I have! Water, 35 liters Carbon, 20 kg Amonia, 4 liters Lime, 1.5 kg Phosphorus, 800 g Salt, 250 g Saltpeter, 100 g Sulfur, 80 g Fluorine, 7.5 g Iron, 5 g Silicon, 3 g Plus 15 miscellaneous trace elements
Their mother had money in the closet. We don't know how much all that cost but they likely used that money to get everything that wasn't easy to get ahold of.
Whats great about this scene is it shows us Ed's only learned enough to start moving forward, but he's no where near the man he'll be at the end of the series. The writers made a good choice in showing his arrogance here, he's a little kid with a lot of power and knowledge but only one traumatizing event as experience.
damn, way to cut off the ending. In case anyone is wondering he says about the sun, "it's just a mass of hydrogen. Get too close to it, like Cornello claims, and you'll just burn up." in reference to the story of Icarus
Water 35 liter carbon 20 kg ammonia 4 liter lime 1.5 kg phosphorus 800 grams salt 250 grams saltpeter 100 grams sulfur 480 grams fluorine 7.5 grams iron 5 grams silicon 3 grams and trace amount of 15 elements
My favorite moment in any bit of media. This explanation and the monologue after he survives the back truck butcher attack. This show is ageless/timeless/legendary!!!
"There you go again, pushing all of your total cynicism onto somebody else. -.-" Believe me, Al, your brother isn't the only one who does that. It happens just as frequently in real life as it does in fiction, when people are cynical or pessimistic or worry a lot, or any resulting combination thereof. They always push and force their negative views onto others; they can never seem to keep it to themselves for some reason. :S They always try to convert people, like they're in some kind of cult. x_x
To be fair in the FMA universe souls are technically just considered a form of energy, even later in the series they reveal that souls are the energy that fuels alchemy.
From what I can tell, it's a bit of Nietzschean philosophy: That God is Dead because we killed Him and it will be up to us to fill that void. Many atheists take that as a challenge to be like God, when Nietzsche was decrying the egotistical nature of the entire dilemma.
Folks you're missing the point. The particular god Rose believes in isn't real regardless of the semi spiritual dimensions of alchemy. And the spiritual dimensions if you even wanna call them that are more akin to deist figures than any theist one like Rose believes. The show is more about the balance and forces of nature which are like a God if you wanna call it that. I find FMA's view of God like Spinoza's. But Ed is also wrong to reduce humans to bear scientific measurements as science without ethics and acknowledgment of nature's laws isn't enough for a moral society. One needs to look beyond religious dogma and scientific literalism to see the worth in humanity and nature.
"We're the closest thing to gods there are" he really was so humble in the beginning, losing 2 limbs and his brothers entire body yet he still thinks they can perform it correctly
Episode 1 ed: We are the closest things to gods in this world, science and alchemy has all the answers. Last episode: God "so you would give it up and lower yourself to a mere human?" Ed "what do you mean lower? That's all I've ever been, a mere human who couldnt save a little girl, not even with alchemy."
Hilariously, according to film theory who actually did all the calculations, Ed's measurements are wrong. Some of the measurements are way off to the point where the body would be dehydrated and the heart wouldn't even start
@@nassymcnute Did you not see the last episode ;) huehue. And yeah I came looking for this scene cause I was just looking up to verify. Some are relatively spot on, others a bit off.
I loved this approach to “what’s the meaning of life” Yeah u can buy the “available buyable” shit that makes up the physical aspect of a human body in flesh but the key element in EVERY HUMAN BEING is the SPIRIT that animates the clay/flesh we call a body. Yes u can be born but if u don’t have “Spirit” or a soul what is the value of that life. NOBODY AND I MEAN NOBODY CAN REPLICATE OR FORGE A SOUL. Not even a father or mother that births baby’s. Woman are incubators that hold the sperm that a man puts in her. Men are sperm holders that put said sperm in women to start the process of life creating man and women are just starting tools of creating life after thst neither party has control of its creation. if thst was the case we could all order children(life) like DoorDash. Then what would mean “life” has no meaning which would also be a big ass slap in the face of god and his sacrifice.
I'm surprised he can talk like this Bear in mind that in 2003 timeline events of first two episodes take place some years after Nina incident remember how traumatized he was he acknowledged he was unable to save her and now here he is taking about how science is the answer to everything
I hate to break it to you, but you can’t use alchemy to raise XXXTentacion or any human being in general back to life. The end result will not be like anything you would have hoped for.
An atheist scientist who is open to foreigners, anti-war (he dislikes the events in Ishval), whose brother married an immigrant would be the one considered woke by the average American Conservative though
I love how he picked up the notes on human transmutation as if he doesnt have it all memorized by heart by know
I have!
Water, 35 liters
Carbon, 20 kg
Amonia, 4 liters
Lime, 1.5 kg
Phosphorus, 800 g
Salt, 250 g
Saltpeter, 100 g
Sulfur, 80 g
Fluorine, 7.5 g
Iron, 5 g
Silicon, 3 g
Plus 15 miscellaneous trace elements
Scientists alchemists and trades tradespersons will always take notes there is always something to be added to the book of your field
I bet he just turned to some random page in his notebook and pretended to be reading from it.
Like how would he get the right page on the first try?
What's also interesting was Rose. As she's just listening to it and was curious about what Ed was reading. Not like the manga or Brotherhood.
They didn’t want to give that away in the first episode I figure
"All of those ingredients can be bought on a child's allowance."
It only just NOW struck me he says this because he bought all that as a child.
Their mother had money in the closet. We don't know how much all that cost but they likely used that money to get everything that wasn't easy to get ahold of.
Whats great about this scene is it shows us Ed's only learned enough to start moving forward, but he's no where near the man he'll be at the end of the series. The writers made a good choice in showing his arrogance here, he's a little kid with a lot of power and knowledge but only one traumatizing event as experience.
damn, way to cut off the ending.
In case anyone is wondering he says about the sun, "it's just a mass of hydrogen. Get too close to it, like Cornello claims, and you'll just burn up." in reference to the story of Icarus
Vic Mignogna makes it sound so badass.
Too bad he's not on funimation anymore.
Wow Edward looks down on religion like anyone whose above 4’ looks down on him.
@Simba Marl'e that’s a mean way to talk about Edward.
dont let him hear you say that
POV: you want to get pummelled with alchemy
Or like anyone above 4 years old also looks down on religion. Enjoy your fairy tails though 🤣🤣
@@mookiestewart3776 You necro a 2 year old comment to tip your fedora?
Touch grass kid.
Water 35 liter carbon 20 kg ammonia 4 liter lime 1.5 kg phosphorus 800 grams salt 250 grams saltpeter 100 grams sulfur 480 grams fluorine 7.5 grams iron 5 grams silicon 3 grams and trace amount of 15 elements
Por enquanto estou tentando salvar o universo.
My favorite moment in any bit of media. This explanation and the monologue after he survives the back truck butcher attack. This show is ageless/timeless/legendary!!!
"There you go again, pushing all of your total cynicism onto somebody else. -.-"
Believe me, Al, your brother isn't the only one who does that. It happens just as frequently in real life as it does in fiction, when people are cynical or pessimistic or worry a lot, or any resulting combination thereof. They always push and force their negative views onto others; they can never seem to keep it to themselves for some reason. :S They always try to convert people, like they're in some kind of cult. x_x
you guys are no different
Ehh, not really. Cheerful and optimistic people are seen as lower than dirt while depressed and depressing cynics can get away with murder.
i like this 2003 version more than brotherhood because they take the scene seriously and there is no rose being confused in the comedy style
I don’t understand how Ed thinks there’s no god when he knows a soul exists. That’s something beyond science.
It's a scientist's conceit to say that a soul is within science, because to that scientist, it's an unknown factor that will eventually be known.
To be fair in the FMA universe souls are technically just considered a form of energy, even later in the series they reveal that souls are the energy that fuels alchemy.
From what I can tell, it's a bit of Nietzschean philosophy: That God is Dead because we killed Him and it will be up to us to fill that void. Many atheists take that as a challenge to be like God, when Nietzsche was decrying the egotistical nature of the entire dilemma.
Not to mention he has literally met god.
Folks you're missing the point. The particular god Rose believes in isn't real regardless of the semi spiritual dimensions of alchemy. And the spiritual dimensions if you even wanna call them that are more akin to deist figures than any theist one like Rose believes. The show is more about the balance and forces of nature which are like a God if you wanna call it that. I find FMA's view of God like Spinoza's. But Ed is also wrong to reduce humans to bear scientific measurements as science without ethics and acknowledgment of nature's laws isn't enough for a moral society. One needs to look beyond religious dogma and scientific literalism to see the worth in humanity and nature.
Ed REALLY needed some of that ego shattering that he got over the season, but maybe not all of it.
"We're the closest thing to gods there are" he really was so humble in the beginning, losing 2 limbs and his brothers entire body yet he still thinks they can perform it correctly
Every angsty teen atheist ever lol.
Prove him wrong
Episode 1 ed: We are the closest things to gods in this world, science and alchemy has all the answers.
Last episode:
God "so you would give it up and lower yourself to a mere human?"
Ed "what do you mean lower? That's all I've ever been, a mere human who couldnt save a little girl, not even with alchemy."
Hilariously, according to film theory who actually did all the calculations, Ed's measurements are wrong. Some of the measurements are way off to the point where the body would be dehydrated and the heart wouldn't even start
yeah but its also in a completely different universe than ours so it doesnt really matter
@@nassymcnute Did you not see the last episode ;)
huehue.
And yeah I came looking for this scene cause I was just looking up to verify. Some are relatively spot on, others a bit off.
@@Fishpks yes and that peoves my point. theyre in a completely different universe lol
More like the writers fault
@@nassymcnute Ok,did you see the movie?
I love this version of the scene so much better than brotherhood. One of many reasons I love both series for their own merits.
“Neither is the sun. It’s just a mass of hydrogen.”
Seriously real.
Has anyone actually attempted to mix this?
well I tried putting a guy in a blender
I'm trying to find this old song on SoundCloud that sampled this 😭
I ...! This moment is etched into my brain🎉! I am a old man now, but this anime is my personal favorite of all time😢🎉
Ed: “we’re the closest things to gods their are”
Me: “whatdidhesayyyyyyy?!?!!?”
Also me: “Hol up nigga chill”
"We're the closest thing to a god"......wow so humble lol
I loved this approach to “what’s the meaning of life”
Yeah u can buy the “available buyable” shit that makes up the physical aspect of a human body in flesh but the key element in EVERY HUMAN BEING is the SPIRIT that animates the clay/flesh we call a body. Yes u can be born but if u don’t have “Spirit” or a soul what is the value of that life. NOBODY AND I MEAN NOBODY CAN REPLICATE OR FORGE A SOUL. Not even a father or mother that births baby’s. Woman are incubators that hold the sperm that a man puts in her. Men are sperm holders that put said sperm in women to start the process of life creating man and women are just starting tools of creating life after thst neither party has control of its creation. if thst was the case we could all order children(life) like DoorDash. Then what would mean “life” has no meaning which would also be a big ass slap in the face of god and his sacrifice.
Ed: science is the answer to everything.
Me: no Knowledge is.
Science is Effort and Knowledge is just a perspective to the mind.
Knowledge is the accumulation of information...which is what science is all about...
@@KainMalice
Knowledge is about everything, Human aspect included, not only empirical information that can change from time to time.
@@giornogiostar3214 What about the human experience doesnt fall under the purview of science???
@@KainMalice
Experience itself, creativity, humanity, emotions, even philosophy by some extent.
While brotherhood is the better version I still say 2003 had a better 1st episode
Lol love all the triggered religious people in the comments 😂😂
Im petty sure he didnt say his in Brotherhood.
Sunaki1000 he did!
But i think that concretly this scene is from just fma
He did, but it’s way better in this version
insan altyazı koyar kardeş
This is from the first anime right??? I remember Ed and Al did face Father (not the father from the dwarf in the flask).
Yes this is 03
I'm mostly trace elements.
Well hydrogen and gold but point made
I beat to this
Me too
this awanser compared to the one he gives to the truth/god at the end of brotherhood... WOW... that is what i call growup
Where do I fine fma 😭I can’t fine it anywhere 😭😭😭
I love this scene although the film theory episode on it kinda ruined it for me
I'm surprised he can talk like this
Bear in mind that in 2003 timeline
events of first two episodes take place some years after Nina incident remember how traumatized he was he acknowledged he was unable to save her and now here he is taking about how science is the answer to everything
NEED THIS FOR XXXTENTACION
What?
I hate to break it to you, but you can’t use alchemy to raise XXXTentacion or any human being in general back to life. The end result will not be like anything you would have hoped for.
Xxx is overrated
looks like someone didn't watch the anime
Fuck that guy.
can you type the formula plz
the grim sword phosphorus and saltpeter (potassium nitrate) used for gun powder
the grim sword you misspelled Sulfur
Joe Humpston he misspelled multiple things
For example he spelt emonia it’s ammonia.
(35 L), Carbon (20 kg), Ammonia (4 L), Lime (1.5 kg), Phosphorous (800 g), Salt (250 g), Saltpeter (100 g), Sulfur (80 g), Fluorine (7.5 g), Iron (5 g), Silicon (3 g) and fifteen traces of other elements.
Cool
Episode number please
Its the First Episode xD
A real scientist explaining reality to a woke one! FMA 03' absolutely called it!!!
An atheist scientist who is open to foreigners, anti-war (he dislikes the events in Ishval), whose brother married an immigrant would be the one considered woke by the average American Conservative though
Lmao there’s nothing “woke” or “scientific” about Rose? Where did you pull this out of?