Dave Hodge Tells CBC How It's Done

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 бер 2011
  • If you're going to go, go with a flip!
  • Спорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 265

  • @pauloantunes3519
    @pauloantunes3519 2 роки тому +6

    The pen flip and the dejected look away, were the cherry on top, 😂
    The CBC’s incompetence has only multiplied exponentially since .

  • @dariderfan
    @dariderfan 12 років тому +15

    As Don Cherry said on his interview with Bob McCown on Prime Time Sports "the television personalities outlast the executives." Hodge is still one of the best!

  • @cliveyoung3619
    @cliveyoung3619 10 років тому +42

    " who's responsible for how we do thing around here..... " great line...

  • @Brian-Hayden
    @Brian-Hayden 6 років тому +37

    This incident actually was a catalyst on how live sports broadcasting worked at the CBC. It got the attention of the leagues and probably helped, to an extent, the development of tsn, and other channels to get a chance at broadcasting games.

    • @BBQFanNo1
      @BBQFanNo1 3 роки тому +9

      Dave Hodge always > Ron McLean. I never have warmed up to Ron McLean from Day 1 he worked on CBC. CBC HNIC only survived well years after Dave Hodge's firing because of Don Cherry
      .

    • @ericcollins8794
      @ericcollins8794 Рік тому +3

      @@BBQFanNo1 it would have survived with or without Dave hodge or Don cherry because it's hnic

    • @MisterMister5893
      @MisterMister5893 Рік тому

      @@BBQFanNo1 Since this isn't CBC's own channel and likelihood of being censored is low, I will say I never liked Ron. He looked, acted and spoke like a bitch. I'm sure a lot of viewers were hoping Don would give him a wedgey on air and slap him good when he delivered one of his snarky remarks towards Don.

  • @veg776543
    @veg776543 10 років тому +47

    I saw this live at that time. Missed Dave since then.

  • @davidjorgensen877
    @davidjorgensen877 8 років тому +52

    I remember that broadcast. After he did this bit I just kind of blinked at the screen and thought, "Did he just dis his boss live on the air?" Hodge was always so smooth and professional - never saw any hint of that coming. I was sad to see him leave HNIC as a result.

    • @RavenRuled
      @RavenRuled 8 років тому +7

      +David Jorgensen As a kid I loved watching him and didn't understand him being gone. Maybe it was because we were taught everyone is human and gets angry. Now after years of working in toxic environments I feel there must have been more going on that week or maybe month.

    • @brett7y7
      @brett7y7 8 років тому +9

      He said it's cause earlier in the day CBC cut short the curling he was watching and that pissed him off, so when it happened at work later that night it was still fresh in his mind and he was trying to sympathize with the viewers. There's an interview on youtube where he talks about it.

    • @smellykelley69
      @smellykelley69 7 років тому +10

      i seen it coming, david. as i recall, it started days before when hodge expressed similar concerns about the way the playoff broadcasts were being handled. when i see the `pen flip` i clearly remember thinking `he is finished`. i will say though that his reactions were entirely indicative of the way most of us were feeling that night.

    • @tonyalwayswaiting4285
      @tonyalwayswaiting4285 5 років тому +1

      I too remembered that particular broad cast

    • @smellykelley69
      @smellykelley69 5 років тому +1

      david, if you remember, the night before he made a similar snide remark about the network and its coverage and if i do recall, i remember thinking that after that broadcast and his pen flip, that his time was very likely coming to an end. hodge`s remarks were completely in line with what most viewers were thinking that night and most of us were frustrated to the point of being enraged with what had happened.

  • @elements422
    @elements422 Рік тому +4

    This Canadian Heritage Moment is brought to you by the legend Dave Hodge.

  • @larryconnors9833
    @larryconnors9833 7 років тому +10

    he was frustrated because it was a stupid foolish thing cbc did..

  • @jayp.6166
    @jayp.6166 5 років тому +20

    What a legend. It was phenomenal to see him back on the HNIC set last night for the first time since this

  • @hockeyjaw
    @hockeyjaw 11 років тому +6

    Dave Hodge said it the way it was, and my hat goes off to him

  • @ldhorricks
    @ldhorricks 13 років тому +12

    Beautiful...one of the great moments in sports broadcasting

  • @werqa123
    @werqa123 12 років тому +2

    so sad what Dave Hodge left CBC and open his place for Cherry. Respect to Dave Hodge from old hockey fan from Russia! I have many HNIC and other games in my dvd collection from 50's - 80's and see now games wich never can see in USSR but all time wanted it since 1976. I'm an old habs fan since 31.12.1975

  • @leafyutube
    @leafyutube 9 років тому +63

    Dave Hodge borrowed a page from George Costanza. If you're gonna get canned, go out with a bang.

    • @comic6308
      @comic6308 6 років тому +16

      George borrowed from Dave

    • @chaseman12
      @chaseman12 5 років тому +4

      Other way around

    • @martinodaniells
      @martinodaniells 5 років тому +1

      He never got canned. He quit. Get your facts straight before commenting.

    • @chaseman12
      @chaseman12 5 років тому +6

      @@martinodaniells He got fired. It is well known.
      I believe you should take your own advice.
      Egg on your face.

    • @sjames304
      @sjames304 5 років тому +1

      @@chaseman12 From what I've read, he was not fired. He was told to apologize by CBC. He refused to apologize and took another job in Vcr.

  • @Tubewings
    @Tubewings 13 років тому +2

    He got fired for that?! Seriously?

  • @warrengauthier4699
    @warrengauthier4699 5 років тому +18

    Lmao...I recall the night he did that and then TSN hired him...eff the CBC😛

  • @legrandfromage6450
    @legrandfromage6450 9 років тому +14

    I think that Habs-Flyers game ended in a tie. It's funny to think back to the days before 24 hour sports channels and internet. It took a minor effort to actually find out the score of a game you were interested in, by tuning in to AM radio 11 o clock news or waiting to check the paper the next day.

  • @shirakohamazaki3913
    @shirakohamazaki3913 9 років тому +14

    Dave Hodge > Ron MacLean

  • @robmclean4352
    @robmclean4352 9 днів тому

    I watched this live and thought, "He's in trouble!"

  • @quentin3330
    @quentin3330 6 років тому +6

    I still remember watching this live as a teen.

  • @flyerspa67
    @flyerspa67 9 років тому +29

    Always Enjoyed Dave Hodge....

  • @bluebear1985
    @bluebear1985 12 років тому +8

    @JBatts41 Apparently this was the second time in the same day this happened with CBC regarding sports coverage. Earlier in the day, the network decided to cut away from the final end of a Brier curling match to go to coverage of an NDP convention.

  • @danielgreco3116
    @danielgreco3116 8 років тому +81

    bautistas bat flip or hodges pen flip ?

  • @aai3661
    @aai3661 5 років тому +5

    Still seems like a minor reason to fire someone who was a bit of a Saturday night institution.

    • @oilersridersbluejays
      @oilersridersbluejays 3 роки тому

      That’s the way CBC does things around here. What’s worse? Our tax dollars fund that propaganda machine we call the CBC.

  • @oscarjetson128
    @oscarjetson128 5 років тому +3

    I remember as a young kid watching this live. My folks said to me "Well, that will be the end of him on HNIC." We had a good laugh though. I think Dave Hodge was expressing the same frustrations that the views were as well. Good for him!

    • @rhiannonk9030
      @rhiannonk9030 Рік тому

      Imagine if we had social media back then, fans would have defended him and called for the heads of those who fired him.

  • @ElectoneGuy
    @ElectoneGuy 5 років тому +4

    Dave and Ron McLean both on Hockey Night in Canada on Saturday, November 24th, 2018 - and in the blue jackets!

  • @lococanada8238
    @lococanada8238 5 років тому +3

    We have Dave to thank for that. The policy was changed soon after that, if I remember correctly. I watched this and other games where OT was not shown so the National could be on at 11! Good job Dave, a trailblazer for sure.

  • @linkofiveo5674
    @linkofiveo5674 2 роки тому +1

    😂😂😂😂😂, he’s a legend! Gotta love Dave Hodge!

  • @pinepoint14
    @pinepoint14 8 років тому +17

    I remember this game and was also disappointed like Dave. Dave Hodge was great as was Ron MacLean (as host) but everything has gone downhill since Sportsnet took over. Very sad.

    • @jakealan4552
      @jakealan4552 8 років тому +1

      rons back

    • @rivahkillah
      @rivahkillah 5 років тому +3

      Quite sure this was long before Sportsnet took over. CBC has been going downhill for a long time, which is why they didn't even own the HNIC song. Of course, when you're a government subsidized, that is not a surprise.

  • @angelomisterioso
    @angelomisterioso 4 роки тому +1

    Kudos Mr. Hodge for telling it like it is. CBC didn't deserve you anyways.

  • @Libertyjack1
    @Libertyjack1 12 років тому +1

    So, what does Don Cherry have to do to get fired?

  • @danielhuntington2116
    @danielhuntington2116 2 роки тому

    Dave Hodge scores a hat trick...we are not able to go there😳...that's the way we do things here🙄....we will try to find out more why we do things this way here.😞...you could sense his frustration but good for him...The Truth was told😀💪👷

  • @oldredbarnman
    @oldredbarnman 2 роки тому +1

    March 14, 1987-35 yrs. ago tonight. A little context to the broadcast-HNIC back then began at 8pm. No pregame, no doubleheader (that began when the 94/95 lockout ended). Toronto played Calgary at MLG, while Montreal hosted Philadelphia. I live in Detroit, so we got the Ontario feed (Tor/Cal). The Leafs beat the Flames 6-4, and the game ended early (HNIC had an 8pm-11pm window). The network decided to go to the finish of the Canadiens/Flyers game (which was tied at 3), to finish out their timeslot. When the 3rd period ended (there were only a few minutes left when they switched), they went to commercial. It was just a few minutes to 11pm(CBC News) when they came back to Dave Hodge. I don't know for sure, but I'm guessing the people who saw the entire Habs/Flyers game didn't miss the OT (Quebec/New Foundland/Maritimes). I personally wasn't happy not being able to see the OT, but it really wasn't a "Heidi" moment. The network was just trying to fill some time, and unfortunately for them OT occurred. When Hodge flipped his pen, I laughed to myself. I was bummed when he got fired, and would've liked his perspective when the Habs and Flyers had their pregame "Pier 6" brawl 2 months later at the Forum.

  • @nldxers
    @nldxers 11 років тому

    yes that would be a good question to find out, obviously someone in charge who never worked in the actual related job. Just like so many other departments. Hire somebody from outside to manage. It gets better every day with idiots in management

  • @johnnyballenatl
    @johnnyballenatl 5 років тому +2

    CBC wanted to get to The National (then-anchored by the late Knowlton Nash) as soon as possible, and I bet Hodge let out a torrent of expletives right after they faded to black.

  • @quincee33
    @quincee33 12 років тому +1

    i still remember watching this that night with my Dad...he turned to me as he was laughing and said "Amatuer Night in Canada, Hodge is probably gonna get fired"

  • @dzanier
    @dzanier 12 років тому +1

    Priceless reaction by Dave Hodge.

  • @ElectoneGuy
    @ElectoneGuy 11 років тому +1

    CBC used to pull that crap all the time back then. But, network television was a lot different and they had to go to their local affiliate stations after the game for news and whatever. Nicely done, Dave.

  • @MarkPentler
    @MarkPentler 13 років тому

    I've always wanted to see this, thanks!

  • @goji059
    @goji059 5 років тому +13

    just like today CBC was all about Diversity,..... sorry i meant Conformity

  • @supernav1974
    @supernav1974 11 років тому +1

    Have to respect that. Even if it was foolish. Worked out fine for him though.

  • @landrykkb
    @landrykkb 11 років тому +1

    Amen to that,my friend,& I don't even really hate Ron MacLean;it's just that Dave Hodge would never back down to Grapes.

    • @oilersridersbluejays
      @oilersridersbluejays 3 роки тому

      That’s right, and usually Don Cherry and Dave Hodge got along. When they disagreed, they were civil and smiling but not backing down. Ron McLean is a little bleeding heart wimp compared to Dave Hodge.

  • @Kwolf1
    @Kwolf1 10 років тому +6

    YESS dave hodge not one shit was given i would be so mad too if they just cut off a game like that

  • @davidbroughall3782
    @davidbroughall3782 5 років тому +1

    What I don't understand is why TSN didn't hire him the day after he was fired from the CBC. Why did it take them 5 years?

    • @warrengauthier4699
      @warrengauthier4699 5 років тому

      Because he was a loose cannon or maybe he did not care to find a new employer?

  • @JB-wr2lx
    @JB-wr2lx 5 років тому +6

    David Suzuki was on next telling Adrian Clarkson how to live a more spartan life .

    • @cooterhazzardbhogg8236
      @cooterhazzardbhogg8236 5 років тому

      He was in her basement checking for drafts with his caulk in his hand -"gun"

    • @canadianroot
      @canadianroot 4 роки тому

      Yo, Adrienne.

    • @oilersridersbluejays
      @oilersridersbluejays 3 роки тому

      The only good thing about CBC was HNIC and back when they would show Blue Jays games. Other than that, there is nowhere near anything you could quality of programming on CBC.

  • @martytruelove5026
    @martytruelove5026 5 років тому +1

    WELL SAID DAVE !

  • @AllRequired
    @AllRequired 4 роки тому

    He didn't even throw it over his shoulder, dammit!

  • @clubhouseme
    @clubhouseme 11 років тому

    They went to the news right after the pen flip.

  • @johnpetrossi6406
    @johnpetrossi6406 5 років тому

    I remember this well Dave f them you were right then and now you at the time were the best hats off

  • @ElectoneGuy
    @ElectoneGuy 12 років тому

    I'll never forget watching this live and wondering what the heck was going on. In understand Dave's frustration that night.

  • @scorpiocanuck6321
    @scorpiocanuck6321 5 років тому

    People are surprised he was fired. Wow!

  • @scottjackson1420
    @scottjackson1420 4 роки тому

    He was great! I love the way Dave handled this. LOL, even though he may have been fired an hour later!

  • @slayerone61
    @slayerone61 3 роки тому

    I, too, saw this live and right after he tossed his pen, I thought to myself "I think he'll get fired."

  • @luker350
    @luker350 12 років тому +1

    Very classical moment in Hockey! Seriously!

  • @leafyutube
    @leafyutube 12 років тому

    Memorable moment in Canadian TV history.

  • @Cheessa
    @Cheessa 13 років тому

    I remember seeing this and thought "Uh oh, Dave's in trouble now" but never did I think they'd fire him.

  • @Lewis94
    @Lewis94 10 років тому

    Duthie isn't a journalist, he's a broadcast host. HUGE difference.

  • @GetBenched2010
    @GetBenched2010 3 роки тому +1

    Considering how little the NHL was paid by the CBC. its a wonder they ever had broadcast rights at all. They were bringing in 2 billion a year on HNIC while the Canadian markets were borderline going out of business and 2 ended up moving. (Edmonton and Calgary just barely survived that era.) Their nonchalant attitude towards broadcasting games, especially playoff games, was shameful. Definitely a "tradition" that didn't deserve to continue.

  • @JBatts41
    @JBatts41 12 років тому

    We are NOT able to go there..... LOL

  • @cmrichardson87
    @cmrichardson87 10 років тому +6

    And so began the Ron MacLean era (aka. Legend in Canadian Hockey/Sports Broadcasting). Peace Dave Hodge.

  • @chevydryden4508
    @chevydryden4508 5 років тому +2

    Hodge the best

  • @aidanmcgloine
    @aidanmcgloine 9 років тому

    I found another great Dave Hodge moment from the 83 Cup Celebration Dave Hodge drops a killer transition line during 1983 Stanley Cup Celebration for the NY Islanders

    • @bb-gc2tx
      @bb-gc2tx 2 роки тому

      whats so great about it?

  • @Bawbster1
    @Bawbster1 5 років тому

    I still say that it wasn't so much the pen flip, it was him calling out the network for their ludicrous decision... and he was justified in what he said.

  • @Lanarkwow
    @Lanarkwow 11 років тому +1

    Yay Dave Hodge and shame on the CBC!!!!!

  • @JuniorNationFan
    @JuniorNationFan 13 років тому

    That's the way I wanna go.

  • @RaginRonic
    @RaginRonic 4 роки тому

    SHS, I was wondering if you could add the date of Sat., Mar. 14, 1987 to either this video's title or the description? It was that night that this Pen Flip happened...the game between the Philadelphia Flyers and Montreal Canadiens ended in a 3-3 draw, for the record. o.o

  • @APmfnK
    @APmfnK 12 років тому

    Dave used to come into the HMV I worked at. One day as I was cashing him out, the pen I was using stopped working. I casually flung it over my shoulder and grabbed another. He seemed pretty annoyed with me after that and I had no idea why. My partner at the cash laughed after he left and explained to me why he was pissed... man I felt bad.

  • @greymilton
    @greymilton 11 років тому

    I remember this... classic!

  • @chinary8
    @chinary8 11 років тому

    Yeah, essentially we had a bunch of people who had no idea how to work in broadcasting telling us what to do. Nothing ever changes and no one in management ever gets sacked. Vancouver's evening newscast is something like 5,000 viewers down from 10,000 five years ago. Think they people responsible in management got canned for that? NEWP!

  • @bareknuckles2u
    @bareknuckles2u 11 років тому +1

    Ron Maclean compared the911 attacks to the NHL playoffs? When did he do that?

  • @WLUgrad
    @WLUgrad 12 років тому

    There's a difference between expressing an opinion and badmouthing your employer on national TV. Any employee publicly making such negative comments about their employer is likely to get fired. That being said, Hodge is still right. It was a ridiculous decision not to show the ending of an overtime game.

  • @the6ig6adwolf
    @the6ig6adwolf 5 років тому +1

    Like a boss!

  • @daboys1215
    @daboys1215 7 років тому +1

    March 14, 1987. Ron Maclean took over as host the following week and Hodge was eventually fired.

    • @PatFrenchLeafsFan1
      @PatFrenchLeafsFan1 10 місяців тому

      Ron even explained it on the Steve Dangle Podcast using his own words. "Finish what you start!"

  • @MapleSyrupPoet
    @MapleSyrupPoet 4 роки тому

    Dave is legendary 🍁🍁❤

  • @leafyutube
    @leafyutube 11 років тому

    Dave followed George Constanza's school of thought. If you're gonna get canned, go out with a bang!

  • @RuiFonseca-pu6yy
    @RuiFonseca-pu6yy 7 місяців тому

    Good man Save thumbs up

  • @PatFrenchLeafsFan1
    @PatFrenchLeafsFan1 3 роки тому

    That was mentioned by Ron Maclean to Steve Dangle on the worst day of CBC Sports. They cut away from the Brier to the NDP Convention where Bob Rae became premier of Ontario and the rest of Canada aired a Star Trek repeat and again the Habs game where Hodge flipped his pen.

  • @juxtarail
    @juxtarail 10 років тому

    The 11:00 pm news was for eastern time zone viewers, midnight atlantic time, and 12:30 am in Newfoundland. What was on at 10 Central, 9 Mountain, and 8 Pacific?

  • @BBQFanNo1
    @BBQFanNo1 3 роки тому +1

    The firing of Don Cherry marked the end of the Good CBC HNIC Commentators such as the Hewitt's, Danny Gallivan, Brian MacFarlane, Dick Irvin Jr, Howie Meeker and Others.

  • @loudmuch
    @loudmuch 10 років тому +2

    This is honestly one of my favorite off ice hockey moments.

  • @hockeyjaw
    @hockeyjaw 11 років тому +1

    shortly after this segment Dave Hodge was dismissed from CBC, which is nonsense

  • @mezu8
    @mezu8 11 років тому

    Why didn't he just check the TSN app on his smartphone?

  • @mrceleb2006
    @mrceleb2006 8 років тому +4

    0:28 - "Good night for 'Hockey Night in Canada'!" Those were the last words Dave Hodge said during his tenure on CBC's 'Hockey Night in Canada'! Ron MacLean took over 'HNIC' afterwards until the 2014-2015 NHL season.

    • @mrceleb2006
      @mrceleb2006 7 років тому

      ...with a vengeance, indeed! There were five Canadian teams in the 2017 NHL playoffs (compared to none the preceding year)...there was only one left until the Stanley Cup Final matchup was set between Pittsburgh and Nashville; the former won their second straight Cup in six games...first time it has happened in the salary cap era and first time in almost two decades! A new NHL dynasty has been born!

  • @sweiland75
    @sweiland75 9 років тому +3

    Just imagine if he had not done this he would have been paired with Don Cherry on Coaches' Corner. Ron McLean is a wallflower who lets Cherry get away with too much but if they had kept Dave there is no way Cherry would still be on the air.

    • @dmorles
      @dmorles 9 років тому +1

      I couldn't imagine Cherry doing his segment with anyone else that could stand him. He runs over the proverbial doormat Maclean every time they're on the air. Feel bad for the guy.

    • @danbutler2981
      @danbutler2981 9 років тому +3

      sweiland75 He actually did do coaches corner with Cherry for 5 or 6 years.

    • @sweiland75
      @sweiland75 9 років тому

      Dan Butler
      I guess I started too late to see that then LOL

    • @Libertyjack1
      @Libertyjack1 8 років тому +1

      +Dan Butler That was before Cherry turned into a reincarnation of Harold Ballard...with loud clothing, of course.

  • @MattiasXL
    @MattiasXL 12 років тому

    Glad somebody called the CBC out on some of the stupid things they do. Too bad nobody flipped a pen on a live broadcast about the dismantling of their orchestra. :/

  • @theraj662
    @theraj662 12 років тому

    Fuck yes! I remember this like it was yesterday! The only person who might be able to say such things and get away with it is Don Cherry.

  • @ldhorricks
    @ldhorricks 12 років тому +1

    @werqa123 Cheers to you from a Canadian living in Prague for 20 years....I too have a large collection of DVDs from the 60's thru the 70's and early 80's...rather watch these games any day over the current NHL circus.

  • @mike196212
    @mike196212 11 років тому

    I remember this. Funny but truthful too. Hodge was sarcastic,ironic and great--far superior to the wishy-washy,''Bullwinklish'',faux ''sophistication'' of Ron McLean. Only the CBC would make a referee a tv ''star.''

  • @zachsmith8967
    @zachsmith8967 5 років тому

    Legend

  • @Scoclamor
    @Scoclamor  13 років тому

    @GuyOrrEspo March 14, 1987 during a game between the Flyers and Habs!

  • @streetcarjay
    @streetcarjay 11 років тому

    That mean's Dave, Your Unemployment cheque is in the mail.

  • @dansmith6748
    @dansmith6748 2 роки тому

    Just prior to this, earlier on the same day in fact, Dave was watching the Brier on the CBC. They cut the broadcast short with 4 rocks remaing, which pissed Dave off, along with a LOT of curling fans. Now he has to tell his viewing audience that the CBC will not be covering the overtime between Montreal and Philadelphia. So he was mad and frustrated, along with the rest of us, for CBC's handling of sports coverage, and gets fired for it.

    • @PatFrenchLeafsFan1
      @PatFrenchLeafsFan1 2 роки тому +1

      Ontario had the NDP Convention while the rest of the country had a Star Trek repeat.

  • @bballman
    @bballman 13 років тому

    A classic footprint in the sands of Canadian Sports Broadcasting.

  • @corymazz
    @corymazz 12 років тому

    ...and the Ron Maclean era began...

  • @PatFrenchLeafsFan1
    @PatFrenchLeafsFan1 3 роки тому

    Ron Maclean's rendition on Steve Dangle: It's typical the way things are things here for the second and I regret to inform you we're going to cut away the OT from tonight's game between Montréal & Philadelphia and... if you're frustrated as I am, you'll take pen to hand and write to the CBC brass. The golden rule is... finish... what you start! Good night from HNIC!

  • @awardwinner
    @awardwinner 10 років тому

    What? Duthie is one of the classiest in the business and has been nominated for 11 Gemini's, winning 3 (including Best Sportscaster in 2009 and 2010).

  • @maximuusintanios3396
    @maximuusintanios3396 9 років тому

    He was in contract negotiations and things weren't going well so Dave did what he did.
    The thing is he doesn't regret it so I respect what he did.
    Also wasn't it during a playoff race where the point or points really mattered?

  • @hondacustom
    @hondacustom 7 років тому +1

    I remember that

  • @seandalton44
    @seandalton44 11 років тому

    Calm down bareknuckles2u. He was referring that they're both warriors, inspiring people. He meant it as a compliment, and apologized afterwards for it.

  • @johngenova5506
    @johngenova5506 5 років тому

    I recall him disappearing from CBC I was young at the time, and no social media to tell what happened, hodge was ok, more old school,, maclean did good to replace hodge

  • @landrykkb
    @landrykkb 12 років тому

    At the time,I somehow missed this,but I gradually noticed over the weeks that Dave Hodge had been phased out.