ikr i read the us edition after the uk edition and trust me the plot twist hits you harder in uk edition than that in the us one because in the uk edition they(pip and Eliot) had such a good relationship which was more formal us edition
@@myxha6709 so? I read American books to the spelling might be different but not much else. This just Americans being dumb and refusing to accept that the world doesn’t revolve around them
I read agggtm and ggbb in the UK versions, and agad in the US, I was sooooo confused😂 I was like wait, but it took place in Little Kilton, what do you mean Fairview? And it used "this" when someone spoke, as opposed to 'this' in the other versions, and when I read colorful, I was like wait, where's the u?😂
@@shanbooksbasically just an american epq used during the final year of an academic term, but its allows students to research and help solve real world issues in the forms of papers, case studies, etc
@@shanbooksthat might be the U.S equivalent of like senior projects bc I know here in the U.S we have to write like either a paper or slideshow of different things we did for a senior projects some of the seniors this year did like internships and some others built stuff for the community and one of the juniors is going to be remodeling part of the school. So kinda similar I think?
I had absolutely no idea there were different versions 😅 I read the first 2 books in the uk version and the last book in the us version nd i was confused the whole time I reread the first two books just to see if i missed something 😂
Ohh thank you so much for this I was kinda confused since I was apparently reading the Uk version while I was listening to the Uk version in Spotify, no wonder some things where missing in the book
I read the US one, I didn’t know the uk one existed, but why do they have to be different? I feel like if there’s a slightly different version of the story it would just ruin it.
So the original is better than the one that was adapted for a different population because for some reason the publishers thought they wouldn’t read a book set in a different country? Big surprise. Quite frankly I don’t see why they had to make a different version, and I definitely don’t see why they had to cut down the amount of detail in it. I’m Indian, but you don’t see me reading an “Indian version” of the book. I read and liked the UK (the original) version just fine.
Hey I have a question, actually I was watching a UA-cam video and it said that in the book a good girls guide to murder the killer was the brother, So can you please tell me is that a spoiler or not. Because I was thinking about buying that book, and I dont want any kind of spoiler 😢
The UK covers aren’t cute so I think I’ll stick with my U.S. ones lol also I already read them so I won’t be breaking my neck to go and read the same book just set in a different country, I’m good 🤣
books usually don’t get an edit that’s as drastic as this though. it’s usually just changing certain words to make it clearer for audiences in different countries - this was something completely different
Cheesecake is obviously sweet and tart why would anyone think to use lox cream cheese in a cake? It's like adding bananas to a pizza, it exists but that still doesn't make any kind of sense to me
She does seem autistic, but it doesn't really impact the book and its never a plot point so it doesn't really matter. Its nice to see some representation of autistic traits though!
after reading the whole series in the american version i can’t imagine it being set in anywhere but Fairview and it’s already so good so idk how the uk one would be better. maybe I’ll find it and read it.
@@koiloylo it didn’t need an edit at all, BUT no one in the US knew it was an edit when it came out, I thought that was the original and it was always in Fairview ect.
![Pip & Ravi - Their Story [A Good Girl's Guide to Murder]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nmUeMch46eg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Pip & Ravi - Their Story [A Good Girl's Guide to Murder]](/img/tr.png)
I don’t understand why there needed to be a us version.
Because Americans can’t bear to read a book that isn’t about their country 😂
@@taylors.version.13 hii swiftie🤗
@@taylors.version.13 factss
The publisher didn’t want the U.K. one. They said it wouldn’t be appealing to American audience
@@taylors.version.13REAL THO.
I thought they where the same just different covers😭 now I need to find the uk version and read it. Is it the same with the whole series?
yes like there was no need for the us versions
mostly everything is same ofc just these tiny details that mean alot to a reader
Lol same
ikr i read the us edition after the uk edition and trust me the plot twist hits you harder in uk edition than that in the us one because in the uk edition they(pip and Eliot) had such a good relationship which was more formal us edition
As an American who read the UK edition and then accidentally bought the US one, I was really not impressed with the latter.
The uk edition was the original, as holly Jackson is from London.
oh, i didn’t know that that’s cool
I really don’t understand why the us version was made
Gladly I read the UK version 👏🏽 it's so strange that the change the setting 🙈
I wonder why they made so many changes. That doesn’t make much sense.
It's called localization. You make changes to fit the culture you're localizing for
@@WeFightForever But the changes in Pip’s relationship to her friends dad doesn’t make sense. That’s not cultural.
@@WeFightForeveralso why? I’m Australian we don’t have an Australian edition that’s dumb
@@naveerarizwan5329because Australians use British English….
@@myxha6709 so? I read American books to the spelling might be different but not much else. This just Americans being dumb and refusing to accept that the world doesn’t revolve around them
my unpopular opinion is I like the us covers better
yeah i personally think they’re way better
same
i like the usa agggtm cover for the first book but for as good as dead I like the UK cover more
wait how did i not know they were different 😭 now i need to read the uk one
I read agggtm and ggbb in the UK versions, and agad in the US, I was sooooo confused😂 I was like wait, but it took place in Little Kilton, what do you mean Fairview? And it used "this" when someone spoke, as opposed to 'this' in the other versions, and when I read colorful, I was like wait, where's the u?😂
SAME lmao
I NEVER knew about this. Definitely getting the other one to try it!
does the american one also have the epq as the central plot? because I thought epq was just a British thing.
she does something called a capstone project but i have no idea how important it is 😅
@@shanbooksbasically just an american epq used during the final year of an academic term, but its allows students to research and help solve real world issues in the forms of papers, case studies, etc
@@shanbooksthat might be the U.S equivalent of like senior projects bc I know here in the U.S we have to write like either a paper or slideshow of different things we did for a senior projects some of the seniors this year did like internships and some others built stuff for the community and one of the juniors is going to be remodeling part of the school. So kinda similar I think?
@@Ellie_2007 that’s kinda what a capstone project is, it’s a huge research project type thing that you do senior year
I had absolutely no idea there were different versions 😅
I read the first 2 books in the uk version and the last book in the us version nd i was confused the whole time
I reread the first two books just to see if i missed something 😂
Ohh that makes sense, i read the uk version, i was so confused on why the city name was different in an audio book
Ok... So english people have no problem with american books but apparently americans need a separate version set in their country?
No, we don’t. but clearly, these publishing companies think we do just a bunch of idiots if you ask me
I am from Australia so I read the UK one and it was very good , highly recommend ❤
Ohh thank you so much for this I was kinda confused since I was apparently reading the Uk version while I was listening to the Uk version in Spotify, no wonder some things where missing in the book
I’ve read the uk first us second and I’m on to the uk third but three books are to good!!
Im so glad the spanish version is translated from the UK edition not the US one
Didn’t even know there was a us edition. Do people do this with a lot of books? Does Harry Potter and the SORCERERS stone take place in Minnesota?
i’ve never heard of it happening to this degree before. sometimes they’ll change certain words for different markets but rarely whole settings etc.
I did not know the UK version had more detail! Is that the case for “Good Girl, Bad Blood” and “As Good as Dead” too?
I have only read the us edition and never heard that she called them pippisomes. I don't know how to spell it but I love that
pipisms i think
I read the UK edition I guess 😂 I didn't even know there was two versions! I think it's kinda cool tho
“The end of the first book is very ‘every thing wrapped up’”
if only you knew.
In Australia we also have the uk version
I read the UK edition.
i didnt know there was a UK version!!
Yes but i do like the us cover more
I read the US one, I didn’t know the uk one existed, but why do they have to be different? I feel like if there’s a slightly different version of the story it would just ruin it.
I have only ever seen the uk version
I didn't even know there were different editions, but I read the UK one and it's my favourite book
I’m so glad I saw this as soon as i bought the UK version lol
I honestly didnt know this was a british author until i just saw the trailer for the show
i read the first book on US version and the next two in UK 😂 i didn’t even notice the back then
I didnt know this but im really glad i got the uk version lmaoo
So the original is better than the one that was adapted for a different population because for some reason the publishers thought they wouldn’t read a book set in a different country? Big surprise. Quite frankly I don’t see why they had to make a different version, and I definitely don’t see why they had to cut down the amount of detail in it. I’m Indian, but you don’t see me reading an “Indian version” of the book. I read and liked the UK (the original) version just fine.
so thats why theres 2 ver
I need to find the US edition. I just need to see how bad it is
Im so mad i didn't knkw about this and bought the hardcovers which are us edition ughhhh
i only have the american version cause that’s all my bookstore had in stock 😢
Does Pip and Ravi end up together after the fourth book ?
Yes! In the 3rd book "as good as dead" they get back together
wait- THERES A FOURTH BOOK?!? whats it called???
@@gtkyurmum Kill joy. Its a prequel.
@@SN_1D ohh tysm
@@SN_1Dwhen???
THERE ARE TWO VERSIONS?
I don’t get why they have to change it for the americans?
does she still do an EPQ in the US edition?
The way i read the first boom in us edition and other two in uk is js
Uk edition is better I don’t see why they needed a us one
man i read the us version alrd i didn't know there were 2 vers☹
Hey I have a question, actually I was watching a UA-cam video and it said that in the book a good girls guide to murder the killer was the brother, So can you please tell me is that a spoiler or not. Because I was thinking about buying that book, and I dont want any kind of spoiler 😢
It’s not a spoiler! The only brother is Pip’s 10 year old brother, and he kills no one
@@_mollyyyThey're talking about Sal Singh, not Josh
It’s not a spoiler, that is on the back of the book and is pretty much where the story starts. So yeah it isn’t a spoiler
The ending is the same right?
yes ofc its the same book just different versions
Where can I read the US version online ?
Does this have a spoiler I paused it but if it doesn’t I will watch if not pls reply to me so I can watch when I’ve finished reading in like 2 days
It doesnt
Why dud they change the year??
Was the book originally written in UK?
yes!
Noo but the US one has a pretty cover 😢
The UK covers aren’t cute so I think I’ll stick with my U.S. ones lol also I already read them so I won’t be breaking my neck to go and read the same book just set in a different country, I’m good 🤣
Even the percy jackson book is diff in each country (almost every)
books usually don’t get an edit that’s as drastic as this though. it’s usually just changing certain words to make it clearer for audiences in different countries - this was something completely different
I read us edition and I’m glad. From what you just described Pip sounds like a 8 year old.
That’s not at all what she’s like
Omg I never thought about that but I am definitely diagnosing pip with autism
…
??
Do they even have EPQ in America? How would that work?
they change it to a senior capstone project
Are we getting an American rendition tv series ? Or a British ?
its british!
What is pip without her pipisms?
i don't need another book i don't need i havent read the other three i dont need another one
In the UK ver Pippa says "holy pepperoni!" While the US ver she says "holy shit!" Like a normal person would
but the point is that pips not normal
UK version>>>
I read the US version should I read the UK version
yes.. you should. you definitely should
@@kookie_809 do you know where to get in the US?
@@EllieGxmes The UK one? Amazon. You'll know by the covers
Cheesecake is obviously sweet and tart why would anyone think to use lox cream cheese in a cake? It's like adding bananas to a pizza, it exists but that still doesn't make any kind of sense to me
i read the UK one and she doesn't seem autistic at all wtf is us edition I will never read that
She does seem autistic, but it doesn't really impact the book and its never a plot point so it doesn't really matter. Its nice to see some representation of autistic traits though!
after reading the whole series in the american version i can’t imagine it being set in anywhere but Fairview and it’s already so good so idk how the uk one would be better. maybe I’ll find it and read it.
Same now that I know it wasn’t originally set in Fairview and that the tv show is gonna be British it just ruins it a bit for me.
Idk where you would even get the U.S verions bc I just bought the box set on Amazon
the uk one is so good im sorry it didn’t need an american edition at all
@@koiloylo it didn’t need an edit at all, BUT no one in the US knew it was an edit when it came out, I thought that was the original and it was always in Fairview ect.
@@Ellie_2007 I got mine online for the 3rd one and the first two I got at Barnes and nobles (I read the first two before the third was out)