Bangladesh's forgotten Hindu Havelis & how they tell a story of oppression, partition

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 лют 2025
  • Hindu Havelis near Bangladesh's capital Dhaka, tell a story of zamindars, oppression, partition. ThePrint Columnist Deep Halder travelled to Kolakopa & spoke to Salahuddin Suman, Bangladesh’s top history & travel UA-camr, and Oral historian Avishek Biswas, who has done his doctoral research on narratives of Dalit Partition survivors. Watch #ThePrintVideo to know more.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Connect with ThePrint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
    » Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
    » Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
    » Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
    » Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
    » Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
    » Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
    » Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

КОМЕНТАРІ • 707

  • @KushChakraborty1
    @KushChakraborty1 Рік тому +130

    This was so real. My mother's family migrated from Bangladesh in waves, and still have the homes they left behind in their hearts. This weaves through so many stories I heard as I grew up. Beautifully potrayed by the print! Thanks you.

    • @wisedesi442
      @wisedesi442 Рік тому +36

      Still you vote for mamta and you will be driven out of WB. Mark my words 25 years max.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому +9

      @@wisedesi442
      We will be saved once you people stop meddling in our affairs. People who cannot manage their own village should have consciousness and decency of not advising others

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal.........

    • @gauravdey4163
      @gauravdey4163 Рік тому +4

      Same here

    • @MrNobody-op6sc
      @MrNobody-op6sc Рік тому +2

      ​@@wisedesi442😢

  • @mausumibairagi5923
    @mausumibairagi5923 Рік тому +34

    My forefathers also fled from their during partition, i am a Hindu, my grand mother use to tell me the scary scenario during partition the Hindu massacre, rape, loot.. I am always an Indian and proud be, Indian government took my great grandfather and others to Andaman and nicobar islands or some stayed in west Bengal and my father and mother born in andaman and i too.. My grandmaa use to tell me that they tortured us so much that even can't be described in words, she says for saving their lives she swim for a day may be i am not confirmed, and so on.... Proud to be an Indian

  • @aganguly23
    @aganguly23 Рік тому +107

    My ancestors were from Bangladesh...they were pretty well off until during partition they came to India and started from scratch...one should not forget the atrocities committee by Muslims against us ....Jai Hind

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal

    • @gauravdey4163
      @gauravdey4163 Рік тому +7

      Jaya bhandari also and Gita Dutta faridpur jamidar s daughter

    • @shreyasbhattacharjee4706
      @shreyasbhattacharjee4706 Рік тому +6

      ​@@gauravdey4163 my maternal side has faridpur ancestry.

    • @aryanhassan4659
      @aryanhassan4659 Рік тому +6

      Same thing happened to muslims who migrated to Pakistan....stop being biasedd

    • @aganguly23
      @aganguly23 Рік тому +11

      @@aryanhassan4659 whosoever you are read history first and how two religions have continuously committed crimes against humanity

  • @gupigainbaghabain6465
    @gupigainbaghabain6465 Рік тому +107

    Our hearts blead, our ancestors left all aur belongings... To save our lives to save our religion... Still now the person who lived through this is alive, my grandfather.

    • @libshastra
      @libshastra Рік тому +20

      They were targeted because of their religion. Pakistani treated them like Jews in WW2

    • @rutvikrs
      @rutvikrs Рік тому +6

      Please document his history and get it verified on the ground.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      @@libshastra .. PERSECUTION of BUDHISTS .
      The famous persecutor of Buddhists was Pushyamitra Sunga, founder of the Sunga Dynasty. Several Chinese and Japanese historians mention Pushyamitra’s name at the head of the list of persecutors. Buddhist writers portray Pushyanitra as a cruel persecutor of the religion of Sakyamuni (Buddha). Pushyamitra, a militant follower of Brahminism, assassinated the last Mauryan Emperor Brhadratha, capturing the throne of Magadha and founded the Sunga Dynasty. It ruled for a period of one hundred and twelve years. Pushyamitra had to justify his position as head of the Brahmanic reaction by persecuting the Buddhists and destroying Buddhist monasteries on the one hand and restoring the sacrificial ceremonies of the Brahmanic faith on the other, for which his principal helpers were Patanjali and also perhaps Manu, the author of the Manusmriti. who was also his contemporary according to some scholars. The persecution of the Buddhists by Pushyamitra, was a logical sequence of the Brahmanic reaction and the political coup d’etat. The Buddhist text Divyavadana mentions the persecutions of Pushyamitra and his destruction of Buddhist stupas and monasteries.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      I suppose your heart does not bleed for causing the partition and initiating the misery for many?

    • @wisedesi442
      @wisedesi442 Рік тому +6

      Still those idiot bhadralok vote Mamta.

  • @djoys7738
    @djoys7738 Рік тому +72

    Most of Bangladesh conveniently and quickly forgot India's help in independence from brutal pakistan rule.
    Sad reality.

    • @TextBookPuncher1
      @TextBookPuncher1 Рік тому +18

      Bro Indians always talk about this when starting a convo with bengalis. This is a cheap move. Indians helped the britishers way more in ww2 but would u speak to the English like this ?

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +5

      What if Mynamar helps Kukis of Manipur?

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому +2

      Most indians outside bengali regions wished to help Bangladesh only to weaken Pakistan. If not for Indira Gandhi and the Communists they would have not even got involved in that war at all.
      Apparently it could have been better.
      Nowadays I find Afghans and Northern Pakistanis and Himalayan indian people much more decent & trustable lot than others.
      Probably it was always so throughout history.
      Appearances say lot of stories, more than any history book.

    • @shohartoislam7106
      @shohartoislam7106 Рік тому +3

      It was not about helping the oppressed. It's about using the opportunity to make your enemy weaker.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому +1

      @@TextBookPuncher1
      Bravo!!!

  • @Dreamelevator20521
    @Dreamelevator20521 25 днів тому +1

    This is so true. My ancestral root was from Bangladesh. Few of my relatives are still there trying to save our ancestral house and lands but I see, we are going to lose them as the current situation is not so good 😢

  • @therationalhuman9874
    @therationalhuman9874 Рік тому +62

    2:12 Incorrect Subtitles at this timestamp. He said 400-500 years, not 4000 years.
    How can there be 4000 year old mosques waen Islam came to be just around 1400 years ago?

    • @rahuldahoob
      @rahuldahoob Рік тому +1

      Correct 👍

    • @eee9034
      @eee9034 Рік тому +3

      Its "The print" , i dont know why but they often do these kind of small mistake

    • @md.mahadihasan4962
      @md.mahadihasan4962 Рік тому +1

      you guys always referred that islam came 1400 years ago..... But prophet Muhammad was the last messenger. Islam came when earth originated because the first man of our earth was prophet adam. Even at the time of egyptian civilisation (pyramid time) there was a prophet named yousuf.......

    • @eee9034
      @eee9034 Рік тому

      @@md.mahadihasan4962 you arab mas ters stole Joseph from jews religion, and repacked him as Yousuf in islam , in a sense you are praying to a jew,
      accept it yahudis are you actual mas ters

    • @BhagatSinghRajguruSukhdevFan
      @BhagatSinghRajguruSukhdevFan Рік тому +1

      Indian news channels ☕
      But yes this was very good documentary

  • @isthiakahsan
    @isthiakahsan 9 місяців тому +11

    I am from the Chittagong region of Bangladesh. I hope one day our Hindus will comeback to their ancestral land🙏🏼

    • @md.mahiin5049
      @md.mahiin5049 8 місяців тому +1

      Shopnodosh joye jabe dada😁

    • @mdakramulIslam-iu3qq
      @mdakramulIslam-iu3qq 8 місяців тому

      Tor dorkar hoile tui endia te ja........

    • @contra7631
      @contra7631 7 місяців тому

      Islamist rah tader ke mereh felbeh.Amneo desher manushera aroh din din radicalised hoche.Ei desher madrasah,waz,mahfil,loudspeakerer azan nah bondho nah hoileh ei desher manush sob somoi radical roye jabeh

    • @ananfardin
      @ananfardin 7 місяців тому

      @@md.mahiin5049তুই কি বো কা চো দা ? খানকির ছেলে ? এই লোকের বাপ দাদার ভিটা চিটাগং, তোরে যদি তোর বাসার থেকে বের করে দেয় ? কেমন লাগবো

    • @induchopra3014
      @induchopra3014 4 місяці тому

      How? To die? You make them feel unsafe. They day hindus do this in india ,muskims will become 1percent in india

  • @TextBookPuncher1
    @TextBookPuncher1 Рік тому +44

    I’m a British born Bangladeshi Muslim. I want to learn more about Bengali hindu merchants and traders ! Thank you for this documentary. I am all for learning about my history. This is my culture too!

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +2

      Another hateful persecutor of Buddhists was Pushyamitra Sunga, founder of the Sunga Dynasty. Several Chinese and Japanese historians mention Pushyamitra’s name at the head of the list of persecutors. Buddhist writers portray Pushyanitra as a cruel persecutor of the religion of Sakyamuni (Buddha). Pushyamitra, a militant follower of Brahminism, assassinated the last Mauryan Emperor Brhadratha, capturing the throne of Magadha and founded the Sunga Dynasty. It ruled for a period of one hundred and twelve years. Pushyamitra had to justify his position as head of the Brahmanic reaction by persecuting the Buddhists and destroying Buddhist monasteries on the one hand and restoring the sacrificial ceremonies of the Brahmanic faith on the other, for which his principal helpers were Patanjali and also perhaps Manu, the author of the Manusmriti. who was also his contemporary according to some scholars

    • @spinerboldac1945
      @spinerboldac1945 Рік тому

      @@nazeerpasha2075 Pushyamitra Sunga lived only 40 odd years iabt 2100 years ago... so very little destruction .. what u all are doing in France pairs riot , usa uk area even today is unspeakable ... just shameless humans

    • @secretporter7415
      @secretporter7415 Рік тому +8

      There is hardly any Bengali Hindu merchants and traders. All the merchants and traders in Bengal were mostly Marwari Hindus and Bengali Muslims. This is still true to this day.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +4

      @@secretporter7415 ... Marwari Gujrati Hindus... Nearly every PAWNBROKER , MONEYLENDER ( mahajan) is a Marwari. They are spread all over India, even in the smallest vellages.

    • @spinerboldac1945
      @spinerboldac1945 Рік тому +11

      @@nazeerpasha2075 in 1947 , 29 %pct were hindu in east pakistan , now. 8 % ...how wonderful these number look....thats what is best teaching...

  • @zion3335
    @zion3335 Рік тому +42

    we (my great grandfather and forefathers) were Bengali Hindu zamindars in faridpur district of Bangladesh, my grandmother told me that her mother in law told her about how big and grand our haveli was. So sad to see these in this condition. I hope Bangladesh govt takes over these grand houses and converts them into govt office, district office or govt guest house etc. This will preserve them.

    • @TextBookPuncher1
      @TextBookPuncher1 Рік тому +1

      Have u visited bangladesh recently

    • @wisedesi442
      @wisedesi442 Рік тому +1

      @@TextBookPuncher1this is one week old video.

    • @rahuldahoob
      @rahuldahoob Рік тому +3

      If you know the name of the haveli you might see some pictures online. Have just seen ours online today. We're also hindu, no one has lived there since the 1940s..altho one relative was still there for a while after. Now abandoned as a govt buildo😢

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal............

    • @shreyasbhattacharjee4706
      @shreyasbhattacharjee4706 Рік тому +1

      Amar maternal side e faridpur er ancestry! Bagchi Tara.

  • @the_nomadicsoul
    @the_nomadicsoul Рік тому +40

    Loved this episode.. My grandparents fled East Pakistan during 1947, leaving everything behind.

    • @TextBookPuncher1
      @TextBookPuncher1 Рік тому +3

      Do u know which part of east Pakistan they lived in?

    • @the_nomadicsoul
      @the_nomadicsoul Рік тому +10

      @@TextBookPuncher1 my maternal grandparents were from Mymensingh District, and my paternal grandparents were from Faridpur. They literally left all their belongings overnight and fled to save their lives.

    • @TextBookPuncher1
      @TextBookPuncher1 Рік тому +10

      @@the_nomadicsoul I’m so sorry they had to go thru this. My family are Muslims but I personally am not overly religious. I value humanity above all and I want to follow my Bengali way of life over desert Arabic tribal logic

    • @namastescience_India
      @namastescience_India Рік тому +7

      ​@@TextBookPuncher1more people like you with such common sense can make the world peaceful!

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal.........

  • @allyoursrob
    @allyoursrob Рік тому +30

    Mulla Claiming Some Mosques Are 4000 Years Old.....
    Why Don't You Tell After The Hindu Genocide, Hindus Left Bangladesh.....

    • @Sourabh-1920
      @Sourabh-1920 Рік тому +2

      Wrong translation

    • @Sourabh-1920
      @Sourabh-1920 Рік тому +4

      He said 400 Years

    • @winsvinodkumar8815
      @winsvinodkumar8815 4 місяці тому

      @@Sourabh-1920 Muslims and Mosques should NEVER be allowed in Non Muslim countries. This is bound to happen to Hindus, Sikhs, Christians, etc. Its an EVIL religion.

  • @aryaaJyoti
    @aryaaJyoti Рік тому +28

    After watching so many documentaries from The Print, this one touched my heart, may be because for the first time I'm hearing stories from my ancestral land.

  • @desistarktm7270
    @desistarktm7270 Рік тому +50

    *Demographics is Destiny*
    It took 1300 years for Muslims to make up 25% of Hindustan population and snatch 25% of it's land in the name of Pakistan.
    Current rate of Islamization of India is way faster than it was at anytime in the history of India including during time of Mughals. Because nobody had "Family planning" in the old times. Currently only Muslims are not having Family planning.

    • @skeletonmasterkiller
      @skeletonmasterkiller Рік тому +5

      Agree is they donot adopt voluntarily to have only two children we must put very heavy punitive taxes on all those people. If they do not pay bulldoze their house

    • @desistarktm7270
      @desistarktm7270 Рік тому +4

      @@skeletonmasterkiller first we should dismantle the sudosecular ecosystem.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      There are many reasons for this growing number of Muslims, such as
      1.The internet. People are seeking an alternative to materialistic hedonic life style.
      2. Hindus working in the middle east and abroad are exposed to Muslims and mix with them.
      3.'Open House ' in the masjids, where the Muslim scholars answer your queries.
      4.Followers of other faiths don't know anything about their religion avoid being asked about their religion.
      5. Islamophobia. People are searching for the reason for hating Islamic ideology.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому +1

      I am sure you live in your manufactured world

    • @garygeorge-wi7co
      @garygeorge-wi7co Рік тому +5

      It is good they have separated. With Oaisi and the Hijbul, India has so many problems. Imagine if India had 500 million Muslims. Hindus will not be able to breathe there.

  • @KrishnaKaliyuga
    @KrishnaKaliyuga Рік тому +17

    Money is NOT everything
    DEMOGRAPHY IS DESTINY

  • @truecolor313
    @truecolor313 Рік тому +10

    My grandfather has not left .because he was gov doc. He loved his people he was serving in different govt hospitals. Now we stuck with severely polarised fundamental Bangladesh

    • @prasantasen8660
      @prasantasen8660 10 місяців тому +2

      চলে আসুন যদি বাচতে চান।

    • @induchopra3014
      @induchopra3014 4 місяці тому

      Write articles in foreign papers. Write online. Spread your story

  • @Hi5Ripon
    @Hi5Ripon Рік тому +7

    As a Bangladeshi, this was very interesting and hats off to Salahuddin bhai

  • @ShaneCallum
    @ShaneCallum Рік тому +24

    I would reconcile when a Bengali Muslim apologises for Direct Action Day. Everyone feels sorry for Bangladeshi Muslims for 1971. A Punjabi muslim considered Bengali Muslim inferior to them. What did the Bengali Muslim do to Hindus in 1946?
    World needs to stop this woke bs. Reconciliation is a two way process. Starts with acknowledgment and ends with a sorry.

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому +1

      these havelis were built during the british raj because the upoercaste hindus cooperated and collaborated with the british as bootlickers in order to exploit their own people. I'm not sure what there is to see here other than the sad remnants of a corrupted people who sold their souls to foreigners in the Hope's of making a quick buck from the exploitation of their own motherland. It's like selling your own mother to be raped then buying a house with that money.

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      Can you tell me how british boots taste I know your people loved licking them.

    • @sadabmosaddek7091
      @sadabmosaddek7091 Рік тому +4

      I don't think we are sitting here for your reconciliation. There are plenty of people who wish to forge a better future together. It is okay if those who cannot escape the curse of history do not join us. In fact, it is much better if you do not join us in our future. Those who really care will join. Cheers.

    • @ShaneCallum
      @ShaneCallum Рік тому +9

      @@sadabmosaddek7091 Thanks! You proved my point.

    • @pritam1167
      @pritam1167 Рік тому

      ​@@sadabmosaddek7091 Those who don't know the pain of Bangladeshi Hindus only they can forget the History. My ancestors left Bangladesh for India with nothing to save the honour of our family and women.
      You people are coward, and don't want to acknowledge the sufferings of Bengali Hindus.
      Whenever I hear the story of suffering from my grandparents my blood boil with contempt.

  • @raghulsrhv915
    @raghulsrhv915 Рік тому +23

    When demographics change,these are bound to happen

    • @desistarktm7270
      @desistarktm7270 Рік тому +4

      *Demographics is destiny*
      Our ancestors ignored demographic jihad, and that's how Pakistan and Bangladesh are formed by amputation of Bharat Mata.
      While Hindus are busy in Education/social climbing/Gender ideology with less regard towards marriage and raising children, Islam is rapidly taking over India with simple demographics of high birth rates and undocumented immigration. At least 100 towns/villages are becoming Muslim majority in India every year.

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      these havelis were built during the british raj because the upoercaste hindus cooperated and collaborated with the british as bootlickers in order to exploit their own people. I'm not sure what there is to see here other than the sad remnants of a corrupted people who sold their souls to foreigners in the Hope's of making a quick buck from the exploitation of their own motherland. It's like selling your own mother to be raped then buying a house with that money.

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      What do british boots taste like? For me its haram but I know your people will eat anything so perhaps you could tell me how gau Mata tastes when it's been made into a boot and is used to walk over your face.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +2

      PARTITION of BENGAL.
      Bengal was partitioned on the alter of caste. That is a long (hi)story.
      Two castes, Namasudra and Pod, both untouchables embraced Islam and their descendants aggregated, according to E A Gait, in 1901, at nine millions. The Bengali Muslims who wanted homeland were numerous than the Hindus by 79,00,000+ in 1941. Had untouchability not forced the Namasudras and Pods to seek shelter under Islam for dignity and protection against persecution, would the Mulsim ever be a majority in Bengal? So, Pakistan in Eastern Bengal was a Hindu gift to Jinnah indeed.

    • @pritam1167
      @pritam1167 Рік тому

      ​@@nazeerpasha2075 It's your misconception or poor knowledge of history. I studied History of Bengal in detail. The main reason for the increase in Islam in Bengal is forceful religious conversion starting from tyrannous Bakhtiyar Khilji, he destroyed Nalanda University and killed many Buddhists and Hindu pandits.
      Islam protected Namasudras !, What a joke. Most of the persecution of Hindus in the hands of Moslems is suffered by Lower cast Hindus.
      We will never forget Noakhali and Great calcutta killing.

  • @birupakshchoudhury7057
    @birupakshchoudhury7057 10 місяців тому +6

    My grandfather also left Bangladesh in those days.....i have my ancestral house in kamarkhal sylhet...he was a zamindar back then

    • @HarandraChandraNath
      @HarandraChandraNath 6 місяців тому +1

      My Great Grandfather (father of my Grandfather) was too a zamindar
      They left Bangladesh when my Grandfather was 5 yrs....
      My Great Grandfather was a zamindar of Kanaighat Sylhet Bangladesh, they bangladesh 85 years ago

  • @soumimukherjee6748
    @soumimukherjee6748 Рік тому +16

    Exceptional episode…one of these havelis will be my ancestral home…will someday go there and see it first hand…how humans destroy their own creations 😢😢😢😢😢

    • @shenanigans4177
      @shenanigans4177 Рік тому +2

      Similar story, except it was my grandmother's side of the family that had a zamindary in Bangladesh and my grandfather was a calcutta resident. I could never bring myself to visit the lands as it would only make me more anguished. A lost cause is a lost cause. One of my professor had been legally trying to get back their ancestral land since the 80s, he didn't even get back half of the property. For most people its generations of wealth and affluence vanishing in thin air overnight.

    • @modicantspeakenglish
      @modicantspeakenglish Рік тому

      Your grandparents were Muslims?

    • @namastescience_India
      @namastescience_India Рік тому +7

      ​@@modicantspeakenglishwho do you think have to leave Islamist country Bangladesh to save their religion and culture?

    • @soumimukherjee6748
      @soumimukherjee6748 Рік тому +5

      @@modicantspeakenglish wow how intelligent you are..

    • @modicantspeakenglish
      @modicantspeakenglish Рік тому

      @@namastescience_India .. Ghoti's were.

  • @rishavkumar1250
    @rishavkumar1250 Рік тому +30

    My ancestors were also Zamindars in Natore, Bangladesh

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      these havelis were built during the british raj because the upoercaste hindus cooperated and collaborated with the british as bootlickers in order to exploit their own people. I'm not sure what there is to see here other than the sad remnants of a corrupted people who sold their souls to foreigners in the Hope's of making a quick buck from the exploitation of their own motherland. It's like selling your own mother to be raped then buying a house with that money.

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      I bet you love the taste of british boots you coward collaborator.

    • @bishalchakraborty115
      @bishalchakraborty115 Рік тому +9

      same here zamindar in Jaldhup, Sylhet Bangladesh..

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      @@bishalchakraborty115 perhaps you could ask your ancestors how british cock tasted since that is how they were able to get their zamindarships.

    • @monojdey900
      @monojdey900 Рік тому +7

      From sylhet hobiganj

  • @nilaymcj
    @nilaymcj Рік тому +11

    Magnificent documentary Deep da 🙏🙏

  • @sandeepanb2005
    @sandeepanb2005 Рік тому +27

    What a valuable lesson from this! The casteist pride of us Hindu bengalis got blown away by the tides of time and they became refugees in their own land. Lesson for all Hindus that practice casteism or any other form of discrimination.

    • @nishantsharma7832
      @nishantsharma7832 Рік тому +3

      Bengali hindu khatam ho jayenge,tab jaake unke andar kaa SECULARISM aur liberalism kaa keeda niklega.😂😂

    • @desistarktm7270
      @desistarktm7270 Рік тому +1

      *The game of Victimhood*
      1) Indian Muslims: Convert some Dalits to Islam and claim 'We're all oppressed like Dalits.'
      2) Western Muslims: Convert some Black Christians to Islam & Claim "We're all oppressed like Blacks."
      3) Muslim countries: Religious freedom is haram. Once a Muslim always a Muslim.

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      these havelis were built during the british raj because the upoercaste hindus cooperated and collaborated with the british as bootlickers in order to exploit their own people. I'm not sure what there is to see here other than the sad remnants of a corrupted people who sold their souls to foreigners in the Hope's of making a quick buck from the exploitation of their own motherland. It's like selling your own mother to be raped then buying a house with that money.

    • @SB-ur3cu
      @SB-ur3cu Рік тому

      These were predominantly Buddhists and animist tradition which got usurped by the Mohammadan hoards.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      @@vu-pd6uf .. PARTITION of BENGAL.
      Bengal was partitioned on the alter of caste. That is a long (hi)story.
      Two castes, Namasudra and Pod, both untouchables embraced Islam and their descendants aggregated, according to E A Gait, in 1901, at nine millions. The Bengali Muslims who wanted homeland were numerous than the Hindus by 79,00,000+ in 1941. Had untouchability not forced the Namasudras and Pods to seek shelter under Islam for dignity and protection against persecution, would the Mulsim ever be a majority in Bengal? So, Pakistan in Eastern Bengal was a Hindu gift to Jinnah indeed.

  • @arunimamazumder5448
    @arunimamazumder5448 Рік тому +7

    True sir. History is heard all over the world but the voices somewhere remain uncovered.

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal...

  • @jayantachatterjee8827
    @jayantachatterjee8827 Рік тому +24

    This is one of the best documentary by the print

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandal dalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal...

    • @jadabeswarbhattacharjee3537
      @jadabeswarbhattacharjee3537 7 місяців тому

      What way?
      For promoting good Muslim of Bangladesh?

  • @DiabloNemes
    @DiabloNemes Рік тому +4

    After 50 or 60 years
    The print :- Forgotten Hindu Havelis in West Bengal(I don’t know what the future name will be )

  • @ramakotaiahk7075
    @ramakotaiahk7075 Рік тому +22

    I think first time i have seen the Print to look beyond so called Sickular ideology... Respect for you...

    • @vypa-bk1iy
      @vypa-bk1iy Рік тому

      these havelis were built during the british raj because the upoercaste hindus cooperated and collaborated with the british as bootlickers in order to exploit their own people. I'm not sure what there is to see here other than the sad remnants of a corrupted people who sold their souls to foreigners in the Hope's of making a quick buck from the exploitation of their own motherland. It's like selling your own mother to be raped then buying a house with that money.

    • @brahm-ahamasmi
      @brahm-ahamasmi Рік тому +8

      Get well soon. Print is fine. You are sick

    • @uditpatwardhan
      @uditpatwardhan Рік тому +7

      Nothing sick about secularism. It is your mentality that is sick.

    • @ChandranPrema123
      @ChandranPrema123 Рік тому +5

      ​@@uditpatwardhanoh is Pakistan a Secular

    • @ex.hindu.now.atheist
      @ex.hindu.now.atheist Рік тому

      @@ChandranPrema123
      "oh is Pakistan a Secular"
      ========================
      why are you comparing india with the failed state pakistan?

  • @shankho91
    @shankho91 9 місяців тому +1

    The recent generation like me would never understand the pain that the migration caused. I still remember the watery eyes my grandparents had whenever they spoke about their land , their home , their childhood frnds and all that they left behind ! I wish they were still alive so that I could take them their once !

  • @shawanroy34
    @shawanroy34 Рік тому +9

    Thanx to Print for taking up such a fascinating issue of utmost historical and cultural significance...would have liked more if more detailed documentary pertaining to this could have been done...In future would love to have more such videos (of course in detail) on issues related to culture, history and heritage

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal....

  • @Hillofriends
    @Hillofriends 11 місяців тому +3

    West Bengal bangali ra jago abar. Nahole agami dine kintu Same hote choleche West Bengal ao... bangali der ses hoye jete hobe kintu nahole ai bhabei😢😢😢

  • @Satisfying._.Videos-o9q
    @Satisfying._.Videos-o9q Рік тому +3

    Muslim destroyed our home and looted our lands and money 😢

  • @Subash-cn9tk
    @Subash-cn9tk Рік тому +8

    Thanks print for uncovering forgotten history

  • @PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz
    @PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz Рік тому +5

    😢😢😢 i am feeling so sad seeing this. My ancestor left their houses bcs of islamic attacks. We were zamindars from dhaka narayanganj.

    • @mohbubmiah955
      @mohbubmiah955 10 місяців тому

      This is propaganda not Islamic attack. ISLAM is against attack on minorities. It could be other factors. Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him said do not attack minorities and if you do i will go against you Muslims on day of judgement.

  • @subyjerrin5837
    @subyjerrin5837 Рік тому +5

    Deep and humble respects to Salahuddin Sumon.

  • @sadhanbasu383
    @sadhanbasu383 9 місяців тому +4

    1881 র জনগননায় পৣথম মুসলিম সংখ্যা বেশী দেখা যায়। 1757য় ইংরেজ পলাশীর যুদ্ধে জিতলো বটে, কিন্তু তখনো হিন্দুদের পাৣয় সরবানগীন পাৣধান্য ছিল।তখনো পরযনত হিন্দু -মুসলিম সংখ্যা ছিল পাৣয় 60:40 .সামরিকক্ষমতা ও ইসলামের আগাৣসী ভূমিকায় এবং হিন্দুপৣধানদের চূড়ান্ত নিরবুদধীতায় মুসলিমদের হাতে রাজনৈতিক ক্ষমতা থেকে গেছিল।মজা হছছে, মুসলিম শাসকদের পৣধান সহযোগী তথা পরামর্শদাতাদের অধিকাংশই ছিল হিন্দু। এবং মুসলিম শাসকদের নিচের ভাগে অধিকাংশই ছিল হিন্দু রাজা আর জমিদার। ইসলাম পৣথম থেকেই যেনতেন কৣমে পৣসারধরমী ধর্ম। উল্টোদিকে হিন্দু ধরমের "মাতববর তথা তথাকথিত উচ্চ বর্ণের পৣধানরা" অধিকাংশই ছিল বাস্তবে "অশিক্ষিত, অরধ-বর্বর -অপরিনামদরশী" নির্বোধ। এরা অবাস্তব জাতিভেদ, অতিক্ষুদৣ সারথে কথায় কথায় দুর্বলহিন্দুদের সমাজচ্যুত করে ইসলামের দিকে কৣমাগত ঠেলে দিয়ে মুসলিম সংখ্যা বৃদ্ধিতে সরাসরি সহায়তা করে আখেরে নিজেদেরি সংখ্যালঘু করে দিল। মুসলিমরা তার পূর্ণ সুযোগ নিয়ে শেষে সংখ্যাগুরুও হয়ে গেল। দুই ধর্মের সংস্কৃতির পার্থক্যর জন্য যদি কোথাও মুসলিমরাসংখ্যাগুরু থাকে, তবে সেখানে কোন সংখ্যালঘু সমপৣদায়ের লোক ই শান্তিতে বসবাস ই করতে পারবে না। অথচ সংখ্যাগুরু যদি হিন্দুরা হয়, তখন কিন্তু সেখানে মুসলিমসহ যে কোন সংখ্যালঘু সমপৣদায়ের লোক ই নিশচিনত ভাবে থাকতে পারে। এর সত্যতা সবাই জানেন। বাংলাদেশ বা পাকিস্তানে অমুসলিমদের সংখ্যা কৣমশ কমে যাচ্ছে আর বাকি যারা এখনো আছেন, তাদের অধিকাংশই কৣমাগত অত্যাচারের জন্য সুযোগ পেলেই ভারতে চলে আসছেন। আর পাকিস্তান ও বাংলাদেশের মুসলিমরাও তাই চান,কারন তাহলৈ তাদের বিষয়- আশয়, ব্যবসা-চাকরী সব লুঠকরা যাবে। । অথচ ভারতের মুসলিমরা কিন্তু কোনকৣমেই ভারত থেকে চলেযেতে চান না, কারন তারা এখানে অনক ভাল ভাবে আর নিরাপদে আছেন। এখন একথা সত্য, যে হিন্দুদের মধ্যে অতি কুৎসিত জাতিভেদ আছে, যা কোনকৣমেই মানা যায় না। এবং এও সত্য যে মুসলিমসহ অন্যান্যদের মধ্যেও অসংখ্য জাতিভেদ আছে। এদের সবার মধ্যেই নানা বিষয়ে তীব্র মতভেদ আছে।আর এও সত্য যে এদের সবার মধ্যেই আসলে ভালো মানুষের সংখ্যাই বেশী, কিন্তু তাদেরবেশিরভাগী ঝামেলায় যেতে চান না।

    • @HarandraChandraNath
      @HarandraChandraNath 6 місяців тому

      Bhai 1915 er Bangladesh Sylhet, Kanaighat er ganana pawa jaabe niki?

  • @manajitmajumder7092
    @manajitmajumder7092 Рік тому +10

    Good endeavour to videograph the landmark Hindu mansions long abandoned due to religious fanaticism coupled with the attraction of forcibly occupying else's property, wealth, and women at state patronage and greed of so called politicians of that time. Many videos on Punjab and Sindh in Pakistan are available on the UA-cam and addition of Bengal episodes are welcome.

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal

    • @isthiakahsan
      @isthiakahsan 9 місяців тому

      I understand that many wrongdoings were done against Hindus. But don't you think Muslims faced the same during partition?

    • @manajitmajumder7092
      @manajitmajumder7092 9 місяців тому

      @@isthiakahsan yes, in course of criminal rampage hapless people of every communities/faith always suffer, whereas the wily politicians and lumpens have a field day. Short stories of Late Sadat Hassan Manto encapsulated such situations vividly.

  • @dennisvazquez2140
    @dennisvazquez2140 Рік тому +5

    A similar historical story is that after World War II Jews throughout North Africa and the Middle East left their homes and most of their possessions behind and moved to the state of Israel. Now Muslims own those Jewish homes and possessions that were left behind.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      Upper Caste Hindus are the Jews of India.
      Hegemony of Upper caste Hindus.
      If 5% trading class get weight disproportionate to its size of population in elective and/or selective postions, it only is, like it or not, a tribute to caste one belongs.
      In West Bengal, when Jyoti Basu, a Kayasth by caste, was the chief minister, his caste men as MLAs were the largest in strength; second slot went to Brahmans and then Baidyas who together make up the so-called bhadralok, accounting just for 6.5% of population(1931 census)! I did an analysis and found that they grabbed 69% of ministerial berths in Basu's last cabinet. Then Kayasth MLAs numbered 64 and Brahman MLAs 61 and Baidyas 6 in a House of 294. But when Buddhdeb Bhattacharya replaced him he reversed the position and Brahmans got upper hand instead. His council of minister were packed up with 48% Brahmans. Yes, you have heard/read it correct.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      @@nazeerpasha2075
      1200 years of non hindu rule in india and this narrative of casteist oppression needs to stop.
      Listen to the song 'sweet dreams are made of these' from Annie Lennox.
      Get over narratives quickly , sooner or later you may realise yiu are sleeping in the wrong bed.
      By the way, for Jews it was much worser.
      They had their home rule only sporadically and which is why they still wait for the messiah and Zionism which established Israel is not the only identifier of jews.
      Moreover, you do not even take into consideration jews of arabia, persia. I knew at least one from Iran who had to move to USA after long effort to escape, which means they were there all around that region.
      Darkness breeds darkness and makes people suffer.
      The only truth human beings can reasonably be confident of is historical truth and if that is tampered with then one is left with only pliable, color changing serpents.

  • @saikatbabu9842
    @saikatbabu9842 Рік тому +2

    Bangladeshi mu$lims are extremely radicalized , even when compared to Pakistanis !! The oppression and persecution that Hindus have to go through in Bangladesh is unimaginable 😪😪

  • @soumenroy7524
    @soumenroy7524 Рік тому +3

    Salauddin sir er Katha gulo Darun,
    R o sunte icche korchilo.

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal

  • @aneekdebnath6892
    @aneekdebnath6892 5 місяців тому

    both my paternal grandfather and maternal grandfather were bangladeshi brhamin hindus . they migrated to india during the 1947 parition my paternals were from dhaka district and they were pujaris in dhakeshwary mata temple and had a magnificient palace near dhaka and my maternals were from noakhali district of chattagram division , they were roy chowdhury and had a palace to known as chowdhury rajbari, its is present there and under our control we visit bangladesh vai train very frequently . my maternal granmother once told me that they also had another palace named chowdhury rajbari only which was forcefully coverted to a mosque which is now known as chowdhury bari moshjid ..... but there werent able to convert the other palace .... my grandmaaother's brother still live there and is a BCS ( equivalent to UPSC in INDIA ) retired

  • @saptarshi-paul
    @saptarshi-paul 7 місяців тому

    Amazing Story... really unexpected from The Print... Keep going!

  • @Grngrsky
    @Grngrsky 5 місяців тому

    This comment section reminds me of something a friend from Kolkata once asked me: “আচ্ছা, যারা বাংলাদেশ থেকে এসেছে-আমি জানি তারা মনে অনেক দুখ নিএ এসেছে, তাও বোলছি-তারা সবাই বলে জে তারা অনেক বর জমিদার ছিলো। এতটুকু দেশে কেমনে এত জমিদার হয়ে?”

  • @arghyamazumder4368
    @arghyamazumder4368 Рік тому +1

    So Avishek Biswas try to establish that Hindu Zamindars are the reason of persecution of Hindus in the East Pakistan without even mentioning a single time religious bigotry ,,so why they persecute poor (untouchable) bengali Hindus living there today and try to occupy their places of worship .Going by your logic persecution of Kashmiri pundits are justified because they are rich and intellectual and furthermore anyone should be lychned if they are rich.

  • @PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz
    @PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz Рік тому +1

    I feel so sad 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢. We want back our land and havelis. Pls hindu indians help us.

    • @mohbubmiah955
      @mohbubmiah955 10 місяців тому

      You can't now but you can come to Bangladesh we will welcome you .

  • @amaleshmukherjee6389
    @amaleshmukherjee6389 Рік тому

    Dear brother i am following you for more than two years
    My observation is that you are a really humanterian and you are doing a great job
    Long live

  • @AmitMishra-lx7er
    @AmitMishra-lx7er 4 місяці тому +1

    Certainly history never forgots🇮🇳💐💫🌙🪔🌳

  • @Gopal_Paul
    @Gopal_Paul 10 місяців тому +3

    Itihas janen bhaya . Apne o Hindu chilen apne nijer 3 ta generation dekhen . Cause no Bengali wasn't born Muslim

    • @tamimhossaion8496
      @tamimhossaion8496 7 місяців тому

      Same logic apply korle keu born Hindu ki vabe hoi ? Arab manei Muslim na so Bangali manei Hindu na . Hindu dhormo ki kono osukh je baper chilo tai cheler o ase?

    • @contra7631
      @contra7631 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@tamimhossaion8496Somosha jeh kono manush muslim dhormo grohon korleh tarah radical fundamentalist hoye jai.Kintu onno dhormer grohon korleh hoi nah

    • @contra7631
      @contra7631 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@tamimhossaion8496Slavery,killing of apostates,killing non muslims in the name of islam,taking jijiyah/taxes from non muslims,child marriage,treating womens like slaves,treating women like second class citizens with forced parda etc. all are halal.And I literally saw all the references,even big islamic scholars agrees with everything I said.Religion of peace,Am I right guys?😂

    • @tamimhossaion8496
      @tamimhossaion8496 7 місяців тому

      @@contra7631 It is your opinion, not mine . Islam ato kharap toh Islam dhormo global religion ki vabe hoi ? Indonesia akta Dutch colony chilo 350 bosor tar pro o Muslim majority keno ?

    • @tamimhossaion8496
      @tamimhossaion8496 7 місяців тому

      @@contra7631 You just have allegations against Islam nothing else . Your scholars all run in an intellectual debate with Muslims scholars. I can answer all of your allegations but you will still hate Islam . Slavery is bad but slavery still exists today in the form of a rat race . In Islam even slaves become kings , western slavery is different from Islamic slavery . Taking tax from non Muslim, as if India doesn't collect tax from its Muslim citizens .

  • @sushovandas3197
    @sushovandas3197 Рік тому +4

    Salahuddin has to repeatedly clarify that his writing and research are not against a particular religion

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому +1

      Yes, because he knew people like you would be commenting.

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal..,,,,,

    • @PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz
      @PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz Рік тому +2

      ​@@ABO-Destinyppl like you are to defend chuslim

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      @@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz
      Much more than that, I am against people like you and your likes all over the world.

  • @nazeerpasha2075
    @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +4

    The best book to know about the glorious past of Bengal is '' The Rise of Islam and the Bengal Frontier, 1204-1760' by Eaton

    • @everythingerina9379
      @everythingerina9379 Рік тому

      Assalamualakum, do you have any link where I can buy this book?

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      @@everythingerina9379 ...
      Title The Rise of Islam and the Bengal Frontier, 1204-1760
      ACLS Humanities E-Book
      Volume 17 of Comparative Studies on Muslim Societies
      History/Asian studies
      Author Richard M. Eaton
      Edition illustrated
      Publisher University of California Press, 1993
      ISBN 0520205073, 9780520205079
      Length 359 pages
      Subjects History › Asia › General

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      @@everythingerina9379 ... I borrowed it from the library in Raleigh.

    • @rahuldahoob
      @rahuldahoob Рік тому

      Amazon??

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +1

      @@rahuldahoob If you ae in US, you can ask the local librarian , they will get it for you .

  • @KamrulHasan-zq2wc
    @KamrulHasan-zq2wc Рік тому +2

    সুমন ভাইয়ের চ্যানেলের লিংক / হ্যান্ডেল খুজছি? কোন টা? ইন্টারেস্টিং অনেক কন্টেন্ট আছে নিশ্চয়।

    • @optimize5089
      @optimize5089 8 місяців тому

      youtube.com/@salahuddinsumon?si=CHpjb63xt-Nevh1E

  • @garygeorge-wi7co
    @garygeorge-wi7co Рік тому +1

    It will be good for Shekhar Gupta to make a program on why Hindus leave Bangladesh. But he would not dare as that may affect the forthcoming election.

  • @Edward4Plantagenet
    @Edward4Plantagenet Рік тому +4

    Bengal people sounds intellectualy matured.
    But it was Bengal which saw horrible riots, kiIIings time & time again. What they speak is actually far from reality.
    Bengali lsIamists are most distant people from Bangla spurit.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      Bandladeshi people are gentic mixture of coastal dravidian and surrounding tibeto burman people while people of west bengal are of coastal dravidian and some indo aryan an d some tibeto burman people.
      The dravidians are of ancient pre islamic middle eastern people while indo aryans are central asian and tibeto burman east asian. The conflict between african plus middle eastern and indo europeans who later became indo aryans in persia plus mongoloid people is manifested not only in bengal, all over the world, not only in politics, in religion, in culture, language,
      You will find that between arabs and iranians in form of sunni vs shia, between south indians and coastal north indians and gangetic plus Himalayan indians even within hinduism in form of shaivism vs vaishnavism/samana trends/buddhism/jainism etc. Within europe and christianity between western europe based Catholicism and eastern europe based orthodox and Protestantism ,even inside india between south based catholic indians and north east based protestant christianity, between african and east asians, between africa based homo sapiens and eurasian based Neanderthals & denisovans .

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal......

    • @isthiakahsan
      @isthiakahsan 9 місяців тому

      Muslims also suffered during partition. It was not one-sided.

  • @alopal3191
    @alopal3191 Рік тому +2

    Excellent work Deep!

  • @ashishb
    @ashishb 6 місяців тому

    So heartbreaking. so called seculars in India should watch this video.

  • @namankaushik3066
    @namankaushik3066 Рік тому +5

    2:13 Where the hell this guy found Mosque which is 4000 years old. 😂

    • @brahm-ahamasmi
      @brahm-ahamasmi Рік тому +4

      That is seemingly a translation error. I think he is saying 400-500, which the translator would have translated as 400, and then while typing, added another zero
      Nice catch
      Hear him say "charshaw, paanshaw"

    • @shohartoislam7106
      @shohartoislam7106 Рік тому +1

      Salahuddin Sumon said 400-500. Translator f*ed that up.

    • @Itiswhatitis-p7r
      @Itiswhatitis-p7r 10 місяців тому

      He said Charso Pachso means 400-500

  • @pritammandal570
    @pritammandal570 Рік тому +3

    Avishek Sir proud of our College ❤️.

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandal dalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal

  • @ticket2discover
    @ticket2discover Рік тому +1

    Amazing Story line..i feel so much for the families who left these huge properties behind in search of safety for the next generations..So much of sacrifice which the later generations may not ever realise.

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      U are coward race u couldn't kicked out Bangladeshi muslim like Punjabi hjndu and sikh have done

    • @damn738
      @damn738 Рік тому

      @@shreeyanksinghvi7748 how about sikha kicking you in Canada and Australia ohhh proud race they couldn't resist a single invader so called invader ,😂😂😂😂

    • @arijitbagchi1192
      @arijitbagchi1192 Рік тому

      ​​@@shreeyanksinghvi7748Bullshit Nehru is big coward so he made a pact with liakat ali khan for not making full population exchange & hence all bengali hindus were stopped from doing riots. Not bengali hindus you sikhs are coward hence you majorly left Pakistan punjab. There are still 2crore bengali hindus in Bangladesh & 2 crore native bengali muslims in west bengal.

  • @RAMESH-js9lc
    @RAMESH-js9lc 5 місяців тому +1

    ‘Kuch nahi hua‘, gang never bothers about these.
    Their concern is only the Islamist.
    Innocense of the Islamist😢

  • @mischuschubhan3618
    @mischuschubhan3618 Рік тому +1

    Most of the Zamindars were cruel and puppets of British. Most of them left to avoid the vengeance from their own subjects (Proja)

  • @whyhaveaname5963
    @whyhaveaname5963 Рік тому +4

    He said 400. Print said 4000 years. A mosque which is 4000 years old? Prints translator is ...

  • @farhidahmed4473
    @farhidahmed4473 8 місяців тому +1

    Ikhtiyar Bin Khilji wasn't the reason for the spike of Muslim Population in East Bengal. He established the first Muslim Sultanate in whole Bengal and beyond but his sultanate was very short lived it was a Hindu king from Sylhet who reverted to Islam and invested in dawah in East Bengal and build diplomacy with other Muslim sultanates of that time.

    • @contra7631
      @contra7631 7 місяців тому

      Slavery,killing of apostates,killing non muslims in the name of islam,taking jijiyah/taxes from non muslims,child marriage,treating womens like slaves,treating women like second class citizens with forced parda etc. all are halal.And I literally saw all the references,even big islamic scholars agrees with everything I said.Religion of peace,Am I right guys?😂

    • @contra7631
      @contra7631 7 місяців тому

      Purai mitha kotha.

    • @farhidahmed4473
      @farhidahmed4473 7 місяців тому

      @@contra7631 what is mitha here?

  • @tapabratachandra1197
    @tapabratachandra1197 Рік тому +1

    So that means Bangals speak truth. They had so big houses 😮😮😮

  • @fahmidarahman8688
    @fahmidarahman8688 2 місяці тому

    There are muslims who left from India during partition and came to Bangladesh leaving everything behind. There are reciprocal stories where muslim businesses have been slowly pushed out of business by the government in India. This you tube video is about the home fallen into ruins, which is sad. War and politics results in these ruins.

  • @itzmontupatel
    @itzmontupatel Рік тому +4

    Islam is 1400 years old then 4000 year old mosque was something else before, not saying trample but if structure is older then religion

    • @brahm-ahamasmi
      @brahm-ahamasmi Рік тому +3

      That is seemingly a translation error. I think he is saying 400-500, which the translator would have translated as 400, and then while typing, added another zero
      Nice catch
      Hear him say "charshaw, paanshaw"

  • @nareshvasishth4034
    @nareshvasishth4034 Рік тому +1

    I left Lahore (Forced to) 1n 1947
    Thief's and Vandals is what I call them.
    They are doing that even now in India.
    So I left. Hopeless

  • @ReturntoJustice
    @ReturntoJustice Рік тому +1

    He speaks 400 years, You provide subtitle of 4000. Strange.

  • @ekinathkhedekar4248
    @ekinathkhedekar4248 Рік тому +1

    And now the second and third generations of such high income, high caste, rich folks or telling other folks in India that cost is M is very rampant here after coming here.

  • @GARRY348
    @GARRY348 Рік тому +1

    Amar dadu jokhon ai video dekh len kanna korte korte bol len je ai bari te tar choto bela katia che. 😢

  • @KDas-jh2qi
    @KDas-jh2qi 7 місяців тому +1

    Dada akdom thik bolecho amar dadu Bangladesh a thakto kintu akhon India because uni Muslim hota chai chen na

  • @parthamukherjee277
    @parthamukherjee277 Рік тому +5

    Why are havelis of rajasthan or north india not the symbols of oppression.Also this is a thesis given by muslims of Bangladesh that hindus were oppressors just like kashmiri thesis of pandits being more rich and oppressive.Zamindars were both muslims and hindus and most of them were the representatives of british power and oppression.Which was true of Undivided India and Pakistan.While the West Pakistan retained zamindari sysytem but dispossed the hindu zamindars.They oppressed the dalit hindus like matuas despite them and their leader jogendranath mandal supporting the muslim league.Then it was not muslim oppression..that was their rightful grab.

    • @sunitadey876
      @sunitadey876 Рік тому +1

      I agree with your opinion I am also a upper caste Hindu.
      But we have to forgive the actions of Jogendranath Mondal.
      Most of the Hindus that still survive in Bangladesh are lower caste.
      I believe we have to create living space in West Bengal space for our 1 crore brothers and sisters still surving in Bangladesh today.

    • @funcorner253
      @funcorner253 Рік тому +1

      ​@@sunitadey876 প: বাংলার মু**ল্লাদের লাত্থায় বের করো আগে

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal............

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal...................@@sunitadey876

    • @supersaiyans7845
      @supersaiyans7845 Рік тому

      ​@@sunitadey876 Do You Think Is it Possible ?

  • @anirban5262
    @anirban5262 Рік тому

    খুব ভালো লাগলো। সালাহউদ্দিন সুমনের অনেক ভ্রমণ ভিডিও দেখেছি। মালদার আদিনা মসজিদের উপর একটা বিস্তারিত ভিডিও দেখেছি। তবে বাংলাদেশের জমিদার বাড়ির বিষয়ে তিনি যা বলেছেন, তিনি অন্তত যেটুকু স্বীকার করেছেন তার জন্য তিনি অবশ্যই প্রণিধানযোগ্য

  • @ankanghosh5272
    @ankanghosh5272 7 місяців тому

    This houses are the proof of so called peaceful follwers atrocities. And irony is , mostly bengalis who flew from Bangladesh , they became seculer and communist in West Bengal. Pathetic.

  • @sudeeprghosh
    @sudeeprghosh Рік тому +1

    Very bold journalism

  • @alokeprasad9343
    @alokeprasad9343 Рік тому

    I liked this and look forward to seeing several such exploratory videos to understand the historical and cultural power and glory of Bengal , and about people who made it possible and also those who destroyed this rich legacy, driven by hate and fundamentalism.

  • @puggleski6097
    @puggleski6097 Рік тому

    Satyajit Ray has referred to this pre Partition Zamindari system critically , and quite deprecatingly in his opus "Jalsaghar".
    These ruins are the telltale marks of that era, in which undivided India's landed elite joined hands with a foreign mercantile organism to whip their serfs into the bottom rung of the Industrial-Imperial pyramid.
    It is best that these sarcophagii are left to rot, and the jungle reclaim them. Conservatorship and curation of these edifices is akin to popularising a portal to a much darker past, much of it eventually, painstakingly, forgotten but at tremendous cost to Bengalis on both sides of the border.

    • @shreeyanksinghvi7748
      @shreeyanksinghvi7748 Рік тому

      bengali hindu are coward race
      by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
      Noakhali riots
      1950 East Pakistan riots
      1962 Rajshahi massacres
      1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
      Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
      Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
      can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
      this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal

    • @Pinto_555
      @Pinto_555 Рік тому +1

      There were as many Hindu zamindars as were Muslims. Among the 12 Bhuiyans, only 3 were local Hindus. There were no Bengali Muslims among them. Isa Khan, the hero of Bangladesh was none other than a descendant of a converted Rajput from North India. At its inception, the Zamindars were Mughal tax collectors, and Hindus proved to be a convenient choice to do the dirty work for the Turko-Mongol powers that be in Delhi. As more and more locals got converted as an incentive for not paying the jizya, or being on the same side as the ruling class, it more sense to make the Hindus do the tax collection. Defaulting in collection could be disastrous for the Hindu zamindar, under the Bengal Nawabate. A system of punishment in what is known as the 'Baikuntha (heavenly) treatment, a zamindar would be dumped in human excreta. Things were different under British rule, but then that was only the period post-1875 when the Brits found it conducive to recruit local participation in the administration of their occupied region.

    • @arijitbagchi1192
      @arijitbagchi1192 Рік тому

      ​@@Pinto_555Hindus were the major bhuyians you fools

  • @subhashchoudhury5894
    @subhashchoudhury5894 7 місяців тому

    There are a lot of Bouddha vihars scattered in Bangladesh..
    Some pre Bouddha relics can also be found.
    The stone near Shah Sultan Balkhi Mahisawar majar was the worshipping place of Koch tribe.

  • @KKPR533
    @KKPR533 Рік тому +1

    My family also had havelis in Present day Bangladesh

  • @nazeerpasha2075
    @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +1

    Hindu Caste System in Real Life.
    1. Mangira temples in Maharshtra. Sacrificing a 'mang'
    2. Moolakram Tax. The Breast Tax
    3. Human Eugenics. The right of the Brahaman to enjoy the Nair women in South India.
    4. Community Lunch. The upper caste people avoid such lunches.
    5. Temple Entry. Even our present president and his predecesor were not allowed to enter inside of Jagannath temple.

    • @Cham-cg4gc
      @Cham-cg4gc Рік тому +1

      I know sending your mother, wife, sisters and daughters every now and then for HALALA has not been good for your mental health.
      Take rest.

    • @RPS1983
      @RPS1983 Рік тому +3

      Jay Pasmanda Muslim.The Pasmanda Muslims are the sons of the soil of India.They deserve their due recognition.

    • @aryanhassan4659
      @aryanhassan4659 Рік тому

      ​@@RPS1983so are the lowerrr casteee hindooess....you know the upper castee hindooee and muslims are less indians..lol

    • @soumyajitguhathakurta7878
      @soumyajitguhathakurta7878 Рік тому +1

      Madrsachap knowledge

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      @@soumyajitguhathakurta7878 .... And what will you call these statements.
      Andhra University Vice Chancellor G. Nageshwar Rao at the Indian Science Congress on Jan 03, 2019
      He claimed the ‘Dashavtar’, ten avatars of Lord Vishnu, predate the Theory of Evolution given by English naturalist Charles Darwin.
      At a presentation, Mr. Rao said Lord Rama used ‘astras’ and ‘shastras’ (weapons), while Lord Vishnu sent a Sudardhan Chakra to chase targets. After hitting them they would come back. This shows that the science of guided missiles is not new to India and it was present thousands of years ago, the vice chancellor said.
      Mr. Rao also said the Ramayana states that Ravana didn’t just have the Pushpak Viman, but had 24 types of aircraft of varying sizes and capacities. He also had several airports in Lanka and he used these aircraft for different purposes.
      Mr. Rao said that as Darwin stated life started from water the first avatar of Lord Vishnu was also a fish (Matysa).
      For the second avatar, he took shape of a tortoise (Kurma), an amphibious animal, the third avatar was a boar’s head and a human body (Varaha), the fourth was the Narsimha avatar with the head of a lion and human body. He took on the human form of Vaman in the fifth avatar.
      He questioned how Gandhari, the mother of Kauravas, could give birth to a 100 children. “Everybody wonders and nobody believes, how come Gandhari gave birth to 100 children. How is it humanly possible? Can a woman give birth to 100 children in one lifetime,” he asked.
      “But now we believe we have test tube babies. Again Mahabharat says, 100 eggs were fertilised and put into 100 earthen pots. Are they not test tube babies? Stem cell research in this country was present thousands of years ago. Today, we speak about stem cell research.
      “We had hundreds of Kauravas from one mother because of stem cell research and test tube baby technology. It happened a few thousand years ago. This was science in this country,” he said.

  • @parthamukherjee277
    @parthamukherjee277 Рік тому +1

    Salahuddin is just a you tuber do not present him as an expert....these people are superficial and to please indian channels they would modify things ...but catch them in their original they would tell a different story to their own brethren.

  • @arshadamin1710
    @arshadamin1710 8 місяців тому

    It was the Sufis from Yemen who was directly involved in the coming of Islam not the Khaljis.

  • @RkR2001
    @RkR2001 Рік тому +1

    Also This area was under IRON RULE OF THE PAKISTAN ARMY TILL 1971.

  • @santosh_979
    @santosh_979 Рік тому +3

    I want Bangladeshi content but the barrier is language.

  • @joydhromandal8551
    @joydhromandal8551 5 місяців тому

    2:15 its 400-500 year old mosque not 4000 years old !!

  • @subramanyasaib5571
    @subramanyasaib5571 Рік тому +5

    Hope this same forum which claims to be unhypenated made some effort to cover or develop such so called stories of suffering in the home land also around the kashmiri hindus suffering and the mess created in the states of the kerala and WB by the local parties or communal strifes or some other actors in extensive manner rather than going to the some other country !! Hope the agendas or the biases are kept on the sideline while giving the patient hearing and considerations around such sensitive content and it is objectively dealt!!

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      Why are south indians who have lost their oppressive space down there so concerned with kashmiri Hindus, bengali hindus, north indian hindus?
      Looks of people says a lot and that cannot be manufactured fighting with mirror or using white paints, that does not get changed even after learning courtesy.
      Best of luck with your serpentine attempts

  • @nazrulhassan6310
    @nazrulhassan6310 Рік тому +1

    great piece

  • @Shaggy-839two
    @Shaggy-839two 6 місяців тому

    This RSS paid ex bangladeshi should never be allowd tonset foot in bangladesh.

  • @RkR2001
    @RkR2001 Рік тому

    Ek Kahawat hai " KHANDHAR BAYAN KAR RAHE THE Imarat Kitni Majbooth Thi " -- Same way all these Abandoned Buildings stand Testimony to a lot of History! Lot of things would have happened which went UNCHRONICLED😮

  • @travelwithlg
    @travelwithlg Рік тому

    Very good video, keep it up.

  • @sourajitlet6961
    @sourajitlet6961 Рік тому

    Abhisekh has highlighted the truth!!!

  • @xylet
    @xylet 3 місяці тому

    Bengali Hindu Ragbari of Bangladesh.

  • @durgamayi5218
    @durgamayi5218 Рік тому

    Very good brother and very good explanation

  • @jadabeswarbhattacharjee3537
    @jadabeswarbhattacharjee3537 7 місяців тому

    So, The Print is showing good Muslim of Bangladesh.
    But, an anecdotal event doesn't reflect general picture.

  • @kmibrahimkhalilullah1162
    @kmibrahimkhalilullah1162 Рік тому +1

    Jesob muslim India theke bd te eshechilo, tader ki obostha, India r oisob jaigar ki obostha???

    • @arijitbagchi1192
      @arijitbagchi1192 Рік тому

      Oto muslim jomidar jaini west bengal thekey porey je tara bipodey porbey na ei bjp r amoley jodi poschim bonger sorkar poriborton hoi tar kono mane nei.

  • @Sanjay9442
    @Sanjay9442 13 днів тому

    But Bengal was mother of Pakistan - Direct Action Day - happened here. Bengali muslims lead the push for Pakistan. Unfortunately they learnt in 1971 that they had been cheated. Communalism is heavily present in Bengali muslims. So Mr. Suman can talk all humanistic angle that he wants - his countrymen are heavily communal

  • @LOMASH29
    @LOMASH29 Рік тому

    Fst time.print channel has posted sensible thing

  • @timbaktuthankgod2737
    @timbaktuthankgod2737 Рік тому +2

    All Bengalis have BENGALI gene irrespective of Muslim converted ones due to Turk, Kurd & Mughal pressure. Joi Bangla!
    My ancestors have a mansion there which is now the regional passport office of Bangladesh.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +3

      Islam was not forced on the Bengalis. The low-caste people accepted Islam to escape 'caste-system'.

    • @rishavkumar1250
      @rishavkumar1250 Рік тому +1

      ​@@nazeerpasha2075no... no lower caste person accepted islam in bengal....
      Tribal animists in Bangladesh became muslim, they were never hindus

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +2

      @@rishavkumar1250 ... what do you mean by ' animists'?
      Do you mean , those who worship monkeys, elephants, snakes, cows and rats?

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      There is nothing called bengali genes idiot.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      @@rishavkumar1250
      The Tribals are much better lot than most Hindus. And without Tribal land Hindustan will be 50% of the land area it is now.
      And then I am sure you will complain of oppression if only the hindus are living in that Hindustan.

  • @butan9019
    @butan9019 Рік тому

    Great video 👏

  • @AlecO-xh8rt
    @AlecO-xh8rt 11 місяців тому

    It is impossible to have a mosque that is 4000 years old. Islam came into being in the 600s.

  • @santosh_979
    @santosh_979 Рік тому +2

    See the difference Bangladeshi talks in Bangla Indian Bengali talks in English because he want this video should reach every linguistic group of India.

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому +2

      Bangladeshies are very proud of their language. It was the language issue that lead to the creation of Bangladesh.

    • @ABO-Destiny
      @ABO-Destiny Рік тому

      @@nazeerpasha2075
      That dies not mean they should not be able to or willing to communicate in an international form in an internationally accepted language.
      Bangladeshis are moving away from English and that will not be good for them.
      Lack of modern education is what resulted in Muslims of subcontinent suffering till to this day and they are themselves to be blamed for that. Bangladesh is ongoing example of how that can unfold.

    • @garygeorge-wi7co
      @garygeorge-wi7co Рік тому

      @@nazeerpasha2075 Rich Bangladeshis do not send their children to Bengali medium schools. Dhaka itself has more UK curriculum schools than the whole of Eastern India. That is what upsets Professor Salimullah Khan. All love for the language is just a hogwash.

    • @garygeorge-wi7co
      @garygeorge-wi7co Рік тому

      Indian Bengali knows, at least those who have some brain left should know, with English you become an Aamla, (officer) and without English you become a kamla (labourer).

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 Рік тому

      @@garygeorge-wi7co .. English has become a universal language and it has become associated with ' job market'.