Do we expect too much from MPs? Feat. Marina Purkiss and Graham Taylor | Jeremy Vine On 5

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
  • With 68 MPs standing down at the next election, Jeremy is joined by Marina Purkiss and Graham Taylor to discuss whether they are dodging a bullet, or if the world of politics is just too toxic.
    Jeremy Vine is on television every weekday at 9:15am until 11:15am on Channel 5.
    Subscribe to the channel for more celebrity interviews, hot topics and debates: bit.ly/34DvAv4
    Twitter: / jeremyvineon5
    Facebook: / jeremyvineon5
    Instagram: / jeremyvineon5
    You can watch all episodes of Jeremy Vine on catch-up using My5 - available on TV, Mobile and Computer: www.my5.tv/jer...
    #JeremyVine #politics #uk

КОМЕНТАРІ • 57

  • @dijoyjoe
    @dijoyjoe Рік тому +23

    If they were better MP's they wouldn't get the flack.

  • @Bickle121
    @Bickle121 Рік тому +24

    So an 80 k job plus massive expenses job where you make decisions that effect the public’s life is difficult ? Awww poor babies.

    • @Lucky-wt6fg
      @Lucky-wt6fg 11 місяців тому +3

      Put them on the minimum wage see how they feel then…….

    • @JamJam0189
      @JamJam0189 8 місяців тому

      Once upon a time MP's were not paid anything at all, this meant only those on high incomes could afford to do the job the super rich in Victorian Britain basically, this was later changed. There are some good hard working MP's out there who turn up to debates and do 50 plus hours a week like the late Jo Cox's sister, but there are too many that don't, there should be minimum attendance for parliament and hours to fulfil the job.@@Lucky-wt6fg

  • @timcastle1844
    @timcastle1844 Рік тому +5

    If they are not capable of doing the job they applied for there is a simple solution, clear off.

  • @jamesudoaffia9380
    @jamesudoaffia9380 Рік тому +10

    Well done Marina, you tell it like it is. These Tory have to be called out.

    • @Lucky-wt6fg
      @Lucky-wt6fg 11 місяців тому +1

      Calling out…….doesn’t seem to be working! I’m afraid more drastic action is required by the people

  • @davidpryle3935
    @davidpryle3935 Рік тому +5

    There is a terrible lack of diversity in parliament. There are now almost no working class MP’s, compared to years ago. The only ones I can think of are Ian Lavery, Angela Rayner, and Lee Anderson.

    • @tonycowin
      @tonycowin Рік тому

      And Anderson is a working-class traitor.

    • @JamJam0189
      @JamJam0189 8 місяців тому +1

      Very true has gone backwards! 2022- Just one in 100 Tory MPs came from a working-class job, new study shows Institute for Public Policy Research study also shows proportion of working-class Labour MPs has halved since 1980s
      In terms of that the Conservatives in general were always the party of rich business men, years ago MP's got no salaries at all and MP's were all upper class toffs mainly from the Liberal and Conservative parties. Labour used to have a significant number of working class MP's now there's been a big increase in those you are trained lawyers from middle class backgrounds and those from rich backgrounds too, and more have gone to Oxford and private school that even the 70's or 80's a lot of this change started under New Labour, the numbers from working class backgrounds of MP's overall is very small those that are often have trade union links. Working class MP's include SNP's Mhairi Black & Labour's Angela Rayner was brought up on a council estate with a single mum, trade unionist John McDonnell former Shadow Chancellor under Corbyn worked at BHS, Richard Burgon and Dennis Skinner certainly is but lost his seat as an MP, Paula Barker MP, Emily Thornberry and arguably Zara Sultan, Olivia Blake, Steve Reed ( Shadow Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs) also not an MP but leader of Labour in Wales Mark Drakeford is arguably from a working class background. But not enough out of 650 MP's.
      Reform UK is led by a business man Richard Tice, alongside the likes of Alex Philips a former MEP fairly rich woman, the idea Reform UK stands up for the working class against the rich elites in laughable just like with Trump's similar claims.

    • @davidpryle3935
      @davidpryle3935 8 місяців тому +1

      @@JamJam0189 It looks to me like the American working class no longer feel represented by any party, and so their vote is up for sale to the highest bidder. They perceive Trump to be the highest bidder at the moment. I agree with you about Reform, and it’s disappointing that ex Labour working class voters are not gravitating towards the SDP, a type of blue Labour Party.

    • @JamJam0189
      @JamJam0189 8 місяців тому

      Yes there are parallels between UK and US politics in the 1980's when both Regan and Thatcher followed similar policies of free market less regulation and lower taxes which benefited the rich the last President that really cared for the working class in the USA was probably Jimmy Carter. The Democrats became more right wing under Clinton choosing third way centrist policies like Blair did. Bernie Sanders and Jeremy Corbyn challenged this and had a good deal of support but were snubbed by the media and their parties. I wish we were more like Finland, Norway, Sweden or Iceland with more left leaning policies and lower poverty levels. @@davidpryle3935

  • @marimota5083
    @marimota5083 7 місяців тому +1

    Aren't you aware why people are so angry with politicians??? 😮wow

  • @davecross4493
    @davecross4493 Рік тому +3

    Haha - it's defo because they don't want to be on the opposition benches.

  • @laurencunningham8312
    @laurencunningham8312 10 місяців тому +2

    How do you burn out from doing no work

  • @alexanderewing3779
    @alexanderewing3779 6 місяців тому +1

    Parliament is not representative. Too many public school boys and we all know who they represent and it's not working people! Power needs to be decentralised and in the hands of local people, who really have the interests of their electors, at heart! Radical change is required, to challenge the status quo!

  • @mattsorrell9386
    @mattsorrell9386 Рік тому +1

    Totally agree

  • @johngalvin3124
    @johngalvin3124 4 місяці тому +1

    Hard work, meagre wages and stress is the average life. 80K a year, massive expenses and a second income is a privileged life. And we just had 14 years of irrefutable proof that any idiot can do it.

  • @Wipeout2806
    @Wipeout2806 Рік тому +1

    if its too hot, get out of the kitchen. OUT!

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому +1

    An old name for an old night stick

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    It's a weapon.

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому +2

    I know the peach one it's like being on adrenaline a day ain't it.

  • @Cyderpunk
    @Cyderpunk Рік тому +3

    Graham Taylor is a typical religious hypocrite

  • @TrevorEden
    @TrevorEden 8 місяців тому

    marina totally right corruption and greed reform in parliament,not the idiots in the reform party are the same for the few.

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    And let them slit the story and means it ain't me they hurt with the lie

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    Yes like with dogs it's cheaper to pick up than to flush or do put else with it,we could make money off it. Others in universe do. 2:07

  • @AnEnemy100
    @AnEnemy100 Рік тому +1

    90,000 negative comments?
    Take a hint Maggie.

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    It's more I need to know their soul and the serliva wears off

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    Yeh miss all it takes is one fling on our kids of today, with stigmata and the go rotten.

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    And ok that star out their forming is stardust

  • @kevinmcelhone7905
    @kevinmcelhone7905 Рік тому +7

    That marina is a joke. She won’t have a migrant in her home because she has a family but wants no borders. She went on about the climate and she has just flew back from Cyprus. Talks the talk but won’t do the walk.

    • @alfsmith4936
      @alfsmith4936 Рік тому +10

      What's the point if nobody else will? She has a point but it takes a bit of thought to make sense of it, which is not something Jeremy Vine viewers do if they can help it.

    • @drewcampbell8555
      @drewcampbell8555 Рік тому +1

      The climate emergency requires international cooperation to achieve the infrastructural and social shift required. But, yeh, just you whinge about a journalist - then you can call "them" all hypocrites and you don't need to do anything to change.

  • @barneyrubble8590
    @barneyrubble8590 Рік тому +5

    Marina is the ultimate champagne socialist 🍸

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    Yes the commen wealth would be good to host, we were last so we're best positioned to host, so we should help or maybe risk looseing it, in style. 1:44

    • @alfsmith4936
      @alfsmith4936 Рік тому +1

      It's our commonwealth.. Australia want us to pay for the games but we are too poor.
      It's a big middle finger to the U.K. and a way for other commonwealth countries to see how we don't care about them as much as ourselves.
      On the bright side.. We would save a lot of money if we disbanded it all, like they want us to.

  • @George57
    @George57 6 місяців тому +1

    Hodge brings everything on herself. Expect to much of them. Most people don’t expect anything from them . Because that’s what we get . Nothing. They should be on minimum wage. And even then they would be paid to much.

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    And break
    Oh my god we have the inferstructer to do it cheap, one the commenwealth will make us money more than we waste. Because it all still in place were as another country would have to spend alot of money to do hense why they don't want to,but us being the last to do it it will work, plus's hosting twice in a row could be good for us medal wise, and the shitting thing,
    Were not animals are we well us not being more like an animal is costing us more the 5 billion a year.

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    What size is the universe compared to god I here, we the universe is about the size of a yoga ball in front of her she can wothtvher hand through us.

  • @PoppiesAndPride
    @PoppiesAndPride Рік тому +2

    I DONT EXPECT ANYTHING FROM THEM, LABOUR ARE WORSE VOTE REFORM

  • @markpape6565
    @markpape6565 Рік тому

    Them sorry

  • @andrewrobinson2565
    @andrewrobinson2565 Рік тому

    Maybe Mhairi Black wants to do something more useful with her life. Good luck to her 😂🎉.