Nature is truly amazing! Every part of the ecosystem has its own unique role, and the connection between all living things, from plants to animals, creates a perfect cycle. These relationships not only sustain life but also bring about incredible things that we still can't fully understand 😃
That's why the older eternal religions like Hinduism talked about cycle of nature and respecting nature.. They had access to history and knowledge which we all slowly lost. Once the real next civilization downfall comes, we will slowly revert back to those religions 99.9% of our history is unknown. Humans have been here for 2 million years but history is only known for last 2000 years for most places. That's just .01% of history known
I used to work with a biologist in the PNW and he said an unfortunate consequence of certain stream restoration practices (like falling logs for better salmon habitat) was that all of these beds of freshwater muscles were being destroyed and neglected as key species who filter the water for salmon. So yes, Salmon are super important, but so much habitat can be damaged by tunnel vision. (I''m no expert, but thought I'd share an insight I heard.)
We may be managers of our little bubble of nature, but Nature will always be infinitely more than we can manage. Just how no one can fully control our Own Nature, aka no one can truly own us, we’ll never be able to fully control or own Nature. Never the less, the abilities of humanity and knowledge we have continues to blow my mind 🙏🏼
The point is we have an interconnected system with a relationship to every aspect of life established over eons. No one is talking about taking control or who is powerful or who dominates
That's why the older eternal religions like Hinduism talked about cycle of nature and respecting nature.. They had access to history and knowledge which we all slowly lost. Once the real next civilization downfall comes, we will slowly revert back to those religions 99.9% of our history is unknown. Humans have been here for 2 million years but history is only known for last 2000 years for most places. That's just .01% of history known
It's a similar idea when people first learn of the gut microbiota, or the bacteria in the digestive tract that aid in digestion and other physiologic processes. To tell people that humans need bacteria living in their bodies can seem like a contradiction considering all that has been taught about hygiene. Then, when the awareness that not all bacteria are the same, and only some are pathologic sets in, it begins to make sense.
💯 There is a universe of sentient creatures living inside of us and on us and they require our care in order to survive, in order for us to survive. ✌️
@@MGTOWPsychetheir intention is indeed a mistery! Stubborn truth is that out of this symbiosis I’m writing this comment 😂 🙏🏽 all the best fellow societies of entities ❤
0:26 It’s amazing that the first thing that instantly came to my mind after hearing this, is the Quranic verse: تَبَارَكَ ٱلَّذِی نَزَّلَ ٱلۡفُرۡقَانَ عَلَىٰ عَبۡدِهِۦ لِیَكُونَ لِلۡعَـٰلَمِینَ نَذِیرًا﴿ ١ ﴾ ٱلَّذِی لَهُۥ مُلۡكُ ٱلسَّمَـٰوَ ٰتِ وَٱلۡأَرۡضِ وَلَمۡ یَتَّخِذۡ وَلَدࣰا وَلَمۡ یَكُن لَّهُۥ شَرِیكࣱ فِی ٱلۡمُلۡكِ وَخَلَقَ كُلَّ شَیۡءࣲ فَقَدَّرَهُۥ تَقۡدِیرࣰا﴿ ٢ ﴾ Translation: Blessed is He(Allah) who sent down the Criterion(Quran) upon His Servant(Muhammad) that he may be to the worlds a warner - He to whom belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth and who has not taken a son and has not had a partner in dominion and has created each thing and determined it with [precise] determination. Al-Furqān, verse 1-2
Every animal, plant, insect, microbe, cell, is a constituent of the broader organism! No matter how little or insignificant the entity, it’s value to the whole can’t be logically denied as of yet, and THIS is true 😊 it is also true that some organisms can de appreciated as very important to a specific environment and cared for accordingly however we can’t give out preference as it was true that some organisms don’t matter, harm is in the end of that road and it can be appreciated in our current environmental situation. I appreciate the approach and invite ourselves to be careful with our words as always ❤
All of these examples are mentioned in a book called secret network of nature….so anyone interested in the relation and inter connection of every being should definitely give it a read
Such cycles are critical for maintaining the balance of ecosystems and illustrate the importance of each species in contributing to environmental health and stability. This symbiotic relationship shows the beauty of ecological interdependence and the cycles that sustain life across different habitats.
I really enjoyed the music in the background. Kinda reminds me of Sufjan Stevens. I watched the video with earbuds and pretty quickly got as interested in the music as I was with what he’s talking about. Honestly even more so.
The positive thing I took away from this is that global crisis doesn't necessarily require an overhaul of everything. Not all things have equal impact on the overall health of a system, including our world. As Dr. Carroll suggested we can manipulate few key players to bring about a major change for the better. So thinking about critical issues facing earth today, we as its managers can use our increasing knowledge to better manage this planet ALL OF US call home. Don't just work hard. Work smart.
Great vid.. Love the Big think... the internet has some real crap on it .. but thankfully there are channels like this... :) happy new year THE BIG THINK......... looking forward to your out put in 25.. Davey P. Peace N Love..
I’ve been thinking about this very same thing. Earth’s ecosystem perhaps has a fail safe switch that gets triggered when there is a threat to the balance it works meticulously to maintain. Ultimately it’s all about balance and the ecosystem prioritizes that balance above all else.
This is what “ Sanatan Dharma (Hinduism) “ preaches.. every living being is interconnected, therefore plays a big role in our life, and needs to be worshipped and taken care of.
Mother Nature has been figuring things out for 3 billion years then humans come along and think we know better (or at best we don't realize what we're doing).
They had a generalized and spiritual belief that nature is all connected, but to claim they "have known and been sharing this" when referring to something this scientifically precise isn't very relevant.
@ I’m First Nations and we had a generalized belief like many religions but also had deep knowledge, or science, that was/is only discounted because of racism. For example a deep understanding of the winds and waters that led to the Māori being the most successful navigators in the world, a deep understanding of the interconnection of plants and their environment, or a deep understanding of the ocean life, and its connections to so much more. And let’s not forget that what you call precision science led to eugenics being recognized as a science previously. There is also much more that could improve our world from our knowledge keepers. My message is that before this scientist making these observations (where he uses ‘I’ asserting that he is the first to understand this interconnection that is inaccurate), many scientists before had made the same observations, and many could still benefit from respecting and learning from indigenous sciences today.
Slightly misdirection regarding the trees needing salmon, trees make their own food through photosynthesis, using energy from sunlight, water from the roots, and carbon dioxide from the air, " fungi absorbs nutrients from dead carcasses " ( salmon and other animals ) and recycle them, which helps trees and other plants grow, trees receive food from fungi through a symbiotic relationship called mycorrhiza, allowing them to share resources and information..
@@offtheradarsomewhere. 80% of the nitrogen in the trees of the Great Bear Rainforest come from salmon carcasses. Remove them and it would dramatically change that ecosystem. I have no idea why you are talking about cacti, they are absolutely irrelevant to the subject.
By trying to dissuade the point you inadvertently substantiated it. 😂 that’s why it’s important to ask yourself if you really need to give your opinion to the world before you give it.
He never actually made his case. He only stated that there was evidence, but didn’t cite anything. Your statement about how trees have evolved to survive and thrive is spot on. At best a rotting salmon has a minimal impact on the trees.
Oh traveler, behold life’s sacred thread, Where unseen hands by balance are led. The wolf, the tree, the salmon’s plight, Together weave the world's great light. For in each leaf, each stream, each call, The circle of life sustains us all. Step closer now, to nature’s grace, And find your home in her embrace.
In Toronto or “the GTA” (the Greater Toronto Area), people are noticing more coyotes roaming the streets. This is due to mass deforestation of once forested land for housing. This will indirectly have an effect on the ecosystem in Toronto I’m predicting. More people tend to be feeding these coyotes as well so they’re becoming domesticated or taught to be a city creature as opposed to a forest one. This is similar to raccoons in Toronto I guess. They will adapt but how will the prey that were once hunted by coyotes adapt?
So trees need nutrients from salmon bodies. “Wow! Who would have thought of such things?” he asks. It’s almost like there was an intelligent Creator who thought of such things… Ah… probably just random collision of atoms though… Whatever an atom is. I mean, did we come from one Adam or from one Atom? 🐟🌲
Nice little over view of basic inter connectedness between kingdoms but nothing about HOW TREES EAT SALMON. Disappointing, I was hoping to learn about the fungal kingdom members that get the nitrogen to the tree roots for example
I heard years ago that if all the honey bees on earth died, mankind would follow within four years. I have no idea if that is true or not, but I would not doubt it for a second.
"We are the managers of nature." ooof Yeah, I really don't like that statement. I don't think Mother Nature likes that statement too much either. "Mom's coming 'round to put it back the way it oughta be." - Tool
We missed the lesson at the end of the Cold War, that you cannot choose between "left" (cooperation, socialism) and "right" (competition, capitalism). Humans cooperate and compete all the time, at the same time, but not consciously. Politics (community, civilization) has always been the challenge to balance competition and cooperation, thoughtfully and with purpose. Then we will have common ground and can solve the problems of living together. America practices socialism, but mostly to benefit the wealthy. Now that the rich and poor are so far apart, we can be divided and destroyed from the inside by fascism. Most of us are fighting over the crumbs, unable to afford to raise and educate children. The wealthy are miserable, too, as they never truly feel they have enough.
Yeah you can see an N15 signature in vegetation along Salmon streams .... it does not mean it is essential or even very important. This MDN idea has been way overblown.
"who would have thought of that?!" indigenous people knew the forest needed salmon. we just ignored them because they were savage heathens. when planting the 3 sisters usually a salmon (fish) head is planted with the seeds.
This is exactly it. People say they care, but then show that saying and doing are opposites of the same coin. Just because most people say they care, their actions say otherwise. When people actually start caring and raising their standards of themselves, then maybe.
Loved most of this BT, except, we are the managers of nature 😂😂😂 I'm sorry, I laughed so loud. Yes, we disturb constantly what nature regulates, and we affect some of the outcomes (temporarily only, especially in the scales of time), but we are the regulator?!? Just ask this question: if nature quits regulating, how many days will we last. AND, if we quit regulating, how many millenia will the planet survive? Besides this crazy point, I really liked the article and thought super insiteful! Thanks❤
I agree with you. That statement threw me off. But then again, I understand maybe a little bit of his reasoning because imo, some people feel the need to acknowledge their self-importance to feel a sense of being valued and worthy lol. It’s not necessarily the truth because if humans were to be extinct, I think Mother Earth will continue to live on and thrive without human existence.
All the materialistic phenomenons on this Earth are related to one another, all the universal phenomenons are related to another, cause all the universal phenomenons are the product of energy...
"Who would have thought of such things?" he asks. Native/indigenous people. They've been telling us these things all along. Framing these as recent discoveries is dishonest and colonial. And the statement "we are nature's managers" is wildly egotistical and is the god complex that got us in the messes we've put ourselves in. It misses the point of his own learnings!
Thanks!
Nature is truly amazing! Every part of the ecosystem has its own unique role, and the connection between all living things, from plants to animals, creates a perfect cycle. These relationships not only sustain life but also bring about incredible things that we still can't fully understand 😃
That's why the older eternal religions like Hinduism talked about cycle of nature and respecting nature.. They had access to history and knowledge which we all slowly lost. Once the real next civilization downfall comes, we will slowly revert back to those religions
99.9% of our history is unknown. Humans have been here for 2 million years but history is only known for last 2000 years for most places. That's just .01% of history known
Make the connection 👉 The Connections (2021) [short documentary] 🌎 ♥️
If you love nature, you don't modify and exploit 👉 Dominion (2018)
I used to work with a biologist in the PNW and he said an unfortunate consequence of certain stream restoration practices (like falling logs for better salmon habitat) was that all of these beds of freshwater muscles were being destroyed and neglected as key species who filter the water for salmon. So yes, Salmon are super important, but so much habitat can be damaged by tunnel vision. (I''m no expert, but thought I'd share an insight I heard.)
I’m forever humbled by the intricate connection of all beings in nature
And at the end nature controls us
We may be managers of our little bubble of nature, but Nature will always be infinitely more than we can manage. Just how no one can fully control our Own Nature, aka no one can truly own us, we’ll never be able to fully control or own Nature. Never the less, the abilities of humanity and knowledge we have continues to blow my mind 🙏🏼
The point is we have an interconnected system with a relationship to every aspect of life established over eons. No one is talking about taking control or who is powerful or who dominates
That's why the older eternal religions like Hinduism talked about cycle of nature and respecting nature.. They had access to history and knowledge which we all slowly lost. Once the real next civilization downfall comes, we will slowly revert back to those religions
99.9% of our history is unknown. Humans have been here for 2 million years but history is only known for last 2000 years for most places. That's just .01% of history known
Make the connection 👉 The Connections (2021) [short documentary] 🌎 ♥️
Sadly, I don't have much confidence in our stewardship at this point. As a species we are too greedy, short-sighted ... and stupid.
You are correct but eventually nature will do it’s thing
It's a similar idea when people first learn of the gut microbiota, or the bacteria in the digestive tract that aid in digestion and other physiologic processes. To tell people that humans need bacteria living in their bodies can seem like a contradiction considering all that has been taught about hygiene. Then, when the awareness that not all bacteria are the same, and only some are pathologic sets in, it begins to make sense.
💯 There is a universe of sentient creatures living inside of us and on us and they require our care in order to survive, in order for us to survive. ✌️
imagine if bacteria drove evolution in order to make the best creature (humans) as a biological exoskeleton for the bacteria !
Bacteria are running the world
Make the connection 👉 The Connections (2021) [short documentary] 🌎 ♥️
@@MGTOWPsychetheir intention is indeed a mistery! Stubborn truth is that out of this symbiosis I’m writing this comment 😂 🙏🏽 all the best fellow societies of entities ❤
Thank you for saying it, That every little Natural thing matters to Life. Not a quote, this is what I took from this.. Thank you
Wishing anyone who reads this message a New Year full of joy and good health!
0:26 It’s amazing that the first thing that instantly came to my mind after hearing this, is the Quranic verse:
تَبَارَكَ ٱلَّذِی نَزَّلَ ٱلۡفُرۡقَانَ عَلَىٰ عَبۡدِهِۦ لِیَكُونَ لِلۡعَـٰلَمِینَ نَذِیرًا﴿ ١ ﴾
ٱلَّذِی لَهُۥ مُلۡكُ ٱلسَّمَـٰوَ ٰتِ وَٱلۡأَرۡضِ وَلَمۡ یَتَّخِذۡ وَلَدࣰا وَلَمۡ یَكُن لَّهُۥ شَرِیكࣱ فِی ٱلۡمُلۡكِ وَخَلَقَ كُلَّ شَیۡءࣲ فَقَدَّرَهُۥ تَقۡدِیرࣰا﴿ ٢ ﴾
Translation:
Blessed is He(Allah) who sent down the Criterion(Quran) upon His Servant(Muhammad) that he may be to the worlds a warner -
He to whom belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth and who has not taken a son and has not had a partner in dominion and has created each thing and determined it with [precise] determination.
Al-Furqān, verse 1-2
Every animal, plant, insect, microbe, cell, is a constituent of the broader organism! No matter how little or insignificant the entity, it’s value to the whole can’t be logically denied as of yet, and THIS is true 😊
it is also true that some organisms can de appreciated as very important to a specific environment and cared for accordingly however we can’t give out preference as it was true that some organisms don’t matter, harm is in the end of that road and it can be appreciated in our current environmental situation. I appreciate the approach and invite ourselves to be careful with our words as always ❤
@bigthink I greatly appreciate all the videos shared on your channel but this was one of my favorites. Thank you for posting such interesting content
All of these examples are mentioned in a book called secret network of nature….so anyone interested in the relation and inter connection of every being should definitely give it a read
Such cycles are critical for maintaining the balance of ecosystems and illustrate the importance of each species in contributing to environmental health and stability. This symbiotic relationship shows the beauty of ecological interdependence and the cycles that sustain life across different habitats.
This is wonderful.
I really enjoyed the music in the background. Kinda reminds me of Sufjan Stevens. I watched the video with earbuds and pretty quickly got as interested in the music as I was with what he’s talking about. Honestly even more so.
If you have access to PBS shows be sure and watch The Serengeti Rules. They did a wonderful job putting that movie together.
The Serengeti Rules is the most hopeful nature documentary I’ve ever seen, [PBS] because it explains how we can save all life on earth.
Make the connection 👉 The Connections (2021) [short documentary] 🌎 ♥️
To paraphrase Nathan Hale:
"I regret that I have but one thumbs up to give to this video!"
It reminds me of a book I've been reading recently, Suzanne Simard's Finding the Mother Tree. Highly recommend!
“You know not what you do”is actually true..
Very educational, thank you ❤
In nature nothing works alone !
nature is the most incomprehensibly beautiful art. art that would take an infinity to fully appreciate.
Make the connection 👉 The Connections (2021) [short documentary] 🌎 ♥️
The positive thing I took away from this is that global crisis doesn't necessarily require an overhaul of everything. Not all things have equal impact on the overall health of a system, including our world. As Dr. Carroll suggested we can manipulate few key players to bring about a major change for the better. So thinking about critical issues facing earth today, we as its managers can use our increasing knowledge to better manage this planet ALL OF US call home. Don't just work hard. Work smart.
outstanding video...
Yes, our trees and the people need the salmon, and they're making a comeback here in WA! ❤😊
Great vid.. Love the Big think... the internet has some real crap on it .. but thankfully there are channels like this... :) happy new year THE BIG THINK......... looking forward to your out put in 25.. Davey P.
Peace N Love..
I’ve been thinking about this very same thing. Earth’s ecosystem perhaps has a fail safe switch that gets triggered when there is a threat to the balance it works meticulously to maintain. Ultimately it’s all about balance and the ecosystem prioritizes that balance above all else.
👋🏼Great explanation!!!💙💙💙
Thank you! Love my true nature info! Always a student 😊👍🏻
This is what “ Sanatan Dharma (Hinduism) “ preaches.. every living being is interconnected, therefore plays a big role in our life, and needs to be worshipped and taken care of.
Wooow amazing 🇬🇧🙌❤️🙏🏻
Vaata Kapha and Pitta is what ancient Indian medicine says for human beings. The 3 that needs to be in balance.
Unpopular opinion: Everything matters, the more impactful, the more it matters.
Mother Nature has been figuring things out for 3 billion years then humans come along and think we know better (or at best we don't realize what we're doing).
Mother Nature is a nightmare, full of incomprehensible suffering always.
@@mpetrison3799 What's the alternative?
Transcendence to a technology/society that sustains everyone @@dfinma
Excellent!
Indigenous peoples have known and been sharing this for decades. Why have we not/cannot listen to them?
They had a generalized and spiritual belief that nature is all connected, but to claim they "have known and been sharing this" when referring to something this scientifically precise isn't very relevant.
@ I’m First Nations and we had a generalized belief like many religions but also had deep knowledge, or science, that was/is only discounted because of racism. For example a deep understanding of the winds and waters that led to the Māori being the most successful navigators in the world, a deep understanding of the interconnection of plants and their environment, or a deep understanding of the ocean life, and its connections to so much more. And let’s not forget that what you call precision science led to eugenics being recognized as a science previously. There is also much more that could improve our world from our knowledge keepers. My message is that before this scientist making these observations (where he uses ‘I’ asserting that he is the first to understand this interconnection that is inaccurate), many scientists before had made the same observations, and many could still benefit from respecting and learning from indigenous sciences today.
Slightly misdirection regarding the trees needing salmon, trees make their own food through photosynthesis, using energy from sunlight, water from the roots, and carbon dioxide from the air, " fungi absorbs nutrients from dead carcasses " ( salmon and other animals ) and recycle them, which helps trees and other plants grow, trees receive food from fungi through a symbiotic relationship called mycorrhiza, allowing them to share resources and information..
That’s interesting info, but ultimately, it reinforces the idea that trees need salmon…just added an extra link to the chain.
@MorseAttack Will have to tell that to the cacti trees in the desert and all the other species of trees that thrive where is no salmon rivers..💙🥰🙏
@@offtheradarsomewhere.
80% of the nitrogen in the trees of the Great Bear Rainforest come from salmon carcasses.
Remove them and it would dramatically change that ecosystem.
I have no idea why you are talking about cacti, they are absolutely irrelevant to the subject.
By trying to dissuade the point you inadvertently substantiated it. 😂 that’s why it’s important to ask yourself if you really need to give your opinion to the world before you give it.
He never actually made his case. He only stated that there was evidence, but didn’t cite anything. Your statement about how trees have evolved to survive and thrive is spot on. At best a rotting salmon has a minimal impact on the trees.
Oh traveler, behold life’s sacred thread,
Where unseen hands by balance are led.
The wolf, the tree, the salmon’s plight,
Together weave the world's great light.
For in each leaf, each stream, each call,
The circle of life sustains us all.
Step closer now, to nature’s grace,
And find your home in her embrace.
Was the Salmon shot taken in Sol Duck River Valley? I was able to see salmons queueing up to jump upstream and travel North for mating season.
We are the nature's manager now..what an arogant thought😂
So saying it's all interconnected; and that it's necessary for balance
Thank you
Amazing to know nurture interaction
Very intersting theme. 😮😮
Cool
Rules without a ‘rule maker’?
GOOD
Every ecosystem balance has at least one Kevin Bacon in the chain.
In Toronto or “the GTA” (the Greater Toronto Area), people are noticing more coyotes roaming the streets. This is due to mass deforestation of once forested land for housing. This will indirectly have an effect on the ecosystem in Toronto I’m predicting. More people tend to be feeding these coyotes as well so they’re becoming domesticated or taught to be a city creature as opposed to a forest one. This is similar to raccoons in Toronto I guess. They will adapt but how will the prey that were once hunted by coyotes adapt?
It kills me that he said the last line the wrong way round to emphasise the result being managing the planet better
EVERY species is important.
We are logically and scientifically "discovering" things that our ancestors knew intuitively thousands of years ago.
3:39 and 4:41. use “organisms” not “creatures”.
So trees need nutrients from salmon bodies. “Wow! Who would have thought of such things?” he asks.
It’s almost like there was an intelligent Creator who thought of such things…
Ah… probably just random collision of atoms though… Whatever an atom is. I mean, did we come from one Adam or from one Atom? 🐟🌲
so intelligent that the designer put a man's g spot up his butt. The Intelligent Design argument has been debunked so many times.
This is not the Sean Carroll I was expecting. 😂
I’m still trying to figure out the circle of 5ths.
Ancient peoples in north america used to bury dead fish to fertilize soils
Still do.😉💕
@@lbthingsstuffmore9513well, most of them probably aren't ancient at the moment, but later they will be 😂
Fish emulsion is still very much a common fertilizer in organic farming.
@@adamk.7177 🤣👍
Yes, i agree, but i need salmon too😂
Nice little over view of basic inter connectedness between kingdoms but nothing about HOW TREES EAT SALMON. Disappointing, I was hoping to learn about the fungal kingdom members that get the nitrogen to the tree roots for example
IN flowing..OUT GOING...ABOVE AND BELOW 🌏👀
So basically even a lil change to our environment can help it. Yet we do nothing.
I heard years ago that if all the honey bees on earth died, mankind would follow within four years.
I have no idea if that is true or not, but I would not doubt it for a second.
If only we used this wisdom of regulatory systems that control and sustain our bodies towards our economic policies...
“Who would have thought of such things?!?”…
Native Americans all over the country silently raise their hands.
"We are the managers of nature."
ooof
Yeah, I really don't like that statement. I don't think Mother Nature likes that statement too much either.
"Mom's coming 'round to put it back the way it oughta be." - Tool
amazing, many thanks !!!
We missed the lesson at the end of the Cold War, that you cannot choose between "left" (cooperation, socialism) and "right" (competition, capitalism). Humans cooperate and compete all the time, at the same time, but not consciously. Politics (community, civilization) has always been the challenge to balance competition and cooperation, thoughtfully and with purpose. Then we will have common ground and can solve the problems of living together. America practices socialism, but mostly to benefit the wealthy. Now that the rich and poor are so far apart, we can be divided and destroyed from the inside by fascism. Most of us are fighting over the crumbs, unable to afford to raise and educate children. The wealthy are miserable, too, as they never truly feel they have enough.
And they run when the sun comes up
With their lives on the line
(ALLIIIIIVEEE)
And it just shows that all world and nature is carnivores grass trees they need meet.
lovely video & intersting insights....but 'manage nature' isn't the right lens to view this from imho (in my humble opinion)
The law of mother's nature..(mercy & love)
Tsunami, Tornordo, hurricane, flooding, corona 😂😂😂
Y trees need omega 3 fatty acid???
trace minerals. and mushrooms assist the tree roots in making it usable.
"Does a bear shit in the woods?"
The trees need the salmon.
Yeah you can see an N15 signature in vegetation along Salmon streams .... it does not mean it is essential or even very important. This MDN idea has been way overblown.
Maaaaaaaaaa de-hinhyahhhhhhhh, babadeeeee simbidahhhhhhh!!
U bloody artificially intelligent man Are u the master of nature man
Oh... the *other* Sean Carroll.
Lmao for a moment I thought Sean Carroll was stepping outside of his comfort zone.
How has the world survived then? With all the species that have gone extinct already?
Sometimes I wonder if our planet is alive and creates us to do the things it needs, kinda like use with red and white blood cells.
"who would have thought of that?!" indigenous people knew the forest needed salmon. we just ignored them because they were savage heathens.
when planting the 3 sisters usually a salmon (fish) head is planted with the seeds.
I feel like an NPC lmao I said "What?!" out loud to myself exactly the same as the guy at 0:08 -____-
They’re called keystone species. Nothing new here.
Except salmon are NOT a keystone species for trees
But we too often DO manage our bodies like we manage nature. Just look at fast food and the obesity epidemic.
This is exactly it. People say they care, but then show that saying and doing are opposites of the same coin. Just because most people say they care, their actions say otherwise. When people actually start caring and raising their standards of themselves, then maybe.
Loved most of this BT, except, we are the managers of nature 😂😂😂 I'm sorry, I laughed so loud. Yes, we disturb constantly what nature regulates, and we affect some of the outcomes (temporarily only, especially in the scales of time), but we are the regulator?!? Just ask this question: if nature quits regulating, how many days will we last. AND, if we quit regulating, how many millenia will the planet survive? Besides this crazy point, I really liked the article and thought super insiteful! Thanks❤
insightful!
I agree with you. That statement threw me off. But then again, I understand maybe a little bit of his reasoning because imo, some people feel the need to acknowledge their self-importance to feel a sense of being valued and worthy lol. It’s not necessarily the truth because if humans were to be extinct, I think Mother Earth will continue to live on and thrive without human existence.
So what you're saying is... trees and I have similar taste
All the materialistic phenomenons on this Earth are related to one another, all the universal phenomenons are related to another, cause all the universal phenomenons are the product of energy...
Melt water rivers don't have a lot of nutrience*
What he said. : )
Make the connection 👉 The Connections (2021) [short documentary] 🌎 ♥️
💡
We need to reintroduce a superpredator thart will predate on human.
Covid can be unleashed again in overpopulated countries.
All praise to the Creator who made everything in its right measure, strength and purpose of life to sustain the entire eco system and the Universe.
"Who would have thought of such things?" he asks. Native/indigenous people. They've been telling us these things all along. Framing these as recent discoveries is dishonest and colonial. And the statement "we are nature's managers" is wildly egotistical and is the god complex that got us in the messes we've put ourselves in. It misses the point of his own learnings!
Subhanallah
If we manages our body like we manages nature we woulndt be exist no more
Dominion (2018)
Why "manage", "regulate"...CONTROL Nature ??? How about learning to understand it and COOPERATE, collaborate with our environment.
Too general , too bad... We are not children