The thing is, she has no sob story or relatablility for the show to leech off of. She's a confident singer. The show shuns that and every other show does as well. Look at that one guy on got talent when they fucked him over for being "too cocky" then made him strip down and hated it and basically got him to leave. I have basically no respect to any of the coaches or judges on these shows cause they're complacent in screwing people over
That's a fair point. I wish I knew how scripted these things were- I feel like the judges ahead of time have a few notes and recommendations from the production team to spice things up. I know I have personally had a friend who I think has a great voice- probably wouldn't win but he had a good chance of getting through with the right song. However, the producers had him sing a different song and also encouraged him to exaggerate certain vocal quirks. He ended up just sounding weird during the TV audition stage after following the advice of the production crew. It's like the show will go out of its way sometimes to create drama and controversy where there is none to be found. Instead of trying to make singers look their best and set them up for success, they intentionally push people to look bad for the sake of drama. I guess it can be entertaining but I can't help but think that a show that focused on the realities of being a singer would be more unique and interesting, especially with celeb coaches.
Katy Perry needs to be very careful with words like “throw your life away” bc if someone is maybe not super well and they audition and don’t make it; well, that’s a slippery slope. Words can be very powerful.
Katy Perry can say whatever she wants and would have zero responsability if that was to happen. Grown people make their own choices. Victim hood mentality in its finest smh...
@@polbzh Don't defend her for being an idiot. Katy is the last person to take advice from, she only says stupid things. In this competition, she's a COACH and a JUDGE, meaning that her words have power to the contestants and you have a responsibility to judge fairly and give appropriate and good advice. Otherwise you have failed at your job and deserve to be criticized/fired
Katy has definitely made weird comments on American Idol for sure. The comment about being on her back too much was utterly unnecessary. Just think before you speak.
I think laughing along with Katy Perry was a protective mechanism, but once she had time to think about it, she knew how incredibly rude and inappropriate Katy was. It’s like when someone makes a joke about you and everyone laugh, you automatically laugh too, because what’s the alternative? Call them out and make the situation even worse? I think those judges should all be ashamed of themselves for laughing at her expense. Shame on them.
Honestly, sometimes you don't even realise someone has been rude to you until after the fact. It's like, you walk away and you're just like... wait a second. Wtf?
@@the.office.alliance4736 YES 👍 I hate that and when you realize it you then start thinking of all the comebacks you could have said drives me crazy when that happens .
I completely agree with the idea that Katy was jealous of her. If anyone was a Katy fan in the 2000s/2010s you remember her being very 'quirky' and 'bubbly' just like this girl she acted annoyed with. Now there's a younger girl with the fun personality but a better voice standing in front of her and she's definitely threatened by it because she fell off
@@rayantoutcourt4134 she’s definitely not popping off the same way she used to though. She was a much bigger deal during the one of the boys/teenage dream era than she is today. I understand she has a family now and is focused on other things but her popularity has been on the decline and she’s never been a powerhouse vocalist.
this girl gotta believe in herself more !! she was so scared to sing her originally chosen song but when she actually went for it like WOW okay !! she is SO SO SO GOODDDD
She said she was rethinking her original song, after Katie perry made fun of her, and for her being a mother, none the less, Katie perry acted jealous, that's all you can get from her treatment of that woman. I think she thought that women is a traditional christian, who wanted children young, and now wants to live her other dream of being a singer, and Katie Perry wanted to break her will down, and make her feel less than, just because she was a young mother,who also just happened to be married
@@zoebella314 yeah it was definitely something goin on in katy’s head… glad i don’t really care for her or stan her even tho all my friends want me to 😴
As a mom of a young child I absolutely absolutely understood her as soon as she was baffled by the question. She couldn’t win no matter how she answered that. I have dreams for my life but once I had a son, my dreams had to evolve because his dreams are so much more important to me. If I’m choosing between my kids and singing career, I’m choosing my kid 100% of the time. I love Sara Beth and can’t wait to support her elsewhere!
You sounded fine. Katy was just outta pocket. When someone like Lionel freakin Ritchie is being that kind about your performance, you know you're doing something right.
You have a powerful voice and don't let this stop you. You have a natural talent that Katy doesn't have like many others. You have the personality to go far. Stay strong and keep singing.
There's many women who had children and still toured, and rocked just as hard as any single women, or men. They all made fun of her, except Lionel, he just laughed uncomfortably at Katie perry, trying to get her to move on, but she didn't she wanted to hurt that women's feeling's and run her off, crying, she wanted it. It's like she would've been happier if that women would've said she had 3 abortions, so she could live her dream, that's what Katie perry wanted, entertainers are really getting disgusting
abortion?! 21st century, use condom for GOD's sake! Oh, but there is no god, so let's kill children, right?! You don't have to have 3 children before you are 20! it's not that you are not going to live your fucking dream, it's about those children- they won't be able to live their dreams ever, because you are not raising them properly, trust me , - you are not! USE CONDOM, you fucking restroom whore! And not to remember who your children's fathers are, is not cool and not liberal! Or, no... it's very liberal!
Firstly, I absolutely love Sara Beth’s voice. She has such an awesome tone, and sung both song’s incredibly well… I absolutely love her laid back relaxed style. She is one of those few people who can do all these cool things with their voice and make it appear effortless. Secondly, Sara Beth isn’t the only contestant that Katy Perry continuously encouraged to yell the song!! Why? We keep wondering why on earth she thinks people need to yell the lyrics. Super bizarre! I personally love the soft delicate parts of a song in contrast with belting and power. I just keep imagining people like Whitney Houston or Billie Eilish going on and Katy Perry telling them to “push, push, that’s not enough” during the soft moments… Lol!! Terrible coaching!
The guilt trip for talented and skilled singers who aren't necessarily Hungry™️ for the title has always baffled me... Katy isn't the first to do this, it's such a strange thing to do
I think I kind of get it. Like In art school if you were a good artist the teachers would be very brutal on critiques and push you really hard. but if you weren’t very good it would seem they were ‘nicer’ cuz they wouldn’t say much cuz they know you reached your limit. So I think for the judges is like she’s naturally talented and they want to push her to her best ability because they know she has it in her. 🤷♂️
@@anasdomain9994 That makes sense, and I actually think u may be right! I've noticed that sorta vibe as well. I just wish they would outright say, "Hey, I can see potential in you, and I want to see you push yourself because I know you can" instead of playing those mind games with the contestants :/
It's basically just saying, "You have to want this so bad that we get to micromanage your life just for the unlikely chance that it will ever be worth it and you only have yourself to blame when we leave your life shattered in pieces with nothing to show for it."
I was a young mum too, had 3 kids by my mid 20s and if anybody said this to me I would be really insulted and it probably would have knocked what little confidence I had left
Katy Perry was beyond rude! This poor girl. She sounded amazing despite not feeling 100% and I’ve seen far worse people on this show get praised for mediocrity because they “look” like an idol. Glad I don’t watch Idol anymore.
I saw this audition before seeing your video... and I remember feeling uncomfortable and mad that she was treated that way. She was all 😅😅😅... insulted but smiling, on some level I just wanted her to tell Katy to f*off.
To be honest I think Katy was probably annoyed by her bubbly personality, and that's more obvious given she said yes to her voice. Not saying it was right, just sharing my opinion.
the table comment 😭 if everyone is ok with that joke then it’s ok but i feel like you should tread carefully over jokes if you don’t really know someone well. once you get to know someone it’s different yk but it’s like you don’t even know her dawg 😭
I remember watching American Idol when I was a kid and the whole concept was like “it’s your dream to be a singer, it’s everything you want, and this is your chance to make it big, so push your limits”. So it’s not really out of pocket to talk a lot about this being a dream. I swear I remember back in the day contestants got sick and forced themselves through the pain to perform. It was wild. Also, I think Katy always dreamed to be a singer so I think it’s hard for her to wrap her mind around someone having kids first and then maybe doing singing later. I guess all Katy’s statements make sense, but She seems to not open up her mind to other peoples experiences that are different than hers. And people in the industry reallly need to start respecting people’s boundaries and safety. Also her comments while she was singing made me so mad. I would have just stopped singing and walked out💀
this is why the voice is the only voice competition show i like- and yes im aware that ones very scripted too but its so much more just about raw vocal talent than the contestants/judges personality and drama
@@tristanparedes omg yes! I've gotten legit good vocal advice from some seasons that I actually use when im singing, just from watching what the coaches tell the singers
It’s not as scripted as you’d think if much at all. I got to watch my sister’s audition a couple years ago and from the recorded shows to the live shows. It’s just how everyone interacts with each other.
Sara is awesome! I hate how the judges assume that she isn’t taking the experience “seriously”. Like have they ever heard of something called being nervous? She’s like singing in front of celebrities AND on national tv! And Katy was hella rude and her comments were def unprofessional and inappropriate! 🙄
I don’t understand why people are riding so hard for defending Katy, like yes she’s human and can be rude but if she’s rude than that’s what she was, Tristan wasn’t full on hating her, he clearly thought it was out of pocket to treat another person like this and even if it was a joke, like it doesn’t come off that way to a lot of people, and if Katy can be critical to the contestant then people can be critical to her, none of this affects her, she’s rich and successful like chill yall Tristan isn’t hating her on this vid
I hated how Katy treated her. Did Katy apologize? She always try’s to make the show about her. I recently read that she announced that she 6 weeks sober. Didn’t see that coming but good for her.
I really love your reactions to auditions so we can hear from your professional output about how they really sound and how they project the sound in their own way
I don't think Katy is particularly nice😅 She's not a good judge. To interrupt someone while they're performing, just to say "not enough"? The way she "coaches" the contestant is the way she sings herself: She's screaming above anything else.
I see what you’re saying but remember it’s a show. There’s ways it’s edited, there’s ways they are told to do certain things by the producers.. also the industry isn’t nice. Be prepared or gtfo ya know?
Why do people think the industry "not being nice" is a good reason to be rude to people? It's not even particularly true to begin with as there are good and bad people in every industry. Not to mention that American Idol doesn't even produce stars anymore, so it's not even apart of "the industry" you're addressing. Being rude because other people you know are also rude isn't really a great argument.
@@tristanparedes I actually never said that it’s okay to not be nice. And yes there is absolutely good and bad in every industry. But pretending that Hollywood is the same as any other industry would be wrong as well. It’s absolutely not.
@@nicolefrances.cWhen Lionel Ritchie, someone with infinitely more talent and experience in the industry than Katy Perry, isn't being an asshole like she is, your point is utterly moot
@@nicolefrances.c no one said Hollywood is the “same” as every other industry? That doesn’t excuse being rude lmao especially a big artist such as Katy Perry who’s career isn’t on the line so she isn’t obligated to follow a “script” for her personality presentation to others
Tori Kelly is actually sorta a family friend and she's such a sweet person with such a great singing voice. I'm so glad she was able to be as successful as she is in her singing career without American Idol. They would've held her back.
It makes me feel so sad that motherhood has been painted in a negative light by do many within pop-culture. Motherhood isn't for everyone, but it is wonderful, it is hard, it is unglamorous many times, it is precious, it is a sacrifice, and it has brought me a level of joy that is indescribable.
Katy was so annoying and rude, but it seemed like none of them really cared about her talent, didn't ask why she could't sing the other song first ans jut kept pushing her to do so, and didn´t even give her any advise that could help her. All that talk about that "being the dream" was so unnecesary and the way Katy said yes at the end like not really wanting to give her a chance but did it anyway, I felt so bad for Sara. Also, I hate that Katy kept interrupting her singing. I'm not a singer but I like to sing karaoke by myself at home sometimes and my dad would interrumpt me when I was singing, even if it was something positive, it would make me lose focus and remember I wasn't really alone (I'm very shy) and it would make me very angry and stop doing it.
you are so right, and im thankful you are speaking your mind especially in a time like this where these judges a lot of times gets to be too much on tv
Bro her voice was so good : o I hope she saw your reaction or other positivity And it doesn't need to be "her dream" to "lay down her life"! She can literally sing to have fun and want to share it with people and be a mom
I don’t watch the show anymore but I do watch Clark Beckham’s youtube channel (he was the runner up on season 14, in 20115). He does reactions to the auditions and performances and gives little behind the scenes tid bits. He’s still a believer in the show because of what it can do for aspiring singers but he’s also very frank about the nature of the process. Anyhow …. Ya, there’s constant debate on his channel about Katy as a judge. She does seem to be hard on a lot of the young, cute women who audition while giving the cute young men every bit of leeway possible. It’s kinda weird to watch. Sometimes she’s the sweetest, warmest person in the room and the next minute she’s making these sorts of comments and you’re just left going, “Wtf? Why did they even air this?”. I guess they need to keep a bit of that Simon Cowell energy alive 🤷♀️. Not great, though.
Also a major part of the new American idol is that the judges are looking for some who can be a star not just a singer, they want an artist who can sing, play and instrument and or be a songwriter. It’s no longer about just being a pretty singer
the vibe has changed A LOT - by the way, on the latest show this week on tv they literally said that they are looking for special people like themselves - they said it’s not about the singing !!!
I saw this before and Katy Perry is clearly trying to make this poor woman run away from her…. She is so rude and abrasive. She is acting like a total bully, and the only reason I can think of is maybe she is jealous of this young, beautiful, talented, happy, mother. Her behavior is just gross and I hope she apologizes to this young woman.
I Had the exact same response as you !!!! they can be so annoying ! i would love to see you react to all the other videos by the way i commented on that video that she didn’t need to try harder cause it’s so natural for her (the screaming was because katy told her to tell) yes you are right katy’s dumb sometimes
Tristan, I know you probably won’t see this, but watching you be so sweet and concerned for Sara really healed something in me. I used to watch American Idol as a teenager, and though I loved to sing at the time (and had for my whole childhood), watching how mean the judges were to the contestants made me feel like I should never sing again because I didn’t want to be a subject of ridicule. Also, the thing you said about a sign of damage being that your throat will feel itchy or painful is so helpful. Thank you for being your kind self and sticking up for this clearly very talented woman. (Not to mention you’re proof that people can be funny and entertaining when listening to singing without being mean, which I love!)
Katy was really weird .. sara has incredible voice and can sing Benny and the jets incredible..I also love her spunky personality and seemed really happy and perky naturally.. and she's down to earth ..cool vibe to her .. Lionel shouldn't say no.. cause sara was real ..her love for music is genuine .. only Luke was amazing
Oh man! I've got the chills! Her voice is amazing! I can see why she was nervous to sing her 1st choice song, but FLAWLESS nonetheless. Katy is scared she's getting old and one day irrelevant herself if she keeps going. This isn't close to the first time I've seen her say something inappropriate inappropriate to a contestant or fan! Quite annoying
Wether it’s her dream or not doesn’t really matter because she has the voice. Thousands of people have tried out and said it was their dream but couldn’t even hold a note. Does that mean they should make it through just off that? We all have dreams but not all our dreams come true.
This is very much giving Post Malone being interviewed by Charlamagne the God vibes. I hope she makes it big like Posty and continues to be kind to those who weren't as gracious. I absolutely love her voice 💚
Let's just be honest. If it were a man behaving like that as a judge on the show. They would probably not be a judge anymore and more than half of the rude comments would just not pass!
I’m sorry but this is bullshit. Simon Cowell is almost always rude and is KNOWN of being rude yet he’s the most famous judge out there and has been a judge for multiple shows. Quit it with this “gender reverse” bullshit
I think if you don't like how you are treated, you have to tell it right away no matter if you're on a show or it's a celebrity that is commenting on you, cause the other person also has to be aware that their behavior is not appropriate to learn not to do it potentionally otherwise they'll never change.
Tristan, I am wondering if you could react to Blindboymusic’s (Murphy’s) audition. He’s a very unconventional singer and it would be interesting seeing how you would react to a unique singer like that. Also, Katy Perry didn’t like his performance because it wasn’t “mainstream” enough🙄
They edit out a-lot so when they say she needs to invest fully and you say you don’t understand why they are saying that to her bc she didn’t once show she was not showing that… it baffles me lol. It’s all edited and she probably said so much more during that audition that made them skeptical.
ive literally auditioned so many times and im no super amazing glorious singer but the number of times someone has performed and someone says " how did they make it and you didnt?" to me is just mind blowing that show is a joke forreal
You can do a thousand things well but only one will be enough for the world to hate you. Katy is an excellent human being and before criticizing someone so much, remember that she is a human being who feels and suffers. I hope all of you are perfect and so you can judge others!! (Someone with a straw tail shouldn't come near fire) .
Kat is said to drink a lot ..… her comments are not kind but degrading thank you for your show you are the one who is a caring and thoughtful man … I agree with you. She is a great musician. Love your program That girl has a style all of her own, its a very unique voice…
She seems like the sweetest person ever! Also really thought the rasp and growl sounded fantastic in her audition, but yeah that’s exactly how Kurt Cobain damaged his vocal cords… P.S. Why is American Idol still being made? Time to let it go to rest.
I agree that Katy had unnecessary points, but I really believe she was trying to make the girl give her best and be confident… As a judge she will never say, its ok if youre unsure about being a singer! I hope ppl understand her side and that she’s able of having mistakes too, I just wish her positive comments like the empathy she had to the guy that was victim of a school shooting have had so much impact and went viral like the negative ones.
Well, to play devil's advocate here, wasn't she the same person who decided to leave the show for her children? As much as I respect that decision and her love and care for her kids, the "dream" argument is very valid here in my opinion. Regardless of her experience on the show, I'm glad she got the exposure she needed to kickstart her music career. I hope she's able to manage both parenthood and music simultaneously. 🖤
I get what katy perry is doing. She’s giving that tough talk to her because that’s how the industry is and maybe she saw this girl is super innocent and wants to see if she can even handle BUT you have to give people a chance… if they go into it thinking they can’t do it they won’t do it. But if they go into thinking they can do it they will give it there best shot and give their all.. let them find out how the industry is themselves
Check out Sara Beth's music here: open.spotify.com/artist/4ikrWdvs3CdWAz3IZmi17r?si=FogGuKCbRP6apyJblXd3nQ
The thing is, she has no sob story or relatablility for the show to leech off of. She's a confident singer. The show shuns that and every other show does as well. Look at that one guy on got talent when they fucked him over for being "too cocky" then made him strip down and hated it and basically got him to leave. I have basically no respect to any of the coaches or judges on these shows cause they're complacent in screwing people over
That's a fair point. I wish I knew how scripted these things were- I feel like the judges ahead of time have a few notes and recommendations from the production team to spice things up. I know I have personally had a friend who I think has a great voice- probably wouldn't win but he had a good chance of getting through with the right song. However, the producers had him sing a different song and also encouraged him to exaggerate certain vocal quirks. He ended up just sounding weird during the TV audition stage after following the advice of the production crew.
It's like the show will go out of its way sometimes to create drama and controversy where there is none to be found. Instead of trying to make singers look their best and set them up for success, they intentionally push people to look bad for the sake of drama. I guess it can be entertaining but I can't help but think that a show that focused on the realities of being a singer would be more unique and interesting, especially with celeb coaches.
@@tristanparedes Yeah... you really can't even put your trust in these shady singing shows anymore smh
Katy was complete trash for this and I'll never forgive her for it. Period
couldn't have put it better
Katy Perry needs to be very careful with words like “throw your life away” bc if someone is maybe not super well and they audition and don’t make it; well, that’s a slippery slope. Words can be very powerful.
So true
Katy Perry can say whatever she wants and would have zero responsability if that was to happen. Grown people make their own choices. Victim hood mentality in its finest smh...
@@polbzh Don't defend her for being an idiot. Katy is the last person to take advice from, she only says stupid things. In this competition, she's a COACH and a JUDGE, meaning that her words have power to the contestants and you have a responsibility to judge fairly and give appropriate and good advice. Otherwise you have failed at your job and deserve to be criticized/fired
Katy has definitely made weird comments on American Idol for sure. The comment about being on her back too much was utterly unnecessary. Just think before you speak.
She's plain rude and self absorbed.
Yeah that was not banter or being witty but just plain rude
Especially when she has kids who are watching on tv
She has been saying so much garbage shit to people as long as she’s had a career. I don’t understand why people like her!
It was slut shaming & mom shaming and it was disgusting. Katy is a terrible person
I think laughing along with Katy Perry was a protective mechanism, but once she had time to think about it, she knew how incredibly rude and inappropriate Katy was. It’s like when someone makes a joke about you and everyone laugh, you automatically laugh too, because what’s the alternative? Call them out and make the situation even worse?
I think those judges should all be ashamed of themselves for laughing at her expense. Shame on them.
Honestly, sometimes you don't even realise someone has been rude to you until after the fact. It's like, you walk away and you're just like... wait a second. Wtf?
What's crazy is that Katy only did what she did to get the girls confidence up and everyone apparently is mad at her for it
To big for her her own mind Perry !
@@the.office.alliance4736 YES 👍 I hate that and when you realize it you then start thinking of all the comebacks you could have said drives me crazy when that happens .
@@whalewolf7477 she did it because she’s a bully . That wasn’t help those were put downs . Perry just isn’t ! But we all have our opinions.
Also I have an original song out and am releasing another next week if anyone wants to listen to me wail a little less aggressively haha 😂🙂😬
so excited to check that out I love your voice!
Did they ask whats wrong with your Voice at all? or was it just edited out
Girl you are so talented!! And you seem like a lovely human being. Don't let the mean (and untrue) comments get to you, stay confident! ❤️✨
I loved your voice - you are amazing!
You have a unique and beautiful voice! I hope you go far in the music biz.
I completely agree with the idea that Katy was jealous of her. If anyone was a Katy fan in the 2000s/2010s you remember her being very 'quirky' and 'bubbly' just like this girl she acted annoyed with. Now there's a younger girl with the fun personality but a better voice standing in front of her and she's definitely threatened by it because she fell off
This is really not it ! Katy is still that b I mean she literally has sold out residency in Vegas lol and an average 10M streams daily
@@rayantoutcourt4134 she’s definitely not popping off the same way she used to though. She was a much bigger deal during the one of the boys/teenage dream era than she is today. I understand she has a family now and is focused on other things but her popularity has been on the decline and she’s never been a powerhouse vocalist.
I completely agree she sounded jealous. Also sometimes jealousy isn’t even rational
@@rayantoutcourt4134residency is only for people who fell off
Simon Cowell is under the table passing Katy notes 📄🤏🤫
😂😂
I think even Simon Cowell would’ve had more tact.
Simon wouldn't have said anything like this.
Maybe back in his American Idol days he would have but he's softened up so much. He's still honest but not mean or rude.
PLSSS😂😭🤚
this girl gotta believe in herself more !! she was so scared to sing her originally chosen song but when she actually went for it like WOW okay !! she is SO SO SO GOODDDD
ik she didn’t feel good but like wow i really hope she can recognize she sounded amazing
She said she was rethinking her original song, after Katie perry made fun of her, and for her being a mother, none the less, Katie perry acted jealous, that's all you can get from her treatment of that woman. I think she thought that women is a traditional christian, who wanted children young, and now wants to live her other dream of being a singer, and Katie Perry wanted to break her will down, and make her feel less than, just because she was a young mother,who also just happened to be married
@@zoebella314 yeah it was definitely something goin on in katy’s head… glad i don’t really care for her or stan her even tho all my friends want me to 😴
@@zoebella314 what does being a Christian have to do with this..?
She said she didn’t want to sing her original song because she had strained her voice.
As a mom of a young child I absolutely absolutely understood her as soon as she was baffled by the question. She couldn’t win no matter how she answered that.
I have dreams for my life but once I had a son, my dreams had to evolve because his dreams are so much more important to me. If I’m choosing between my kids and singing career, I’m choosing my kid 100% of the time.
I love Sara Beth and can’t wait to support her elsewhere!
I would have thought that Katy as a mother would have been kinder to Sara Beth.
@@ashleydowney1222 honestly dude. Her poor kid.
At this point, American Idol may as well have a written plot and it's NOT SINGING or musicianship that's for sure😭😭
They automatically assumed she wasn’t taking it seriously because she has children. That’s the true mom shaming in all this. Katy’s gross.
Exactly. I never really liked her, and her singing is overrated, in my opinion. She has no right to shame anyone, especially a hard-working mother.
Lots of other contestants that won and contestants that made it to the finals were parents
Also it doesn’t normally tickle or hurt but just that day my voice was GONE
You sounded fine. Katy was just outta pocket. When someone like Lionel freakin Ritchie is being that kind about your performance, you know you're doing something right.
Your voice wasn't gone you have an amazing unique voice, I wish I sounded half as good as you. If that is your voice gone...well damn lol.
Your tik tok and the audition were so different, but they were both AMAZING
I agree your voice is awesome. Katy was just really out of pocket that audition and I don’t really know why
You have a powerful voice and don't let this stop you. You have a natural talent that Katy doesn't have like many others. You have the personality to go far. Stay strong and keep singing.
There's many women who had children and still toured, and rocked just as hard as any single women, or men. They all made fun of her, except Lionel, he just laughed uncomfortably at Katie perry, trying to get her to move on, but she didn't she wanted to hurt that women's feeling's and run her off, crying, she wanted it. It's like she would've been happier if that women would've said she had 3 abortions, so she could live her dream, that's what Katie perry wanted, entertainers are really getting disgusting
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
You're absolutely right! It's disgusting!
Yessss P!nk for example, tours with her kids on tour with her! It IS possible.
abortion?! 21st century, use condom for GOD's sake! Oh, but there is no god, so let's kill children, right?! You don't have to have 3 children before you are 20! it's not that you are not going to live your fucking dream, it's about those children- they won't be able to live their dreams ever, because you are not raising them properly, trust me , - you are not! USE CONDOM, you fucking restroom whore! And not to remember who your children's fathers are, is not cool and not liberal! Or, no... it's very liberal!
Katie’s voice is so shrill.
And that's the real katy perry in a nutshell
Firstly, I absolutely love Sara Beth’s voice. She has such an awesome tone, and sung both song’s incredibly well… I absolutely love her laid back relaxed style. She is one of those few people who can do all these cool things with their voice and make it appear effortless. Secondly, Sara Beth isn’t the only contestant that Katy Perry continuously encouraged to yell the song!! Why? We keep wondering why on earth she thinks people need to yell the lyrics. Super bizarre! I personally love the soft delicate parts of a song in contrast with belting and power. I just keep imagining people like Whitney Houston or Billie Eilish going on and Katy Perry telling them to “push, push, that’s not enough” during the soft moments… Lol!! Terrible coaching!
Exactly!!
The guilt trip for talented and skilled singers who aren't necessarily Hungry™️ for the title has always baffled me... Katy isn't the first to do this, it's such a strange thing to do
I think I kind of get it. Like In art school if you were a good artist the teachers would be very brutal on critiques and push you really hard. but if you weren’t very good it would seem they were ‘nicer’ cuz they wouldn’t say much cuz they know you reached your limit. So I think for the judges is like she’s naturally talented and they want to push her to her best ability because they know she has it in her. 🤷♂️
@@anasdomain9994 That makes sense, and I actually think u may be right! I've noticed that sorta vibe as well. I just wish they would outright say, "Hey, I can see potential in you, and I want to see you push yourself because I know you can" instead of playing those mind games with the contestants :/
It's basically just saying, "You have to want this so bad that we get to micromanage your life just for the unlikely chance that it will ever be worth it and you only have yourself to blame when we leave your life shattered in pieces with nothing to show for it."
I was a young mum too, had 3 kids by my mid 20s and if anybody said this to me I would be really insulted and it probably would have knocked what little confidence I had left
Katy Perry was beyond rude! This poor girl. She sounded amazing despite not feeling 100% and I’ve seen far worse people on this show get praised for mediocrity because they “look” like an idol. Glad I don’t watch Idol anymore.
I saw this audition before seeing your video... and I remember feeling uncomfortable and mad that she was treated that way. She was all 😅😅😅... insulted but smiling, on some level I just wanted her to tell Katy to f*off.
Spot on, Tristan. You would be a great coach for this singer. You seem like you would bring out the best in her already amazing voice.
To be honest I think Katy was probably annoyed by her bubbly personality, and that's more obvious given she said yes to her voice. Not saying it was right, just sharing my opinion.
the table comment 😭 if everyone is ok with that joke then it’s ok but i feel like you should tread carefully over jokes if you don’t really know someone well. once you get to know someone it’s different yk but it’s like you don’t even know her dawg 😭
Oh my goodness it’s me! And you! I’ve watched your videos for FOREVER. 🤍😩
You’re a queen! Love your style and voice
OMG WAIT YOU'RE ON UA-cam TOO??????? i love you and your style so much, you're so awesome!!!!! :DDD
Love your voice girl! And you seem like an awesome and positive person. Much love 💗
I remember watching American Idol when I was a kid and the whole concept was like “it’s your dream to be a singer, it’s everything you want, and this is your chance to make it big, so push your limits”. So it’s not really out of pocket to talk a lot about this being a dream. I swear I remember back in the day contestants got sick and forced themselves through the pain to perform. It was wild. Also, I think Katy always dreamed to be a singer so I think it’s hard for her to wrap her mind around someone having kids first and then maybe doing singing later. I guess all Katy’s statements make sense, but She seems to not open up her mind to other peoples experiences that are different than hers. And people in the industry reallly need to start respecting people’s boundaries and safety.
Also her comments while she was singing made me so mad. I would have just stopped singing and walked out💀
I love how positive you are about singing being “someone’s dream”
Keep pumping out positivity Tristan! This is awesome !! 💜💜💜
She’s fun to watch, I bet she’s even more fun without Katy heckling her.
this is why the voice is the only voice competition show i like- and yes im aware that ones very scripted too but its so much more just about raw vocal talent than the contestants/judges personality and drama
The judges are def way more professional and seem to really help the contestants
@@tristanparedes omg yes! I've gotten legit good vocal advice from some seasons that I actually use when im singing, just from watching what the coaches tell the singers
It’s not as scripted as you’d think if much at all. I got to watch my sister’s audition a couple years ago and from the recorded shows to the live shows. It’s just how everyone interacts with each other.
@@MrNumber1ukfan ooh that's so cool! it's my favorite show so it's nice to know it's not scripted
Sara is awesome! I hate how the judges assume that she isn’t taking the experience “seriously”. Like have they ever heard of something called being nervous? She’s like singing in front of celebrities AND on national tv! And Katy was hella rude and her comments were def unprofessional and inappropriate! 🙄
I don’t understand why people are riding so hard for defending Katy, like yes she’s human and can be rude but if she’s rude than that’s what she was, Tristan wasn’t full on hating her, he clearly thought it was out of pocket to treat another person like this and even if it was a joke, like it doesn’t come off that way to a lot of people, and if Katy can be critical to the contestant then people can be critical to her, none of this affects her, she’s rich and successful like chill yall Tristan isn’t hating her on this vid
Wow, she's a wonderful singer! I love her tone, the way she carries notes & her beautiful, magnetic smile :) Great singer.
I hated how Katy treated her. Did Katy apologize? She always try’s to make the show about her.
I recently read that she announced that she 6 weeks sober. Didn’t see that coming but good for her.
I really hope she apologizes
she's probably experiencing withdrawal that's why she's cranky 😭😭
I really love your reactions to auditions so we can hear from your professional output about how they really sound and how they project the sound in their own way
I don't think Katy is particularly nice😅 She's not a good judge. To interrupt someone while they're performing, just to say "not enough"? The way she "coaches" the contestant is the way she sings herself: She's screaming above anything else.
I see what you’re saying but remember it’s a show. There’s ways it’s edited, there’s ways they are told to do certain things by the producers.. also the industry isn’t nice. Be prepared or gtfo ya know?
Why do people think the industry "not being nice" is a good reason to be rude to people? It's not even particularly true to begin with as there are good and bad people in every industry. Not to mention that American Idol doesn't even produce stars anymore, so it's not even apart of "the industry" you're addressing. Being rude because other people you know are also rude isn't really a great argument.
@@tristanparedes I actually never said that it’s okay to not be nice. And yes there is absolutely good and bad in every industry. But pretending that Hollywood is the same as any other industry would be wrong as well. It’s absolutely not.
@@nicolefrances.cWhen Lionel Ritchie, someone with infinitely more talent and experience in the industry than Katy Perry, isn't being an asshole like she is, your point is utterly moot
@@nicolefrances.c no one said Hollywood is the “same” as every other industry? That doesn’t excuse being rude lmao especially a big artist such as Katy Perry who’s career isn’t on the line so she isn’t obligated to follow a “script” for her personality presentation to others
Tori Kelly is actually sorta a family friend and she's such a sweet person with such a great singing voice. I'm so glad she was able to be as successful as she is in her singing career without American Idol. They would've held her back.
Katy...why don't you sing Firework live...👀🥱🤣🤣
she sung it on the president inguation maybe go and watch it d6bass
that comment about being on her back too much seemed so weird and sexist to me.. just icky
I appreciate you being so caring with her ^^ You should be an American Idol judge 😅
I think she’s a better singer than Katy Perry to be honest…. She’s a mom, I can see why being a singer isn’t totally her ‘dream’
Be fr, she is not better than katy. She good
Katy Perry is an entertainer but she is just an average singer at best.
Just stop kidding !! Katy Perry is vocally better
Dont be ridiculous
Yeah I’d be pissed if Katy said that to me.
Dude, this was great! I'm so glad you reviewed this and spoke the truth, for real.
Nobody:
Katy: HOLD IT OUT THOUGH
😂😂😂😂 I’m 💀
It makes me feel so sad that motherhood has been painted in a negative light by do many within pop-culture. Motherhood isn't for everyone, but it is wonderful, it is hard, it is unglamorous many times, it is precious, it is a sacrifice, and it has brought me a level of joy that is indescribable.
Her voice is so good!
Yesss please do the Tori Kelly audition. Her voice is amazing
Agreed!! Simon was awful to her on her audition
Love how people are commenting without watching the video first 😂
She performed so well 🎶🎶🎶🎶 those comments are omg 😳
Bruh, mad respect for keeping as cool as a cucumber. I want the full cover.
Katy was so annoying and rude, but it seemed like none of them really cared about her talent, didn't ask why she could't sing the other song first ans jut kept pushing her to do so, and didn´t even give her any advise that could help her. All that talk about that "being the dream" was so unnecesary and the way Katy said yes at the end like not really wanting to give her a chance but did it anyway, I felt so bad for Sara.
Also, I hate that Katy kept interrupting her singing. I'm not a singer but I like to sing karaoke by myself at home sometimes and my dad would interrumpt me when I was singing, even if it was something positive, it would make me lose focus and remember I wasn't really alone (I'm very shy) and it would make me very angry and stop doing it.
I get jealousy vibes from Katy sometimes. This one seems to be to the extreme. Sara’s voice is so beautiful and unique!
you are so right, and im thankful you are speaking your mind especially in a time like this where these judges a lot of times gets to be too much on tv
Bro her voice was so good : o I hope she saw your reaction or other positivity
And it doesn't need to be "her dream" to "lay down her life"! She can literally sing to have fun and want to share it with people and be a mom
Tristan - she’s yelling the line Benny too loud because katy told her to yell
I loved her performance!! Katy needs to experiment with letting others shine and taking a step back 👌
I don’t watch the show anymore but I do watch Clark Beckham’s youtube channel (he was the runner up on season 14, in 20115). He does reactions to the auditions and performances and gives little behind the scenes tid bits. He’s still a believer in the show because of what it can do for aspiring singers but he’s also very frank about the nature of the process. Anyhow …. Ya, there’s constant debate on his channel about Katy as a judge. She does seem to be hard on a lot of the young, cute women who audition while giving the cute young men every bit of leeway possible. It’s kinda weird to watch. Sometimes she’s the sweetest, warmest person in the room and the next minute she’s making these sorts of comments and you’re just left going, “Wtf? Why did they even air this?”. I guess they need to keep a bit of that Simon Cowell energy alive 🤷♀️. Not great, though.
She had me jamming and singing along as soon as she started singing amy, she's talented. She shoulda done valerie
sounds a lot like Katy is trying to get people to sell their souls like she did 😅
Katy definetly crossed the line
Also a major part of the new American idol is that the judges are looking for some who can be a star not just a singer, they want an artist who can sing, play and instrument and or be a songwriter. It’s no longer about just being a pretty singer
I love Katy so much, she’s always such a kind heart, grateful and light person, i think it is a plot..
A great audition you should watch is Alejandro Aranda. Its so cool to see how stunned the judges were especially with the guitar playing
I love him!!
I think they do these things to make the show more popular for television views.
Bingo!
the vibe has changed A LOT - by the way, on the latest show this week on tv they literally said that they are looking for special people like themselves - they said it’s not about the singing !!!
I mean…I didn’t honestly expect much more from Katy, being real
don’t mind her she’s just off her meds today 😭
I saw this before and Katy Perry is clearly trying to make this poor woman run away from her…. She is so rude and abrasive. She is acting like a total bully, and the only reason I can think of is maybe she is jealous of this young, beautiful, talented, happy, mother. Her behavior is just gross and I hope she apologizes to this young woman.
I Had the exact same response as you !!!! they can be so annoying ! i would love to see you react to all the other videos
by the way i commented on that video that she didn’t need to try harder cause it’s so natural for her (the screaming was because katy told her to tell) yes you are right katy’s dumb sometimes
FINALLY !!! I would love to watch American Idol with you ❤
Tristan, I know you probably won’t see this, but watching you be so sweet and concerned for Sara really healed something in me. I used to watch American Idol as a teenager, and though I loved to sing at the time (and had for my whole childhood), watching how mean the judges were to the contestants made me feel like I should never sing again because I didn’t want to be a subject of ridicule. Also, the thing you said about a sign of damage being that your throat will feel itchy or painful is so helpful. Thank you for being your kind self and sticking up for this clearly very talented woman. (Not to mention you’re proof that people can be funny and entertaining when listening to singing without being mean, which I love!)
This is a good time to remind everyone of Katy earnestly asking if "math was related to science" for no other reason than to humble her.
Katy was really weird .. sara has incredible voice and can sing Benny and the jets incredible..I also love her spunky personality and seemed really happy and perky naturally.. and she's down to earth ..cool vibe to her .. Lionel shouldn't say no.. cause sara was real ..her love for music is genuine .. only Luke was amazing
Oh man! I've got the chills! Her voice is amazing! I can see why she was nervous to sing her 1st choice song, but FLAWLESS nonetheless. Katy is scared she's getting old and one day irrelevant herself if she keeps going. This isn't close to the first time I've seen her say something inappropriate inappropriate to a contestant or fan! Quite annoying
Do you like to hate on everyone huhh
Irrelevant okay honey 😂😂
Wtf her voice was amazing, lovely tone!
I would love to see you react to the best of and worst of with these shows that would be fun
Wether it’s her dream or not doesn’t really matter because she has the voice. Thousands of people have tried out and said it was their dream but couldn’t even hold a note. Does that mean they should make it through just off that? We all have dreams but not all our dreams come true.
This is very much giving Post Malone being interviewed by Charlamagne the God vibes. I hope she makes it big like Posty and continues to be kind to those who weren't as gracious. I absolutely love her voice 💚
Besides her singing Sara is just so damn likeable. Usually Katy is too but something was up that day.
I never understood why they made Katy a judge in the first place
Let's just be honest. If it were a man behaving like that as a judge on the show. They would probably not be a judge anymore and more than half of the rude comments would just not pass!
I’m sorry but this is bullshit. Simon Cowell is almost always rude and is KNOWN of being rude yet he’s the most famous judge out there and has been a judge for multiple shows. Quit it with this “gender reverse” bullshit
Simon Cowell did it for years and got away with it so I don't think so.
@@Heidaaaa he was rude sure but I've not seen him make inappropriate comments like I've seen katy do . Rest maybe if he did I'm not aware
The judges probably get assigned different lines to say for each contestant. They don’t care about embarrassing people as long as they earn a buck
I think if you don't like how you are treated, you have to tell it right away no matter if you're on a show or it's a celebrity that is commenting on you, cause the other person also has to be aware that their behavior is not appropriate to learn not to do it potentionally otherwise they'll never change.
'this show didn't make anyone successful in years' took me out. So true!
I love this! You should react to singing show auditions more often! This was so fun to watch
“The show hasn’t produced any stars in recent seasons” - Gabby Barret and Catie Turner are right there
Who?
God I love these reactions, and your videos as well!!
Tristan, I am wondering if you could react to Blindboymusic’s (Murphy’s) audition. He’s a very unconventional singer and it would be interesting seeing how you would react to a unique singer like that. Also, Katy Perry didn’t like his performance because it wasn’t “mainstream” enough🙄
@@bludbrat I remember being in the Reddit and seeing the tweets of literal PROTESTS😭😭😭
WORST mistake taking him off. I love him!!!
So, a woman who has children “laid on the table too much” … I forgot that this was an American idol 1935 edition . Katy Perry has a kid …
They edit out a-lot so when they say she needs to invest fully and you say you don’t understand why they are saying that to her bc she didn’t once show she was not showing that… it baffles me lol. It’s all edited and she probably said so much more during that audition that made them skeptical.
CAN YOU REACT TO JISOOS SOLO SOMG “FLOWER” FROM BLACKPINK ( and her side track too if u can)
ive literally auditioned so many times and im no super amazing glorious singer but the number of times someone has performed and someone says " how did they make it and you didnt?" to me is just mind blowing that show is a joke forreal
You can do a thousand things well but only one will be enough for the world to hate you. Katy is an excellent human being and before criticizing someone so much, remember that she is a human being who feels and suffers. I hope all of you are perfect and so you can judge others!! (Someone with a straw tail shouldn't come near fire) .
Kat is said to drink a lot ..…
her comments are not kind but degrading
thank you for your show you are the one who is a caring and thoughtful man …
I agree with you. She is a great musician.
Love your program
That girl has a style all of her own, its a very unique voice…
She seems like the sweetest person ever! Also really thought the rasp and growl sounded fantastic in her audition, but yeah that’s exactly how Kurt Cobain damaged his vocal cords…
P.S. Why is American Idol still being made? Time to let it go to rest.
I agree that Katy had unnecessary points, but I really believe she was trying to make the girl give her best and be confident… As a judge she will never say, its ok if youre unsure about being a singer! I hope ppl understand her side and that she’s able of having mistakes too, I just wish her positive comments like the empathy she had to the guy that was victim of a school shooting have had so much impact and went viral like the negative ones.
Well, to play devil's advocate here, wasn't she the same person who decided to leave the show for her children? As much as I respect that decision and her love and care for her kids, the "dream" argument is very valid here in my opinion.
Regardless of her experience on the show, I'm glad she got the exposure she needed to kickstart her music career. I hope she's able to manage both parenthood and music simultaneously. 🖤
She is ADORABLE!!! I love her
I get what katy perry is doing. She’s giving that tough talk to her because that’s how the industry is and maybe she saw this girl is super innocent and wants to see if she can even handle BUT you have to give people a chance… if they go into it thinking they can’t do it they won’t do it. But if they go into thinking they can do it they will give it there best shot and give their all.. let them find out how the industry is themselves
Love her voice👏👏👏
Love your reviews and reactions 🙌🙌
I’ve noticed you haven’t reacted to Sza’s new songs….. you’ll love her voice I promise. 👀
I love katy❤