Scene from Brokeback Mountain, The Horrific incident
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- *WARNING* DO NOT WATCH THIS SCENE IF YOU HAVE NOT SCENE THE MOVIE *WARNING*
This scene is by request also. This is one of my favorite scenes as it sheds light to why Ennis has all this fear.
This is also the scene were they are together on Mountain again for the first time in 4 years.
Enjoy.
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
It's crazy people live/lived out their whole lives pretending to be someone they aren't.
This is still real life for some people which is what really makes it scary
They had no choice, this was the time when living openly as gay could get you killed
@@rtjahyadi7868 you're right 😢
Its crazy. I cant imagine.
It’s not that crazy.
It kills me when Jack says "you know it could be like this, just like this. Always" 😭😭😭😭
Renata Riquelme he said it when i read this and it broke my heart fuck
What it mean ?
cheedohs 😭😭did you watch the movie and did you like it ?
😢😢😢😢😢
🤮🤮🤮🤮
What Ennis saw as a child would definitely be enough to traumatize someone. Which is why it’s difficult to come out
@The voice of... Yeah & I’m pretty sure this right here was part of the reason for that
Homosexuality was illegal at the time. No one wishes to come out in such a context...
@@anaisseby5610 It wasn’t just about it being illegal
@@joewhitehead3 I never said it was the only think to hold them back but that surely doesn't invite anyone to come out...
@@anaisseby5610 Neither does seeing other homosexuals getting viciously murdered, like here
"You shut up about Alma, this ain't her fault." I love that line and all the implications and emotion behind it.
☹️💔
Oh my name...
Alma *
@@DanielPlainview-dj5hn Thank you. Yikes lol
You know, Ennis gave up their happiness and they were together only for few days a year, because he did not want them to end up together like that, like his dad showed him. And Jack ended up like that anyway, even tho he did all he could to avoid it. That must have crashed Ennis's soul to pieces.
I'm usually not a fan of romantic movies. I actually hate them, most of the time. And one my friend, who's a great fan of Jake Gyllenhaal, almost demanded me to watch this one. Well, I'm glad she did, Brokeback Moutain is definitely one of the most touching film I've ever seen, without being pathetically cheesy at all, like most of romantic movies are.
Matty Bruno Lucas Zenere Salas it was tho wasn’t it.
Justin Case it’s good
Well you cant really get cheesy with cowboys. Gods own country share the same vibe buts not as good plot. But you should check it out anyway.
So the only one you like is with the swordfighters? Okay
I recommend Nightcrawler. That's his finest performance.
What's mind-blowing is that Heath and Jake were already open-minded about homosexuality at this time. And it warms my heart to see that they literally gave it all just to portray and bring to life those two characters, even though they're straight in real life.
Indeed
@Brah Believe it or not but it was. Specialy coming from famous actors. Just take a look at today's news. Some people are still stunned when they see a "straight" actor/actress play a Gay/Bi/Lesbian character. Like Maya Hawke who plays Robin Buckley in Stranger Things for instance. So imagine how it was in 2005.
@Brah Bush literally got elected 5 years earlier on the promise that he'd veto gay marriage lol
2005 was like today.
Nothing revolutionary in playing the role of a homosexual.
@@danielepetrucci5274 really depends where you lived
some places in 2005 closer to 80s than 2023. all changed when internet became mass available.
Imagine not being able to see the person you love for four years.
imagine never being able to see him again because some bigots killed him for being himself..
Try 15 years :(
I know that pain,glad I don’t have to feel it anymore.
@@iagreebut7269
.
i'm living the same scenario and it's been 2 years already
This movie always makes me cry buckets. The pain is so tangible. One of the absolute best of the century so far. The performances are shattering. RIP Heath Ledger.
Awful. Shaped his whole life. He could never get from under it.
That little stroke Jack gives to his ear, what else can he do?
I agree. This scene is the most poignant for me, maybe even more than the “I wish I could quit you” scene and the ending because it says SO much. That incident traumatized and put the fear in Ennis of what happens to you if your gay, just like his dad intended, and that’s why he couldn’t commit to Jack, even after his divorce from Alma, was paranoid and asked Jack if he thought anyone secretly knew anything, and envisioned Jack dying of a hate crime.
Lmao
@@lindseymays144Which for all we (and Ennis) know, was actually what happened to Jack. So horrible. No closure.
Very easy to say Ennis was a coward. It's far more complex than that. He's a stubborn, lonely man. He doesn't envision a different life, one where he could be with Jack and be happy, or somewhere else. It's part of a deeply rooted culture and way of life. He then pays the price and realizes his mistakes.
Also let me add that in the novel it's very clear that he's bi and enjoyed the straight lifestyle, but his demise was that a man was his soulmate. So he's in a constant inner battle with himself and doesn't accept that his heart chose Jack. Jack knew who he was, Ennis didn't.
@@gk9546Jack wanted to fuck more often than Ennis did. That’s the problem
To think that people could do that to another human being
Yeah and they wanna take away peoples right to carry a gun. This kind of stuff actually happens in real life, this poor fictional character should have had a gun.
@@justincase4382 Uh....the poor fictional characters were ranchers from Texas in the 50's....they had PLENTY of guns.
Justin Case I have a question so what happen in this scene like why his dad kill those people ?
@It’s funneh And the krew fan They were gay and the dad is homophobic.
@@justincase4382 Omg but ginving the bad guys guns isn't the best idea either?
Heath ledger's acting in this scene always blows me away his ability to portray a character's inability to express his emotions is such a skill with in its self and to think he pulled off this extraordinary performance when he was only 25!! what in amazing talent he truely was rip heath
Ennis' greatest fear came to pass on Jack
Nope. Jack wasn't tortured to death. It was just Ennis' imagination. What Lureen said on the phone was true.
@@stilscarlott it was filmed in a way that we do not know the truth of Jack’s death
@@stilscarlott I believe in the book it was true that Jack was beaten to death.
@@evagabor5 Originally, in the film it would be like this and not ambiguous. There is a deleted scene, after Ennis and Jack's last meeting, where two mechanics see Jack and Randall saying goodbye. The two actors who play the two mechanics are the same ones who beat Jack in that scene imagined by Ennis.
3:03-3:14 - "as long as we can ride it...there ain't no reins on this one" - so honest this moment, deeply profound. One can almost say the same about any burden which is difficult to bear.
Lol "ride it"
It ties into Jack's interest in rodeoing. But it's quite ironic how Jack can't seem to bear it as much as Ennis can. Perhaps if Ennis tried riding a bull, he'd be better at it than Jack.
zorrostealth what did his dad do like did his dad kill those peopel ?
It’s funneh And the krew fan The story says that his dad laughed about Earl’s death and it’s implied that he helped kill him
They rode it all right
It became a huge part of culture for a while and was constantly joked about and mocked. But behind all that was a truly powerful movie that changed many lives. Most people now never will see it because of all those jokes made about it and that's unfortunate.
So upsetting that people reduced it down to gay jokes. People just couldn't fathom two men loving each other back then, I'll never forgive anyone who made fun of this movie
The jokes are funny though
I just watched the movie a week ago for the first time and this is positively the one movie that touched my heart the most. Everything we see on the internet today, it's bizarre. Its like people sharply became gay friendly just to show that they aren't homophobic and it was normalised, ON THE INTERNET. For me, real life is still like brokeback mountain. Its difficult and very much NOT easy to be gay, let alone out to anyone
I watched it when I was younger and I thought the movie was gonna be funny because of all the jokes. The way it was advertised to me in high-school was it's a gay cowboy story between The Joker and Prince of Persia. And there were so many memes and parodies and puns that I genuinely thought it was gonna be the same type of funny action movies as Men In Black or KickAss or The Mask. I was totally confused when it wasn't the case. Instead it was super depressing, and slightly traumatizing and I was not prepared at all
what jokes? i don't get it. did i miss something?
It is not a choice. No one would choose a life of discrimination.
@Igloo Zoo are bisexuals and pansexuals non existent?
@Igloo Zoo what about those gays that are like "you never know if you dont try" like wtf? it makes it seem like it is a choice
@Igloo Zoo so being gay is a choice
@Igloo Zoo so why do you gays try to turn straight people gay, yet bitch and cry about acceptance?
@Igloo Zoo horrible response, this is why its hard to support you gay people, i try to be understanding that its not a choice but sometimes i believe that you people choose to be gay.
the saddest bit about this scene is that this is how Jack is going to die :(
wait, exactly, i haven’t seen the whole movie, just found these clips of it, does all of this happen to Jack
@@ashleya1227 you have to see the movie for yourself
@@jakobcoyne5701 Actually jake died from a car exploding in his face
@@sagal1449 I think he did too!!! I am so ugh, because I want him to have died from an accident, not hate... Jack was a good man, he didn't deserve to die that way
@@sagal1449 no taht was a cover up for what happened, his wife lurreen hired some ppl to beat him to death
Two tough old birds
Two gay birds
Scenes like this are way more scary than most monster movies or things like that because this is a reality. These things happen. Some horrible people out there
Different time back then. Ennis was just being honest and practical about the situation.
Not really. The film is all about Ennis making excuses to always keep the people he loves at arm's reach and never emotionally connecting with them. The tragedy isn't really about the world rejecting them, it's that they're two completely incompatible people who are in love. And it's only after Jack dies that Ennis is finally ready to be the person who could love Jack the way Jack needed him to. He's too late of course, for Jack's sake, and so "swears" to be more emotionally available to the people in his life. That's why he changes his mind about his daughter's wedding, whereas previously he would've made an excuse not to be there.
The first things we learn about Ennis is that he's lost people in his life. His parents, then his siblings after they got married and had no more room for him. So he never gets close to people out of fear of losing them. And it took losing Jack for him to realise that he lost his one shot at happiness ironically because he was afraid to lose it. And he tries to do better for his daughters.
Similarly the woman he was dating after Alma, he didn't stop seeing her because he disliked her because he was gay, he stopped seeing her because they actually connected, and that made Ennis uncomfortable and he felt he had to break it off before he got hurt. But its Ennis who is the one hurting himself.
@@ash_yt0 no, really. You see a body thats been tortured to death for being with another dude, and you see that body at a young age believe me you have a different outlook of the world.
@@geoff3103 I think you missed my point. Of course this would be traumatising.
But the film is more about Ennis's broader issues. By the end of the film you realise he often makes excuses. He not only turns down Jack but also turns down opportunities like spending time with his daughters. He pushes people away, and you realise that the reasons he gives are just excuses to not be close with anyone.
This is so sad. I'm gonna create my own happy ending: Jack and Ennis move to Canada or New York and by a farm/gorgeous condo where they live happily ever after. Then Alma and the other wife take their kids and live together in a big house where they both work and pay off the mortgage and raise their children to be all-inclusive, non-discriminatory, beautiful and brilliant individuals. The end. :]
that will be the perfect end...
thank you
I love your ending. In the '60's it was not likely but why not?
But what about Mexico
Your ending is stupid. .
That doesn’t sound happy
I think Ledgers performance here was equal to the Joker...
cdpay73 wow
I agree.
@@catsrule1343 better.
Yes.
@@catsrule1343
If you noticed in that scene when he was talking to his daughters while they were eating dinner at one point, he sounded alike the Joker "I was flying in the air"
"you know it could be like this, just like this. Always"
"how"
"we go to a northern state
"ok"
Jack and Ennis live up north happily ever after, THE END
I was trying to explain to a Christian how being gay isn’t something you choose by trying ask why he chooses to be attracted to women and not men. He seriously could not understand the concept
Far-right evangelicals are willfully ignorant.
Jack deserved so much better he loved Ennis with all his heart.
jake has the most amazing laugh - it always makes me smile, it's such a natural sound, and his gorgeous dimples (which we can't really see here) just adds to the perfection
He’s so handsome!
at the end when jack touches him, heath's expression is amazing.
once in a while...every four fuckin years?...gaah i love that line..
I love the way Ennis talks. It's beautiful.
I miss Heath Ledger. No telling what roles he would have had by now.
Jake's talking is beautiful too
ive never seen this film , but it got my mate through homophobic bullying at school, i mean Homopobia is up there and is one of the worst things in existence
It reminds me my own private idaho campfire scene between River Phoenix and Keanu Reeves .
Huh???
roastingpotato my own private idaho the film. just watch it, its also heartbreaking
Great performances from Jake and Heath. The world has lost a truly talented actor. May he rest in peace.
He has a very as Heath called it, "Clenched" personality and he reflected that in his speech.
man..this made me cry...especially when he put his hand on his cheek...it hurts to not be able to be with someone you love so much...it just hurts...and hurts even more to think about Heath's death...I really should stop watching these clips..before i fall into a depressing stupor...
Read the short story ;) It's almost more moving than the movie. Unlike far too much gay literature, this is a story about love, not sex. It's beautiful and fantastic for that reason. It opens peoples eyes to the reality and normalcy of two people of the same sex simply falling in love with each other...
My heart breaks when he says “for as long as we can ride it” and then the music starts playing before he says “there ain’t no reins on this one”. This movie is just so tragic it crushes me 😓
You like the movie ?
*If you can't fix it then you gotta stand it.* that's actually what happened to Ennis at the end. Poor guy. 😭 This movie breaks my heart so much. 💔😭
Part 1: This scene brings tears to my eyes. As a young gay man it is so wonderful to see a movie with actors who are playing these men as real people (as opposed to the steriotypical comic gay characters on a lot of films.)
Amen
Ben Mallinson People need to see this movie to the understand how hatd it is to live sexually free 😭
Ben, Love your posts on here. You seem like an awesome person!
Never be ashamed of something you have no control over
On the contrary, it’s called free will.. Gays know the consequences…..
Heath was such a good actor. Living deep south most of my life, I always noticed that a lot of country men have a way of speaking and he NAILS it. That tight lipped, neutral face expression, and low voice. It’s just enough that it’s polite, but not too much for you to think their guard is down.
They belong together though T_T
absolutely, touches my heart everytime. he delievers it beautifully
Jake is so freaking gorgeous.
They could have been so happy together! They could have had such a happy life! Ennis couldn’t let him love and be loved by Jack. He was just too scared. To scared to be who he was, to scared to admit how much he really was in love with Jack and how much Jack loved him. Too traumatized by what his father showed him. Too scared to take that leap and run with Jack
I hear my friends say theyre in love everyday. I thought I knew what it meant myself. That was till I watched this movie. Nothing was every the same.
A good description of marriage: "If you can't fix it, you gotta stand it!"
So glad times are better now in terms of ppls sexualities and others acceptance of it, treating it no different than heterosexuality. Ppl were soo fucked up, still r, but that's soo inhumane and wrong. Just disgusting how u could do that to ppl who ain't bothering nobody
@@thegatekeeper8612 What is fun is that straight people also get aids, and not to mention, gay people born out of straight relationships, so, even if some psycho guy locks every gay human somewhere, it won't end
It’s still a battle... but I do see what you’re saying
Yea I also wish asexuality is more known. Hopefully it will be and I hate that other sexualites that is not heterosexual are looked at as something wrong or to be ashamed of. People don't choose their sexual orientation. That's just people who are ignorant that think that.
Rod can you stop being homophobic? Thank you!
@@0demia not agreeing or disliking something isn't a phobia dumb fuck.
The thing is, if they were together, maybe they would get on each others' nerves sooner. Like this, their meetings were frequent enough to keep the flame alive, but sporadic enough so they don't grow tired of each other.
Maybe it was the best it was ever going to get.
People tend to forget two things:
1) It’s a dangerous world
2) Nothing ever changes
God Bless Heath, you will be truly missed
This movie is a heartbreaking masterpiece
i kind of laughed at this film before i'd even seen it, but now i have, it is actually really powerful and sad
What homophobia does…
What a tremendous loss Heath Ledger was to artistry.....and then to lose Phillip Seymour Hoffman 5-6yrs later? Devastating
Imagine being in love with someone but being scared for your safety because of it.. and being disgusted with yourself..💔 and still till this day lgbtq rights are nowhere where they need to be. This movie breaks my heart
It’s nowhere near what it used to be. They’ve come A LONG WAY.
@@GIGI_NYC Some still live in fear or are closeted because they live in strict or religious authoritarian environment's and families
This was a masterclass in acting from heath ledger!! his expression in this scene was just heart breaking even at such a young age when he played this character showed wisdom beyond his years my god what a talent he was may his legend never die r.i.p heath
Amen to that. All we can do is try to be more tolerate and realize..people, it's just love.
Ennis was in fear especially for Jack's life he knew that what eventually happened would I believe broke his heart too that he could not stop it maybe he felt guilt for running away
I love the soundtrack to this film
This movie is so powerful and daring. Those actors were brave to make those roles!
Perhaps the film makes less discrimination in the world, gay people still face hard discimination every day:(
I'm not gay at all.
But I think this film is excellent
One of the most emotional movies Ledger and Gyllenhaal 2 of the best intense performances a good movie
This is such a beautiful movie. I remember seeing it for the guest time and being so moved. The restraint and passion, it's something really special.
I don't want people to forget him.
aw this is beautiful!!!
I WATCHED THIS A FEW MONTHS AGO ITS WAS VERY LONG AND BEAUTIFUL MOVIE BUT FUCK THE ENDING.
THIS BROKE MY HEART AND IM TEARING UP AGAIN.
As a married man with a child, Jack already has responsibilities in life. It's selfish of him to be thinking about a relationship with Ennis.
It’s not selfish to think about it. It is selfish to act on it though.
@@anjelica948 That's very true. I stand corrected.
Ennis was a coward. Jack was willing to do anything, give up everything to be with him, but Ennis was a coward.
"coward" and yet you could never know what he really felt...
@@juanmanuelmoramontes3883 It doesn’t matter what he felt, he was too afraid to be with Jack and it ended up killing both of them inside. Jack was ready to be with him, but Ennis was too afraid.
Ennis was traumatized. I'd hardly call him a coward.
He was coward for not wanting what happened to those men, when he was kid, to happen to him?
@@joewhitehead3 yes! He let his fear consume him, and that fear made him hurt his wife, his children, the man he loved, and himself. He was a coward because he wasn’t even willing to meet Jack in the middle, and he was selfish. And I’m not saying this is a bad thing as a character. It makes him realistic.
As a suspected gay young man who was raised on a dairy farm (suspected because I wasn’t married by 21, I was constantly asked if I was gay and shot at. The local police didn’t even give my white-trash neighbors a ticket. So if any of you younger guys who attend Pride festivities and all wonder why some of us are still gun shy…this scene explains it REALLY clearly. My dad committed suicide in front of me 3 years ago and the last thing he said before he did it was what a disgrace I was. Jack’s dad, as portrayed in this movie was a replica of my old man.
It is also say's eating shelled fish is a sin, so the majority of the world is going to hell.
I cant believe Heath Ledger is gone.
RIP Heath Ledger.
Doesn’t matter how you feel about people living their lives. If they aren’t physically hurting someone, we don’t hurt them. So much violence in this world already don’t add to it. Love each other. Be kind to others. I worked in retail I had some awful customers but I was always kind to them. I figured something else was going in their lives to make them angry so why would I fuss back with them to add to it.
To show there are consequences for their actions. To show the world isn't a beautiful place where you get everything you want no matter what that is. Being gay in California or Texas at that time means you can be tortured and killed. It was just a life lesson.
joshig1983 Thank you for saying that. I was wanting to comment on this string but your comment said it well. That's the way it was and you had to adapt and take precautions. What lifestyle doesn't have to do that?
I'm surprised the full movie isn't anywhere on youtube.
Hi There There's a thing called copyright law.
Lol
Its on Pornhub!
@@gt9188 So are scenes of the US version of Shameless, particularly with Ian and Mickey.
The loss is ours, but we do not contest your right to go away dear Heath. Your debts are paid. Go now, and live once more in a happier time and place.
These 2 are amazing. Ang Lee is a MASTER
Dear Viewers:
NBC has flagged this video for Copyright infringement and unfortunately UA-cam will end up removing it. I wish there is something I could do but I cannot, I urge everyone to purchase the movie as I'm sure they will remove all the clips from UA-cam.
“If you can’t fix it; you gotta stand it…… they’re ain’t no reins on this one”. Ennis is right. Jack is pipe dreaming.
if you cant fix it, you have to stand it..... :,(
Ledger , essayed this role beautifully. Almost can see his lips moving, talks in that Texan accent.
Like the movie ?
such a sad movie...:( but beautifully played...
Totally agree with you. When I told my students about this beautiful film being about love, they asked me if I was gay. Now when you know that they are freshmen in their early late teenage, it sounds really sad!
I've been waiting 10 years to ask u this, are u gay?
God, this movie was so beautiful and sad. Most melodramas get you to cry, I feel, by being sorta trite and manipulative -- the 2 lovers meet, they're forced apart, one of them dies or almost dies, tears, the end. But this movie was so understated and real, by the end of the film I felt so much for all of the characters.
Just think how many people were/are in Jack & Ennis' situation. Heartbreaking.
You said it. My uncle's only a few years older than me, and he struggled with being gay for a long time (he lived in Texas...) but now he's happily married with a beautiful adopted daughter. Any two people can find love in eachother, given the right circumstances.
I actually found it kinda funny, he sounded so pissed: "every 4 fucking years?!" lol
El trauma de Ennis que no le permitió ser feliz con quien quería y la decepción de Jack 🥺😢😭
You probably have not seen the movie, he is incredible in this role and a incredible actor. Which nearly every critic of this movie will tell you.
Part 2:
It is such a sad story, so sad they lived their lives in secret due to hateful people but I think the characterisation of the relationship between these two men is just beuatiful.
I have a loving supportive family and network of friends who never descriminated against me!! and I am so grateful for this........................ We can all aspire to be supportive to those people who were not brought up in as accepting and supportive environment towards gay people as I was.
Yeah, about homophobia maybe, but also about living your entire life with regrets and what if's? It would not have been so poignant with a man/woman, but still the big picture-- how awful to not be able to be with the one you love. Sad. Great Movie -- a must see
lol why do ppl have to say that they are not gay when posting comments. I am not and i think it's a wonderful movie.
but...you just....
It would suck to be gay in that time. Always would have to sneak around just to be who you are.
I must say they should have went to San Francisco.
It’s not that ennis didn’t want a life with Jack. It was the consequences. It was a different world back then and it was easy to get whipped. Ennis knew full well since he witness the corpse of that guy he knew as a kid. If anyone found out then that could be him or Jack.
Makes me cry.
Progress never Ends.
I'm Bisexual & Proud 🏳️🌈
From 1:26-1:40 is the clip they showed at the academy awards for his nomination for Best Actor
I agreeee :D This movie makes me soo sad tho! :D Heath was an amazing actor and hopefully he is happy up in Heaven! I love you Heath Rip :(
3:12 gets me
I miss this movie.
I went to see it with my brother...who really surprised me..i never thought he would even consider it. :).
I just loved Heath's performance in this movie - absolutely brilliant!!!
It’s not that ennis didn’t want a life with Jack. It was the consequences. It was a different world back then and it was easy to get whipped. Ennis knew full well since he witness the corpse of that guy earl when he was a kid. Sight like that at nine years old would traumatize anyone.
My thoughts exactly