Sheikh Mujibur Rehman, Bangabandhu | Faisal Warraich
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 гру 2021
- #History #Science #mujeeburrehman
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
🌒🌒🌒 Social Media
🔷 Twitter / fswarraich
📺 Instagram / faisal_warraich__
📘 Facebook / faisalwarraichofficial
🎥🎥🎥 Films you must watch before you die
░▒► The Ottoman Empire: bit.ly/3jGk2wo
░▒► Muslim Cold War 01: bit.ly/3P44djT
░▒► Muslim Cold War 02: bit.ly/3wfymUK
░▒► Muslim Cold War 03: bit.ly/3N0uPjU
░▒► Muhammad bin Qasim and Sindh: bit.ly/3yhvMQW
░▒► M. Bin Qasim & Raja Dahar: • The Real Story behind ...
░▒► The History of Arabs and Israel: • Origins of the Arab-Is...
░▒► Why the USA lost the Afghan war: • Why did the USA fail i...
░▒► Story of Charles Darwin and Evolution: bit.ly/3kOLgns
░▒► History of USA/America: bit.ly/2GkT5Ri
░▒► Pak India war of 1965: bit.ly/3vUJnvT
░▒► Pak India war of 1971: bit.ly/3vW0opE
░▒► The Universe complete Film: bit.ly/3w9BstD
░▒► Rise and Fall of Muslim Spain: bit.ly/397NI68
░▒► Who was Karl Marx: bit.ly/3sIdIfl
░▒► Last days of M Ali Jinnah: bit.ly/3vUFI1e
░▒► Last days of Saddam Hussain: bit.ly/3FsCjKf
░▒► Last days of Qasem Sulemani: bit.ly/3kRDvx9
░▒► Where is the family of the last Ottoman Caliph? bit.ly/3P8ZFbW
Thanks for watching my curios fellows, and always remember we love 💝 you all - Розваги
Hey, my curious fellows, you can follow me on my Facebook account. Thanks
دوستو آپ میرا فیس بک اکاؤنٹ بھی فالو کر سکتے ہیں۔ شکریہ
facebook.com/FSWarraich
Bhutto was sindi and ayub khan belong to kpk then why against punjabi ?
please can you make vlog about ziaur Rahman,,former Bangladesh president
Siachin pe v video bnaiye. AAPKA Sab war series dekhe h. Mst h
aaap ko yae bhi yaad dilana chata hoon kae yae awami league hi thi jo apnay ahtajaj main khoon kharabay ki wajha banay thay
Faisal bhai plz apna background btayen details because its important as a listener or reader.
آپ کی باتوں سے پتہ چل رہا محترم شیخ مجیب الرحمان نڈر لیڈر اور ایک محبِ وطن تھے۔
ابھی تک میں جناب شیخ مجیب الرحمان کو غلط سمجھاتا تھا اب جب میں انکے بارے میں جان چکا ہوں تو میرے نظر میں وہ ایک عظیم شخصیت ہیں
قصہ مختصر کہ آرمی و اسٹیبلشمنٹ ہی ہر سانحے کی مؤجب تھی، ہے اور خدا نخواستہ رہے گی
Sheikh Mujeeb was never a traitor. Pak Army not only oppressed the Bangalis but also brainwashed West Pakistanis against them. They deserved their independence. Love from Lahore
کیاجرنیل آسمان سےاترےیافرشتےہیں؟ان پرتنقیدکرناسوال کرنا
انکوانکےآئینی حدودبتاناکفر؟
وردی پہن مقدس گائےبن جاتےہیں پھرچاہےیہ جوبھی کرےکرپشن
سمگلنگ
دہشت گردی
ٹارگٹ کیلنگ
کاروبارسیاست کرے،اپنےہی شہریوں کےبیڈ رومز میں کیمرےلگائےبھتہ خوری کرےآپ وردی پہن کرہم سےزیادہ محب وطن نہیں بنجاتے
I am a Bangadeshi. For the first time, I saw a Pakistani speaking about Mujib with the respect he deserves. Thank you 💖🇧🇩 He fought for Bengali rights in his later years. But he sacrificed a lot for your country too. At least he doesn't deserve to be called a traitor. Bengalis themselves wanted separation bcz of the discrimination and rascism they faced. Bengalis are not fools.
Mam I respect your point of view and I wanna assure that nobody in the public was ready for this separation even today we in Pakistan express that incident with great grief and sorrow....I wish that that shouldn't happened to us it has caused both countries with serious issues afterwards...😥😥
Shaikh Mujeeb Pakistani Hero...
@@hydragaming8481 Probably West Pakistan people were not ready for separation. But that was not the case of East Pakistan. If you think, Mujib influenced us, thats not true at all. In fact he was under severe public pressure to declare independence on 7th March 1971. He didn't do it to save people from immediate military crackdown. You can read Pak Army personnel, Brig. Siddik Salik's book. It was east pakistan people who dictated his actions, not the other way around.
We Pakistani hate Bhutto and know that mujeeb was not a traitor
Mujeb hero of muslim
شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن کبھی بھی غدار نہیں تھے، اصل غدار تو وہ محکمہ زراعت والے تھے جس نے مادر ملت کو غدار ڈکلیئر کیا تھا
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
True
East India company part 2 ,I mean Pakistan army jernols
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
محکمہ زراعت 😂
Sheikh mujerb ur Rehman a true Patriot mulism leader and brave soldier of Quaid Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah nd Fatihma Jinnah.
Lov nd respect for sheikh mujeeb Rehman from Pakistan
I am a pakistani when Bangladesh was formed I was four years old I say with confidence Mujibur Rahman was not a traitor he wanted to save the federation from disintegration
At least someone speaking the truth to our new generation. God bless you 👏
Excellent wiraich Sahab
Hum musalman sirf nam ky h. Sirf islam k hisab sy hi hojata to aaj aysa na sus rahyhoty
Excellent
"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.”
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
after watching this episode, my respect for Bengalis has increased. huge respect for them and their bold leader sheikh mujeeb ul rehman.
Mr. Adil: Sheikh Shab will die again if he mistakenly sees your wrong written of sheikh mubeeb ul rehman name from the grave 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@user-ku3jw7ij8n 😂😂😂😂
They are not bangali they are Bangladeshi brothers ... Geography of my Pakistani people is very bad ...
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
@@shahroz01 Their Nationality is Bangladeshi but Ethnically they are Bangali.
شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن صاحب ایک محب وطن پاکستانی تھے، اللہ تعالٰی انہیں جنت الفردوس میں اعلٰی مقام عطا فرمائے آمین یا رب العالمین
Greate Respect for Shiekh Mujibur Rehman from Pakistan.
I am listening from Bangladesh🇧🇩. Thank you for talking about Sheikh Mujibur Rahman with the respect he deserves. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was a true patriot who wanted to work for the betterment of the people of the country both East and west Pakistan.
If Sheikh Mujibur Rahman had survived, the golden Bengal of Bangladesh would have been built by now.Everywhere in the East or West, there are some Kulangars. We had some Kulangars in Bengal.
InshaALLAH We will fulfill Sheikh Mujibur Rahman's dream of a golden Bengal for the next generation.❤️🇧🇩
Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️
You are right bro shaikh mujib was right bhutto was culprit
Sorry for everything bro
Hum us waqt mojod nhi thy
🙏
It’s a shame that our corrupt leaders like Bhutto and Yahya khan showed no respect to the election votes. Most of Pakistanis have nothing against Bangalis it’s the politicians, people have no clue.
No issue
Y did u kill him so early, u should hav let him made golden bengal with his corruption n lawlessness.
But now ur country leaders are servant of modi sarkar especially ur witch prime Minister
Listening from Bangladesh..
Great respect to Faisal bhai for speaking the truth ❤️
Respecet From pakistan❤
آپ جس طرح تاریخ بیان کرتے ہے قابل تعریف ۔
کسی تاریخ دان کی سب سے بڑی خصوصیت غیر جانبداری ہوتی ۔دوسرا تاریخ دان کو انتہا پسند نہیں ہونا چاہیے ۔آپ میں یہ دونوں صفات ہے
One of the best vlog to understand Pak history,politics , geopolitics. Unbiased, bold,eye opening. Truth be told at any cost. I've subscribed. Kindly ,if possible , use less pure Urdu words.I'm Indian non Hindi speaker. Hat's off to your research and nice presentation.
عداوتیں تھیں تغافل تھا رنجشیں تھیں مگر
بچھڑنے والے میں سب کچھ تھا بےوفائی نہ تھی
😭😭
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
💟
Kmall
بے وفائی تو کر ہی دی تھی
اب یہی کچھ عمران خان کے ساتھ ہوا تو کیا وہ بھارت کے ساتھ مل گیا؟
جو مجیب کے ساتھ بھیانک تھا اس ملک کے ساتھ بھیانک کھیل کھیلا گیا لیکن دشمن کے ساتھ ملنے کو جسٹیفائی نہیں کیا جا سکتا
@@romanarauf6547 آپ ٹھیک کہ رہی ہیں۔ میں جسٹیفائی کر بھی نہیں رہی۔ پر اگرتلہ سازش ایک تو کبھی ثابت نہیں ہوئی ۔ دوسرا قائد اعظم بھی گاندھی اور نہرو سے ملتے تھے تو کیا بےوفائی کرتے تھے؟ آپ مانے نہ مانے 1965 میں مشرقی پاکستان سے جنگ کے دوران واقعی رابطہ ٹوٹ گیا تھا۔ بغاوت کرنی ہوتی تو اس وقت کرسکتا تھا۔ اس نے آخری وقت تک کوشش کی کہ کسی طرح حق مل جاۓ ۔ ہماری طرف سے ایک کوشش نظر نہیں آتی ۔
میں آپ سے پوچھتی ہوں ۔ ہمیں انڈیا سے الگ ہونے کی کیا ضرورت تھے جب کہ قائد اعظم خود ہندو مسلم اتحاد کے بانی تھے۔ ضرورت یہ تھی کہ قائد کو نظر آ گیا تھا کہ انگریزوں کے جانے کے بعد ہندو قابض ہو جائیں گے اور مسلمان دوسرے درجے کے ہو کے رہ جائیں گے ۔ آپ نے بنگالیوں کی مدد سے آزادی تو حاصل کر لی۔ لیکن انھے دوسرے درجے کی قوم بنا دیا۔ آپ میں اور ان میں فرق بس اتنا ہے کہ آپ نے آزادی کے لئے ایک بار کوشش کی۔ انہوں نے 2 بار۔ بےوفائی تو آپ نے بھی کی ہے ہندوستان سے
I'm an Bangladeshi..
Apko salute hai true history samne lane ke liye.. orvi behtar hota agar 1952 ka language movement ko skeep na karta...
Because this movement create international mother's language day.
My father served in East Pakistan for 4 years, he had very fond memories of Bengalis and he used to praise them. im 1990s, one of his old friends visited us in Paksitan from Bangladesh.
Sheikh mujibur and sylhet division did not want separation but they did want justice. Pakistan zindabad from sylhet, BD
Bari Himmat ki hai ap ne Faisal Bhai, Well done ✅
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡.
My eyes are crying 😓😢..
How we Lost our Brave And patriotic Sheikh Mujeeb..
Thanks for Showing us Truth 💔
I am a pakistani and I apologise from my Bangladeshi fellows on the atrocities committed by West pakistan . I am an urdu speaking from karachi.
Your forefathers must be from up .
I m from azad kashmir and i agreed with you
@@Garimachaturvedi-vk4sz
Not our Forefathers, there are some corrupt people mad with power where the main culprit is not Pakistani Citizens.
As Faisal Sir said separation should happen with a political way not with bloody war.
Anyhow we are also in grief.
شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن ایک محب وطن بندہ تھا ۔ سلام مجیب الرحمٰن ، حکومت اسی کو ہی ملنی چاہئے تھی ۔ شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن زندہ باد ۔
بہترین تجزیہ ہے، مغربی پاکستان کی عسکری، سول عہدران اور سیاسی لیڈر یہ چاہتے تھے کہ مشرقی پاکستان انکے ساتھ نہ رہے۔
Listening from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
❤
@@eddykhan6672 ❤️
@@mariaain8640 Many of the Bangladeshi people can...I used to listened to Dr. Zakir Naik's lecture in urdu when I was younger, may be that's why.
But I can't write it.
Do you know urdo bro bangali
@@aamirpak3369 yes
I can understand urdu very well
i am also crying after seeing this 😥
Pakistan tornay mian bhi kuch logo ki iqtdar ki hawas na sab sa bara kardar ata kia
sheikh Mujeeb was a proud leader of pakistan
Bhutto was traitor of Pakistan,he nationalist everything, only for power ,he killed with Ayub to mattama Fatima Jinnah,
He Bhutto says you go there we here
Brilliant. Thank you sir.
I was born in then east Pakistan and was there during the creation of Bangladesh. Later migrated to Pakistan. Respect for Shaikh Mujibur Rahman.
From the beginning leaders of Bengalis were not sincere for Pakistan independence they joined enemy India against a Muslim country which is their mistake and will see India against BD incoming years .
Respect for this great leader from Pakistan 🇵🇰. We are sorry to our bengali brothers. Just because of some ego general & establishment. You brothers separated your path from us.
Ha vai bilkul thik kaha Apne. Love from Bangladesh
yani is mulk ka jub bhi nuqsaan hoa to gererals ki iqtdar ki hawas ki waja sa hi hoa
@@AliHassan-uw5bn Yeh sach to Pakistan ke wajood ke 9 saal mein hi samaj Jana chahiye ta Pakistan ki logo ko.
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
آپ کو اللہ نے کمال صلاحیت عطا کی ہے۔ ماشاءاللہ
Your Videos are based on pure facts,
Love your channel from Karachi 🇵🇰
Huge Huge respect for true leader,,, Shaikh Mujib Ur Rahman.....
FAISAL vai thanks for this video ... It's True everything you say.. love from BANGLADESH .
Am from pakistan but i still love bangladesh❤
Love you bro 😘🇵🇰🇧🇩
Love you Bangladesh Love u sheikh mujeeb .we should forget all bad old memories.
As a Pakistan. First we should accept our mistakes and apologize to the atrocities made on the people of West Pakistan now Bangladesh. Whenever I meet someone form Bangladesh I first say sorry for what my elders did. Our government should publicly apologize and declare Sheikh Mujib as one of the heroes of Pakistan
@@junaidshakeel7823 I am feel guilt for worshiping my country
صرف ملک ہی دولخت نہیں ہوا ، دل کے بھی ٹکڑے ہو گئے
There was another thing. In 1947,Sylhet was the only area of Indian Subcontinent who was allowed to vote whether to join India or Pakistan. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman played a vital role in this campaign. His working area was Karimganj District which voted in favor of Pakistan by 50.44%. But later this district was exchanged with Moulvibazar District which hurt Mujib's feelings because he had lost despite winning. He mentioned this in his bood "The unfinished memories".
This is called free press...keep it up👍
Thank you so much brother 🥰🥰🥰🥰
To our Bangladeshi Brothers ...We are ashamed for the behavior of our politicians and we apologize for that. 🙏
Well explanation, love from India 🇮🇳
Mujib is not only the founder of Bangladesh, but also one of the leading characters to found Pakistan.
حسیں آنکھوں مدھر گیتوں کے سندر دیش کو کھو کر
میں حیراں ہوں وہ ذکر وادی کشمیر کرتے ہیں 😢
Pakistani Qoum ko engage rakhney kay liye. Taki voh Pakistani Fauj ki aiyashiyoon, fash ghalatiyoon, sazishoon ore qoumi jarayim say bekhabar rahaein. Lekin tareekh khud bol padee....
love u Faisal bhai from Bangladesh 🇧🇩😍🇵🇰and also Dekho Suno Jano is my favourite channel,
love sheikh mujeebur Rehman and my dear Bangladesh East Bangladesh
Shaikh mujeeb is a hero for their own people and he is not a traitor.
The all episode is the dust of our general's and politician's mind.
I really feel sorry for Bangladesh
Thanks from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
In 1969 september pakistan army led by brigadiar zia ul haq ( who later become pakistan president in 1979) led pakistan army killed 20,000 palestinian refugee s in jordan refugee camp. this incident is known as black september. pakistan army killed the palestinian refugees on the order of us president lyndon johnson . pakistan receives us aid in return pakistan does dirty works for usa. more palestinians were killed by pakistan army in 3 days than isreal did in 30 years . this is the true face of munafiq punjabi army
Please don't feel sorry for Bangladesh personally (Bangladeshi people had hugely sacrificed but are free and doing alright). But, you and the younger generation may well ask your leaders in power to express the due formal regret to Bangladesh (for the prolonged injustice and the atrocities committed by the Pak Army on the innocent civilians during the liberation war and settle the differences for normalising the mutual relation.
Pakistani rular was gadar
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
I have been to Bangladesh, travelled a lot and met with a number of people from all social strata. I found them soft and simpl and very committed nation by nature. I did realize as a West Pakistani that it must have been outrageously horrible treatment that we gave to my Bangla brothers to take them to that extreme. Sheikh Mujeeb was a soldier of Muhammad Fatima Jinah against Murderer Traitor Mir Jafer Ayub Khan.... We are Sorry my Bangla Brothers n Sisters.....
Really he was a honest loyal man Allah kareem ghareek rehmat farmaye Aameen
فیصل بھائی اللہ پاک پنجتن پاک کے صدقے آپ پر اپنا فضل کرے آپ کو بخت لگائے۔ آپ کے مال عزت اہل و عیال کو سلامت رکھے۔میں آجکل Ppsc pakistan studies lecturership preparation کر رہی ہوں اور آپ کی videos میرے لیے خدائی مدد ثابت ہو رہی ہیں
ماشاءاللہ، بہت خوب آپ مجھ سے بھی رابطہ کرسکتے ہیں
Thank you for speaking up the truth and telling unbiased history to the new generations
کوئی بھی غدار نہیں ہوتا حالات و واقعات بناتے ہیں
Sheikh mujeeb ur rehman was a warrior
Did excellent job for libration of Bangladesh
جو لوگ بھٹو کو لیڈر سمجھتے ہیں یہ ویڈیو سپیشل ان لوگوں کے لئے ہے
Faisal vai you presented the situation perfectly. I want give my heartiest gratitude to you. This is like gift on the 50th Victory day of Bangladesh. Also I hope brotherhood in Bangladesh & Pakistan.
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡.
Pakistan doesn't need brotherhood with you. Carry on with your romance with India with the help of which your forefathers separated our Pakistan. May Sheikh Mujeeb and Bhutto both rot in hell.
I lived with Bengali family in England for couple of years they were truly humble, We have lot of Bengalis in Karachi, respect and love for Bengalis brother
So with Pakistanis in Bangladesh
وہ ہم سفر تھا مگر اس سے ہمنوائی نہ تھی
کہ دھوپ چھاؤں کا عالم رہا جدائی نہ تھی
You spoke truth, truth & only truth. Thank you very much for your unbiased and bold expression. Wish you all the best.
Very good .❤❤❤
Love from Bangladesh ♥️🇧🇩🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
From Pakistan Jo howa chor do we are Muslims we are one Pakistan Zindabad 🇵🇰 Bangladesh Zindabad 🇧🇩 😍😞🥺😃
ماشاءاللہ بہترین
sheikh mujeeb is truly patriotic PAKISTANI , with HUGE RESPECT FROM PAKISTAN FOR BANGLADESH.
and also sorry for the worse behavior of pak army & politician.
Love and respect for our Bangalis Brothers from Pakistan
How beautifully you narrated the whole story.. our political and establishment elite still haven't learned from our past
Bro, where are you from?
I'm a Gujjar from haryana
I was only sixteen years old. I remember the day the Fall of Dacca
happened and our family did not eat any dinner. For days our family had no desire to eat any meal. We just took few bites for every meals. We hardly talked with our family members and we all had tears in our eyes.
We love our Bengali brothers.
@@sonubose390 You are kafir for him. 🤣😁 Don't be happy by seeing him.
Sheikh Mujeeb u Rehman was a Pakistani Hero.
میں ایک پاکستانی ہوتے ہوئے میں شیخ مجیب ائرحمن کو سلام پیش کرتا ہوں اس نے زبردس کام کیا ہے
Sheikh Muzib sir deserves respect
@@mariaain8640 he was not a traitor. He just fought for his people but when he thought he became the owner of Bangladesh he got killed
I don't comment on Shiekh Mujib, what done is done, but now we have to build our future. We can only took lessons from our past and hope we don't make the mistake in future. My love and sympathy to the people of Bangladesh, but now it's the time to make our relation better and best for the future of both the countries. Thank you
ضد ی رہنے کی روش ایسے حالات کو جنم دیتی ہے
افسوس اس وقت بھی صدر فوجی تھا ،😭😭
I would like to say sorry to Bangladeshis for what West Pakistani generals and politicians did to their ancestors. I would address following points to my fellow Pakistanis and Bangladeshis:
1- Separation of Bangladesh happened due to long dictatorship rule of Ayub, Yahya and Bhutto's greed of power. It was same colonial mindset which British left.
2- Jinnah never wanted partition of India. He wanted dominion or confederation status of two Muslim India(West Pakistan and Bangal) and a single Hindu India.
3- Bengal was the main hub of Muslim league and Pakistan struggle and had strong Muslim league support. West Pakistan did little less in separation struggle. Bangal was the core epicentre of separation. In fact Bengalis did this many times in history. First when they separated them from Mughal empire then they divided Bengal into East and West in 1905. Then they divided British India into Pakistan and India and then again divided Pakistan in 1970s. East Bengalis were always rebellious.
4- Regarding Bangal's urdu-bangali controversy, it is the mistake of Bangalis as Bangali was not spoken in any of the part of West Pakistan. What Bangalis claimed for Bengali language can also be raised by Punjab, Sindh, Baluchistan etc (e.g Punjabi to be national language or pushto to be national language etc). Hence urdu or Hindi or any former language like Spanish, Persian etc was a wise decision but Bengali nationalism come in the way. Also Jinnah was not a Urdu speaker but a Englishman and a Gujarati.
5- Events in East Pakistan and operation searchlight was not known to general public of West Pakistan as everything was censored by long dictatorship regime and state owned control of radio and media. State media just told that India has interfered in East Pakistan etc. Otherwise operation would be halted because of public pressure. General Ayub also finished and disbanded every political party including Muslim league during his dictatorship regime. This caused a democratic vacuum.
6- Bhutto should have given the utmost right to Mujeeb as he was rightly having majority.
7- Single Pakistan was never into the plan by Muslim league. It is evident from Jinnah's acceptance of Cabinet mission plan A which Congress rejected it and was last nail in the coffin for partition. It was British and Congress which forced Jinnah in the end to accept one country and that too also with division of Punjab and Bangal.
8. Muslim league was never a disciplined party unlike congress. Hence after the death of M. Ali Jinnah, Muslim league started facing a deadly political vacuum.
9. Greedy bureaucracy, long political instability in Pakistan and then the long dictatorship rule were the main cause of weakened governance system and policies. This caused economic disparity in East Pakistan especially in general Ayub's era which is another major cause of separation of East Pakistan.
10- It was literally much difficult to control both parts of Pakistan with a strong federal system as both parts have no physical borders. It was always going to be hard on resources due to hostile neighbour. Thus it was better to have a confederation, weak centre or a separate states.
11- Pakistan failed to conduct general elections for 23 years since its existence. The first general election done was in 1970 which unfortunately formed the basis of separation of East Pakistan.
Edit:
Now it's a new era. Let us forget the past and move on for good. History will remain history. Nor the present generations of British or anyothers can't be blamed for what their ancestors or small group of power hungry people did. Lets move forward just like Japan and US or France and Great Britain after many wars.
👍
dil khoon ke ansoo roraha hai bhai agar ham zara si samajhdari ka izhar karte or apne bengali bhaio ke sath insaf karte to kabhi bhi Pakistan nahi toot ta 😔🇵🇰❤
Number 2 is BS
Pata nhi hum ye baaten apni new generation ko batany se Q dirty hen...?
Where you get your point number 2
Where as i read jinnah said we either want separate india or burn india to Britain after 45 elections
True history .
♥️ From 🇧🇩
Nice❤❤❤
Ap ki baton ki ek hi bat he k is sab ka zimadar shekh mujeburhman nhi balqe jernel yayha the ,,, Allah Pak Pakistan or Bangladesh ki hifazt farmay AMEN 🕋☝️🇵🇰🤲
I still remember an old man who met me at Hajj he was crying his lungs out as soon as he heard name of Pakistan 😢
I guess it's the most balanced view on fall of Dhaka and main culprit for this disaster was ayub khan , yahya khan and ZA Bhutto
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.”
Sheikh mujeeb ur Rehman great person,
اللہ پاک آپکو اپنے حفظ و امان میں رکھے۔۔۔آمین
Shaikh mujeeb and Altaf Hussain both are great leader
Wish you were the guy in authority to educate this nation 35 years back, so for sure we as a nation must have some respect and honour today, anyways never so late, millions of prayers to you brother for telling the truth JazakAllah Pakistan ZindaBaad Faisal Bhai Zindabaad…..
Thank you very much bhai for speaking the truth and realizing the feeling of Bangladeshi people. Love my country Bangladesh so much. Wish you people all the best. May Allah bless us all.
We are also love u brother & both Muslim countries .
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
بہت کمال سر جی
جو بھی ہوا اچھا نہیں ہوا کاش اس وقت ایک دوسرے کے لئے دل بڑے کر دیئے جاتے
Sheikh mujibur rehman was not a traitor
Sheikh mujibur rehman was a pro Pakistani man
True..!! It was Bhutto & General Ayub who were traitors ..!!
you have no right to say any one traitor
@@naeemafridi2311 you have no right to say any one traitor
Hi Faisal.
I will appreciate you for made this documentary in such a bold way.
Thanks :)
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
بہترین جناب
as a pakistani i realize now that shk mujeeeb was a great man
Sheikh Mujib Rahman Was a Patriotic Person, Injustice was done with him by West Pakistan as well as by His Own People at his death time. You are right Faisal Bhai.
love from Jamshoro, Sindh.
Pakistani hamesha se bangalion ko haqeer r na cheez smajhty rahy hain. Unko separation pe hum hi me majboor kia.
@@fahdhasnain979 ye baat ghalat he
@@danimalik2274 Ye baat sahih hai.
Bhi ap dekho agr ap sachy pakistani ho to aur ap py koi zulm karta hy to kia ap bolo gye k main sindh ko azad dekh a chahta hoon bulke ap un ka muqabala kro gye aur hamesha ik pakistan ki bat kro gye sheikh mujeeb rehman ka india sy rabta tha is liye us sny yeh kia yaqeenan is main hamari galti thi magr is ki itni bari saza ni thi
@@mabdullahshafqat2658 bhai bangaladesh mai ek progect nhi lgya jab kai idhar dam bnn rhy thy ek baar bhutto kutty nai media pr bangalio ko kah yai keely ka patto sai tashref saaf krny wali qaum ko kia zarort tarqi ki bhutto jesy saur hi peda huye pakistan mai
As always, excellent analysis, someone who has read "Shahab Nama" by Qudrat-Ullah Shahab, will totally agree with this vlog. Great work to make the new generation aware of our history. I wish we could put the Hamood-ur-Rehman Commission Report in our History books!
*Sheikh Mujeeb ghaddar nahi tha, Bhutto ghaddar tha jisko Pakistani sharabi generals ne politician banaya, iske baad sharabi generals ne Nawaz sharif ko politician banaya, Pakistan ke sath ghaddari sharabi generals ne ki jo hamesha Bhutto aur Nawaz sharif jesay saanp peda krtay hain jo baad main sabko dastay hain* 😡
Ghaddari ka thappa lagana asaan hy dear. Mujeeb did his best to keep Pakistan one country, and going towards freedom from Pakistani Military dictators in the late 50s and 60s, was his last resort. On the other hand, Bhutto was blamed for a lot of things (that might have been done by Gen. Ayub's successor, Gen. Yahya). Bhutto's biggest mistake was becoming arrogant, which cost him his life in the end. We are unfortunate that our Army brass has tasted the blood and now they don't want to let go of power, especially after Gen. Zia's 11 years. From Aug. 1988 to Oct. 1999 they were in the background. After Gen. Musharaf all the way to April 2022, they have been playing cat & mouse. Things will not be right, as long as COAS is more powerful than PM and doesn't start saluting the Defence Minister, who is his actual boss, it's the other way around!
اس ملک ۔یں ہر محب وطن کو غدار کہا گیا اور غداروں کو ہر سہولت اور اقتدار دیا گیا شیخ مجیب بہت بڑا محب وطن تھا
He was a hero thanks for sharing the truth from Pakistan
Sheik Mujeeb ur Rahman have total loyalty with pakistan.if we read Independent history Seikh Mujeeb ur Rahman is win election 1971 but Bhutto don't want Prime Minister him.
finally we lose east Pakistan
since my childhood i hate shkh mujubir rehman but after realizing the truth i admire him and his philosophy. love for all bengladesh muslims from Pakistan. be united
dunya ka bhetreen insan ta
Sheikh mujid ur rahman was real hero who fight for this right
love from Pakistan
As a Pakistani 🇵🇰
We are sorry Bangladesh 🇧🇩
But We are brother ❤️🇧🇩🇵🇰
Thanks from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Thank you for your understanding; you may also demand of your government to say sorry formally to Bangladesh and settle the differences for a normal relation.
@@farhadfaisal9410 impossible some people still want us to be separated,, indians and india raw agents working in Pakistan,, these are the same people who started civil war in bengal and funded mukhti bani
Where from u _city
@@shamimakhter9598 اسلام آباد پاکستان
During our education, we, the Pakistani students, go through the 1940 Lahore Resolution many times and learn it by heart. We are used to writing long notes on it in the Pakistan Studies exam to get full marks. And all of us know that the word used there is "states". And "states" means "states". It is no wrong interpretation.
We, the Pakistanis, know very well that the name Pakistan came from the letters of Punjab, Afghan province (NWFP at that time), Kashmir, Sindh, and BalochisTAN. It symbolizes the northwestern Muslim majority units of the sub-continent. It should not have been thrown upon the Bengalis... They had the right to call their land Bangladesh or anything else for that matter...
The British created a united Pakistan, but I think the responsibility lied with the political leadership after that. They should have separated these two states as soon as possible, according to the 1940 Lahore resolution.
Anyway, I believe that the responsibility still lies with us i.e. with Pakistan to develop a better relationship between the two countries. For this, steps need to be taken on the highest level. It must be admitted, on the highest level, that the political leadership of West Pakistan showed a lack of political acumen and made grave mistakes.
Jinnah and Muslim league never talked about one state. They were in favour of Muslim states calling it Muslim India
@@imranahmad7871 yes, sir. You are right. If they had done it as soon as was possible, the situation would have been better perhaps.
Anyway, we can't do anything about it now. It is all done now... We can only work for a better future...
Responsinlity lies with political leadership ?Who were not even given a chance !
@@021muneeburrehman7 Sir, I have a different view about it with most respect. Whenever there is a martial law in this country, the army never does it alone. The military has always gotten support from a fraction of our political leaders because they are all always willing to put their respective political opponents aside by collaborating with the military. You can see that happening even these days. All the opposition wants the army to throw Imran Khan out. I am not saying that the PTI-led coalition government has come without the support of army. But do you see what these politicians are doing? Asking the military to do it because they are not able to mobilize public on a mass scale themselves. So they want an easy way out. And what will happen if PTI govt is thrown out? How will these opposition leaders stop military from toppling their governments in future if they ever come to rule? Will they have the required moral authority to stand against the army? No... They won't have it... They don't have it even now... This is unfortunate... But that is how it is... They must learn to solve their problems by themselves but they are always looking towards the military for help... Pakistan is not a state run by the Cabinet and the Parliament, it works like a traditional "Jirga"... And these politicians have been the part of that Jirga... They are not separate from it...
@@shmuqasimafter 1920 British spread linguistics nationalism for there devide and rule policy,many popular local leaders demand for unified state based on language ,but jinga fear because many of the linguistic state are Hindu majority,so jinga fear,and mohmed Iqbal inspired him for creation of Muslim majority state,
I am a Hindu indian
مغربی پاکستانیوں کی نا انصافیوں نے مشرقی پاکستان کو بنگلا دیش بننے دیا جسکے دوران لاکھوں مسلمانوں کا خون نا حق بہا اللہ کریم نے سب غداروں کو عبرت کا نشا ن بنا یا سبحان اللہ
عالي جناب الفظ مو اعيته ادع كرين آپکے ویڈیون مین مزہ آجائے گا
Very good presentation
Honest Interpretation of events. Congratulations! FSW ji.
Great Leader Sheikh Mujeeb ❤❤❤from Pakistan
Great respect to shaikh sb.. such a brave leader he was.. we are sorry sir..
It's very sad for us that our brothers were separated due to power's hunger of our politicians.
Not only politician also dictators
@@muhammadyasirkhanlohani6628 politician are always play as pupit by such dictators.
Your brother is happy in their country. Jo log Pakistan ka sath ha Pakistan na unko Kya deya
@@farooqkhan9260 Hum logo mein koi unity nahi hai.Hum log kabhi army se question nahi karte kabhi military dictatorship ke against stand nahi liya."Khuda ne aj tak us quam ke halat nahi badli
na ho jis ko khayal apne halat badalne ka".
@@musicalife859 itni mindwashing may kbhi koi question krta hy to phir uska hal nawaz shareef wala hota hy ! ( khud sb sy bara gadar therta hy ) Keep Quiet and live the few days of your life ! Question sirf politicians sy or wafadari sirf generals ki (Golden Rule ;:)
Very comprehensive and objective video. Thank you Faisal bhai. My family loves your videos. Great asset for generations to come.
🇮🇳🤝🇧🇩🤝🇵🇰
I remembered my father told me in 1992 about Pakistan army did wrong with Bangladesh 🇧🇩 peoples.....
Till now they are doing wrong with my Pakistan 🇵🇰 just for taken benefits of luxury life and power,
But Allah will safe our countries Pakistan and Bangladesh 🇵🇰 🇧🇩
In Shaa Allah
Because lot of Muslims sacrifice their life in 1947.
We're just SABBER
In Shaa Allah
Allah will provide us new leadership......
Ameen
Jazzak Allah Khair
Faisal Warraich Bhai