Why This Melody Is Actually Genius (Chainsmokers)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 288

  • @GreenFesh
    @GreenFesh Рік тому +772

    It's nice to see a musician appreciating mainstream music and not just saying that it's uninspiring bs that anybody could do. Yes, anybody could. But only they actually do it. It's not easy.

    • @neptune2973
      @neptune2973 Рік тому

      most mainstream music is butt and listened to by NPCs

    • @tommasobertini141
      @tommasobertini141 Рік тому +35

      i was thinking the same thing, mainstream music is underrated, is just that not many people can recognize how much work there's behind a pop song, and just because is pop of course is bad music

    • @CrazzyJokerr
      @CrazzyJokerr Рік тому +19

      Well, compared to other musical styles it's in fact very easy music. And due to the lack of complexity it's very easy to reproduce an therefore "easy". But without the feeling thats not gonna work anyway so 🤷

    • @leooooo795
      @leooooo795 Рік тому +24

      @@tommasobertini141 mainstream music is underrated? thats definitely a unique opinion

    • @scoobertmcruppert2915
      @scoobertmcruppert2915 Рік тому +2

      @@tommasobertini141 Yeah…I think it’s quite literally impossible for MAINSTREAM music to be underrated…

  • @heyitspixl
    @heyitspixl Рік тому +230

    if anybody's wondering, the name for that sustained note in the chords is called a pedal point or pedal note. it creates a lot of harmonic tension that resolves nicely back to the tonic, especially if the pedal point is the tonic or dominant (as mentioned in the vid)

    • @AlexRome
      @AlexRome  Рік тому +55

      Interesting. I’ll use this term instead of drone. What’s funny is that two of my production students are music theory professors and neither of them correct me when I refer to pedal tones as “running tonics” or “drones”. I’m going to go call them out and see what they say haha!

    • @supriyopal6067
      @supriyopal6067 Рік тому +3

      @@AlexRome what! 😂👍

    • @bencastor9207
      @bencastor9207 Рік тому +15

      @@AlexRome they likely don't correct you because they know what you mean and don't think it is important enough to call you up on.

    • @jaybefaulky4902
      @jaybefaulky4902 Рік тому +2

      well technically it's the minor 3rd and major7th it's written in key of Bminor but one could argue that it can be thought of as in Dmajor then it would in fact be the tonic and dominant, otherwise not. but I get your point ..the vocal melody is more of a Bminor thing though..Cheers

    • @jaybefaulky4902
      @jaybefaulky4902 Рік тому +1

      by the way the weird thing is it ''resolves' to the Major6th in Bminor so it's kinda weird and very interesting depending what key you perceive it as. for example I could tell someone that the song is ACTUALLY in 'G Lydian' and this would work as well in fact I think this is more accurate.

  • @darrenrobinson8317
    @darrenrobinson8317 Рік тому +140

    love the chainsmokers stuff,simplicity at its best.

  • @GOWENYT
    @GOWENYT Рік тому +79

    Nice to see someone actually dive into the creativity of The Chainsmokers instead of just jump on the hate train and pass! Great video

  • @sxoutz
    @sxoutz Рік тому +26

    "I could never be coldplay, but i could write a melody with a horn" -alex rome 2023
    Im dying rn 😂

  • @jalenpadilla7744
    @jalenpadilla7744 Рік тому +2

    Being able to not only label these concepts (drone, major and minor scales, and how they fit in as themes) but recognize them in a song and notice how they are standard setting in the industry… I am blown away. Will definitely change how I listen to seemingly mainstream electronic music from now on.

  • @benjiviews4300
    @benjiviews4300 Рік тому +48

    Love your analysis videos, super interesting, useful and entertaining

  • @koppy82
    @koppy82 Рік тому +8

    The best part is when they add in ANOTHER top melody, those harmonics are insane

  • @moonman1533
    @moonman1533 Рік тому +10

    Please do more breakdowns like this.. They're fantastic! I'm always amazing how Calvin Harris makes his chords and melodies and switches them up with simple (yet genius) techniques like that.

  • @ryun3307
    @ryun3307 Рік тому +7

    You're the best, Alex. Still slowly applying my bootcamp training.

    • @AlexRome
      @AlexRome  Рік тому +1

      Ayyy Ryun! Cool to see you here.

    • @ryun3307
      @ryun3307 Рік тому

      @@AlexRome Thanks:)

  • @MalikAmer87
    @MalikAmer87 Рік тому +3

    Amazing short informative video, this is why I love this channel.

  • @swayybeats
    @swayybeats Рік тому +2

    I've always noticed that the drop had one common note in each chord, good to finally see the musical theory behind it and actually made me realise that it's a common theme throughout the song

  • @elijahcruz8895
    @elijahcruz8895 Рік тому +5

    Your videos are so good, they make me wanna keep producing no matter what! I quite literally started livestreaming me making songs because of your channel.

  • @MatrikxXI
    @MatrikxXI Рік тому +46

    Sometimes, instead of throwing in everything we know, what we need to do is just add a pinch of simplicity,. and we are good to go :D
    Btw, Can you do analysis on Illenium's music too? and how he keep his signature consistently?
    That will be much appreciated

    • @AlexRome
      @AlexRome  Рік тому +14

      Yep! Been brainstorming for a video that dives into that whole Illenium style sound.

    • @MatrikxXI
      @MatrikxXI Рік тому +1

      @@AlexRome That would come out amazing IG!! I'll be waiting for that!!Keep it up Alex 💪

    • @wesleymarquardt4708
      @wesleymarquardt4708 Рік тому

      Yes! An Illenium breakdown would be amazing!! I've always enjoyed his music and while I'm not an amazing musical guy, I always find it interesting to see the technical aspects of my favorite artists.

    • @UhKimboze
      @UhKimboze Рік тому

      @@AlexRome I gotta say, his chords on his Say It remix are my favorite he has ever done. It's a unique sound I've never seen anybody successfully replicate.

    • @alicehoon7474
      @alicehoon7474 3 місяці тому

      @@AlexRomecan you please sound design the synth sound,melody of something just like this

  • @rodybothe3329
    @rodybothe3329 Рік тому +5

    This song is pure gold! Thanks for the explanation, awesome to see it in depth.

  • @aspect795
    @aspect795 Рік тому +5

    great balance of educational, entertaining and interesting. awesome video man

  • @raincastmusic
    @raincastmusic Рік тому +1

    As someone who actually liked SJLT, i really appreciate those simple yet creative techniques

  • @mayurtummewar3312
    @mayurtummewar3312 Рік тому +1

    4:28 its a GOLDMINE from here on

  • @Giannboy1
    @Giannboy1 Рік тому +2

    Great stuff Alex. Thanks for the Free Chord Building Blueprint!
    Gianni

  • @catmasterOP
    @catmasterOP Рік тому +3

    so simple yet so sophisticated

  • @ItsJustOakleyy
    @ItsJustOakleyy Рік тому +3

    Really great video. Educational, entertaining, and explained well to all skill levels. You gained a fan today!

  • @yepyepmusic
    @yepyepmusic 6 місяців тому

    This remake is so accurate.
    Thank you for this video!

  • @Best-Regions
    @Best-Regions 11 місяців тому

    Gold. All of these are gold. Thank you Alex. Adds so much depth and appreciation

  • @LarsLentz
    @LarsLentz Рік тому

    That was a great deconstruction - thank you!

  • @mayurtummewar3312
    @mayurtummewar3312 Рік тому +3

    that drop was exactly what fascinated me everytime I listened to the song
    thanks for explaining the magic 🤩🤩🤩

  • @akeyasa2228
    @akeyasa2228 Рік тому +2

    What’s really amazing is classical composers doing stuff like this in their head hundreds of years ago.

  • @tillenbillagwa7548
    @tillenbillagwa7548 Рік тому

    That's it I'm doing music this summer. (Your content is inspirational, bud)

  • @88keysLA
    @88keysLA Рік тому

    Most useful channel for music production on UA-cam

  • @DanLaDue
    @DanLaDue Рік тому

    Usually I think your videos are a little click-baity but this one is great

  • @jacobl7451
    @jacobl7451 Рік тому +1

    as a producer,
    I WANT SOMETHING JUST LIKE THIS

  • @YamenJahangeer
    @YamenJahangeer 7 місяців тому

    Love the hat/cap you are wearing. I can't stop just only focusing on it through out the video. FYI, Love your videos. I watch them all.

  • @fornoreason8822
    @fornoreason8822 Рік тому +1

    Take it easy Alex, their music isn't all that, it's just corporate pop with a team of producers but it is cool that you analyzed it. A theorical breakdown is always good to see for the independent. Peace.

  • @jessiedupuis4633
    @jessiedupuis4633 Рік тому +5

    Your freaking amazing man! Love what you do!

  • @prodnaki
    @prodnaki Рік тому +2

    05:56
    Bro can't be serious here💀

  • @gawergy
    @gawergy Рік тому

    "I'll never be coldplay, but I can write a melody with a horn" KILLED ME ahahah

  • @MicahBratt
    @MicahBratt Рік тому +1

    I did a remake of something just like this a few years back. Still love the song. Coldplay really gave it a vibe

  • @hillelshmuel1354
    @hillelshmuel1354 Рік тому +4

    I really liked this video. Please do more analysis for songs like this

  • @mandieheart8577
    @mandieheart8577 Рік тому +2

    I love this type of analysis! Thanks for making

  • @kalebsatterfield2443
    @kalebsatterfield2443 Рік тому +54

    "nobody before did that" yes alex that exact idea has been used in tens of thousands of songs of so many genres. Stacking 5ths is incredibly common. This chord progression is in every other song basically.

    • @ISHI6I
      @ISHI6I Рік тому +7

      But what else is he gonna copy, paste, rinse, and repeat for content

    • @koppy82
      @koppy82 Рік тому +7

      I think his point is that most songs with this style of song writing doesn't just get 2 billion plays or get as big as that song did

    • @yaboiii6214
      @yaboiii6214 Рік тому +8

      yeah this video is top tier comedy honestly, he cannot be serious

    • @ISHI6I
      @ISHI6I Рік тому

      @@yaboiii6214 I could make a PH pov video with his reactions to the most basic chord resolutions

    • @majorbajor
      @majorbajor Рік тому +10

      @@yaboiii6214 yeah it's really hard to believe that someone could do those reactions unironically. Chainsmokers are successful because their music is simple. And this video acts like playing eighth notes instead of quarter notes is like a huge revolution. Or that the fact that the drop has a rhythm is praised.

  • @jdotx9843
    @jdotx9843 Рік тому

    3:54 what a poetic line.

  • @maxsoutherland
    @maxsoutherland Рік тому +3

    Brilliant work! Great video! Thank You!

  • @newportreds6710
    @newportreds6710 Рік тому +1

    love this! wish you replicated the beautiful guitar melody/solo towards the end of the song

  • @LetsHaveFunJeremiah_LHFJRandom
    @LetsHaveFunJeremiah_LHFJRandom 11 місяців тому

    I remember when i used to hear that song come on a lot in 2017 even whenever i was in Middle School.

  • @JohnPaul-oq6ud
    @JohnPaul-oq6ud Рік тому

    I've watched a handful of your videos and could not get over your HEAVY Delco accent. Hat and Jersey confirms it

  • @djraff_official
    @djraff_official Рік тому

    thanks for the guide mr.rome chainsmokers is one of my favorite song in my list instead of playing online games,i focused myself to create and mix the song using fl studio and so this time im going to read the 7 step chord building blueprint in my laptop............... keep up the good work bro im always wacthing your videos

  • @SwedishLatino
    @SwedishLatino Рік тому

    love your enthusiasm man haha great content as always

  • @stephenquinn3251
    @stephenquinn3251 Рік тому +1

    Awesome video! I love the chainsmokers so it's fascinating to see the breakdown like this. Keep up the great work 🙏

  • @suchitputhalat4796
    @suchitputhalat4796 Рік тому

    East or west Sir Alex Rome is the best !🤩

  • @zhidongwu9059
    @zhidongwu9059 Рік тому +3

    Isn’t it using the 456 progression in d major? And the drone is just using the tonic note of d major? I’m still a noob, help plz. So confused when Alex said it was using the relative D in the key of B minor

    • @AutPen38
      @AutPen38 Рік тому

      It's one of those songs in which the key/scale is ambiguous because it doesn't begin or end on an obvious tonic. Most websites report it as B minor, but Wikipedia's editors decided it's in D major. Since both scales contain the same actual notes, it doesn't really matter, and you can describe it according to your own personal preference.

  • @peachellowoverload
    @peachellowoverload Рік тому +2

    is that drone note within the chord progression cau i saw that D is written just half a note above C#

  • @MrTroller97
    @MrTroller97 Рік тому

    my favourite song of all time! the drop makes me float every time. thanks for making this - a wonderful deconstruction :)

  • @eljohncabildo4086
    @eljohncabildo4086 Рік тому +2

    I would like you to do a breakdown video of their song "Roses". I believe it is their most overlooked song. The drop on that song is a thing of beauty.

  • @justinsprout7611
    @justinsprout7611 Рік тому

    Super cool video thanks dude! I feel like I always am over complicating my composition trying to make it unique and interesting, but rarely ever try to make just a simple aspect of the composition interesting in itself. Mainstream/pop has so many things to learn from in making a song listenable and marketable

  • @LokiVR2045
    @LokiVR2045 16 днів тому

    6:15 bro why you stop it right before the drop I was rocking out 🤘😎

  • @alexzehnmusik
    @alexzehnmusik Рік тому

    You're amazing man 🔥

  • @moadot720
    @moadot720 Рік тому

    I like how I could tell it was about Something Just Like This from how the rhythm looks on the MIDI.

  • @jv_matos
    @jv_matos Рік тому +1

    Everyone jokes that they only use the 5 not piano to write songs and etc but it takes real geniality to make #1 hits in Pop, Dance and Trap music

  • @supriyopal6067
    @supriyopal6067 Рік тому +1

    That's really very interesting! Great video ❤️

  • @donn1473
    @donn1473 Рік тому

    Great breakdown Alex!

  • @supernova1831
    @supernova1831 Рік тому +2

    Loved it, please make more videos like this 😃

  • @abdullahal-shiyab7930
    @abdullahal-shiyab7930 Рік тому +7

    avicii did it first in silhouettes

    • @sjmusic4804
      @sjmusic4804 5 місяців тому

      He was a guinius he has a lot of contribution in electronic music

  • @perkiousmusic
    @perkiousmusic Рік тому +3

    Honestly, I have a big issue with The Chainsmokers that is quite different from what most people have and that is their unwillingness to move away from the mainstream they did a remix competition for their track the fall and the winning song that they chose was your generic pop house track which confused me when I first heard it because there were people who had remixes like mine who went out of their way to do unique and creative ideas that is really my biggest gripe with The Chainsmokers they're not willing to leave their comfort Zone and it can be infuriating especially when your remixes you did is better than the remix that they put out

    • @shayanmandal1270
      @shayanmandal1270 Рік тому +1

      Listen to their new album pal and fully.

    • @perkiousmusic
      @perkiousmusic Рік тому +2

      @@shayanmandal1270 I was referencing their remix competitions and no I haven't heard anything experimental in their latest album I did listen to it nothing underground everything was just safe

    • @Cry_ct
      @Cry_ct Рік тому +1

      To be fair, the pop house generation of music was the only good one. Modern music is super trash.

  • @ArtEntity
    @ArtEntity Рік тому

    these are the best freaking videos ever

  • @hannahbackward
    @hannahbackward Рік тому

    When you chop out the notes to give it a syncopated feel, the downbeat of the second chord changes to the second bar instead of a quarter note after This probably confused a lot of viewers. Your videos are great none-the-less. The little details used to drive me nuts when I was beginning. You are as thorough as anyone else! I never took your Bootcamp but I have taken a few of your competitors and I can tell you they all leave out a lot more stuff than you. All the best stuff is resampled and they tell you to just pull it into the project. It never fails. I'm like, wait, hold on, darn it, that's why I paid more than $100 to take your course to learn how you made that rolling baseline in your song or that "Big Reverb Lead" that sold me on your course. I don't want no stinking sample. Lol. Anyway, you provide a hell of a lot more than others and anyone could see by the visuals in this video exactly where the A major chord fell. I must give the Chainsmokers credit for that minor tweak because it changes the feel completely. Very glad I learned that trick from you, Alex! Thanks!

  • @ashisangini
    @ashisangini Рік тому

    this song is still one of my favorites! thanks for the explanation...

  • @dobsashimself
    @dobsashimself Рік тому

    Well done... oftentimes the simple ideas are the best ideas!

  • @phamdevin
    @phamdevin Рік тому

    Thank you Alex! This is great knowledge.

  • @ldcommando1616
    @ldcommando1616 Рік тому +1

    It’s a shame people ignore or shit on mainstream music so much. This stuff is fascinating

    • @leooooo795
      @leooooo795 Рік тому

      they shit on it because its involves less creativity and music theory then something like TPAB

    • @mrbuffwoopmusic8788
      @mrbuffwoopmusic8788 Рік тому

      @@leooooo795 me when my favorite rapper doesn't get any attention for 0.2 seconds

  • @NikBeats2k
    @NikBeats2k Рік тому

    Chainsmokers are MAD GENIUS 🔥

  • @wuhn_media
    @wuhn_media Рік тому

    Now I know why I loved the song

  • @LUXSTARI
    @LUXSTARI Рік тому

    Great video. Amazing explanation.

  • @llaarryy180
    @llaarryy180 Рік тому

    Fantastic breakdown and go birds!🦅

  • @PJSvndsn
    @PJSvndsn Рік тому

    So simple yet so beautiful

  • @adoniscious
    @adoniscious Рік тому +3

    Wow 😳 this is so insanely awesome 😎😳🔥🔥🔥
    First comment 😂

  • @johndoe_1984
    @johndoe_1984 Рік тому +7

    Bach is genius. Mozart is genius. Beethoven is genius.

    • @kadinimdad
      @kadinimdad Рік тому

      Grass is green sky is blue you wanna cookie?

    • @gaopinghu7332
      @gaopinghu7332 Рік тому

      Uhhh what?

    • @AutPen38
      @AutPen38 Рік тому +1

      They can't be geniuses. They never stacked fifths like the Chainsmokers. Nobody ever did this. Oh wait.

  • @cydrawal
    @cydrawal Рік тому

    alex is totally giving off stoner vibes nowadays it’s lovely

  • @rechasebass
    @rechasebass Рік тому

    Great video really enjoyed it.

  • @Test-ev4oh
    @Test-ev4oh 3 місяці тому

    Awesome video, but which vet sounds did you use in this video? So what did you use to make the guitar and piano sound?

  • @MrBrownAlliance
    @MrBrownAlliance Рік тому

    i always enjoy your content very much!

  • @chance2971
    @chance2971 Рік тому +1

    Hey I noticed an issue on the document you provided in the description. The A major and A flat major chords are mixed up.

  • @doorwaysintomusic
    @doorwaysintomusic Рік тому +4

    thank you so much for your analysis of this song -- I learned so much and you made the learning very enjoyable!

  • @solomonomusic
    @solomonomusic Рік тому +1

    Hate the birds, but love your tips as always!

  • @matthiastrilsbach7292
    @matthiastrilsbach7292 Рік тому

    hey! love the video! would you (or anyone that knows) mind sharing what guitar vst was used? thank you!

  • @jackmatthess
    @jackmatthess Рік тому

    things are already starting to get sparkly I can feel it"

  • @danielrenjiro
    @danielrenjiro Рік тому

    i wanna see full process of making song
    by chord progression to mastering
    do it man plz, so freaking interesting

  • @Peach10001
    @Peach10001 Рік тому

    Brother my brother...I gotta....I have no words...I was just scrolling through and I can across you......I tell you my story I m
    A fan of TCS for a very long time and recently they didnt made any hit songs that made me kinda upset cause I m little biased to them but you were the first to appreciate their work....I don't know I m just feeling very nice after watching you video
    I love you😭😭🥺❤❤❤❤❤

  • @derekfenton1371
    @derekfenton1371 Рік тому

    what piano were you using in the beginning for the chords it was so warm

  • @will_hunt
    @will_hunt Рік тому

    Great breakdown

  • @darthrevan6713
    @darthrevan6713 Рік тому +1

    Is this song actually in Bm? The constant drone in D leads me to believe it is actually just in D without ever hitting the tonic. If it was in Bm it would sound like it would want to lead to the Bm but it doesn’t.

    • @AutPen38
      @AutPen38 Рік тому

      It's ambiguous because it doesn't start or end on the tonic. Most websites say it's in B minor, but Wikipedia says D major. It basically comes down to personal preference. I think you could even say it's in G Lydian or something like that.

  • @xtadeus4777
    @xtadeus4777 Рік тому

    Thx for the video !
    That is a real good headphone that can keep you warm, even if it is -10 degrees celsius outside right ?

  • @Vintsent
    @Vintsent Рік тому

    =as Always ! Just Amazing, thanks a lot Alex

  • @GhostEntertainmentMusic
    @GhostEntertainmentMusic Рік тому

    good video 💯

  • @MikeyD
    @MikeyD Рік тому

    Man that was a great video

  • @tonycinbox
    @tonycinbox Рік тому

    What also makes that song amazing is Chris Martin's vocal s.

  • @Janis.540
    @Janis.540 Рік тому +2

    so cute how you're feeling it so hard every time haha ♥

  • @hwd98
    @hwd98 Рік тому

    “And it just made me wanna quit!” 😂

  • @Gagan_salwan
    @Gagan_salwan Рік тому

    Damn i was waiting for that last melody at the end of song (it is sooooooo emotional)😂, great work tho man. nice breakdown

  • @franklingrear5326
    @franklingrear5326 6 місяців тому

    been watching for a bit and this is how i find out youre an eagles fan. go birds

  • @Riyan-fk4oj
    @Riyan-fk4oj Рік тому +1

    Amazing explanation my guy! You’ve definitely proven that you got some cool analysis talent that’ll help you understand the theory behind it. Btw, don’t feel discouraged if someone makes better music than you do, music takes time and effort (which The Chainsmokers had plenty of, specifically the effort part because the song was written by 5 people!) Anyways, great job explaining everything in such a short amount of time and I’ll see you on the flip side! 💪

  • @igorgrego6996
    @igorgrego6996 Рік тому

    Would this method be a pentatonic scale?