@@rogerdavies2796 it does. I'm assuming it's (at least partly) because Americans are less passionate about football generally and so have less inclination and interest into the tactical, analytical and cultural side of football, so their job is to provide a little bit of analysis, but mostly focus on entertainment and using entertainment to try and gather a larger viewership in the US. Just assumptions though ofc
@@Just2GdTobiTrue you ovs didnt watch the video lol.The reason you play him at lb is so that when trent goes into midfield, levi goes into centerback as a back 3
I think Reece James should be ahead of TAA, if he's fit. TAA is very overrated, weaker defensively than James or Walker. And every game for Liverpool and England he makes 2 or 3 awful attempted passes. It's just that every now and then one comes off and people are amazed. Reminds me of Ibrahimovic, who just used to shoot from anywhere. And occasionally he'd score a banger. And people would be amazed. The thing is if you keep shooting from anywhere or playing crazy passes, eventually one will come off. But it doesn't mean you haven't wasted a huge amount of chances. People forget the misses because they don't make the tiktok edits.
@@Flecky LOL great point. A transitional type of formation. But I promise you, when defending LEVI will be at LB and… Just watch LEVI COLWILL’s interviews on SKY SPORTS with NONI MADUEKE about playing in the left.
@@Alx-h9gsuch a dumb thing to mention Ibra taking shots which strikers are supposed to be doing to have a chance of scoring goals. You're definitely a Southgate fan who prefers to safe and boring sideways football with NO risks 🤢
And as was said, he is WELSH lol, why would he be excited or even bloody care about a German manager of England who doesn't even start until the new year... getting advice from someone who has never managed 😆 🤣
Finally we see Bellingham as the 8 which is what I've always seen him as. He can attack and defend and has energy and determination. In every game I always (used to, costs too much now lol) buy him and stick him at CDM or CM, then put one of the million other CAM's ahead of him. I think it was Camavinga, Tchouameni or Gravenberch with Soboszlai (now both at liverpool lol) and Bellingham, this was maybe fifa 21. Bellingham can attack but it feels like a waste not to have him box to box.
Except he doesn’t play there irl for a reason. Also it puts up the same issue we have had Rice is not a DM. Arteta removed him from that position because he can’t play there.
@@JM-1Le-d9pThat's what team sheet says but when you actually watch a game you can clearly see the work rate of Bellingham both offensively and defensively
People will go at Jamie for not starting Foden in this team, fun little fact, Foden has the same amount of international goals as Trent even tho Trent has barely played for England over the years under southgate and Foden has been a starter for atleast a couple years now
@@Matthew-bu7fg it is a crazy stat when u think about it tho, foden probably got more minutes for england over the years than trent and trent’s out scored him😭
Foden's only good in a Man City team littered with players worth hundreds of millions, the 2nd best coach in the world telling him exactly what to do and protected by everyone around him. Put him in a different team (i.e. England 50+ times) and his true ability shows. The guy should be no-where near the starting XI.
Precisely because he has pace running beyond him. He did the same for Spurs. In the Euros, nobody did that, so the game became compressed. Which is precisely why we need a formation and players that allow it.
4:32 How was the summer Harry Kane's team? If you wanted a team with Kane as the focal point you would of played Gordon or took grealish for the pace and width which works perfect for Kane, the team southgate had was trying to be a bit of everyones team and had no focus on a style for 1 player
That is the probleme they were not making use of their players but instead just playing star players and hope that it works without any balanace in the lineup
That's not what he means. Saying it's his team means Kane could do whatever role he wanted and players would have to play around him. Nothing about a focal point
Both are great options. It's guehi's shirt for now, but branthwaite can win it from him. As long as liability maguire never plays for england again, it's all good.
I honestly thought Sky had tele-transported peak Jose back from 2006 with all his charisma, charm and tactical insight. Turns out it's Aaron "erm" Ramsey!
I think we might have to see regularly switched out with faster more direct players more often. Watkins with this set up would thrive far greater than Kane would slow the attacks down
@@scottfletcherr1457 agreed but he is better player a breaking lines and splitting the back line. when kane is in the team the back four dont have a to move much and can sit and be compact . Feel like this is much more difficult to break down and why england struggle at times
Id say nail 2-3 formations so they are very very familiar anymore and it may cause confusion and there won't be enough time to work on them in great detail
The problem with previous England managers has been their insistence on playing certain players in a position that isn’t where they play at their club and expect them to deliver on the same level. This often leads to an imbalanced side, which is counterproductive. Palmer, Bellingham, and Foden are the perfect example of this. They are all great players, but it’s the player that is going to be left out, who is quite possibly not as talented in the overall sense, but gives the team a more solid and balanced look. The fact of having a player like that on the bench has got to be seen as a positive. Nobody can deny the quality of Ronaldo and his contribution to the national side, but I think Portugal had a problem with their manager feeling pressured to play him in a system that shields his decline in terms of lacking impact in pace and a lack of tracking back to defend, which was a big factor in his performances.
Rice offers alot more when hes supported by a ball playing cm like gomes or mainoo. you cant get balance without a midfielder that is willing to just play the 5 yard passes. it was night and day the difference between the greece game & the finland game. Think gomes is a great option but any player like that is key in this system
I think Jude can definitely be that ball playing cm, he has the ability. If not I would go for Wharton, I think he's miles better than Gomes and mainoo. Especially for build up play on the ball, no-one does it better than he does. He excels in transition!
I think Jude offers way more than just being a ball carrying cm. He’s a super talent that I would rather be allowed freedom to impact the game wherever he wants on the pitch. Gomez is great to carry the ball along side a Declan rice that can play a number 6 but is more extraordinary as a central number 8.
@@Elixity69wharton is awful, biggest flavour of the week in years. “80m” dropped from the palace team btw with the worst defensive stats in the league.
@@whn2058the thing is with Kobbie is he loves driving the ball forward himself and playing that short pass to wingers and strikers. He's confident but yeah definitely needs working on his long passes. As a UTD fan I hope he does because that kid has unreal potential. We'll see what happens this season
Great formation by carragher. Exactly how I think England should set up. Only thing I would change is I would play Stones and Colwill at cb and a natural left back who can overlap effectively. Either Chillwell or Shaw.
@josh-sina you don't see flying left backs anymore when the right back goes in to midfield. Chilwell and Shaw can't keep fit and have had their chance. Rico Henry is one to watch when back fit. I'd be happy with Colwill playing in that position personally and coming in to make it a back 3. I really rate Branthwaite as well.
It’s actually a more balance line up with Reece James or Kyle Walker RB, Stones & Colwill CB & Rico Lewis LB, because James/Walker, Stones & Colwill will become the 3 CBs with Lewis stepping into Midfield like he does for City.
Overall win ratio % is not what is important for England....Capello had the highest win % as England manager but was an abject failure when it came to when it mattered - within tournament football. What I want to see is the win ratio of the top managers in CL overall and then the win ratio in the knockout phase of CL. That is the closest comparison to international tournament football.
Tuchel is a cup manager, in knockout tournaments he's amazing. With International management and international tournaments being mainly knockout tournaments I think we have a real chance. Granted he's been out of a job since Julian Nagelsman took over Bayern but I have a good feeling. Main problem is will he keep every players ego under check because that's what Capello failed to do not to mention half the team cared about club football more than international
Angel Gomez was exactly what we needed when he played - Bellingham and Rice don't offer enough in build-out or cover - they both want to bomb forward. If no Angel Gomez then someone similar like Wharton. Need to focus less on player reputation and more on roles they perform.
I dont mind Carragher's selection....but I think the best things about Carsley's temporary management has been to see the obvious value of Grealish on the left and the success of Trent as an inverted LB - which made the most of his ability to switch into the middle when required while not overly exposing him further up the park. I would therefore have Walker or Reece (if he gets back to what he was) as RB.....or alternatively if you wanted to switch it, have Chilwell as LB with Rico Lewis as the RB option to tuck into midfield. If Trent plays RB he will tuck inside at times and he will push on at times....which means we would need a LB who can also do those jobs to mirror him - and we don't have that option.
Why are those 2 mutually exclusive? You can want an English manager out of principle because that is how you view international football whilst conceding that Tuchel was the best manager available.
I agree with Carragher about people saying Kane should stay up high, utterly clueless! Kane and England are at their most dangerous when our best playmaker is playmaking.
@@juz882010then jude can jog on. Palmer's a much better 10 and if bellingham doesn't want to put the team ahead of his overinflated ego, england will be better off without him.
Saka in both Carragher and Ramsey's side selections, hopefully Gordon or Rashford offer something different as I can't see Rice playing well enough in the same side as Palmer. Although it'll be interesting to see what the likes of Walker and Palmer can do with Bellingham under Tuchel.
You can also play him on Right wing or as number 10 instead of palmer. Foden also has a lot more experience in big games and plays for the best team in Europe as well.
Only guy here in the comment section that actually spotted that. It´s clear as days, if RJ is fit, Trent isn´t playing... Not even getting a sniff at that starting XI
I don't know about his XI out of possession but it could work as a 3-3-2-2 in possession. We've seen Rice's inability to play line-breaking passes, especially over the top, but I think Trent will be able to cover for that when he drifts in alongside Rice. Someone on Twitter said you should only start with one of Foden, Bellingham and Palmer, and I agree with that against top opposition. Hell, even against anyone but the minnows.
I don't agree. This is more of the same if you ask me. I think Tuchel will go for a 3-4-2-1. This will get the best out of Foden Parmer and Bellingham as England's best players. Further, maintaining a deep midfield partnership of Rice and Man Utd starlet Mainoo will help England control the game with potential replacements of Wharton playing right into the scheme of things. A new back three built around John stones works well if quick players are brought in as support wide backs. That's my take on things.
Has anyone noticed how 6 of the top 10 managers with the best win ratios since 2015-16 are italian? if our player academies were as a good as coverciano, we would win every major tournament until the end of time!
Everyone doubts Foden but now we have a manager that can get the best out of him, he’s technical ability is unrivalled when he’s on top form. The disrespect😢
Problem is, he's not very reliable. He's nowhere near the level of De Bruyne for example who produces every time he's on the pitch. Occasionally Foden is excellent for a few games but then he does nothing again for a while.
He’s never been in top form for England only when he plays in a Pep system. No disrespect everyone else is their on Merit or deserve a chance, he shouldn’t start unless he has another season like last year imo.
@@samholt9177 He's never turned up for England. Played every game in the Euros and has absolutely nothing to show for it. Palmer did so much more with much less.
I really don't agree that you have to get into the team based on club form. You have to think of the player profile. Just picking the "best" 11 gives us no balance.
Telling you right now, marcus rashford will play on the left when it comes to it. Tuchel loves him, He's far far better than gordon and his record for england proves it. remember this comment and the praise better be as loud as the criticism.
I’d agree his absolute best is better than Gordon, but Gordon offers you a min 6/10 performance and great work rate every game. When Rashford isn’t scoring goals he offers absolutely nothing to a team. He’s been dreadful for 18 months too.
Good to read a comment from someone who isn't entirely influenced by media narratives. Most people commenting on here are thick as two short planks and just repeat what they've heard on the telly...
Carra is pretty much right apart from Walker in for Alexander-Arnold and Guehi for Braithwate. Unfortunately Foden is benched but what a great option to bring on. It needs to be the best TEAM which is not necessarily the best individual players.
Finally a pundit who realises that darling saint Foden can’t be a starter for England. Take him out of that drugged up Lance Armstrong FC side he’s a mid table player at best. Jamie has picked the best 11 here. 👏🏻
I hope Thomas is tactically clever enough to recognize that this Real Madrid Bellingham is a virus that will destroy the chemistry of the team on the pitch. He can‘t dribble properly but he loves himself dribbling way too much, you will see it yourself.
I agree. Bags of talent but he always looks lazy. People hype him up for moments of magic but don't remember the countless cutbacks into exactly where he should be, that he wasn't there for because he was jogging up the pitch.
he cant dribble properly? a virus? looks lazy?😂 Again, these are more examples of the dearth of footballing knowledge in England. It's right through every level.
Normally I really like Jude but the team is more important. The BVB Bellingham is the player we need, the Real Madrid Bellingham is a hero ball, passion merchant. They say his parents keep him grounded, I don‘t see that. Jude is literally becoming a villain. He loves to see himself on the big screen. Nowadays he disappears for 90 minutes and scores a last minute winner just to then say rubbish like „who else?“. There‘s also a reason why in the England camp Trent is his only proper mate, there‘s a reason the players at Dortmund didn‘t like him that much and now he is squaring up to Vinicius. The media wants to portray him as the messiah. Just look at this embarassing Adidas ad for the euros. If you make a 21 year old believe that this world is his, you can‘t expect him to be a humble team player. If Tuchel is a proper manager, he either drops Jude or he gets him to become a team player again who tracks back, doesn‘t cry on the ground all the time, doesn‘t keep the ball for 5 hours before passing it and doesn’t think he‘s a 9 when really he should be an 8. It‘s so frustrating, I genuinely believe that Jude is the biggest problem in this team and because of his massive PR no one questions him, the FA certainly don‘t. Gotta hope for Super Tommy Tuchel.
Kane is the biggest problem in this team now IMO, his legs have gone completely and it's not even a case of dropping deep anymore, he literally plays in midfield virtually all the time. He's never in his actual position, he always stood on the toes of the midfield players which means we have no focal point and virtually 0 threat inside the box. Kane either needs to change up his game or be dropped. Watkins has more than proven his worth.
@@LA-ue2ph Him dropping as deep as he now is, is still as massive problem whether he has pace around him or not. At times he plays in front of the back 4.
If Harry Kane drops deep, shouldn't Saka or Gordon look for that, stay forward or switch in the moment and look for a through ball to utilise their pace. Adaption on the fly.
Carragher genuinely has everything as a pundit, clear opinions that he can back up with extensive knowledge, an incredible football memory and tries to get others involved to open up debate. Ramsey however, clearly doesn’t have a future in punditry
If Bellingham trent rice and saka wasn't so allergic to passing to foden he would start making things happen, plus tuchel needs to start watkins regularly
@@paulosullivan6694 The World Cup is about 18 months away. They mentioned building for the future, why would you pick an aging Kane to lead the line when he has flopped so bad. Time to hand the striker reign over to Ollie Walkins at least.
Carra: "So, what do you think?" :D
Ramsey: "Yeah, man, whatever you just said is cool with me."
😂😂
Be nice if he stopped interrupting him though, wouldn't it?
He's so nervous. Hopefully he'll grow more confident.
Ramsey: I don't give a damn Carra I'm Welsh
Is it his first gig?
Ramsey is amazingly inspiring to listen to, makes me want to jump out of bed and seize the day.
😂
That is his first tv appearance
@@VARMOT123 probably his last.
@@VARMOT123 Following a hamstring injury, means missing 7 games with Cardiff City.
😂😂😂
Wow. Ramsey could bore a glass eye to tears.
Bravo
@@alabastercodefy5636 Thanks. We know Aaron got an hamstring injury, meaning missed out 7 games with Cardiff City.
This is antisemitic
To sleep
😂
Absolute edge of your seat stuff from Ramsey
Aaron Ramsey offers something but I can’t quite put my finger on it. Hang on I’ve found the word, NOTHING.
What ?
A terrible jacket?
@@KevinPoulter-k8mare you simple? If you can't understand that comment you must have double digit IQ 🤡
AIaron Ramsey 🥲
@@KevinPoulter-k8m You know that Aaron was a vice-captain of the Cardiff City.
I've spent 10 years of my life developing a cure for insomnia, then Aaron Ramsey became a pundit.
Aaron Ramsey is painfully flat
What do you expect when English people are asking a Welshman about the English team obviously they aren’t gonna raving and excited
Yes, he's now a vice-captain of Cardiff City.
@@dangerousmouse20 id probably rather watch paint dry than listen to him speak about football.
Leave him alone. Give him a few appearances
@@lsr3794flat as a pancake 😂 Just like in this video..then again he is Welsh. He wishes he’s had our national team
Carra's tactical knowledge and articulation of it is very compelling.
Can't think of anyone better to be honest.
He’s had 10 years honing his skills. Ramsey has had 10 minutes 😂😂😂
Yeah I agree, but ironically he becomes a little kid like Micah Richards when he's next to Henry and Kate😂
@@sfb4144 So true. The whole show seems forced
@@rogerdavies2796 it does. I'm assuming it's (at least partly) because Americans are less passionate about football generally and so have less inclination and interest into the tactical, analytical and cultural side of football, so their job is to provide a little bit of analysis, but mostly focus on entertainment and using entertainment to try and gather a larger viewership in the US. Just assumptions though ofc
omg did bara bet predict ramsey delivering another round of absolutely nothing again? they must have a crystal ball or something!
Bara bet ?
It's a scam
Jamie has cooked with this lineup 🔥
Cooked with a CB at LB 😅
Levi COLWILL IS A CENTRE BACK
@@Just2GdTobiTrue you ovs didnt watch the video lol.The reason you play him at lb is so that when trent goes into midfield, levi goes into centerback as a back 3
I think Reece James should be ahead of TAA, if he's fit. TAA is very overrated, weaker defensively than James or Walker. And every game for Liverpool and England he makes 2 or 3 awful attempted passes. It's just that every now and then one comes off and people are amazed. Reminds me of Ibrahimovic, who just used to shoot from anywhere. And occasionally he'd score a banger. And people would be amazed. The thing is if you keep shooting from anywhere or playing crazy passes, eventually one will come off. But it doesn't mean you haven't wasted a huge amount of chances. People forget the misses because they don't make the tiktok edits.
@@Flecky LOL great point.
A transitional type of formation.
But I promise you, when defending LEVI will be at LB and…
Just watch LEVI COLWILL’s interviews on SKY SPORTS with NONI MADUEKE about playing in the left.
@@Alx-h9gsuch a dumb thing to mention Ibra taking shots which strikers are supposed to be doing to have a chance of scoring goals. You're definitely a Southgate fan who prefers to safe and boring sideways football with NO risks 🤢
Cara has it spot on tactically and right players as an initial starting line up. Finally a world class coach who understands tactics.
That Welsh fella is really enthusiastic
Says Rodriguez . It is his first appearance
And as was said, he is WELSH lol, why would he be excited or even bloody care about a German manager of England who doesn't even start until the new year... getting advice from someone who has never managed 😆 🤣
Why invite a Welshman on and talk about England? 🙄😂
No one in the comments been in front of cameras on live tv lol
Finally we see Bellingham as the 8 which is what I've always seen him as. He can attack and defend and has energy and determination. In every game I always (used to, costs too much now lol) buy him and stick him at CDM or CM, then put one of the million other CAM's ahead of him. I think it was Camavinga, Tchouameni or Gravenberch with Soboszlai (now both at liverpool lol) and Bellingham, this was maybe fifa 21. Bellingham can attack but it feels like a waste not to have him box to box.
Except he doesn’t play there irl for a reason. Also it puts up the same issue we have had Rice is not a DM. Arteta removed him from that position because he can’t play there.
Have you ever seen a Real Madrid game?
Real Madrid normally plays 3 in midfield and then Bellingham Mbappe & VJ as forwards.
@@JM-1Le-d9pThat's what team sheet says but when you actually watch a game you can clearly see the work rate of Bellingham both offensively and defensively
@SIN-tb2zg if Kane is the 9 BLHM is most useful as the 10.
Jamie’s team is absolutely spot on attacking wise
People will go at Jamie for not starting Foden in this team, fun little fact, Foden has the same amount of international goals as Trent even tho Trent has barely played for England over the years under southgate and Foden has been a starter for atleast a couple years now
Foden should not be playing it's no shock. No automatic right to start for England he is terrible.
fun little fact: beans go well on toast
@@Matthew-bu7fg it is a crazy stat when u think about it tho, foden probably got more minutes for england over the years than trent and trent’s out scored him😭
Massively overrated.
Foden's only good in a Man City team littered with players worth hundreds of millions, the 2nd best coach in the world telling him exactly what to do and protected by everyone around him.
Put him in a different team (i.e. England 50+ times) and his true ability shows. The guy should be no-where near the starting XI.
Kane drops deep in every game at Bayern and plays brillant passes and volleys to his teammates.. and still shoots a crazy amount of goals up front.
@@JohnDoe-sr3qz yeah this aint bayern pal
Precisely because he has pace running beyond him. He did the same for Spurs. In the Euros, nobody did that, so the game became compressed. Which is precisely why we need a formation and players that allow it.
Not really. Most games he goes missing for us.
@@alexsagert7609 "Us" being who exactly?
@@scottwallbank4794 Bayern Munich.
4:32 How was the summer Harry Kane's team? If you wanted a team with Kane as the focal point you would of played Gordon or took grealish for the pace and width which works perfect for Kane, the team southgate had was trying to be a bit of everyones team and had no focus on a style for 1 player
Indeed
That is the probleme they were not making use of their players but instead just playing star players and hope that it works without any balanace in the lineup
would HAVE not would of
That's not what he means. Saying it's his team means Kane could do whatever role he wanted and players would have to play around him. Nothing about a focal point
@@Pricelessmile the thing is a lot of players did that under southgate not just Kane, Bellingham had a free role too imo
Who gave Aaron Ramsey a job on the telly 😂? Good players don't always make good pundits, guys got the personality of a rock!
Guehi was fantastic for us in the summer, no need to drop him
I agree he was perhaps our best player, but I think Branthwaite is absolute class, maybe Im a little bias as an Everton fan, but he is solid.
Both are great options. It's guehi's shirt for now, but branthwaite can win it from him.
As long as liability maguire never plays for england again, it's all good.
Stones is miles past it
@@vibepenguin4459 I'd run Guehi and Branthwaite as our CBs tbh (with colwill on the left coming inside when we have possession as cara mentioned)
@@jeannotschumacher1024 good enough for Pep and Man City mate
Bloody hell. Jamie Carragher just giving a decent bit of analysis and tactical breakdown...
If Kane is to play, there needs to be players next to him who can run in behind and compensate for his lack of pace like Rashford or Gordon
Rashford 🤣
@@max_thorneyou clearly don’t know tuchel 😂 he loves Rashford
gordan fs
@@alexking805 he wont use wingers... will be wing backs chilwell/james
@@max_thorne He's been Uniteds best player this season lol
Starting 11 talk is redundant due to the amount of subs now. It shouldn't be a problem that Palmer and Foden rotate that 10 position.
Or just start Palmer every game and only sub him if the game is over in either direction. If Palmer keeps performing like he has for the last year.
I honestly thought Sky had tele-transported peak Jose back from 2006 with all his charisma, charm and tactical insight. Turns out it's Aaron "erm" Ramsey!
I think we might have to see regularly switched out with faster more direct players more often. Watkins with this set up would thrive far greater than Kane would slow the attacks down
Watkins isn't in the same class as Kane.
@@scottfletcherr1457we saw at the Euros mate, Kane can't stay forward half the time and slowed us down going forwards, Watkins always showed up
@@scottfletcherr1457 agreed but he is better player a breaking lines and splitting the back line. when kane is in the team the back four dont have a to move much and can sit and be compact . Feel like this is much more difficult to break down and why england struggle at times
Another clown who thinks Kane slows England 😐😐its getting boring now with these rags baits
Drop Kane
An absolutely brilliant lineup. Lot of people might not rate cara but his ball knowledge and intelligence is elite
He should stop criticism and become a coach then.
@@richarda3514irony. Are you going to become a presenter?
Give over mate, the state of that team 😂
Where’s guehi ?
Id say nail 2-3 formations so they are very very familiar anymore and it may cause confusion and there won't be enough time to work on them in great detail
Thank God Tuchel has Carragher here to pick his team for him.
Bang on from Jamie. Always thought the lack of pace on both wings was our failing at the euros
crazy how no one's talking about the bara bet free picks
What’s this Bara Bet thing?
@@JB17658I'm pretty sure these are bot comments to promote it. They have so many likes for nothing too
@@JB17658 scam promoted by bots
@@JB17658 i think these bara bet comments are all bots
@@JB17658 These are just bots setup by the betting websites to draw people to their sites.
The problem with previous England managers has been their insistence on playing certain players in a position that isn’t where they play at their club and expect them to deliver on the same level. This often leads to an imbalanced side, which is counterproductive. Palmer, Bellingham, and Foden are the perfect example of this. They are all great players, but it’s the player that is going to be left out, who is quite possibly not as talented in the overall sense, but gives the team a more solid and balanced look. The fact of having a player like that on the bench has got to be seen as a positive.
Nobody can deny the quality of Ronaldo and his contribution to the national side, but I think Portugal had a problem with their manager feeling pressured to play him in a system that shields his decline in terms of lacking impact in pace and a lack of tracking back to defend, which was a big factor in his performances.
Carragher is really good at what he does
The glazing is crazy
@@jaketeall9665 Shut up mate. Carra is good, especially compared to Gary Neville.
@@Ofp238 biased scouser
If he is that good, he should coach. He is a studio manager, at best.
he picked gordon? spitty carra is clueless.
FYI.
If Reece stays fit Tuchel is picking him all day, he was his favourite player, and Reece played unbelievable under him
Rice offers alot more when hes supported by a ball playing cm like gomes or mainoo. you cant get balance without a midfielder that is willing to just play the 5 yard passes. it was night and day the difference between the greece game & the finland game. Think gomes is a great option but any player like that is key in this system
I think Jude can definitely be that ball playing cm, he has the ability. If not I would go for Wharton, I think he's miles better than Gomes and mainoo. Especially for build up play on the ball, no-one does it better than he does. He excels in transition!
I think Jude offers way more than just being a ball carrying cm. He’s a super talent that I would rather be allowed freedom to impact the game wherever he wants on the pitch. Gomez is great to carry the ball along side a Declan rice that can play a number 6 but is more extraordinary as a central number 8.
Mainoo is decent under pressure but he's not ready for the level. His long passing and power isn't there. Gomes should play alongside Rice.
@@Elixity69wharton is awful, biggest flavour of the week in years. “80m” dropped from the palace team btw with the worst defensive stats in the league.
@@whn2058the thing is with Kobbie is he loves driving the ball forward himself and playing that short pass to wingers and strikers. He's confident but yeah definitely needs working on his long passes. As a UTD fan I hope he does because that kid has unreal potential. We'll see what happens this season
Great formation by carragher. Exactly how I think England should set up. Only thing I would change is I would play Stones and Colwill at cb and a natural left back who can overlap effectively. Either Chillwell or Shaw.
@josh-sina you don't see flying left backs anymore when the right back goes in to midfield. Chilwell and Shaw can't keep fit and have had their chance. Rico Henry is one to watch when back fit. I'd be happy with Colwill playing in that position personally and coming in to make it a back 3.
I really rate Branthwaite as well.
Why does Ramsey sound Italian
Yup, bit of the Schteve McClarens
Calzaghe family? Italian community in the valleys 👀🤣
He did play at Juventus for a few years may be partly the reason
Because he’s speaking nonsense
@@noelmcgovern8995 "Play" is too strong a word.
It’s actually a more balance line up with Reece James or Kyle Walker RB, Stones & Colwill CB & Rico Lewis LB, because James/Walker, Stones & Colwill will become the 3 CBs with Lewis stepping into Midfield like he does for City.
Overall win ratio % is not what is important for England....Capello had the highest win % as England manager but was an abject failure when it came to when it mattered - within tournament football.
What I want to see is the win ratio of the top managers in CL overall and then the win ratio in the knockout phase of CL.
That is the closest comparison to international tournament football.
Tuchel is a cup manager, in knockout tournaments he's amazing. With International management and international tournaments being mainly knockout tournaments I think we have a real chance. Granted he's been out of a job since Julian Nagelsman took over Bayern but I have a good feeling. Main problem is will he keep every players ego under check because that's what Capello failed to do not to mention half the team cared about club football more than international
Angel Gomez was exactly what we needed when he played - Bellingham and Rice don't offer enough in build-out or cover - they both want to bomb forward. If no Angel Gomez then someone similar like Wharton. Need to focus less on player reputation and more on roles they perform.
Finally someone with a brain
Every international team plays with pure DM
Sad not seeing Mourinho in that list at 0:13. Expected given he's taken on more challenging roles but still
Hes useless that's why he's not on the list. Have you watched his football 😮
@@timhorrocks3515 Useless is a bit harsh. He's not as good as he used to be. But for a long period he was the best in the world.
jose hasnt had a succesfull league campaign in 9 years.
He's never been the same since the run in with the physio. If he had treated her with respect he'd still be the elite coach he used to be.
@@timhorrocks3515🤦♂️
Looking at the win ratio or win percentage here is crazy, he managed PSG and Bayern for almost 2/3 of those games...
I dont mind Carragher's selection....but I think the best things about Carsley's temporary management has been to see the obvious value of Grealish on the left and the success of Trent as an inverted LB - which made the most of his ability to switch into the middle when required while not overly exposing him further up the park.
I would therefore have Walker or Reece (if he gets back to what he was) as RB.....or alternatively if you wanted to switch it, have Chilwell as LB with Rico Lewis as the RB option to tuck into midfield.
If Trent plays RB he will tuck inside at times and he will push on at times....which means we would need a LB who can also do those jobs to mirror him - and we don't have that option.
You don't have to mirror it on the other side. Not everyone does that. Wouldn't mind trying trent at LB though since we have so many good right backs.
Sancho is way better than your boxer. Tell him to join wwe
Idc what ppl say about kane when we put Watkins on in euros we looked a LOT better
Carra: that shows England have got the best manager
Jamie, you were slagging it off a week ago saying you wanted an Englishman. Make your mind up
He said he'd prefer an Englishman now he's getting behind the new manager. Supporting his team. A novel idea for English fans
Why are those 2 mutually exclusive? You can want an English manager out of principle because that is how you view international football whilst conceding that Tuchel was the best manager available.
I agree with Carragher about people saying Kane should stay up high, utterly clueless! Kane and England are at their most dangerous when our best playmaker is playmaking.
6:20 does he not realise that Jude played in a double pivot or as a number 8 during his time at dortmund?
he doesnt want to play there anymore
@@juz882010did he tell you that mate
@@juz882010then jude can jog on. Palmer's a much better 10 and if bellingham doesn't want to put the team ahead of his overinflated ego, england will be better off without him.
@@jonathancampbell9133maybe it's about time to drop kane too for a game here and there.
There are other strikers around with different qualities.
@@jonathancampbell9133 England would be better off without their best player? Their future captain? Come on now. What he wants he's gonna get. LOL.
Wow! Revolutionary system. All these new ideas and players will really rock the boat.
Finally someone not trying to squeeze Foden in
Oooh my God! Carra that's unbelievably under the belt, that line up would be beaten
Who's here from bara bet??
Your father
@@pc-gu4nv his father left years ago and isn't coming back
Saka in both Carragher and Ramsey's side selections, hopefully Gordon or Rashford offer something different as I can't see Rice playing well enough in the same side as Palmer. Although it'll be interesting to see what the likes of Walker and Palmer can do with Bellingham under Tuchel.
Can’t believe Foden is still being considered to start…Foden is bench quality at best in an England shirt 🤦♂️
You can also play him on Right wing or as number 10 instead of palmer. Foden also has a lot more experience in big games and plays for the best team in Europe as well.
Foden would be a great option from the bench and make teams fear England's bench even more as clearly he shouldn't be starting games atm
@@Ibrahim-nf6yh He's great in Pep's system but hasn't done if for England
You can't believe it because you're an idiot...
T@@aidygoonerthat how pep used him right now comes off the bench that is he best
If Reece is in form he is a lock for RB with Tuchel.
Trent wont start for Tuchel, its either Reece or Walker, he likes his fullbacks to defend
Only guy here in the comment section that actually spotted that. It´s clear as days, if RJ is fit, Trent isn´t playing... Not even getting a sniff at that starting XI
@@MrDddrrrggg treht is starting have u seen the season he is having that fact u saying defending and walker.
@@therealhb1763 No he’s not. If Reece is fit, forget about Trent
0:13 Maybe they should have looked at the managers who had the most trophies in knock out competitions.
I think Palmer has to start personally .Also Bruno Fernandes could be a good bet in Fantasy Football next week
I don't know about his XI out of possession but it could work as a 3-3-2-2 in possession. We've seen Rice's inability to play line-breaking passes, especially over the top, but I think Trent will be able to cover for that when he drifts in alongside Rice. Someone on Twitter said you should only start with one of Foden, Bellingham and Palmer, and I agree with that against top opposition. Hell, even against anyone but the minnows.
jamie spot on with line up
Agree with Jamie’s lineup tbf but if Maguire is fit he starts over Branthwaite
😂😂😂😂😂
Something tells me Carra would have made a better manager than Stevie lol
Carragher is spot on with this lineup in and out of possession
Imagine being a 30 something, millionaire, ex footballer and giving a secondary school level presentation on sky sports
Imagine being a bitter nobody in the comments 🤡
Wish cara had become a manager guys spot on
Carragher sporting 7 different pantone shades of grey
I don't agree. This is more of the same if you ask me. I think Tuchel will go for a 3-4-2-1. This will get the best out of Foden Parmer and Bellingham as England's best players. Further, maintaining a deep midfield partnership of Rice and Man Utd starlet Mainoo will help England control the game with potential replacements of Wharton playing right into the scheme of things.
A new back three built around John stones works well if quick players are brought in as support wide backs. That's my take on things.
Stones is miles over the top
good video ❤
Of course, Monday Night Football welcomes Aaron Ramsey from Cardiff City.
Has anyone noticed how 6 of the top 10 managers with the best win ratios since 2015-16 are italian? if our player academies were as a good as coverciano, we would win every major tournament until the end of time!
Everyone doubts Foden but now we have a manager that can get the best out of him, he’s technical ability is unrivalled when he’s on top form. The disrespect😢
Problem is, he's not very reliable. He's nowhere near the level of De Bruyne for example who produces every time he's on the pitch. Occasionally Foden is excellent for a few games but then he does nothing again for a while.
it is rivalled. by palmer
He’s never been in top form for England only when he plays in a Pep system. No disrespect everyone else is their on Merit or deserve a chance, he shouldn’t start unless he has another season like last year imo.
@@samholt9177 He's never turned up for England. Played every game in the Euros and has absolutely nothing to show for it. Palmer did so much more with much less.
@@Alx-h9gde Bruyne overrated too. Never delivers for Belgium.
Just build the team around Palmer. He hasn't hit his stride for England yet but he has the highest ceiling alongside Bellingham out of everyone.
Pep is in a league of his own
Great manager but we have to always remember the context.
@@gustavbrinkel5489Yeah, like others that managed Real, Bayern, PSG and Chelsea are managing broke clubs
Not psg is owned by a country in that list.
Tuchel didn't manage a strong Chelsea
@@buzzztang they were the best in Europe. Swatted away any team including Real Madrid. Let in one goal in the knock out stage I believe.
I really don't agree that you have to get into the team based on club form.
You have to think of the player profile. Just picking the "best" 11 gives us no balance.
Love that team!! Maybe Shaw in for Colwill
🤣
fitness
Carra literally just forgot that Kane did plenty of dropping deep while he played for him a Bayern.
Grealish massively underrated
As always. England’s best player 90% of the time he’s on.
Fr💯🤦🏽♂️
😂😂😂
Grealish is a great alternative to Gordon depending on the opposition
@@wurkin89 grealish everso dull...no wonder why Doku always sits him in the far terraces. Maybe should try boxing.
Phil goes more central whereas Anthony brings more pace and goes deep down the wing
Telling you right now, marcus rashford will play on the left when it comes to it. Tuchel loves him, He's far far better than gordon and his record for england proves it. remember this comment and the praise better be as loud as the criticism.
I’d agree his absolute best is better than Gordon, but Gordon offers you a min 6/10 performance and great work rate every game. When Rashford isn’t scoring goals he offers absolutely nothing to a team. He’s been dreadful for 18 months too.
Good to read a comment from someone who isn't entirely influenced by media narratives. Most people commenting on here are thick as two short planks and just repeat what they've heard on the telly...
Carra speaking facts tbf, not many arguments can be made with that
Branthwaite 😂
Guehi is the best CB England have. And if James stays fit, he will 100% be ahead of TAA.
He was shite against Liverpool yesterday
James is done. Legs are gone too heavy too much scar tissue damage. Will never be fully fit. Never seen the hype
he is nowhere near the best CB england have what are you smoking
@@MCJC96 If he gets fit, he´s starting over Trent and it´s not even close. Actually Trent might even get left at home with Walker and Reece.
James is a sneeze away from a meniscus tear
Carra is pretty much right apart from Walker in for Alexander-Arnold and Guehi for Braithwate. Unfortunately Foden is benched but what a great option to bring on. It needs to be the best TEAM which is not necessarily the best individual players.
Completely agree with Jamie
playing saka with foden on the bench is just crazy.
Finally a pundit who realises that darling saint Foden can’t be a starter for England. Take him out of that drugged up Lance Armstrong FC side he’s a mid table player at best. Jamie has picked the best 11 here. 👏🏻
Perfect line up. Well done Carra 🤟🏻
I hope Thomas is tactically clever enough to recognize that this Real Madrid Bellingham is a virus that will destroy the chemistry of the team on the pitch. He can‘t dribble properly but he loves himself dribbling way too much, you will see it yourself.
I agree. Bags of talent but he always looks lazy. People hype him up for moments of magic but don't remember the countless cutbacks into exactly where he should be, that he wasn't there for because he was jogging up the pitch.
he should play deep like he used to at Dortmund
he cant dribble properly? a virus? looks lazy?😂
Again, these are more examples of the dearth of footballing knowledge in England. It's right through every level.
@@harryclassa well said Harry. Bellingham is a parasite to this team and he should be dropped. He’s not a team player has a huge ego.
Normally I really like Jude but the team is more important. The BVB Bellingham is the player we need, the Real Madrid Bellingham is a hero ball, passion merchant. They say his parents keep him grounded, I don‘t see that. Jude is literally becoming a villain. He loves to see himself on the big screen. Nowadays he disappears for 90 minutes and scores a last minute winner just to then say rubbish like „who else?“. There‘s also a reason why in the England camp Trent is his only proper mate, there‘s a reason the players at Dortmund didn‘t like him that much and now he is squaring up to Vinicius. The media wants to portray him as the messiah. Just look at this embarassing Adidas ad for the euros. If you make a 21 year old believe that this world is his, you can‘t expect him to be a humble team player. If Tuchel is a proper manager, he either drops Jude or he gets him to become a team player again who tracks back, doesn‘t cry on the ground all the time, doesn‘t keep the ball for 5 hours before passing it and doesn’t think he‘s a 9 when really he should be an 8. It‘s so frustrating, I genuinely believe that Jude is the biggest problem in this team and because of his massive PR no one questions him, the FA certainly don‘t. Gotta hope for Super Tommy Tuchel.
Tyrick Mitchell needs to change teams to crack the England squad, that lb position is butters.
Kane is the biggest problem in this team now IMO, his legs have gone completely and it's not even a case of dropping deep anymore, he literally plays in midfield virtually all the time. He's never in his actual position, he always stood on the toes of the midfield players which means we have no focal point and virtually 0 threat inside the box. Kane either needs to change up his game or be dropped. Watkins has more than proven his worth.
Kane being dropped will give him a kick in the backside and he’ll be back to his best
or the most likely scenario would be to build around him to accommodate for his dropping deep, tuchel won't drop kane
@@LA-ue2ph Him dropping as deep as he now is, is still as massive problem whether he has pace around him or not. At times he plays in front of the back 4.
Used as a Super Sub in the last 20-25mins might be the best way to use him.
@@ItsAv3rageGamerit ain’t a problem it’s a advantage to us him dropping deep helps us
If Harry Kane drops deep, shouldn't Saka or Gordon look for that, stay forward or switch in the moment and look for a through ball to utilise their pace. Adaption on the fly.
People who think Kane should be benched dribble down the front of their shirts.
Notice how no one ever questions or discusses saka?
Carragher genuinely has everything as a pundit, clear opinions that he can back up with extensive knowledge, an incredible football memory and tries to get others involved to open up debate. Ramsey however, clearly doesn’t have a future in punditry
Naaah that leaves declan on his own, its also how good they are off the ball. They need another all round cm not just cdm and 3 or cams
Carra talking sense for a change
I love Jamie’s lineup it’s either foden or Gordon
Kane should not be starting for England at the World Cup. He will be a mannequin like he was at the euros
He should be starting looks like you don’t watch football he wasn’t fit at the euros but now he is back fit and is performing again
southgate was playing him in dm for most of the euros.
@@User-22-i6u Do you believe every excuse?
@@Flecky no, he was playing himself there
@@CodPatrol it ain’t an excuse it’s a fact watch football to understand
If Bellingham trent rice and saka wasn't so allergic to passing to foden he would start making things happen, plus tuchel needs to start watkins regularly
Nah Foden is just not him for England
If four great passers of the ball aren't finding you. Is that their fault or yours?
Kane shouldn't be anywhere near the starting XI at this stage. Embarrassing.
Do you think mason greenwood will be in England squad
Absolutely mental take there....... 😂
@@paulosullivan6694 i understand England will never call him but is not mental funny
@@paulosullivan6694 The World Cup is about 18 months away. They mentioned building for the future, why would you pick an aging Kane to lead the line when he has flopped so bad.
Time to hand the striker reign over to Ollie Walkins at least.
PETER, YOU'RE A MENTALIST.
Angel Gomes needs to be in the number 6 position. He controlls the game from deep far better than Rice and Bellingham can.
Ramsey sounds so dull and boring, no energy at all when he's speaking.
Has he been forced to come on sky at gun point or something lol
He’s not arsed about the England manager or squad
@@tonnaboy10 yeah tbh dont know why they had a welsh player doing a video on the england job
@@tonnaboy10 He sounded the same when they talked about his former team arsenal too.
@@casey2230 I think he’s too shy to be a pundit
James would stay fit
Right back for sure.
Tuchel isn’t picking “gordan” ahead of Rashford 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@innerviciouscycle yeah we’ll see about that 🤣
@@innerviciouscycle tuchel is a Rashford stan. Always going on about him in press conferences.
why not? you speak to thomas much?
Pep played close to the most and highest win percentage is crazy