Gravitas: Ukraine's defence is crumbling, here's proof
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 чер 2024
- Data shows that Ukraine's defence is crumbling. Russian attacks have become more lethal than ever. Ukraine is shooting down a far smaller proportion of Russian missile attacks than it was earlier in the war.
#russia #ukraine #russiaukrainewar
About Channel:
WION The World is One News examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim is to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to world politics. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalized united world. So for us, the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs and personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Join our WhatsApp Channel: bit.ly/455YOQ0
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for the latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Business:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps: bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
Ukraine intercepted hypersonic missiles but can't intercept S300 missiles
I'm calling shenanigans 🤪
S300 can't shoot down anything LOL. The Ukrainians destroyed 3 S400s in 1 day. Of course Putin announced the new S500 48 hours later just enough time for the paint to dry on the repainted S400s LOL
Why? Defense networks get overloaded. Do you not understand the physics of this or do you just seek opportunity to "call shenanigans?". The later, I'm gonna guess.
The S-300/S-400 parts of this report are hurting my ears. Those are air defence systems, not offensive. Even if Kiev keeps repeating that Ru is using S-300 missiles to attack ground targets, in an effort to blame Ru when Ua missiles hitting apartments instead of targets. (Both are capable of attacking surface targets, but it makes no sense to use them as such when you have hundreds of cruise missiles and drones a month for that.)
@@imrekalman9044 You have to first understand that S300 missiles are over stocked due to their age ones that are no longer viable could be repurposed for ground attack roles. Of course Russia and Ukraine will claim their own mistakes, failing equipment etc were the other side. Repurposed s300 missiles is an old story, and it matches other systems that should have been destroyed over a decade ago due to high failure rates caused by age being repurposed. Russia has no concern about unexploded ordnance and will fire everything at its disposal.
@@Matt-en3mv Old story and just as BS as it is now.
Even a fool knew Ukraine can't beat Russia
So you are saying western media are beyond fool?
Ukraine people died American and Ukraine politicians got rich.
No one ever accused Ukrainians of being smart
Depends on what side of the spectrum the fool was on. One side believed like Russia leadership that Ukraine would collapse in weeks. The other side believed that Russian people would stand up to its government at the losses of their children and their economy collapse. Both fools still have hope that their predictions will still come true in time though the cost is far worse then either predicted.
Wrong!!!!! Russia has lost this war, they are losing 1 solder every 30 seconds, that means by the end of May they will have lost half million, KIA,,wounded, or taken. And are now spending 25% of it's GDP on the military. The west can not afford to let Russia win and the US, UK, EU alone has $200 trillion wealth, Russia now $1.6 Trillon, same size as Italy! Even Chinese military experts agree, Russia can not win!
Met two Aussies who returned home, getting out before they get over run...manpower for Ukraine's defence from volunteers is drying up.
Last information I read Ukraine wasn’t openly taking in Foreign fighters anymore. I understand people want to fight for a purpose but when you know that you will die not because of the enemy but rather your own country politics it’s a hard pill to swallow.
@@Matt-en3mv they still are, most mercs are from South America now.
Thank god the two Aussies got back. 😀😃😄🥰😍
Crazy that Aussies once fought against Nazis now they are fighting for them
Two PTSD victims enjoy
She looks happy Ukraine is losing 🤣
Ukraine isn't losing. Nato, the US military complex, Zelensky, and the EU are losing.
Yeah , good girl she is,😂😂
You want her to cry foolishness of one man, who chooses to drag Ukrainians to early grave.
Because she knows Ukraine is fighting a very baseless and useless war
She is, we all are.
What has happened to 100% interceptions 😂😂
130% rather
In some cases 135% 😂😂
100% interceptions, yet everywhere where battle happening is in ruins and videos how bombs drop on kiev... Funny
@@potatogod3882 Had this channel been reporting that? I'd never seen this reported. Except in comments sections. By Russians. Funny, huh.
That information is only known in Europe and America. 😊
Russia's Security Council is the most powerful organization in Russia, it oversees security in all of Russia. It's different but not a step down for Shoigu.
Here, Reggie, I wrote this for someone else but you seem to beg my question as well.
Approbation, Elevation and Castration. Now he will have responsibility without power. The life of Putin's freshly minted court eunuch is now the 'Gui Man's lot.
Why is there denial of this? His performance was not so great lately. He got... rebranded and removed from military authority. Why is this so effing hard to process?
Good grief, Russia would do well to make more changes and adopt a more dynamic approach if it wishes to actually achieve its stated goals.
Clearly its current approach is not suitable to the desired outcome. Why is it so hard to accept that this is not a reward?
Correct. The Security Council (then under a different name) was created by Yeltsin in the mess left by Gorbachev and around the time a young ex-KGB officer name of Putin showed energy as a politically adept inspector and organizer of personnel structures -- including industrial boards and bureaucracies.
Just as Yeltsin had been known to drop in to see workers, Putin was even better at this, being younger and fitter. We tend to forget that Yeltsin had his first stroke in 1992. But what city lad Putin lacked was knowledge of Russia's greater regions and diversity of languages, ethnicities and sheer extent.
The Security Council has duties in all civil resources, representation, policing, utilities and very large projects. Shoigu was 20 years in the south Siberian vast area stretching from the Caucasus states through the steppes to the east border of Mongolia and China -- notably along the railways on a scale we can scarce imagine. As a post-graduate civil engineer and logistics expert operating 4000km away from Moscow, Shoigu became part of the army because military organization suited the tasks in hand but was never a combat soldier nor pretended to be. This type of organization had been successfully used by the British well into the 20th century.
When Putin became PM he wanted to see how the remarkably able Siberian fared in boring politics so made him the political head of the Moscow region (a sort of mayor) for 4 years then brought him into the cabinet as Defense Minister. That post in Russia is not like in western countries insofar as he is not in actual charge of the military. It is really a 'front man' post linking the PM's office with the president and economists in the PM's office. The Foreign Secretary is closer to the president's office, with duties worldwide.
Shoigu and Gerasimov agreed that there was confusing overlap and were also concerned about efficient spending -- as were Putin and the PM's office. The deputy PM (now Defense Minister) was the key economist the main men talked to and even before the Ivanov corruption hiccup (Shoigu offered his resignation but was refused by the others), Putin spoke about firming up the Security Council ready for various implementations of major developments east and south with the CIS, Turkey, Iran and both south east Asian Russia and the Arctic. The obvious candidate was Shoigu the Siberian and speaker of several Turkic languages and Yakutian.
He will spearhead these developments with teams prepared for ages by the president and PM offices, inclusive of orderly immigration and population of Russian central Asia.
SO, not a demotion or sideways move but actually a vital stage in what Russia has naturally become. Gerasimov is also not a European Russian by a few km as he is from Kazan Tartar stock just a bit west of the Urals (where Asia technically begins).
He is a member of the Security Council but often sends deputies to meetings as he is primarily a career soldier and historian rather busy with Ukraine at present and expanding the army engineering sector for the major works mentioned.
The oft photographed Putin/Shoigu fishing and riding trips are mostly taken at Gerasimov's small cooperative estate (owned by the Tartar people) near the Volga and although he participates he is a bit camera shy and disapproves of hunting wild fauna -- very unlike his father and son. He is more scholarly and more like what Patreus pretended to be.
@@stephenhall3515 So... he got kicked upstairs.
The Rothschild family poked the wrong bear
All that lives has its own nemesis
Interesting mythology. Thought it was the Obama family these days.
The Rothschild didn't start this war, buddy.
The CIA*
@@user-zy3nv1jy1m Nope, Russia invaded Ukraine. End of story.
Why don't you report accurately? Sergey Shoigu was not sacked. He has been promoted to be the Secretary of the Russian National Security Council, a position which is senior to that of the minister of defense, which makes him the top Senior Advisor to Putin. I don't know where are you getting your "sack" story from?
Sorry, in the Anglo-sphere where we speak about these things more accurately, Ole Sergey has gone through the transformative process of Approbation, Elevation and Castration. We also call it being "kicked upstairs." It is what happens to loyal idiots when they let dear leader down one time too many.
That's not a promotion
@@kvdp3806 Just tell the story you want it to be, 🤣
@@mariadamen7886 you are correct and she’s incorrect on the new invasion of Ukraine . The Russian advance has been stopped. Russia has captured between 12 and 14 very small villages
I read that Ukraine is advancing , towards the west :)
My Canadian neighbours are already taking their blue and yellow flags down
Heil Zelensky!!! They munt be so proud of counting Hunka as their own
Only to be replaced with black/green/red/white flag perhaps?
@@ebutuoY_kcuF The pride flag
@@ddaman5764 Trudeau love those. We are the most woke nation on the planet... no wonder Canadian's birth rate is so low. Non-binary is not tolerated, but encourage.
Why mind is still up and proud , i think people like bullies that attack weaker countries
He didn't sack him, he was redeploy to head the Federal Security Council
Yes he sacked him. You just dont get it or dont accept it
A promotion actually and the military needs an economist to deal with the Russian military factories
Sergei Shoigu has not been fired. Actually he has been promoted.
Um. No. But you do you. It is kinda funny to read the opinions of people from society's with no negative feedback function.
@@kvdp3806 Well, yeah, it is funnier seeing the desperation of people from societies that expect, nay demand, negative feedback where there is none.
@@ClaytonOmwanga What now? Your English, it might, could, maybe, use a bit of work. Try that again. Once more, with meaning!
Seriously Clay. That sentence has words but without a context, which you do not provide, it is essentially meaningless.
Did you kick sand while you typed it?
Shoigu was PROMOTED...your report is incorrect
No he wasn't that position supposedly has no power in Russia compared to his last posting its more of a demotion if anything
@@TBantz its a promotion....Secretary of Russia's Security Council is ranked higher than defense minister (this post reports to the security council and secretary is the boss) Shoigu is touted to be the next Putin.
@@TBantz
security council is the political body with HIGHEST AUTHORITY IN RUSSIA.
vladimir putin is THE MOST POWERFULL MAN IN RUSSIA ..not because his a president OF RUSSIA...but because simoultaneously he is the PRESIDENT OF SECURITY COUNCIL aswell.
decisions of security council OVERWRITTE decisions of president of russia.
one day when putin steps down as a PRSIDENT OF RUSSIA he will be able to dictate state policies ( if he wants to ) to a new president ( who ever that might be ) because HE WILL STILL BE PRESIDENT OF SECURITY COUNCIL .
also members of security council are NOT SUBJEC TO ELLECTIONS....they are there pretty much for life .
@@TBantzare you dunce or what 😂😂the man get higher status in office...
He was fired because didn't get Chasiv Yar before victory day 11.5
The offence has failed, now the defence too... The corruption that's not failing in Ukraine.
BS it's failed it has just started
LOL, how many times did I hear Ukraine is losing and Russia is winning these past 2 years? Too many times that's what 🤣
@@MrDosonhai It is losing you would have to be a really low budget IQ not to see that
I thought Russia was using shovels😅😅
China North Korea Iran and India have been sending Russia weapons and ammo for over a year now.
They are melting shovels and using washing machine parts to make advanced missiles
Advanced shovels and washing machines indeed
Shovels are beating NATo weapons. lol pathetic. Russia is not our enemy.
@@kirkclarke7396 😂😂
Shoigu was promoted.
The Rothschild family left the chat
The Rothschilds didn't start this war, buddy.
Went to hell actually😅
Putler left kharkiv 😂😂
there is no one evidence that Ukraine shot down any hypersonic missal 😉
Maybe it was in their delusional dreams.
Interceptor missiles cost alot of money, six months of no funds and no missiles means no shoot downs. Its not rocket science no pun intended.
Left alone O Ukraine
Hindustan and gravitas you are biased in your reporting very very very biased
Disprove her facts, and you might be unbiased.
Just tell us news please and leave your opinions out of it
No money for Ukraine. None of our concern.
So who is telling the truth about this war. Are you saying all the American aid is not helping Ukraine?
Check the Videos on across many other channels. The truth is there for every who has eyes to see. The West will lie to you Mate
Most of that aid stays in the US, goes to the MIC, then there's a corruption cut, what is left ensures the conflict continues, leading to more death and destruction in UA. So yes, that aid is not helping UA at all.
That's what I am asking myself hindustan, gravitas and Scott Ritter stop reporting biased information. Indians support Russia they are birds of the same feathers "BRICS" THE TRUTH SHALL SET US FREE, I WILL NOT SUPPORT A COUNTRY THAT DOES NOT FIGHT SOLDIERS BUT CRUSH CIVILIAN INFRASTRUCTURE. THAT OLD SICK MAN, WANTS TO DICTATE TERMS OF CEASEFIRE SHEER MADNESS HE IS INSANE. SLAVA UKRAINE SLAVA. MYA THE GOD ALMIGHTY HELP AND PROTCT YOU IN THIS DIFFICULT TIME
I'm not going to listen to India proganda
Most of the aid was stolen by the corrupt Ukrainian politicians who run that shithole.
Ukraine needs another game changer - stealth tanks
Shovels
Or advanced washing machine parts
@@kirkclarke7396 🤣How do you know it is not the detergent instead of the washing machine that is causing the problem?
@@AnonymousTraveler-ze2vm Russia is removing foreign detergent from their shops because they say it poses health risks so maybe Ukraine will lose the war because of their own washing detergent, who knows
Fund it by your self and tell everyone about it
Sacked? Stop lying
Misinformation
Good news
Ukrainians should have negotiated this a long time ago. What is the point in wasting so many innocent lives?
Russia should have never invaided a independent sovereign country UKRAIN!
@@JimRogers-oc2jd That's because you really don't understand the reason for the invasion. Why is NATO surrounding Russia against their original agreement? Can you explain?
I doubt Russia will negotiate now, why would they, they are smashing Ukraine.
UKR only lost 31 000 men... according to Zelenski and Gravitas 🤣
The only lost 31,000 men... according to Zelenski and Gravitas!
You are the only person telling truth God help Russia people ❤❤❤
History legends,military summary
@@JJ03330New Atlas and many more!
RUSSIA STARTED THAT WAR NOT UKRAINE, UKRAINE IS ONLY FIGHTING FOR THEIR FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY
You can also hear reporting of this nature from other outlets. Just less gleefully presented.
They keep saying Putin sack the defense minister as if he is now jobless 😂😂😂
He was promoted to
Always listen to the lady in blue😅
Uni-brow truth teller
Shoigu was not sacked and it was known for years that Shoigu wanted to step down from his defence position.
Ukraine's Grand Offensive failed and Russia is only getting more confident, but US leadership is acting like nothing has changed. I saw a report that the F-16's Ukraine wants might still be months and months away from delivery. It almost sounded like they might not be coming. Time to talk peace.
Pretty sure Shoigu was promoted NOT demoted.
Approbation, Elevation and Castration. Now he will have responsibility without power. The life of Putin's freshly minted court eunuch is now the 'Gui Man's lot.
Why is there denial of this? His performance was not so great lately. He got... rebranded and removed from military authority. Why is this so effing hard to process.
Good grief, Russia would do well to make more changes and adopt a more dynamic approach if it wishes to actually achieve its stated goals.
Clearly its current approach is not suitable to the desired outcome.
Shoigu didnt get "sacked," he got promoted. Making "sense" of this is as simple as reporting without western bias.
Why do these hosts take extra long pauses in between sentences?
Ask the teleprompter
Shoigu > defense ministry to security council is in fact a promotion. Shoigu is going to be the next Putin.
Why would anyone want to die in US proxy war on behalf of rich and callous oligarchs is something that is hard to understand.
Actually India had an obligation to help Russia in weapons and strategy since they help India in 1971 Indo pak war but also countered USA,Britain nuclear war ships with theirs and numerous other times they stood for India while Ukraine always stood with west and used every opportunity to hurt India.
how can india help now if russia is the number 1 ally of china, china love india 😂😂😂😂
@@darkempath2594 ... they will have need of each other more than ever to pounce over the ones that overplayed their hands...
This always happens when one is goaded into a war that his blows are not his but from others who take advantage of his sufferings.
Good this war needs to end ...
Strange? Ukraine says that it intercepts 200% of all missiles. Great achievement by Ukraine!!!
That's good humor. 🤣🤣🤣
The building just gets in the way of the missle
Where is this said? I wish to see these lies.
What do you mean? 100 % real missiles and 100% missiles imaginary!?
Russia will take Ukraine in 3 days. Russia is the second strongest military in the world, Ukraine is no match for Russian tanks, Russia has destroyed more tanks than Ukraine possessed despite capturing large depots with tanks. Russia has destroyed all patriot systems, Russia hypersonic missiles cannot be intercepted, Russia takes civilian out of hiding to protect them as Ukrainians fire on their positions. Ukrainians use civilians in Mariupol as human shields by forcing them to take cover in basements. Ukrainian civilians complain that Ukrainian soldiers fire on them once freed by Russian army, shows man wearing camouflage standing near armored Russian military where he was fired on. Russia protect civilians by maintaining civilian corridor to Russian controlled territory open while leveling cities.
Is crumbing? Sad. Stop the killing and end this war. Who benefits? Where have all the fathers gone?😢
But they said that they are intercepting all the missiles from Russia.
100% of 46%?
😂😂😂😂@@crapphone7744
U will say anything to help Russia
Shoigu was asked to fly to Saint Petersburg to attend an important meeting, he said he'll prefer to go there by car (PRG-proof one)
My man is smart
The tittle should be..
EVIL gets defeated by gods wrath
Ukraine's defense was trembling even before the war started 2 years ago
Shoigu was not demoted but effectively promoted. The secretary of the NSC is more powerful than Defence Minister.
For the last 3 years, you keep saying Ukraine is failing .......
Putin raises Shoigu
meanwhile ukrobots: AAA Shoigu fired it's a collapse
Like I'm going to listen to a script written by Russia?
This reporter is completely wrong on shoigu he was promoted into the administration of the security council of Russia
Russia's offence is grinding...to a halt.
Ukraine is done son
So where the hell is other german and european systems, this sounds a bit sad, it seems the US patriot is the only reliable systems but very scarce with the batteries.
What are you talking about? Shoygu got a raise. He is now the chief of security consul of the RussianFederation
Russia may be doing well but that doesn't mean that it will win we can't tell who is going to win until the end of the war. just look at history sometimes the victors aren't the ones with the biggest armies but the ones who were determent to win at any cost.
A good leader know when to accept defeat
Shoigu wan't demoted, he was actually promoted.
I hope there is one day peace all around the world! This happens only if the world powers stop creating business opportunities out of wars.
Hundred billion dollars and they’re failing?
They been promised 60 b. So far received maybe 400 mil.
Would be great to hear the truth from her one time
I knew it. Russia wasn't using they best weapons in the start of the war 🤔
@1leckiedon The Russians appeared measured yet resolute from the outset.
That's what was said about Russian tanks. Now they are using atv's. 😂😅😂😅😅
@thisguyshorty3554 russia won't lose this war. An im not seen ukraine winning either
@@og.bowiiii Russia shouldn't loose to a bunch of none military experienced citizens. But 2 yrs and Ukraine is still it's own country.
Russia has a history of winning many major wars besides this lil squabble with Ukraine. What was Ukraine thinking to poke the Bear?
In any other country being the person responsible for the day to day running of a war were you were losing 1k men a day would have got you sacked a long time ago.
God Almighty Father protect Ukraine military Soldiers Amen 🇺🇦🇺🇦🙏🙏🙏
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Soon Foolinsky : My kingdom (corrupted) for a horse !! (Shakespeare) galloping to his mansion somewhere in the world
The supposed "Wonder Boy" of Western Europe may soon become the "Whipping Boy" of Eastern Europe. 🤣
Now it seems like Ukraine is holding just fine
Send UK Challenger Tanks. Like Proffesor Clark once said, it's a game changer.
Russia ran out of weapons 2 years ago, so how is Ukrine not winning 🙄 🤔.
Good. Analysis based on facts and not emotion.
Thank you for this exceptional journalism
Wow. Molly is lovely 😍
Mmmmmmm
The end of the western hegemony 😅
Now think where did that US Aid package gone 😂
This is what WION channel was saying (with an air of utmost confidence) in February of 2022 "Kyiv is going to fall and taken over by Russian army very soon ... it is not the matter of if, it is the matter of when..."
Sergei Shoigu was not sacked but promoted to the security council… stop the lies
Could the 'reason' that confuses you be that that a man has been promoted after 11 years of good service?
2:20 who TF would intercept a missile that spirals when taking off 😂
Shoigu got a promotion to a cake position... and the Economist is going to make their "War Machine" even more efficient than it is now... Russia is going to save HUGE money on an already winning war... He's going to make their machine HUM~!
Did anyone actually believe Ukraine could win? This war was over before it started.
Gr8 Delivecennce!
One of the channels I like to watch because it's telling the TRUTH!
So many war freaks in this world now.
Οur regards to Mr Boris Johnson ....
Shoigu wasn't demoted. Putin raised him to higher position.
Ukraine is been loosing all the time but these news media talking nonsense everyday
A 2 day SMO is going on 3 yrs. Russia can't be that advanced in their arsenal. 😂😅😂😅
Finally. Unbiased news
😅 What will India do when Russia Takes over their government...
Shoigu was promoted. Get your facts straight.
Hey lady thanks for reporting from the FRONTLINE!
Right👌
The word is YEAR and not YER 😂😂
Doesn't look good for Ukr
Not at all, Thanks to Johnson, Stoltenberg,Macron(pedofillia victim) Ursula, Soltz ,Biden,and many more morally bankrupt vultures ,😢
interestingly most people around the world already know it except U$UK regime sponsoring and funding notsee UKR.
Yookrane should become apart of Russia
gotta love zelenski's gold plated throne... 😅
Losing side hasnt resorted to meatwave attacks. Makes me wonder who is actually 'losing' the most??
Zelenski & Biden VS Putin & Xi - the last two are true and equal friends! I bet Zelenski will never go to a concert with his master! 😂
СЛАВА РОССИИ !
For the moment
Uuurrahhh💪💪💪
Theres no glory for invading a peaceful country unprovoked..
Theres no GLORY for attacking a peaceful country ..unprovoked! Thats genocide.
...But there's a reason for ukraine to threat Russia with biological labs ruled by Americans ( Hubter Biden with over 3t labs...What a coincidence!!!) and to develop threatening germs and batteries aimed at Russian neighboring lands, and present a military threat wirh NATO and other western gangs...
Speak reason not freezing dude!
Thank you for factual reporting.
However tragic for both sides.
The U.S. neocon régime’s proxy regime is triggering their downfall.
Paris