Beat Saber vs. Supernatural - Which is the better workout?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- Is Supernatural just a knock off Beat Saber? Is Beat Saber a better workout than Supernatural? It's time to settle the score! Don't forget to LIKE and SUBSCRIBE for more content!
Subscribe for more Virtual Reality Fitness reviews from a REAL Fitness Professional:
/ @fitprovr
Share this video with a friend:
• Video
Let's connect:
Instagram - / ari_lifts_things
Shout out to Bart Graft for providing me with the track "Capital Investment" for my intro music, you can check out his channel HERE:
/ @bartgraft9925
Thanks again for watching, I look forward to hearing what people have to say about this one!
#beatsaber #oculusquest2 #getsupernatural
Ultimately the best workout is going to be the one you'll regularly do. Beat Saber brings me much joy so I'm going to keep playing. If you're a Beat Saber player who goes for top scores, you'll know that the scoring mechanism favors large, sweeping motions, not the choppy motions you're talking about. And once you're playing on Expert Plus the range of motion is very large, so if you're an expert plus Beat Saber player and maximizing for score you will absolutely be getting an amazing workout.
Yeah it's pretty obvious he is not a skilled Beat Saber player
@@Watesoftheoasis I mean, he says so himself, right in the video lmao
@@igo9481 Sure, but then to take his experience as a bad player and extrapolate that is, frankly, idiotic.
@@Watesoftheoasis his only point is to get people to stop shaming SN players by hammering on about how they are the same game when they are clearly not. Climb down out of your own ass and listen to the points being made instead of trying super hard to be really smart. It's, quite frankly, idiotic
Chords person only helps prove SB is better for a work out asap. You need to become a expert or better to start getting a work out in saber beat off. Appreciate your info!
The problem was that he set out to prove that supernatural was better, so he subconsciously moved him arms less and tried to get a worse workout from beatsaber. It’s a common happening in experiments known as subject bias.
Confirmation bias
Confirmation bias
And he is not playing on the difficulty enthusiast play (E+)
I play custom levels in beatsaber on E+ with 2kg weight on every hand and a 10kg vest, this guy telling me im not working out because beat saber was not built to be a workout is a moronic take when my chest HRM is estimating im spending about 1000kcal per hour
As you're probably aware, there is a large aftermarket for custom beat sabre maps. There is a specific category for "fitness" and that is intense and uses a much more extensive range of motion than many of the other maps. It's quite a robust workout.
Those are a thing??
If you have "More playlists" with Mod Assistant do a search for "Fitbeats" and get ready to SQUAT lol
I had no idea. I’ll look when I get home. Thanks for the info
in the extras volume, "fitbeat" is one of these maps. for anyone not wanting to fiddle with mods
yea some of those idk if there badly made or im just slow as hell lmao.
💯 I've been working out pretty regularly for 16 years then suddenly got completely bored. I started using Supernatural 11 days ago and I am hooked! I've always been the type that preferred playing sports over organized exercising, but that is just not possible with my career anymore and this has been a perfect solution. I don't care how tired or sore I am, I come home every day looking forward to doing Supernatural. And even if I tell myself I'm only going to do 20 minutes, I end up doing an hour, even an hour and a half. It's not only great for someone who is competitive, but for someone who really wants a fun workout. And I also have to say that for us older females, it is a great way to tone your arms. If you do it right, and follow the form that they want you to, in terms of body movements, it is an amazing workout!
SN is pretty amazing. Been doing it for about 6 weeks. Started out twice a week, then 3x now moving to 4x a week. It’s a great workout and I encourage folks to give it a shot. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
Im definitely thinking of trying it out,I have the day off from work for 4 days and i think that could be a good thing for me to use during that time.
I like beat Saber and already bought it but realized there's like not much song selection. I'm thinking of getting the supernatural but it's so expensive, does it come with good music or do I have to pay extra like beat saber?
Ashame it doesn't work in every country
@@samanthalebaron2113 It comes with music, and they literally add new workouts every single day...there's currently over 900 workouts that they are still adding to.
It sucks, it isn't fun, and its a ripoff of Beat Saber trying to market as a fitness game.
The problem is that you don't use your shoulders in Beat Saber like you're doing in Supernatural. My shoulders burn after I intentionally use them for slashing. There's no need to compare them because they're very similar, it just depends how you play them.
I would argue that there is much more leg involvement in SN as well.
@@FitProVR yeah that's true. There are Beat Saber maps that utilizes the walls to push a fitness theme, but I admit there are only a few of these that the community is making.
@@PatrickJoshua 💯💯 thanks for your input! I appreciate it!
SN has a 30 day free trial. More than enough time to figure out if it works for you! Cheaper than a gym.
Exactly. I'm happy they are willing to do this.
Agreed! I just finished my first workout. I’m sold!!
I don’t really have the money to use supernatural, I do have beat saber and managed to lose 20 pounds playing it. It truly depends on your play style when playing beat saber.
How often do you play?
@@FirstnameLastname-jo7sc when I lost the weight I played 4-5 times a week for an hour or two at a time, I was also eating very healthy and drinking no soda or anything like that.
Fatal_Corn For how many days ?
@@neosj3003 prolly months
I am 61 and I love supernatural. I turned my 69 year old husband on to working out with it too. What a workout. I will often end my vr session with a song or two in beat saber. I enjoy the beauty of Supernatural and its' 360 degree element so much more. 2 thumbs up and definitely worth the money. I finally found something to get me to exercise that excites me.
I love supernatural, I was struggling getting motivated to workout and my husband got a oculus quest I found supernatural and now I look forward to working out everyday. ❤️
It definitely has the motivation piece on lock!
Yep! I needed a hook and it has delivered!
Same!!
@@TROLL-TV are you in the US or Canada? This is the only places it is available.
@@TROLL-TV maybe eventually but as of now there are no plans
Supernatrual is an amazing workout tool. I usually use Beat Saber to warm up, and then I jump right into Supernatural. Thank you for creating this video. Can't wait to check out more of your content!
after playing both, i can say while they both have things that cut (or break) things coming at you, they are very different games, because supernatural wants you to keep working out, while beat saber just wants you to cut blocks. i love beat saber a lot better than supernatural, but supernatural gives me a better workout.
I avoided SN for so long, and had that same "it's just Beatsaber" mentality. But then decided to try the one month trial a few weeks ago, now I see the value in it and am definitely keeping it with a subscription. Also, I definitely hit a much higher heart rate on SN.
Absolutely! They are very different!
I agree! I love and use both, but the better work out is SN. Mix up Flow with boxing and you will sweat and breathe heavy and be good-tired.
I really appreciate your perspective. And by your metrics you are indeed correct. However, that’s why I intentionally stay at expert level, use weight bands on my arms, and use wide arm motion to slice the blocks. I have nothing against Supernatural, it’s just not a good fit for me. Beat Saber is the first game that has made me want to move my body and now I feel like I’m addicted to working out. Appreciate ya.
That’s awesome and what working out is all about! Finding what you love and making it work for you! Keep it up!
I love SN. I been in it 5 weeks and lost almost 10lbs and stabilized my heart rates. I suffer from Ankylosing Spondylitis and a ton of their health issues and am old so needed to get in better shape. This is the only workout I been able to do and have fun too. My fitbit don't lie. It's a killer workout. Beat is still fun. But not even close to the same workout
I still think super natural is a beatsaber knock off
I definitely see the inspiration and see what you’re talking about. They are very similar from the outside but man i can’t push a workout hard in beatsaber, even on expert+ which I’m garbage at.
So your saying beatsaber is to hard for you
@@jakelingala1546 nah, I’m just not very good at anything beyond hard, i can complete a few expert tracks but they get a little difficult and i haven’t put enough time in to master the rhythm.
@@FitProVR thats a YOU problem, my beatsaber workout spends around 1000 of EXCESS kcal per hour because i force myself to do large super fast swings(up to 150ish kmh) and i use weighted cuffs on E+
Watched this and went with Supernatural and literally just did 2 hours worth. It was sooo much fun and I am drenched in sweat. Thanks for the comparison video!
I love both games, but use them differently. I do use Beat Saber like a warmup for Supernatural or a way to be active on a rest day, but it’s mainly just fun for me. I like to dance out my stress in Beat Saber. I’m much more intentional about Supernatural- I always try to improve my form and listen to the coaches for a motivational boost, and I like to interact with and encourage other players in their goals. They’re my two favorite games right now.
I love both. Not gonna lie…I use Beat Saber as a warm up. Definitely need to get used to small arm movements vs large whole body movements. Both are enjoyable in their own way.
That's cool I use beat Saber on normal as a cool down in the BTS and play through the entire TinyTan pack. Supernatural is the exercise workout I have been waiting my whole life for. Video game meets work out. I actually look forward to working out everyday!
Some I use it as warmup
I actually LOVE supernatural and it’s the reason I got a Quest 2. I am a runner. My legs are legit. My upper body and core str get his total crap. So I’ve been doing supernatural for 2 weeks now and will DEFINITELY be buying the annual subscription. My arms and core are getting such a good workout.
I haven’t tried beats. Because my focus is fitness.
Absolutely agreed. Beatsaber is fun but for me it’s not a fitness challenge by any stretch.
Same!
I got my quest 2 yesterday. I'm blown away. Also signed up on supernatural. It's just incredible, I don't even have the words. I like beat saver, its fun too. But the graphics and music in supernatural are awesome. I really feel like I went somewhere, plus it's a good workout. Maybe not super intense, but I'm sedentary person. Doing this activity instead of eating is a good thing.
Welcome to the club!
Great video! Don't know why this has any downvotes. Both games are great but Supernatural gives me the most amazing cardio workout. I LOVE it.
This has been the best review I've watched so far. I don't have an Oculus yet, but I've been debating on this game when I do get it. I'm definitely going to give the month trial a try as soon as I get the Oculus now. Thank you for taking the time to make this.
Love your videos! Thanks for the info. I just got the oculus and first purchased Beat Saber. I love the rhythm and hitting to the beat. I think it’s great for reflexes and hand eye coordination. I love the music choices offered too, but did Lady Gaga too. THEN I decided to get SN on its free trial. Now it’s only 14 days. I’m all in. I love the boxing and Flow. Both are definitely an awesome workout. I’m a fitness instructor so I believe in conquering each level before moving to the next. I’m sweating with every workout. Beat Saber is fun…SN is fun and a workout. 👍
I’ve been doing SN for four months, and I think it’s amazing. $179 per year is NOT a ton of money. It’s less expensive than a gym, it’s WAY more fun, and I can do it any time. At home. In my living room. In my yard. Wherever I feel like it. And I can do it in my underpants! Lol. Beat Saber is fun, no doubt, but it really isn’t the same as Supernatural.
Im glad exercise has been boosted by oculus and im not shaming, but an eternity of beatsaber is 30$ which is cheap if i do say so myself, but you might not want to get beat saber, if you dont have a strong will you may switch
Awesome video!!! I cringe when people say Beat Saber is more of a workout than Supernatural. I started with Beat Saber and saw SN and said the same thing, RIP off! BOY WAS I WRONG!!! 2 months into SN now. ❤
Absolutely!
Developers have been creating variations of fun game designs since the beginning. Call Of Duty/Battlefield, Street Fighter/Mortal Kombat, Fortnite/PUBG, Tetris/Puyo Puyo etc. That is how "Game Genre's" are formed. Even subtle tweaks in game design can make for very different emergent gameplay.
Absolutely agreed!!
I love both Beat Saber and Supernatural and since I got my Oculus... SythRiders! That said... I'm a supernatural addict. I genuinely love it, I am healthier for it and so glad to have it in my life.
Synthriders is fun! I just can't get my heart rate up in that game lol
Synthriders is just not a work out.
@@picanha694 were all at different fitness level, SR just doesn’t work for me though, not enough gross motor movements
@@FitProVR scaling the play area works for a lot of people - makes the orbs harder to reach, requiring more movement. Some people scale to where they even have to jump to hit the high ones.
I’m not a gamer. I’m a 58 year old woman who hates the gym. I saw the ad for supernatural and right then bought the Oculus just for it. $20 a month is nothing these days and if this gets me off the couch and sweating it’s well worth it
HMMMMMMM I really like this video, makes me want to challenge your theory haha. As someone that plays beat saber at a higher level every day, I'm curious how many more calories I'd burn versus playing supernatural. Wrist movement does most certainly come into play at a higher level of the game, but there are quite a few players that use both shoulders and wrists, especially for sliders in beat saber. May make a video about this??
Absolutely! I’d be interested i. What you come up with. That was a big limiting factor for me: not being great at beat saber. How’s your supernatural skills?
Love supernatural. Lots of fun and good workout. If you are on the fence, just try it. Been working out pretty hard for 25 years now and SN is a great addition to weights, swimming and my elliptical machine.
Absolutely. Just doing cardio is not great, especially this volume of shoulder work. I’ll have an “everything wrong with supernatural” video coming soon!
Great video! I love both games but there’s no doubt that they are completely different. Supernatural is a true fitness game and worth every penny of the monthly subscription for how much I personally get out of it.
Agreed! The value varies from person to person!
I love supernatural! I’m on my second week of the free trial and when it’s over I’m definitely keeping it. I get a better workout than at the gym and it’s way more fun. Definitely worth it.
I mega loveeee SN and I enjoy BeatS. Simple!!!!😅🤣
Great Vid!!!! Keep it up!!!!!
Thank you!
Something I wish he'd have been able to include in his evaluation of custom songs, where the mapping is much smoother and generally superior to the OSTs, allowing for faster note speed and more notes per second. Once you get in the 8+ star range, it's certainly an intense workout due to jumps in notes (ex: upper left to lower right swings) and the sheer speed of streams. That's not even taking into account the custom songs made expressly for fitness, as another commenter already noted. Some good examples of strenuous songs: Camellia - Night Raid With A Dragon (Fvrwvrd Remix) Expert+ or PARANOID MIRAGE | Kobaryo | Expert+
Preach!! I just got my first VR headset, Oculus 2, two days ago and, of course, got Beat Saber right away. I was looking for a good fitness app and am using the 30 day trial. Good video! Thanks man!
Same!
I’ve actually cried the first time I tried Supernatural it! Finally, I found something that motivates me, doesn’t judge me, supports me, doesn’t LOOK at me, let’s me choose when and what I want.... and so many things that brings me back to fitness that I used to know when fitness and being in shape was my life.... Years ago... Finally, something is here that ACTUALLY IS CHANGING MY LIFE! Whoever is crying about membership price of $20-25?! If you can’t afford this, go and work more! Or don’t buy dinner to deliver to you, learn how to cook! This price is NOTHING for a person like me and anyone else who would love to get THE perfect exercise!
beat saber is just fun, im not really looking for a workout it's more of a "i need to move more today" kind of thing, both games are great imo
If you need to move more, play some 360 stages on beat saber, it works. If you already have beat saber just add thrill of the fight to it if you “really” want to move
Thanks for the review comparison. I'll have to pick SN up now. Started getting into VR fitness with BoxVR and Beatsaber and now really looking for more VR fitness apps. But dude, you have to give custom songs a chance. For me, custom songs changed BS from a a rhythm game to an actual cardio session. Depending on the song layout (further out boxes), playing on only hard or sometimes even expert so you can focus on and have time to swing from the shoulder rather than the elbows or wrists, my HR readily getting into the 120-140bpm range, I find a pretty good workout can be had (enough that I can feel my shoulders getting a bit overused and I need actual recovery days). Anyhoo, nice channel, just stumbled upon it.
I totally get that, i just didn’t feel like a modded game vs a non modded game would be a fair comparison
@@FitProVR So a little after my comment I ended up trying Supernatural. Didn't realize it wasn't available on Steam so it finally pushed me into getting a Quest 2 for my VR workouts, which I was already looking into before since it's not tethered and I didn't care for getting super sweaty in my PCVR headset. And my already purchased Steam VR games (BS, Synth Riders) are still playable with Airlink. I love it. The H intensity anyway. The L and M levels I just use for warmups. My HR readings comparing BS and SN are actually opposite from yours though which I find interesting. I think the rapid change in directions in BS (song dependent of course) make me have to swing faster than SN (I like to swing hard, imagining it's a sword, and with more shoulders). Have you tried swinging BS lightsabers more like you do the SN bats? I like them both, in different ways though. I think selecting what songs to play make BS more fun and SN more cardio with motivational voiceovers so I end up using them both in my VR cardio workouts now. Wish I could play more but rest days and all. Lol.
Supernatural is so much more than just some regular VR fitness app. I get a lot of spirited motivation from the coaches/trainers and they take you through a progression increasing your fitness challenges as you go. The carefully curate your preferences according to your selections. The coaches bring humour and personality to each workout and sometimes they even do theatrical stuff to keep it fun and interesting. I get a good laugh out of it. The progression of music, the diversity of movement presented with each successive workout as it learns which music/choices you favor most, it suits the whole package to YOU. Nothing can replace it! I've lost 26 lbs so far and this is just the beginning. In truth, it really doesn't feel like I'm trudging, but succeeding!
I am a very good beat saber player. Supernatural kicks my ass. Lol
Lol, I'm decent at SN but BeatS is always breaking my brain!
I started with beat saber then found SN and then tried going back to beat saber after using SN after a while and I didn't like it. SN is superior for me hands down
Me and my dad are gonna play supernatural now and see how it goes
Fantastic! Let me know how it goes and what you thought!
Just signed up for 30 days free myself. Using this with my 18/6 fasting as another weight loss tool. Thanks for making this video.
@@Cabby-om2tv glad i can help :)
Love this. As an older vet out of shape person Supernatural is everything I wanted in a fitness program and has got me from sedentary to daily 40 minute workout since the day I started. Best saber is fun but I hate the music lol. Need some pop and 80s songs lol
Yeah, I'm definitely an 80's child who needs ALL the 80's music. The Retrofit one is pretty solid.
Try moonrider on Oculus browser. It's free and considered a beat saber alternative. If you use classic mode, you can do different songs from different decades
@@natrlchallenge i like moon rider! But for some reason it doesn’t always respond to my hits!
In fact, the beatsaber can be made more suitable for fitness, you can make a mode with short sabers and a lot of sitting, I think such a fitness mode is a matter of time, in the meantime, the supernatural is more suitable for fitness
We just got Oculus 2, my husband and I each got one. He purchased Beat Saber, I purchased Supernatural. The best one is the one that makes you WANT to do it, and I want to do Supernatural. I find it fun, I find the locations beautiful and fascinating, and I have a favorite trainer I gravitate towards. I'm 49 years old, diabetic, have frozen shoulder (which makes Supernatural extremely difficult for me, but I still love it) and not too long ago finished chemo. I'm pretty unhealthy, in other words. I am stunned I get home and want to do Supernatural. I've graduated in a relatively short amount of time from 10 minutes to 30 minutes a day. My husband loves beat Saber. He's in much better shape than I am, and he considers it his workout.
thank you for this video! I was on the fence about trying out this supernatural, now I'm super excited. thank you!
Thank you for your video. I am 59 yrs old got me an Oculus Queet 2 for Xmas and have the Beat Saver and Supernatural. I like both but with the workouts of Supernatural and super music it's greater than Beat Saver. I feel work all my muscles and trully break a sweat. I don't know about loosing weight yet but sure I feel a little muscular tone and energetic since I use Supernatural. I highly recommended to people of my age, I love it. ❤
While I definitely agree supernatural gives more of a workout than beat saber does, I feel like, depending on the song beat saber can be considered a workout. If you just play the base game, then no it’s not a workout. If you get custom songs and find songs tailored to a workout, then I think in some cases it’s equal to supernatural. I have many different songs for beat saber tailored to a workout, making me do squats, lunges and more. I also use super natural as well. Both are really good.
What Facebook group are you on? I'm on Oculus Quest 2 - Age 40+ and it's the best group I've ever been a part of. Also, I liked Supernatural, but who can afford an extra $20/month? That's the only reason I didn't sign up.
I'm on Oculus Quest 2 group, Oculus Quest Group, Official Supernatural Group, and some beat saber one!
Go out to eat one less time per month and it's totally covered
Frickin love Supernatural. I’ve played Beat Saber since October and am solid in Expert mode, scoring S’s, and can do some Expert+ with A scores. It in no way compares to Supernatural. I have to play Beats on Expert+ for at least an hour to feel my body temp rise a little. I play Low intensity in Supernatural, and am completely drenched after 10 minutes. I don’t even get that going hardcore at the gym. I quit my gym membership after my Supernatual trial. No joke.
What expert plus songs are u playing 😂
Custom songs get me sweating and arms sore way more than stock
I go with "why can't we have both?". I play Beat saber for fun and Supernatural for exercising almost every day and together they are part of my "gym-at-home" routine :D
I do only play in the Quest 2 so the only thing I have to complain about is Beat saber really needs more songs. And Supernatural needs the option to turn the coach voice off, hehe
Good thing you can turn off the coach voice now
Awesome video. I don't have a VR headset yet, so I have almost no experience with the physicality of the games, so the differences between these games wasn't obvious at all to me! Thinking about the range of motion required is something I'll keep in mind going forward when researching VR!
Actually was searching video reviews if other people thought beat Saber was a workout. I mean it definitely got my heart rate up and I thought it was. You just gave me something else to try. Thanks.
I love supernatural. I got a 30 day trial and is my first week and I simply love sn the coaches, the sessions, everything and it is a wonderful workout! For someone that hate gyms I am hooked and do the sessions daily and everyday I get out of bed I want to use it! Excellent product!
The first week I tried it I did the training for a whole week so I could learn the proper posture and moves! I think that help me a lot! Highly recommend it! Love it
Me: pouring sweat while cranking songs to faster speeds.
Him: Beat Saber isn't fitness
Also - not a lot of fat drummers out there
I agree SN is way MORE fitness though
Gives a fair, balanced report (imho) and data to back up, people still trash. and Arie(sp?) even still liked Beat Saber! as others said, ultimately the best one is the one you keep working and moving to...so enjoy the one you like, and quite hating on others. Personally I love Supernatural and feel I get the best overall work out. with former broken arm in shoulder joint, and damage to other shoulder, Supernatural has dramatically helped restore joint movement the others dont. but do something, get off the couch and move:-) Happy Gaming!
I just had so much fun in a workout it brought me to tears.
I completely agree with you. I think the people who are bashing it the most would not be at all interested in paying a dime for an authentic fitness regimen, but would for a gaming platform. I wouldn’t mind some of the basic Beat Saber music to head over to Supernatural one bit. Like you, I love both, but for very different reasons, and use them for entirely different purposes. I signed up for a year with the trial, and use it daily. I haven’t gone beyond what came with Beat Saber either.
Couldn't have said it better myself! I didn't sign up for the year though, I pay monthly.
I’m only a couple of days into Supernatural, but besides your input on the workout, the stunning settings are a great motivator for me vs the dark arcade graphics of Beat Saber.
Beat sabers is my warm up. Then I take to the bridge with SN!
Yessss!
"Let's stop shaming people for trying to be healthy!" 9:10
Amen, brother!!!
While you can play beatsaber with your wrists, it is also meant to be played with your arms. The blocks give you bonus points for following through them with your strikes, so someone who can get fast and strike through the blocks will have a higher score.
I play about 1 hour of beat saber a day and burn anywhere between 900 - 1200 calories playing 7+ star songs. It takes a while to get to that level, but you can get very fit playing this game. Best money I've ever spent honestly.
I think we made need to think more about the term "workout".
There are aerobic workouts.
There are strength workouts.
There are endurance workouts.
Perhaps we should also be talking about the importance of workouts focused building coordination/developing/maintaining the musculo-nervous system.
Movement is as important in exercising the brain as it is the musculoskeletal complex.
Thus, perhaps rhythm games are as important for what they can exercise as "fitness-focused" games.
Perhaps we can get a rhythm game that has been designed specifically with developing cognitive/brain-muscle health.
Personally, I pay the monthly subscription for Supernatural because it is a fitness program that I actually love. I also LOVE Beat Saber. I would log into both apps every day, but if I "play" Supernatural before Beat Saber, I will not play Beat Saber. I usually play Beat Saber as a warm-up to Supernatural, and proceed to get my ass handed to me. Supernatural is most definitely more of a workout, even in a "Quick Hits" "light intensity" session. I mostly play Beat Saber just for fun, and it definitely delivers. This is only my opinion, of course. ☺
Yes, that is EXACTLY what I do!!!
Thank you for this video. I was on the fence about getting a VR headset but now this has motivated me to get one and I will give Supernatural a try as well. Got me to subscribe after watching a few of your videos. Keep them coming!
Every week!
As long as it's subscription based i rather Beat Saber and pay for music packs the right way to ask for more money not but monthly fees.
I play Beat Saber the way you say to play Supernatural, moving from the shoulder and trying to put my whole body into it. I’m not playing for the score, and yes, I use the ‘no fail’ option. I don’t like the ‘drum playing’ moves; they are not the way a sword moves. ( I have friends who do HEMA, so my initial interest was mimicking realistic sword swings).
Personally, I find the voiceover ‘encouragements’ in Supernatural to be very annoying. So much so that they make me want to just quit (i have the same problem in a live fitness class. Don’t distract me!)
Anyway, I just wanted to say that just as you can play Supernatural without taking real advantage of its training function, you can also play Beat Saber for the workout, and not as a game.
100% agree with your assessment. I too like Beat Saber and the music. I was sold on Supernatural from the first workout. Yes, it is similar to Beat Saber, but with purpose. The movements are far more deliberate. I actually squat and lunge with the triangles in SN, and find I cheat more with BS by just leaning my head to avoid the walls. I like the grand arm movements of SN versus the fast "drumming" of BS, it dust feels more fluid and natural. I'm definitely a fan.
Absolutely, beat saber just isn’t fitness focused, it’s completion focused.
According to this video I play Beat Saber wrong? I use full arm swings and wrist, and do a range of difficulties for a range of motion. I would try supernatural, but I can't afford another 25+ CAD a month for some time. Maybe when the future seems a bit more financially secure. It's nosedived in the past near half year for me. :/
You are playing beat saber correctly. You must do full swings to score the full points. The little flick wrist thing is going to kill your score. If you are getting at least A rank prefer S rank, then you are definitely getting a workout.
@@DaniGirl6 I get S/SS most songs(expert/expert+) I do actually. I figure with games like this, the best way to play is the way you want to play. I suppose if competitive some ways are better than others, but I'm bloody 42 and there's no way I'm competing with those half my age, so full wacky swings with wrist it is.
Thank you for this content. This is what I'm looking for. Chosing a VR game to get rid of daily immobility sometimes seems like a challenge. I can't always play Beat Saber!
I have both Beat Saber and Supernatural. Beat Saber is fun, but for a workout, I prefer Supernatural.
Many Beat Saber veterans claim that you can get a solid workout at expert or expert+ difficulty. However, Beat Saber has too heavy a cognitive load. Supernatural offers much clearer indications of the direction and angle at which you should hit the targets. You can see this clearly when the targets are still far away, allowing you to plan a better flow of motion and exert your full power. In Beat Saber, the cubes at most expert and expert+ levels are tricky; they change directions as they approach you, often not revealing their true directions until they are very close. I feel my mind heavily focusing on cubes but not on my body and muscles. With no time to plan ahead, this results in sweeping motions with speed but not enough power.
Other reasons I feel Supernatural is better for workouts include: First, Beat Saber has too many cubes in positions with awkward directions, requiring you to use your arm and wrist to whip the targets, which doesn't engage other parts of your body. Second, expert and expert+ levels are not for everyone. Those who claim to advance to expert or expert+ easily are either still young and thus super energetic and agile with fast responses, or they are gifted enough to do it even at an older age. If you're the one, you should be grateful instead of shamming people who cannot do expert or expert+! I'm 43 and can only handle an average of 3 to 4 targets per second, placing me between hard and expert difficulty in Beat Saber. Anything more difficult than that leads to frustration. However, in Supernatural, I can achieve medium and high intensity with Diamond (the highest score tier), which is easier but still provides excellent workout results because it targets your full body muscle groups. Third, Supernatural offers boxing, which demands more from the core and footwork if done correctly. This provides a more balanced workout if added to your routine. Fourth, Supernatural has coaches, filmed with real person in warm up and cool down sessions for all workout lists. While many fans don’t care about the coaches and turn off their voices during songs, I like them. They feel like companions during the workout, even if they say silly things and I don’t take their advice seriously. They makes me feel welcomed to workout every day. With Beat Saber, it feels like you're alone in a cold, flashy cyberspace.
If you just want to choose one and your primary focus is fitness, choose Supernatural. If you want coolness and fun, and fitness is a bonus but not a necessity, go ahead with Beat Saber.
I play both but played Best Saber first. Beat Saber never struck me as a work out but more as a game that tried to test your dexterity and skill. It struck me as a challenge but not physically and more as a Star Wars Light Saber version of Guitar Hero. I still play it, but more for how fun it is to try and move up in the campaign. I literally use it as a cool down workout to Supernatural.
I've been playing Supernatural for a month and a half with a 50/50 mix of boxing and the flow batons. Hands down, Supernatural is the better workout for me. From the get go (literally the tutorial onwards) the coaches are constantly mentioning maintaining form and keeping your arms straight while making those large sweeping movements. They also concentrate on proper posture and convey a general sense of motivation geared towards getting in shape along with a constant physical and mental improvement fitness wise. They also have several muscle groups and areas of the body they focus on depending on the workout. The same goes for the boxing videos. The addition of squats and lunges completely ups the workout and intensity level of Supernatural when doing the flow batons and with boxing there are constant slips and dips, so by the time you're done with a workout you're drenched in sweat (dips, squats, lunges and slips really make your quads and hammies work hard).
I, like you, enjoy both but I just see Supernatural as the one I use for high intensity cardio mixed with coaching and fun while Bear Saber is my low intensity cool down cardio workout or sometimes I just play it to have fun outside of a workout session. I completely agree with your assessment. I'm not challenging anyone who has had a different experience or has a different opinion than me. To each his own. For me, Supernatural is definitely not a Beat Saber knock off. They both occupy a different VR space in my opinion and I'm glad they both exist!
Awesome demonstration...we enjoyed the content and my wife and I are convinced.
I just got my OQ2 today and I got Beat Saber and Supernatural and did both workouts. I did Beat Saber first and it was fun and I worked up a sweat. However, you are correct...Supernatural is not a knockoff it us a WORKOUT! I was completely out if breath and drenched in sweat. It was a FULL body workout. I am also doing VZFit so between these three and my MYX II bike....I should be getting back to better health quick and fun way!
I love beat sabre...tried supernatural and it is not nearly as fun. Supernatural has to much talking and the fun is just missing. I personally find the games being called fitness training are just beat sabre repurposed and lacks the fun that beat sabre has making you want to go for more. Two songs on hard and I need a break because I am sweating, my muscles feel it, and my heart rate is up there...I am almost fifty. The only real difference is beat sabre doesn't have a trainer telling you to keep you muscles tight. You have to learn not to extend your arms if you want to stand a chance on not failing past hard. I think he is getting some sort of sponsorship for supernatural. Also, as you get used to the songs, you start moving your body even more and dancing along at the same time. Beat sabre for the win...hands down.
Love Supernatural. For me there is also aa big difference between being in those beautiful locations versus being in the black tunnel.
That was the first thing i noticed about beatsaber too! Pretty bland.
you can customize your location and colors in beat saber it's not just a black tunnel
There are mods to change the environment in beat saber if you don’t like the default ones or just want different scenery
stfu there are so many things in the beat saber maps i fell like ur just salty ur bad, get good scrub
@@shorse4665 another thing i love about beat saber is the warm and welcoming community!
I'm a die hard Beat Saber player for sure, but would never ashame others for playing other games for sure! At the end we all should appreciate the creators' efforts for creating such joyful games
So what makes Supernatural a better fitness game is the fitness coach telling you to use your shoulder?
You can just do that in Beatsaber and I do it all the time even on expert+.
There are 3 minute songs after which my arms hurt, Im out of breath and my pulse at 170.
I cant really judge Supernatural as I cannot own it but you didn't really made a compelling argument why supernatural is a better workout except that you don't do extended arm movements in bs, which you jhowever could have done.
I appreciate your feedback however if you tried supernatural i believe you’d see the difference. Hard to make that judgement without playing it.
I prefer beatsaber
you showed some scores around 8:04, and I checked those scores up against the scores of the beat saber heart rate details over at the vr health institute and it showed much higher heart rates on beat saber. Expert+ and modded play along with competitive play (and levels created for fitness) completely outmatch the basic expert/hard player like yourself. large sweeping movements are recommended for competitive play and--though wrists are used a lot-- you need to use your arms a lot as well.
I’m not even going to read the comments because I’m sure you’ll get a variety of different opinions. As a disabled person, I’m going to say I still try to work out daily. I’ve done both BSab & SN for more than a year & yes I pay the subscription for SN. I love them both, but like you said, I do get a better cardio workout w/SN than w/BSab.
The downside w/SN is I can’t do the lunges & squats due to the multiple surgeries I’ve had from my cancer. I wish SN would allow us to turn off the triangles coming at us, bc if we can’t use them for their purpose, they are super annoying. Also, I wish I could turn off the coaches voice throughout my workout. It’s fine for the first time you are doing one, but if you like the workout & want to come back to it… we’ll I’d rather just hear the music while I’m working out. In BSab we ARE able to turn off bombs, walls etc so that’s a great feature! Some people can’t candle the motion of the triangles either in SN. I DO love the boxing with SN better than any other app! I get the best cardio with it, but I must say, they are making it pretty hard on a few, where like w/BSab you don’t get the full ROM due to the speed of the targets coming at you, therefore hindering your workout HR.
All in all they are both fun & if someone doesn’t want to pay to workout, then BSab is better than nothing… especially if they really put full arm ROM into their swings. Thx for your video.
Great video! I play both as well and I find SN to provide the better workout all around. However, you can get a sweat going playing BS if you play the easier levels where the cubes are coming at you slower and play like SN with full strikes through the targets. YMMV
I agree that you get a better workout in the easier levels with beat saber, they’re just not all that fun
This was an awesome video. My wife and kids like beat saber, but for all the reasons you mentioned, I think supernatural is the fit for me. I like the idea of these games being fun but I went out and got a VR to try something that’s going to get me moving. So any games that’s going to give me a better workout is the one I’m going to lean more to. Something tells me neither games are going anywhere in my household🤣🤣
My vote is Supernatural, the boxing though I find to be a much more intense workout. There’s also a ton of music and you don’t have to purchase song packages. Now that the cost is only $10/month it’s a great price.
I find this kinda bullsh*t. BeatSaber can be played both casually or intensively. If you want to burn more cal, then you should choose a song where the blocks distance is huge, and with walls. Some songs require you so skip left and right, while some songs require you to duck and stand quickly, and some songs have a huge block spacing which require you to literally swing both your arms. You can’t get the most out from it if you decided to play songs where walls are minimal, and with tightly packed blocks.
I appreciate your feedback and see your point.
You can play Beat Saber veeeery differently. If you just aim to hit the nodes, you can do - even on Expert+ - with little movement. But the fun is the movement. Try to dance along with the song. Especially on E+ I get a hellish workout out of it. So what you're saying basically is statistics for N=1 which is you. Sorry.
Just joined the VR world, just because I wanted to start working out and HAVE FUN. I tried Supernatural and I LOVE IT. The following day all my muscles were aching! It's a whole body workout and exactly what I need. As you said, with Beat Saber you move much less, ypu mostly have to be quick, also I don't like the fact that if you "fail" while playing it stops (not sure if that can be turned off) but that doesn't happen in Supernatural, the let you finish your song/session no matter how you're going.
So for me, Supernatural > Beat Saber
Despite my best intentions to NOT keep Supernatural after the free trial last year, alas, I found I really REALLY liked the workout it gave me, so ended up subscribing for the year at their introductory discounted rate. In comparison, I've only played Beat Saber twice since getting Supernatural. BS is a fun GAME, I do like it, bought it twice - once for the Rift and once for the Quest - but SN is a fun WORKOUT, and is my most used Quest app behind VZfit on my stationary bike.
Oooo i got VZ fit coming up!
I love beat saber it’s always fun but I just started my 30 day trail on SN and in the tutorial I felt so good the outside view and the trainers that talk to u is so motivational I like it alot
How’d you get a 30 day trial for SuperNatural? All I’ve seen is 7 days.
I prefer Supernatural to Beat Saber not because I think it’s a better workout, but because the music doesn’t stop if I miss targets. Therefore, SN is a better workout for me.
I would love to play Supernatural but I have severe motion sickness 😭 I played the free trial and got sick. I love BeatSaber because of the steady levels and visuals, I find there aren't enough songs and I wish it were more of a workout though, but I try to get in at least 30 mins a day, every time I find myself going for 1 hour and a half cause I'm having so much fun 😆 I'm a really obese person and I gotta say this game has really helped my weight loss, as of last year I am 45 lbs down! okay it's not just BeatSaber but still! I try to dance a lot and do squats when I play, I also play with people online, it helps me feel more competitive. Thank you for your video! I love the look and feel of both games and anyone who thinks Supernatural is bad and a rip off, please it's not that deep, just don't buy it haha
I like the music selection in Supernatural more than Beat Saber. I can workout to classical music! And I also like that the focus is not on hitting every single target perfectly. It’s about moving your body.
If you’re wondering about the difference, beat saber feels a lot tighter than supernatural. Beat saber is all in the wrists, and the goal is perfection. Supernatural has wide, sweeping movements and the goal is moving your whole body and getting a sweat on. If you don’t like the trainer voice in your ear, there is an option in the settings menu to turn the trainer volume down. I noticed a lot of people don’t know about this setting. Also, supernatural has boxing modes and meditations that don’t get enough hype so I had to mention that.
I will continue to play both, because I like them for different reasons. Beat saber is a fun game to play with friends, and supernatural is a fitness game I can play every day and not get bored of. As someone who works a sedentary job, and struggles to stick to a workout routine, the idea of fitness+play is essential to my mental and physical well-being.
Just started using Supernatural yesterday. Enjoying it.
So instead of smashing blue & red blocks you smash black and white drop shaped objects? How could I have not seen the big difference??
I’ve been doing beat saber for over a week and it gets my heart rate up, I run out of breath, it’s fun. So heart rate going? Cool. Nice.
Now I just started my Supernatural trial today with some boxing, since they added that…and my legs are SORE 😂 That’s how you know it’s a good workout!! I’m pumped! I’m not feeling it in my core yet but i need to get used to it. And paired with a normal ab work out, I feel like Supernatural will be a good addition to the weekly workout schedule!
I have them both and yes Supernatural is a sweat out everytime.
Agreed!
I did compare the 2 as I have both. Supernatural is definitely worth the money. I bought the ouculus for a specific reason and that was for fitness. I have only had supernatural for 2 days and beat saber for a month or so. Hands down supernatural.
Now my question is what about fitxr and supernatural? How do you put supernatural up against Fitxr for fitness?
Great video BTW
Thank you! And yes! I plan on doing those two compared because they are probably the two people mention the most. I’m gonna hurt a lot of feelings though lol
Very difficult custom games are certainly a small workout lol