US Role in Deadly ATACMS Strike on Crimean Beach & Why Ukraine Calls Crimeans "Civilian Occupiers"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- - A deadly ATACMS strike on a Crimean beach left several civilians dead including children, followed by Moscow blaming Washington for the attack;
- Senior Ukrainian presidential advisor Mykhailo Podolyak refused to apologize for the attack, instead insisting civilians are considered “occupiers” and that signs of peaceful life on the peninsula cannot be allowed;
- The US provides Ukraine with all targeting data for HIMARS/M270 strikes for both shorter range guided rockets and longer range ATACMS according to the Washington Post;
- Leaked audio between senior German military officers reveal that all NATO long-range weapons require NATO mission planning and targeting data transferred to Ukrainians, with the addition of US and British personnel on the ground helping prepare weapons for strikes;
- The deadly attack is only the latest in a long line of atrocities enabled by US-NATO support of Ukraine's various governments following the US overthrow of Ukraine's elected government in 2014;
References:
NEO - US-Ukrainian ATACMS Strikes on Crimea Vindicate Moscow (June 28, 2024):
journal-neo.su...
Ukrinform - There cannot be any "beaches," "tourist zones" and other fictitious signs of "peaceful life" in Crimea, temporarily occupied by the Russians (June 25, 2024):
www.ukrinform....
The Telegraph - Ukraine suspected of ATACMS strike on Russian space control centre in Crimea, Ukraine: The Latest (June 25, 2024):
• Ukraine suspected of A...
The Telegraph - Crimean sunbathers struck by deadly shrapnel shower from Ukrainian missile (June 23, 2024):
www.telegraph....
The Guardian - US campaign behind the turmoil in Kiev (November 2014):
www.theguardia...
USAID, IRI - Public Opinion Survey Residents of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea May 16 - 30, 2013:
pdf.usaid.gov/...
BBC - Russian parliament approves troop deployment in Ukraine (March 2014):
www.bbc.com/ne...
Washington Post - Ukraine’s rocket campaign reliant on U.S. precision targeting, officials say (February 2023):
www.washington...
Where to Find My Work:
Website: landdestroyer....
Telegram: t.me/brianlove...
Twitter: / brianjberletic
Odysee (UA-cam alternative): odysee.com/@La...
Rumble (UA-cam alternative): rumble.com/c/c...
Weibo: weibo.com/u/77...
ไบรอัน แฟนคลับ (Facebook): / brianthaifanclub
Line Group: lin.ee/JIxTpKe
Gab: gab.com/BrianB...
VK (Facebook alternative): brianbe...
How to Support my Work (and thank you!):
Buy Me A Coffee: www.buymeacoff...
Patreon: / landdestroyer
PromptPay: 0851547235
Cryptocurrency Donations:
Ethereum (ETH): 0xee6ed93c3adc474450011e9af22939a0b9b312c7
BitCoin (BTC): 1AfGnbmHxA6cy9YKUSxysXvpJPyecpBKrr
Monero (XMR): 845TCXx3pchSBXuDL7FHG679gbWD2wkHS6MJxuq7jFVsVFj7T6xsry747uhhGZUdkaRXbbrMfo5c8RnGfzGZ13KxQUdHVLR
Here is the article: journal-neo.su/2024/06/28/us-ukrainian-atacms-strikes-on-crimea-vindicate-moscow/
How about instead of telling us you wrote an article, you just present the article as a video? Try it it'll be good
Brian I need to ask you something.
If WE believe that the U.S. directs all of Ukraines Actions...I think anyone sane believes this..... if this is the case, why would we believe that ANY interview(er) actually performed the interview with a Ukrainian. Considering it is all directed by the U.S. , I don't believe ANY of this 'Interviews' actually took place. I believe in most cases, these 'articles' are written with no permission from Ukraine.. Let alone the U.s?
How we knew that the strike was deliberate:
US immediately released press statements that the strike was the result of falling debris. That is, no time was given for analysis and investigation. A key marker for a cover story and admission of culpability.
How we proved it was deliberate:
When missiles are intercepted, they do not get to perfectly deploy their warhead payload. As the video of the strike shows, the warhead delivered its payload perfectly.
Now what is interesting is that we know Russia spoofs and jams these missiles GPS guidance. A rough guideline is 1 second of jamming results in 1->2m2 of targeting error. The missile struck about 50m-> 100m before the beach.
Now i've checked the map, i cannot see targets behind the beach, the beach struck was jutting out to sea, very little land was behind the beach as a line drawn from the missiles direction attests.
So to me, the target was civilians. Which cannister rounds / bomblets are perfect for
Brian, according to Jacques Baud at the time of the Maiden Coup there were 22,000 Ukrainian military in Crimea. Out of those 22,000 Ukrainian military 20,000 immediately changed sides and joined the Russian military. I've heard him say this more than once.
Shameful behaviour by US and NATO.
Plus the lying BBC.
Nothing new for them. No one should be shocked by this. The US and Nato have condoned every single action done by Israel against children as well.
My family live in Crimea for a little more than 100 years. I guess i'm "civilian occupier" too, i voted on referendum to join Russia, after all. How ukrops expected us to react to this? If hatred towards Ukrainian state was not peaked among Crimeans before, it sure did so now
Ty tady nemáš co dělat! Anexe Krymu Kateřinou Velikou byla zlomem, dnešní nároky ale neospravedlňuje, upozorňují historici ! Krymský poloostrov se před 240 lety stal součástí Ruského impéria. Strategické vítězství carevny Kateřiny II. Veliké zajistilo Rusku přístup k Černému moři a zároveň oslabilo dávného konkurenta, Osmanskou říši. Pro původní obyvatele Krymu však anexe znamenala nejen ztrátu vlastního státu. Krymští Tataři byli během století z poloostrova vytlačeni a jejich dějiny vymazány. Jsi okupant a na Ukrajině máš mlčet a nebo jít tam, odkud jsi přišel! Ty jsi rusák, tak jděte, a žádná válka nebude! Čistky obyvatel nejen Stalina a Kateřiny Veliké se vám zatmělo! ua-cam.com/video/hde-2h5eEQI/v-deo.html ct24.ceskatelevize.cz/clanek/svet/anexe-krymu-katerinou-velikou-byla-zlomem-dnesni-naroky-ale-neospravedlnuje-upozornuji-historici-7544
One fact, supressed in the West and in Ukraine is there was a referendum in Crimea in 1991, even before Ukraine gained independence. They wanted to split from Ukraine and become an independent republic. They won majority of vites, but Ukraine refused to recognize the results.
Came across this while doing some research on the matter 2 weeks ago.
You'll never get a job at the BBC🤣
@fifi23o5 - correction: central Soviet government refused to split Crimea from Ukraine. Probably they were afraid that would cause a chain of further requests for separation amongst other Soviet republics and regions, probably fearing of sparkling civil war amongst the nationalities.
Thanks for that. Whenever I hear _Crimean referendum_ I think 2014 (which keeps getting dismissed as "illegal" because by then it needed to be held in accordance with the Ukrainian constitution). Now I know the issue has a much longer history.
After only a very brief skim of related information I can see Crimean autonomy has been a delicate matter for Russian-Ukrainian relations for a very long time and it was being handled diplomatically until ... well, at first glance it sure looks like the US just ran in there like one of those flirty girls who like to cause drama among boys simply for the fun of causing drama.
@@retyroniExcellent comment! 😂
Yep, the western media conveniently omitts the fact that the first referendum to go back to Russia was held in 1991, that's exactly the reason why Ukraine's structure WAS of 34 regions (oblast) and the AUTONOMOUS region of Crimea.
Ukraine would Not be fighting today without the Help From The US/Europe, it would have ended before it started.
Without US/western meddling all this would never even start.
Same thing with Israelis.
Exactly
The billionaires steal from the people to gain new territory for their empires.
Nothing would have even started.
So, if Ukraine and the West believe Crimeans in Crimea are civil occupiers and should be targeted, do they also believe Israeli's occupying the West Bank should also be targeted?
100% Right
At least Crimea had a referendum Palestine / Israel occupied Palestine haven't
Russians in Crimea are indigeneous while israelis in Palestine are invaders.
A tiny difference.
Oh, no. That would be too logical.
i love the smell of hypocrisy i the morning ... smells like victory!!!
Nazis 🤷♂️
Exactly
Specifically Ukrainian Nazism
And they don’t hide it - just remember who their president clapped for in the Canadian Parliament.
Podoliak could not hide his real sinister nature! Even kids didn’t stop this guy. Disgusting!
Indeed there's is no doubt these criminals see any Russian as a target, vile creatures to a man and war criminals.
With these globalists and their not see proxies, they prefer kids
The Minsk agreement could have prevented all this but US wanted to "weaken Russia" by "fighting to the last Ukrainian."
We also need to remember that Crimea was attached to Ukraine in 1953 in a manner that went against the constitution of the Soviet Union by a leader that some claim was Ukrainian.
Also between 1991 and 2014, the Ukrainian government sought to limit the autonomy of Crimea against the wishes of those living in Crimea.
After Crimea left Ukraine in 2014, Ukraine cut the electricity supply and water supply to the peninsula, ensuring bridges were burnt.
And Zelensky went on TV in Ukraine, as a comedian, and mocked Crimeans for not having water or electricity.
USsupports ethnic cleansing in Ukraine and Gaza.
@ViceCoin, whats going on in Gaza "the palestinians" can only be blamed on themselves, because when they elected the psychopathic Hamas to rule for them they are to blamed for everything that happens there.
First of all until 1991 the whole Ukraine was part of UDSSR including Crimea. The West guaranteed that NATO would not move one inch closer once they would become a sovereign country. Ukraine only became a problem when the US and Europe were not holding their promises and made a regime change and thereafter the whole problem we got now was created by NATO.
What they mean by ‘taking back’ Crimea is ethnic cleansing and war crimes. A West Bank G…a..z……a 2.0
Crimea has been Russian longer than USA has existed.
@@TheBelrickCrimea became Russian lands in 1774, two years before the United States gained independence.
Russia signed a treaty they would not invade Ukraine in exchange for Ukraine giving them all Soviet nuclear weapons in Ukraine. Ukraine is a sovereign nation and they can choose to ally with whomever they want. Russia violated the treaty.
@@RobOfTheNorth2001 Not even close to the truth, Robby.
It's a shame Ukrainians lost their morality for a few billion dollars 😢
Every NATO country lost its morality backing them
Not even. Those carrying out such acts had no morality in the first place and still have none. Whereas for the clueless Ukrainians, they believe the west loves them. They don't realise that Ukraine is only being used.
Not even. Those carrying out such acts had no morality in the first place and still have none. Whereas for the the others, they believe the west loves them. They don't realise that they're only being used.
To lose something, first they needed to have it.
Some Ukrainians. Most Ukrainians will never see that money.
The ones who were brainwashed to support the belligerence against Russia, were conditioned in the same way most USAns and EUans (Asians, Africans, etc…): through the work of the NED, NGOs, USAID, etc… through higher education, tech training, the promise of well paying jobs in the empire or for the empire.
That’s the sellout.
That’s how they manufacture consent. That’s how they manipulated so many people to willingly take the Western mRNA injection. That’s how they manipulate people into dehumanizing and hating others…
the Russians
the Chinese
the Muslims
the Arabs
the Anti-vaxx…
Your passion for the facts and accuracy is admirable and disarming! Wonderful work Brian!
👍🏼🤝
There is no doubt the majority of Crimeans wanted to join Russia in 2014. As far as was it legal?..it was as legal as Kosovo.
no, Kosovo is core ancient Serbia , where a former (100y? ) assimilated albanian (refugee)group was used by cia&itsalbanianmafia-allies + US imported jihadists to "rebel", to destroy Serbia, and install a ciamafia - Natostan demanding independance!!
Crimea, as ecolained, was an autonomous nationstate publicly menaced of invasion and destruction by an illegal foreign-backed naziregime.
I think more legal than Kosovo, because the people didn't vote in Kosovo
There was no referendum in Kosovo.
there were international observers in Crimea in 2014. But corporate Media never meant to mentioned them following the narrative.
More so. For one thing, the Western theft of Kosovo to turn it into Greater Camp Bondsteel was not on the basis of a referendum, despite Obama publicly lying (in 2014) that it was.
The Kiev response , copying Isnotreal semantics, shows that they still and always think of territory, without population. They "own" land and may kill human "occupiers".
Most of the time it's the resource value of the land, but strategic value is also considered...
Suggestion: all your hard work will be valuable Documentary someday. The detailed timelines, equipment, incremental strategic analysis will be a valuable resource for future researchers.
This polling is also why the US gave minimal protestations when Russia occupied Crimea when it came to a policy standpoint, because they knew it wasn't likely to stay with Ukraine regardless.
❤Thank you very much for this lesson . Keep up the good work Brian.
That 'Ukraine: The Latest' podcast is pure cope and propaganda.
the telegraphs Ukrainian flag thumb nail give the game away about any kind ot neutral journalism.. Strange to see them saying anything anti Ukrainian
Agreed
They crossed a line and now the west is paying for it 😂😂 send more of your -foreign mercenaries- american, french and british volunteers
Don't forget Canada.... Trudeau has his little fingers in Ukraine too!! Idiot!
(Not you, Trudeau!😂)
Was taught in History books that Crimea was fought and conquered by the Russians in the 18th Century, the Crimean War 1853-56 was between Britain, France, Ottoman Empire and Russia, and that Crimea was an independent Tatar Republic until 1954 when ceded to Ukraine as part of the 300-year of Ukraine-Russia unification... If both Russia and Ukraine speak Cyrillic - that make them practically Family - and that makes U.S./NATO the Neighbours from Hell out to steal the both the Bear's Cub and her Den, right? Must be Safety Deposit Boxes in Sevastopol that the FBI wants...
You left out Nikita Khrushchev.
A good summary in general, but this bit isn't accurate:
_Crimea was an independent Tatar Republic until 1954_
Crimea was an autonomous republic inside the Russian Federation until 1954 (as it is again now), but the majority had been Russian for generations, not Tatar. The Tatars I think were one of the recognised ethnic minorities, with special protections. (Though they had been badly treated not long before because of some of them co-operating with the German occupiers during WW2.)
Thank you Brian Berletic, you are one of the best and most honest analysts online!!
Russia needs to stop pussy-footing around with Ukraine and, at least, pick up the pace and remove the money laundering capitol of the world.
Russia wants to keep the respect of the rest of the world, that's why it doesn't want to be seen as the aggressor! One has to admire Putin's resilience and patience! It must be hard...
Cute. If Crimeans are "civilian occupiers", then what are the immigrants to Isrl, most of them are not even West Asians, who are now living in settlements created by Isrl's occupation of Pal.
It all comes from America basically
From Africa; Angola... VIVA The INDISPUTABLE greatest WARRIORS of our world; with the most POWERFUL army on planet; Big Russia rules ⭐
AMEN!
@@rafaellastracom6411 Amen
MPLA😊
Força Amigo!!!👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼😃
"Occupiers"😂😂😂😂😂
They've been there for centuries
De ja Vu reading your comment too!
Слава Киевской Руси.
No one was occupied. Have some mercy
Even before the legitimate referendum of 2014 Cimea had NOT been a legitimate part of Ukraine. The act of transferring The Crimea Peninsula from the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic to the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic had never been legitimate: The decision was made behind the scenes bypassing the articles 49 of the Constitution of the USSR, 33 of the Constitution of the RSFSR and 30 of the Constitution of the Ukrainian SSR by the order of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR - the organ that doesn't have an authority to make decisions on the territory transfers, it was breaking the law.
Besides,the 2d moment of the territory transfer had to be an act of the documenting the change of borders, but such document had never been issued by either side. The transfer was done bypassing the Constitution on major levels.
Russia should taeget the NATO satelites ,we know it can be done ,Russia has demonstrated it can back last year i believe.
Praise the lord for the gift of Brian Berletic, unbelievable, brother your research and analysis is first class thanks so much, you shed a lot of new light on this situation in Ukraine
"Civilian Occupiers"...isn't that what Hamas calls Israelis?
нет не так.
All isnotrealis are invaders.
But in that case it is true. Its the Israelis who were/are the occupiers... sanctioned by the US and the West!!!
Israel, with US support, has lowered the bar that other nations figure they can target civilians too.
а чем израильские сионисты - людоеды отличаются от американских сионистов - людоедов.
The only bar that had been lowered is the notion that combatants are expected to make themselves distinct (wearing military insignias and uniforms) from civilians and remove said civilians from the combat zone.... Case in point, what the Russians and Ukrainians are currently doing.
In Palestine, they do the exact opposite. They don't wear uniforms and specifically imbed themselves in civilian areas so that any attack against them would result in collateral damage and then have the gall to complain about civilian casualties.
This fact is often ignored by people who wish to push the narrative that Israel would waste millions of dollars worth of munitions targeting civilians.
There was never a bar with the US. The US has always targeted civilians. The Israelis learned from them.
Mark Milley, former Joint chief of staff: “Before we criticize Israel, let’s not forget that we [USA]
- destroyed 69 Japanese cities not including Hiroshima and Nagasaki
- killed countless innocent civilians in Mosul, Iraq and Raqqa, Syria
- killed 12,000 innocent French civilians… “
That is to forget Korea, Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, Iraq and so many other countries where civilians in their hundreds of thousands have been massacred by the evil empire.
military summit : Atakms whole taken by the russian military, to study and build defense against.
Thank you, Brian, ❤. Excellent job.
Zelenskyy current status is self proclamied Ukranian president or dictator.
Thanks, Brian, I was looking for this pole in your previous videos, but just couldn't remember where exactly you were covoring this info. It's like you red my mind making another video about it.🤜🏼🤛🏻
Great analysis Brian, you have put the beach incident to bed for me. Your research uncovering publications is stellar, their own words out them out as compliance...
'Occupiers' have been living in Crimea for centuries. Thank You, Brian. B.R.
So what? Don't try to justify a war of conquest because "we used to live there." By this logic, Russia would no longer exist, as most of it used to be Poland and Mongolia, and a good portion of the Far East is historically Chinese. Does that give them the right to break russia up and steal territory? No, sp stop trying to justify the russians doing it.
And lived before any hypotetical Ukrainian settled here. Crimean Khanate, last piece of the Golden Horde and disgusting criminal hole that rised its economy solely by capturing villagers of Russia and Poland and selling them as slaves into Turkey, was defeated by Russian troops and annexed by Russia, after that people from mainland Russia come to live here, not from territory of future Ukraine (because Ukrainian steppes already very fertile, why would people abandon them, now, that they are secured from Crimean Tatar attacks? On the other hand, people from the northern reaches of the country was happy to pick place more suitable for agriculture). And built beautiful cities all across Black Sea shore. And now Ukraine claim all that land and cities as initially theirs, not as basically gift of Russia (with one single condition, one simple red line - to not oppress ethnic Russians that live there, and let them speak their language. Ukraine failed that spectacularly). Blissful that Ukrainian patriot that ingnorant for history, but that doesn't help him in the long run
@@mcnuffin1208the unconstitutional ukrainian regime tried to play empire when it invaded the Donbasd in 2014
@@AtticusKarpenter справедивости ради, Крымское ханство конфликтовало с ханами Золотой Орды, и этим неоднократно пользовалось Московкое княжество по принципу враг моего врага... Но в любом случае, крымские татары появились в Крыму не ранее монгольских завоеваний 13 века, так что коренными обитателями Крыма они считаться не могут. Затем Крымское ханство попало в вассальные подчинение к Османской империи, когда турки захватилии Константинополь и перекрыли европейским христианам (в частности генуэзцам) доступ в Черное море. Изначально христианская Грузия тоже оказалась отрезанной османами от поддержки христиан в Европе и окружена мусульманами на Кавказе. Христианская Армения и вовсе была полностью аннексирована османами. Исламским правителям запрещалось порабощать мусульман, Крымское ханство соотвестветсвенно нападало и порабощали лишь христиан и местных язычников, совершая свои набеги на север. В 18 веке османский вассалитет Крымского ханства оспариваривался Российской империей в нескольких русско-турецких войнах. Несамостоятельность Крымского ханства бороться против турок и прекратить работорговлю предопредилило включение Крыма непосредственно в состав Российской империи при Екатерине II мирным путем. Россияне начали строить город Севастополь с портом и гаванью, способной вмещать весь Черноморский флот на сотни лет вперед. Неудивительно что главной целью Крымской войны 1853-1856 гг стала борьба за Севастополь, и в несколько меньшей степени, контроль городов и крепостей по Дунаю и в Армении. Жестокие сражения той войны до сих пор обижают англичан и французов, а также турок и сардинцев. В клипе группы Iron Maiden The Trooper и нескольких фильмах про Атаку легкой кавалерийской бригады англичан под Севастополем показано это.
What morality?! en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacres_of_Poles_in_Volhynia_and_Eastern_Galicia
Thanks Brian..greatly appreciated
We need to talk about this. Thanks for the work.
not just talk, we need to share the true information.
@@tanyaluhrs8750 exactly
The US is directly implicated in targeting the beach?
Not so much targeting the beach, it's more likely they were targeting an airbase on Crimea but the Russians intercepted them and the bomblets landed on the beach which is why they didn't actually go off. But it is certain the Americans were involved in the targeting.
@@mrsnuffleupagus9014The trajectory of the missiles creates much doubt the air base was the actual target. Maybe the beach wasn't the actual target, that information will never be known but this war is about narratives. The Russians are only playing the Western game. This specific narrative has gotten much traction in Russia the only place it is really important for the Russian leadership.
@@mrsnuffleupagus9014 they went off.
Their gear, their people in charge of it.
@@gregkillam no they didn't. If they had we would be looking at ten times innocent deaths.
Disgusting behavior 😑
Your analysis is greatly appreciated. It reveals the truth which is silenced or shunned by the western media. Thank you, Brian, from a Brit living in Bangkok for almost 20 years.
The occupants of Crimea have lived there for 6 generations....same as Donbas.
So many people are saying that "surely America wouldn't sanction an attack on a civilian area".
Tell that to the millions of Vietnamese, Cambodians, Laos, Afghans, Syrians, Serbs, Libyans that Americans have slaughtered.
Ukraine: nooo, the primitive orcs cannot shoot down our advanced wonderweapons (80s tech ATACMS)
Also Ukraine when they bomb civilians: Russia shot down our old missiles thats why it struck civilians
Vol 2.
Ukraine: yesss, our brave air defence crews shoot down 99-100% of Russian missiles
Also Ukraine: Russia deliberately bonbs our civilians and the missile only hit civilians because we couldn't intercept it
Bonjour , merci . Parfait comme d'habitude .
Au revoir et à bientôt .
ZELENSKIY is FAB 100K for Ukraine, Klitschko is FAB 20K for Kiev.
NATO members provide Ukraine with information collected during reconnaissance flights of aircraft equipped with AWACS systems, reports the UK Defence Journal.
The United States has committed an Act of International Terrorism on the territory of Russia
Russia has the right to charge the United States in accordance with International legal Acts and Conventions in the field of International terrorism:
International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism (adopted by UN General Assembly Resolution 54/109 of December 9, 1999);
Declaration on Measures to Eliminate International Terrorism (approved by UN General Assembly Resolution 49/60 of December 9, 1994);
The International Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings (New York, December 15, 1997) After the indictment, ALL UN member states that have signed these documents will be REQUIRED to assist in the EXTRADITION of the accused
"Crimea will be Ukrainian or it will be depopulated" is a ukrainian xxzi slogan. I've traced it back to 2006. Podolyaks remark is in line with the slogan.
Can't remember when and where Nazis say anything good about civilians or respect the rights of people.
Okay, giving Ukraine-USA-NATO the maximum benefit of the doubt, the missiles that were fired and were intercepted, including the one that landed on the beach in Crimea, carried cluster munitions. If they were intercepted and the beach in Crimea was not actually the intended target, what was the intended target? Cluster munitions are an anti-personnel weapon, made to kill people, not to damage runways, reinforced bunkers or hangars, and so on. So who were they actually trying to kill?
I always thought that The Ukraine was The Borderland of Russia, hence all of the various Gargantuan Monuments to the various generations of Heroes who have had to leave home and go back out to Ukraine again ..Anyway I always thought of Crimea as the place where the Russians went to go lay around on Towels and do the Beach thing. ⛱
I thought that this was all common knowledge, who would dispute this?
De ja vu reading your comment!
@FunkyWinkerbean ...something you would know nothing about.
Excellent work brian ❤❤
always very informative. Thank you.
16:00 onwards… your memory Brian! Brilliant!
The entire vlog is an example of excellence in reporting and analysis.
Thank you Brian, for another of your well researched reports. It should now be evident even to the casual observer of the NATO/Ukraine vs Russia war that neither Russia nor China can be defeated by a NATO+ using conventional weapons. Even though it is most likely that the side facing imminent defeat would be the first to escalate from the use of conventional weapons to the use of nuclear weapons, irrespective of which side did so, the outcome of a nuclear war between such heavily armed nation states could be the premature extinction of our human race.
"Civilian Occupiers"... Yeah. They would be happy to see the ukrainian government return.
The question is then who exactly is the Ukrainian leadership liberating Crimea from, the Russian military or the Crimean people?
@@seeker2118 украинское руководство ни кого не освобождает.
Doesn't every country have civilian occupiers ? People who live there ?
My question is about DDR!!! Why germany can be united but russia not? Nobody asked people of ddr anything about reunion of germany! Also what happened to ddr army?
Thank you Brian! I've been following this topic since 2014. I remember reading about those polls and it's great that you've brought it back to our attention.
beware us aid.
Great listening Brian
Wow, this was so fascinating and informative. Thank-you!
If the people who overthrew the government have the right to self-determination, then the people who didn't overthrow the government also have the right to self-determination.
Washington has always violently contradicted what it says it supports.
This highlights the importance of being able to rain immediate retribution upon the American homeland as a deterrence. But this is assuming Washington even cared about American lives.
We're here, we're in Crimea, Get used to it.
@FunkyWinkerbeando you really know?
I doubt.
@@zoltanbarath7371 He probably does not. He is only one day old after all.
US needs to understand that playing Russian roulette with a nuclear superpower is never a good idea.
❗️👍 Thank you for making these important facts known in the Collective West! It's important to spread these facts far and wide!!
the position of Western democratic regimes like Israel or Ukraine on civilian casualties consists of cynically justifying the casualties with sadistic and hate-addled statements. Meanwhile, someone they villify such as President Assad responds sincerely that it was not his intention to cause any such loss to bystanders
Thanks Brian for another analysis that looks behind the curtain to bring clarity to this tragic event.
Excellent Brian.thank you.
Critically informative
Thanks again, Brian, for an excellent report.
"And we have an unique opportunity today, where it was possible to do this very quickly and painlessly in the first three to six months of the war. Then many of the pro-Russians could have been physically purged. Today it's a bit more complicated, but then again it being a bit more complicated doesn't mean it's impossible." - Podolyak in interview for the UA state TV, 2023
The entirety of Crimea has been strictly Russian territory since Russia took it from the Turks the old-fashioned way in 1776. There was a short break (25 years) in ownership following the collapse of the Soviet Union, which is now being rectified due entirely to the extreme idiocy of USnato.
How many people in Crimea get their pensions paid by Russia.? Many, so it makes complete sense those people would favour Russia over Ukraine.
I am not a military man and I don't know why cluster munitions would be used to target an airfield. I lived 6 years, aged 4 to 10, on a Canadian airforce base and all I saw were buildings (to be targeted with building-busters), open fields of shortgrass and runways (with few human targets for cluster bombs), prairie dogs, and western meadowlarks.
Ukraine is stuck into its video game narrative where it can make no mistake, can't get defeated even one second. Otherwise the geeks supporting it will be annoyed. But those geeks have no problem hitting civilans. After all they live in video games. Just look their attitude towards nuclear weapons: they just believe if Russia used nuclear weapons they would reply and... Win... And then restart a new game
Instead of arming Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan; US tax payer money should be spent on infrastructure, healthcare, education, homelessness etc.
Your work, as always, is most appreciated Brian. Many thanks.
I am sick of the ciA. Crimea is russia period exclaimation. Go back 300 years
Brian's analysis is always spot on
The day that attack on Crimea happened, there was a US drone patrolling up and down the black sea for several hours...MQ-9 reaper drone I think...it was visible on flightradar24.
Excellent as per usual,
Crimeea it NEVER was a UA territory..end of story...
This kind of elegant simplicity in content and presentation. Tasty.
Lindsey says best money ever spent.
IMHO When it eventually comes out in the wash, the Ukraine war will be known to be caused by Brandon alone.
Do not forget Victoria "The Cookie Monster" Nuland.
Her contribution is enormous.
No. Obama. Biden isn't running shit, well actually he literally is, but you are actually watching Obama's 3rd term
Excellent report.
Thank you for truth and honesty.
Thank you
Excellent closing argument Brian. The Judge would be proud.
Great and necessary aclaration dear Brian!! 👏👏👍👍
The attack on Crimea, may actually have been an accident. The bomblets were not supposed to land on the beach. The problem is, the USA gave the loaded gun to Ukraine. Ukraine used the loaded gun.
Yes. Loaded gun was presented to a fascist psychopaths. Both mad ukraine and US guilty of this war crime
Mein Kampf 2.0!!!!!!!! Where îs The ICC?????
Another deep dive from Brian!
Historically, before Ukraine was part of Russia, has Ukraine ever been in control of Crimea? Before 1782 that is.
nope
Crimea was granted to Russia by Turkey after Crimean War under 1 condition: that it will never go to another country.
There was no Ukraine yet.Ukraine was pieced together by Lenin in 1922 out of parts of Russia, Poland,Romania and Hungary.
Hrushchev gave Crimea to Ukraine in 1954.
Still Crimea had their autonomous parliament and government.
Понятие - украинец, впервые официально появилось в 1916 году. Вы може самостоятельно посмотреть переписи населения Польши, России, Венгрии, Румынии, Австрии до 1916 года и убедиться, что такого этноса не существует.
Telegraph....😂😂😂😂😂😂 Rudyard kipling wrote a line in the verse 'IF' about the Telegraph,
If you can bear to hear the truth you have spoken, twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools.....