajan DNA project.

  • @liorsultanov2970
    @liorsultanov2970 Рік тому +6

    J1 is my haplogroup

    • @liorsultanov2970
      @liorsultanov2970 Рік тому +1

      @علي الحكلي الكِندي🇦🇪
      Do not remember brother. Will look it up.

  • @ghoduknvvgllhgbn9704
    @ghoduknvvgllhgbn9704 Місяць тому

    I fell on haplogroup J1. My characteristics: I am 180 cm tall, slim, and have dark skin, but I am not black. My eyebrows are thick, my eyelashes are also thick, and my hair is black and curly.

  • @abdelhadihajji8773
    @abdelhadihajji8773 10 місяців тому +1

    I'm J -cts 5368 Asie occidentale et Afrique du Nord
    99,6 %
    Nord-Africain
    96,4 %
    Arabe, égyptien et levantin
    3,2 % please any explication thanks and what does it mean -cts 5368

  • @NotLeftarded1
    @NotLeftarded1 8 місяців тому +3

    Youngest means newest most evolved , an amalgamation of all the goodness that came before. The best of everything put into one.

    • @user-cg2tw8pw7j
      @user-cg2tw8pw7j 8 місяців тому

      Jesus: No, the Khazars are stupid, but you are talking about the Rothschild family

    • @metacomet2066
      @metacomet2066 4 місяці тому

      Maybe it's just the most mutated. 🦍😄

  • @martinmaltbor1290
    @martinmaltbor1290 Рік тому +15

    As far as I know Jews and Arabs are both semitic people who share a common ancestor on the paternal side which is Abraham and on their maternal side, they have two different ancestors or mothers.
    So genetically they are half brothers and half sisters.

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji Рік тому

      j-p58 is responsible for semetic language.
      Brother J-p58 came to arabia more 9000-10.000 years ago. And all Arab Tribes have it at 80-95%
      As all Arabs and the Cohen( descendants of Aaron) are j1c3d.
      (((And j1c3d is a descendent of j-p58 pure semetic hqplogroup )))
      And j1c3d is proven to be Abraham haplogroup because it fits very well.
      Not Jews take a maternal lineage to determand Ito be Jewish . While the Cohen are the only to take paternal lineage and they Are descendants of Abraham paternally (j1c3d)
      The lemba Jewish tribes in south Africa and Zimbabwe have the j1c3d wich is Abrahamic
      E1b1* is nearly 40-50 thousand years old so it’s not Abraham.
      The natufians were all exact e-z830 within only E1b1b
      While e1b1a people spoke Proto-niger-Congo-languages and bantu languages
      and e1b1a has absolutely nothing to do with Afro asiatic languages because e1b1a never ever was in levant. E1b1a was always in west/central Africa since e1b1 spiltet 50.000 years ago.
      Now Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade
      Very simple.

    • @zokavulin
      @zokavulin Рік тому +4

      @@Football-ko1ji Abraham was a Hurrian ,Schasu that did take out his people 3 000 years ago have been Arabic people from Jordania

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji Рік тому

      @@zokavulin yes I know

    • @mrvk39
      @mrvk39 Рік тому +8

      Abraham isn't a scientific reference point. But, yes, on paternal side they share Semitic DNA and maternal, most Ashkenazi Jews share North Italian DNA - probably from the time men migrated from Palestine to the Roman Empire either as slaves or traders/laborers and then married to local women. Apparently, this practice was so concerning, Jewish Rabbis then changed Jewish ancestry from their father's side to mother's side to discourage the practice of marrying local women in Europe

    • @kenlieberman4215
      @kenlieberman4215 Рік тому +2

      @@mrvk39 Don't be ridiculous.

  • @vincentrockel1149
    @vincentrockel1149 7 місяців тому

    Arab seems to suggest a ethnic group while, unless referring to historical jews, the moniker jew suggests religious affiliation, not ethnicity.

  • @gamalnassertv
    @gamalnassertv Місяць тому +1

    J1 is frequent in many of the Northeast African ethnic-groups.
    Sudanese Arabs 50%
    Sudanese Copts 45%
    Nubians 40%
    Beja 40%
    Ethio-Semites 30%
    ....etc

  • @Yekemcar
    @Yekemcar Рік тому +13

    Most remarkable thing that haplogroup J (both branch J1, J2) are coming from Caucasian region then spread to south in ~40,000 years ago ... !!!🤔

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji Рік тому

      j-p58 is responsible for semetic language.
      Brother J-p58 came to arabia more 9000-10.000 years ago. And all Arab Tribes have it at 80-95%
      As all Arabs and the Cohen( descendants of Aaron) are j1c3d.
      (((And j1c3d is a descendent of j-p58 pure semetic hqplogroup )))
      And j1c3d is proven to be Abraham haplogroup because it fits very well.
      Not Jews take a maternal lineage to determand Ito be Jewish . While the Cohen are the only to take paternal lineage and they Are descendants of Abraham paternally (j1c3d)
      The lemba Jewish tribes in south Africa and Zimbabwe have the j1c3d wich is Abrahamic
      E1b1* is nearly 40-50 thousand years old so it’s not Abraham.
      The natufians were all exact e-z830 within only E1b1b
      While e1b1a people spoke Proto-niger-Congo-languages and bantu languages
      and e1b1a has absolutely nothing to do with Afro asiatic languages because e1b1a never ever was in levant. E1b1a was always in west/central Africa since e1b1 spiltet 50.000 years ago.
      Now Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade
      Very simple.

    • @mrvk39
      @mrvk39 Рік тому

      these are probably original farmers who spread through the Middle East and replaced and mixed with Neolihic hunter-gathers that lived in the Middle East. It would make sense that they would dominate, since farming produced far greater populations vs. ones produced by hunter-gatherers.

    • @Liz-nx2br
      @Liz-nx2br 10 місяців тому

      Hmm I’m J1D , I’m from Eritrea , Africa. Confusing….??

    • @MohamedAhmed-eg3mh
      @MohamedAhmed-eg3mh 8 місяців тому +1

      Yeah, they're the orginal Caucasians

    • @user-zl7cq9db3c
      @user-zl7cq9db3c 7 місяців тому

      If there are a lot of Caucasian Europeans mixed with Arabs, it does not mean that Arabs come from the Caucasus
      You say that Africans come from Latin America because there are a lot of blacks in Latin America mixed with the local population

  • @zg104
    @zg104 Рік тому +10

    We all are human and living creatures first and foremost

  • @komolkovathana8568
    @komolkovathana8568 7 місяців тому

    01:42 your assumption (theory) is based on the idea that the original genes are still remain in the people around Caucasus (mountain) range, hence nominated "Caucasian" Tribe or Caucasoids, (around Georgia and Azerbaijan, etc). Due to the fact that in ancient time, they (the whole community) were quite "sessile/well-settled" to the farmland and (at least the greater portion) were hardly moved to s'where else. ..But what if there was some place, where the people settled long, long BEFORE living in Caucasus mountain.. ie near/closed to AFRICAN continent, like Syria (today's) or Senai and the Nile Delta..or even in PERSIA/Mesopotamia (including middle East) how come your (geo-) Politics assumption were based on that the WHOLE mother genes of the (post) NEO-Lithic 's were all came (originally) from Caucasoids in (western) Central Asia, and not s'where BEFORE that. You can "centralised" the Mother Genes as in Balkan or in Rome (Both geo-politics Centers of ancient World, but for certain..non-Biological point.)

    • @komolkovathana8568
      @komolkovathana8568 7 місяців тому

      From Biological point of view, the Genetic MUTATION/Variation is quite Continuous Process. No any time stopped/fixed no matter when we/you stayed s'where for very very long long period of time, eg in African Steppe, in the Nile delta or in Crescent Moon Valley, your inside coding (that control our regeneration and survival), your genes keep-on changing, including BEFORE the ROUGH Terrian of the Mountain ( that's very hard to PLANT, just nomadic lifestyle of Shepherd or some wild fruits collectors. (No wheat & Grains yet..?)

  • @tilz393
    @tilz393 Рік тому

    everyone on earth sooooooooo closely related any comment on any differences is pride the ones you insult are your brothers like it or not wanta bet

  • @gojkosimovljevic
    @gojkosimovljevic Рік тому +7

    Jews and Arabs have same Ydna J1 but different mtdna.

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  Рік тому

      👌👍👍👍👍

    • @eytharburhan8869
      @eytharburhan8869 Рік тому +2

      Even Arabs have mtdna K but very different versions

    • @user-jr4kc6lu9q
      @user-jr4kc6lu9q Рік тому +1

      Sometimes Jews and Arabs share the same mtDNA haplogroups too. For example, HV1b2 is shared between Ashkenazi Jews and Arabs from the United Arab Emirates, J1b1a3 is shared between Syrian Jews and Palestinian Arabs, and L3x1a is shared between Yemenite Jews and Saudi Arabians.

    • @user-zl7cq9db3c
      @user-zl7cq9db3c 5 місяців тому +1

      The J gene was established in the Arabian Peninsula, specifically in the southwestern coast of the island, and the greatest concentration and purity of the J gene is found in that place among the tribes, and this is consistent with the Islamic narrative, as there were the ancestors of the current Arabs, such as: the Prophet Ibrahim, Ismael, and Ishac.
      It also agrees with the popular Arabic narrative about the ancestors of the Arabs of Yemen, such as: Saba / Hud Aber / Qahtan / Ya’arub / karbeal / sharhabeal
      I do not believe that there is a relationship between the Arabs (people with olive skin) and the Scandinavian race (people with white skin) in southern Europe and the northern Arab world. There is a natural mixing between the two parties. It is a demographic border.

  • @daxconnell7661
    @daxconnell7661 Рік тому +15

    Abraham had Ishmael with Hagar(Egyptian) that became the ancestor of the Arab people even according to Jewish and Islamic traditions and is also accepted by Christianity, and later Isaac with his wife Sarah to become the ancestor of the Jews, which would fit the genetics found

    • @zokavulin
      @zokavulin Рік тому

      for all what we know arbaham was a hurrian from Urkesh 4 000 years ago ...his descendants have been wiped out from schasu(arabs) from jodania around 3000 years ago that did take over the culture and history of his descendants though women they did take

    • @RyujinRyujin-uy2wm
      @RyujinRyujin-uy2wm Рік тому +2

      Sarah is the mother of isaac

    • @here_we_go_again2571
      @here_we_go_again2571 Рік тому

      Sarah was Abraham's
      kinswoman (relative)
      Hagar was a slave given
      to Sarah by the Egyptian
      Pharoh.
      Abraham's father,
      Terah, and Abraham
      migrated from Ur
      of the Chaldees
      (located in the
      southern area
      of the modern
      country of Iraq)
      TO
      Harran (or nearby
      that ancient site)
      Located (exact
      spot unknown)
      in what is now
      southeastern
      Turkey/northern Iraq/
      eastern Syria[1]
      1.) Ur of the Chaldees
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ur_of_the_Chaldees
      "Other sites traditionally thought to be Abraham's birthplace are in the vicinity of the city of *Edessa* ( *Şanlıurfa* in modern south eastern Turkey). Traditional Jewish and Muslim authorities, such as Maimonides and Josephus, placed Ur Kaśdim at various Upper Mesopotamian or at other southeast Anatolian sites[citation needed] such as *Urkesh* ,
      *Urartu* , *Urfa* , or *Kutha* ."
      Traders from Ur of the Chaldees are known to have settled in the above-mentioned areas.
      So, the idea of someone moving from what is now southern Iraq, northward through the
      fertile cresent to (roughly) southeastern Turkey is likely. It is also likely that someone
      from/near Harran might migrate westward and southward into the Levant and eventually
      make their way to Egypt and back into Canaan.

    • @patricioferreira5495
      @patricioferreira5495 Рік тому +8

      No, even when Ibrahim (Abraham) arrived in Meca, arabs were already present there. The ancestor of arabs (as well jews) is Oud (Heber), the greatgrandfather of Ibrahim (Abraham), before him.

    • @multiolshop5894
      @multiolshop5894 Рік тому

      Yes so it mix with Hagar haplogroup (derived from Hagar father) but I don't know what their haplogroup ? African or another Egypt tribe ?

  • @claudebuysse7482
    @claudebuysse7482 Рік тому +2

    Some archeologist from Israel think that the palestinians are the descendent of the jews who were converterd by Islam during their expansion. And The semitic people had same sort of alpabet . Not the Indo-European.

    • @here_we_go_again2571
      @here_we_go_again2571 Рік тому +4

      There are a lot of
      Palestinian people
      whose families were
      once Christians at
      sone time too.
      Ditto with some
      people in areas
      of Syria and Turkey
      as well as portions
      of Arabia.
      During the time of
      the Roman empire
      there were Jews
      living on both sides
      of the Red Sea as
      well as in Yemen
      and Ethiopia.
      There are very some
      very old houses in the
      West Bank that have
      a star of David engraved
      in the stone over the
      door. (I saw a video
      about it once)

    • @johankarlsson6
      @johankarlsson6 3 місяці тому

      Greeks and minoans had alphabeth related to that of the semite tribes. It was based on syllables rather than symbols.

  • @TuPerCent
    @TuPerCent Рік тому

    If Jacob & Esau are twins then how could their offspring not share genes & be cousins? Abraham was called out of Iraq so they should have shared genes as well?
    Josephs sons were Egyptian.
    Does this mean the Jewish peoples are cousins to all of these distinct people groups?
    I'm just trying to figure this out
    It's complicated🤔🙃

    • @algarniAS
      @algarniAS Рік тому +4

      False Jewish legends are the cause of all this chaos. Genes have proven the sincerity of Arab historians and that they were right in that the Amalekites (العماليق - The Gaints) are the Canaanites and not the sons of Esau.
      According to Arab historians, the Amalekites who are fighting the Israelis in Palestine are the same Ancient Arab Canaanites who taught Ismail the Arabic language and he married a women from them and became an Arab like them. They were Bedouins and fierce fighters and their bodies were huge, so the Ismailis called them Amalek (This is the secret of the name that the Jews and Christians do not know where it came from , It means The giants in the Arabic language)
      Those Jewish legends are the result of their failure to fight them, and their betrayal of Moses and Haron, -peace be upon them- .

  • @sasshiro
    @sasshiro 9 місяців тому +7

    I’m just here to read the comments, getting my popcorn ready…

  • @zerguioussamaabdallah8369
    @zerguioussamaabdallah8369 2 роки тому +8

    A little correction : J1 in Algeria is 35% not 22%

    • @geonomad1
      @geonomad1  2 роки тому +5

      Thanks. Mistyping!!

    • @amazingamazigh6847
      @amazingamazigh6847 2 роки тому +6

      Not true, its lower than 22%! More like 5%. In Morocco its less than 1%! Stop your arab propaganda!

    • @amazingamazigh6847
      @amazingamazigh6847 2 роки тому

      @Ainz Ooal Gown arab history books sure know how to brainwash people haha. The Maghreb countries have almost 0% middle eastern dna! J is almost non existyin Morocco and Algeria and also Tunisia! The arab tribes migrations are a hoax and fairy tales!

    • @amazingamazigh6847
      @amazingamazigh6847 2 роки тому

      @Ainz Ooal Gown youre full of shi.t haha. 99,99% of Algerians are Berbers or Arabized Berbers!

    • @zerguioussamaabdallah8369
      @zerguioussamaabdallah8369 2 роки тому +3

      @@amazingamazigh6847 Algeria is indeed 35% J1 bro , Just check europedia (scientific page )
      This isn't propaganda, it's just the truth

  • @ljeanabldr
    @ljeanabldr 7 місяців тому

    What's J1C2?