Why were Jews Murdered in the Hebron Riots Massacre?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лип 2024
- In the summer of 1929, the British-controlled region of Palestine saw growing fault lines between Arabs and Jews. Tensions rose until they erupted one fateful day. In the city of Hebron a riot quickly turned into a gruesome massacre, and in a mere two hours, 67 Jews were murdered. The Hebron Riots were the catalyst for the week of terror that followed. In total 133 Jews and 116 Arabs were killed and most peaceful Jewish-Arab coexistence came to an unfortunate end.
Chapters
00:00 Intro
01:08 British Mandate in Palestine
02:05 Haj Amin al-Husseini and the Temple Mount
04:03 Tisha B'Av Western Wall March
04:52 Arab mob storms the Western Wall
05:36 What is the importance of Hebron?
06:29 The Hebron riot of 1929
07:55 The home of Eliezer Dan Slonim
08:37 Arabs who saved their Jewish neighbors
09:14 Aftermath of the massacre
09:57 Echoes of the massacre today
11:20 The Hebron massacre as a turning point in the Conflict
12:12 Rebuilding the trust
12:46 Outro
Subscribe and turn on your notifications so you don’t miss future uploads!
ua-cam.com/users/UNPACKED?sub_...
Recommended video- Is Israel an Occupying Power?
• Is Israel an Occupying...
We have merch! - shop.jewishunpacked.com/?...
Let’s connect:
Website - www.jewishunpacked.com
Instagram - / jewishunpacked
Twitter - / jewishunpacked
TikTok - / jewishunpacked
Facebook - / jewishunpacked
-----------
Executive Producers:
- Debra Klein
- Avi Naider
- Jerry Ostrov
- Barry Skolnick
Gold Level:
- Blavatnik Family Foundation
- The Associated’s Insight Israel Forum
- The Crane Foundation
- Aimee & Jerry Ostrov
- Skolnick Family Charitable Trust
Silver Level:
- Sig and Miriam Feiger Family Foundation
- The Messinger Family Charitable Fund
- Rachie and Jon Teller
Bronze Level:
- The Bernstein Family Foundation
- Jewish Federation of Broward County
- Betsy and Philip Darivoff
- Jewish Federation of Metropolitan Detroit
- JCRC of the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia
- Marilyn and Neville Isaacson
- Corie and Michael Koss
- Steve Miller
- Pamela Rose
- Kim and Perry Shwachman
- Marci and Andrew Spitzer
-----------
Image and footage credits:
Associated Press
Boomerang Fighting for Israel
Blaues Sofa
British Pathé
Bundesarchiv
Carmel Newsreel
Centre National du Cinéma
Central Zionist Archives
The Pritzker Family National Photography Collection, The National Library of Israel
Chicago Film Archives
David Rumsey Map Collection, David Rumsey Map Center, Stanford Libraries
Flavio~
Geva Films
Historical Jewish Press website - www.jpress.org.il - founded by the National Library and Tel Aviv University
Imperial War Museum
Israel Film Archive - Jerusalem Cinematheque
Israeli GPO: Zoltan Kluger, Moshe Milner, Mark Neyman
Israeli State Archives
KKL - JNF Photo Archive
Library of Congress
Nadav Mann, BITMUNA. From the Haim Berger collection, from the collection of Gra postcards-Dr. Shulamit Gera, from the Edgar Hirschbein collection-Tamar Levy, and from the Yechiel Zehavi collection. The Pritzker Family National Photography Collection, The National Library of Israel
Mount of Olives Information Center, ELAD
Murnau Stiftung and Deutschlandradio Kultur
National Archives and Records Administration
National Gallery of Art
New York Times
Newspapers.com: The Gazette, Reading Times, The Sacramento Bee, The Salt Lake Tribune
The Oded Yarkoni Historical Archives of Petach Tikva, The National Library of Israel
Pexels, Krivec Ales
Picador Books
The Slonin Family
The Steven Spielberg Jewish Film Archive
Storyblocks
TikTok
Twitter
From the Wein Family Album, Ranaana, In Israelalbum.org.il, the Yad Yitzchak ben Zvi archive
Yad Yitzchak ben Zvi, The National Library of Israel
young shanahan
-----------
About Unpacked: We provide nuanced insights by unpacking all things Jewish. People are complex and complicated - yet we’re constantly being pushed to oversimplify our world. At Unpacked we know that being complex makes us more interesting. Because of this, we break the world down with nuance and insight to drive your curiosity and challenge your thinking.
About History of Israel Explained: This series casts a new perspective on the history of the modern State of Israel, both pre and post 1948. We explore the inspiring highs and heartbreaking lows, and the everyday struggles of ordinary people. Understand how the Jewish State came to be by meeting prominent Zionist figures and learning about key historical events. Explore aspects of Israeli society, from its famous military to the meaning of the national anthem, and more.
#History #Israel #hebron
Love how we unpack yesterday? Check out our new channel and see how unpack today 👀👀👀youtube.com/@todayunpacked
The Arabs are on your truffe and wasting your land which got smaller and smaller on 1948... The Arabs don't want peace! They are war mongers... "Don't trust them; Let them die"
In such times of darkness it always warms my heart to hear there was a small amount of people helping despite the danger
Yeah, man. Figured I better help my little cousin around the castle. They out here talking reckless about the kingdom👇🏽
The Palestinian hatred of Jewish prayer still exists even to this day. As a Muslim I find that Jewish prayer at the Kotel is beautiful but every Palestinian I speak with mentioned they hate it. So I dunno why is anti Judaism associated with Palestinian struggle. 🤷🏾♂️
Antisemitism is the oldest hatred. All people of good conscience must fight to eradicate it.
They grow up learning nothing but hate
Obviously they’re not acting on behalf of G-D’s good will
Kafir
because without their hatred of Judaism their whole cause crumbles. that is what drives them. The hatred of all things Jewish. they don't care about building their own country.
Thank you for sharing this important history that is so often erased in popular narrative.
Exactly. Must protect Kosher Queen at all costs💪🏽
Kosher🍆halal inside
The ancient community of Jews that resided in Aza city perished at the same week, same with that of Shechem/Nablus and dozen others. Hebron is the most known because of its importance (The forefathers of Jews are buried there) and because the massacre of the community in Hebron was documented and the gruesome photos were published and archived by the NY Times.
There was no massacre
@@NikoBellaKhouf2just like there is no palestine
@@NikoBellaKhouf2 I need proof
@@joseph8762 it's been there for thousands of years
@@cyberspek8996 I need proof
Great Job Noam. Loved your writing and approach as usual. Appreciate the classic film and still footage alot
Amazing! I really love what you guys are doing here!
Just found this channel. Wonderful to hear about our peoples, even the darkest of stories, without the subtle condescending undertones, from "scholars". Either way, thank you all at this channel
2 years later, peaceful coexistence seems further away than ever. The parallels between the Hebron massacre and the Oct 7 massacre are chilling.
Nothing has changed.
Changed! Jews can protect themselves!
It's just the other way around now
@@iAMaReaperGotprobZ Why has Palestine been the one that has initiated EVERY WAR since 1948 then?
Oct 7 is like 1929 on a much larger scale. Even the nature of the atrocities against Jewish civilians is the same.
Jews must defend themselves against evil, in every way possible. It is not enough to be good, one and all must have the power to maintain it.
“When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace,” Jimi Hendrix
In order to understand what really happened beginning with Zionism in the early 1880's, it is necessary to read Joan Peters' book, Since Time Immemorial. She set out on the side of the Arab refugees, but her research, based on the historical archives of the Ottoman Turks who first ruled that land and also on the records at that time of the British consul, revealed that (1) Jerusalem was 75 percent Jewish out of a population of about 20,000, and (2) the land outside of the town was virtually uninhabited except by Bedouin Nomads. This is not an easy book to read because it is so detailed with thousands of footnotes. The Arabs were not able to live in that land until the Jews, by sheer hard work and brain power, began to restore the ruined land to fertility. Then the Arabs began flooding in. During the British Mandate for Palestine, it was the Jews who adopted the name Palestinian, while the Arabs rejected it vehemently.
Lenin was a zionist
Russia famine
Holodomor
Yea, I will always support the white race first. Just like jews support their fellow jews such as George soros.
If only they supported Jesus, but you know circle signature
None of this is true. Jerusalem was never anywhere close to 75% Jewish. Arabs did not flood into Palestine, those were jews who illegally flooded in. Also the land was never ruined, it was fertile and cultivated before the jews came there.
@@northwind8821 Source?
@@ratatosk8935 source say the opposite...
@@avrahampresman6692 Yes. This is why I doesn't await a proper and based answer from this commenter.
So relevant now that history is repeating itself.
Thanks, the video is very informative, the amount of comments from the Hamas propaganda proves that it is true, they are going crazy when they hear the truth.
Of course the reality was that the Land, including Jerusalem had been mandated by the League of Nations to become sovereign to the Jews. And yes, mandated to Jews, with a legal instrument to back this up, called "The Mandate for Palestine". The Arabs had not been sovereign, nor did they "own' the Land, the Turks had, and had lost it to the Allied Powers during WW1.
This event reminds me of an event that happened in Missouri to the early Saints in Haun's Mill.
Can everyone use a grogger whenever the name "Hajj Amin al Husseini" is mentioned!!
He was good friends with Joseph Gobbels!
@@jrutt2675 He was good friends with Hitler!! Use a grogger whenever the Mufti's name is mentioned.
@@jrutt2675 so..he wasn't wrong in worrying about zionism or the British. Of course when someone shares an enemy they will ally. In this case Jewish supremacy and colonization by the british.
@@amirmonem8080 yeah. The British were so Pro-Zionist, millions of Jews couldn’t get there to escape Hitler
Great video
Thank you for sharing.
Pretty, pretty, pretty great analysis.
Great job with this video.
Jewish people will survive!
We’re past that point now we’re going to flourish
It would’ve been appropriate to go back to 1834 when Ibrahim pasha came to the city and did the same thing to the Jewish population
I am looking for the Hatikvah record played in the end of the 'Hevron massacre podcast version but so far to no avail.
Excellent site. If only this kind of history was more widely disseminated.
I really hope they can find peace, cuz we can all co-exist.
Amen
We are absolutely ready when they are. I don’t want that to sound 'us and them', we are ready with open arms.
@@sydyidanton5873 i knaw that some Palestinian civilians are ready. But please tell me why ur “government” (i put it in quotations because its not really a government, more of an unorganized authority) has rejected the 2 states plan we offered 5 TIMES ALREADY😩
Bro please tell the terr0rists to find peace
@@itamarrevah2260 I think he is Israeli.
Excellently Professionally Adventurously Done B'H B'H B'H B'H B'H THANK You Almighty King PAPA The Shekinah's Presense for Your Protection Guidance Provision for My Dear Brother who gave this presentation. Shalu Shalom Yerushalyim, Yisrael Shalom & Shabbos Shalom Blessings
Oh I heard of it all right; I know all about it as it concerned my husband's family and his family's home in Hebron.
I feel like this episode is remiss without also talking about Baruch Goldstein, and why his portrait hung for years in the living room of Israel’s current national security minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir
Try to understand a doctor who was first on the scene. Of terrorist attack time after time. Baruch goldstein
@Michael Walsh We know his name because he was one of few if not the only Israeli attacker. But who can name the plentiful palestininian attackers other than the palestinian community? I can't even name the fella who committed suicide fast recently.
Its incredible, all these massacres, the arabs never wanted to have peace with others as long as they are treated as dhimmis.
And the comparison to the Spanish Inquisition is very exaggerated, thats old school belief. There were torture but not as barbaric
Peace was never an option, it started as an occupation that evolved into apartheid. As a Sephardi, you should know this better than anyone...
What's new?
Chaim Weizmann had sent a letter to the Mufti that the immigration of Jews to Palestine would benefit their economy.
He added an maximum number of Jews would immigrate. The Mufti accepted it.
When the Mufti had a meeting with Adolf Adolf said " But then they will all come to you !" and the Mufti replied what Chaim Weizmann wrote in his letter
Alot of Anti-semites here. @UNPACKED your work matters, just ignore them
Truth depends on who.
I think both sides use propaganda
Well, it appears that not only in the new York times , newspapers, about the Jews, praying what was left of the wall in Jerusalem,”
It’s written in the oldest Book, scroll.
------
They kept calling loudly in the language of the Jews, to the people of Jerusalem who were on the wall to make them afraid
And to terrify them, in order to
Capture the city.
Verse 19.
They spoke against the God of Jerusalem the same way
As against the gods of the peoples of the
Earth,
Which are the work of man’s hands.
2 chronicles 32 : 18-19.
If a person reads verses 20-22.
Reads like Yahweh there “God, would help them,
If Jews , or Israelites would have other gods Yahweh, would abandon them ,
Strange I thought the Bible, or scroll was written long, long ago from antiquity, so the “Almighty God knew this was going to happen.?
It does say his thoughts are way higher then man’s,
If I could read Hebrew, I would try to get hold of very old manuscripts and read if it said the same words.”
🙏✡ God Bless Israel ✡🙏
The ashke-nazi are the nazi
We can all safely say that Hebron is a very holy place to all followers of Islam, Judaism, and Christianity.
The Arab riots took place in May 2021 not 2022, but otherwise good info and video
The tragedy of human evil.
New York Times: Blackest day of Spanish inquisition... WTF!
Yeah, "La Leyenda Negra" another convenient false narrative... WTF!
Today Jews protect themselves much better in Israel as much more Palestinians generally die in the ongoing perhaps for long time to come conflict!I want all Palestinians to move to Egypt but I also want Jews not to provoke in any way any dangerous Palestinian hoodlums in any mosques too🚨Let’s hope for peace!
I want all fake Jews to go back to Poland, Ukraine, Russia, Belarus, and whichever crevice u crawled out from. Mizrahim and Sephardim will stay as we are the real indigenous people of this land also known as Palestinians.
Palestinian dead count in 2022 - 200 (47 children)
Abraham two children still fight each other calling the other to be baby killers 😅
7/10/23
King Sen’nash’erib Of Assyria,
2 Chronicles 32 : 18.
They kept calling loudly in the language of the Jews
To the people of Jerusalem who were on the wall ,
To make them afraid and to terrify them,
In order to capture the city.
Verse 19.
They spoke against the God of Jerusalem the same way as against the gods of
The peoples of the earth.
So the Arabs blew there horns to terrify, the Jews, and capture the city of. Jerusalem.
2 kings 16 : 6.
At that time king Rezin of. Syria restored Elath to Edom, after which he drove the Jews out of Elath .
And. The Edomite Enter Elath . And they have accupied it down to. This. Day.
Verse 7.
So Ahaz sent messengers to king tiglath-pileser of Assyria,
Saying “I’am your servant and your son.
Come up and save me from the hand of the king of Syria , and the hand of Israel,
Who are attacking me.
Verse 8.
Ahaz then took the silver and the Gold, that was to be found at
The house of Yahweh, YHWH, And the treasures of the kings house,
And sent the king of
Assyria, A bribe.
Yes according to scriptures the Arabs , have wared with Israel.
So this is why the almighty God is given the land to Israel, because of otheres being wicked.
Isaiah 14 : 25.
Really Jews only have the wall, and Jerusalem is there’s.
Well I would wait for the true foundation,
Hebrew 11 : 10. 16.
Psalms 127 : 1.
Unless Jehovah builds the house it is in vain that it’s builders work hard on it.
Unless Yahweh, guards the city
It is in vain that the guard stays awake.
Israel 🇮🇱 ❤ ✡ 😢
Mel Gibson, shame.
Mel gibson💓💓💓
Not all muslims are bad
no one said that. it's also mentioned in the video that there were few of them who helped the jewish people during the massacare.
All of them are bad
40 young men went to hide inside a house that's the problem
It's very inappropriate, as well as childish, for the presenter of this video to make silly little jokes during a presentation of this nature.
Unpacking a bias view
Who are we to talk about BIAS we just killed 1 million Iraqis and explained it all away and no one ever says anything about it with bias news and the things we pull. They are just trying to protect themselves against people that have and still say we want to kill you.
Religion makes no sense.....
God does though...
God created us all.....
You guys need to get it together outside of your religious animosities
Praying for you all to stop the hatred
Nonsense
By the time the Ottoman Turks were done with Jerusalem, very few jews survived. And Britain Started the Arab-Israeli Conflict.
The Jews / Zionism also killed British soldiers and top British rank officials not just in Jerusalem but in London too.
The earliest history of a person who engaged in terrorism and in a court of law was a jew stabbing a Roman in the market's. Plus: Zionism is an aggressive and discriminatory ideology, indeed.
You cannot deny that. And Gaza prison break out was to be expected. Israeli Apartheid cannot lock up 2 million families.
Arabs had been killing Jews for centuries, and you never expected that they will rise up against you? You are angry because you Arabs hate non-Muslims ruling over you?
@@ianhomerpura8937 Hasbara at work
@@ianhomerpura8937 Arabs were the ones who kept those vermin from going extinct.
Here are some lies/misinformation in the video.
1) It wasn't the Mufti who stopped them from putting the sheets, it was already established during the Ottomans' rule that jewish people weren't allowed to bring chairs, sheets, and what not to the wall. Also, you make it seem as if praying at the wall was a new occurrence that started during the British occupation, which at the time angered the Mufti. That is also not true since the Jewish people there were already praying at the wall before the Brits came, so that narrative doesn't really make sense.
2) The mufti did actually make a complaint to the governing party(the brits), and they did actually inform the Jewish people to not bring anything to the wall again, also this was already agreed upon between the Jewish people and Muslim people. Also also this happened in 1928 and not in 1929, which was when the clashes occurred.
3) The protests were done first by a large number of Jewish people in Jerusalem, in which they kept shouting "the wall is ours". The next day, Muslims came out with their own protests also in Jerusalem, in which clashes between muslims and jews occurred. In the next couple of days, the clashes spread across other areas. One of the areas happened to be Al Khalil/Hebron, where the incident happened. Also loved the way you completely brushed over the fact that muslims were also killed, while also giving that amazing dramatic setup for the killing of the jewish people. As well as spreading information that isn't backed up by any real evidence other than "an unnamed american student", because that sir is called propaganda.
4)The grand Mufti "cozied up" to Germany and Italy to try and gain independence for what we refer to now as the MENA region. He did actually manage to help Libya get its independence from Italy. So it's not as you make it up to be, that he was there to "To Help Hitler Get Rid Of The Jews", since the whole world was not aware of what was happening to the Jewish people in Germany at the time. Finally, this isn't what you portray it to be, which is muslims(aggressors) and jews(victims), since both sides attacked and killed each other.
The omission of the nationalists' protest in the wake of the British refusal to deal with the problem does strike me as intellectually dishonest too...
If you had made the video though, it would have been more biased than the one you criticize, so all is well. No one would take a video on UA-cam for gospel, anyway. Especially on an event so defining to the mythology of Zionism and history of the Mandate alike.
@pingxingming idk about my video being more biased than this one. Why do you say that? While yes, I agree that this is yt and it's probably not the best place to get unbiased information and that my video would also probably be biased too. But hey, where the heck would you get unbiased info? Everything has biasism in it somehow if you look for it, but there is also something called common sense and actual evidence in audio, videos, leaked documents, confessions, and so on that anyone can watch and use to find, maybe not the whole truth but at least something more truthful than a video or an article on the internet. But then again, who has the time to do such things, right?
@@omartarek3706 Because you seem to be making the point that the video should be dismissed based on the omissions you mentioned, but those don't really change what happened; whether or not the mufti was the main instigator wasn't the focus of the video. The video tries to explain what paved the way for the massacre, and it did a pretty good job I think.
For neutrality's sake what I would have added is that Arabs were also murdered and the mufti spoke to the mob presumably to calm them down, and that the Haganah wouldn't have made much of a difference due to lack of manpower. The fact that Hebron features strongly in Zionist "mythology" is as interesting as it is predictable. But details like these or the funeral of the first victim being seen as provocation are beyond the scope of this type of video I suppose.
Learn to use indents and spacing out paragraphs it put me off from reading.
@pingxingming While yes, that is the title of the video. The content and structure of the information used in the video doesnt aim to do that.
Hitler wasn't around in 1929
He met with Hitler later on
Is this a serious comment?
yes
Umm yeah... Mein Kampf was literally written in 1925. Hitler already had jew-hatred by this point.
@@avabrackett7159 he had nothing to do with events in Hebron in 1929, that is the point I'm making
I am so grateful for this information! We need to remember, God is in control. He has informed us of His will and
way in the Holy Bible. We need only to seek in study of the sacred Word His way and truth. Despite the hatred and lies, the Jews have survived and will prevail. The Holy Bible and Israel are proof of that truth! In Jesus name: Amen!
No mediator necessary we have the truth in the Torah
You need to come to God--Father,Son, and Holy Spirit, read the Bible and the Holy Spirit will aid you in understanding beyond history.cultute, language, and emotion to learn the truth of His Word.
@@larryjones-emery807 Quit converting Jews to your religion!
@@larryjones-emery807 No need. We have our books, written in the original language, while you have sad translations of translations of translations, that have lost all meaning.
Jews reject Jesus Muslims accept Jesus who is the anti Christ?
Proverbs 13:2((N.L.T.))🍞
Guilt Tripping.
The amount of bias in the language used and story telling is just scandalous
Who are we to talk about that we just killed 1 million Arabs in Iraq with alot of BIAS and excuses to explain it away and no one ever talks against it. The jews are just trying to defend themselves against people who have repeatedly tried and said I want to kill you.
Not bias just facts
Was this video funded by the State of Israel?
Was your comment funded by Hizbullah?
I don't think so. It is costly for them.
I think it was jointly funded by the Iranian, Qatar's nd American government as usual.
Could you find out more details please?
No, it's literally history...
Maybe american evangelist?
No but the deaths of a million Iraqi was funded by us.
...I understand the point you're trying to make by this Video, but you're completely ignoring that the Arab ppl were also victims here. The Arab ppl were mislead and didn't deserve what happened to them after the massacre 1929...and they don't deserve to live the way they do Today, Oppressed by Israel
They are the oppressors, not the oppressed. If they were forced to live under the dhimmi laws, that oppressed Jews, when muslims controlled the city, they might have something to complain about. But, Arab Israelis have it better than any other Arabs in the middle east, despite being colonizers.
Massacring civilians, raping women and butchering children because they were "misled" is a weak defense. Kind of like the defense that Hamas had to rape women and butcher children on Oct 7.
Double standards u zionest
Meaning what? Do you have something to say?
Calling someone a Zionist doesn’t do anything
You wanna criticize the mufti but he was right about the dangers of zionism and the British intentions in Palestine
Or he was just an antisemite. Like you.
You should pull down this video. It's so wrong to frame the story and boil down the conflict to it being Jews' own home. Both Jews and Arabs are indigenous to land. You also repeatedly used language downplaying the crimes against innocent Arabs, selectively using "some" and only talking about "unarmed" Jews who were "savagely" murdered. I typically like Unpacked, but this is a bad video if your goal is objective education.
Because the blood of Arabs have been spilled because they want war, if they shut up and behave, they'll have no issue 🙄
This is also the reason we don't trust em
Jews from Judea Arabs from Arabia
That’s right he should’ve added Ibrahim Pasha rampage through the city close to a century earlier
name the incident and the armed jews in hebron and safed had to defend themselves or to retaliate against the arabs...has there been any major retaliation by jewish organizations against arabs before 1936 "grand arab rebellion"?please enlighten me if there were ...
Such a crock of bullshit.
Like you lied about the 40 beheaded babies.
Don’t worry - we made a whole video about that lie: ua-cam.com/video/1W6NoBsnmDk/v-deo.html
stop lying
where is he lying? source?
wow how bigoted and one sided is this?
Not ever going to happen you can't coincide with a neighbor that wants to exterminate you.
The Only solution is Jesus Christ, I promise He will end this soon. Believe in Him. He said he the truth and the way the life. ❤