Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays! This is part 1 and part 2 of a video from a while back put together as the full movie. Didn’t want to make a new video on Christmas but still wanted to upload, so I hope you enjoy!
Merry Christmas and thank you! Day 34 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
Genuinely crazy how actually knowing how a story should end and understanding character motivations makes for a good story. Even crazier that a SINGLE FAN can write a better story than an entire company.
That's what happens when you don't have to make concessions to the art to please a failed creative who instead had his uncle get him a job as an executive for the studio. That's why a lot of art house indie films tend to be better than major blockbusters plot wise or just in terms of creativity and originality. It's not always that the director has a better vision. They just didn't have to get that vision approved by Kathleen Kennedy.
@@BC92Se7en Right, but youre forgetting the decisions Quigon would have made. He does not see himself as "the best Jedi", even in this rendition of events, Quigon's next move after accepting Yoda stepping down was _not_ to take power and command for himself, but to recommend open minds and always keep a seat left open that the leaders take turns sitting in.
Although it was predictable that Maul would be the one to carry the dark side forward, I loved how this played out with the Jedi under new management and balancing their roles as warriors and peacekeepers! Plus, it was a great way to wrap it up with Anakin getting to fulfill his role as the chosen one even though he wasn't the one to kill Sidious.
I watch *ONE* video talking about Star Wars in an alternate timeline and now the UA-cam ads won’t leave me alone💀 I guess it’s worth it though to see content like this. So thank you.
Pretty engrossing! I think one of the takeaways for Qui-Gon's new Jedi Order, was the Jedi can't be afraid of the Dark Side. They don't have to embrace it, but they do have to understand it. Courtesy of Count Dooku. Also the corrupt chancellor should have faced a huge backlash for abandoning the Jedi in their time of need. Perhaps he ordered a comms-blackout of the outer rim, supposedly to avoid public panic. 37:43 Hey! That ship is from the wrong universe! LOL
One I've always been curious about. What if Ezra Bridger missed Obi-Wan and stumbled onto Luke Skywalker when he went to Tantooine? They would be about the same age. Ezra and Luke could very easily team up and find both back with the ghost crew. Now wouldn't that change, I don't know...; EVERYTHING!? Just a thought.
The Jedi Order was always pulled in too many directions. They followed the will of the people, the will of the Republic, and the will of the Force. During Yoda's time, the Jedi Council seems to have gotten lazy and assumed that the will of the people and the will of the Republic are the same. Qui Gon would have had the Jedi follow the will of the Force which would have mostly aligned with the will of the people. This would be a tremendous improvement for the Jedi Order. Conflict would then arise when the will of the force and the will of the Republic come into disagreement. Very similar to Luke's Jedi Order that tended to butt heads with the New Republic.
Lovely job with this, and unlike when the reinforcements arrive in Rise of Skywalker, you actually set up early on why the Outer Rim peoples would want to come to the heroes aid.
Rise of Skywalker was the worst of all the films - a hidden Sith fleet of hundreds of thousands of people, no economy to build or support them... K. Then the deus ex machina of the "good guys" showing up. Such lazy writing.
Where would Ahsoka, Ventress, Jango, Satine, and other noteworthy characters (not including clones since they were never created) fit into all this? Would Ahsoka still have become Anakin's padawan? Would Ventress have becoem the Jedi her master trained her to be? Would Jango have ever fathered a son to carry on his legacy? Would Satine and Obi-wan have rekindled their love?
The clones we'd created. They were ordered years prior. Jango would have still gotten his clone to raise.ashoka would still have been trained so would ventress
Woow, just woww. I love this video. My new favorite "What If" right next to Anakin leaving the order with Ahsoka. It felt a little iffy at first with Maul's defeat, but aside from that, everything was such a great story. This wpuld make a perfect alternative to the story we got.
I sometimes wonder If Dooku would have been anywhere near as effective, If anyone other than Christopher Lee had played him? In some respects the Star Wars prequels have something in common with the Fox X-Men series in that even its biggest detractors can't say enough good things about how certain actors nailed their roles, like with Patrick Stewart, Kelsey Grammar etc in X-Men and I'd assume the same for the likes of Liam Neeson, Christopher Lee and others in the prequels.
@terynmallory9764 by the time of The Phantom Menace, Dooku was already exploring the Dark Side. But Qui Gon’s death was the catalyst that pushed him that much quicker. But, outside of @StarWarsGalaxy’s theory, if Qui Gon Jinn survived then I believe Dooku still would have turned.
Ik this comment is super late but I have to say it’s nice to see these kind of fan fictions again reminds me of the good old days of Star Wars theory. “No I’m not saying anything bad about Star Wars theory I love Star Wars theory in fact” But I do have to say you bring back that old feeling to when I was a teenager of truly enjoying Star Wars fan fiction and I can’t be the only one who feels this way so keep up the good work!!
Qui Gon had survived Darth Maul saber duel, and basically the profecy would have been nulled. That's the paradigm of religions. Had he survived, Anakin would have been his disciple for sure, and the prophecy would not matter. He is a beacon, a teacher, a guide, he is not for the council as many say. Qui Gon represents the change, a different point of view, and that's something the Jedi Order didn't want. He would have personally taken care and guided Anakin in a way that he would become a sentinel 100%. I'm even sure that, if Mace Windu were to be alive following this logic, he would have taught him his style not to be his disciple, but to create a form to counter him. He had the talent, a perfect master in Qui Gon, and also Obi Wan as senior. Had given time, the most efficient way for Anakin to train would be teaching him all the basic forms in the 7 styles, to let him create a form which could be the perfect counter for dueling. He is more akin to combat than be a force user.
I remember Mother Tal Zin saying Savage had greater potential then Maul which is likely why Palpatine slew him while still so inexperienced and weak and took Maul who was the bigger threat at that time. He didn't want to risk Savage escaping like Maul did and finding a new master to finish his training since there was no chance in the situation Savage would turn to Palpatine or Dooku for what they have done to him personally
I do wish some clones including Rex were completed and they were able to find new paths instead of default soldiers but this was a great story either way
QuiGon: You will never win Sidious Sidious: Anakin join me and we can rule the galaxy together!!! Anakin: Never!!! I am a Jedi like Qui Gon before me!!! Sidious: So be it… Master JEDI!!! Que Epic Battle of Ass kicking AWESOMENESS!!!!
8:00.....there's no way, Sidious would have sensed a wavering as soon as Dooku betrayed him, or at the very least sensed all those forced users heading his way and got the hell out of there. He's not stupid.
Sideous is known to be overconfident and assume the darkness will win out in people. He did the same thing with Anakin and Vader at the end of Return of the Jedi. It makes sense that he'd be overconfident this time as well when he thinks he's completely fooled everyone.
Besides even in legends it was the death of anakin solo that messed her up and sent her on the path to darkness. She blamed the Skywalker clan. Luke Leia Jacen Jaina Mara Ben skywalker. Those were who she hated that sent her over. Plus a nightsister
What if a coup happened directly inside the jedi order, a group of insurrectionist jedi had enough of the clone wars and enough of the council obeying the senate, outnumbering the republic loyalist jedi and overthrowing them? We can go down the route of these insurrectionist jedi, manipulating official republic military orders so that some of the most powerful jedi in the order recieve bogus orders and are sent on wild bantha chases. What if growing up on Naboo, Palpatine become friends with a wookie, they become such great friends for life, that even as he becomes Sidious, he cares for one thing other than power, that being the wookie, the wookie becomes his right hand, his confidante and is one of the few beings in the galaxy that knows his identity as the sith lord and is there by his side during his rise to emperor?
I think if that happened The Rat would banish them. Or buy them and "wokefuck" the stories to death. Think of the mess when the Force transforms Qui Gon into a female Rodian just because Kinky Kathy thought it "neat". "That's an alternative too".
@@RichardHansbury Damn, I'm glad the author of this video spent his time thinking about ideas he loves, rather than went your path and thought only about things he hates.
What if Maul agree and join Qui-Gon Jinn force ghost during his jorney in dark castle? Jinn offered new path, in original story he refuse but what if he didn’t? :D
I agree with that and it would also a cool what if for maul would be what if Maul learned Nightsister magic from talzin, imagine maul becoming like some kind of with sorcerer
I kinda dig the alt-Maul stories I've seen, taking him at various points and turning him to the light. Heck I even recall one where the Jedi found him first and he never became a Darth at all.
@@SensiofRabbitude I agree, Starwars needs to make a what if show like marvel, it would be a good way to seeing alternate events without breaking starwars canon
It goes to the next oldest council member which I believe was operancesus and after that it was plo Koon. Windu is quite young compared to a lot of other masters
Can you please do What If Anakin Skywalker was King of Naboo and Padme Amidala was a slave on Tatooine aka The Chosen One What if Anakin Skywalker drank from the mystical Well of Urd giving his arm as a sacrifice What if Padme was the one that fell for Anakin upon first sight in The Phantom Menace until he is sent to protect her in AOTC falling for her but against it trying to follow the Jedi code What if Anakin had a spit personality disorder like Moon knight What if R2 D2 had his memory wiped with C3PO
What if Uncle Owen had been visited by Yoda on his way to Dagobah? Yoda would have explained quite passionately Luke's future role and how Obi Wan was to mentor Luke. So Kenobi moves into Skywalker Ranch um... the Lars farm. So for Luke's first decade Obi Wan tells Owen and Beru about Anakin, Padme, Leia, and the Organas. Luke is raised with Obi Wan guarding Luke and helping the farm succeed. "Uncle Bail" might visit with Leia about 10 years in to introduce them. They become Luke's family, too. But really no teaching, until then Luke is a normal boy. Then a carefully concealed training of Luke and Leia as Padawans. Leia trains for diplomacy and Force lore, Luke trains like Obi Wan as a defender of peace. So, in time the Bothans deliver the Death Star documents with the help of R2D2 and C3PO, who never left the Organas after Padme died, their memories still intact. So by 16 years old both Luke and Leia are trained to the skill level we see in ROTJ. Vader has less reason to suspect Leia than other Senators because she is a wise Jedi now. Obi Wan the great General lives up to his reputation and hires a smuggler called Han (with Chewie and Lando) to command squadrons of X-wings and Y-wings to defend Alderaan (or another world that earns Tarkin's wrath. Han earns more than enough to free him from all debts and obligations. Luke sinks that shot after Obi Wan fights and defeats Vader (training younglings honed his skills beyond his former best). Then soon (just about the time rumors run rampant) Obi Wan, Luke, Leia, and Han in the Falcon penetrate the palace on Coruscant and conquer Sidious and give him the treatment, "You were the Chancellor! You were chosen to bring Peace to the Galaxy and you plunged it into darkness!" And, like Vader before him, he attacks and the ghostly cackle of Yoda distracts him while the twins turn him into chutney sauce. Or maybe first Vader lets Anakin come out then he talks Palpetine into joining the light and creating a New Order without either the limitations of Jedi or Sith philosophy (like Kevin J. Anderson's "EU" books had students who saw the Force more as a rainbow and the wielder's intent being Dark or Light, anger and aggression being the flaws but no "darkness shall ever follow him" because two of the most powerful Sith chose not to die like Maul and Dooku but to gain victory through defeat. So Leia becomes Chief of a New Republic and Luke Grand Master with Palpetine, Anakin, Obi Wan, Han Solo, Chewbacca, Lando Calrissian, Owen Lars, and Bail Organa mentoring the Twins and uniting various factions into a new society with better Karma. Then come the Yuzhan Vong for a bit of excitement... Or the Chiss. Or a Droid-rights rebellion. Or Rodian rights. Or anti-clone hysteria. Or Killik joiners. With a New Republic led by Leia and Luke with a few apprentice Jedi and fleets of Refitted Star Cruisers (former Star Destroyers outfitted for multiple missions as well as war) garrisoned to systems not just warfleets they would have a smooth-running society not one fresh out of civil war.
Awesome! Merry Christimas. Please do a video about what if Luke Skywalker come back in ROTJ to complete his training and Yoda not die. Pleaseee, no one did any video about it.
The ancient Jedi held the belief that every being, regardless of their actions or allegiance, deserved a chance at redemption and salvation. This principle raises an intriguing question: how would the narrative of the Star Wars universe differ if the preceding generation of Jedi had imparted a fervent determination in the younger generation to actively seek out and attempt to bring those who had succumbed to the teachings of the Dark Side back into the light? This would involve endeavors to save individuals such as Palpatine, Maul, Ventress, and Dooku, among others. It's intriguing to consider how the story would unfold if every Jedi made it their mission to guide those who had strayed onto the path of darkness back to the light. In this context, Qui-Gon Jinn stands out as a potential candidate with the capability to accomplish such a formidable task.
Don't think that plo would die like that cause he even defeated Yoda ( yes it was once but hey) and Anakin, since those 2 are one of the most powerful jedi of that age
I wonder why the Jedi were so blind sighted? Everyone was free to study as they wanted and we know a few Jedi had an interest or aptitude for fire sight force abilities and this council had a lot more communication with each other why didn't anyone feel any kind of warning about the threat? The council was really blind and stagnated before that is why Yoda stepped down. Why were they still blindsided so completely now? Especially with Qui Gon never forgetting Palpatine's doing words about how the Sith always return
Qui Gon would have never become GM. He actively refused his seat on the council multiple times. And he much preferred being in the field to explore the mysteries of the Force.
Okay this story is very good I did enjoy it I do wish it was a lot longer I hope you come back make something like this again and keep up the good work and May the force be with you
With that many Jedi going to defeat him, wouldn't he like not stand a chance? They would be aware of his strength and know to be ready to deflect the lightning beforehand no? Sad that Anakin couldn't defeat Maul when he attacked :/
darth maul was around 32 bby to 2 aby, darth talon was around at 137 aby, also savage would not be looking for darth maul if dooku hadnt wanted a zabrak apprentice which wouldnt have happened if he didnt turn dark
qui gon wouldn't have cut maul in half, and the only reason obiwon did it was because qui gon died, maul would have either fell not cut in half, captured, or just killed beheaded or stabbed in the heart
Hola! Noté una cosa rara. cuando traduzco al inglés la bandera española🇪🇸 cambia a la bandera americana🇺🇸. También utilicé el traductor de Google para esto.
I really enjoy your videos. I was thinking that you could probably produce some shorter ones as well, with smaller changes that may still affect the galaxy. I imagine the force would have guided Qui Gon to Anakin on Tatooine regardless, but what if he and his mother weren't slaves? That would be a bigger one. How would Palpatine have approached grooming Anakin if Padme had never gotten pregnant? That could be a shorter one. You could make some interesting changes based on Rebels. Just some thoughts. Again, great stuff.
Or what if the Hutts hadn't remained neutral during the Clone Wars? It's my understanding that Jabba was funneling materials to the Separatists during that time. What if that had changed?
Can you continue this with Plagues arriving infront of Maul? Sense Cidiues didn't become councilor, then he never killed dark plague. That would be the next movie 100%>
Day 35 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
the Star Wars Galaxy I see your friends with pente patrol also friends with fantasy folklore I'm sure you and him can work together also one last thing the Star Wars Galaxy please tell me have you added on your list what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself who better to train teach mentor and master the young Skywalker his creator his father the force itself not the Jedi or sith but the force you can do it along with many more my friend thank you May the force be with you may GOD help you and lastly again Merry Christmas 👍👋
Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays! This is part 1 and part 2 of a video from a while back put together as the full movie. Didn’t want to make a new video on Christmas but still wanted to upload, so I hope you enjoy!
Day 32 of asking what if Vader used bor gullet to torture leia for informstion
Merry Christmas to you too, thanks for giving us content on this special day.
Merry Christmas!
Merry Christmas and thank you!
Day 34 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
Day 4 Ahsoka redeems Vader and they fight the one Sith
Genuinely crazy how actually knowing how a story should end and understanding character motivations makes for a good story. Even crazier that a SINGLE FAN can write a better story than an entire company.
Not to mention the hundreds of great stories he's made
That's what happens when you don't have to make concessions to the art to please a failed creative who instead had his uncle get him a job as an executive for the studio. That's why a lot of art house indie films tend to be better than major blockbusters plot wise or just in terms of creativity and originality. It's not always that the director has a better vision. They just didn't have to get that vision approved by Kathleen Kennedy.
Yoda turning everything over to Qui would single handedly have reformed the Jedi... after a while.
@@BC92Se7en Right, but youre forgetting the decisions Quigon would have made. He does not see himself as "the best Jedi", even in this rendition of events, Quigon's next move after accepting Yoda stepping down was _not_ to take power and command for himself, but to recommend open minds and always keep a seat left open that the leaders take turns sitting in.
@@BC92Se7enpretty sure qui gon actually did request for backup but the jedi were like nah you’d win
@@B3an01the jedi council didnt take him seriously and only sent him and obi
Although it was predictable that Maul would be the one to carry the dark side forward, I loved how this played out with the Jedi under new management and balancing their roles as warriors and peacekeepers! Plus, it was a great way to wrap it up with Anakin getting to fulfill his role as the chosen one even though he wasn't the one to kill Sidious.
I watch *ONE* video talking about Star Wars in an alternate timeline and now the UA-cam ads won’t leave me alone💀
I guess it’s worth it though to see content like this.
So thank you.
Pretty engrossing! I think one of the takeaways for Qui-Gon's new Jedi Order, was the Jedi can't be afraid of the Dark Side. They don't have to embrace it, but they do have to understand it. Courtesy of Count Dooku. Also the corrupt chancellor should have faced a huge backlash for abandoning the Jedi in their time of need. Perhaps he ordered a comms-blackout of the outer rim, supposedly to avoid public panic.
37:43 Hey! That ship is from the wrong universe! LOL
One I've always been curious about.
What if Ezra Bridger missed Obi-Wan and stumbled onto Luke Skywalker when he went to Tantooine?
They would be about the same age. Ezra and Luke could very easily team up and find both back with the ghost crew.
Now wouldn't that change, I don't know...; EVERYTHING!?
Just a thought.
That would be interesting
That is a good one
Definitely a good idea
Interesting take, however Obi-Wan was always watching over Luke. Being a general and a master jedi, he would naturally intercept
@@aidenlor5022
By the time Obi-Wan hides and buries Maul's body Ezra would have plenty of time to find and leave with Luke
18:20 One correction. Darth Talon is a Twi'lek, not a Zabrak.
"one correction" 🤓
and who are you mortal
Facts tho
I'm not the only one bugged by that thank God.
I don’t think this is important detail.
The Jedi Order was always pulled in too many directions. They followed the will of the people, the will of the Republic, and the will of the Force. During Yoda's time, the Jedi Council seems to have gotten lazy and assumed that the will of the people and the will of the Republic are the same.
Qui Gon would have had the Jedi follow the will of the Force which would have mostly aligned with the will of the people. This would be a tremendous improvement for the Jedi Order. Conflict would then arise when the will of the force and the will of the Republic come into disagreement. Very similar to Luke's Jedi Order that tended to butt heads with the New Republic.
I gotta say, I'm enjoying the writing in these alternative "What-If" scenarios than the actual canon plot.
Lovely job with this, and unlike when the reinforcements arrive in Rise of Skywalker, you actually set up early on why the Outer Rim peoples would want to come to the heroes aid.
Rise of Skywalker was the worst of all the films - a hidden Sith fleet of hundreds of thousands of people, no economy to build or support them... K. Then the deus ex machina of the "good guys" showing up. Such lazy writing.
35:20 Obi-Wan, really pulled a marvel endgame
Obi-Wan really pulled an "On your left"
Marvel reference
"I understood that reference"
Heres one, what if the Jedi sided with the CIS?
CIS?
@Mr.supergamer20 yeah, that's the separatists they were also called the Confederacy of Independent Systems or CIS
GIVE THIS MAN THE STAR WARS FRANCHISE 🔥🔥🔥🔥🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅✨✨✨✨✨
Where would Ahsoka, Ventress, Jango, Satine, and other noteworthy characters (not including clones since they were never created) fit into all this?
Would Ahsoka still have become Anakin's padawan?
Would Ventress have becoem the Jedi her master trained her to be?
Would Jango have ever fathered a son to carry on his legacy?
Would Satine and Obi-wan have rekindled their love?
The clones we'd created. They were ordered years prior. Jango would have still gotten his clone to raise.ashoka would still have been trained so would ventress
The story kinda turned me off after they said talon was a zaberak
@@austinwhite3132george lucas planned on having maul and talon be master and apprentice
@@aparks22 that’s irrelevant to what I just said
Woow, just woww. I love this video. My new favorite "What If" right next to Anakin leaving the order with Ahsoka.
It felt a little iffy at first with Maul's defeat, but aside from that, everything was such a great story. This wpuld make a perfect alternative to the story we got.
Dooku didn’t seek out Palpatine until after qui gon died. If qui gon didn’t did he would’ve never looked in the first place
Not true. Did u watch tales of the jedi
I sometimes wonder If Dooku would have been anywhere near as effective, If anyone other than Christopher Lee had played him?
In some respects the Star Wars prequels have something in common with the Fox X-Men series in that even its biggest detractors can't say enough good things about how certain actors nailed their roles, like with Patrick Stewart, Kelsey Grammar etc in X-Men and I'd assume the same for the likes of Liam Neeson, Christopher Lee and others in the prequels.
@terynmallory9764 by the time of The Phantom Menace, Dooku was already exploring the Dark Side. But Qui Gon’s death was the catalyst that pushed him that much quicker. But, outside of @StarWarsGalaxy’s theory, if Qui Gon Jinn survived then I believe Dooku still would have turned.
Ahh yes, the Christmas gift I was hoping for
35:24-35:39-According to TV Tropes that would be an example of "The Cavalry."
Ik this comment is super late but I have to say it’s nice to see these kind of fan fictions again reminds me of the good old days of Star Wars theory. “No I’m not saying anything bad about Star Wars theory I love Star Wars theory in fact” But I do have to say you bring back that old feeling to when I was a teenager of truly enjoying Star Wars fan fiction and I can’t be the only one who feels this way so keep up the good work!!
Only in Star Wars can you say, "and the good guys set up an enlightened theocratic republic." And that be the good ending.
man, what a lovely video, This sure is a nice take on- AAH GAUNTS GHOST JUMPSCARE AT 14:18
Qui Gon had survived Darth Maul saber duel, and basically the profecy would have been nulled.
That's the paradigm of religions. Had he survived, Anakin would have been his disciple for sure, and the prophecy would not matter. He is a beacon, a teacher, a guide, he is not for the council as many say. Qui Gon represents the change, a different point of view, and that's something the Jedi Order didn't want. He would have personally taken care and guided Anakin in a way that he would become a sentinel 100%.
I'm even sure that, if Mace Windu were to be alive following this logic, he would have taught him his style not to be his disciple, but to create a form to counter him. He had the talent, a perfect master in Qui Gon, and also Obi Wan as senior. Had given time, the most efficient way for Anakin to train would be teaching him all the basic forms in the 7 styles, to let him create a form which could be the perfect counter for dueling. He is more akin to combat than be a force user.
Palpatine had contingency plans for basically everything. Qui Gon dying made everything easier for him.
You are the greatest Star Wars What If creator who ever lived!!!! :)
It’s nice to see Darth Teranus in Jedi form
I don't mean to be rude, but I'm pretty sure it was "Tyrannus." 🤔
However, if you ask me, Teranus sounds better. :)
Amazing man. Please make more of this I’m more than addicted. This seems like the only fuel of joy I have in my life
What if the droids rebelled against the cis
?
What about the droid attack on the cis?
@@SensiofRabbitude stop the droids we must
That would be an awesome one to see
Banning kids from saying first
I always report them for spam because there ends up being 3-10 saying it at times
When I do it it's because despite having notifs set to all I rarely see notifs on new video BEFORE they've been out for days.
Bot
@@ZmbieTaco sounds like insecurity. 😂
I REPORT THEM FOR TERRORISM
I remember Mother Tal Zin saying Savage had greater potential then Maul which is likely why Palpatine slew him while still so inexperienced and weak and took Maul who was the bigger threat at that time.
He didn't want to risk Savage escaping like Maul did and finding a new master to finish his training since there was no chance in the situation Savage would turn to Palpatine or Dooku for what they have done to him personally
I do wish some clones including Rex were completed and they were able to find new paths instead of default soldiers but this was a great story either way
QuiGon: You will never win Sidious
Sidious: Anakin join me and we can rule the galaxy together!!!
Anakin: Never!!! I am a Jedi like Qui Gon before me!!!
Sidious: So be it… Master JEDI!!!
Que Epic Battle of Ass kicking AWESOMENESS!!!!
I love these videos. Darth talon isn't a zabrak though, she's a twilek. Other than that, great work.
Twilek aren't people. They're product so it's okay to get the wrong race.
Why should he be the only one in starwars that can't tank a gut shot with a 20,000 degree lightsaber?
This is one of my favorite stories ever fron yours! What a masterpiece!
I could definitely get behind this idea of an alternate timeline 😊.
That was fuckin beautiful bro good shit g
"A Failure, Dooku is not." 🙏🏽
I know this was months ago but wow. This just shows that the Jedi always gotta be ready to fight even though they are keepers of the peace. Good video
Great story as usual!
8:00.....there's no way, Sidious would have sensed a wavering as soon as Dooku betrayed him, or at the very least sensed all those forced users heading his way and got the hell out of there. He's not stupid.
This is very true, but nonetheless still a very good what if story
Sideous is known to be overconfident and assume the darkness will win out in people. He did the same thing with Anakin and Vader at the end of Return of the Jedi. It makes sense that he'd be overconfident this time as well when he thinks he's completely fooled everyone.
35:32 would’ve been the most badass thing in cinema history lowkey
That was an excellent Star Wars 'what if' story. I really enjoyed it. Keep up the good work!
Besides even in legends it was the death of anakin solo that messed her up and sent her on the path to darkness. She blamed the Skywalker clan. Luke Leia Jacen Jaina Mara Ben skywalker. Those were who she hated that sent her over. Plus a nightsister
What if a coup happened directly inside the jedi order, a group of insurrectionist jedi had enough of the clone wars and enough of the council obeying the senate, outnumbering the republic loyalist jedi and overthrowing them?
We can go down the route of these insurrectionist jedi, manipulating official republic military orders so that some of the most powerful jedi in the order recieve bogus orders and are sent on wild bantha chases.
What if growing up on Naboo, Palpatine become friends with a wookie, they become such great friends for life, that even as he becomes Sidious, he cares for one thing other than power, that being the wookie, the wookie becomes his right hand, his confidante and is one of the few beings in the galaxy that knows his identity as the sith lord and is there by his side during his rise to emperor?
The 2nd one is very creative, but Palpatine was a psycho, this is a very wholesome scenario tho?
@@Wildanimal2000we can just say that the wookie shares palpatjnes pyscho tendencies.
@@Only1199 that works
@@Wildanimal2000I feel like Palpatine was too calculated to be a psycho
@@aircoolguy5218 when I meant psycho I meant that he was and became pure evil, but good point
Unpopular opinion: the fall of the Jedi was Yoda’s fault
I feel like plo koon wouldn't surrender. The man was a better seer than qui gon and had a far more practical mindset.
This was george lucas’ original idea for the sequels but disney ignored it
Someone needs to animate these and use AI voices these are incredible
I think if that happened The Rat would banish them. Or buy them and "wokefuck" the stories to death. Think of the mess when the Force transforms Qui Gon into a female Rodian just because Kinky Kathy thought it "neat". "That's an alternative too".
@@RichardHansbury Damn, I'm glad the author of this video spent his time thinking about ideas he loves, rather than went your path and thought only about things he hates.
This theory brought me to tears mann. Wow.
This was a pretty good one great job is always.
37:40 (?) HAHAHA! The shadows from B5 investigate Star Wars.
🔥🔥🔥🔥 Yo man. That was fire!!! Wish i could been made, im all right fanmade it with clone wars 2D animation 👌🏻🔥🔥🔥🔥
What if Maul agree and join Qui-Gon Jinn force ghost during his jorney in dark castle? Jinn offered new path, in original story he refuse but what if he didn’t? :D
I agree with that and it would also a cool what if for maul would be what if Maul learned Nightsister magic from talzin, imagine maul becoming like some kind of with sorcerer
I kinda dig the alt-Maul stories I've seen, taking him at various points and turning him to the light.
Heck I even recall one where the Jedi found him first and he never became a Darth at all.
@@SensiofRabbitude I agree, Starwars needs to make a what if show like marvel, it would be a good way to seeing alternate events without breaking starwars canon
Now I'm curious of what would happen if maul and savage killed sidius on mandalor
Loved the story, 10/10
This would be a lot better story then what Disney gave us I would of loved to watch this time line
37:46 Oh LOOK, a Shadow capital ship?!
Wouldn't the role of Grand Master be passed on to Mace Windu? I always thought he was the Orders number 2 on the council 🤔
It goes to the next oldest council member which I believe was operancesus and after that it was plo Koon. Windu is quite young compared to a lot of other masters
This so good because plo Koon could best Yoda in lightsaber combat
Can you please do What If Anakin Skywalker was King of Naboo and Padme Amidala was a slave on Tatooine aka The Chosen One
What if Anakin Skywalker drank from the mystical Well of Urd giving his arm as a sacrifice
What if Padme was the one that fell for Anakin upon first sight in The Phantom Menace until he is sent to protect her in AOTC falling for her but against it trying to follow the Jedi code
What if Anakin had a spit personality disorder like Moon knight
What if R2 D2 had his memory wiped with C3PO
Yeah I wouldn't mind a gender swap what if like what if Anakin was a girl and padme a boy that would be a unique dynamic 😊
What if Uncle Owen had been visited by Yoda on his way to Dagobah? Yoda would have explained quite passionately Luke's future role and how Obi Wan was to mentor Luke.
So Kenobi moves into Skywalker Ranch um... the Lars farm. So for Luke's first decade Obi Wan tells Owen and Beru about Anakin, Padme, Leia, and the Organas. Luke is raised with Obi Wan guarding Luke and helping the farm succeed.
"Uncle Bail" might visit with Leia about 10 years in to introduce them. They become Luke's family, too. But really no teaching, until then Luke is a normal boy.
Then a carefully concealed training of Luke and Leia as Padawans. Leia trains for diplomacy and Force lore, Luke trains like Obi Wan as a defender of peace.
So, in time the Bothans deliver the Death Star documents with the help of R2D2 and C3PO, who never left the Organas after Padme died, their memories still intact.
So by 16 years old both Luke and Leia are trained to the skill level we see in ROTJ. Vader has less reason to suspect Leia than other Senators because she is a wise Jedi now. Obi Wan the great General lives up to his reputation and hires a smuggler called Han (with Chewie and Lando) to command squadrons of X-wings and Y-wings to defend Alderaan (or another world that earns Tarkin's wrath. Han earns more than enough to free him from all debts and obligations. Luke sinks that shot after Obi Wan fights and defeats Vader (training younglings honed his skills beyond his former best).
Then soon (just about the time rumors run rampant) Obi Wan, Luke, Leia, and Han in the Falcon penetrate the palace on Coruscant and conquer Sidious and give him the treatment, "You were the Chancellor! You were chosen to bring Peace to the Galaxy and you plunged it into darkness!" And, like Vader before him, he attacks and the ghostly cackle of Yoda distracts him while the twins turn him into chutney sauce.
Or maybe first Vader lets Anakin come out then he talks Palpetine into joining the light and creating a New Order without either the limitations of Jedi or Sith philosophy (like Kevin J. Anderson's "EU" books had students who saw the Force more as a rainbow and the wielder's intent being Dark or Light, anger and aggression being the flaws but no "darkness shall ever follow him" because two of the most powerful Sith chose not to die like Maul and Dooku but to gain victory through defeat.
So Leia becomes Chief of a New Republic and Luke Grand Master with Palpetine, Anakin, Obi Wan, Han Solo, Chewbacca, Lando Calrissian, Owen Lars, and Bail Organa mentoring the Twins and uniting various factions into a new society with better Karma.
Then come the Yuzhan Vong for a bit of excitement...
Or the Chiss. Or a Droid-rights rebellion. Or Rodian rights. Or anti-clone hysteria. Or Killik joiners. With a New Republic led by Leia and Luke with a few apprentice Jedi and fleets of Refitted Star Cruisers (former Star Destroyers outfitted for multiple missions as well as war) garrisoned to systems not just warfleets they would have a smooth-running society not one fresh out of civil war.
What if the Skywalker twins were switched at birth
Nice vid, glad to be here so early
Oh and Marry Christmas
Very funny that Eith Koth and Saese Tien still die at Palpatine‘s Hand
Awesome! Merry Christimas.
Please do a video about what if Luke Skywalker come back in ROTJ to complete his training and Yoda not die. Pleaseee, no one did any video about it.
😊
8:30 could be worse, he could have found yoda, high on ketamine, in his 2001 honda civic.
This was leagues above the sequels
💯
The ancient Jedi held the belief that every being, regardless of their actions or allegiance, deserved a chance at redemption and salvation. This principle raises an intriguing question: how would the narrative of the Star Wars universe differ if the preceding generation of Jedi had imparted a fervent determination in the younger generation to actively seek out and attempt to bring those who had succumbed to the teachings of the Dark Side back into the light? This would involve endeavors to save individuals such as Palpatine, Maul, Ventress, and Dooku, among others. It's intriguing to consider how the story would unfold if every Jedi made it their mission to guide those who had strayed onto the path of darkness back to the light. In this context, Qui-Gon Jinn stands out as a potential candidate with the capability to accomplish such a formidable task.
Don't think that plo would die like that cause he even defeated Yoda ( yes it was once but hey) and Anakin, since those 2 are one of the most powerful jedi of that age
What if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis
This was a nice story
I wonder why the Jedi were so blind sighted?
Everyone was free to study as they wanted and we know a few Jedi had an interest or aptitude for fire sight force abilities and this council had a lot more communication with each other why didn't anyone feel any kind of warning about the threat?
The council was really blind and stagnated before that is why Yoda stepped down.
Why were they still blindsided so completely now?
Especially with Qui Gon never forgetting Palpatine's doing words about how the Sith always return
Qui Gon would have never become GM. He actively refused his seat on the council multiple times. And he much preferred being in the field to explore the mysteries of the Force.
Waaaaait, Darth Talon isn’t a zabrak tho. Dam in the “actually” guy now 😂
Excellent work on this video!
I like Anakin's robes in the thumbnail.
When you revealed tallon you said zabrak. She’s a twilek or was this to spice the story up
Okay this story is very good I did enjoy it I do wish it was a lot longer I hope you come back make something like this again and keep up the good work and May the force be with you
I like this video … ANOTHER!
With that many Jedi going to defeat him, wouldn't he like not stand a chance? They would be aware of his strength and know to be ready to deflect the lightning beforehand no? Sad that Anakin couldn't defeat Maul when he attacked :/
Nicely done story
darth maul was around 32 bby to 2 aby, darth talon was around at 137 aby, also savage would not be looking for darth maul if dooku hadnt wanted a zabrak apprentice which wouldnt have happened if he didnt turn dark
aswell as this darth talon is a twilek not a zabrak
The only thing ive learned is to fear the hooded politicians
Please do “What if Quinlan Vos Trained Anakin Skywalker?”
yeah whathe said
Yeah that sounds like a pretty cool one
@@deepwashington499 have seen my comments as well
Bro made a better stiry then disney ever could
Windu ain’t on board with shit 😂😂😂
qui gon wouldn't have cut maul in half, and the only reason obiwon did it was because qui gon died, maul would have either fell not cut in half, captured, or just killed beheaded or stabbed in the heart
Darth-loes knows
🇪🇸 Gracias ¿Podría poner subtítulos en español porfavor?
Hola! Noté una cosa rara. cuando traduzco al inglés la bandera española🇪🇸 cambia a la bandera americana🇺🇸. También utilicé el traductor de Google para esto.
I feel like Darth maul was more powerful than he should have been here.
I really enjoy your videos. I was thinking that you could probably produce some shorter ones as well, with smaller changes that may still affect the galaxy. I imagine the force would have guided Qui Gon to Anakin on Tatooine regardless, but what if he and his mother weren't slaves? That would be a bigger one. How would Palpatine have approached grooming Anakin if Padme had never gotten pregnant? That could be a shorter one. You could make some interesting changes based on Rebels. Just some thoughts. Again, great stuff.
Or what if the Hutts hadn't remained neutral during the Clone Wars? It's my understanding that Jabba was funneling materials to the Separatists during that time. What if that had changed?
I'm confused. I thought Plo was cut in half, but a little later, he was still there, surrendering with Anakin?
If Maul could do it...
I’m pretty sure this was a back story of how plo and anakin were captured by the shadow collective
That was delicious thank you
Honestly the best one if yet. Would it made for a short series?
But it has the feel good
Dooku's problem with the order was deeper then that so i doubt he would of turned back to the light.
Can you continue this with Plagues arriving infront of Maul? Sense Cidiues didn't become councilor, then he never killed dark plague. That would be the next movie 100%>
Day 35 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
I love this. 🤘🤘🤘💯💯💯
the Star Wars Galaxy I see your friends with pente patrol also friends with fantasy folklore I'm sure you and him can work together also one last thing the Star Wars Galaxy please tell me have you added on your list what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself who better to train teach mentor and master the young Skywalker his creator his father the force itself not the Jedi or sith but the force you can do it along with many more my friend thank you May the force be with you may GOD help you and lastly again Merry Christmas 👍👋