FSW Vlog | What can Pakistan learn from India's 1991 economic crisis? | Faisal Warraich
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лип 2022
- #fsw #pakistan #india #explained
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
🌒🌒🌒 Contacts for ads and marketing
📩 imfaisalwarraich@gmail.com
☎️ +92300-6957785
🌒🌒🌒 Social Media
🔷 Twitter / fswarraich
📺 Instagram / faisal_warr. .
📘 Facebook / faisalwarrai. .
🎥🎥🎥 Films you must watch before you die
░▒► The Ottoman Empire: bit.ly/3jGk2wo
░▒► Muslim Cold War 01: bit.ly/3P44djT
░▒► Muslim Cold War 02: bit.ly/3wfymUK
░▒► Muslim Cold War 03: bit.ly/3N0uPjU
░▒► Muhammad bin Qasim and Sindh: bit.ly/3yhvMQW
░▒► M. Bin Qasim & Raja Dahar: • The Real Story behind ...
░▒► The History of Arabs and Israel: • Origins of the Arab-Is...
░▒► Why the USA lost the Afghan war: • Why did the USA fail i...
░▒► Story of Charles Darwin and Evolution: bit.ly/3kOLgns
░▒► History of USA/America: bit.ly/2GkT5Ri
░▒► Pak India war of 1965: bit.ly/3vUJnvT
░▒► Pak India war of 1971: bit.ly/3vW0opE
░▒► The Universe complete Film: bit.ly/3w9BstD
░▒► Rise and Fall of Muslim Spain: bit.ly/397NI68
░▒► Who was Karl Marx: bit.ly/3sIdIfl
░▒► Last days of Saddam Hussain: bit.ly/3FsCjKf
░▒► Last days of Qasem Sulemani: bit.ly/3kRDvx9
░▒► Where is the family of the last Ottoman Caliph? bit.ly/3P8ZFbW
✌ The list of the greatest documentary films ever made
☀ History of Nations
• History of the United ...
• History of the United ...
• History of Pakistan #0...
• History of Afghanistan...
• The Ottoman Empire S01...
• Why Europe is more dev...
• How Powerful is Americ...
• Geopolitical Tales 21 ...
☀ Biographies
• Who was Genghis Khan? ...
• Who was Abraham Lincol...
• Wo Kon Tha #61 | Who W...
• The Story of Bengal E0...
• Wo Kon Tha # 002 | Who...
• Last days of Muhammad ...
☀ Science & Now
• The Universe # 001 | S...
• The Great Game 01 | Ho...
• Why Finland and Sweden...
• Evolution 01 | Human E...
• Two incredible stories...
• Islamic Golden Age 03 ...
☀Wars & Battles
• The Great Generals and...
• Why did the US lose in...
• Muslim Cold War 01 | S...
• History Of Pakistan | ...
• History Of Pakistan | ...
Thanks for watching my curios fellows, and always remember we love 💝 you all - Розваги
We had AB Vajpayee as opposition leader,who never played politics during crisis of India.Whereas,your opposition leaders instigating your people.We had a great Finance Minister,MMS who had no foreign passports.Whereas every bureaucrats in your country,every army general,every leaders have a foreign passports,and foreign business.
Hmmmmm......
You are right 100%😭
Yes you are correct brother.
No hate my friend,as a true Indian I really want to see Pakistan prosper,a stable and prosperous Pakistan is boon for India.But Problem is that your,leaders and Upper class.Everyone,who are attached to Pakistan Governance holds a foreign passport.Every Rich People or Upper Middle Class of your country wants to flee the country.They just made a UA-cam channel and give gyaan sitting from the luxury in foreign country.They do not want to work on grass roots level.
Maybe in India we have corrupt politicians,but we also have leaders which genuinely thinks for our country.Sadly,Pakistan didn't have them.Pakistan had leaders who transportedPakistan's resources to foreign offshore Bank Accounts.
but the time is not 1991
1991 - year of "End of history and the last man " Francis fukuyama - jubilation
USA was a confident nation that was ready to share and over confident about its economic might and was willing to give concessions
Today the USA is a mean - selfish - very less confident nation ... not ready to give any concession to any country
bickering and biting and ready to push his own mother under the bus for survival..
the times are not the same and hence your analysis is full of flaws.
P.V. Narsimha Rao is from my state and my district. I am proud that he allowed Dr.Manmohan singh to do reforms freely. which helped india to become 5th largest economy.
Very good information 🙏🙏🙏👍❤️
PV Narasimha Rao was one of the great personalities who had dedicated himself for his country, I bow down to such a great man.🙏
By the way I'm from uttar pradesh
Bayya pv narasimha rao mottham m.sing meedha vadhilesi chethulu etthesaadu
Ur state and district does not matter.
from "tea is fantastic" to "tea is unaffordable, lets drink sattu". pakistan have developed a lot
😂😂😂maze lena v jaruri h🤪
No problem we r very mehman dar phir aoou gay tu phir cahiyee peleyyeen gay jitni mrzi mahnge hou jaye
@@WaqasAli-tp1jf enjoy your mehangai🤪
@@Sagarkumar-qs1qe koye baat nahi bro apna time ayega
@@Sagarkumar-qs1qe main Pakistani hn by the way bro
india is a economical/entrepreneurial economy... Pakistan is a army run state.... an army run state cannot me economical viable state...
Isahalah murdabad pakistan 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I did not know that even pakistani channel can teach me indian history. 👍
More power to you brother.
he took everything from PRADHANMANTRI
Khud ki history padh le.
@@tichyleagues6189 any proof
@@Rajput1678 Pradhanmantri episode 20 dekh le 🐕🦺
Isiliye toh humaru hdi abhi bhi kam hain humre desh ke log khud ke desh ke bare main nhi jante.
Mr. Manmohan singh may not be able to deliver the role of PM properly beacuse of coalition but he is one of the best economist india had, even today he give suggestions on new policy and had a healthy discussion with the govt because its a question of national interest and all parties stand with it
Who said that MMS was not deliver their role as PM. Kindly check Indian economy during his regime. He believe on less talk but more more work. Have you remember mid 2007 and early 2009 it was there global financial crisis (GFC) refers to the period of extreme stress in global financial markets and banking systems, even that time Indian economy was not stable but emerging. And for your kind info that time MMS was In PMO. He was and remain legend. 🙏
Except economy there also other factors which are important sir ..example defence ...foreign policy etc if manmohan was a good pm ..he would have lahore after 26/11 ..like america did after 9/11 ..now even your army is pleading for seize fire 🤣🤣 modi bahut marega
@@priyanshusharma353 pulmawa gurdaspur attack b toh hue,,,2014 ke bad sab se jyda fauji sheed hue hmre
@@mdfarhanmateen412 but he cant stop scams and his china policy was very passive
Scams were done ministers of other parties and Manmohan Singh implemented RTI act,which proved negative for congress.Nuclear Deal done by him was biggest deal in the history of India.
PAKISTAN went to IMF 13 times.... still facing economy problem.
INDIA went to IMF 1 time ..... gave all the loan back with interest in few years .
Lesson- If you really want to do something for the betterment of the country you learn your lesson and do it in 1st time.
Good 👍
22 times, not 13 times
Duh it's 22
v right bro sad to our leadership
22nd time
There is so much pain in the eyes of Hon. PM P.V. Narsimha Rao sir. He is almost in tears giving this speech. With former PM dead and the economy dying, sach much dil pe patthar rakh ke aur sar pe kafan bandh ke ye faisla liya unhone !
The man did not get the respect he deserved, he should have gotten Bharat Ratna !
The problem was PVN son in law got caught in corruption. In urea import and land scam .its saddest part ..otherwise PVN would be given Bharath ratna award ..
A very well balanced and researched program based on facts, well done 👏
I m following many pakistani channel but this is only one pakistani channel that made content based on true facts and not on the basis of imagination. 🙏🙏
How many pakistani youtubers channels u follows?
And you are responsible for bailing out Pakistan in this financial crisis😂😂
@@jitendersingh4263 😝😝😝
Being an Indian very few people know the details of the Economic reform we had. Thank you for this content.
School nahi gye ho kya.?? Hame to 9th 10th mei economic reform bare mei padhaya gya tha
Iam seeing a significant change in the mindset of Pakistani citizens now they also want to develop and grow. This “will and mindset” will alone do wonders for your country. Don’t loose hope brothers one day you will also shine and rise. Thank you for your lovely comments, love from your neighbour 🙏🏼🇮🇳
Never underestimate the jihadi mindset of pakistan
Notice the dead silence, the lack of response to your comment, even though it ends in "love from your neighbour"?
You _really_ think their mindset has changed?
@@ArmageddonIsHere haha yeah you are right but things are changing, they are at least trying to introspect. Let’s hope for the best.
@@biggdaddyy
They are introspecting for _their_ survival, not yours.
Pakistan (the country, not necessarily the people) is what is called a "minimum satisfier": it will do the bare minimum necessary to wriggle out from a tough situation.
But once the danger is past, it's back to it's old ways again. You can _hope_ , but don't have expectations.
@@ArmageddonIsHere SiLenCE can SaY many things...but People WITH NERO MIND like you always fail to UNDERSTAND.....
Well explained based on research and facts..
Love from India 🇮🇳
War mongering dear just check it out war mongering is more in India than Pakistan, it is India who have placed 4 put of 5 army's operational commands at Pakistan's borders have placed 3 air force's operational commands at Pakistan's border.
Also when US was in Afghanistan India had 1 embassy and 4 consulates in Afghanistan a country where Indians number have never gone up from 5000 but in UAE where there are 3.5 million Indians India have only 1 embassy and 1 consulate
So question is that why India had so many consulates in Afghanistan anyone with a common sense they were there to support sponsor and finance terrorism in Pakistan working in the name of TTP BLA ISIS K BRA PTM and many others.
@@AbdulGhafoor-sw4oz go to FATF if you have a problem .
@@AbdulGhafoor-sw4oz Well, Any country with access to surplus funds would sabotage its enemy. india is doing it because it can and you are crying about it because that’s all you can. 😂✌️
@@AbdulGhafoor-sw4oz bhai,
1. Since taliban takeover, attacks on your army have increased, and there is no India in Afghanistan now that you can blame. So how is it happening?
2. India never indulges in terrorism like you, we have our own FP and other interests in Afg. We have had close ties with Afg since the time of independence.
3. You are wrong, there was a time when there were 90000+ Sikhs in Afg.
4. EVERY SINGLE WAR was started by you in the past. Even the 1971 war, you formally stated by preemptively striking an Indian air base.
5. Our 5 operational commands are placed against both China and Pakistan.
@@mrgyani
Interviews of those pilots who Inside East Pakistan territory attacked unsuspecting Pakistani pilots of F86 sabre and downed plane are available if you agree I will be sending you link.
Well balanced analysis….there is a need for series in history of Indian civilisation especially from Gupta and Ashoka period and political rift between various rulers
Agree sir
There is no need for that
@@jaspreetsinghkhalsa2961 nobody asked you
@@jaspreetsinghkhalsa2961 why no need? Like who are you?
Tumhari nasle ki nasle roangi maadhar chodon jaise economic problems tere desh men hai.
Or leader....aison ko to humlog gutter me bhi nhi rkhte jisko ki pata ho ki desh par pahad tootne wala hai or madhar jaat fir bhi apni fayede k liye poltics khel rha ho
What a irony now CEO of IMF is an Indian ....even Owner of East india company is also an and indian even Upcoming Prime minister of UK would be an indian (Rishi Sunak ji) .
I have research on this topic....Kudos to that time patriotic indians who save indian economy 🙏
Great analysis bro.
Wish Paksitan should work hard instead of too much depending on CCP.
And I am sure he/she gonna be so anti indian
@@hirenahir76200 Bro now people are realizing that there is no benefit for anyone in this animosity
East India company still exist? Great information.
CEO of IMF is Kristalina Georgieva.
CEO OR DIRECTOR of IMF is NOT indian. Check your facts properly before saying it.
From 1billion usd to 600+ billion usd forex reserves!!!
Thats how we transformed!!
Long way to go by friend. We are still one of the poorest country of the world and are HDI are dismal. We need to keep growing at 7-8% to keep reducing poverty and work heavily on reducing our dismal HDI numbers.
@@sandeepshah105 bhai mere hisab jab india petrol banane lag gaya ya ev pe shift ho gaya (jo ki hora we are in the beginning of ev gen) pir apan import karenge hi nahi petrol and pir voi paisa apan use kar sakte h
@@sandeepshah105 Poorest? How? Do you even know how economy works?
@AJ Mr Economist, look at the per capita income for India. It is among the lowest in the world signifying wealth concentration. Look at the HDI index of India, it is among the worst in the world.
@@sandeepshah105 Per capita income is useless lol Greece GDP per capita income is higher than China but it's defaulted on it's debt whereas China economy doing well similarly sri lanka GDP per capita income is higher than india yet it becomes a bankrupt nation and indian economy on the other hand doing well.
its Narasimha Rao, the man who rebuild India, and then india made long-term policies on Economies.
Don't forget manmohan Singh ❤
@@amantripathi7156 He is a Robot
@@footyshorts6323 ya like robot very smart and Efficient ❤❤
@@footyshorts6323 robot better than modi
Yes Manmohan Singh efforts also appreciated he and ex minister Sinha and his team made long term plans,
بھارت اور پاکستان میں سب سے بڑا فرق یہ ہے کہ جب بھی بھارت میں کوئی بحران آتا ہے تو تمام سیاسی رہنما اور عوام ایک ہو جاتے ہیں لیکن پاکستان کے لیڈروں کی ترجیح ملک اور عوام سے بڑھ کر اپنے مفادات کی تکمیل ہوتی ہے۔ وہ لوگوں کو گمراہ کرنے کے لیے مذہب دیتے اور استعمال کرتے ہیں۔
پاکستان کے حالات اس وقت یکسر مختلف ہیں، تمام سیاسی جماعتیں ملک کی خاطر اپنے اختلافات بھلا کر پاکستان کے لیے ایک ہو گئی ہیں۔ صرف دو جماعتیں ہیں جو پاکستان کا نہی بلکہ اپنا مفاد کو دیکھ رہی ہیں۔ پہلی تحریک انصاف اور دوسری مسلم لیک ق۔
Absolutely true. Army is your enemy. Imran Khan recognises and confronted and see what happened
@@ranashoaib88
Dream on!
That's what happens when you allow your "leaders" to keep a second passport. Their bags are always packed, and one leg is always out of the door....
Oh satta matka and rana shoaib shutdown your mouth 👄 🙄 we and imrankhan is struggling for pakistan 🇵🇰 we will grow inshallah 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Sir you forgot to mention that after IMF loan Govt of India issued $5 billion worth of bonds to NRIs and the patriotic Indians across the world responded and these bonds were oversold. Thankfully this $5 billion took IMF out of equation for ever.
1990s the decade that changed India Forever 🇮🇳
All credit goes to our great Economist sir Manmohan Singh 🙇
No all credit goes to PV Narasimha Rao
Even indians don't explain so well as you have done.
well done Faisal bhia
That's great 😃 now Pakistan will compare and its economy will get well
Lol... They don't need to because they are ahead of us... I'm a pakistani btw
@@yousafemail well esa nhi h..ache youtuber India me bhi h in economics
I wasn't being negative towards India.. I agree with you absolutely India has talent in every walk of life. India being an economical power and with their achievements India's focus is different to Pakistan.
@@yousafemail economical power not really.. would have to work almost 20 years for manufacturing and take 50% of people involved in agriculture to industry
Manmohan Singh was Outstanding Economist...he did excellent plan and executed perfectly....
Actually it was Pv narshima rao who was the real planner but congress betrayed him and gave all his credit to Manmohan
@@helloworld.w6075 thoda criset jata narsimha rao ku…lekin marshmallow rao aur Mann mohan sing ruling reign m Bhot zyada Timelapse hai…so Manmohan sing did because he is Well educated politician as Abdul kalam and even I really like atal bihari bhajpaye…legends❤️
He was pv Narasimha Rao who has introduced the reforms in the economy, manmohan was just taking orders like he was taking from Sonia Gandhi.
You are absolutely right ✅
Manmohan was following direction
In Pakistan our situation is bit different in these points:
01. In Pakistan we are continually facing political instability.
02. We had energy crisis which never allowed foreign investment in Pakistan
03. Terrorism, extremism and intolerance is a fundamental problem in Pakistan which india was not upto untill 2000.
04. Our military controls our industry they do not allow foreign investors to come and challenge their own hagemony.
That's why our liberalisation of 1990 didn't pave the road to progress but indian reforms of 1991 did.
Same solutions for Pakistan .....
Forget Kashmir
Eliminate extremist forces and terrorist groups from Pakistan .
Establish fresh relationship with India.
These still no intolerance in India after 2000. Some riots sure happen, but they happen in almost all countries.
@@bhatusonawane7054 you forget about India 🇮🇳 because the China is going to harap it soon
@@TECH-IELaa really 😂😂😂😂 India is the forth biggest military power and 5the biggest economics...with friends like USA, Russia, Israel,France ......does China have guts to touch India.....Indian army killed 40 Chinese with bare hands in galwan valley clash .....
.pakisthan is becoming the modern colony of China ...you don't have the money to pay there debt ..dhire dhire tumhara Pura mulk kharid lenge .abhi to gwadar port hi liya..😂😂😂dhire dhire tumhare airports railways or bad me Pura country takeover.. Kar linye Chinese ...summer me aaya hai ki tumhari yah ki ladkiya bhi kharid ke le hate hai Chinese 😂😂😂.
@@TECH-IELaa china aaisa sochega v nahi 😀
Reasons for present situation of Pakistan --
1 ) pro active role of establishment in politics of country
2 ) political instability
3 ) active involvement in Terrorism
4 ) Free trade agreement with China which has been destroying their local industry since it came into existence .
5 ) Loans -- at high rate from China
6 ) High level corruption
7 ) over obsession for Kashmir
8 ) No trade ties with India which has increased their import bill and inflation in the country --- balance of payment crisis
9 ) weak foreign policy
10 ) bad relations with neighbors ( Iran , India , Afghanistan etc. )
11) high expenditure on Military
12) No rights to balochis , sindhis , mujahirs , hindu , Minorities , --- increase in separatists tendencies , govt .. Failed to tap potential of individuals from such communities ...
13 ) claiming so called religious superiority ..... Over obsession with religion
14) no nationalism
15 ) standard of education ( meagre spending on education )
16 ) military mindset of people 16 ) conservative society ...
17 ) communal mindset of society
Aur hmare masoom Pakistani bhai aj b India ko Pakistan se gareeb bolte hn...
Fact is fact, India is far ahead from Pakistan
Koi bhi pakisatani india ko pakisatan se garib mulk nahi bolta hai.
Unhone taraki ki hai humne nahi ki hai mai khud bolata hu
@@ahmed-sq6us bhai hum aur tarakki kr lete pr Humaye yaha starting se kafi samay tak single party system raha wo thi congress jo unhone chaha wo hua abhi jo bhi aap aggressive response dekhte ho Indian foreign policy m ya Indian people m wo kai salon ka accumulation h jaisa india ko yaha k logon ko treat kiya gya unhe misinform kiya gya ye uska gussa h actually m current k events itna bada reason nahi h isiliye kabhi aapko lgega ki yar main acche se baat kr rha hu tab bhi koi Indian mujhe ulta reply kr rha h actually m ya to wo abhi k teen h 😂 ya wo purana accumulated gussa h india m rahkar hi india ko kuch had tak samjha ka sakta h bahar se aap india ko kabhi nahi jaan paoge
Political stability matters alot. Look at India, Bangladesh, Veitnam etc. so many example in our neighborhood. Our elites are short-sighted and insincere with the nation.
Lol u dont realise. India is one of the most unstable countries in whole world. India is more unstable than Pakistan Or any other country
"Pakistan is an experiment"
----- Maulana Abul Kalam Azad
"Pakistan will be a laboratory"
----- Muhammad Ali Jinnah
Experiments don't run forever.
And sometimes they even blow up the laboratory.
@@ArmageddonIsHere lol.
@@ArmageddonIsHere and when they are successful they are groundbreaking.we are currently going through a hard time but these things will allow us to create a masterpiece.keep doubting and hating and we will show you.
@@basheerwayne69
India goes _ONE_ time to the IMF, repays ahead of schedule and never goes there again.
Pakistan has been *22* times to the IMF; like a drug addict, it can't seem to kick the habit and keeps coming back again and again, to the point that even the IMF - famously called "lender of last resort" - the lender who will lend when no one else will, doesn't want to see Pakistan again.
And you think you "will show us"?
We have seen enough and the story is always the same!
We as Pakistanis should be united and work hard for Pakistan ❤
India ki gdp 2.9$ trillion nhi hai 3.5$ trillion hai jo ki 5 th rank par hai
Forex reserve 600$ billion + jo ki 4 rank par hai
ہم اس وقت تک ترقی نہیں کرسکتے جب تک سیاست آرمی کرے گی، اور عدلیہ حساس ادارے چلائیں گے. قومی مفاد پر زاتی مفاد ترجیح ہونگے.
Proud to be indian 🇮🇳💚 muslim allhamdulilah i love my nation and i respect all nations 💚💚
ohhhh achaaa
Try eating beef
Haha... Indian Muslim
Now u should be ashamed of being called yourself an indian owing to the rising monster of hindutva 👎
Indian and pakistan need to learn peace or atleast speak proper dialogue .
A well researched journey to India's past in its economic troubled period of early 90s.
All kudos to creator(s) & specially to speaker Faisal Bhai towards fair & unbiased analysis !
Jahil or jihadi Pakistani kee facts wrong hai like Ex PM Chandra Shekhar belongs to Samajwadi Party
From begging to 8th largest creditor of imf . Proud to be Indian 🇮🇳🇮🇳.
Faisal bhai, I was busy preparing for my entrance exam when I received a notification of your video and I couldn't ignore it even though I wanted to because your videos are so interesting.❤
Same here brooo
Neet de rha hai kya ....mai ne save to watch later kiya ....mai bhi prepare kr rha hoon....5 din mai zindagi ka faisla hone wala hai
but the time is not 1991
1991 - year of "End of history and the last man " Francis fukuyama - jubilation
USA was a confident nation that was ready to share and over confident about its economic might and was willing to give concessions
Today the USA is a mean - selfish - very less confident nation ... not ready to give any concession to any country
bickering and biting and ready to push his own mother under the bus for survival..
the times are not the same and hence your analysis is full of flaws.
🤣🤣🤣 Maksad he Pakistani awam ko Nawazo league ko support kro koi masla hee nhn he k Agr mehngae ho rhi he to.
Lagta he is video k lie khas Mal Mila he Bhai sahib ko
India learnt and chose the right way and now we have to do so
Very hard for us thanks to corrupt politicians , + India is a authoritarian Hindutva regime acting as a Democracy, they can do whatever they want in terms of politics or economics
As dr. Manmohan singh said " history will be kinder to me" and now india is witnessing it.
In very humble words i also wanna mention that pakistani army n terrorism both are hazardous for its growth. They always create political instability in pak which is a major difference btw india n pak. Indian govt is sovereign but pak's govt is totally under army's pressure.
1st thing pak is not a strong enemy for india...but india is....we spend most of our budget on army, military stability because we have the worst neighbors ever, i am eye witness of Baluchistan terrisom (raw), now all we want is to get rid of india's evil hands, we didn't need to be a nuclear power but we did it to survive. And 2 thing is our corrupt politicians,,,,,our people are namak haram they support again and again these Satan.
@@ishan8394 India face enemy from 2 sides. Pak army is corrupt more than its politicians. No check on terrorism. Pak knows India is never gonna attack them and initiate a war, India will only respond. Secondly pak foreign policy which is tilted towards USA since inception is a blunder, India never took any side too strongly, thats y its sovereign with its decisions.
History will be kinder to MMS as FM, not PM. His second term as PM was a disaster
@@mlg1279 at that time also he saved India when world was under recession.
@@priyabisaria5030 Not really. The problems were just postponed to 2011-12, when the economy was in the doldrums.
Also, he was passive, with scams and corruption cases booming.
We are Now 3.6 trillion doller economy
And now we are on top 5😎
Indeed India struggled alot. We should learn from them
🤣🤣🤣 Maksad he Pakistani awam ko Nawazo league ko support kro koi masla hee nhn he k Agr mehngae ho rhi he to.
Lagta he is video k lie khas Mal Mila he Bhai sahib ko
@@AbdulGhafoor-sw4oz bsdky political baat ki hy mny koi ? Apni bhen mat paish kro idr.
@@AbdulGhafoor-sw4oz 🇮🇳 py charay pmln bhi pti bhi or tu bhi
Bete ko baap se sikhna hi chahiye 😂😂
@@pavitraprabhakar1
Jigar bap Pakistan hee tha Jo k tamam aalmi sazisho k bawjood bhi or sanctions k bawjood bhi 4 decades se ziada time tak India se ziada behtr financial position me tha
Wese ajeeb bat he na Jo khud ko bap keh rhe he. Wo ek din bad yane 15 August ko peda hua 🤣🤣🤣
Sir shrilanka economy crisis par ek video please ❤❤❤
Love and Respect from India I ❤❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳
Love from 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
❤️ From 🇮🇳
This is the first video of yours that I have watched and I am extremely impressed. You are the first Pakistani youth who is well informed about history and knowledgeable about things. Just one small clarification, as of today, India's GDP is $3.4 trillion and we are the 5th largest economy.
I love my india 🇮🇳
Proud to be indian 😎
No matter what I always support my india ♥
We are not traitor like Pakistan who was divided our country
Bhagat Singh Zindabad
Manmohan Singh zindabad
We need French Secularism for better india 🇮🇳
We don't like religious state like Pakistan. Even if we majority We still want Secularism for peace ✌
Jai Hind
Jai Bharat
Liberal India , Secular India
Same 0% respect for India hate India more than france and Israel 😎🖤
Love you Bhai you spoke my heart......... secularism jindsbad
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 follow your culture first . It itself teaches secularism.
how lovely 😍
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 jyada secular mat ho bhai Apna dharm follow kr .
Jai shivaji jai bhavani 🚩
Solute to manmohan singh.
Need to read his books.
A great philospher of economics and finance.
phir madarasa kon jayega 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@dungurothu 😂😂
@@dungurothu Teri Amma to ashram ki gufa me jati hai gufa putra
No bro he was just following pv Narasimha Rao who was the one who reformed the economy
@@dungurothu 😂😂😂
Current India's nominal gdp is 3.637 trillion or foreign reserves is 596 billion
Best wishes Broo. Here Pak is F*cked.
@@FarhanUA-cam283 indian purchasing power parity gdp is 12.32 trillions 😂😂😂🤣🤑
@@FarhanUA-cam283 UA-cam pr world gdp live aati h you can check it
@@FarhanUA-cam283 hope so everything go fine and Pakistani army stop entering in politics
@@pavitraprabhakar1 bro don't be rude
Best Wishes from Mumbai. Excellent, unbiased, well-researched video. Keep it up ..regards.
just a correction indian economy by now is about 3.5 trillion but is 6th largest or fifth largest depends which website has published the report
report
3.6
From today its 5th largest.
@@nationalistcreator ✌🏻🇮🇳
Now 5th
let's not forget that India at the time of its independence completely abolishes feudalism because of that people got a chance to make progress in their lives unlike in Pakistan where feudal lords enjoy all types of protocol .
But Till the 1990s Pakistan was Way Ahead of India and Pakistan was the Richest and Most Prosperous of the South-Asian Countries till then.
🤣🤣🤣 Maksad he Pakistani awam ko Nawazo league ko support kro koi masla hee nhn he k Agr mehngae ho rhi he to.
Lagta he is video k lie khas Mal Mila he Bhai sahib ko
@@AbdulGhafoor-sw4oz Lagta ye hai k timatar ka rerha lagate ho 😂
Very true Noor.. I was surprised to see feudal system with thousands of acres owned by single name. In India farmers like us got the land registered on our name and started getting 2-3 times yield from it. Jamindari was abolished in 1952 and so many land reforms followed. Pakistan got most fertile land but since farmers dont own it, yield is half of what is grown at Indian side.
And the army is not dominated by any single ethnic group, so it's impossible for that single group to gang up and topple the civilian politicians, also India has a VERY vast variety of ethnicities and languages, ALL of who are very argumentative and indisciplined, in short it's hard enough to win a election AND stay in power but impossible to stage a coup and rule the country by force. Unlike Pakistan and Myanmar. Where the Punjabi and Barmar dominate the army and thus everyone and everything else. The result is there for all to see.
My dream both Pakistan and India may grow at a high speed and both the countries start doing healthy business between them.
Kind heart owner respecting
😂
Ab bas ho gaya yr bohot India Pakistan kar liye ismai luksan hum common logo ka hora hai
It can happen if india start dialogue with pakistan. India totaly refuses any talks with pakistan. India s behaviour is rude and totaly negative.
India is growing (in fact India is the fastest growing major economy in the world) without any trade with Pakistan.India does not need Pakistan at all. Practically there is no chance of smooth trade with Pakistan coz situation can get worse anytime and trade can come to halt yet again.
Very well researched brother even as an indian I didn't know this much happened 😂😂
He is a researcher 😒
I was in class 6 in India during 1991. Newspaper headlines used to show US very negatively like in nowadays Pakistan and we believed that US was forcing India to sign some World trade organization pact. Never knew that India was on the verge of bankruptcy at that time. Hope Pakistan can take this economic blow on the chin and work positively in right direction and grow economically. Take care Pakistanis.
Thank you 🙏🏾 brother.
I was 5 year old in 1991.
My second kudos for your fairly un-biased presentation.
By 1991, India had built great scientific temperament through great institutions like IIT. By 1991, India had also built great productive capacity in manufacturing. It was ready to take-off in 1991. Unfortunately Pakistan in 2022 is still contaminated with religious extremism and no productive efficiency. Contrary to liberalisation, Pakistan needs government intervention for atleast 20 years to get things in order.
and religious extremism has been contaminating India's so called educated society since 2014 or from 2004 Gujrat riots. two decades of extremism will eventually destroy India in a different way.
How shamelessly you are talking about religious extremisim when Muslims are killed by Hindu extremist groups everyday.
I agree with you. If 2day we are in this miserable condition is all because if most corrupt political parties. Sadly saying our Generals always supported them.
Well your comments are correct about the economy of Pakistan but the religious extremism is a menace that prevailed in both countries. Look at your country what the RSS and Bajrang dal doing. What the system is doing with dalits. And yes we have also religious problems so they exist on both sides but the point is the wheel of economy should be running as it did in India but it also created a huge difference between the poor and the rich. I would say in Pakistan the difference is way less than India because our labour earns much better than the Indian labour. In India one can become Mukesh Ambani but there are crores of people who dont even can afford a toilet
@@hidayatafridi1019 Then How come the "Human Development Index" of India way Ahead of Pakistan??
What a way to explain it
Amazing
Never thought a Pakistani would explain 1991 economic crises to indian 😂
no bro not us indian ... he explained it to the Pakistani citizens 😀
G bhi ye Hume Pakistanio ko dilasa dy rha he pr I love India even wanted friend ship but it's all in hand of India q k India her liahz se bra he (kia kr skty he
@@abubakarsiddique8676 we don't want pakistani begger to friendship 🤣🤣
Don't you ever listen 👂
Beggar can't be choosen 😅🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Your research and presentation regarding this topic compel me to come to the comments section to write a praise message for you, well done! It's was a fairly researched and unbiased presentation so kudos to you and your research team for this. Stay blessed and keep enlightening people.
Nirsima rao never bought properties abroad. This is the difference between our and their liberalization
Most important thing that Pakistan should learn from rest of the world is that don't take religion too seriously.
Yes but we are Stuck just Because Americans missions in Afghanistan
@@shazainbaloch2538 Stop giving excuses. Pakistani people don't work for improving their life they live in a delusion that they will go to heaven after their death but it's just a hoax created by desert cult.
@@shazainbaloch2538 no the main reason is that Pakistan adds religion in all things..which is not good
What about Isreal?
@@alizayn2170 there religion never stopped them from having innovation
after studying pak history of coups and instability idk how do you even think Pakistan can recover itself from economical crisis. pak has 2 possible future. either it will become a corrupt military state like myanmar Burma or become sri lanka a default state.
india had economical crisis but india never had a bad history like Pakistan. in order to understand or better predict future of something, we must understand its past.
pakistan 1965 era was believe to be the best era. that was because they had Bengal as engine, they has steel mils , jud mills which were all auctioned or closed down. Zia asked iranian manufacturers to close down due to Saudi. after separation of bengal if u see the graph, Pakistan economically was starting to sink.
similarly ppl think musharraf was doing well. No,,, all musharraf did was manipulating the expenditures by reduction and removal in government employments. he dissolved the whole parliament and court system for years. on the top aids from USA. The problem of crisis is deep rooted after separation of Bengal and then zia ul haqs mistakes on top.
investor do their thorough homework before investing into failed state. after 5 years of observation Volkswagen car manufacturer changed their mind and decided not to invest in Pakistan.
im 32, i can surely say i wont see pakistan grow in my remaining life unless a miracle happens. if they put their nuclear assets for 20 years for IMF, even if they pay off the debt. this will not solve the main issue
Thank you for showing a bleak outlook/future for a piece of land where 220 million ppl happened to be living in. Guess you are not the bearer of good news. 🙏🙏🙏 Some good points tho.
USA always provide aid without thinking that Pakistan will return on the other hand Pakistan's Friend China always give the loan on high interest rate, China is grabbing Pakistan
Greetings from Bharat, very sensible analysis.
India too has dark history . Before British jnvasion India was golden cage. In 1947 idnia was broke into 3 pieces ( India pak bangladesh). But India focused on itself unlike pak which focused in kashmir
He is saying shameful on putting gold in foreign banks at least he is showing little bit jealous to India 😅
Salute to great and smart brain of India 👌
It's actually considered a shameful thing in Indian society he is not wrong on that terminology I don't know about Pakistan & Bangladesh but india m agar aapko apna Sona ( ghar ka ho ya desh ka ) girwi rakhna pade to ye bhut sharmnak cheez mani jati h
@@peacefollower5026 but he is using this to show his jealous to India 😅
@@asiafarhima3930
Nope . Our ancestors stored gold for future but selling that gold means we wasted their hardwork and Generally we purchase gold on festival .
And this year Indian imported almost 100 tonnes of gold from open market :)
And Indian households have almost 25000 tonnes of gold as per reports
Thank you so much that time india prime minister pv Narasimha Rao ji and finance minister Dr Manmohan Singh ji for save india from economic crises in 1991
As a Indian 🇮🇳 I totally disagree with your starting statements on Liberisation
The thing you don't tell about it
That Liberisation is for Indian companies so that they can grow and promote made in India..
But we don't able to take benefit from the Liberation
That's the point 👉
after liberalisation western companies started business partnership with indian companies
@@Rahulravi_91 And the jobs they are providing is in huge number die to liberalization commen man get good job in company with respected salary to upgrade his living standards which creats money flow in market.
If commen man didn't had enough funds i don't care how much you put effort GDP never get high.
I am not professional economists but i never seen any country with people are struggling for food and the country is well developed.
ستو پینے سے سنت بھی ادا ہوجائیگی ۔ تو پھرترقی ہونا دور نہ ہوگی۔ واہ سبحان اللہ
Your videos changes my perception towards the other Pakistanis,you r truly a historian not a complete one but still good than others...You have sound research...kudos
But pakistan's economic issues are totally different from india's crisis and mostly pakistani economy is suffering and will suffer. many large sectors are privatized but problem in policy making, political instability, security concerns that's why foreign investers don't take interest in pakistan, educational and development of human resource, don't take serious agriculture reforms that's why production slowdown day by day.
In these all issues technocracy in economic decision is very important.
But complete economic liberalization also makes difference between poor and rich so some important and basic sectors of economy like transport health education and some other government should control like china and western europe then poor persons also will survive otherwise in free market economy rich will enjoy economic benefit as they are enjoying in pakistan now
But unfortunately military, political leaders, land Lords and other responsibil institutions don't take it serious. Because of their interest.
I would like to reply in one line about Pakistan
Pakistan is hard country that can be surprised like previous few back when Pakistan 5.8 GDP growth during pandemic
electoral system is the root cause of Pakistan problems. Only a dictator or Presidential system can manage it
@@ishaazvlogs you are 100% right my brother plus pakistan has an abudant amount of undocumented economy if pakistan gets its documentation done pakistan will take off instantaneously
but the time is not 1991
1991 - year of "End of history and the last man " Francis fukuyama - jubilation
USA was a confident nation that was ready to share and over confident about its economic might and was willing to give concessions
Today the USA is a mean - selfish - very less confident nation ... not ready to give any concession to any country
bickering and biting and ready to push his own mother under the bus for survival..
the times are not the same and hence your analysis is full of flaws.
Atleast some pakistan really know what was the real problem of pakistan it's totally different and pakistan need 20 year plan in which they stop using kashmir name because if you say anything about kashmir,india will use it's influence in global level and pressurized.
Bro agar ek bar Imf jane se india shramsar ho gya to 22 bar imf jane pe pakistanis ko kya hona chahiye 🤣🤣🤣
Pakistan ki besharm kaum hai unhe koi fark nhi padta 😂😂
BhikhManga🤣🤣🤣🤣
India's gdp in 2022 is actually 3.6T USD. The latest figures haven't been updated since 2020.
Now 4.5 Trillion doller.
Real Factful and True Explanation. And Analysis.
10 out of 10
You have provided wrong data about Indian economy now in terms of Nominal GDP India rank 5th in the world, GDP PPP India rank 3rd in the world and in forex reserve India rank 4th in the world.
JAI HIND🇮🇳🇮🇳
Actually he clarified about it in a live QnA, That data collection takes a lot of time and providing the right info is also his responsibility, but, when his videos are uploaded until that time things get change very often, Usually his team is very efficient in this area, it's very rare to see such error. I just checked the stats of Indian GDP and you're correct, it's on 5th in (Nom.)
@@kumailhaider3508 bro doesn't matter wo upar niche hoti rehti h .we were number 5 in 2018 then slipped in 2019.. maybe number 4 in few years
Faisal Warraich sb You are truly an inspiration.
I have seen a lot of Pakistani channels but the research from you is amazing 👍👍
So well written edited and perfectly made video .
Your voice remind me of me listening news on radio .
Very well researched and spoken ❤️
Take a bow
Wow! Sir
My research proposal have been completed with yours v log on indian economy...
India will become super power one day insha allah and ameen .. jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@mehakdeepsingh4849 love u bhai
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I agree brother.
Your prediction is right bro, we just don’t want to become economic power, but also need to become saviour of poor countries, a big brother. That is our culture. Vasudhaiv kutumbakam
I agree with you Pakistan is going down because of Punjabi
Very informative and very insightful. Clearly explained with facts and logic with no bias. Great job! and Thank you!
Critical reasoning and analytical thought process is a challenge in almost all countries. But in Pakistan, it becomes a crime. So much credit to you for the content.
P.V Narasimha Rao was a great politician to help to overcome the bankrupt situation
Overcome ni outcome
Unfortunately Congress betrayed pv narshima rao and gave his credit to Manmohan
@@robinakousar8024 thanks ji
And Dr Manmohan Singh ji also
Market was not closed for politics but it was done so that poverty can be reduced as liberalisation increases inequality.
@@DwindlingLamp Even with the current dip, I'm so glad 🙂 I've built my portfolio to $50,560 from my weekly trade. I'm having my fourth withdrawal in 10 business days 💯
@@oliviapourkarim5697 Investing is a stepping stone to success, investing is what create wealth.
@@priscilla9560 Bitcoin trading options is just like another business but in this case more sophisticated and advanced
@Pan Jun II Same here, I earn $13,000 a week. GOD bless Eric Williams , he has been a blessing to my family
@@Kelvinpatrick23 I wanted to trade but got confused with the fluctuations of price
Nehru restricted privatization
Narasimha Rao let privatization
That's it.
Nehru following Russia s 5 year plan
Narsimha Rao opened indian market to world
Narsimha Rao is a Gem. A true patriot. Salute to great leader.
Super power India 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jai hind 🇮🇳 🌷 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Economically,,, defence
In world
Excellent, probably the best politico-economic analysis I have come across.
Bhai Pak economy k present condition discuss kare
India to gold girvi rakha but Pak ne to
Sadke gvt office sports complex tak ko nahi bakhsha
Bacha fisal masjid parliament House supreme court pm house
O kab tak rakh sakte hy
Kindly inform us
As Pakistanis I'll say you are a gem and keep growing
Unbiased analysis. 👍 love from India 🇮🇳
They had Manmohan Singh what a great man and we had ishaq dar The right hand of Nawaz Sharif who's an absconder
Very informative. We should learn lesson from it.
Very well stated and informative video. Hope the people and politicians of Pakistan understand this.
Once I find "FSW Vlogs" and "Big Socho"'s new upload, I can't do my any very important work. Salute to you Faisal Bi. I be able to make me a clear point of view about National and international interests and trends by hearing your Vlogs. It's all very precious things that we have access in free due to your highness. May Allah give you it's reward.
Watching you since ur early videos on DSJ. love ur way of explaining things.
MashaAllah faisal bhai you are very talented❤️
Your Content is amazing. So much detail and unbiased analysis. Love from India.
Very pertinent and quality content with great presentation. More power to you bro!!
Brother can you please do a video on understanding inflation for an average pakistani and masses... The nation needs to know why the value of pak rupee has fallen so much, what made it go down. What we export vs our imports
Faisal i am one of your earlier viewer and Mashalla you have come along way Allah ap ko aur taraaki day... feels so good to see you grow they way you have... :)
Masha Allah
Aameen ❤️
Thanks for showing this part of Indian History Honestly....
Well done..
It's called LPG Liberalisation , Privatisation and Globalization after this step India became an open Market and then FDI was introduced . Foreigners started investing in India .
Great & Best of luck for the future👍
Same situation we are in.Good work.
*14:00** gold sirf dikhane ko nahi kharda jata bhai India m, sabse secure investment hota h ye, value hamesha hi badhti h gold ki, apne ghar ka gold girvi rakhna koi neech kaam nahi, tavi to India m kahawat h "jab ghar m pada ho sona to fir kyu ko Rona" but ye tumhe samjh nahi ayega, kyuki Islam m to gold kharidna haraam h*
Nehru didn't make India,he is one of the freedom fighters.....Nobody in 47 made India. BHARAT was always there ,many countries will go and many will form new boundaries but ek Bharat shrest bharat will always there.......
I am getting more and more knowledgeable because of your Amazing videos. Thanks to you Faisal Bhai 👍
The entire script has been stolen from the Indian show Prime Minister.
@@deepakdabral8091 so it means that it is all correct information
Indian election commission itna taqitwar q ha keh koi party election result pe sawal ni othati. Please es pe ek video bnae.
Kyuki election commission ke head or uski functioning me koi haat nhi dalta.. Indira Gandhi ne try kiya tha emergency laga ke
India me constitution kabhi bhi hata nhi h.. pakistan me uski value kabhi rhi nhi
Yeah waqai unfortunate ha. Pakistan me koi institution Azad ni ha. Or koi Kam ka bhe ni ha. Ksi party ne dhandli ka Rasta rokne ki koshash ni ki.
@@tanveerahmed729 as long army control karna chahegi yeh to hoga.. It's on pakistani people only
Well balanced analysis 👏👌 👍
Inspite of war Indian and Pakistani peoples will have to focus on true facts and growth of nation.
Thank you for such a great video and the learning which not only apply for nation but in life also👍