Netflix's Star Wars Ripoff is a TOTAL DISASTER
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- For some reason, Netflix gave Zach Snyder $166 Million Dollars to make a Star Wars film. The result is a movie some critics are calling one of the worst sci-fi films of all time, and assuredly the worst movie Snyder has ever directed. Let's take a look at some of the reviews for Rebel Moon Part One: A Child of Fire.
►SECOND CHANNEL: / vitotwo
►COMIC: www.superkille...
►PATREON: / thevitoshow
►MERCH: killdozer.indus...
►PODCAST: biggestproblem.com
►TWITCH: / thevitoshow
Send Vito Stuff:
Vito Gesualdi
PO Box 575
San Gabriel, CA 91778
13:50 Re, 'fake grittiness': Yes, there's a specific way of distressing costumes that all movies use. You throw the costume into a dryer for several cycles along with a scoop of dry, medium-gauge gravel. I think it was pioneered by the Lord of the Rings people. Once you recognize the pattern of fake 'wear', you see it everywhere, in every genre film since then.
I don't think this is even specific to movie costumes. Rolling jeans with rocks is a very common method in factories
@@mikeydflyingtoaster right but the context I originally heard this in was when they were trying to costume Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn and wanted his clothes to look like shit from a lifetime patrolling Middle Earth as a Ranger. Regular 'distressing' of costumes meant snipping little holes in the clothes here and there but they decided that didn't look right so they came up with something else. I've heard people who know about knitting look at the shitty sweaters everyone is wearing in The Matrix and say, "There is no way a sweater would unravel that way on its own."
@@jeremy____5747 Gotcha. I suppose I can support the efforts of the filmmakers because of course they need to create a specific look for their characters even if they fail to do a job that holds up to scrutiny. A normal pair of jeans being ripped and having paint splattered on them before they are ever worn is really bizarre when you think about it. Saying that, I know I own jeans just like that. Fashion is weird
Zack Snyder is not good with dialogue and struggles to make a full coherent story. the two things that I think he does well is action and humor.
I would disagree about Zach’s dialogue. I think it’s excellent. However, I’m sure we could both agree that our moms’ name is Martha.😂 thus, brilliant dialogue. Haven’t even watched the movie and I know how great the dialogue is 😮
Is that a friend of Zack Snyder?
if you can't even spell his name noones gonna take you seriously
@@Lamaldo78I save proper grammar for my job
He's not George Lucas lol his dialogues fine, his biggest weakness is joining a story together and pacing
"they work for reputable organizations, big time news papers and publications"....Vito buddy have you not been paying attention the last 6 or 8 years?
I find it funny how when Snyder gets negative reviews from rotton tomatoes it matters..... 😂
I didn't like justice league or bvs, but I did like 300 and watchmen. So I have no problem watching a Sci fi movie with a subscription I'm already paying for and can always stop the movie if I don't like it.
I don't care what critics say. I judge films for myself.
Then you are a dumb consumer
For having his own opinion? 😂😂😂😂
@@vitoAnd you need to grow up and get out of that basement surrounded by toys. When was the last time you had a woman?
@@leogolive Dude the movie sucks...chill out and get in touch with reality🤣
@@vitoYou fell off, bad.
On the bright side, Disney gets a break from bad news.
Not really. Netflix just buys the shit off of whoever. So Disney is still responsible for this.
good one 😂
Hey Vuti. I think calling it a Star Wars rip off gives Star Wars too much credit. From the trailer, I pick up some DUNE, WARHAMMER, ARCANE, FOUNDATION, EXPANSE, fantasy like DUNGEONS & DRAGONS/STARCRAFT and yes, also Star Wars. It's the sci-fi genre. I don't think we as creatives or as a public should allow Star Wars to claim that domain solely.
As our reality gets close to advanced technology and even space exploration and continue to further ponder our place in the galaxy, I think movies like this will only increase and I'll be damned if they're all gonna be deemed Star Wars knock-off's. The amount of sci-fi and fantasy that Star Wars drew from at the time of its inception is immense and shouldn't be allowed to be packed up with a brand label.
Anyway, I'm gonna give it a shot.
To anybody who isn't creative for a living, here's an exercise:
Think of a truly original idea right now. That hasn't been seen or done before.
You have to think of what's been seen and done before.
So the result is by its very nature derived from other existing things.
In fact, the ideas you come up with are only seen as valuable and or novel precisely because of the significance they derive from other existing thoughts, characters, ideas, concepts, etc.
First, they should not have told people it was originally made for Star Wars.
Second, they should not have said it was a part one.
Third, They should have made their first movie, and maybe subsequent movies, a stand alone.
Also, I agree that critics should at least like, if not specialize in genres they critic. For example, I don't chick flicks so I don't think I shouldn't be advising on one, lol
Specialize? Your post was going so good, so extremely well, until you made that last sentence.
@@icqpimp I agree with you that specialize wasn't the right way to say it. I guess I should should have kept it a personal choice for myself, that I would worry that my personal genre bias might negatively affect my critique to those that would look to my opinion. I suppose to get around that I would have to let let my genre preferences be known and ask people to judge for themselves
UA-camrs seem to love RT when it aligns with their opinions but then calls them shills and phonies other times.
The only time critics get it wrong is when they are dealing with franchise films like Star Wars. Properly critiquing a film like that requires awareness of the surrounding lore which many critics lack.
Rebel Moon is a new franchise and thus the critics can be trusted.
@@vitoshill inventing rules.
@@vito75% of top critics thought Army of the Dead was a good movie 🤮
Snyder shined in Guardians of Ga’hoole because he handled the action and the original story wasn’t written by him.
The look and style of the good Snyder films can mainly be attributed to cinematographer Larry Fong and visual effects artist John ‘D.J.’ Des Jardin.
Ehhh rotten tomato critics have always hated Snyder and criticized him for things they gave other movies like Disney marvel and Star Wars praise for. That being said with how bad army of the dead was I’m not going to say it’s going to be good either. Although if Kathleen Kennedy denied it that’s a good sign too lol might have actually likable characters in it
This movie was so boring, I turned it off after she killed the first Space Nazis.
So it’s the same quality as Disney Star Wars? No surprise there. Snyder’s Watchmen was good, the rest of his movies are bad.
Netflix ain't feeling bad. I guarantee this will be the number one streaming movie on all platforms
Yep. Even if most people don't even watch the whole thing, doesn't matter. Watching a streaming video requires such minimal investment.
Doesn't really matter how many people watch it. Every single subscriber could watch it. That doesn't do anything for them. They want to pick up new subscribers. If it doesn't do that it doesn't make them money.
I never hear anyone say this, so i've decided to bring it up anytime Snyder is mentioned- the ending of Man of Steel- Superman snaps Zod's neck, screams with rage and cries about 'what he had to do',and the emotional impact Snyder wants isn't there- because it's a scene lifted from a better story, one i know Snyder is familiar with- Alan Moore's Miracleman. An exact panel reconstruction of Miracleman holding dead Johnny Bates😢.
Snyder is a hack.
Shambles is technically correct because the independent is a British newspaper. In British English shambles can be used on its own as a noun as in “x is a shambles”. In American English I’m pretty sure it can only be used like this “x was in shambles”
Every time a film of his fails he pulls the same sh/t. "That wasn't my real vision, the studio's against me, I have a better longer cut of the film" blah blah blah.
It's funny how $83 million seems like a high budget movie for Netflix, but pretty low for your typical blockbuster movie lol. Plus, the budget was likely even lower, because I'd imagine a majority of the $166 million was saved for part 2.
Didn't expect another Hack Snyder picture to get any praise from the critics
The problem with Snyder is they let him write too many of his productions. He is a very talented director and visual artist, but not a good storyteller.
Will never watch another girl boss movie period.
I second that.
Why do you guys hate women? 😂😂😂😂 poor guy probably gets no pussy
How many reputable critics liked the last jedi?
“Big time magazines” 😂😂😂😂 old media
Sci-fi "Seven Samurai" has actually already been done. An anime called "Samurai 7", it was decent from what I remember.
It doesn't matter if it sucks as long as it puts up numbers. That's all Netflix cares about.
@2:38 Vito is talking to himself, not Scraps
I've never really gotten rotten tomatoes. If a movie is universally panned by critics, wouldn't it be 100% rotten? 0% rotten indicates that it's not rotten i.e. good?
I’ll judge it myself. At worst, it can’t be any worse than Disney’s derivative Star Wars crapfest.
Same here. Will see it this week.
Netflix holds the rights to Old Man's War. That book series would make an awesome "star wars" trilogy.
There's so many book sagas that are ripe for big screen adoptions. Thank God they don't do it, thought. They'd just eff it up.
Disney definitely could have paid the critics off to try and crush it, not out of the realm of possibility
Dude please shut up🤣
A scenario that's rather probable
Kinda sensitive to criticism as a critic is certainly ironic but as a critic you haven't seen this and no one in the comments has and to be frank I don't know a review I have read about media that I personally enjoy in the last several years that has been close to accurate. Why? Because I think alot of these people get paid very well by companies to give positive reviews and access. It's a movie trying to take away attention from Disney SW that certainly has all the wrong media attention and subpar content of the last several years with D+ struggling seem like a media slam campaign against Snyder's movie but I think this will have the opposite effect as now everyone will want to see this just to see if it is that bad. Again no one here has seen this movie.
After watching the movie for 15min I turned it off. I couldn't do it. I didnt know the show was considered unpopular.
Movie is prob cap, but could also be stuffy reviewers who are mad it ll be in the theaters without the traditional corrupt process
Dont know why they keep giving Zack the keys, on a side note, get the bunny army to Pop Culture Crisis at 3.
I love that Zack Snyder began using the speed up slow down shots to help emphasize the individual comic frames from 300, but at this point I don't think even he remembers why he uses them
How is Charlie Hunam still working. He makes Keanu look like Brando.
He is Brando in comparison. Point Break, The Matrix… 😀
@@andreasgoransson But he'll always be Bill S. Preston, Esq. to me... primarily because that's the only character that he can convincingly pull off. 😂
@@amandzzz hahahaha 😂
When mom says, we have Star Wars at home.
Better than modern star wars.
why do they need to keep every decent franchise running forever! it's always the equivalent of dying a hero or living long enuf to become the enemy. same with ppl who refuse to retire until their like 90. just give us something new and get rid of all the greedy boomers clinging onto the top of the chain who keep trying to squeeze every dollar out of every franchise. we need ppl in their 40s running hollywood and the country, not some crusty old fux in their 80s
Let's not forget RTcritics score 83% for Ring of Power
Make entertainment male again.
'Battle beyond the stars' was a Sci-fi 7 samurai. I would expect anything by Snyder to be shallow, he seems to base his plotting on the phrase 'Wouldn't it be cool if..' and the most complex he gets with his characters is 'badass'. However, to be fair, RT 'top reviewers are never going to give Snyder a good review because his fans seem to have the wrong politics, and they're the same people who gave good reviews to the likes of She Hulk, the Last Jedi, etc. - so we shouldn't really be legitimising anything they say. But I'm sure it will be crap.
If it's anything like every other movie he's made in the last 13 years, it's probably a piece of shit
I understand, Vito. Do I listen to the fuckin critics or not? Make up your damn mind.
The rumor is that George Lucas chased Zack Snyder out his office with a hammer after hearing his idea for a star wars film😂
Can't wait to watch this trashfire of a movie. Star Wars is more Hidden Fortress though than Seven Samurai.
Nerds piss me off now. They didn’t used to.
Remo Williams: The Adventure Begins
Anyone who still hires Zack Snyder deserves their failure. Double plus so, if you actually let him write the script!
Also, I heard that even the "positive" reviews were like 6/10 level middling, not even really praising it.
I remember people hyping Shitty Space Magnificent seven wars up and I was confused after seeing the first set photo. I’m not a cinephile hell I loved 300 but this looked like garbage
I'm just here to watch the Snyder bros lose their collective shit.
Where a force unleashed movie, or God forbid a Disney series
Just watched the trailer and I still have chills.th8s shit looks amazing.
Honestly I have no idea if this movie is any good. It could be as bad as the crirics say. But I don't trust critics after how bad they were with stuff like Last Jedi or Last of Us 2. I'll wait for the general audience consensus.
What happened to our comment chain?
I am sorry Snyderstans but he ALWAYS BEEN A HACK.
You can say it all you want, but it wont make it true. You probably don't know what a "hack" is.
Vito, I love ya but your basing this entire video on a shitty websites critic's score. Top critics don't often reflect people's opinion on a movie. That's why they're separate.
This is a big sci fi movie unrelated to star wars.. people will go see it cuz its something new and refreshing.
Top critics are awesome and I trust their expertise
wow no top critics liked it? Does that mean its the best movie ever?
I tried to watch this, but it's terrible. Zack Snyder should've just been a visual director or cinematographer and should also be kept away from slow motion for the rest of his life.
Pls review the movie when it gets released 🙏🙏🙏🙏
A low crictic score on rotten tomatoes makes me curious. I always watch
watched this between christmas and new years, probably one of the worst movies ive ever seen
All Tell...No Show.
The beginning....long overly verbose, intro then a skinny space Emo girl plowing a dirt farm.
Then space Hobbiton Prancing Pony....
Really? No Zazz.
Did Zack Snyder rip off Battle Beyond the Stars?
Need white elephant gift? VIto's advertised merch would be great
Zack Snyder makes garbage movies. He's like Michael Bay, but far less coherent and struggling with some kind of ongoing depression. If you like garbage movies, more power to you. But do be aware that you are watching garbage movies when you watch his stuff.
I agree, but I liked 300 and wonder woman
@@colinjohnson6454 he was a minor contributor on Wonder Woman.. like JJ Abrams on Cloverfield or something.. other people are the real creatives on them.
@@thisguy4505 Thats true.
If critics hate it then it might be great. Critics love trash
Holy crap that sucks for Snyder fans….
I saw reviews I feel it's constructed hate
When we gaming Vito?
snyder is a hack. completely unoriginal
So did you watch this flick ?
You’re a funny guy, Vito - and consistently so. 👌😁
Disney Star Wars are Dead 😵
The best Star Wars movie is The Fifth Element.
Looks like it was all shot on one set peice like a sitcom 😂
Love scraps
"they just took a shower, they are not gritty"
Sure, but why would they be dirty? If anything, showering and washing would be a lot easier on the future. Why *would* they be dirty? To live up to your expectations?
Dune did the same, part 1 is just the bait for part 2
A whole setup film that didn’t have a lot of action but look at the praise that film garnered im not saying it’s bad by any means but ide argue it’s not the masterpiece some claim and I’m willing to bet when this movie dropS I’ll be arguing it’s not as bad as some of these critics say…that’s usually how this type of thing goes with me
@@alxinthehype Nah dude when a movie debuts with 9%, clearly something is wrong that movie. Critics do get it wrong but never to this extent. The movie probably largely sucks
@@M_k-zi3tn 😅I think you missed and made my point at the same time almost every movie has issues it’s why I bought up dune ALOT of people say it’s a total snooze fest but yet the critics pretty much loved it did it get panned for being what some may consider a boring movie….nope I’m just saying the problems in rebel moon might not be as bad as that score and also since I’m not a fool I want you to know the difference between debuting with a 9% with like 8 reviews and debuting with a 9% with 150 because the difference is real buddy unless you just trust every critic and your making excuses to further hate on the film
@@alxinthehype yeah but clearly not a lot of people have a problem with Dune given it's ratings from both critics and audiences are very high. So the 2 movies aren't in a similar situation in any way.
9% hoewver you wanna look at it is major cause for concern and sure, maybe the problems aren't as bad as the critics are making it out to be, but that could just simply mean the movie sucks slightly less, therefore it still pretty much sucks.
@@M_k-zi3tn if that’s your takeaway I can’t argue that but it’s definitely other perspectives to view a rotten tomatoe critic in 2023
You're compromised media... I'm out
good
I think you are talking too bold about a movie you didn’t watch. Knit picking on the pictures and stuff.. I am not defending a movie which I didn’t watch but I wouldn’t shit on it this much, I’d just report that the feed back is bad, and may be lightly comment on it.m, I would lose myself on shifting on every material I can see about it on the internet if I were you.
The movies good its also not very much like star wars
cope
Omg daddy I’m first
First.
you saw it?
Yup
Am so glad am not Sub'd with Netflix , that Budget is just totally ridiculous , And who wants to see another Film near based on what has went Before..
Honestly Vito, top critics also said the Last Jedi was a masterpiece so... I wouldn't go dunking on this movie until you've watched it. Some people just like dunking on Snyder. He's like the Nickleback and/or Creed of film; their music might be shallow and corny, but sometimes I find myself belting out "NEVER MADE IT AS A WISEMAN."/"CAN YOU TAKE ME HIGGGHHAAAAA"
@@edreynolds8721 Star Wars has had 40 years to succeed and fail, and for the past decade it’s mostly failed. it’s released some stinkers. This is not even out on Netflix yet, it’s only being reviewed by round 1 of critics from top publications, watch the fucking thing before you start comparing it to how much money Star Wars has made. That’s like asking a toddler why they aren’t playing basketball like Lebron James yet.
Some people do actually have taste, you know
@@edreynolds8721 lol I only liked rogue one from Disney as well. I think I misunderstood your initial comment. Are you pro star wars being the (let’s say) gold standard for science fiction film for how much money it’s made? Is that what you were implying? Because I’d argue that it’s its detriment to the genre. I’ve been increasingly frustrated with how much Disney has taken the IP and cratered it (IMHO) so it’s good to know we agree on that. Frankly, I was looking forward to Rebel Moon because I liked the idea of how Snyder took his story pitch from Disney and gave it to Netflix. Especially after this entire past year of Disney SW. I was hoping for good things because I want there to be competitiveness in this genre, in entertainment as a whole. Aside from that, the trailer looked amazing and it has two of my favorite actors; Charlie Hunnam and Doona Bae. I’m sorry for the misunderstanding if that is the case. Watching a video of Vito ingesting the salt of critics who are probably very pro studio system and anti Netflix was also frustrating to watch. My original stance still stands: like “bad” alt Rock bands like nickleback and creed; Snyder is like Michael Bay in that he’s an easy target and punching bag for heady critics at major publications. Rebel Moon is fucking obviously a contrived Star Wars movie made by Zack Snyder, a guy famous for making shallow comic book movies (yes, watchmen) people knocking it for story structure and characterization are idiots to think it’s anything more than CGI and cool effects. You can expect more of movies, sure, but for Rebel Moon, that’s what I know i’m getting into. This comment is beyond my misunderstanding at this point. if I wanted a deep, rich, sci-fi story I’d fucking READ Dune. SW has always been kinda ass, and I hope it gets put to rest honorably someday. Anyways again sorry and good to know we agree on something.
Sorry dude, but The Last Jedi is a masterpiece compared to this crap. Hell, the poster alone looks like a mish-mash mess from about four different films.
@@edreynolds8721right, the all time leading scorer in the NBA sucks. Stop snorting that powder, kiddo.
This is the first time I hear about this.
And I am so happy that people are trying to make "new Star Wars" kinda films.
It's awesome! But they usually fail (understandable)
But we might get a hit at some point!
I like that thought.
This makes me think of the review of Battlefield earth by Jon Stewart "A cross between Star Wars and the smell of ass”. I sense a long review of this that I'm going to enjoy. Common Vito you know you're looking forward to this.
Tbh
I’d prefer more crappy Star Wars content then crappy Star Wars knock offs
😂😂😂😂😂
I only like things based on the Rotten Tomatoes score.
I usually trust the audience score over critics but then you have Bright which was godawful and the fans loved it, apparently.
Watched tis last night, went in not knowing anything other than what was in the trailers. It was the dumbest thing I've seen in a while. It didn't feel like Star Wars at all to me.... I don't know what the hell that was, but it wasn't good.
Action films like this are no longer interesting, and the "strong female character" trope, whilst it was already very cringe in 2015, has gotten so stale that even mainstream, normie audiences can't really take this slop any more. The only hope that Hollywood tells new stories that are much more character or world-building driven, either with male OR female characters.
This used to be par-for-the-course in 2014, when we had great male-driven series like LOTR/The Hobbit and Star Wars, but also great female-driven series like My Little Pony. In order to save itself, Hollywood needs to go back to this kind of storytelling. It is very sad that the last 7-8 years of Hollywood have been an absolute disaster, a veritable QUAGMIRE of mind-rot and hackish storytelling, but the only way we can move past it is, as JJ Abrams so infamously and badly put it in 2015, "move backwards, so we can go forwards."
What would actually be innovative that this point would be to make a story about a male action hero who does all the normal action hero stuff, one liners, pulling off impossible stunts etc, but who just happens to be in a loving relationship with another man who's definitely a little more feminine than him but not full Will and Grace gay.
The Hobbit was awful
They gotta stop giving him money 😂 his fanbase alone isn't gonna cover the cost of making these movies
Probably not enough "slit slappin" in the movie. 0/10
Zack Snyder was inspired by Star Wars to make Rebel Moon.
Obviously derivative, but keep in mind that it was originally envisioned to take place in the SW galaxy. In that context, it flows more naturally with the pre-existing continuity. No, it's not the greatest thing ever, but it's still better than ANYTHING in the Sequel Trilogy!
That poster is fantastic it looks like it could be excellent. Too bad
What! The caliber minds like Mags Visago involved how could this possibly suck!?
Man, Sucker Punch is something I only know of because it was one of the first Red Letter Media reviews.