I Tried 5 Highly Rated Underseat Carryon Luggages From Amazon

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 123

  • @bettermenttravel
    @bettermenttravel  10 місяців тому +2

    My Top 3 Picks:
    Best Overall goes to TravelPro Maxlite Luggage: amzn.to/471Tlfi
    Best Value goes to Rockland Luggage : amzn.to/3MIcwSa
    Best for Laptop Lifestyle goes to Verage Luggage: amzn.to/3NaACq8

  • @_w_w_
    @_w_w_ Рік тому +34

    Great video and very informative. I'd be interested to learn more about how they actually fit under the seat, and whether they meet airlines' underseat personal item dimensions.

    • @4tdaz
      @4tdaz Рік тому +2

      The travel pro does. I've owned it for years. Fits perfectly

    • @_w_w_
      @_w_w_ Рік тому +5

      @@4tdaz I had a Travel Pro and it didn't fit in low cost airlines when they may jam in more seats per row.

    • @4tdaz
      @4tdaz Рік тому +2

      @@_w_w_ Good point. However, I'm 6'1 and I myself don't fit on Spirit, so I don't even think about their under seats. I just remember my knees being up and my feet dangling b/c they smash the rows so close. My bad.

    • @_w_w_
      @_w_w_ Рік тому +1

      @@4tdazNow you are thinking. People that buy this luggage are flying low cost airlines and trying to avoid fees. This goes back to the logic behind my question and post.

    • @crochetcreations3232
      @crochetcreations3232 4 місяці тому +1

      Not always true. International airlines have a much smaller carry on and personal item allowance than US domestic. It is based on size and weight. Also, some of us have bad backs and need something small that also has wheels. Everyone needs are different

  • @kathygann7632
    @kathygann7632 Рік тому +49

    For all the bags that don’t have enough padding to protect electronics, just fold a sweater toward the outside to provide your own padding.

    • @sassytbc7923
      @sassytbc7923 Рік тому +2

      A towel will work as well, in case you are traveling to a location that’s quite warm

    • @_w_w_
      @_w_w_ Рік тому +5

      I design electronics so I will disagree with this suggestion. Get a laptop sleeve... they are cheap, lightweight and offer even protection all around. They can also provide some anti-static benefits. Using sweater to wrap electronics is not ideal because of possible static-electricity this can create, which may lead to component damage or data loss.

    • @kathygann7632
      @kathygann7632 Рік тому +2

      @@_w_w_ good points. I was just thinking of padding it. Some sleeves are made in a modal fabric which takes no space.

    • @kathygann7632
      @kathygann7632 Рік тому

      @@_w_w_ great point. Usually I carry an iPad mini (lightweight) with a waterproof Lifeproof case to protect it, but I never thought of static.thanks for giving me some things to think about.

  • @DeeDee-qm2zn
    @DeeDee-qm2zn 8 місяців тому +5

    I bought the Rockland underseat bag based on your review, and I am extremely pleased! Thank you!

  • @lynnevandewalle3829
    @lynnevandewalle3829 Рік тому +6

    Your video is excellent. I have the Travelpro Maxlite 5 under the seat piece you featured, however it did not fit under a seat on American or Southwest.
    I love it still use it, but put it in overhead bin.

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  10 місяців тому +1

      That's unfortunate, i plan on making an update video on underseat carryon luggages soon!

  • @janetsecrest7446
    @janetsecrest7446 11 місяців тому +4

    Thank you so much! I wish you’d reviewed the Sampsonite spinner Underseater. I really want a 4-wheeled bag and your video is the best to show the actual features

  • @stacyalvarez9046
    @stacyalvarez9046 8 місяців тому +3

    You are very good at reviewing these items. I appreciate that you went at a smooth quick pace but not too fast. I also like the details you pointed out. Thank you

  • @kathygann7632
    @kathygann7632 Рік тому +18

    Thanks for doing this. Years ago, my 3 year old grandson asked for a suitcase for Christmas I got him and his older sister under seat suitcases and packing cubes. At first their mother cried bloody murder because she didn’t want to juggle more suitcases, but realized she loved them. I’m now looking for one for my last of 5 grandkids so this was very helpful.

    • @bedtimestoriesforkids9755
      @bedtimestoriesforkids9755 Рік тому +1

      Is your 3 year old grandson your son's son? ( or your daughter's son?)

    • @kathygann7632
      @kathygann7632 Рік тому +1

      @@bedtimestoriesforkids9755 The one I’m looking for now is for my son’s second daughter

    • @kaylaEA_
      @kaylaEA_ 9 місяців тому +1

      @@kathygann7632 It’ll be great for them to have when they’re older and want to travel the budget airlines for quick inexpensive trips.

  • @ChaseMaximilian
    @ChaseMaximilian Рік тому +2

    Thanks Bud. I’m traveling soon and this luggage style caught my eye in Amazon.

  • @cm1jon610
    @cm1jon610 Рік тому +7

    Excellent reviews! Greatly appreciated!

  • @kathygann7632
    @kathygann7632 Рік тому +2

    Years ago, I bought a Samantha Brown under seater that unzips to a carryon. It is now my go to because I fly on Allegiant airlines, and personal items are still free.

  • @jennytran4849
    @jennytran4849 Рік тому +9

    Thank you! Very informative! Can you do the same with amazon under the seat backpacks? :)

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  Рік тому +5

      Yes I can ! Thanks for the idea :) Im getting a lot of support from people like you! I wanna make more travel gear review videos!

    • @largelingerie
      @largelingerie Рік тому +4

      Yes, I,was expecting this to be about under seat personal item bag, not wheeled carry-on. Also, since different airlines have different size limits, can you provide the sizes of everything you review, please.

    • @chillaxtita7339
      @chillaxtita7339 Рік тому

      Love your review in every single bags and your opinion matters to me too, It's quite interesting that you bought all of these bags with your own money, Appreciate your effort❤, new subs here😊

  • @AnneMB955
    @AnneMB955 7 місяців тому

    Great review thanks. Have had an underseat Delsey for about 10 years now. I do like the choice of smaller bags for minimalist packing. 👏🇦🇺

  • @kimcaplan7963
    @kimcaplan7963 Рік тому +41

    You just confirmed why not to buy an under the seat roller bag. I was considering it, but after watching your video, you confirmed there is not enough room for all the items I now carry in by large backpack. If you are packing clothes, then you would also pack toiletries. If you are packing electronics, then you would pack the cables. All the side pockets on these bags are not expandable enough for the bulk of these items. Also, if you were able to pack all the pockets to their capacity, it won't fit under the seat. Or worse, you can't get to pockets when you are sitting in your seat to reach and grab because you jam the bag in to get it to fit under the seat😂. I'm sticking with the backpack. Seriously, thanks for the review!

    • @John-hs8id
      @John-hs8id Рік тому +14

      You make a valid point about traditional underseat rollers, and I can understand why they might not meet everyone's needs. However, I'd like to share my experience with my UNDERSEAT PRO foldable rolling suitcase.This suitcase has a distinct design that sets it apart from the bags reviewed on Jon's video. Its rectangular shape and clamshell style optimizes space and organization in a way that typical underseat bags don't. It features mesh pockets all around the inner lateral sides, allowing easy access to essentials such as snacks, charging cables, and wireless earphones without even taking the bag out. Moreover, it has a padded laptop pocket, big enough to fit up to a 17" laptop. As someone who prefers to travel light, I find that this suitcase offers enough space for a week's worth of clothes, electronics, cables, and more. Even fully packed, my suitcase fits snugly under the seat in front of me ( I travel Spirit, Frontier, Allegiant, and American Airlines). The fact that it folds down for easy storage when not in use is an added bonus!

    • @ElPandaWarrior
      @ElPandaWarrior Рік тому +5

      I use a briggs and riley underseat roller bag plus a smaller backpack for all the electronics and my toiletry kit. The back pack rides on top of the cabin bag. Three weeks in Asia with just these two items and it turns out I was over packed!

    • @robinkrieger8003
      @robinkrieger8003 Рік тому +6

      Except the backpack gets heavy on my shoulders ….I carry backpack and these underseat rollers so the qbdkoack can go over the handle

    • @paulfowler9832
      @paulfowler9832 Рік тому +10

      not everyone wants to or can carry an under seat bag around an airport when you get older you'll know😊

  • @OneJoy5801
    @OneJoy5801 Рік тому +6

    I have a Samsonite underseat large size luggage that I've had for 8 years now. It has so many pockets and pouches many of which are detachable, it's insane. I used it mainly for overnight business trips and love it.

  • @Scolopente
    @Scolopente Рік тому +4

    Looks like some of the side pockets might be perfect for a pair of flip flops?

  • @teeadvocate
    @teeadvocate 11 місяців тому +1

    Thanks, I have been trying to decide which bag to get. :)

  • @MamabearXX
    @MamabearXX Рік тому +3

    It would be good to have the empty weights of each of the bags too. Where I live you can only take 7kg as carry-on, being one bag plus a personal item, like a handbag or laptop, but all have to total no more than 7kg.

  • @b00bala64
    @b00bala64 Рік тому +3

    Wow! Love the video detail. Thanks!

  • @jbowerdel
    @jbowerdel Рік тому +18

    would have liked to see that these bags actually fit underseat-they look too large to me and I don't want to be on the plane when i find out it doesn't fit. Otherwise nice review of the bags themselves.

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  Рік тому +10

      Thank you!! I thought about the idea too. I would have to think how to actually do this without being on a plane. Maybe i ll make a mock underseat

    • @brendakrause5639
      @brendakrause5639 6 місяців тому

      ​@@bettermenttravel try sitting 2 chairs in front of each other. Separate by how many inches between seats for the airlines.

    • @TheOriginalMarimoChan
      @TheOriginalMarimoChan Місяць тому

      My medium-sized kid's backpack barely fits under the seats of most US airlines! On our last trip on Delta of Sept 2024, my backpack poked out from under the seat in front of me, so I had to put the airlines blanket on it to hide it from the flight attendant!

  • @WhyYouTrippin
    @WhyYouTrippin Рік тому +1

    Ayo... it's Albi here! I was just researching carry-on luggage and your video popped up in my recommendations feed!

  • @OnyxMoonSign
    @OnyxMoonSign 3 місяці тому

    I'm wondering if an under the seat airplane bag could be used at a stadium or convention center? Or is that a different size space than airplane seats?

  • @sharonsardeson7992
    @sharonsardeson7992 11 місяців тому +5

    Those 360 wheels take space away from the main compartment so less room for clothes.

  • @gwensoma7793
    @gwensoma7793 11 місяців тому +1

    Very helpful reviews! Thank you!

  • @TLhike
    @TLhike 5 місяців тому

    Wierd question, could you use the travelpro & have a 35L backpack ontop vertically as a dolly essentially with out it being unstable? Or will it just flop over thanks!

  • @linhchanbrown2006
    @linhchanbrown2006 Рік тому +11

    Good review! However, it would have been even better if you can show how each of them actually fit under-seat, and a comparison of weight for us older travelers!

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  Рік тому +4

      Thank you!! Will think of that for next time :) I ll buy like a mock airplane seat perhaps in an updated video!!

  • @bethmctv9317
    @bethmctv9317 9 місяців тому

    Appreciate the reviews. Wish I knew if any (or all) would fit if you are in an aisle seat on American or United. 🤨

  • @ellentoyonaga687
    @ellentoyonaga687 Рік тому +1

    Does the travel pro's handle lock at the middle position or only at the fully extended position?

  • @danielneveu5894
    @danielneveu5894 Рік тому +1

    The outside pockets are good for putting in shoes .

  • @judychatham3767
    @judychatham3767 6 місяців тому

    I was hoping at least one Samsonite underseater was in your review, but it was not :( However, it was an excellent video and left me to decide between the Travel Pro Maxlite and a Samsonite.

  • @kakaeculbertson564
    @kakaeculbertson564 Рік тому

    Some airlines that say your under seat carry-on is a backpack. Are those rollers considered your 1 item? ITA air and Ryanair specifically.

  • @jennierandomz
    @jennierandomz Рік тому

    Can u review underseat pro suitcase and backpack?

  • @4tdaz
    @4tdaz Рік тому +1

    The big sacrifice of spinners is you lose internal volume. And its big. However if you dont need the volume and if you for sure are leaving under your seat, your feet will thank you with the extra room. As with everything. Its all about compromises and where you are willing to give up something

  • @TK-cl1jm
    @TK-cl1jm 11 місяців тому +4

    Excellent comparison, just what I was looking for!
    FYI, "luggages" is incorrect. Luggage is an uncountable noun, and therefore always singular.

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  10 місяців тому

      I love this point haha! I will keep this in mind for future videos!

  • @TischTosh
    @TischTosh Рік тому

    The coolife, the one you didn't call out in the end, is the one I'd probably buy (unless the travelpro was on firesale-- they make tough but professional looking gear!)

    • @_w_w_
      @_w_w_ Рік тому

      You know that middle padded section for computer/tablet? It's a bit dangerous. If you don't pack evenly, just he shown in his video, you could assert pressure points on the computer or tablet, this could lead to damages. The idea of using this section in the middle of the suitecase is good, because it allows more padding above and below it, but it will require even packing, so you don't create uneven pressure points onto your electronic devices.

  • @itHas2BeYou
    @itHas2BeYou Рік тому +1

    For underseat bag/cabin bag. I think It should be be without the wheels..
    From my experiences. I get stopped by the staff. The size is alright but the Weight is problem. Especially when the flight is full.
    I bought 16inch. Hard cover. Hand carry bag. From aliexpress. Fly with laptop bag and one hand carry. Never had a problem. 😁.

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  10 місяців тому

      I do prefer your later way of flying. Laptop bag and one hand carry and i have no problems either!

  • @laptacksea
    @laptacksea 8 місяців тому

    Nice review!

  • @starb.1130
    @starb.1130 6 місяців тому

    Tip for these things also is to learn packing hacks and use compression cubes. There are countless videos on UA-cam with people showing you how. Even with plus size folks. The only issue is some will fit under the seat and some won't. I hear the Amazon Basics 33 x 33 x 22.86 cm ( 13 x 13 x 9 in)and the Underseat Pro 45 x 36 x 20cm (18 x1 4 x 8 in) will fit under seats. I hate 2 wheel suitcases as well. I never owned a spinner and I'm looking around for one now, but it needs to small enough where they won't try and check my bag.

  • @63Lsp
    @63Lsp 10 місяців тому +1

    Great reviews. Could I suggest you minimize/re-position the font on screen? It blocks the product you are showing . Other wise great😊

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  10 місяців тому

      Thanks so much! Will keep that in mind for future videos forsure :)

  • @carolinagirl3110
    @carolinagirl3110 Рік тому +2

    Great review!….thanks

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  Рік тому +1

      Glad it was helpful! Your comment makes me wanna do better reviews in the future!

  • @michellefilmore9343
    @michellefilmore9343 Рік тому

    Great Information - thanks.

  • @fransiscaemilia565
    @fransiscaemilia565 11 місяців тому +1

    Pls info what kind of under seater have 1 kg weight?
    Tq

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  10 місяців тому

      I have all the links in the description! I would recommend checking that out and then seeing the weight on AMZ

  • @LAURABOHDAN
    @LAURABOHDAN Рік тому +17

    This review is TERRIFIC!
    Most people cut them selves short by having too small of a personal item bag. Properly managed my personal bag holds about 1/3 the volume of my
    roll-aboard. I have never been stoped on any flight, international or domestic. Love Laura

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  Рік тому +3

      Thanks so much!!!! will be doing more reviews like this

  • @ElPandaWarrior
    @ElPandaWarrior Рік тому +2

    You need to include a toiletry kit to approximate real life. Nearly everyone includes one in their carry on luggage.

  • @annchurchill2638
    @annchurchill2638 5 місяців тому

    If any of these came with a heavy duty plastic bag you can vacuum I would buy it.. Those hold a lot of clothes in a small space,.

  • @gaila.8830
    @gaila.8830 Рік тому +1

    Thank you for sharing 😊

  • @stephrainspirite9985
    @stephrainspirite9985 Рік тому

    something confusing is you are calling an underseat personal itema carry on.. You dont need a wholelot of prtection if you have it undre your seat. The first few bags have solid round tops whichlimits thins to fit.

  • @joselynrijna462
    @joselynrijna462 Рік тому +3

    G the camera is moving too much making me dizzy 🥴

  • @floridasingularity3700
    @floridasingularity3700 Рік тому +3

    As a grown man, I could never see value in wheeling around an under-seat sized bag. I go with backpack options. Any advantages to a rolling case that I’m missing?

    • @TischTosh
      @TischTosh Рік тому +2

      I'm 4'11", but I love OBT/Carry on only. If I get a backpack to carry what I need (comfortably) , the comfort mods are expensive. I'm told it looks odd as well (bag's big, I'm tiny). Sweat is real. if I'm dressed up at all, a roller is a must.

    • @squirrelnibbler19
      @squirrelnibbler19 Рік тому

      These are so small, wheeling them seems unnecessary if you are fairly healthy.

  • @kirstenveneziano1205
    @kirstenveneziano1205 10 місяців тому +2

    Your review on the bags and what they fit is fine; however, you don't talk about whether the bags fit under the seat of domestic or International airlines. Without that information, the review means very little.

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  10 місяців тому +2

      makes complete sense! I plan on doing an update video on this.

  • @AliNawaz-nd5wi
    @AliNawaz-nd5wi 8 місяців тому

    Dear Brother, Please Show me video In soft shell luggage ultra light weight hand carry 18 inches under seat trolley wheels carry -on price. Lot of thanks

  • @brendakrause5639
    @brendakrause5639 6 місяців тому

    I could fit about the same amount of items in a $30 backpack.

  • @marlongalit3954
    @marlongalit3954 Рік тому +1

    How much

  • @gloriamaggs5453
    @gloriamaggs5453 7 місяців тому +1

    I use a Samsonite underneath
    spinner..love it..the only luggage that I use...pack less and enjoy more...

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  7 місяців тому

      I have to check this out! I ll be creating an updated video

  • @stinkiebearr
    @stinkiebearr Рік тому +1

    Im not travelling anywhere anytime soon. But im preparing for one day! Pray for me yall i want to travel 😭

  • @fransiscaemilia565
    @fransiscaemilia565 11 місяців тому +1

    And have 4 wheel drive

  • @cathylingo9521
    @cathylingo9521 Рік тому

    Do they all fit the budget airlines personal item?

    • @stephenjarzombek2903
      @stephenjarzombek2903 Рік тому +1

      Same question here. I read comments on the Travelpro not only being too large by United's standards for an underseat item, but that it didn't fit under some other airline seats due to its thickness at 8.5".

  • @LunarEclipse-xv8jx
    @LunarEclipse-xv8jx Рік тому

    Good interview with a WISE woman!

  • @susangilliam6400
    @susangilliam6400 Рік тому

    In reviewing the last bag those straps work like I guesset so the front does not flop open and one of the other bags also has a guesset that doesn't allow the bag to flop all the way down if you choose to use it that way.
    I'm a girl..and none of the bags work for all My stuff..however one of the Amazon Basics bag similar I own abs it's pretty good in comparison to these.
    Thanks

    • @risi20
      @risi20 Рік тому

      Which bag works for you?

  • @momdaughtertalk8008
    @momdaughtertalk8008 Рік тому

    thanks for sharing

    • @bettermenttravel
      @bettermenttravel  Рік тому

      Thanks for watching! I put a lot of time into this video and plan on doing more reviews in the future!

  • @Colorado18
    @Colorado18 9 місяців тому +1

    thsnk you

  • @realityDoubleCheck-ss5xt
    @realityDoubleCheck-ss5xt 7 місяців тому

    All of them do not meet sizes for the majority of airlines : 17-9-10

  • @starbright47
    @starbright47 Рік тому

    Ok, but unhelpful without measurements. I realise plane sizes underfoot may differ, but they have tb general sizing for seats. Disappointing as I'm looking for this❣️

  • @bluewaters2231
    @bluewaters2231 8 місяців тому

    subscriptn done. all d best.❤

  • @alicek412
    @alicek412 Рік тому +2

    Good review video but the camera movement is just too much.

  • @mrbenwong86
    @mrbenwong86 Рік тому +1

    Doesn't look like it will fit underseat.

  • @fransiscaemilia565
    @fransiscaemilia565 11 місяців тому +1

    And can keep 15,6" laptop.

  • @SolarizeYourLife
    @SolarizeYourLife Рік тому +3

    What pisses me off is that the "A" crowd that gets on the damn plane first, can and will stuff both bags in the overhead!!! And couples will take the window seat and aile seat in hopes no one will take the middle seat!!! YES, ONE ASSHOLE COUPLE DID BOTH ABOVE THINGS ON MY LAST TRIP...

    • @TrackerRoo
      @TrackerRoo Рік тому

      Airlines really need to stop allowing people to bring wheeled luggage into the plane as carryons. Should be limited to a normal sized backpack and a normal sized purse for carryons.

    • @bettyparker3317
      @bettyparker3317 5 місяців тому

      I will absolutely second this. The airlines should prohibit more than one bag per passenger in the overhead bin.
      As to the video itself, it’s good, and helpful. It’d be even more helpful if you gave each bags weight.

    • @henrysmom1742
      @henrysmom1742 5 місяців тому

      Recently I flew from LAX to Denver when they announced that everyone had to check their carry on bags at the gate. Caused a bit of an uproar, but those with backpacks, purses and under seat bags were lucky. I didn’t mind..l check my bag no matter what. I fly with carry on only but check it. Very rarely wait more than 10 minutes and don’t have to worry about it. Been flying for over 50 years and have only had one bag misrputed…by TWA in mid-70s

  • @arthurott4561
    @arthurott4561 Рік тому +1

    How about calling it a tablet instead of being so crApplecentric with the constant reference to an ipad.

  • @klle3419
    @klle3419 10 місяців тому

    delete 90% of the actuallys

  • @Niceshopx01
    @Niceshopx01 Рік тому +1

    No one complains when a rich dude shows off his car collection, as well as no one complains their bag collection from #eastlisa