I'd rather see that money go to sending robots. Earth needs more investment, and speeding up the robotics industry could help us make life on Earth much better.
The race to the moon forced the development of technologies that benefit us all today. I think Elon is looking to repeat that and force the development of better rockets, life support systems and a lot of automated technologies. Imagine if he were to combine all of his knowledge and companies to work on this. Neuralink chips embedded in astronauts to work efficiently with various technologies such as Optimus robots. Boring company tunnelling machines to create underground habitats, storage facilities and perhaps mining capabilities. The robots themselves would have to establish the foundation of the colony before humans could go there. Have a Starlink-like constellation around Mars to provide communication and maybe navigation and weather tracking. All of these technologies would have to be advanced enough to pull this off but in the process of improving them, they become much better, faster down here on Earth. You need a goal to really make advances, otherwise progress is slow, in tiny increments. Just look at SpaceX, Tesla, Starlink, etc. People are not used to it and so are skeptical towards the ideas, but he makes things happen and improves on them. But perhaps more importantly, he generally creates technology at the lowest cost possible. So you can't look at what it cost NASA to do something and say that is what it will cost SpaceX. Can you say Artemis? So if Elon creates the technologies that would actually keep people alive on an inhospitable planet, I imagine that just might be what saves us here on Earth because we are just so hopeless in changing our ways. It looks like we can't stop wrecking our environment even though we know we are doing it. We're also one big solar flare away, among other things, from losing our atmosphere. If Elon has a plan and the will, I think he should just do it. It's easy to be a nay-sayer. Many of them thought that automobiles would never replace the horse. Reusable rockets on the cheap, laughable. Electric cars are for golf courses. Right. Sorry for getting carried away but thanks for the opportunity.
Brian, I think there are much WORSE things to waste one's money on, no? Go Elon just dont expect taxpayers to divert THEIR money to such a cause.. Otherwise the technological spin offs alone will be globally beneficial to our species, AND our shared future..Peace.
Im a person of the urban neighborhoods(ghettos). And im not that educated , on paper. With degrees & so fourth. But , i love this kind of knowledge. Tyson, has been my new guy i follow. He's the best. This was a great segment.
your "great guy" once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..." neil is a horrible person. and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine" if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere have a nice day
@@subwaybe2008 This life changing 🚼 information is here for us all... your social status is irrelevant... Whether we grasp this information or not... We're all on the same playing field 🎮 pass your knowledge 2 willing accepting humans 👤👤👥
The great Dr. Tyson is a genius. He once commented on something after he said that made so much sense. He claimed that Musk among other say we need to reconstruct life on Mars to save humanity. Degrasee says that if you have the technology. teraform Mars. Why if we do why wouldn't you reteraform earth. Easier & why couldn't we do it if we have technology teraform . Make sense . Why find another planet.
Neil, I was working at Western Electric in 1977, and in my plant, engineers were walking around with "ginned-up" WW2 walky-talkies testing cell phones... saying, I kidd you not: " CAN YOU HEAR ME NOW!"....
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/yt
@@DrBrianKeating’just’ it being non pretentious, and interesting, informative colloquial discussion about the stuff we’re all like talking, hearing and learning about. No challenge or torture for brain and ears…as if ur listening into a good conversation a ‘table next to you’…capisci?😉
neil once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..." neil is a horrible person. and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine" if you still think neil is a respectful guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere have a nice day
Completely off topic, but I just read this article that describes a paper that proposes that dark energy doesn't exist, and that the accelerated expansion of the universe is an illusion caused by gravity. Also that the expansion is not necessarily uniform. It was fascinating and I was wondering if you've heard anything about it, if its worth thinking about at all, and if true, what would the cocnclusions could we draw?
Thanks for this revelation and at the very least, it does sound compellingly interesting. And although I’m not a cynic, I’m completely skeptical of this paper.
Sounds interesting indeed. I think I know where they are headed with such a title, but let me give you a more intuitive example of how observed cosmic redshift of furthest galaxies can indeed be a mere optical illusion: Suppose we could shrink ourselves to subatomic sizes and stand on the core of an atom looking outward. What would we see? Well, we would have the quantized electron orbits around the core high above us and for as far as the eye could see. As per known atomic setup, these electron orbits are measured in eV’s. Very high energy orbits close by, quickly dropping off the further out the atom bound electrons are from the core. We also know there is motion between these electron orbits in so called ‘quantum leaps’ where electrons move instantaneous between the different eV orbits, under the emittance of a photon. The photon carries the energy of the eV potential difference between the two electron orbits involved. That means that motion close by the atomic core involves the emittance of very high energy (blueish) photons, whereas motion far out will cause low energy (reddish) photons to be emitted. So how would our eyes now see these motions, from the perspective of the atomic core? Well, we would say the motion of furthest electrons is obviously redshifted and we would WRONGLY assume this was a redshift caused by apparent higher speed of outer electrons. WRONG! The speed is no different, we only see a ‘redshift’ because there is motion in the E field further away. So now back to our macroworld again. We would experience incoming cosmic photons that cross the fabric of our galaxy as redshifted if they similarly cross a strong E potential relative to the core of our galaxy. What constitutes as further distance from our ST perspective, is represented as redshifted from and ‘energy as the grid’ perspective. I may remind all of you that both voyager spacecraft did encounter an unexpected stark increase of such galactic E field charge as they crossed the heliosphere. So there IS and observed element of E field drop off towards the outer galactic border. As such the subatomic setup appears to re-iterate in the galactic fabric setup, which would perfectly explain cosmic redshift without the need for an external doppler effect, for which illusive dark energy was invented by humans.
Niel has a point about animals- we have especially learned so much about wildlife after the smart phone has recorded problem solving animals, but a great show as usual from Brian.
he is wrong about it. and he once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..." neil is a horrible person. and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine" if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere have a nice day
Thanks for watching! Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
neil is a douche he once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..." neil is a horrible person. and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine" if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere have a nice day
When i think I'm smart, i remember i must always be humble. And think there is always someone who is smarter. Pride only gets you in trouble. To really understand and learn, and go far in life, you need to be both humble and driven.
You have the best science podcast, Brian. I really enjoy the thought provoking questions, and all the research you do prior to your conversations with others. You know how to get to the gold.
I'm glad you enjoy it! Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
@ The thing I enjoyed most was the fraternité. I know you and Neil don't agree with everything, but you saw a colleague being thrown to the wolves and you stepped in and had him on your show to talk about a book he's excited about. You engaged with that excitement, and I could see how much that meant to Neil. A lot of the time you have big names in science on, and because of your interest and empathy toward them, they really want to share their ideas and work with you and the audience. It makes me think how we're all kids hoping someone will ask us about the things we're interested in. You do that for your community, and for the larger community of people who watch and listen to your show. It's heartwarming. You're a good mensch.
neil is a douche he once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..." neil is a horrible person. and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine" if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere have a nice day
Wow what a great podcast to listen to early Christmas morning;like a wonderful unexpected present to open! Just an aside: I was a Liberal Arts Major in French Language and Literature. One Christmas party my husband and I went to one of the sons of this family was sitting there and introduced to us and said he is at Cern??? I at the time didn't know what that was only a connection that it was bordering FRANCE! I couldn't wait to ask him about speaking French. Well long short we made a connection! I immediately wanted to now all about the Higgs! He was there that July when they discovered it at Cern. He is a scholar and graduated from University of Pennsylvania post graduate doctorate program and I am always fascinated by this topic and also about Physics which is way out of my league. I admire and thank you Doctor Brian Keating!
@jamescorn9278 I tried that, but it sounds like a retard bloke speaking, no doubt like yourself. Hope you aint got kids. Some people shouldn't be able to breed, don't you agree imbecile?
I am a fan of both of you! Dr. Tyson was animated and excited but i loved some of his points. I liked the magpie example and though WWI and &WWII examples were sad, it put into perspective our current societal conflicts vs the prior century's. Dr. Keating, I really appreciated your graceful and patient style of interviewing as it was in contrast to Dr. Tyson's overtly eager response. Even though you guys did not cover the cosmos in great detail, I appreciated the wide topics and knowledge that both of you imparted in this podcast. definitely something to ruminate about. Thank you as always @DrBrianKeating!
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/yt
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
I like Neil…I don’t have a degree in science like Neil…so I don’t think I wanna hate on someone who is assessing life more than me, if all I’m doing is criticizing him and not compiling info and documenting it, like he is…
Niel: “There are two kinds of people in the world: those who divide everyone into two kinds of people, and those who don’t.” I cackled! He’s just brilliant 😂
@ScrewdriverTUNING Agnosticism is likely the balanced, middle ground allowing for pure reasoning, the best humanity can do, as well as the continuing exploration of spirituality, God/god if you will, which no concept seems to fully captured yet, except for those who are overly sure.
Wow. Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
Theres a universe where ND Tyson is a hardworking physicist...ONLY!!! If you dont work in his field, invisible. Im glad im in the universe im in today! Thx ND! And Thanmks BK for persisting and increasing your reach and ability to teach. Perhaps you and Mr. Nobel had plans outside "your" expectations?!
Neil is just saying that if we have the technology & resources to make Mars liveable, then we have the technology & resources to make Earth liveable-- much more quickly and at a fraction of the cost.
Any scientist who doesn't want to double their sample size for studying how to make planets liveable isn't worth listening to. Nof1 experiments are worthless if you have the option of an Nof2 experiment.
Really enjoy this. My first listen. Just a suggestion. In your ad to subscribe you say” subscribe to me and the channel” instead of the channel and me “ to us” later you say me and Neil are good communicators which is very true but it should be “Neil and I” are good communicators. “We” Thank you for one of my favorite podcasts!!
the Concept of Life, is a Blink of an Eye... yet, nobody knows if we live or we die, after death? accomplishments are not the ultimate goal of humanity.... Love is!
I'd be available to talk about this if you are interested. I also was friends with Edgar Mitchell, met him at his house, as he was an adviser on our KESE Project. I held a small moon rock in my hands!! So cool!
The first Europeans to the New World, was *Columbus?* And here i thought that was *already debunked,* and that it had been proven that, The *Vikings, were the first* to the New World? (The people that crossed over on the Beringia Land Bridge excepted of course), are *Vikings* not considered to be European?
As a person alive during the 60's, yes I would love for StarTrek to be here now. But we need to save this planet before we try to terrafarm Mars. Musk forgets that what wants is Startrek but remember that in the story, this planet's problems have largely been solved.
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
2π β = ((sqrt(2)×10^-33 eV)×(c/(π×10^51 m/s^2))) is the equation for quanta of action for geometry to encircle the energy of a photon with a wavelength the size of the visible Universe and t_BB. The time after the Big Bang was a first day start, in theory.
47:00 Last time at Christmas lunch and discussion on science, religion, and creation at Freshbrook church Swindon, Wiltshire. The Big Bang, one member replied ref Genesis, and God said,' Let there be light'. Does he follow evolution? Open book for me on my Agnostic journey
A fascinating conversation. Neil deGrasse Tyson is knowledgeable and very entertaining. Amazing insights, enlightening facts, and good fun. We're so lucky to have such conversations out there for everyone to enjoy and learn from. Every time Neil deGrasse Tyson speaks, I learn so much about our world and the universe. Just marvelous. Thank you for inviting Neil for this excellent discussion. Looking forward to the next visit.
Thanks! It was a blast.💥 Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
Fun fact. Electric cars save on polution, in theory, the problem is most people charge those cars at night when we burn fossil fuels, not so environmentally friendly as people think, today. I am sure we will improve through science and as a rev head, I can tell you one thing. With the potential hourse power and tourch , cars will be a lot more fun
"The singularity is where God divides by zero." Great! I always wondered what happened to the inverse square laws when r approaches zero. Does the force approach infinity?
I really think that we should focus on what it is that holds the earth together. What is in the centre that is so powerful that it attracts matter into an almost perfect ball, that is alive! All we know is that matter is very strong. What if a tiny minute piece of that hole is not strong enough to maintain its position in the said black hole and fly off in its own orbit, amassing space matter, eventually forming an orb.?
We don't know what consciousness is, we don't know what space is, we don't know what matter is, we don't know what energy is, we don't know what radiation really is, we don't know where life came from, we don't really know why gravity exists ... and a thousand other things. A lot of mystery left !
A self-sustaining city on Mars with a million people is not feasible from an economic standpoint. The only individuals who could financially support this are billionaires. For them, a trip to Mars might be an exotic experience, but it is unlikely they would want to stay there permanently or for an extended period. No matter how luxurious it is, you’re still a bird in a cage. For ordinary people, Musk will never be able to make this profitable. A more logical scenario is an expensive hotel, complemented by some research facilities and mining operations. This would mean the focus would primarily be on robots, with only a potential hotel catering to short-term stays for humans. Mining and the exploration of our solar system will primarily be carried out by drones and robots. This is economically viable, involves much lower insurance costs, and allows for 24/7 efficiency.
Not even wrong about going to Mars. Of course there's an economic reward from going to Mars. It's the continuing transfer of wealth from taxpayers TO ELON. It doesn't matter if everybody else loses, as long as Elon wins.
Neil, is it possible for you to talk with Buzz about his concept for a Earth-Mars-Earth NON-STOP ORBIT for shuttling people and hardware to/from Mars before it's too late... I know he has some dementia, but may be he can still talk about it. I had several Conversations with him about that, and it makes a LOT more sense than Elon's BFRs...
I will rewatch a movie with the subtitles on and I notice a word I've never seen before. My brain has ignored hearing these words before if I didn't recognize them. But when I see them in writing it stands out for some reason. I will figure out the meaning in context of the conversation in the movie or I will go look up the word. I know I've heard them before as it's in a movie I've seen more than once before.
1:29:34 “God doesn’t divide by zero!” So does Neil believe or not believe in SINGULARITIES? The intro kinda suggests yes but the whole explanation sorta suggests no.
1h:20min. Argument about a trans woman fighting a man: the tw is a man who maybe didn't make the transition yet and even if he did it he should not fight neither with women or men with other trans women. The same thing should/has to be the other way around: trans man(woman who transition to man) should fight /compete with other tm. They have to make categories for them but not put them in the same category with men or women. Do not wanna say about the other ones who they believe that they are animals (sorry couldn't find the right word). I tried my best to not upset anyone
_"I_ _don't_ _care_ _who_ _you_ _vote_ _for."_ - Tyson at 1:12:20 *what?* Do scientists OR educators OR intellectuals OR space enthusiasts not want funding??? VOTE INDEPENDENT, FOR THE DAMNED SCIENCE PARTY. YES, BE POLITICAL *FOR SCIENCE*.
Damn, seeing him get so frustrated over people saying Science hasn't advanced is nice. Keep antagonizing him the next time bring up the same thing lmao.
I really appreciate your efforts! A bit off-topic, but I wanted to ask: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). What's the best way to send them to Binance?
![Yann LeCun: AI Doomsday Fears Are Overblown [Ep. 473]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/u7e0YUcZYbE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Yann LeCun: AI Doomsday Fears Are Overblown [Ep. 473]](/img/tr.png)
What do you think - is Elon wasting his money on Mars🔴?
*Join my mailing list for your chance to win a real meteorite* 💥 BrianKeating.com/yt
I'd rather see that money go to sending robots. Earth needs more investment, and speeding up the robotics industry could help us make life on Earth much better.
@ Thanks
Some people would prefer him to be on Mars wasting his money. 🤣
The race to the moon forced the development of technologies that benefit us all today. I think Elon is looking to repeat that and force the development of better rockets, life support systems and a lot of automated technologies. Imagine if he were to combine all of his knowledge and companies to work on this. Neuralink chips embedded in astronauts to work efficiently with various technologies such as Optimus robots. Boring company tunnelling machines to create underground habitats, storage facilities and perhaps mining capabilities. The robots themselves would have to establish the foundation of the colony before humans could go there. Have a Starlink-like constellation around Mars to provide communication and maybe navigation and weather tracking. All of these technologies would have to be advanced enough to pull this off but in the process of improving them, they become much better, faster down here on Earth. You need a goal to really make advances, otherwise progress is slow, in tiny increments. Just look at SpaceX, Tesla, Starlink, etc. People are not used to it and so are skeptical towards the ideas, but he makes things happen and improves on them. But perhaps more importantly, he generally creates technology at the lowest cost possible. So you can't look at what it cost NASA to do something and say that is what it will cost SpaceX. Can you say Artemis? So if Elon creates the technologies that would actually keep people alive on an inhospitable planet, I imagine that just might be what saves us here on Earth because we are just so hopeless in changing our ways. It looks like we can't stop wrecking our environment even though we know we are doing it. We're also one big solar flare away, among other things, from losing our atmosphere. If Elon has a plan and the will, I think he should just do it. It's easy to be a nay-sayer. Many of them thought that automobiles would never replace the horse. Reusable rockets on the cheap, laughable. Electric cars are for golf courses. Right. Sorry for getting carried away but thanks for the opportunity.
Brian, I think there are much WORSE things to waste one's money on, no? Go Elon just dont expect taxpayers to divert THEIR money to such a cause.. Otherwise the technological spin offs alone will be globally beneficial to our species, AND our shared future..Peace.
Im a person of the urban neighborhoods(ghettos). And im not that educated , on paper. With degrees & so fourth. But , i love this kind of knowledge. Tyson, has been my new guy i follow. He's the best. This was a great segment.
glad you're here... stay in touch with me and my guests join my list briankeating.com/yt it's free and fabulous
your "great guy" once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..."
neil is a horrible person.
and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports
the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine"
if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere
have a nice day
@@subwaybe2008 This life changing 🚼 information is here for us all... your social status is irrelevant... Whether we grasp this information or not... We're all on the same playing field 🎮 pass your knowledge 2 willing accepting humans 👤👤👥
@@subwaybe2008 ♥️
The great Dr. Tyson is a genius. He once commented on something after he said that made so much sense. He claimed that Musk among other say we need to reconstruct life on Mars to save humanity. Degrasee says that if you have the technology. teraform Mars. Why if we do why wouldn't you reteraform earth. Easier & why couldn't we do it if we have technology teraform . Make sense . Why find another planet.
Thanks for asking my question Dr. Keating! Thanks also Dr. Tyson for your answer!
Great episode pal , happy holidays
Thanks brother 🙏
Thanks Brian. It was a real treat listening to both you and Neil. Peace and love always, Calvin.
It's always a pleasure, Calvin. Thanks for watching!
Neil, I was working at Western Electric in 1977, and in my plant, engineers were walking around with "ginned-up" WW2 walky-talkies testing cell phones... saying, I kidd you not: " CAN YOU HEAR ME NOW!"....
Thanks 4 having NdGT on! It’s about keeping an objective approach and staying focused on the matter not just the person! Respect and appreciation!
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/yt
@@DrBrianKeating’just’ it being non pretentious, and interesting, informative colloquial discussion about the stuff we’re all like talking, hearing and learning about. No challenge or torture for brain and ears…as if ur listening into a good conversation a ‘table next to you’…capisci?😉
neil once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..."
neil is a horrible person.
and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports
the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine"
if you still think neil is a respectful guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere
have a nice day
Completely off topic, but I just read this article that describes a paper that proposes that dark energy doesn't exist, and that the accelerated expansion of the universe is an illusion caused by gravity. Also that the expansion is not necessarily uniform. It was fascinating and I was wondering if you've heard anything about it, if its worth thinking about at all, and if true, what would the cocnclusions could we draw?
Video on this coming soon Thanks
Thanks for this revelation and at the very least, it does sound compellingly interesting.
And although I’m not a cynic, I’m completely skeptical of this paper.
@@DrBrianKeatingGreat and much appreciated. Maybe you can put together a panel of active in the field cosmologist and astrophysicist.
Sounds interesting indeed. I think I know where they are headed with such a title, but let me give you a more intuitive example of how observed cosmic redshift of furthest galaxies can indeed be a mere optical illusion: Suppose we could shrink ourselves to subatomic sizes and stand on the core of an atom looking outward. What would we see? Well, we would have the quantized electron orbits around the core high above us and for as far as the eye could see. As per known atomic setup, these electron orbits are measured in eV’s. Very high energy orbits close by, quickly dropping off the further out the atom bound electrons are from the core. We also know there is motion between these electron orbits in so called ‘quantum leaps’ where electrons move instantaneous between the different eV orbits, under the emittance of a photon. The photon carries the energy of the eV potential difference between the two electron orbits involved. That means that motion close by the atomic core involves the emittance of very high energy (blueish) photons, whereas motion far out will cause low energy (reddish) photons to be emitted. So how would our eyes now see these motions, from the perspective of the atomic core? Well, we would say the motion of furthest electrons is obviously redshifted and we would WRONGLY assume this was a redshift caused by apparent higher speed of outer electrons. WRONG! The speed is no different, we only see a ‘redshift’ because there is motion in the E field further away.
So now back to our macroworld again. We would experience incoming cosmic photons that cross the fabric of our galaxy as redshifted if they similarly cross a strong E potential relative to the core of our galaxy. What constitutes as further distance from our ST perspective, is represented as redshifted from and ‘energy as the grid’ perspective. I may remind all of you that both voyager spacecraft did encounter an unexpected stark increase of such galactic E field charge as they crossed the heliosphere. So there IS and observed element of E field drop off towards the outer galactic border. As such the subatomic setup appears to re-iterate in the galactic fabric setup, which would perfectly explain cosmic redshift without the need for an external doppler effect, for which illusive dark energy was invented by humans.
❤❤❤❤!!!!@RWin-fp5jn
Niel has a point about animals- we have especially learned so much about wildlife after the smart phone has recorded problem solving animals, but a great show as usual from Brian.
Thanks Neil for explaing your hormone idea. Definently needed carification.
he is wrong about it.
and he once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..."
neil is a horrible person.
and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports
the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine"
if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere
have a nice day
Brian's right. Some think they sound smart if they express pessimism.
@@fred_2021 I doubt that
I wish to god we could have Elon and Neil get into it it would get millions of views and neither would turn down the interview
Please try to make that happen Brian
`Elon has no Physics education at all. His only degree is in English and he has very little knowledge of hard science.
Always love a NDT discussion! Very thoughtful insights in science and other frontiers in life! Love learning from this guy!
Thanks for watching! Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
neil is a douche
he once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..."
neil is a horrible person.
and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports
the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine"
if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere
have a nice day
I give you a 10 outta 9
Gravity on Mars is not what we developed with. It is not our home.
Brilliant discussion by two great thinkers. Thank you.
When i think I'm smart, i remember i must always be humble. And think there is always someone who is smarter. Pride only gets you in trouble. To really understand and learn, and go far in life, you need to be both humble and driven.
You have the best science podcast, Brian. I really enjoy the thought provoking questions, and all the research you do prior to your conversations with others. You know how to get to the gold.
I'm glad you enjoy it! Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
@ The thing I enjoyed most was the fraternité. I know you and Neil don't agree with everything, but you saw a colleague being thrown to the wolves and you stepped in and had him on your show to talk about a book he's excited about. You engaged with that excitement, and I could see how much that meant to Neil. A lot of the time you have big names in science on, and because of your interest and empathy toward them, they really want to share their ideas and work with you and the audience. It makes me think how we're all kids hoping someone will ask us about the things we're interested in. You do that for your community, and for the larger community of people who watch and listen to your show. It's heartwarming. You're a good mensch.
@ Thanks so much Happy New Year!
Beautiful book cover. Makes you curious about & want to read the book ❤😮😊
Indeed
NDT is my favorite public speaking scientist. Thank you Brian for having him on again.
neil is a douche
he once said... (and i need you all to grasp the audacity and arrogance of his statement).... he said, on camera .... "well, i dont know anything about this subject, but here is what i think should happen..."
neil is a horrible person.
and he is 100% INCORRECT in the statement he made... there ARE only two genders, and trans women do NOT belong in womens sports
the ONLY acceptable words after stating "i dont know anything about the subject" are "so i shall not opine"
if you still think neil is a great guy.... go rethink your life... you have taken a wrong turn somewhere
have a nice day
Wow what a great podcast to listen to early Christmas morning;like a wonderful unexpected present to open!
Just an aside: I was a Liberal Arts Major in French Language and Literature. One Christmas party my husband and I went to one of the sons of this family was sitting there and introduced to us and said he is at Cern??? I at the time didn't know what that was only a connection that it was bordering FRANCE! I couldn't wait to ask him about speaking French. Well long short we made a connection! I immediately wanted to now all about the Higgs! He was there that July when they discovered it at Cern. He is a scholar and graduated from University of Pennsylvania post graduate doctorate program and I am always fascinated by this topic and also about Physics which is way out of my league.
I admire and thank you Doctor Brian Keating!
That’s amazing, what a connection! It's cool how physics can bring people together.
World's most famous science historian to be precise
You're my "top" Brian, Brian. Tip. Don't talk so fast, give kids time to take it in❤
@@kevincasson9848 you can turn the speed down in the settings genius. For your slow children
@jamescorn9278 I tried that, but it sounds like a retard bloke speaking, no doubt like yourself. Hope you aint got kids. Some people shouldn't be able to breed, don't you agree imbecile?
I am a fan of both of you! Dr. Tyson was animated and excited but i loved some of his points. I liked the magpie example and though WWI and &WWII examples were sad, it put into perspective our current societal conflicts vs the prior century's. Dr. Keating, I really appreciated your graceful and patient style of interviewing as it was in contrast to Dr. Tyson's overtly eager response. Even though you guys did not cover the cosmos in great detail, I appreciated the wide topics and knowledge that both of you imparted in this podcast. definitely something to ruminate about. Thank you as always @DrBrianKeating!
My pleasure 😇
Great talk with Dr. Niel!
Better to waste on Mars than putting it to work disassembling social security and the rest of the government. What a jerk!
Have a comedian fly him out.. got one: craig ferguson
Neil is a cool cat
Great episode!
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/yt
I think that the first time I've heard neal drop the f bomb like that. 26:48
Enjoyed the talk!
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
The title says this is 'Neil deGrasse Tyson's Tour of The Cosmos [Ep. 472]' but instead we get an episode of 'Into The Impossible'
I like Neil…I don’t have a degree in science like Neil…so I don’t think I wanna hate on someone who is assessing life more than me, if all I’m doing is criticizing him and not compiling info and documenting it, like he is…
Niel: “There are two kinds of people in the world: those who divide everyone into two kinds of people, and those who don’t.” I cackled! He’s just brilliant 😂
How did the atheists become the new Roman Catholic Church.
@ScrewdriverTUNING Agnosticism is likely the balanced, middle ground allowing for pure reasoning, the best humanity can do, as well as the continuing exploration of spirituality, God/god if you will, which no concept seems to fully captured yet, except for those who are overly sure.
@ 🤣😂🤣
@ does not seem so to me. It seems just as corrupt. Using bias instead of reason.
This is wonderful! ❤
I’m glad you enjoyed it!
U 2guys are my favorite Teachers
Wow. Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
@DrBrianKeating
What's up Dr Keating
Even though u younger than me.
We your my teacher.
Would u please put on your list.
I would argue we may go to Mars to satisfy the deity. The Elon deity. Criticism aside - Go Starship Flight Test 7!
Theres a universe where ND Tyson is a hardworking physicist...ONLY!!! If you dont work in his field, invisible. Im glad im in the universe im in today! Thx ND! And Thanmks BK for persisting and increasing your reach and ability to teach. Perhaps you and Mr. Nobel had plans outside "your" expectations?!
Great interview
I never really thought about colonizing Mars, but if NDT says it's impossible, I should really start taking it seriously.
It is not impossible but he says it is easier to prepare earth than leave and terraform Mars, which is a valid argument
Neil is just saying that if we have the technology & resources to make Mars liveable, then we have the technology & resources to make Earth liveable-- much more quickly and at a fraction of the cost.
Any scientist who doesn't want to double their sample size for studying how to make planets liveable isn't worth listening to. Nof1 experiments are worthless if you have the option of an Nof2 experiment.
You keep listening to the scientists who prefer Nof1 experiments to larger sample sizes. Imma keep following the scientific method.
Brian cox > NDT
I got here late, did Neil call him racist again yet??
Not this time 😂
Call who racist?
I've never heard Neil call an individual racist. But if he did, he had evidence to back it up. He does not make unsubstantiated allegations.
The link is above, I'm curious of your thoughts
@@TheOldHippiebilly
Honestly I just put this on, so I don't know yet.
Neil is calling you out Sabine.
Amazing talk, hope to the future.
I wish the Professor much luck with his book
Really enjoy this. My first listen. Just a suggestion. In your ad to subscribe you say” subscribe to me and the channel” instead of the channel and me “ to us” later you say me and Neil are good communicators which is very true but it should be “Neil and I” are good communicators. “We”
Thank you for one of my favorite podcasts!!
Being realistic is boring and undesirable.
Being realistic is fun, just as honestly is to mathematics...
Love what you are doing Brian! Can I get a meteorite ?
the Concept of Life, is a Blink of an Eye...
yet, nobody knows if we live or we die, after death?
accomplishments are not the ultimate goal of humanity....
Love is!
I'd be available to talk about this if you are interested. I also was friends with Edgar Mitchell, met him at his house, as he was an adviser on our KESE Project. I held a small moon rock in my hands!! So cool!
The first Europeans to the New World, was *Columbus?*
And here i thought that was *already debunked,* and that it had been proven that, The *Vikings, were the first* to the New World? (The people that crossed over on the Beringia Land Bridge excepted of course), are *Vikings* not considered to be European?
As a person alive during the 60's, yes I would love for StarTrek to be here now. But we need to save this planet before we try to terrafarm Mars. Musk forgets that what wants is Startrek but remember that in the story, this planet's problems have largely been solved.
Was a good talk. Nice
Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
2π β = ((sqrt(2)×10^-33 eV)×(c/(π×10^51 m/s^2))) is the equation for quanta of action for geometry to encircle the energy of a photon with a wavelength the size of the visible Universe and t_BB. The time after the Big Bang was a first day start, in theory.
@@gregoryhead382 😮
47:00 Last time at Christmas lunch and discussion on science, religion, and creation at Freshbrook church Swindon, Wiltshire. The Big Bang, one member replied ref Genesis, and God said,' Let there be light'. Does he follow evolution? Open book for me on my Agnostic journey
Professional celebrity …. Blah blah blah … click ….
Neil Tyson, you mean the non-science celebrity who doesn’t believe in the objectivity of sex? Yeah that guy is a joke
Should have had the science guy on too. His science background was stand up comedy. Couldn't make it up.
Non-science? You sound like a fool. Just because you can't understand what he's saying doesn't make him wrong, it makes you ignorant
Have you ever heard of hermaphrodites?
In nature there are various animals that change gender during their life. Why would we be any different?
A fascinating conversation. Neil deGrasse Tyson is knowledgeable and very entertaining. Amazing insights, enlightening facts, and good fun. We're so lucky to have such conversations out there for everyone to enjoy and learn from. Every time Neil deGrasse Tyson speaks, I learn so much about our world and the universe. Just marvelous. Thank you for inviting Neil for this excellent discussion. Looking forward to the next visit.
Thanks! It was a blast.💥 Thanks so much! *What was your favorite takeaway from this conversation?* _Please join my mailing list to get _*_FREE_*_ notes & resources from this show! Click_ 👉 briankeating.com/list
Fun fact. Electric cars save on polution, in theory, the problem is most people charge those cars at night when we burn fossil fuels, not so environmentally friendly as people think, today. I am sure we will improve through science and as a rev head, I can tell you one thing. With the potential hourse power and tourch , cars will be a lot more fun
2:20 good clip straight off the bat...
"The singularity is where God divides by zero." Great!
I always wondered what happened to the inverse square laws when r approaches zero.
Does the force approach infinity?
I really think that we should focus on what it is that holds the earth together. What is in the centre that is so powerful that it attracts matter into an almost perfect ball, that is alive! All we know is that matter is very strong. What if a tiny minute piece of that hole is not strong enough to maintain its position in the said black hole and fly off in its own orbit, amassing space matter, eventually forming an orb.?
You know what's unrealistic . Naturally occuring abiogenesis
Tell us how it's done then? You're a bit premature.
@steveburris6543 the word of God spoke life into existence.
He's talking about God obviously.
I'm only 47 and I feel like I don't know what button to press.....
We don't know what consciousness is, we don't know what space is, we don't know what matter is, we don't know what energy is, we don't know what radiation really is, we don't know where life came from, we don't really know why gravity exists ... and a thousand other things.
A lot of mystery left !
A self-sustaining city on Mars with a million people is not feasible from an economic standpoint. The only individuals who could financially support this are billionaires. For them, a trip to Mars might be an exotic experience, but it is unlikely they would want to stay there permanently or for an extended period. No matter how luxurious it is, you’re still a bird in a cage. For ordinary people, Musk will never be able to make this profitable.
A more logical scenario is an expensive hotel, complemented by some research facilities and mining operations. This would mean the focus would primarily be on robots, with only a potential hotel catering to short-term stays for humans.
Mining and the exploration of our solar system will primarily be carried out by drones and robots. This is economically viable, involves much lower insurance costs, and allows for 24/7 efficiency.
Not even wrong about going to Mars. Of course there's an economic reward from going to Mars. It's the continuing transfer of wealth from taxpayers TO ELON. It doesn't matter if everybody else loses, as long as Elon wins.
Neil, is it possible for you to talk with Buzz about his concept for a Earth-Mars-Earth NON-STOP ORBIT for shuttling people and hardware to/from Mars before it's too late... I know he has some dementia, but may be he can still talk about it. I had several Conversations with him about that, and it makes a LOT more sense than Elon's BFRs...
Let’s Go!
If this is a professor then I don't want to be one
I enjoy this show, but man, waaaaay too many ads. I've never complained about ads before, but this is ridiculous. Sorry man.
I whould not think of that
We need more Ads Brian.👍🏻
"Math does not respond well to opinion" - Drew Oeltmann ;)
That is a powerful statement, indeed.
@@DrBrianKeating Thanks Dr. Keating!! That means a lot. MERRY XMAS
we are really significant cause we are build in the image of God
Let’s gooooo 👏👏
🎉
Holy crap! Brian looks like Buzz Lightyear!.. The chin, the nose, Wow..
I will rewatch a movie with the subtitles on and I notice a word I've never seen before. My brain has ignored hearing these words before if I didn't recognize them. But when I see them in writing it stands out for some reason. I will figure out the meaning in context of the conversation in the movie or I will go look up the word. I know I've heard them before as it's in a movie I've seen more than once before.
Neil daFraud 🥱
Neil "full of gas" Tyson
Lookin for a deGrass kickin?
Dr. Tyson Demolished Elon, he is not to be messed with. And now even MAGA is mad at Elon. Interesting.
I Englished my English. I recant that comment
No worries
Hope Musk does go to Mars soon
1:29:34 “God doesn’t divide by zero!” So does Neil believe or not believe in SINGULARITIES? The intro kinda suggests yes but the whole explanation sorta suggests no.
Hormone levels: Athletes in the Olympics are already submitting to tests for drugs. Why not test for hormone levels at the same time?
Merlin Magi or scientist great title for a book Dr.Neil
You can mention Gaza Neil.
When you talk of bringing the universe down to earth I am thinking how that did not work out well for the dinosaurs.
What's with the whispering?
1h:20min. Argument about a trans woman fighting a man: the tw is a man who maybe didn't make the transition yet and even if he did it he should not fight neither with women or men with other trans women. The same thing should/has to be the other way around: trans man(woman who transition to man) should fight /compete with other tm. They have to make categories for them but not put them in the same category with men or women. Do not wanna say about the other ones who they believe that they are animals (sorry couldn't find the right word).
I tried my best to not upset anyone
_"I_ _don't_ _care_ _who_ _you_ _vote_ _for."_ - Tyson at 1:12:20
*what?*
Do scientists OR educators OR intellectuals OR space enthusiasts not want funding???
VOTE INDEPENDENT, FOR THE DAMNED SCIENCE PARTY. YES, BE POLITICAL *FOR SCIENCE*.
Neil, check out Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac single: "Oh Well".
I can handle DT one on one but when there are 3 or more he becomes unbearably annoying.
What's up Dr Keating
Love you the whole show even if though guys make me that I wasn't the center of the universe
Dr. Tyson is the Best. And no, cupcake, you are not the center of the universe. Now get some Cosmic Insignificance Therapy.
Damn, seeing him get so frustrated over people saying Science hasn't advanced is nice. Keep antagonizing him the next time bring up the same thing lmao.
Wokie MacWokeson talking about objective truth.
I really appreciate your efforts! A bit off-topic, but I wanted to ask: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). What's the best way to send them to Binance?
1:47:07 Gaza...
Any comment about current US genocide in Gaza?
Is it so wrong to dream? Neil's politics has gotten in the way of foward thinking.
AI will never know what chocolate tastes like or what an orgasm feels like. In this regard, it can never surpass us in knowledge.
Never say never.
@@kyaintit will it have a favorite color, or animal or rock band??
@@kyaintit Never have I never said never, never.