Bad Songwriting Advice That HURTS Aspiring Writers

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 33

  • @WILKESmusic
    @WILKESmusic Місяць тому +5

    “Every song doesn’t have to have anything” 💯

  • @LeoDizonMendoza
    @LeoDizonMendoza Місяць тому +2

    Love this channel, currently working on my second album, and these videos are exactly what I need to get back into songwriting ❤

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      Good luck with the project. We love helping. Write on!

  • @lindseyscruggs8303
    @lindseyscruggs8303 Місяць тому +1

    What a great way to describe when a bridge is necessary: "When you've got a river to cross".
    I usually write bridges, but you guys are spot on. They aren't needed for every song. One of the best songs ever written, "Me and Bobby McGee". Technically, it has a bridge, but that bridge is just "Lah da dah-- da dah dah--- Lah di dah da dah-- Lah di dah da dah da Bobby McGee, yeah..." Etc etc.
    It can be an instrumental. It can be a bunch of nonsense vocalizations. It can be a bridge to cross a seemingly insurmountable chasm. It can be nothing at all.
    Like people, every song is different and has its own path to travel.
    Another example: "Fast Car". It breaks a lot of "rules". Verse, Verse, Verse, Pre-chorus, Chorus, Verse, Chorus, Verse, Chorus, Pre-chorus. End of song. One of the greatest pieces of storytelling ever written. It doesn't need a separate bridge. Conceptually, the entire song is a bridge, leading right back where she started. A requiem for a dream.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      Great insights. Write on! CM

  • @heartshinemusic
    @heartshinemusic Місяць тому +3

    I wrote a lot of songs before I became aware of this thing called "Counting Syllables". I think it's good to know that it exist and that it can be important and helpful, as long as you allow yourself to break the rules. (You explained this wonderfully!) I personally like the limits of the songwriting craft and then become creative within a self-imposed framework. Once you understand the rules (or guidelines), you can purposefully decide to break them. Just be able to always explain to yourself WHY you are doing something. I think counting syllable is a useful technique for beginners who tend to force two-syllable-words on one note/beat, which often sounds very fumbled and amateurish.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому +1

      Write on! Well said. -CM

    • @stormedbyhippiesc3966
      @stormedbyhippiesc3966 Місяць тому +2

      Well said

    • @offlynice
      @offlynice Місяць тому +1

      I never thought of this until I was working with my partner in rhyme, and I seen him going over his lyrics in his head, while counting on his fingers. And I'm like, whatya doing? He said, counting my syllables like it was something everyone knew you had to do. I'm like, well who cares if it sounds good? If it rides the beat and melody well, that's all that matters to me.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      @@offlynice Write on! ~CM

  • @RobbieKaye
    @RobbieKaye 27 днів тому

    Excellent info and encouragement again! Thanks Clay and Marty!

  • @1flat1sharp47
    @1flat1sharp47 Місяць тому +1

    I have struggled to find a songwriting partner at the same interest and availability level as myself, but I love to work together when it clicks.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      We have lots of folks serious about cowriting at a high level in our SongTown community. www.songtown.com

  • @MrTom8102
    @MrTom8102 Місяць тому +1

    I like and agree with the conversation about every path is different..Nice job guys thank you

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      Thanks for jumping in on the conversation. Write on! CM

  • @alanbruce7
    @alanbruce7 Місяць тому

    Another great session guys. Some good advice.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      awww thanks! Glad to help. Write on! CM

  • @fredepps3196
    @fredepps3196 Місяць тому +2

    Bridges…yeah, I’ve been compulsively putting them in every song. Last song had like 24 chords hh

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому +2

      Chord FOMO is real. Afraid to leave one out? 😂. Write on! CM

    • @fredepps3196
      @fredepps3196 Місяць тому

      @@SongTownUSA Yes, I’m forcing myself to use no more than 6 chords. And considering carefully whether a bridge is really better than an instrumental solo or something like that.

  • @jcmacmusic
    @jcmacmusic Місяць тому +1

    Love it thank you…

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      HEy buddy, appreciate it! ~CM

  • @SongTownUSA
    @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому +2

    We Critiqued 2,000 People's Songs (Here's What We Learned) ua-cam.com/video/NKZUvSyxGKA/v-deo.html

  • @ianshortall3356
    @ianshortall3356 Місяць тому

    Groovy advice guys!!!

  • @dougk7075
    @dougk7075 17 днів тому

    Good video, guys, thanks so much.
    I know it likely varies by song/project, but can you talk more about when does a songwriter generally know that it’s just them on a tune and when does a co-writer enter the picture?
    Also, at what point does someone become a co-writer on a song? When they suggest one or two notes and/or word changes that seem to improve the song? Again, I imagine it varies.
    Thanks.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  17 днів тому +1

      For me personally, I’ve made many suggestions to help our songtown members make their songs better and don’t expect cowriting credit. I feel when I invite someone in to help them they are a cowriter if it’s made the song better. I don’t count words or lines. -CM

    • @dougk7075
      @dougk7075 16 днів тому

      Thanks.

  • @michaelenosmusic
    @michaelenosmusic Місяць тому

    I have had people tell me that artists and managers are only looking for a certain bpm for country radio... shouldn't that be irrelevant?? A good song is a good song.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому +2

      Tempos are always a part of what drives a format. But there are always exceptions. Up tempo get more cuts but ballads are often song of the years. So write them all! :) Clay

  • @jriccardi01
    @jriccardi01 Місяць тому +1

    I hope the “13 songwriters” comment wasn’t a dig at Rick Beato.

    • @SongTownUSA
      @SongTownUSA  Місяць тому

      Ha! Our video came out before his.