Why Putin's troops failed to press the advantage in his Kharkiv push | Maj. Gen. Rupert Jones
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 чер 2024
- Russian troops lack the strategy and training to push home their objectives in Putin's offensive in the north of Ukraine, Maj. Gen. Rupert Jones tells Frontline.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Blessings, peace and luck from California to Ukraine. 🙏🙏☮🍀💛💙
Putin trading Europe as a partner for North Korea. Genius 😂
Putin is a Circus 🎪 full of clowns 🤡 🙄 🤣 😂
I am Russian. Live Samara. Putin is *disaster* and now Russ army laughed at worldwide😢
Another very stable genius. 😆
@@dpelpal ну и как нынче погодка в Самаре ?
Europe has never been a partner, you just used our resources.
Ukraine gets to embarrass two loud-mouth dictators at the same time.
I am Russ woman, live Samara. We live poorly and need TOILET. 😢
How did the 2023 Ukraine offensive go? Lol
@@Sambo890 Better than 3 days to Kyiv. Lol
@@dpelpal I'm so sorry for what you going through i don't see it getting better for you in the short term hopefully in the long term it will
@@tlhamp0 Thank yous
Before this invasion started the Russian army was seen to be omnipotent with vast resources and equipment and yet they can’t seem to overcome a adversary that has not the same capabilities!
I'd say the Russian army is a paper tiger. But thats an insult to both paper and tigers😂😂😂
some say Russia has gained what they wanted and now are just holding it.
@@JerryPenna Those people are deluding themselves, you don’t waste all the equipment, munitions and more importantly the men to hold a small portion of the territory the Russians thought was theirs in a short time scale and then claim what they have achieved is somehow all they wanted in the first place!
@@davidkennedy8929 that makes sense. Frustrating to live with people who see a situation completely perverted.
You folks are living in a dream world.
North Korean troops being deployed in Ukraine, this means Russia is losing the war if they had to hire the NK troops. its that bad.
Just the same in World War II when all those Americans joined the English.
@@dalecrocker3213No, it's not the same botski troll
Koreans will flee in droves to get away from Mordor and their own country 😂
It means the DPRK has found a new income stream
@@boink800 Essentially it is. It's called getting help from your allies.
As usual it was worth spending my time on listening to your interview. Thanks.
Putin is secure until he isn't. The Russian regime is stable until it isn't. The clue is the economic strength.
Russia 1989: _All ok! Russia stronk!_
Russia 1995: Please send food and spare clothing to Rusha'😪
Slavia Ukraini 🇬🇧 ♥️ 🇺🇦
The Russian Special Military Diaster continues to amuse us. Ha ha ha ha 😂 🤣 😆 😄 😀
They're advancing by going backwards😂😂😂😂😂
@@starseedmiracle Oh yes, and the Moskva still sails as well! Statue of Liberty fell down! Britain Kaput! 😅
@@starseedmiracle Are we fabricating figures again, botski? Ha ha 😂 🤣 😆 😄 😅 😀
@@boink800 You fabricated a goal to Russia. They clearly stated the goals with this Kharkiv attack. They achieved it already. I dont get why everybody acts like they wnated to take more, when even Putin live on air stated the exact goals when they moved the troops in.
@@starseedmiracle Says the Russian MoD? they claim the failures of Kyiv, Kharkiv, Snake Island and Kherson to be "good will gestures". The number is actually closer to 70k killed and 3 to 4 times wounded
Excellent discussion. God bless the people of Ukraine.
Modern military technology favours defense. The element of surprise is denied by satellite and drone surveillance and the attacker is exposed to attack by precision weapons.
Favours defence or favors defense.. are you Canadian?
Just heard that Ukraine will receive 8 Patriot batteries from Israel!
The legendary Patriot what is hated everywhere by its users. ;)
@@TenylegMinekez-uc7co Yeah it's hated so much by Ukraine they are asking for more.
They lost the war badly so now it's terrorism 24/7.
@@TenylegMinekez-uc7co?
@@Monaco-BuilditFixitDriveitEver Iraq, Saudi-Arbia, Israel. Just the countries bought and used it. Or tried to use it.🤣
If Putler lets NK troops be in Ukraine, then NATO troops are also allowed.
Why? Russia is already losing😂
@@dpelpal
To make it lose faster, duh.
Russia won when the Ukrainian counteroffensive failed entirely. Russia has won the war....period
@@KIZMET3001
LOL, and then you woke up?
NATO forces have been in Ukraine for many months now 👍
Putin is gambling everyday.
And losing😂
Delusional jibberish
It’s certainly not for a lack of trying on the part of the Russians - but Ukrainians are just so stubborn on defence. They have all the nice defensive positions, all the logistics, and the morale too seems much higher with them. Russia just keeps hitting their heads into the wall.
Thanks for uptodate on the war.
Interesting and balanced. Thank you.
They know everything.... After it happend.
Another repeat. You have great guests but the constant repeats are really off putting. At least label them as abridged or brief or something so we don't have to watch a few minutes before realising we've already seen this interview.
The other thing that really annoys me, is the false kinda "intro".. it's a total spoiler to hear the first minute or so with no context and then to have it repeated.. I ALWAYS try and search for the actual real start.. I find it insulting to the viewer.. a simple "intro" chapter should be inforce ;-)))
@@toonertik totally agreed!
Time Radio is all about cheating. Quite amusing really.
If this channel isn't repulsive to you due to its endless fairy tales and blatant lies your not paying attention
It's because the Russians have met their brother slavs in battle. Maybe they are looking the mirror, maybe the younger brother has more desire and more vibrant youth to beat the older brother. The older brother needs to step back and respect the fight of the younger one.
I can't seem to find these segments in podcast form, please provide as very interesting
Thanks!
❤Ukrainian ❤
Stop pretending you care about Ukraine. It's sickening
Fools rush in!
These are the same people telling you the Petrol-Dollar being lost isn't a big deal as banks fail and the Yen collapses.
There is too little attention given to how effective an operator Putin is within the vertical of power. It is his creation and it is amazingly robust while he is at its pinnacle. However, when he inevitably leaves the stage the whole system will collapse into infighting. Ukraine has to survive as a nation until that happens.
Time is on Ukraine's side. Russia could never win with time an ally of Ukraine.
Ukraine will NEVER go on the offensive again until they have robust Air power and it was ridiculous of their Allies to expect them to get past the Surovikin line with Zero air help! I tell you the US would NEVER go to war not even with air power but they would ne attack without Air Superiority!!!
they are STILL waiting for the F16s...... nearly 30 months into this war, if Ukraines allies really supported them, this whole thing would have been over by now.
@@amonbonyora89 The First F16’s are supposed to arrive in June which is over in 1 week. Has anything promised EVER arrived on time? I suspect not!
@@amonbonyora89You do realize it takes like three years to train an F-16 pilot right genius?
They won’t need to go on an offensive. Russia will just exhaust itself and leave.
@@SeanP7195 That would be awesome! Let’s hope they leave sooner or later. My calculations are that Russia can afford to continue for a year and then their Sovereign Wealth Fund will be dangerously low. The Allies need to keep helping Ukraine through’25.
I agree with Jones, foreign mercenaries from Cuba, Africa, and now possibly North Korea reveal the shortage of ethnic Russians available to fight in Ukraine. Language is probably the critical factor. If Russian officers find it difficult to lead Russian speaking conscripts, think how difficult it is to lead foreign speaking troops, especially in the chaos of battle. With the demand for soldiers, the Kremlin must balance the personnel needed for battle with the manpower needed for commercial and war industries. Considering the fact that more than 50% of the population is female, and cultural taboos prevent females from working in heavy industry or serving near the battle fronts, Putin is handicapped even more. Despite the lack face-to-face field engagements in 2024, the strategic targeting of Russian radar sites and air defense systems, compromises the Russian ability to target Ukrainian military resources. With the advent of F-16 and Mirage fighters, the tables will be turned, concurrent with Ukrainian drone/missile attacks on oil refiing infrastructure.
I mean these foeign mercenary line sprove to be wrong every time the times brought it up. As all of your nonsensical points.
@@attilamarics3374 Have you been drinking the Kremlin Kool-Aide? The only country to perfect the mercenary formula was the French Foreign Legion. Russia's most recent experience with paid, mercenary fighters was Wagner who turned on the Kremlin almost one year ago today. These Soldiers of Fortune (mercenaries) believe in nothing, are loyal to nothing, and would stab Putin in the back if offered the right price. Russian generals must sleep with one eye open to see if their 'friends' would betray them.
Times lies continuously. The war is lost.
We have to keep Trump out of the white house because he will help Putin
Pendant que les Russes s'épuisent en Ukraine, les Chinois lorgnent patiemment sur une autre frontière. La Russie leur a déjà cédé avec un sourire pincé une moitié de l'île Bolchoï Oussouriisk, près de la ville de Khabarosk, une porte d'entrée vers la Mandchourie extérieure (superficie de près de 2 fois l'Ukraine). Fin stratège ce Poutine!😃
Слава Україні! 💙💛
Great analysis
Slava Ukraini
One more reason for the failure of the Kharkiv offensive is also that it was started prematurely. It was obvious that the build up of troops and material wasn't finished but then, the US passed the $61 billion aid package, so Putin and/or his generals decided to start it early to preempt the arrival of US aid.
The delay of that aid package by Putin's assets (whether knowingly or otherwise) in the US Congress sadly allowed him to take Avdiivka though.
@@frankpulmanns6685 Oh, it was knowingly.
Someone needs to let the little boy Pootin know he has lost his war against Ukraine~~~!!! 𝙎𝙝𝙖𝙡𝙤𝙢
The ones who did are rotting away in prison now.
Still can't see Ukraine results. Did they go directly to Vladivostok? I thought they wanted to get back Ukrainian territories...
Putin won
Who is lying to you? The truth is the opposite.
Hello, is this still working.
This isn't 3 hours old it's yesterday's content.
Russia hasn't been good on the offense since Stalin pushed the Nazi's out of russia and all the way to Berlin. Since World War II, russia has mostly been really good at defense. They lost in Afghanistan. But russia has been really good at "cold war" and being on the defense. We know how good the russians at defense from when Ukraine attempted their counter offense last summer. There is a history of russia's giving up, i.e. Afghanistan and the collapse of the Eastern Block. What Ukraine wants is to speed up the russian collapse on the eastern front. It took so long for the Eastern Block to collapse along with the Berlin Wall, but the West was not in a hot war then as Ukraine is in a hot war currently. It should be expected that with (1) the sanctions, (2) the Ukrainian heavy attacks on oil refineries, (3) the tremendous loses of russian lives and in military equipment, (4) the Black Sea Fleet's limited area of maneuvers, (5) the poor leadership of russian generals, (6) the failures of putin, (7) the free world against him, (8) the necessity to rely upon North Korea for help, ((9) the moral decay of the leadership of russia and their short term denial of war crimes, the kidnapping of children, and the eventual realization of payments of reparations, which they are now learning about since interests from their assets are going to be going to Ukraine, the problems inside russia that are not being address, should make putin an outcast in russia, and as such, by his inner circle. Expect a real bloodletting among his senior staff before his demise comes about.
Hasnt it not yet confirmed about nk participation?
Never been totally convinced the Ukrainians were ever low on ammo. If ammo stocks really were running low then they wouldn’t be telling everyone. They’d be far more likely to keep quiet about it. The fact they were saying they were running out of ammo suggested to me they weren’t. It’s more likely that dozens and dozens of countries have been keeping them well supplied for months and months
Probably why Russia losing so badly. I'm in Russia. I know the true loss
They were low the only reason they didn't retreat was for there own drone production they were vastly short of artillery shells
😃. Sure. They would be quiet about it. And the Russians wouldn't notice that they don't shoot as much as earlier. You are a military mastermind 🤣
@@dpelpal Sure, sure.
Putin failure is always the same, send a lot of men and win?😵💫
Putin won
They were not pushing to Kharkiv,they were on purpose only going to the river line to make Ukrainian artillery out of range of their cities and too spread out Ukrainian forces so they have more of a advantage in the Donbass
Another repeat
Russia just liberated spirne in occupied east ukraine
if this guy was a general our military is not worth the trouble.
Huh??
@@rogerout8875 not exactly an expert in his field bro...
@@operator9858 what??,
'Russia is about to lose' - The Times for last 3 years 😂😂😂😂
Listen to the interview...they re not saying that.
Russia is about to lose. It has been inevitable since they failed spectacularly to take Kyiv. Putin’s Martingale strategy with Russia’s national wealth fund can’t last for long.
Failed? But you have seen the maps day by day?
Hush now, these throbbers still believe Russia ran out of ammo 2 years ago, and are fighting with shovels!
Absolutely! What's taking the pathetic Russian "army" soooooooo long??? Have you seen a calendar??
The Russians have been playing the long grinding game. They are making gains everywhere. I don't know what map this guy is looking at but it's not one in this reality.
@aurelius7 I guess that's Plan B after 3-day Invasion that we heard on Russian state run TV.
Nobody knows how to die for their country like a Russian!
Putin crushed NATO weapon operators all across Ukraine .
Sources?? That sounds like something a desperate putin troll would literally make up.
@@rogerout8875 There are hundreds of videos if you don't look the other way.
@@Arhatu what do I loom up to find that nonsense?
I look forward to watching how you continue to avoid actually answering the question
@@Arhatu answer the question
@@rogerout8875 I don't know how to answer , should I send the photo of map or Western weapons exibit in Moskow?
This expert was very informative and thoughtful in his analysis. Much better than a previous expert of yours recently who laughably believed that one call from China, and Russia will stop the War immediately… because…China…said so. And this man wasn’t joking??? Probably the most uninformed thing Anyone on earth has said about The Invasion.
The Russians couldn't attack on other parts of the front, because the needed their most motivated and effective troops in the Kherson sectors as well, in the second line, to prevent mass desertion.
STOP REPEAT POSTINGS YOU SHOWED ME THIS YESTERDAY. GET SERIOUS.
It really the human factor. Russia allready lost most of its high ranking offciers in prevoius years.
You cant just subsitute someone with a differnt backround and expect them to know what they are doing.
Repeat Please
Why, this guy cracks me up, although the real answer would make for a very short video, Why did the Russian's fail, because they are Russian not a long or sexy answer just a truthful one.🙃
I would like to hear what general Jones considers victory. Maybe he should read about the last two years of WW2. He knows nothing about the Russians way of war. If they are quoting the ISW you’re losing.
Wow - Galatians is among the most interesting books in the NT, and this guest chose to spend the entire interview discussing boring textual minutia. This could have been a great video, but the scholar can't seem to see the forest for the trees. Wish he had focused on what Paul was actually expressing.
Comrade Putin shall preserve
😁😁😁😁 Should Moscow surrender? 😂
Let's discuss it in 2035🤓
From the history books
@@rogerout8875 Our hypersonic missiles don't care about history books😁
@@StPiter111 Patriot doesn't care about any junk Russian missile
@@StPiter111 At least you know you'd get totally flatlined in a conventionnal war
@@AnimaChronix3 against NATO? Russia produces four and a half million shells and hundreads of tanks per year😅 NATO produces less than one million shells and dozens of new tanks per year. 😅
Russia's got 6000 brand new hypersonic nukes like Sarmat, Bulava, Avantgard, Kinzhal, Czircon, Topol, Yars, etc.
The Western Minuteman and Trident missiles are 40 years old, and can't fly 😁
Let's dance😎
With curent limits USA weapon delivery no hope for Ukraine counteroffensive
As soon as NK troops are attack NK gonna try to escalate even tho they are in Ukraine lol
NK troops will immediately defect and surrender.
Battle of the Bulges and hosting teenage soldiers ww3 memories.
Science fiction... without the science ;)
What part hurt your feelings the most?
@@rogerout8875 the fiction part ;) ❤
@@michaelkozhuharov1923 and specifically, which part was that?
(This is the part where you keep running away)
Please slow down, complete your sentences, pronunciation is important. Ramblings, you know? I mean, terrible guest.
01:23 This guy is British, the viewers of Times RADIO are basically British or Europeans, why is he bringing "American football", "the quality of the plays" to the conversation?
I mean, the majority of us don't even know the rules, the full nine yards of it...
Why didn't he use a rugby or a standard football analogy?
Why is he being a lap dog?
Because American football is infinitely more exciting than your soccer yawn fest!
@@KIZMET3001 No mate, this British dude is really selling the war to the Americans.
Regarding how exciting the two sports are... I mean, the numbers speak for themselves.
One is a national sport, the other is a global sport.
Oooh shovels again. Here we go. Can you tell me what happened to Ukraine 2023 big offensive after the west unprecedented military aid? Asking for a friend lol
Russia has multiple failed offensives bud.
That's why you can't name one!
@foilhat1138 but still kept thr same 18% new territory they took 20 months ago lol
@@Sambo890 After losing half the territory they occupied 2.5 years ago.
@foilhat1138 have they kept the 18% tho? After unprecedented military aid from West. Lol thr big counter offensive they took back what of the 18% ? Il help you out , none hahahaha
Wow. With all due respect Major General, you are not acknowledging reality. Russia is, and has been since the beginning, playing the long game. They are making gains all across the front lines. Are we both looking at the same map?
Some say Russia has gained what they wanted and now are just holding it?
They have no hope of that either.
Some say Rushin' army is a total joke. And I'm Russian, I should know
Putin wanted ALL of Ukraine
There’s so much misinformation its hard tell whats going on, fact from fiction.
Gained what they wanted? Even recently they claimed the entirety of the four provinces which are partly covered in Ukrainian troops.
Dumb much? Russia pushed until the newest batch of weapons started arriving in Ukraine, then dug in. You people have absolutely no idea when it comes to tactics. Now, the ukes will go on the attack and lose around 30,000 more troops.
Ukraine already lost 30 thousand troops over the last month.
@@KIZMET3001accourding to kremlin TV?
If that's what helps you sleep..
@@KIZMET3001Sources? That sounds like something a desperate putin troll would literally make up.
@@rogerout8875 Both the russkis and the ukes lost around 30k troops in June. There's the difference between a propagandist and a realist. Realists don't choose sides.
This man is talking garbage.
What part hurt your feelings the most?
I think TR needs to be kicked off UA-cam and sanctioned like Russia for recycling stories with different clickbait Headlines! Truly unprofessional and disrespectful of their audience!
Ok Ivan
Then why are you here?
Zelenski just said he needs negotiations as he has lost too many troops.
Liar
Hello Ivan.
@@tomw.6757 "Ukraine does not want to prolong the war, we do not want it to last for years", - Zelensky
❗"We have many wounded and killed on the battlefield. We have to put a settlement plan on the table within a few months," the president added.
@@tellyboy17 you poor fool. Russia has already lost
Yeh, With this failure rate , Putin is continually retreating ….towards Kiev 😜. Seriously are you a news or wishful thinking channel 😂
You know that's not actually happening, right? The furthest Russia has advanced is 30 kilometers.
That's like 15 miles. It's nothing.
@@tomw.6757 yeh, and Putin is seriously sick …..since 2022 😜🤣
@@capthajjarable I wouldn't know about that. I do know Russia lost this war.
You must be new here! Welcome to the lie factory complex!
Your delusional
Russia 🇷🇺 is great and strong.
Hillarious rant
Absolute garbage...
Utter nonsense!
Slava Ukraini
God bless Ukraine
6******