I read it and enjoyed it immensely. I'm a Jodi fan. I can see how people would classify it as a white savior story, but it was so much more than that. The book was written for people like Jodi, from her world, with her skin color. I totally respect your opinion. I think people should read it and determine whether they like it for themselves.
I really enjoyed it as well and though I respect her opinion immensely, there was so much more to the book than described, but I take that it happens when one dislikes it in my opinion. I am a big Jodi fan as well because I enjoy her putting the real harsh reality out there, not many would be bold enough to do so. I wouldn't say I'm biased but I will say Jodi played it a little safe in certain areas and yes the ending was not what I wanted and would have preferred with this man damn near groveling at her feet being for forgiveness but oh well. I also thought it wasn't too long, but could have even been a little longer. I think she should give Jodi another chance because her stories are amazing
I disagree regarding the ending, Shannon. Even as part of his redemption, Turk would have never dropped to Ruth‘s feet and started groveling; that’s not his character. Besides, what’s the age old saying? “Actions speak louder than words“? I would say he definitely proved he had changed and was continuing to work on doing so through his actions; leaving the movement, reaching out to vulnerable people who would be easy to manipulate just like he was in his… For lack of better words here, “younger years“, speaking out against the twisted beliefs he once happily embraced, acknowledging the skepticism of those who attend his speaking engagements who don’t believe he could have possibly changed and even admitting he deserves that treatment, among some other things I may not have mentioned. If that’s not at the very least an attempt at redemption, tell me what is. Part of me wonders if Ruth did in fact recognize him when he and his three-year-old daughter were in her clinic because of his daughter’s sore throat at the end, but I like that Jodi left that up in the air for us to decide.
Oh heck, the books Jodi Picoult has lent her name to ALWAYS reduce complicated social issues into a Hallmark movie. I believe she hires a staff of researchers to hand her bullet points on the issue, and she and others weave it into a book/screenplay. No editor wants to mess with this popular (and very profitable) formula. I loved this review. Thanks, Didi.
Thank you for your review. I just finished SGT for my book club. Because I had issues with the stereotypes in this story, I wanted to see what others, especially black readers, had to say about their perspective. In retrospect, I should have read the author's notes before I even started reading and I would have had a different feeling while reading it. Reading her notes and seeing her interviewed helped me in my final analysis. This book starts an examination and conversation about racism that many of us are too afraid to have, and I think that was the author's goal in writing this story, especially with the stereotypes. I know from seeing a morning show interview that Picoult did a lot of research and consulted with black women in writing Ruth's voice (over 100 hours of recorded interviews). I wouldn't write Jodi Picoult off your reading list. She is definitely someone who picks topics that are important and I don't think she writes simply to entertain her readers. Reading Nineteen Minutes over a decade ago totally changed me.
I will never pick up another Piccoult books because I don't like her writing nor do I like her approach to writing on subjects like this one. She just isn't for me. I only picked it up because it was my book club's pick of the month.
I actually really enjoyed this book. However, I understand where you're coming from. The characters were definitely off and yes, the sister was irritatingly stereotypical for me. It felt like lost potential there for a really strong character. On the other hand, other characters (like the children )and the moments between them felt very real. Although, Ruth and Kennedy, and their relationship, were all a bit flimsy for me as well. Nonetheless, I liked that light was shed on some really tough issues. I was surprised that these issues actually happen to nurses and other medical professionals. It is story that needs to be told even if it was written like a Lifetime movie at times. The story and concept(s) were important, and for me, entertaining/intriguing.
Agree. 1000. Percent.I listened to this book on audio and I remember thinking all along, 'just stop listening to it'. I am sure I would have DNF'd it if I'd purchased it as a physical book. As it was on audio, it accompanied me through hours of dishes and eye-rolling. ALL the stereotypes. ALL the expected plot points. Little to no nuance and a ridiculously neat ending. Thanks for confirming my thoughts exactly. Will be reading "sing unburied sing" which is sure to be lovely as Ward takes care with her prose.
Thanks for sharing your review. As I was reading this book, it made me really uncomfortable that the author was a white woman and I questioned how accurately she was representing reality for African Americans, but the author's note at the end resolved this for me. The book is definitely not perfect and full of stereotypes, but I think this was intentional. Readers (should) know that these are stereotypes and that they're characters, not real people, serving a purpose to make a point. From the author's note: "When it comes to social justice, the role of the white ally is not to be a savior or a fixer. Instead, the role of the ally is to find other white people and talk to make them see that many of the benefits they’ve enjoyed in life are direct results of the fact that someone else did not have the same benefits." This is what it did for me. While I don't trust that I have much more insight into the experiences of African Americans, I'm at least more conscious of my own privileges and I feel better equipped to be an ally. As far as the writing goes, I enjoyed it. I was engaged. It is being adapted to film, by the way. I feel like that's going to be worse -- trying to condense this already condensed book into a two-hour movie. I enjoyed the book and I hope they do it justice. Regardless, I'm bummed that it disappointed you but I'm glad to have heard your opinion. I do have a question for you: when you mention the part that should have been cut from the book at the end, are you referencing the "Afterbirth" section, or "Shine," the short story at the end? I can see a justification for either, but I'm just curious. :)
I just don't like how one character represents one person and how then everything is skewed and un realistic. Not to mention the writing isn't that great either.
@@browngirlreading Is there a better book you would recommend on this subject? I thought Jodi did an excellent job of explaining all 3 main characters' point of view. If you don't think she helped white people to understand a few things, do you feel she hurt black people? I'm confused why you would trash her efforts. At least she MADE the effort, which is more than we can say for most.
I read this book last year and loved it, now thinking back I remember I had the same issues you did but I somehow looked past it because I loved the court case, I'm not African American and that sequence helped me realise my own subconscious prejudices. Although now your review has showed me that I'm a working progress. It never crossed my mind that Kennedy was a stereotypical white saviour. I was looking out for misrepresentation of black women or people. So much so that i completely disregarded the perspective of a black person because I just assumed she was finally being heard, but through a white woman!? Why? Reading and hearing all your reviews has made me so much more mindful, I've definitely reconsidered my opinion on this novel.
The premise of the book sounded interesting but I had a feeling it would not be executed properly. One of the reasons i felt this way was because I worked in a hospital for many years and I know of cases where patients refused to have nonwhite doctors and nurses take care of them. It's a hurtful experience to have a professionally trained person being told they are not capable of providing care because of their ethnicity. I wasn't sure if a White writer could capture all of those feelings. Doesn't sound like she did. Thanks for the thoughtful review Didi!
I haven't finished reading the book. I really am enjoying just turning the pages. The book keeps my attention. I like what you are saying. It is never easy living amongst people who are predominately of a different color. I went through it myself. It did cross my mind about Ruth's attitude. It could never be that easy being the minority. The White Supremacists floored me. I had no idea that it was so close to home. I thought she really did her research on the topic. So are there White Supremacists living in my neighborhood? I always say racism is alive and kicking. I have no basis for that remark. I just sense it.
What did the rest of your bookclub think about it? That must have been one interesting meeting! I never read any Picoult, and never was really tempted to. Not sure why, though.
Well the majority were surprised at the intensity of racism in the States. We didn't talk about the UK though. There were more than half that thought the same as me. As a whole we didn't think the book was well approached and written at all.
Wow. I didn't know what this book was about, but I have seen it around a bit. I have read one Picoult in the past (The Tenth Circle) and there were plenty of problems with that story, too. Thank you for your honesty - I love when you discuss your criticisms!
I think it's pretty unfair to undermine this book as quickly as you and others have, especially for those who have based it solely on this video. Reading this at first I cannot lie, I was very skeptical in the narrative and character development for all the reasons you and others have pointed out. But I ultimately felt, when finishing the book, that the book, although can be seen as flawed from the offset due to the author and her unconscious biases as a white woman, there was a very real, tone to the story and characters that is very valuable to the audience and climate of today. After reading her authors notes, I truly believe that you cannot fault this book in a 'she's white and therefore cannot capture a narrative like this' manner because she clearly understands the sheer velocity of the task to write such a novel and has executed it to the best of her abilities. Incredible book that can teach all of us a little something
Firstly this is a review and my honest opinion. I don't have the habit of undermining authors. I took the time to read ti cover tot cover and watched videos of her talking about her book. I'm going to have to kindly disagree. No shed didn't do a good job on it. This is a poorly constructed novel with stereotypical characters. That's a fact. Now if you got something out of it good for you. If this book had been written by a black woman I'd have said the same things and we have had loads of questions. Picoult had good intentions in writing this novel and I don't knock her for that, but what she says she wanted to bring out in this novel just wasn't there in my opinion.
I am avoiding this just because of the white savior trope. I am so sick and tired of seeing white savior tropes on tv, in movies, in books--I'm over it.
I was avoiding this one because it sounded like a hot mess from the synopsis alone, but then I saw that you were reading it so I wanted to see what you thought. If you had liked it then I would've given it a chance. But nope. No thank you.
Sadly yes. I probably wouldn't have read it either if it wasn't my book club's pick.:( Funny how the synopsis can just give you that feeling of No Ma'am. LOL!
Just finished the book and really enjoyed it. I also enjoyed your review. I know that she based part of the story on a situation that happened in Michigan. I'm wondering how you would have written if differently. How do you have contrasting characters and avoid stereo types? Why do you think Viola Davis wants to be a part of this project? Is she selling out (in your opinion)? Thanks
Piccolo writes all of her books in this same way. You either like it or you don't. I don't. It's not because a novel is based on a true story that it's good. I don't see what Viola Davis accepting a role in the film adaptation has to do with selling out. I just don't like the way this author chose to fictionalise this woman's story.
You: "This was a... Hot... Mess!" Me: "Tell. Me. EVERYTHING." It was so interesting to hear your thoughts on this, because so many people have come into my bookstore to purchase it. It almost seems like Picoult is writing a book for the "trend" of diversity, as opposed to writing a realistic depiction of the diverse world in which we live. Shame.
Matthew Sciarappa I prefer Truth over Trend. I do appreciate that the author did try to do research to see the situation from a black person's perspective. I haven't read the book though but it is based on a true incident but the key word is BASED.
Unfortunately most of her books come across as insincere to the point where it feels like she's jumping on trends. School shootings, cancer, now race: i think Picoult really needs to reflect and decide which kinds of stories are not her place to tell (or at least, are the kinds of stories she should research *way* more thoroughly.)
Wow! I appreciated your review...didn't have the same experience with it, but felt some of your frustrations. I have read one other book by Jodi Picoult, "Wish You Were Here" (which I liked) I plan to read another by her to develop a more fleshed-out opinion about her writing style as an author. I was curious to know if you decided to read any more novels by her. As far as a movie, although I enjoyed the book, I wouldn't want to see this become one, but I may not get my wish.
When I was about 19 I read I think 2 or 3 of her books. I didn't love her writing I found it entertaining but predictable. Her books are something I would need to be in the mood for, they remind me of a Hallmark movie, very formulaic. From what I saw of this one in particular, I think she was just trying to hard, and just ended up writing stereotypes. Perhaps she went a little to far out of her comfort zone. I think her writing has a place but it certainly isn't for everyone. Great review!!
Totally agree, a hot black and white mess. I read the large print so 720 pages of racism. Makes me wonder about the source, just saying. Only thing u can say about this book is kudos to Ruth for staying in her truth.
Hi Didi. I enjoyed her 2004 novel *My Sister's Keeper* though I don't remember much about the plot now. (I read it about six years ago.) If you're interested in reading a novel by a white woman who does a commendable job at depicting the black experience in a racially divided society, check out *Wide Sargasso Sea* by Jean Rhys. It's set in the Caribbean, post-Emancipation, but I think it's 'relate-able' in 2017.
Thanks for the review. I guess I will cancel my hold request at the public library! I read My Sister's Keeper by the same author, a few years ago. I actually enjoyed that one.
I get the feeling she wants to be Joyce Carol Oates but she's more Jennifer Weiner, lol. I have a friend who loves Picoult and wants me to reader and I keep "forgetting" to pick her up!!
Someone brought this up in my book club as a book they enjoyed. Going off her description of it I immediately thought that I would be far too critical of the book to enjoy it. Glad I made the right decision. Thank you for the review.
Love your glasses :) Jodi Picoult was never somebody I would pick up but I guess that is part of a charm of being in a book club, one widens horizons. :)
I really enjoy this book. Books are not meant to always be 100 facts. There are pockets in the story that does make you stop and think. I do agree there were a lot of topics/issues were mentioned just to mention but were irrelevant to the story. However I did enjoy this book. For me it was a 5 star.
The only book from geral I've realy enjoyed was the "My sister's Keeper". The others have read are very stereotyped for me. I remember the last one I gave a try on and was completely tired of it because ir seamed a moral lesson shoved to our brain.
I read the book when it came out. I had heard so much hype about it, wow I really enjoyed the book, it was a bit long and the end was like a lifetime movie. I think she got it kind of right as a hospital worker for the last 25+ years, it's very political and I really can see this happening, but I did wonder how a white Women would know about a black Woman and her experiences but I guess it's plausible, as always I love your reviews always on point and a personal level thank You for challenging me to read more convoluted books instead of the fluff. I'm sure you didn't even know you did that for me.xoxoxo
I would hope in a hospital a superior would be more responsible than the one in the book. However what bothered me the most was the stereotypical view of each character they were nothing more than representations. Henceforth not fully developed three dimensional characters. For such a serious subject that's devastating to read such a poorly developed and written story. Thanks for commenting and supporting!
Oh my goodness I could not agree with you more! This book was a contrived and shallow attempt at being relevant. Thank you so much for your wonderful videos and reviews. I don't comment much but always watch :D
I am reading it now and searched out reviews like this bc I am having such a hard time reading Turks chapters. I am enjoying the story, but his chapters make me feel sick and dirty. Idk if I want to continue for this reason. I do see what you are saying about the other characters. I do see about Ruth shrugging off comments and things. It’s highly pointed out and I’m assuming that it will cause some growth or something at some point. Also it 100% comes directly from how her mom raised her. I’m interested in that dynamic as well.
Strongly disagree. 5 stars! This is an awesome read. The cultural elements, experiences and emotions, especially those related to living as a Black person in America are spot on! Nothing stereotypical here. Ruth's character is hard working and proud, yet has the misconception that hard work and a good education will make her an equal to her counterparts. Great set up as the desire for equality continues to be the number one value for most Black Americans.. America is a long, long, long way from being post racial and I love that Picoult had the courage and brilliance to share the lenses of Ruth and how she navigates White America; Turk, the White Supremacist, and Kennedy, Ruth's attorney who has an unconscious bias toward Black America.
I completely agree with you, this book was excellent. (How nice that some people feel they have never met a Ruth, an Adisa, or a Turk. I have.) The author did a great job of explaining things to white people. It wasn't meant to be perfect in every way, nor could any book be. It's a start - and a much needed start.
I have just started reading this and as a nurse I was really disgusted by the hospital staff. I’m not a nurse in US so I have no idea what things are like but it just seemed off. I’m finding that the writing style is very much like a romance novel with the predictable happy ending. On the subject of racism, I noticed the stereotypes immediately and it made me uncomfortable. I was wondering if you have any book recommendations that address racism and have wonderful well developed characters. Thank you so much for this review.
Thanks for watching and commenting! Here are some great examples: Grant Park, The Last thing You Surrender, Freeman, The Blacker the Berry, The Trees, Another Country, Real Life, A More Perfect Union, The Vanishing Half, etc.
I really liked the book.... But dialogue like this is so important for us to learn from each other... Thank you for speaking to the white savior complex... That is humbling and good to hear your thoughts on.
When Ruth was trying to get Kennedy to see that race really did and should be addressed in the trial. Kennedy told Ruth that bringing up race would not win the trial because justice usually turns a blind eye to racism. Kennedy finally sees the light and tells the truth about how being a racist is wrong. It’s also based on a true story. However, I respect your views and understand where u are coming from as well. Your review makes sense to me it’s just that I have been in that same situation as Ruth as far as trying to explain why race matters. My sister refused to read the book as well.
Great review. :) I like the way you articulate your thoughts. If you do not mind sharing, I would love to hear your thoughts on the way "To Kill a Mockingbird" handles racism.
Thank you for the compliments! I'd have to re-read To Kill a Mockingbird in order to do that. not ready to re-read it at the moment. Maybe one day. When I do I'll be sure to talk about how racism is handled.
Amen. It was my first novel by Picoult and I was so disappointed. I felt the novel screamed of in-authenticity and patronization, and I was exhausted by the end from the author driving her message into the ground.
Yes she was obviously on a mission to convince the readers of a lot of things. Didn't work and her editors should have been honest with her. Probably won't pick up anything else by her. Ain't nobody got time for that!
I read the book and absolutely loved it! I appreciate your views but disagree for the most part. Yes, she tries to represent different ‘stereotypes’of black character. You said Oddettte was the mother of the girls. I think she was actually the black lawyer who represented the white supremacists in court. Also some really relatable situations of subtle racism like the shopping experience . Jodi is a fantastic author and love it or not, she deserves credit for giving a very important subject the thought and research that she did. She did pack a lot into the book. At least 4 stars from me.
I know this is an old video, but I just came across it and I just had to comment. Thank you for this review. This book was the subject of one of the most uncomfortable book club experiences I've ever had. I agree with your take on this book...I was very uncomfortable reading it. The stereotypes were just over the top--I could recognize it and I actually felt guilty about them. As I said after finishing, this was another example of white people trying to make themselves feel better over racism. But, I also had issues with it beyond the racial aspects. I have two friends who were in the same book club. One is a doctor and one is a lawyer and they were furious over how badly (perhaps inaccurately or ignorantly would be better words) their fields of expertise were portrayed here. So, onto the book club. One friend (the lawyer) refused to even attend. The other friend (the doctor) and I went together and we were so dreading the conversation that we met for margaritas beforehand to numb our reactions (or at least to be able to claim intoxication for any bad behavior on our part). Fortunately, everyone else who attended that particular meeting felt the same way we did. The discomfort came at the next meeting when someone who had not attended the discussion told us we were all wrong for not liking the book and we didn't know what we were talking about. I nearly quit that book club there and then. In short, this book convinced me to add Jodi Picoult to my "do not read" list and has convinced me to be very selective about which books I read that feature something about race and I try to choose only among own voices books. Okay, sorry for that long rant on a 5 year old post, but I just wanted to let you know that I so appreciated your thoughts on this!
Hello I'm happy that you understood my perspective on this book. As you can see in this comment section there are many like the lady in your book club. No worries. It's been 5 years and I still won't read Piccolo either. Are you still attending the book club? What sorts of books are you reading these days?
@@browngirlreading I actually have just recently decided to leave that particular book club (the Small Great Things was not the only weird incident), but I'm in 2 other books clubs plus some podcast-led book discussion. My currently book club reads are Sitting Pretty: The View from My Ordinary, Resilient, Disabled Body by Rebekah Taussig (I'm enjoying it and it is giving me a lot to think about, but unfortunately I can't make that particular book discussion) and Caramelo by Sandra Cisneros (it has taken me a little while to settle in with this one, but I'm starting to enjoy it).
🤣 I have had those "Lord, God, Jesus" moments while reading Jodi Picoult. Sadly, I have read more disappointing books by her than books that I've liked by her. My Sister's Keeper was the first book I've read of Picoult and I liked it. It was ages ago though and I'm not sure I'd feel the same about it. Did you read Vanishing Act? I saw it on one of your 2013 ? videos.
Wow. Thanks Didi dodged a bullet with that one. I've never read her, but I have other interesting books on my TBR so I'll be skipping her for a minute.
I'm so glad to found this review here! I'm not sure how to classify this story: On the one hand it is full of stereotypical characters (Adisa, Turk) and on the other hand it tries to teach oder tell us something about racism and the different perspectives of ethnicities... Some of Ruth's desicions aren't comprehending for me. She's a bit to stubborn, but Kennedy's sometimes blind for Ruth's sensitivity. But I like both and they find a way to understand each others life better! :) I like the book up to now, the last 150 pages will be read over the next days! I'm not an American, so I don't have enough expericences to know if this kind of setting is realistic oder stereotypical? "All things are based on racism" is what I read in every second line. Is this a realistic image of the US? I hope not! I expected a book which shows conflicts between black and white Americans, but I think Jodi Picoult forgot sometimes, that we are all more than our skin colors, also people of color! We all play different roles in our lives and we all have different facets of personality. But Picoult created a story were all concentrates to much on ethnicities. I miss some human(!) contact and happier and carefree scenes, were Ruth and Kennedy are just two women, Ruth and her son are just a family,... These are only my impressions about the story as a not-US-American. I hope not to offend someone here. ❤ Discrimination is a personal and sensitive experience and talking about is important. But I really miss something in this book, and sometimes it doesn't have the right measure for me. 🤔
Well the book is based on racism from the US opinion and sadly racism is based on skin color, which is what she's trying to show in the story even though I don't think she does a very good job of it.
@@browngirlreading Thx for your answer. I finished the book a few days ago. I agree with the message of the book that skin color matters and not all people of a community are equal, although the preferred ones (e.g. some white people) don't like to believe that. They rather believe that racism doesn't exist anymore and all people have the same chances. But I miss some emotions and... just some more!! I thought racism is _always_ connected with personal emotions, but this book couldn't make me feel _enough_ anger, fears (...there was too much distance!) and --- SPOILER ALERT --- this "perfect happy end"... well... I don't think there is a "perfect" solution. This isn't realistic. Humans (of a big society) always find a smaller group which they discriminate. :( (women, foreigners or religious minorities...) The book was O.K. for me, but I think there are some better and more "intensive" books about racism.
Finally I'm watching one of your videos where I'm not going to buy the book ; ) But I already bought Sing, Unburied, Sing. Right now I am reading The Child Finder by Rene Denfeld and it is excellent!
Dr. Jeff I've got your back. Gotta tell it like it is. I've heard good things about The Child Finder, however I didn't like her first book so not sure this one is for me.
I've bought the book to see these issues for myself. I needed to buy it for this purpose, because I'm from Europe and it's not in the library. I chose a paperback not an e-book; so if it is going to annoy me, I will be able to swap it.
I started it, but I struggled (as with all her books I read or at least started), my main problem is that her books are shallow for me, I want to like the characters but something is always missing. I have a precise problem here too, I watch some medical dramas and read a few medical memoirs (nurses, midwives) and Ms. Picoult here starts explaining basic things about these professions like the readers were ten-year-old kids. Very bugging.
I’m about 1/3 of the way in this book and all of these red flag kept popping up and I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who pinned point several of the issues with the book.
@@browngirlreading It would be interesting to see how the general public would receive this book now. You know? Like would I have caught on to the many microaggressions and the obvious white savior complex of the book? I don’t know. I would like to say I do, but my 21 year old self is very diferente than me.
I don’t quite understand the disappointment surrounding how turks ark in the story ends. Isn’t that what we want? For racists to see that they are wrong and to learn to do better? I know I’m oversimplifying it, so I’ll go into greater detail of how his part of the story ends. What’s the age old saying? “Actions speak louder than words“? well, what about him leaving the movement? Reaching out to vulnerable people who would be easy to manipulate and use just like he was in his younger years? Speaking out against the twisted beliefs he once happily embraced? Acknowledging the skepticism of those who attend his speaking engagements who don’t believe he could have possibly changed and even admitting he deserves that treatment? Why is that disappointing?
OK, so who’s POV should the entire book have been written in, then? And, how should it have ended? Should Ruth have been the only character from whose point of view we got this story? should Kennedy have been portrayed differently than how she was and if yes, how so? Should Turk have been portrayed as having been born with racism and hatred in his DNA, rather than him being shaped into one by his mother, his grandfather and later, others in those white supremacist groups who preyed on his insecurities and need to feel accepted?
I watched Picoult's interview on CBS this Morning. Awww man, they were talking very highly about the book. You said it's crap, huh, LOL! 😂😂😂😂 Sounds like she tried to appease all sides, and ended up pleasing none
Whoops. I'm 5 years late to the party. Just read this. I found it quite hard to put down. Interesting story. Like you say, though, it was full of stereotypes and some moments had me sat there, like "really? 🤨" My overall opinion is, it was an engaging story, but, of middling quality. 3.5 stars.
I work at a library and i hate this book. Hate having to shelve it so much cause that means folks are reading it way too damn much. I havent read it and I wont. I have better books to read
This book was chosen for my book club, all white women, I am hispanic/white. This book was terrible, I give it one star. I thought the writing was actually racist. Light skin Ruth is good, her dark skin sister is bad. Also, the whole thing is implausible, MAYBE if it had been written like it was 1960. I'm not saying that racism doesn't exist, but this would not happen in a hospital today in this country. I used to like Jodi, but she became too preachy. Great review BTW!
Sadly I think that it can happen that people refuse to be treated by black nurses and doctors and also the other way around doctors and nurses that are racist and don't want to treat patients of color. But I just couldn't get on board with this book at all. Terrible writing and representations.
I enjoyed the book but there were certain parts of it that made me feel a certain kind of way. For example, sometimes the use of the N word seemed excessive, over-dramatized, and gratuitous. That said, the book got me thinking about ways to make talking about race easier. Long story short, if you’re black, build your own Mt Rushmore of white people you have known, persons with whom you have interacted. No parameters…can be any four you choose for whatever reason. White people do the same, construct your Mt. Rushmore of black persons you’ve known. But here’s the key, once you determine your Mt Rushmore, write each name on paper adding one sentence for each explaining why they are worthy enough to grace your monument. Thinking it is one thing, seeing it on paper is very different. Now you’re ready to have a meaningful convo with anyone else who has built and fleshed out their own similar Mt. Rushmore. Took me a while to finally settle on my Mt Rushmore. The drill required more thought and introspection than I imagined. Give it a try!
There is no thinking about race easier. The authors wrote the book like it was a research project so nothing in the book feels authentic. So I'm not following what you're talking about building my Mt Rushmore. I didn't write the book. Piccolo did. She has the problem portraying racism in her book.
I really liked this book but I can see where you are coming from in your review. It was funny how you said possible movie. Yes, one is coming starring 2 big actors. Julia Roberts and viola Davis. Definitely not a lifetime movie 🤣
Throughout the reading I kept thinking, she needed a black co-author to add humanity to her research points. She tried to fit too much in and the characters were flat stereotypes. The end was dismissive and flippant, all is right with the world.
Thank you sooo much for this review Queen. This book is being used as a graduation requirement in Waukesha Wisconsin School District. This book is not fit to be read by young generation in 2022. Let alone be a GRADUATION REQUIREMENT!!!
Yaaaaaaasss😂😂😂😂😂 A hot mess INDEED smh...your points are so spot on. I too was hopeful about 70 pages in but her characters just had no depth and it was like she just made these contrived Black folk up. To make matters worse the ending was so unbelievable-especially for Turks character. I don't know what she trying to do with this book but she just shouldn't have. Clear example of how one should stay in their lane! Sad thing is her central audience will now think they are in the "know" due to reading this book lol
Something like this actually happened, pretty recently, I think. Maybe that's why it's not that great. Picoult probably wrote it quickly, then her editors, etc rushed to get it out. But, maybe not. I've read one of her previous books and I wasn't impressed at all.
Girl, I can't believe your book club chose this! Jodi Picoult trying to write a Black woman character? HELL NO. This sounds like a one star, you know my ass would've burned it. XD This type of shit is published to pander to specific types of people.
Thank goodness I am not the only one to hate this book! I started during school break in jan and within maybe 100 pages I couldn't. As soon as her sister came in i had to deep breathe to continue. Then the mains boss being so complacent with that racist. I kept telling myself it was bc of the time but it was so stereotypical i had to drop it. I didn't finish it and never will. I have read 2 other of her books which were great so. She needs to Never touch this subject again. Thank goodness I didn't get as far as the white savior bit bc that mess makes me see complete red. Honestly no. From the first sentences i was getting angry w how delicate her moms employer was portrayed and need to be coddled. Just stop. I will never ever recommend this boom. Ever. Great review btw!
Great review and it makes me want to read the book even more because your review of this book is the second one I've encountered and is totally different from the first review I saw which was by a white person. The stark difference in opinions makes me even more curious about it.
Thank you for your honesty, Didi. (And sticking to your opinions when people defend this, because this is your review and your opinion. If they really want to read it or liked it, that's fine, but your review is your review!) I love the scrolling text under the review: black lives matter, police brutality, black hair prejudice... Now i won't be wasting my time with this trash and read someone else who can actually write.
Hello Rashmika! I always stick to my opinion. If people don't agree that's fine. We don't all have to like the same books. But I can't cosign on this one. I'm a black woman. There are better books out there with real messages. Thanks for taking the time to watch my video and to comment!
i've seen jodi picoult out there for a while so i was going to see what all the hype was about but now that i've gotten a sample i think i'll steer clear lol. and i'm glad you didn't make any excuses for her bad writing and stereotypes because i'm sure a lot of people played it off as one of those "she's doing this on purpose like 4th dimension chess" or some bullshit like that 👌🏾👌🏾
Thank you for articulating this. I felt really awkward with this. It was a boookclub read for me too. I felt there was no nuance to any of the characters. I don't really get along with Jodi Picoult. I have read 3 all for Bookclub over the years. This was by far the cringiest for me. You articulated what I felt but could not put into words. Thank you for this video.
Thanks for watching and commenting Lia! Yes this is a difficult subject to tackle for anybody but I feel like her editors let her down tremendously. They should have told her to dig deeper and quit with the stereotypes. I think we have enough of this in books, movies, publicity, ....
@@browngirlreading I finished it a few days ago, and yeahh that was definitely not the best book I've read. I definitely am not part of the demographic the book was meant for and it painfully shows
The book just didn’t flow. Didn’t like the way she broke it up. RUTH blah blah blah. KENNEDY blah blah. TURK blah blah. Too much repetition. Agree with you about editing. Too long.
I literrally began to read, checked the author's background, thought "can't be that bad", read the "Turk or Tuskwhatevernaziasshole"s chapter, and closed the book aha. Fck white savior, we already know this story, the wrote it 1000 times It's still a good book for non black I guess, to educate a little bit of the racist system
Very interesting review. I'm very interested in your comments about the stereotypical characters. As an author, I'd like to see what that looks like. From the descriptions you gave of the characters, the truth is that there are people like that. Nevertheless, I respect your opinions. lajefferson.com
I thought that exactly terrible writing, and I hate the going back and forth between characters. Also that every single stereotype had to be mentioned it was painfully obvious that she researched and was trying to fit in that fake woke rhetoric etc even if not for the role of the public defender but herself as the author. I haven’t finished the book im halfway through and had to watch a review because I am stuck deciding if it’s worth it to finish it.
Explain to me why would anyone want to read such a book. It either angers or depresses you. It must truly be horrible because I have never heard you give such a critical review.
Well this book is inspired by a true story. It just wasn't done well. This is not the first critical review I've done. I don't do them too often of course. This one annoyed me so much though.
Well people can write what they want to but if they are going to write about racism they need to do their research and make the story feel realistic or else it will be a flop.
Ugggh. It sounds horrendous. I think your 2 star rating is probably a little generous. I have read a couple of her books - they are entirely forgettable, and I agree with you that she just can't write; although that is not the only problem with her books, obviously.
Odette is the prosecuting attorney, not her mother. I feel like the purpose of the book is to get people to truly look within themselves and examine their own personal bias! Thanks for your review!
Im trying to read this book and I just... it’s very problematic for me. It just feels like Jodi is using black experiences just to check off that she wrote about them; she gets to make thousands of dollars off from this book and won’t ever have to experience what black Americans experience. Especially the way she has no problem throwing around the n word and other racial slurs. I get she’s trying to write a white supremacist but is it really necessary?
I think JP tried to get everything in instead. of really trying to authentically speak on the subject. Using the n word could come up when writing about racism. It all depends on the way it's used. No this wasn't the best book ok pretty bad in my opinion. So we agree.
Ok ok. So I am looking for black folks reviews. It’s clear that her target audience of liberal white women loved it. Which is great. I like the story very much for its ability to get white folks to reflect from the perspective of a white person. I did not like Where Ruth was placed in this story. The positions she’s put in and her meltdown and then acceptance of Turks family in the end. I don’t like that there is blame found in her. I don’t like how the story attempts to seemingly dilute the absurdity of the oppression Ruth faces with her admission to purposeful hesitation. It’s very conforming of white fear to me. I don’t find Ruth very consistent as a character with herself. I know plenty of color blind speaking black women they take their roles very seriously as professionals. She’s not going to not intervene in real life. Real Ruth saves a life period. Anyway thanks for your thoughts.
I read it and enjoyed it immensely. I'm a Jodi fan. I can see how people would classify it as a white savior story, but it was so much more than that. The book was written for people like Jodi, from her world, with her skin color. I totally respect your opinion. I think people should read it and determine whether they like it for themselves.
I really enjoyed it as well and though I respect her opinion immensely, there was so much more to the book than described, but I take that it happens when one dislikes it in my opinion. I am a big Jodi fan as well because I enjoy her putting the real harsh reality out there, not many would be bold enough to do so. I wouldn't say I'm biased but I will say Jodi played it a little safe in certain areas and yes the ending was not what I wanted and would have preferred with this man damn near groveling at her feet being for forgiveness but oh well. I also thought it wasn't too long, but could have even been a little longer. I think she should give Jodi another chance because her stories are amazing
I disagree regarding the ending, Shannon. Even as part of his redemption, Turk would have never dropped to Ruth‘s feet and started groveling; that’s not his character. Besides, what’s the age old saying? “Actions speak louder than words“? I would say he definitely proved he had changed and was continuing to work on doing so through his actions; leaving the movement, reaching out to vulnerable people who would be easy to manipulate just like he was in his…
For lack of better words here, “younger years“, speaking out against the twisted beliefs he once happily embraced, acknowledging the skepticism of those who attend his speaking engagements who don’t believe he could have possibly changed and even admitting he deserves that treatment, among some other things I may not have mentioned. If that’s not at the very least an attempt at redemption, tell me what is.
Part of me wonders if Ruth did in fact recognize him when he and his three-year-old daughter were in her clinic because of his daughter’s sore throat at the end, but I like that Jodi left that up in the air for us to decide.
I actually really loved the book. I felt strong attachment to the nurse.
I liked it too, many bad reviews, I don't know what to say... To me it was interesting, no further phylosophy
Oh heck, the books Jodi Picoult has lent her name to ALWAYS reduce complicated social issues into a Hallmark movie. I believe she hires a staff of researchers to hand her bullet points on the issue, and she and others weave it into a book/screenplay. No editor wants to mess with this popular (and very profitable) formula. I loved this review. Thanks, Didi.
Thank you! Someone else told me the same thing. Well now we all know where her books stand.
Thank you for your review. I just finished SGT for my book club. Because I had issues with the stereotypes in this story, I wanted to see what others, especially black readers, had to say about their perspective. In retrospect, I should have read the author's notes before I even started reading and I would have had a different feeling while reading it. Reading her notes and seeing her interviewed helped me in my final analysis. This book starts an examination and conversation about racism that many of us are too afraid to have, and I think that was the author's goal in writing this story, especially with the stereotypes. I know from seeing a morning show interview that Picoult did a lot of research and consulted with black women in writing Ruth's voice (over 100 hours of recorded interviews). I wouldn't write Jodi Picoult off your reading list. She is definitely someone who picks topics that are important and I don't think she writes simply to entertain her readers. Reading Nineteen Minutes over a decade ago totally changed me.
I will never pick up another Piccoult books because I don't like her writing nor do I like her approach to writing on subjects like this one. She just isn't for me. I only picked it up because it was my book club's pick of the month.
I actually really enjoyed this book. However, I understand where you're coming from. The characters were definitely off and yes, the sister was irritatingly stereotypical for me. It felt like lost potential there for a really strong character. On the other hand, other characters (like the children )and the moments between them felt very real. Although, Ruth and Kennedy, and their relationship, were all a bit flimsy for me as well. Nonetheless, I liked that light was shed on some really tough issues. I was surprised that these issues actually happen to nurses and other medical professionals. It is story that needs to be told even if it was written like a Lifetime movie at times. The story and concept(s) were important, and for me, entertaining/intriguing.
She should have focused on the hospital aspect but she didn't treat it at all. She used it as a way to fuel her book about race.
Agree. 1000. Percent.I listened to this book on audio and I remember thinking all along, 'just stop listening to it'. I am sure I would have DNF'd it if I'd purchased it as a physical book. As it was on audio, it accompanied me through hours of dishes and eye-rolling. ALL the stereotypes. ALL the expected plot points. Little to no nuance and a ridiculously neat ending. Thanks for confirming my thoughts exactly. Will be reading "sing unburied sing" which is sure to be lovely as Ward takes care with her prose.
I hear ya on the eyeball rolling.
Thanks for sharing your review. As I was reading this book, it made me really uncomfortable that the author was a white woman and I questioned how accurately she was representing reality for African Americans, but the author's note at the end resolved this for me. The book is definitely not perfect and full of stereotypes, but I think this was intentional. Readers (should) know that these are stereotypes and that they're characters, not real people, serving a purpose to make a point.
From the author's note: "When it comes to social justice, the role of the white ally is not to be a savior or a fixer. Instead, the role of the ally is to find other white people and talk to make them see that many of the benefits they’ve enjoyed in life are direct results of the fact that someone else did not have the same benefits." This is what it did for me. While I don't trust that I have much more insight into the experiences of African Americans, I'm at least more conscious of my own privileges and I feel better equipped to be an ally.
As far as the writing goes, I enjoyed it. I was engaged. It is being adapted to film, by the way. I feel like that's going to be worse -- trying to condense this already condensed book into a two-hour movie. I enjoyed the book and I hope they do it justice.
Regardless, I'm bummed that it disappointed you but I'm glad to have heard your opinion. I do have a question for you: when you mention the part that should have been cut from the book at the end, are you referencing the "Afterbirth" section, or "Shine," the short story at the end? I can see a justification for either, but I'm just curious. :)
I just don't like how one character represents one person and how then everything is skewed and un realistic. Not to mention the writing isn't that great either.
@@browngirlreading Is there a better book you would recommend on this subject? I thought Jodi did an excellent job of explaining all 3 main characters' point of view. If you don't think she helped white people to understand a few things, do you feel she hurt black people? I'm confused why you would trash her efforts. At least she MADE the effort, which is more than we can say for most.
I read this book last year and loved it, now thinking back I remember I had the same issues you did but I somehow looked past it because I loved the court case, I'm not African American and that sequence helped me realise my own subconscious prejudices. Although now your review has showed me that I'm a working progress. It never crossed my mind that Kennedy was a stereotypical white saviour. I was looking out for misrepresentation of black women or people. So much so that i completely disregarded the perspective of a black person because I just assumed she was finally being heard, but through a white woman!? Why?
Reading and hearing all your reviews has made me so much more mindful, I've definitely reconsidered my opinion on this novel.
Earth to Sav same! Well written !
The premise of the book sounded interesting but I had a feeling it would not be executed properly. One of the reasons i felt this way was because I worked in a hospital for many years and I know of cases where patients refused to have nonwhite doctors and nurses take care of them. It's a hurtful experience to have a professionally trained person being told they are not capable of providing care because of their ethnicity. I wasn't sure if a White writer could capture all of those feelings. Doesn't sound like she did. Thanks for the thoughtful review Didi!
I wish she would have stuck to exploring that part of the book but she was hell bent on discussing racism in America.
I haven't finished reading the book. I really am enjoying just turning the pages. The book keeps my attention. I like what you are saying. It is never easy living amongst people who are predominately of a different color. I went through it myself. It did cross my mind about Ruth's attitude. It could never be that easy being the minority. The White Supremacists floored me. I had no idea that it was so close to home. I thought she really did her research on the topic. So are there White Supremacists living in my neighborhood? I always say racism is alive and kicking. I have no basis for that remark. I just sense it.
Probably.
What did the rest of your bookclub think about it? That must have been one interesting meeting! I never read any Picoult, and never was really tempted to. Not sure why, though.
Well the majority were surprised at the intensity of racism in the States. We didn't talk about the UK though. There were more than half that thought the same as me. As a whole we didn't think the book was well approached and written at all.
Thanks for reviewing a book you didn't like. I like hearing why you didn't like a book just as much as hearing why you liked it.
Thanks for understanding! I usually pick really good books but this was a book club pick so I'm not responsible for it. I didn't vote for it either.
Wow. I didn't know what this book was about, but I have seen it around a bit. I have read one Picoult in the past (The Tenth Circle) and there were plenty of problems with that story, too. Thank you for your honesty - I love when you discuss your criticisms!
Thanks Kristi!
Thanks for the review but when it comes to books I have to check them out myself but I do like hearing other perspectives.
I have seen Jodi picoult here and there but never felt like picking her up.... and it seems like I'm not starting today.
I think it's pretty unfair to undermine this book as quickly as you and others have, especially for those who have based it solely on this video. Reading this at first I cannot lie, I was very skeptical in the narrative and character development for all the reasons you and others have pointed out. But I ultimately felt, when finishing the book, that the book, although can be seen as flawed from the offset due to the author and her unconscious biases as a white woman, there was a very real, tone to the story and characters that is very valuable to the audience and climate of today. After reading her authors notes, I truly believe that you cannot fault this book in a 'she's white and therefore cannot capture a narrative like this' manner because she clearly understands the sheer velocity of the task to write such a novel and has executed it to the best of her abilities. Incredible book that can teach all of us a little something
Firstly this is a review and my honest opinion. I don't have the habit of undermining authors. I took the time to read ti cover tot cover and watched videos of her talking about her book. I'm going to have to kindly disagree. No shed didn't do a good job on it. This is a poorly constructed novel with stereotypical characters. That's a fact. Now if you got something out of it good for you. If this book had been written by a black woman I'd have said the same things and we have had loads of questions. Picoult had good intentions in writing this novel and I don't knock her for that, but what she says she wanted to bring out in this novel just wasn't there in my opinion.
I am avoiding this just because of the white savior trope. I am so sick and tired of seeing white savior tropes on tv, in movies, in books--I'm over it.
Girl me too!
You should read the book before judging actually...
I was avoiding this one because it sounded like a hot mess from the synopsis alone, but then I saw that you were reading it so I wanted to see what you thought. If you had liked it then I would've given it a chance. But nope. No thank you.
Sadly yes. I probably wouldn't have read it either if it wasn't my book club's pick.:(
Funny how the synopsis can just give you that feeling of No Ma'am. LOL!
The book is great and I absolutely loved it. You are missing out
Thanks for the book review. Sounds like one I'll probably avoid. Please give details on the scarf and lippie! Thanks!
You're welcome! The scarf is from Indira de Paris and the lip color is from Kiko Gossamer Emotion 128. Thanks for watching!
Brown Girl Reading Thank you! Love your channel.
Just finished the book and really enjoyed it. I also enjoyed your review. I know that she based part of the story on a situation that happened in Michigan. I'm wondering how you would have written if differently. How do you have contrasting characters and avoid stereo types? Why do you think Viola Davis wants to be a part of this project? Is she selling out (in your opinion)? Thanks
Piccolo writes all of her books in this same way. You either like it or you don't. I don't. It's not because a novel is based on a true story that it's good. I don't see what Viola Davis accepting a role in the film adaptation has to do with selling out. I just don't like the way this author chose to fictionalise this woman's story.
You: "This was a... Hot... Mess!"
Me: "Tell. Me. EVERYTHING."
It was so interesting to hear your thoughts on this, because so many people have come into my bookstore to purchase it.
It almost seems like Picoult is writing a book for the "trend" of diversity, as opposed to writing a realistic depiction of the diverse world in which we live. Shame.
I think she honestly feels like she's doing it right and that's what's even more shocking.
Matthew Sciarappa I prefer Truth over Trend. I do appreciate that the author did try to do research to see the situation from a black person's perspective. I haven't read the book though but it is based on a true incident but the key word is BASED.
Based is one thing but stereotyping is another. Read the book for yourself and make your own opinion. These are mine.
Unfortunately most of her books come across as insincere to the point where it feels like she's jumping on trends. School shootings, cancer, now race: i think Picoult really needs to reflect and decide which kinds of stories are not her place to tell (or at least, are the kinds of stories she should research *way* more thoroughly.)
Wow! I appreciated your review...didn't have the same experience with it, but felt some of your frustrations. I have read one other book by Jodi Picoult, "Wish You Were Here" (which I liked) I plan to read another by her to develop a more fleshed-out opinion about her writing style as an author. I was curious to know if you decided to read any more novels by her. As far as a movie, although I enjoyed the book, I wouldn't want to see this become one, but I may not get my wish.
No I will not be picking up another Piccolo if I can help it.
@@browngirlreading okaaay
When I was about 19 I read I think 2 or 3 of her books. I didn't love her writing I found it entertaining but predictable. Her books are something I would need to be in the mood for, they remind me of a Hallmark movie, very formulaic. From what I saw of this one in particular, I think she was just trying to hard, and just ended up writing stereotypes. Perhaps she went a little to far out of her comfort zone. I think her writing has a place but it certainly isn't for everyone. Great review!!
Totally agree, a hot black and white mess. I read the large print so 720 pages of racism. Makes me wonder about the source, just saying. Only thing u can say about this book is kudos to Ruth for staying in her truth.
Hi Didi. I enjoyed her 2004 novel *My Sister's Keeper* though I don't remember much about the plot now. (I read it about six years ago.) If you're interested in reading a novel by a white woman who does a commendable job at depicting the black experience in a racially divided society, check out *Wide Sargasso Sea* by Jean Rhys. It's set in the Caribbean, post-Emancipation, but I think it's 'relate-able' in 2017.
Yes Wide Saragasso Sea is on my TBR. Actually it's been on it for a long while. One day...
Bungi yes! Didi, I highly recommend it too, especially if u have read Jane Eyre...will stop there without giving anything away
Thanks for the review. I guess I will cancel my hold request at the public library! I read My Sister's Keeper by the same author, a few years ago. I actually enjoyed that one.
Love this review, so honest and hilarious! The premise sounds really good, to bad it turned out to be a "hot mess" . 😂
I get the feeling she wants to be Joyce Carol Oates but she's more Jennifer Weiner, lol. I have a friend who loves Picoult and wants me to reader and I keep "forgetting" to pick her up!!
I say keep forgetting to pick her up. You won't like her writing or the way she tells a story.
Someone brought this up in my book club as a book they enjoyed. Going off her description of it I immediately thought that I would be far too critical of the book to enjoy it. Glad I made the right decision. Thank you for the review.
Love your glasses :) Jodi Picoult was never somebody I would pick up but I guess that is part of a charm of being in a book club, one widens horizons. :)
Thank you! Oh yes so wide that you fall 5 meters down the the hole on your head. LOL! It only took 2 days to read, so no sweat.
I really enjoy this book. Books are not meant to always be 100 facts. There are pockets in the story that does make you stop and think. I do agree there were a lot of topics/issues were mentioned just to mention but were irrelevant to the story. However I did enjoy this book. For me it was a 5 star.
No it doesn't have to be 100% facts but for me it has to be believable. You enjoyed it and I didn't. Oh well.
The only book from geral I've realy enjoyed was the "My sister's Keeper". The others have read are very stereotyped for me. I remember the last one I gave a try on and was completely tired of it because ir seamed a moral lesson shoved to our brain.
I read the book when it came out. I had heard so much hype about it, wow I really enjoyed the book, it was a bit long and the end was like a lifetime movie. I think she got it kind of right as a hospital worker for the last 25+ years, it's very political and I really can see this happening, but I did wonder how a white Women would know about a black Woman and her experiences but I guess it's plausible, as always I love your reviews always on point and a personal level thank You for challenging me to read more convoluted books instead of the fluff. I'm sure you didn't even know you did that for me.xoxoxo
I would hope in a hospital a superior would be more responsible than the one in the book. However what bothered me the most was the stereotypical view of each character they were nothing more than representations. Henceforth not fully developed three dimensional characters. For such a serious subject that's devastating to read such a poorly developed and written story. Thanks for commenting and supporting!
Oh my goodness I could not agree with you more! This book was a contrived and shallow attempt at being relevant. Thank you so much for your wonderful videos and reviews. I don't comment much but always watch :D
Thank you Stevie for supporting and commenting! I really appreciate it. :)
I am reading it now and searched out reviews like this bc I am having such a hard time reading Turks chapters. I am enjoying the story, but his chapters make me feel sick and dirty. Idk if I want to continue for this reason.
I do see what you are saying about the other characters. I do see about Ruth shrugging off comments and things. It’s highly pointed out and I’m assuming that it will cause some growth or something at some point. Also it 100% comes directly from how her mom raised her. I’m interested in that dynamic as well.
Jodi Picoult is one of my Authors to Avoid. Her books are just Lifetime movies in print form.
Accurate. 😂
Eileen L a few of her books have been adopted into Lifetime movies 😂
Maybe the movie is better ... ? Is it out yet?
@@Mercuriusdm Not yet. Saw 2020, then just read 2021. Not sure exactly with COVID-19.
Oooohh!! Thank you soooo much for sharing this!!! I must go pick this uuuppp!!!!
Strongly disagree. 5 stars!
This is an awesome read. The cultural elements, experiences and emotions, especially those related to living as a Black person in America are spot on! Nothing stereotypical here. Ruth's character is hard working and proud, yet has the misconception that hard work and a good education will make her an equal to her counterparts. Great set up as the desire for equality continues to be the number one value for most Black Americans.. America is a long, long, long way from being post racial and I love that Picoult had the courage and brilliance to share the lenses of Ruth and how she navigates White America; Turk, the White Supremacist, and Kennedy, Ruth's attorney who has an unconscious bias toward Black America.
We can agree to disagree.
I completely agree with you, this book was excellent. (How nice that some people feel they have never met a Ruth, an Adisa, or a Turk. I have.) The author did a great job of explaining things to white people. It wasn't meant to be perfect in every way, nor could any book be. It's a start - and a much needed start.
I have just started reading this and as a nurse I was really disgusted by the hospital staff. I’m not a nurse in US so I have no idea what things are like but it just seemed off. I’m finding that the writing style is very much like a romance novel with the predictable happy ending. On the subject of racism, I noticed the stereotypes immediately and it made me uncomfortable. I was wondering if you have any book recommendations that address racism and have wonderful well developed characters. Thank you so much for this review.
Thanks for watching and commenting! Here are some great examples: Grant Park, The Last thing You Surrender, Freeman, The Blacker the Berry, The Trees, Another Country, Real Life, A More Perfect Union, The Vanishing Half, etc.
Yikes! I've never read anything by Picoult and I doubt I ever will after your review.
This is an interesting review! I've always been curious about Jodi Picoult's books, but I've never tried one.
This book may not be the one, in my opinion.
Echo Heron writes nonfiction books about challenges nurses face. She does it well.
Love your energy here :)
I really liked the book.... But dialogue like this is so important for us to learn from each other... Thank you for speaking to the white savior complex... That is humbling and good to hear your thoughts on.
When Ruth was trying to get Kennedy to see that race really did and should be addressed in the trial. Kennedy told Ruth that bringing up race would not win the trial because justice usually turns a blind eye to racism. Kennedy finally sees the light and tells the truth about how being a racist is wrong. It’s also based on a true story. However, I respect your views and understand where u are coming from as well. Your review makes sense to me it’s just that I have been in that same situation as Ruth as far as trying to explain why race matters. My sister refused to read the book as well.
A bit to simple for a complex subject in my opinion.
No m'am, haha! I've read two other books by her and for some reason never picked this one up...this review makes me glad. TFS your thoughts. 😉
Great review. :) I like the way you articulate your thoughts. If you do not mind sharing, I would love to hear your thoughts on the way "To Kill a Mockingbird" handles racism.
Thank you for the compliments! I'd have to re-read To Kill a Mockingbird in order to do that. not ready to re-read it at the moment. Maybe one day. When I do I'll be sure to talk about how racism is handled.
I love your headwrap
I enjoyed it very much but I listened to it on Audiobook. I like listening the Picoult book and Jodie did lots of research for this book.
I need more real depth in my books, not stereotypes
Was is stereotypical or real? I know each of those people in the book and it was SPOT ON!
This book is 'kinda' based on a true story here in states about 10-15 yrs ago
Yes I know.
Im not upd8d from being headlines. But is interesting read come think about it.
Amen. It was my first novel by Picoult and I was so disappointed. I felt the novel screamed of in-authenticity and patronization, and I was exhausted by the end from the author driving her message into the ground.
Yes she was obviously on a mission to convince the readers of a lot of things. Didn't work and her editors should have been honest with her. Probably won't pick up anything else by her. Ain't nobody got time for that!
I read the book and absolutely loved it!
I appreciate your views but disagree for the most part. Yes, she tries to represent different ‘stereotypes’of black character. You said Oddettte was the mother of the girls. I think she was actually the black lawyer who represented the white supremacists in court.
Also some really relatable situations of subtle racism like the shopping experience .
Jodi is a fantastic author and love it or not, she deserves credit for giving a very important subject the thought and research that she did. She did pack a lot into the book.
At least 4 stars from me.
Good for you! We can agree to disagree. The lawyer's name is Kennedy.
The characters seem stereotypical but the story was inspired by an actual court case.
I know and I knew that when I read it but the book is still bad.
Thanks so much for your honesty. I’ll pass on this one. Too many other potentially good books out there.
Agreed! So many good books out there to be messing around reading bad ones. Happy reading Columbus!
I know this is an old video, but I just came across it and I just had to comment. Thank you for this review. This book was the subject of one of the most uncomfortable book club experiences I've ever had. I agree with your take on this book...I was very uncomfortable reading it. The stereotypes were just over the top--I could recognize it and I actually felt guilty about them. As I said after finishing, this was another example of white people trying to make themselves feel better over racism.
But, I also had issues with it beyond the racial aspects. I have two friends who were in the same book club. One is a doctor and one is a lawyer and they were furious over how badly (perhaps inaccurately or ignorantly would be better words) their fields of expertise were portrayed here.
So, onto the book club. One friend (the lawyer) refused to even attend. The other friend (the doctor) and I went together and we were so dreading the conversation that we met for margaritas beforehand to numb our reactions (or at least to be able to claim intoxication for any bad behavior on our part). Fortunately, everyone else who attended that particular meeting felt the same way we did. The discomfort came at the next meeting when someone who had not attended the discussion told us we were all wrong for not liking the book and we didn't know what we were talking about. I nearly quit that book club there and then.
In short, this book convinced me to add Jodi Picoult to my "do not read" list and has convinced me to be very selective about which books I read that feature something about race and I try to choose only among own voices books. Okay, sorry for that long rant on a 5 year old post, but I just wanted to let you know that I so appreciated your thoughts on this!
Hello I'm happy that you understood my perspective on this book. As you can see in this comment section there are many like the lady in your book club. No worries. It's been 5 years and I still won't read Piccolo either. Are you still attending the book club? What sorts of books are you reading these days?
@@browngirlreading I actually have just recently decided to leave that particular book club (the Small Great Things was not the only weird incident), but I'm in 2 other books clubs plus some podcast-led book discussion. My currently book club reads are Sitting Pretty: The View from My Ordinary, Resilient, Disabled Body by Rebekah Taussig (I'm enjoying it and it is giving me a lot to think about, but unfortunately I can't make that particular book discussion) and Caramelo by Sandra Cisneros (it has taken me a little while to settle in with this one, but I'm starting to enjoy it).
🤣 I have had those "Lord, God, Jesus" moments while reading Jodi Picoult. Sadly, I have read more disappointing books by her than books that I've liked by her. My Sister's Keeper was the first book I've read of Picoult and I liked it. It was ages ago though and I'm not sure I'd feel the same about it. Did you read Vanishing Act? I saw it on one of your 2013 ? videos.
Vanishing Act was gifted to me and I never could get into it.
@@browngirlreading Thank you for the feedback. I'm guessing it will be a fail for me as well. =/
Wow. Thanks Didi dodged a bullet with that one. I've never read her, but I have other interesting books on my TBR so I'll be skipping her for a minute.
I'm so glad to found this review here! I'm not sure how to classify this story: On the one hand it is full of stereotypical characters (Adisa, Turk) and on the other hand it tries to teach oder tell us something about racism and the different perspectives of ethnicities...
Some of Ruth's desicions aren't comprehending for me. She's a bit to stubborn, but Kennedy's sometimes blind for Ruth's sensitivity. But I like both and they find a way to understand each others life better! :)
I like the book up to now, the last 150 pages will be read over the next days!
I'm not an American, so I don't have enough expericences to know if this kind of setting is realistic oder stereotypical?
"All things are based on racism" is what I read in every second line. Is this a realistic image of the US? I hope not!
I expected a book which shows conflicts between black and white Americans, but I think Jodi Picoult forgot sometimes, that we are all more than our skin colors, also people of color! We all play different roles in our lives and we all have different facets of personality. But Picoult created a story were all concentrates to much on ethnicities. I miss some human(!) contact and happier and carefree scenes, were Ruth and Kennedy are just two women, Ruth and her son are just a family,...
These are only my impressions about the story as a not-US-American.
I hope not to offend someone here. ❤
Discrimination is a personal and sensitive experience and talking about is important. But I really miss something in this book, and sometimes it doesn't have the right measure for me. 🤔
Well the book is based on racism from the US opinion and sadly racism is based on skin color, which is what she's trying to show in the story even though I don't think she does a very good job of it.
@@browngirlreading Thx for your answer. I finished the book a few days ago.
I agree with the message of the book that skin color matters and not all people of a community are equal, although the preferred ones (e.g. some white people) don't like to believe that. They rather believe that racism doesn't exist anymore and all people have the same chances.
But I miss some emotions and... just some more!!
I thought racism is _always_ connected with personal emotions, but this book couldn't make me feel _enough_ anger, fears (...there was too much distance!) and
--- SPOILER ALERT ---
this "perfect happy end"... well... I don't think there is a "perfect" solution. This isn't realistic. Humans (of a big society) always find a smaller group which they discriminate. :(
(women, foreigners or religious minorities...)
The book was O.K. for me, but I think there are some better and more "intensive" books about racism.
Finally I'm watching one of your videos where I'm not going to buy the book ; ) But I already bought Sing, Unburied, Sing. Right now I am reading The Child Finder by Rene Denfeld and it is excellent!
Dr. Jeff I've got your back. Gotta tell it like it is. I've heard good things about The Child Finder, however I didn't like her first book so not sure this one is for me.
I was hoping this was good because I think it was inspired by a real incident that happened...such a shame it did not come out well.
I've bought the book to see these issues for myself. I needed to buy it for this purpose, because I'm from Europe and it's not in the library. I chose a paperback not an e-book; so if it is going to annoy me, I will be able to swap it.
Please come back Kate and let me know what you think of Small Great Things.
Of course.
I started it, but I struggled (as with all her books I read or at least started), my main problem is that her books are shallow for me, I want to like the characters but something is always missing. I have a precise problem here too, I watch some medical dramas and read a few medical memoirs (nurses, midwives) and Ms. Picoult here starts explaining basic things about these professions like the readers were ten-year-old kids. Very bugging.
I'm not surprised.
Great review! You said it much more eloquently than I could. I agree with much of what you said about the book and the stereotypes perpetuated by it.
I’m about 1/3 of the way in this book and all of these red flag kept popping up and I’m glad I wasn’t the only one who pinned point several of the issues with the book.
Glad you agreed because people purposely come to this review to tell me I'm wrong. LOL!
@@browngirlreading It would be interesting to see how the general public would receive this book now. You know? Like would I have caught on to the many microaggressions and the obvious white savior complex of the book? I don’t know. I would like to say I do, but my 21 year old self is very diferente than me.
I don’t quite understand the disappointment surrounding how turks ark in the story ends. Isn’t that what we want? For racists to see that they are wrong and to learn to do better?
I know I’m oversimplifying it, so I’ll go into greater detail of how his part of the story ends. What’s the age old saying? “Actions speak louder than words“? well, what about him leaving the movement? Reaching out to vulnerable people who would be easy to manipulate and use just like he was in his younger years? Speaking out against the twisted beliefs he once happily embraced? Acknowledging the skepticism of those who attend his speaking engagements who don’t believe he could have possibly changed and even admitting he deserves that treatment?
Why is that disappointing?
It's not realistic but then nothing about this book is written in a realistic fashion.
OK, so who’s POV should the entire book have been written in, then? And, how should it have ended?
Should Ruth have been the only character from whose point of view we got this story? should Kennedy have been portrayed differently than how she was and if yes, how so? Should Turk have been portrayed as having been born with racism and hatred in his DNA, rather than him being shaped into one by his mother, his grandfather and later, others in those white supremacist groups who preyed on his insecurities and need to feel accepted?
I watched Picoult's interview on CBS this Morning. Awww man, they were talking very highly about the book. You said it's crap, huh, LOL! 😂😂😂😂
Sounds like she tried to appease all sides, and ended up pleasing none
CALLewisATL read it
I recommend reading it. I thought it was wonderful.
LOL I totally loved this review. I was cracking up at your critique. Then the scrolling at the bottom. Good night! lol
Tried to get my point across bu t wow this book was a disaster My first one star of the year. :(
Whoops. I'm 5 years late to the party. Just read this. I found it quite hard to put down. Interesting story.
Like you say, though, it was full of stereotypes and some moments had me sat there, like "really? 🤨"
My overall opinion is, it was an engaging story, but, of middling quality. 3.5 stars.
Well that's a generous rating.
I work at a library and i hate this book. Hate having to shelve it so much cause that means folks are reading it way too damn much. I havent read it and I wont. I have better books to read
Damn that's hard. Hang in there and try to propose something else anything else that's better. That'll make you feel a little better.
This book was chosen for my book club, all white women, I am hispanic/white. This book was terrible, I give it one star. I thought the writing was actually racist. Light skin Ruth is good, her dark skin sister is bad. Also, the whole thing is implausible, MAYBE if it had been written like it was 1960. I'm not saying that racism doesn't exist, but this would not happen in a hospital today in this country. I used to like Jodi, but she became too preachy. Great review BTW!
Sadly I think that it can happen that people refuse to be treated by black nurses and doctors and also the other way around doctors and nurses that are racist and don't want to treat patients of color. But I just couldn't get on board with this book at all. Terrible writing and representations.
I enjoyed the book but there were certain parts of it that made me feel a certain kind of way. For example, sometimes the use of the N word seemed excessive, over-dramatized, and gratuitous. That said, the book got me thinking about ways to make talking about race easier. Long story short, if you’re black, build your own Mt Rushmore of white people you have known, persons with whom you have interacted. No parameters…can be any four you choose for whatever reason. White people do the same, construct your Mt. Rushmore of black persons you’ve known. But here’s the key, once you determine your Mt Rushmore, write each name on paper adding one sentence for each explaining why they are worthy enough to grace your monument. Thinking it is one thing, seeing it on paper is very different. Now you’re ready to have a meaningful convo with anyone else who has built and fleshed out their own similar Mt. Rushmore. Took me a while to finally settle on my Mt Rushmore. The drill required more thought and introspection than I imagined. Give it a try!
There is no thinking about race easier. The authors wrote the book like it was a research project so nothing in the book feels authentic. So I'm not following what you're talking about building my Mt Rushmore. I didn't write the book. Piccolo did. She has the problem portraying racism in her book.
@@browngirlreading Agreeing to disagree. Our respective takes are far apart.
@@aProudOG I got that from your first comment. I rest on my review.
I really liked this book but I can see where you are coming from in your review. It was funny how you said possible movie. Yes, one is coming starring 2 big actors. Julia Roberts and viola Davis. Definitely not a lifetime movie 🤣
Lifetime movie script though.
Sounds like that other hot mess The Help
Similar. They both bring out the worst in me. :(
Ouch! Thats why I love your reviews. Honest.
Can't do it any other way. ;)
Throughout the reading I kept thinking, she needed a black co-author to add humanity to her research points. She tried to fit too much in and the characters were flat stereotypes. The end was dismissive and flippant, all is right with the world.
Thank you sooo much for this review Queen. This book is being used as a graduation requirement in Waukesha Wisconsin School District. This book is not fit to be read by young generation in 2022. Let alone be a GRADUATION REQUIREMENT!!!
A graduation requirement?! Why?! I'm shocked. Smh...
Yaaaaaaasss😂😂😂😂😂 A hot mess INDEED smh...your points are so spot on. I too was hopeful about 70 pages in but her characters just had no depth and it was like she just made these contrived Black folk up. To make matters worse the ending was so unbelievable-especially for Turks character. I don't know what she trying to do with this book but she just shouldn't have. Clear example of how one should stay in their lane! Sad thing is her central audience will now think they are in the "know" due to reading this book lol
This is what I fear too. I just want to meet the black people that so called helped her right authentic black characters. :/
It was such a good book.
Something like this actually happened, pretty recently, I think. Maybe that's why it's not that great. Picoult probably wrote it quickly, then her editors, etc rushed to get it out. But, maybe not. I've read one of her previous books and I wasn't impressed at all.
Yes something did happen like it but that isn't why the book is a flop.
I guess not. I was thinking she rushed to get the book out while the topic was still current. Love your channel!
Girl, I can't believe your book club chose this! Jodi Picoult trying to write a Black woman character? HELL NO. This sounds like a one star, you know my ass would've burned it. XD This type of shit is published to pander to specific types of people.
Girl you know I didn't vote for this one. Yes it's a book that does a lot of pandering, bowing, and scraping.... Can't get off of the ground. :(
Thank goodness I am not the only one to hate this book! I started during school break in jan and within maybe 100 pages I couldn't. As soon as her sister came in i had to deep breathe to continue. Then the mains boss being so complacent with that racist. I kept telling myself it was bc of the time but it was so stereotypical i had to drop it. I didn't finish it and never will. I have read 2 other of her books which were great so. She needs to Never touch this subject again. Thank goodness I didn't get as far as the white savior bit bc that mess makes me see complete red. Honestly no. From the first sentences i was getting angry w how delicate her moms employer was portrayed and need to be coddled. Just stop. I will never ever recommend this boom. Ever. Great review btw!
Agree with everything you said. Apparently she got her black friends to read though. I thought really?
Great review and it makes me want to read the book even more because your review of this book is the second one I've encountered and is totally different from the first review I saw which was by a white person. The stark difference in opinions makes me even more curious about it.
Definitely read it for yourself and come back and let me know what you think about it.
Thank you for your honesty, Didi. (And sticking to your opinions when people defend this, because this is your review and your opinion. If they really want to read it or liked it, that's fine, but your review is your review!)
I love the scrolling text under the review: black lives matter, police brutality, black hair prejudice...
Now i won't be wasting my time with this trash and read someone else who can actually write.
Hello Rashmika! I always stick to my opinion. If people don't agree that's fine. We don't all have to like the same books. But I can't cosign on this one. I'm a black woman. There are better books out there with real messages. Thanks for taking the time to watch my video and to comment!
idk how I missed watching this video because it has 10K views lol just watched the whole thing
Yes it's a video that brings loads of JP fans.
I LOVED this book. Soooo good
What did you love about it?
i've seen jodi picoult out there for a while so i was going to see what all the hype was about but now that i've gotten a sample i think i'll steer clear lol. and i'm glad you didn't make any excuses for her bad writing and stereotypes because i'm sure a lot of people played it off as one of those "she's doing this on purpose like 4th dimension chess" or some bullshit like that 👌🏾👌🏾
Thank you for articulating this. I felt really awkward with this. It was a boookclub read for me too. I felt there was no nuance to any of the characters. I don't really get along with Jodi Picoult. I have read 3 all for Bookclub over the years. This was by far the cringiest for me. You articulated what I felt but could not put into words. Thank you for this video.
Thanks for watching and commenting Lia! Yes this is a difficult subject to tackle for anybody but I feel like her editors let her down tremendously. They should have told her to dig deeper and quit with the stereotypes. I think we have enough of this in books, movies, publicity, ....
About half way through this book and I roll my eyes every 2 minutes, but maybe I’m being too harsh
Nope nopt at all. It's that kind of book. Wait until you get to the end. You're going to want to throw it out the window.
@@browngirlreading I finished it a few days ago, and yeahh that was definitely not the best book I've read. I definitely am not part of the demographic the book was meant for and it painfully shows
The book just didn’t flow. Didn’t like the way she broke it up. RUTH blah blah blah. KENNEDY blah blah. TURK blah blah. Too much repetition. Agree with you about editing. Too long.
She wrote slurs into a story. She chose to do it. I don’t care if you’re writing a racist character, you can be racist without slurs.
I literrally began to read, checked the author's background, thought "can't be that bad", read the "Turk or Tuskwhatevernaziasshole"s chapter, and closed the book aha. Fck white savior, we already know this story, the wrote it 1000 times
It's still a good book for non black I guess, to educate a little bit of the racist system
Very interesting review. I'm very interested in your comments about the stereotypical characters. As an author, I'd like to see what that looks like. From the descriptions you gave of the characters, the truth is that there are people like that. Nevertheless, I respect your opinions. lajefferson.com
I thought that exactly terrible writing, and I hate the going back and forth between characters. Also that every single stereotype had to be mentioned it was painfully obvious that she researched and was trying to fit in that fake woke rhetoric etc even if not for the role of the public defender but herself as the author. I haven’t finished the book im halfway through and had to watch a review because I am stuck deciding if it’s worth it to finish it.
Glad you agree. There are so many that think it's the best book. I'll never pick up another book from this author if I can help it.
I knew you were going to hate it! LOL.
LOL!
Explain to me why would anyone want to read such a book. It either angers or depresses you. It must truly be horrible because I have never heard you give such a critical review.
Well this book is inspired by a true story. It just wasn't done well. This is not the first critical review I've done. I don't do them too often of course. This one annoyed me so much though.
I’m reading it in English class (as a german) and I think it’s a bit strange a white women makes a book about black citizen problems
Well people can write what they want to but if they are going to write about racism they need to do their research and make the story feel realistic or else it will be a flop.
Ugggh. It sounds horrendous. I think your 2 star rating is probably a little generous. I have read a couple of her books - they are entirely forgettable, and I agree with you that she just can't write; although that is not the only problem with her books, obviously.
In the end I gave it 1 star. If I say No Ma'am in a review video I can't honestly give the book more than that.
Odette is the prosecuting attorney, not her mother. I feel like the purpose of the book is to get people to truly look within themselves and examine their own personal bias! Thanks for your review!
Im trying to read this book and I just... it’s very problematic for me. It just feels like Jodi is using black experiences just to check off that she wrote about them; she gets to make thousands of dollars off from this book and won’t ever have to experience what black Americans experience. Especially the way she has no problem throwing around the n word and other racial slurs. I get she’s trying to write a white supremacist but is it really necessary?
I think JP tried to get everything in instead. of really trying to authentically speak on the subject. Using the n word could come up when writing about racism. It all depends on the way it's used. No this wasn't the best book ok pretty bad in my opinion. So we agree.
Ok ok. So I am looking for black folks reviews. It’s clear that her target audience of liberal white women loved it. Which is great. I like the story very much for its ability to get white folks to reflect from the perspective of a white person. I did not like Where Ruth was placed in this story. The positions she’s put in and her meltdown and then acceptance of Turks family in the end. I don’t like that there is blame found in her. I don’t like how the story attempts to seemingly dilute the absurdity of the oppression Ruth faces with her admission to purposeful hesitation. It’s very conforming of white fear to me. I don’t find Ruth very consistent as a character with herself. I know plenty of color blind speaking black women they take their roles very seriously as professionals. She’s not going to not intervene in real life. Real Ruth saves a life period. Anyway thanks for your thoughts.
Did you read this book? Because she did intervene, and if that baby's life could have been saved, she would have saved it.