Rod Stewart vs Jorgen Ben Jor (Tomando Notas)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 45

  • @atcasanova
    @atcasanova 12 років тому +78

    Stewart got sued and lost. Jorge Ben (the brazilian dude) settled the dispute amicably, asking Stewart to donate the profits from his song to UNICEF, and he agreed.
    This is the kind of man he is.

  • @zhivago295
    @zhivago295 10 років тому +39

    Jorge Ben is a very fine musician…Chove Chuva for example is a great song.

  • @vinicius813
    @vinicius813 7 років тому +18

    Cada país tem seus heróis, aqui crescemos ouvindo nossas musicas sempre em convívio com o enlatado que vem de fora e mesmo assim sabemos reconhecer a boa música seja daqui como do extrangeiro. Abaixem a guarda e reconhecem que o talento na música vem de todos os cantos do mundo, pois a música é uma linguagem universal. Neste caso Jorge Ben Jor contribuiu com outro artista mesmo sem ser de sua vontade e os colonialistas teimam em nunca reconhecer a riqueza de outras culturas, exploram nossas riquezas e ainda empinam o nariz dizendo que devemos ser gratos pelas migalhas jogadas em nosso quintal como se os seus "grandes" artistas do pop mainstream estivessem acima de qualquer outro estilo musical.

  • @pequeniodelascalles
    @pequeniodelascalles Рік тому +1

    Cada dia mais creu the la mandioca ¡¡que grande el negro!!

  • @cascam1
    @cascam1 2 роки тому +4

    Rod indeed plagiarized Ben's while visiting RIO for Carnival with Elton John. There is an Elton video interview whereby Elton throws Rod under the bus asserting that Rod "stole Do Ya Think I'm Sexy from Jorge Ben". Both JB and RS are amazing artists. The legal disputes settled and WE won because we love their music!

  • @recrolonezenilofaicren.3206
    @recrolonezenilofaicren.3206 3 роки тому +14

    Rapaz, é isso mesmo kkkkkkkk, plagiou a lenda Jorge Ben Jor, que orgulho kkkkkkkkkkkkkk, se bem que o Jorge Ben Jor também já era lenda por ter criado a "Mas Que Nada" (que tem uma fama internacional sem precedentes).

    • @dgsjrext282
      @dgsjrext282 2 роки тому

      Imo they don’t sound that similar just a little

    • @pedromavaz
      @pedromavaz 2 роки тому +2

      @@dgsjrext282 It can even be more, it's 8 bars

    • @pedromavaz
      @pedromavaz 2 роки тому +2

      @@dgsjrext282 And are similar

  • @recrolonezenilofaicren.3206
    @recrolonezenilofaicren.3206 3 роки тому +1

    Adorei o vídeo ❤❤❤

  • @zhivago295
    @zhivago295 10 років тому +15

    Shame on you Rod..went to Rio on vacation and stolen this song from Jorge Ben

  • @Juuxr
    @Juuxr 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you for posting this comparison here. It's important to show how americans and europeans actually stole another countries' songs and other artistic expressions and worst, it's they that are recognized as the creators

    • @Juuxr
      @Juuxr 2 роки тому

      (Being "Americans" were, the United States's, since that's how they call themselves)

    • @Redman_real
      @Redman_real Рік тому +1

      Rod never claimed he owned the famous melody once he was sued he admitted in court under oath that he heard in Brazil and later used in his song
      Also rod didn't copy an entire song he used a melody which I think sounds better when jorge does it but besides that point

  • @erosarthur4227
    @erosarthur4227 9 років тому +5

    GREGORIOUS TAJ MAHAL ITS THE ORIGINAL SONG

  • @ricomajestic
    @ricomajestic 8 років тому +3

    There are some similarities in the melodies but the phrases are distinct enough to be considered two different melodies.

    • @ricomajestic
      @ricomajestic 8 років тому +2

      Pablo Eklund He said it was "unconscious plagiarism" but I think he got bad legal advice when he settled out of court. There really is just one melodic phrase in the entire Jorgen Ben Jor song that sounds similar to a melodic phrase in the chorus of Rod Stewart's song! I've heard a lot worse copyright infringement than this. Led Zeppelin blatantly ripped off from a lot of lesser known artists and got away with it. Rod probably figured "that's what I get for writing a disco song" and since he was a multi-millionaire already he didn't care. Besides the royalties were donated to charity which is good!

    • @rexmundi2237
      @rexmundi2237 8 років тому +10

      total rubbish. Rod BOUGHT the single by Jorge Ben when he was touring Brazil with Elton John, recorded Do Ya Think I'm Sexy' soon after.. Elton's confirmed that and agreed it was pinched. The fact Stewart settled out of court which proves that he KNEW he was guilty of copyright infringement. Other than that, use ya fkin EARS man!

    • @l34ndr0am
      @l34ndr0am 6 років тому +4

      "Use ya fkin ears man", priceless.

    • @yoshivo3800
      @yoshivo3800 5 років тому

      I agree ☝🏻

  • @horizontesoberano
    @horizontesoberano 3 роки тому

    Hola, Nacho. Todo bien? Soy brasileño y tengo una sugestión: America - Thin man vs Seu Jorge Burguesinha. Gracias

  • @dariomachado5968
    @dariomachado5968 2 роки тому +1

    La verdad me parece un plagio muuuyyy rebuscado de rod hacia jorge. Pero jorge se parece a denzel washington. Podria reclamar eso tambien.

  • @juke1225
    @juke1225 3 роки тому

    Look at the bright side. Rod made the song better.

    • @thalesluan9679
      @thalesluan9679 3 роки тому +6

      Jorge ben jor é muito melhor

    • @eduardopessoa5788
      @eduardopessoa5788 3 роки тому +1

      no way

    • @Juuxr
      @Juuxr 2 роки тому +4

      Of course a song about "being sexy" is better than a song about the history behind the construction of a historical monument (Taj Mahal)!
      Guess some people didn't evolved right.

    • @czarnpg
      @czarnpg 2 роки тому

      i dont think so.

    • @llamadrama1090
      @llamadrama1090 2 роки тому

      thats because the version in this video isnt the full version