I find this extra funny because Edward's Voice Actor Vic Mignogna voiced Junpei from Persona 3 and one of Junpei's catchphrase is "Who's da man" and it's somehow fitting.
jolly I was going to say that he’d be all “ah, love...” but I don’t think anyone looking at this without hearing what they were saying would be able to deduce that it was a proposal.
tbf the kid just saved the entire fucking country from a government conspiracy that would kill everyone, i imagine news of that travels fast then again, not like anyone could ever tell that _he's_ the fullmetal alchemist at first glance, so,,,
Well pretty sure it was obvious to most of us watching before it clicked with her visually. I certainly had no problem understanding what he meant instantly. And I'm not even CLOSE to amazing.
@Sophia Manzor - The cutest thing is that I don't think that _really_ bothers him at all, just being so happy for him to have his body back. Of course I'm sure Al probably points it out every now and again, just to be obnoxious x3 They _are_ brothers, after all. I think Ed has the broader shoulders & more 'toned' look, though.
And it makes perfect sense, everything up to then revolved around equivalent exchange. The moment Ed stopped being an alchemist was not when he gave up his door of truth but when Winry said to hell with equivalent exchange and broke it by giving him all of her.
@@ursomrano542 I agree, but I wouldn’t say he stopped being an alchemist. I think he realized there there can be something more. An addition added though the love and compassion of another person
Watch a Manipuri movie where kiss, sex, even wearing pant of somewhat above short by girl or anything that reveal cleavage are all ban from appearing on-screen
@@soap9277 I believe the author said they didn't get together because they wanted to keep things professional between them and didn't want their relationship cutting into their work. Feels bad, man 🥲
Does anyone notice that he looks like his father in this moment with his attire and he has a young appearance of Hohenheim (Ik i probably didnt spell his name correctly)
Yeah he really does! He looks like a man, not a boy. It's two years later here so he's probably 18 or so. Maybe 19. He looks just like his dad while Alphonse's face is more their mother's shape.
Still one of the most iconic-slash-romantic scenes, much much more than any typical cringy romance anime w/ over-"cuteness" can ever hope to achieve. Just this 3 minute scene is more genuine and heartfelt than the rest of those garbage anime with many episodes of pseudo romance.
Because in FMA romance isn't the main focus, and small sweet moments like this one are very rare and just sprinkled in a little bit as fanservice, in a way, while also developing the characters. This is why the ending is so satisfying, it's because we got attached to them and wished that they would eventually live a carefree life where they would have time to think about small things like love and marriage.
@@nguyenthanhhai6725 It was cartoony as all fuck. Far from realistic. Even if they are shy together, that shit is not how shy people talk lol. And even if it was realistic, that wouldnt change the fact that this scene was corny and cringey as hell. I mean, minecon is a real event but its still cringey AF
@@sinistrecigogne I'm actually writing for a character who has Asperger's and doesn't quite grasp the concept of love, and he ends up in rather perverted situations that make him question what counts as love or lust?
I love how he uses a metaphor of alchemy because he's too shy to say his true feelings but it ends up sounding even more romantic than an average proposal 💘
"EQUIVALENT EXCHANGE! I'LL GIVE HALF OF MY LIFE TO YOU, IF YOU GIVE HALF OF YOURS TO ME!" LOL! Edward. I love how he was blushing as he said that, it was so cute~!
HN doğan she’s talking about how much of her life to give to him. She said all of it at first but then said maybe not all so she starts think about the percentage of her life that she would give to him.
It would make me very happy if they would come out with just 1 ova of their life together after the events of brotherhood. I'm still extremely satisfied by this ending, but it would be that little cherry on top of the sundae
Such a cute little scene. I especially love the end portrait. In the manga, it's a little more obvious that they're recreating the picture pose from when Ed and Al were kids...Winry's hair was even done in the same style as Trisha's (with a low tied ponytail). Ed's smiling face being a nice contrast to Hohenheim's crying one. Plus, Paninya and Garfield were not in the manga portrait, so it's implied a bit that Al and May might be paired together.
Ed: Pulls a literal metal pipe out of his abdomen, transmutes brother's soul without a leg after severe trauma, beats up Father with his bare hands Also Ed: eQuiValeNT ExCHanGE!!!!
🤷♂️ most guys will think it's easy, or easier, to shake off a physical injury. It's much harder to risk your heart knowing that it doesn't depend on your own strength or will to pull through.
The picture honestly reminds me of the picture of Trisha and Hohenheim with Ed and Al as small children. It’s just that Ed is smiling (Hohenheim was crying) and there are more people in the background.
ed slowly grew taller than winry throughout the entirety of the series just for this scene to have a cute height difference between them and nothing will convince me otherwise
I love how you can see it in his face that before the train was gonna arrive he was already contemplating on when to propose and got panicky when he heard the train arriving. It’s so cute.
I get where you’re coming from but you can’t flood the show with romance and fan service while also deviating from the plot. Looking at you sword art online. Looking at YOU.
The series finale should have been 1 hour long, it felt rushed and they could've explained things like if Izumi got her organs back, and more EdWin screentime
Well Nalu is HEAVILY implied by the end of the show and it only isn't said because that would be out of character for Natsu, plus if you look at how Natsu and Lucy behave over the course of the later arcs you'll see there's a good to fair chance they already got together off screen.
And it’s an honest laugh too. Not the “Ha-ha, we’re getting away from you.” Or a small chuckle, or a power drunk giggle like when he found out his automail arm in Briggs was a wonder to fight with. This is an honest belly laugh.
@@JadoreFabulosity89 Yeah, but I had it all planned out. Mustang would throw Ed a Bachelor Party (complete with a battalion of buxom beauties wearing TINY MINISKIRTS), Sig and Izumi would stand in for Hoenheim and Trisha, Garfiel would give Winry away in place of her Dad, Al would be Ed's Best Man, Paninya would be Winry's Maid of Honor, Dominic's Grandson would be their ring bearer, Elicia would be Winry's Flower Girl (you can hear Maes up in Heaven telling everyone else up there to look at how cute she is, can't you), Armstrong would be crying throughout the whole thing, Ling would be going to town on the catering (most notable being a huge chunk of Ed and Winry's wedding cake missing) and (assuming they didn't already get together) Hawkeye would catch the bouquet and Mustang catches the garter (or alternatively, Mei and Al.)
Love this scene and how this show portrayed a romance better in 1 scene than most show do in their runtime. No awkward love triangle, no will they/won’t they scenarios (or well, very few), no infidelity. Just 2 interdependent, strong, talented buddies that end up falling in love. Makes my heart soar and has to be one of my favorite scenes in anime
Proposals in TV shows and movies are always corny and cliché, but this one right never gets old and is consistent with both character's personalities. Very well executed and planned out.
I like brotherhood more The original I loved up until then ending obviously lol The only thing I like more in the original was the episode with the little girl and the dog it was way more dark and detailed...shit fucked me up for that entire day lmao
Both are really good. I liked the original bcuz they really brought a lot of focus and development to kimmly, lust, and scar. And had a unique story for the philosophers stone and hohenheims wife. It is like a different universe of fma sorta
Edward looks so much like his dad in that jacket it’s uncanny. Also his family photo is directly apposed to his father’s family photo. Hohenheim’s family photo has him crying his eyes out and he doesn’t have anyone around him but in Edwards photo he has a massive smile and is surrounded by his friends. The writing in this show is insane.
@Mordecai Israel *Extreme Feminism*. Actual feminism is a good thing when talking about wage gaps, or fair treatment. When feminism is used on basic things that there is really no issue with is Extreme Feminism, and even women hate that.
Hughes: "She'd make a fine wife" *And he was right* I wish the things would have gone different so many of the characters that died would have attended to their wedding, like Hohenheimm seeing his grandchildren and Nina as a flower girl, and Hughes being the goofball he is. However, it's pretty cute that Ed hold his son like his father did when he was a child.
Makes me laugh: Ed fought against homonculus, monsters, Scar, the Flame Alchemist, Kimblee, the Father, and whatever. He rushes into fight without thinking, always ready for this. He has given his arm with a lot of courage to save his brother' soul, trained fast and hard in one year, has been the youngest State alchemist of the world!!! But telling Winry he loves her........................................................................hun-hun... too frightened... 😂🤣
READ THE REPLIES AND FULL COMMENT BEFORE COMMENTING, YOU'RE ALL MAKING THE SAME WRONG POINT. I think FMA is the only anime in which we actually see a character grow throughout the series. I get it's because it's crucial to the story, but still, it's just something we don't see. You all seem to be missing the point here, so let me rephrase. When I say "grow" I mean, physically grow, as in height. Episode to episode you can physically measure Edwards growth against Alphonse when they're standing side by side. The animation team and original Manga artists did such a good job growing hit as a realistic status. FMA you actually see the growth episode to episode, they even have episodes about Ed needing new autoparts because he's grown. Naruto stays the same size for the entire first series and then literally ages 2 years over the span of one episode. Same with Dragon Ball, Hunter X Hunter and Attack on Titan. Most anime's have the character as 5ft one episode and then timeskip a year the next episode and the character is 6ft and looks completely different. And no, FMA is not the first Anime I've watched, as of latest completion I've watch 216 different Animes, however I keep coming back to FMA becaaaaause, it's so good and the animation team care's so much.
the fact that Ed burst out laughing when Winry tried reasoning with it and that hug though so cute the only couple that didnt kiss once Darn that wouldve been perfect timing
What I appreciate about this how Winry understood what he meant very quickly. Edward wanted to tell her but had difficulty finding the words. Truly coming together.
The voices just fit the characters better in the dub. The English voices really capture the English/German setting. And oh man, what a sweet ending. Hologram playing at the end really brought the feels.
Edward: *inhales* please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes
Just a request to all of you.. That can you please visit my channel and if you like it then make sure you subscribed my channel to access my channel content... You can watch amvs of mine
Lets not forget about the Real MVP, The Train waiting for Edward to propose.
amen brother
Ecactly what I was thinking during the whole scene, would never happen irl 😂
Still beautiful tho
Lol😂
Equlivent exchange=will you marry me
LOOOL
"How about I just give you my whole life?"
That's a damn good answer.
i know right ;)
Satan: I would like that
@@ar.71944 r/cursed comments
Lol.😂
Woah guys what’s poking me 👀
Oh just an arrow that’s about to pierce me heart
So there was this comment I saw and it said “Ed finally learned how to make a person” and that bastard made me choke on my food
THATS THE BEST COMMENT HERE 😂
I needed about a minute to understand 😂😂
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA BEST COMMENT
LOL
I think I get the joke but I am not sure, can someone please explain it to me?
Love how Ed is a badass prodigal alchemist who pulled a steel pipe from his guts but when it comes to Winry he's all blushing and goofy.
Ikr it's so cute 😳❤
That’s not the only thing Ed piped
BeWaRe Jay I see what you did here
That's litterly how every man is 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@BeWaReJay i just choked on my water
Meanwhile the guy driving the train while waiting is like , "that's ma mann"
Plot twist: It was Armstrong and as soon as he got on the train, he went over and congratulated him
@@preston1088 also he isnt wearing any shirt and he Is stretching while doing it
The train driver is an EdWin shipper...his only complaint is that Ed didn't kiss her.
I find this extra funny because Edward's Voice Actor Vic Mignogna voiced Junpei from Persona 3 and one of Junpei's catchphrase is "Who's da man" and it's somehow fitting.
@@deadpool-rz7wp With sparkles✨
Typical male: Will you marry me
Edward Elric: *eQuIvAlEnT eXcHaNgE*
Lunch LMAO
Al: Propose normally
Edward Elric: Ah Yes, *E Q U I V A L E N T E X C H A N G E*
True true true true
Lunch I bet she will take off her shirt to get him in the mood but he will just see a bunch of different angles or ways to stop her with alchemy
@@jonathanmchenry7874 More like it's the speech of science lovers/alchemists/automail maker
my type of proposal
"EQUIVALENT EXCHANGE"
OwO whats that?
Flaming Fox OwO whats equivalent exchange?
never heard or seen that before.
Pikachu desu It's something in alchemy, like trade something for another.
Pikachu desu its exactly what it sounds like. A fair trade, life for love
soooooo... Y'all both give half and you get too keep everything when y'all divorce?
the train guy is probably pissed off
Yeah the wait made him take more cash from me. Thanks train dude.
jolly I was going to say that he’d be all “ah, love...” but I don’t think anyone looking at this without hearing what they were saying would be able to deduce that it was a proposal.
tbf the kid just saved the entire fucking country from a government conspiracy that would kill everyone, i imagine news of that travels fast
then again, not like anyone could ever tell that _he's_ the fullmetal alchemist at first glance, so,,,
And more cash please (I've waited for you to long)
Nah, Buccaneer is.
“I’ll give you my whole life instead!”
Ed: *starts buffering*
Ed.exe has ceased to function come back later
>Close program
>Wait for Ed.exe to respond
EdwardElric.EXE has stopped responding...
*Windows error message noise*
Gotta say I never expected this to get 1.5k likes. Thanks, I guess? XD
I mean that's a pretty damn good answer
The fact that Winry understood what he meant was really amazing.
Well pretty sure it was obvious to most of us watching before it clicked with her visually. I certainly had no problem understanding what he meant instantly. And I'm not even CLOSE to amazing.
TheOriginalGankstar
RHG Jester IKR?
This isn't your average anime, the guys and gals aren't batshit oblivious to each other xD
Dawud Khan so true
Only in anime will two characters literally get married and have kids without us seeing a single kiss.
Actually Clannad is that as well! The main characters never kiss.
Goku....
@@fmanerd321 Naruto....
King Luis uhhhh pretty sure naruto kissed hinata in the movie
Cough Tokyo ghoul cough
*ed gets close to winry*
Me: *Expecting a kiss*
*they hug*
Me: b r u h
Bruh moment x2
Bruh moment x3
Bruh moment x4
bruh moment x5
Bruh moment x6
This is the best proposal in Anime EVER! Also I like how Ed is taller than Winry now. It fits the ending of the show.
This proposal is the cutest one ever.
enthusiastic Psychopath Well she did she's not into men shorter than her XD
That moment when you realize Al is still taller than Ed
@Sophia Manzor - The cutest thing is that I don't think that _really_ bothers him at all, just being so happy for him to have his body back. Of course I'm sure Al probably points it out every now and again, just to be obnoxious x3 They _are_ brothers, after all. I think Ed has the broader shoulders & more 'toned' look, though.
Its cheesy as heck when he says equivalent exchange but I have to go through it because I wanna see if she accepts or not now let me watch it.
I like how the train just stopped and waited for Ed while he "proposed."
"So, is that little guy gonna get on or what...?"
"I HEARD THAT!"
LOLLLLL 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Strix182
or something like this.
"Would you just get on with it, Propose to her already.....?"
Strix182 he's not little anymore
IM DEAD LMAOOOOOOO
Jersey's God Aah, but he will always be little in our hearts xD
I love how his brain completely breaks down and goes to equivalent exchange
And it makes perfect sense, everything up to then revolved around equivalent exchange. The moment Ed stopped being an alchemist was not when he gave up his door of truth but when Winry said to hell with equivalent exchange and broke it by giving him all of her.
@@ursomrano542 I agree, but I wouldn’t say he stopped being an alchemist. I think he realized there there can be something more. An addition added though the love and compassion of another person
It's from which series fmab or fma
@@tikenani4179 fmab. It’s definitively the better one, although I do suggest watching fma after watching fmab first
@@FrameErbie I already started watching fmab
"HOW ABOUT I JUST GIVE YOU MY WHOLE LIFE!"
Beautiful winry ur a true wife already
I mean 85s a good number though
@@connerheyl5096 it is
The thing that always gets me the most about this scene is how similar he looks to Hoenheim. I love that.
James Vermont ikr
Hohenheim***
James Vermont i know! Essentially With his hair like .
Hohenheim looked exactly like Ed when he was young, I love that.
Lol true
Ed and Winrey, throughout the entire series, never kissed on-screen. Now that's something people. That's seriously something
Watch a Manipuri movie where kiss, sex, even wearing pant of somewhat above short by girl or anything that reveal cleavage are all ban from appearing on-screen
You know what else is something? We never actually found out if Mustang and Hawkeye were a thing or not.
@@soap9277 yep:(
@@soap9277 naw ima kill my self if you die there def a thing
@@soap9277 I believe the author said they didn't get together because they wanted to keep things professional between them and didn't want their relationship cutting into their work. Feels bad, man 🥲
Edward is taller then Winry now.
Star Pit
than*
Star Pit that's the most amazing part of the series
Star Pit *than
Star Pit but he will always be little in our hearts
true lmao
*hug happens*
Me: JUST KISS HER YA DWEEB
I thaught the same 😂
The could've at least said "I love you." Honestly....
@Madigan Glenn I heard it was because the author couldn't draw people kissing lmao
@march cat Wait, so that's why we didn't get to see their wedding?
@Madigan Glenn the Author: Hiromi Arakawa didn't know how to draw them kissing
Ed: Will you marry me?
Also Ed: *Takes a train far away from his fiancee*
Yea...Ed is definitely a master of mixed messages.
"In the old days, when a man had to travel far, he would declare his love to his love interest before he left".
@@jppcouto ok boomer
it is a joke
Like father like S-
(This is just a joke)
Typical anime male protagonist
That was the cheesiest proposal ever but hey it worked
But still I'll admit it was kinda cute
Luna Silver
Luna Silver Tbh that's how most proposals go anyway.
Well it was pretty original. Beats the traditional 10k ring soppy bullshit.
Too bad it doesn't work always in real life. Some of us wish it did
That's how a nerd proposes
That would imply a nerd would be able to get themselves into a situation where a proposal isn't a suicidal action to take
Are you talking from experience??😭😭
😅
i think we're brothers I
XD atleast this nerd succeeds unlike you
"Who needs alchemy when i have all of them"
You've done it that's the right answer. Congratulations you beat me
Nathaniel _ nice pfp
@@dat_roy_main_6262 thanks buddy
Who needs alchemy when we have chemistry?
@@macdege6754 basically yeah. alchemy is basically advanced chemistry.
I love how his son has the same grin as him
Plus they have the same antenna on their hair XD
Called a cowlick but same thing.
Did you just assume the gender?
father like son
That’s literally all I can think about in the picture! Their grins are just so goofy XD
I like how they argue then winry just realize she just confessed her feelings as well😂😍😂
Truee😭💜
Didn't need a comment for 2 years and people just liked that's how powerful the truth is.
True
Does anyone notice that he looks like his father in this moment with his attire and he has a young appearance of Hohenheim (Ik i probably didnt spell his name correctly)
Esleagon yeah, I noticed that
Bruh hohenheim was waaay more badass looking when he was young, just look at the dwarf in the flasks last form
Yeah he really does! He looks like a man, not a boy. It's two years later here so he's probably 18 or so. Maybe 19. He looks just like his dad while Alphonse's face is more their mother's shape.
Maybe I'm crazy but didn't the one of winry's parents were cousins with Ed and Al?!?!? So winry is the daughter of Ed and Al cousin?
How i thought the same damn thing
HOLY ED GOT TALL.....did he drink his milk finally?!
No
He was never short you fool
@@jusbetter7634 what are ya talking about
Dev it was Alphonse that was weighing him down
He was never that short
@@nemo.greenn724 im gonna be honest i dont remember much but ur prob right
anyone notice winry is wearing ed's hoodie from when he came back home with al?
Omg now that you mention it she is aswel
Good catch
IT'S SO CUTE
YES
Yes
Winry: I’ll give you my whole live
Edward: *windows crashing sounds*
I love your profile pic XDD
@@gin3986 thank you :3 it took forever to find it on my pc
Still one of the most iconic-slash-romantic scenes, much much more than any typical cringy romance anime w/ over-"cuteness" can ever hope to achieve. Just this 3 minute scene is more genuine and heartfelt than the rest of those garbage anime with many episodes of pseudo romance.
Because in FMA romance isn't the main focus, and small sweet moments like this one are very rare and just sprinkled in a little bit as fanservice, in a way, while also developing the characters. This is why the ending is so satisfying, it's because we got attached to them and wished that they would eventually live a carefree life where they would have time to think about small things like love and marriage.
This scene was cringey as hell. Though its nice that they ended up together in the end.
@@NinteddyRose as it should be. It decribes the feeling between them. A little shyness when they confess their feeling. Isn't that realistic.?
@@nguyenthanhhai6725
It was cartoony as all fuck. Far from realistic. Even if they are shy together, that shit is not how shy people talk lol. And even if it was realistic, that wouldnt change the fact that this scene was corny and cringey as hell. I mean, minecon is a real event but its still cringey AF
@@sinistrecigogne I'm actually writing for a character who has Asperger's and doesn't quite grasp the concept of love, and he ends up in rather perverted situations that make him question what counts as love or lust?
This has to be the funniest proposal in the history of anime
But also the most sincere and heartfelt
@@GeraltofRivia22 no....
@@dragonballhaven1417 why not?
@@GeraltofRivia22 cause fma brotherhood isnt that good
@@dragonballhaven1417 you're entitled to be wrong
Imagine if she said
“I love you, but as a friend"
Imagine if she said I love Emilia
@@triggeredavdol3371 OHHHHHHH CRAP U MADE ME CHOCKE ON MY FOOD
I would give the anime a 1/10 lmao
Lol
@@triggeredavdol3371 I was about to say the same thing!!!!
First of all: BLUSHY ED IS SO CUTE second: if my future husband doesn't propose to me like this I ain't saying yes
Luna Love good luck
You don't need husband, you need luck....
*If you keep thinking like that then Mr Right is just pass right by you*
Ur future husband is probably off watching harem and reverse trap animes 😁
That's why you still single
I wonder if Winry thought that Ed was gonna kiss her.
*spins like a ballerina* eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!
SuperMysticMage
OH that's adorable! I love it!
DkXboxer
oh stop it >//w//
SuperMysticMage its sTill adorable XD
saaaaame. this is a dream
He offers half his life. She offers her WHOLE life in return. Ed's right, Equivalent Exchange just got straight-up owned here! :D
God dammit Ed! Cannot even accomplish a simple proposal!!! At least it worked out
Topher -VS- World its cause he doesn't drink his milk
Buddypoke & animation & blog videos the last 😐
What do you mean "cannot accomplish"? She said "yes".
I'm on episode 30 or 31 wow this is a spoiler
Wait they had kids?!?!
now thats what i call a proposal, not this tacky roses on the beach with a 20k ring. maybe im just a simple girl
PotionsMaster007 awe ;0
PotionsMaster007 I feel the same way. Proposals don't need to be extravagant; they need to be from the heart.
PotionsMaster007 nothing wrong with simple. I think a simple gesture rings more sincere than a whole bunch of expensive stuff.
Izayoi Bara IKR
PotionsMaster007 amen sista
I love how he uses a metaphor of alchemy because he's too shy to say his true feelings but it ends up sounding even more romantic than an average proposal 💘
best proposal ever
Jersey's God go watch hinata's confession
Nah, m8 this is the best
Rem says hi.
Rinku San rezero is trash
+Epic Channel why is it trash?
"EQUIVALENT EXCHANGE! I'LL GIVE HALF OF MY LIFE TO YOU, IF YOU GIVE HALF OF YOURS TO ME!"
LOL! Edward. I love how he was blushing as he said that, it was so cute~!
I'm taken. B )
“Yeah.. 85 is a good number??”
What is the meaning of this, can you please explain? :')
HN doğan she’s talking about how much of her life to give to him. She said all of it at first but then said maybe not all so she starts think about the percentage of her life that she would give to him.
@@aegis5678 thank you 😅😂😂
69 is better ^^
@@samlerf nice
It would make me very happy if they would come out with just 1 ova of their life together after the events of brotherhood. I'm still extremely satisfied by this ending, but it would be that little cherry on top of the sundae
W H O L E S O M E
I've been hoping for that for so long
It would be so easy, just do it!!
Make a petition, I'll sign
I still ain't that satisfied, i did not like ed losing his ability to transmute or use alchemy
Such a cute little scene. I especially love the end portrait. In the manga, it's a little more obvious that they're recreating the picture pose from when Ed and Al were kids...Winry's hair was even done in the same style as Trisha's (with a low tied ponytail). Ed's smiling face being a nice contrast to Hohenheim's crying one. Plus, Paninya and Garfield were not in the manga portrait, so it's implied a bit that Al and May might be paired together.
Sandy Prater low tied pony tail not the hair style of death
Ed: Pulls a literal metal pipe out of his abdomen, transmutes brother's soul without a leg after severe trauma, beats up Father with his bare hands
Also Ed: eQuiValeNT ExCHanGE!!!!
🤷♂️ most guys will think it's easy, or easier, to shake off a physical injury. It's much harder to risk your heart knowing that it doesn't depend on your own strength or will to pull through.
This makes me ridiculously happy no matter how often I see it.
Hannah Kramer same
same:)
Literally watched/read this(on Instagram or Pinterest) about 10 tens, me: 😊
Times*
Same😭❤
Ha ha, oh man that's funny! He thinks marriage is like equivalent exchange! Lol! Wait till he learns.
Kip Higginson 😂
Marriage is basically signing a contract that says your freedom is now no more
He might lose his other arm
Aha😂😂😂
Haha. Well if you are that kind of guy who needs to explore every cave in this world it surely means nothing :D
Awwwww Ed’s son has his cute smile and their daughter reminds me of Al when he was a 👶
Skye Salaman ;i think it was suppose to be that way
His son is ed n his daughter is al of next generation
The baby emoji for some reason is funny asf😭
The picture honestly reminds me of the picture of Trisha and Hohenheim with Ed and Al as small children. It’s just that Ed is smiling (Hohenheim was crying) and there are more people in the background.
Maybe I'm crazy but didn't the one of winry's parents were cousins with Ed and Al?!?!? So winry is the daughter of Ed and Al cousin?
@@marvingomez9564 They just grew up together.
ed slowly grew taller than winry throughout the entirety of the series just for this scene to have a cute height difference between them and nothing will convince me otherwise
@Split Dimension yh especially around the time of the promised day like the last 15 eps XD
“That’s nonsense- how about I just give you my whole life?”
HOW ABOUT YOU JUST TAKE MY HEART AND SQUEEZE IT EVEN MORE THIS IS THE CUTEST SHIT IM
I love how you can see it in his face that before the train was gonna arrive he was already contemplating on when to propose and got panicky when he heard the train arriving. It’s so cute.
The only thing about this I hate is that they didn't show any more of their new relationship in the show😔😔😔
It would of just been a rom com by then
I get where you’re coming from but you can’t flood the show with romance and fan service while also deviating from the plot. Looking at you sword art online. Looking at YOU.
@@chroma2992 Watch SAO Alicisation before talking
This was like 5 minutes before the show ended tho
@@warmmasaanims
Are you saying I can't say a show is bad if ONLY the season three is good?
All the nerd jokes aside, that was a damned good scene. I really wish they would do a sequel series though QQ
fr ;^; I just finished and I NEED MORE
The series finale should have been 1 hour long, it felt rushed and they could've explained things like if Izumi got her organs back, and more EdWin screentime
@@3badthebad in the manga there still more scene in the ending?
pls no sequel
Nalu: Who are you?
Edwin: I'm you but cannon
Well Nalu is HEAVILY implied by the end of the show and it only isn't said because that would be out of character for Natsu, plus if you look at how Natsu and Lucy behave over the course of the later arcs you'll see there's a good to fair chance they already got together off screen.
Edwin is also actually in a good anime
@qwerty uiopa Edwin is canon, but Nalu isn't canon yet.
Eragon15 not YET
@@justever5301 That's what I said.
Lol, balanced proposal
There isn't such a thing
Nocturno looooool right
Nocturno ay
Nocturno are any of you even speaking from experience?
Theres a balanced comment
Edward's laugh is the greatest thing ever holy shit
And it’s an honest laugh too.
Not the “Ha-ha, we’re getting away from you.” Or a small chuckle, or a power drunk giggle like when he found out his automail arm in Briggs was a wonder to fight with.
This is an honest belly laugh.
I’m so happy they got married and had kids!! The 2003 version broke my heart because they couldn’t be together, I’m glad fma brotherhood changed that!
The 2003 version has an original storyline. Brotherhood follows exactly what's in the manga.
Abraham E. Yes, I know! :) I’ve been following the series since 2004.
Would've been better if we actually saw them getting married.
@@ZeldaEd123 I agree! That would’ve been nice but at least we saw they had kids.😊
@@JadoreFabulosity89 Yeah, but I had it all planned out. Mustang would throw Ed a Bachelor Party (complete with a battalion of buxom beauties wearing TINY MINISKIRTS), Sig and Izumi would stand in for Hoenheim and Trisha, Garfiel would give Winry away in place of her Dad, Al would be Ed's Best Man, Paninya would be Winry's Maid of Honor, Dominic's Grandson would be their ring bearer, Elicia would be Winry's Flower Girl (you can hear Maes up in Heaven telling everyone else up there to look at how cute she is, can't you), Armstrong would be crying throughout the whole thing, Ling would be going to town on the catering (most notable being a huge chunk of Ed and Winry's wedding cake missing) and (assuming they didn't already get together) Hawkeye would catch the bouquet and Mustang catches the garter (or alternatively, Mei and Al.)
They are so nerdy and naive I love it
Love this scene and how this show portrayed a romance better in 1 scene than most show do in their runtime. No awkward love triangle, no will they/won’t they scenarios (or well, very few), no infidelity. Just 2 interdependent, strong, talented buddies that end up falling in love. Makes my heart soar and has to be one of my favorite scenes in anime
*me in shock* he's grown up so well
*me cries* he grew *gasp* TALLER
Pikachu desu I know I was thinking the same thing this comment killed me
@@nakagamipenguin well dang
Cuz he learned to drink his malk
Hollywood should take notes
Harem anime as well
@@samuraibunny1758and 70% of romance anime
Proposals in TV shows and movies are always corny and cliché, but this one right never gets old and is consistent with both character's personalities. Very well executed and planned out.
and that is why Brotherhood is better than the first one, who in their right mind thought it was a good idea to split Ed and Winry!
I like the first one its just I wish Ed and Winry got together I would've loved it more. :'(
vootsak1 I like to think of the original FMA anime as an AU if certain events had not played out.
Nah the original is better
I like brotherhood more
The original I loved up until then ending obviously lol
The only thing I like more in the original was the episode with the little girl and the dog it was way more dark and detailed...shit fucked me up for that entire day lmao
Both are really good. I liked the original bcuz they really brought a lot of focus and development to kimmly, lust, and scar. And had a unique story for the philosophers stone and hohenheims wife. It is like a different universe of fma sorta
*"I'll give half of my life to you if you give half of your life to me" ✨✨😭 perfect*
.
.
Edit 21/02/21 I'm still here for this wholesome couple♡
Ishika - oh hey we have the same name!😂
@@ishuika are you Indian?
He's holding back.
Edward looks so much like his dad in that jacket it’s uncanny. Also his family photo is directly apposed to his father’s family photo. Hohenheim’s family photo has him crying his eyes out and he doesn’t have anyone around him but in Edwards photo he has a massive smile and is surrounded by his friends. The writing in this show is insane.
everybody knows that the saying of equivalent exchange in real life is as follows:
Happy wife, happy life
That isn't just an exchange, that is a core life value that is sacred above all else.
@Mordecai Israel *Extreme Feminism*. Actual feminism is a good thing when talking about wage gaps, or fair treatment. When feminism is used on basic things that there is really no issue with is Extreme Feminism, and even women hate that.
that shit real
this is and will always be the best anime ever
Ouma agreed
Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure, but this one touched my heart.
U forgot about Cory in the house
I like hunter
agreed
Best most in-character anime confession I've seen yet.
I just noticed that Ed's coat looks a lot like his dad's, did he even know about that afterwards?
I wish there was a kiss!!! ;-; but this was still adorable!
Hughes: "She'd make a fine wife"
*And he was right*
I wish the things would have gone different so many of the characters that died would have attended to their wedding, like Hohenheimm seeing his grandchildren and Nina as a flower girl, and Hughes being the goofball he is.
However, it's pretty cute that Ed hold his son like his father did when he was a child.
when u did the math with Winry and got the same answer
I love how his kid's cheesing just as hard as he is😂😂
"How about I just give you my full life"
*Realises*
"Wait no how about 90% no 85% no...."
*Edward is dieing inside*
☺️☺️☺️☺️ I love how flustered Winry is and then Ed laughs and hugs her when she asks if he was making fun of her.
HES FINALLY TALLER THEN HER!!!!!
He very slowly gets taller and taller throughout the series. It's very subtle :)
Can't call him little
Edward (Somehow breaking into our world and off in the distance): I AM NOT LITTLE!
The fact that the train didn’t leave is amazing
I liked how Ed had the guts to say it to her face
i actually did this to my wife...only problem is she doesn't know fullmetal that well...
*applause* LUCKY Lady! To bad she has no idea how lucky, since she doesn't know the show 😅
Hate to break it to you man, but... She's not the one for you.
Your wife just isnt into anime things. Anyway, Congrats on your wedding!
Cringe 😂
I’d even lose an arm and a leg for that to happen to me.
Makes me laugh: Ed fought against homonculus, monsters, Scar, the Flame Alchemist, Kimblee, the Father, and whatever. He rushes into fight without thinking, always ready for this. He has given his arm with a lot of courage to save his brother' soul, trained fast and hard in one year, has been the youngest State alchemist of the world!!!
But telling Winry he loves her........................................................................hun-hun... too frightened... 😂🤣
I'm glad this wasn't cheesy, but cute
0:17 Ed if you keep slouching like that your gonna become short again.
Always loved this scene.
The way Ed notes how Winry ignored equivalent exchange is such a perfect send off to the whole arc they went through.
READ THE REPLIES AND FULL COMMENT BEFORE COMMENTING, YOU'RE ALL MAKING THE SAME WRONG POINT.
I think FMA is the only anime in which we actually see a character grow throughout the series.
I get it's because it's crucial to the story, but still, it's just something we don't see.
You all seem to be missing the point here, so let me rephrase.
When I say "grow" I mean, physically grow, as in height.
Episode to episode you can physically measure Edwards growth against Alphonse when they're standing side by side. The animation team and original Manga artists did such a good job growing hit as a realistic status.
FMA you actually see the growth episode to episode, they even have episodes about Ed needing new autoparts because he's grown.
Naruto stays the same size for the entire first series and then literally ages 2 years over the span of one episode.
Same with Dragon Ball, Hunter X Hunter and Attack on Titan.
Most anime's have the character as 5ft one episode and then timeskip a year the next episode and the character is 6ft and looks completely different.
And no, FMA is not the first Anime I've watched, as of latest completion I've watch 216 different Animes, however I keep coming back to FMA becaaaaause, it's so good and the animation team care's so much.
Dragon ball, although it's mainly done across several time skips.
Danahan child, is fma the only anime you’ve seen?
What about Naruto?
@@shorty7523 he means physically grow, like height.
Wait for Vinland Saga
Winry is wearing Ed's hoodie 😍
If a male weeb were to ask a girl to marry them, They would totally use ed's equivalent exchange line. Assuming the girl they like was also a web.
There both lookin like " OMGEEZE YOU JUST SAID YOU LOVE ME " AWWW it's cute
the fact that Ed burst out laughing when Winry tried reasoning with it and that hug though so cute
the only couple that didnt kiss once Darn that wouldve been perfect timing
People say they wanted a kiss but honestly that hug felt so much more real
I'm sobbing this is is perfect
What I appreciate about this how Winry understood what he meant very quickly. Edward wanted to tell her but had difficulty finding the words. Truly coming together.
The voices just fit the characters better in the dub. The English voices really capture the English/German setting. And oh man, what a sweet ending. Hologram playing at the end really brought the feels.
if i ever get married to another anime lover, this is how id propose.
Everyone: "How could a little guy score such a beautiful woman?"
Ed's angry face: "LET'S JUST SAY MY OTHER PARTS MAKE UP FOR THAT!!!"
"What you say?!?!" How mad he was that she disrespected alchemy when he is proposing to her has me rolling!
Edward: *inhales* please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes please say yes
They’re so cute. I’m glad that they ended up together at the end. I couldn’t help it when Ed bursted out laughing 😂 at 2:06😂😂😂😂
2:54
Happy ending: Ed finally got laid...
Bruh...yes
Yo
That's enough internet for today 🙃
Just a request to all of you.. That can you please visit my channel and if you like it then make sure you subscribed my channel to access my channel content... You can watch amvs of mine
I'm sorry but I just finished fmab just a few hours ago but don't remember the picture after the train clip. Is that pic from the anime? 😭
how I wan to be proposed to.
Tobi Otaku that would be great
will ya marry me
Meeee to 😢
Phoenix Flames Will you marry me
Equivalent Exchange
I love that shes just as aekward as he is and responds in the same way despite calling him hopeless